Vous êtes sur la page 1sur 2

Miranda v. Arizona 384 U.S. 436 (1966).

FACTS: The Supreme Cour!" de#i"ion in Miranda v. Arizona addre""ed $our


di$$eren #a"e" invo%vin& #u"odia% inerro&aion". 'n ea#h o$ he"e #a"e"( he de$endan
)a" *ue"ioned +, po%i#e o$$i#er"( dee#ive"( or a pro"e#uin& aorne, in a room in
)hi#h he )a" #u o$$ $rom he ou"ide )or%d. 'n none o$ he"e #a"e" )a" he de$endan
&iven a $u%% and e$$e#ive )arnin& o$ hi" ri&h" a he ou"e o$ he inerro&aion pro#e"".
'n a%% he #a"e"( he *ue"ionin& e%i#ied ora% admi""ion" and( in hree o$ hem( "i&ned
"aemen" ha )ere admied a ria%.
Miranda v. Arizona: Miranda )a" arre"ed a hi" home and a-en in #u"od, o a po%i#e
"aion )here he )a" ideni$ied +, he #omp%ainin& )ine"". .e )a" hen inerro&aed
+, )o po%i#e o$$i#er" $or )o hour"( )hi#h re"u%ed in a "i&ned( )rien #on$e""ion. A
ria%( he ora% and )rien #on$e""ion" )ere pre"ened o he /ur,. Miranda )a" $ound
&ui%, o$ -idnappin& and rape and )a" "enen#ed o 01231 ,ear" impri"onmen on ea#h
#oun. 3n appea%( he Supreme Cour o$ Arizona he%d ha Miranda!" #on"iuiona%
ri&h" )ere no vio%aed in o+ainin& he #on$e""ion.
'SSU4: 5heher 6"aemen" o+ained $rom an individua% )ho i" "u+/e#ed o
#u"odia% po%i#e inerro&aion7 are admi""i+%e a&ain" him in a #rimina% ria% and )heher
6pro#edure" )hi#h a""ure ha he individua% i" a##orded hi" privi%e&e under he Fi$h
Amendmen o he Con"iuion no o +e #ompe%%ed o in#riminae him"e%$7 are
ne#e""ar,.
.489:The Cour he%d ha 6here #an +e no dou+ ha he Fi$h Amendmen privi%e&e i"
avai%a+%e ou"ide o$ #rimina% #our pro#eedin&" and "erve" o proe# per"on" in a%%
"ein&" in )hi#h heir $reedom o$ a#ion i" #urai%ed in an, "i&ni$i#an )a, $rom +ein&
#ompe%%ed o in#riminae hem"e%ve".7 A" "u#h( 6he pro"e#uion ma, no u"e
"aemen"( )heher e:#u%paor, or in#u%paor,( "emmin& $rom #u"odia% inerro&aion o$
he de$endan un%e"" i demon"rae" he u"e o$ pro#edura% "a$e&uard" e$$e#ive o
"e#ure he privi%e&e a&ain" "e%$2in#riminaion. ;, #u"odia% inerro&aion( )e mean
*ue"ionin& iniiaed +, %a) en$or#emen o$$i#er" a$er a per"on ha" +een a-en ino
#u"od, or oher)i"e deprived o$ hi" $reedom o$ a#ion in an, "i&ni$i#an )a,.7
The Cour $urher he%d ha 6)ihou proper "a$e&uard" he pro#e"" o$ in2#u"od,
inerro&aion o$ per"on" "u"pe#ed or a##u"ed o$ #rime #onain" inheren%, #ompe%%in&
pre""ure" )hi#h )or- o undermine he individua%!" )i%% o re"i" and o #ompe% him o
"pea- )here he )ou%d oher)i"e do "o $ree%,.7 There$ore( a de$endan 6mu" +e )arned
prior o an, *ue"ionin& ha he ha" he ri&h o remain "i%en( ha an,hin& he "a," #an
+e u"ed a&ain" him in a #our o$ %a)( ha he ha" he ri&h o he pre"en#e o$ an
aorne,( and ha i$ he #anno a$$ord an aorne, one )i%% +e appoined $or him prior o
an, *ue"ionin& i$ he "o de"ire".7
The Supreme Cour rever"ed he /ud&men o$ he Supreme Cour o$ Arizona in Miranda(
rever"ed he /ud&men o$ he <e) =or- Cour o$ Appea%" in >i&nera( rever"ed he
/ud&men o$ he Cour o$ Appea%" $or he <inh Cir#ui in 5e"over( and a$$irmed he
/ud&men o$ he Supreme Cour o$ Ca%i$ornia in Se)ar.

Vous aimerez peut-être aussi