TONCHE MEDINA, OLIGARIO

A091-767-234
STEWART DETENTION CENTER
146 CCA ROAD
LUMPKIN, GA 31815
U.S. Department of Justice
Executive Ofce fr Immigration Review
Board of Immigration Appeals
Ofce of the Clerk
5107 Leeburg Pike, Suite 2000
Fall Church, Vrginia 20530
OHS/ICE Ofice of Chief Counsel SOC
146 CCA Road
Lumpkin, GA 31815
Name: TONCHE MEDINA, OLIGARIO A 091-767-234
Date of this notice: 5/27/2014
Enclosed is a copy of the Boad's decision and order in the above-referenced case.
Enclosure
Panel Members:
Adkins-Blanch, Charles K.
Sincerely,
Don c t
Donna Carr
Chief Clerk
lucasd
Useream: Docket
For more unpublished BIA decisions, visit www.irac.net/unpublished
I
m
m
i
g
r
a
n
t

&

R
e
f
u
g
e
e

A
p
p
e
l
l
a
t
e

C
e
n
t
e
r

|

w
w
w
.
i
r
a
c
.
n
e
t
Cite as: Oligario Tonche Medina, A091 767 234 (BIA May 27, 2014)
. U.S. Deparent of Justce
Executive Ofce fr Imigaton Review
Falls Chuch, Vigina 20530
File: A091 767 234 - Lupkn, GA
I re: OLIGARIO TONCHE MEDINA
IN REMOVAL PROCEEDINGS
APPEAL
ON BEHALF OF RESPONENT: Pro se
Decision of te Board of Imigrtion Apeals
Date:
MAY
2 7 2014
Te respondet, a natve ad citize of Mexico who is a retng lawfl peraet residet,
appes te deision of te Imigation Judge, dated Febray 4, 2014, ordeng his reova
fom te Unted States. Te record will be readed.
Te Imigaton Judge did not preae a seaate oral or writte decision in ts mate
setg out te reaons fr he decision. See Mater of A-P-, 22 l&N Dec. 468 (IA 1999).
Imporaty, te Immigaton Judge has not meaingflly set frt te basis fr her holding that
te respondent is inadmissible as a result of his 1993 convicton fr a cmina ofense. See
Vartela v. Holder, 132 S.Ct. 1479 (2012) (oldig that applying the Illega Immigaton Refr
ad I igat Responsibility Act ("HIRA") to a pre-HIA conviction, teeby deving the
alie of his previously-held rigt to ret to te United States afe bref tps abroad, was
impessibly retoactive). Even toug te respondent was appaently convicted of a
subsequet cminal ofee in 2012, the Deamet of Homelad Security ("OHS") has not
alleged tat said conviction indeedetly subjects h to reoval fom te United States. See
8 C.F.R. 1240.lO(e) (rovding tat te DHS may fle additiona or substtted fcta
alegations in wrtng).
For te reasons set frt aove, te record will be reted to te Imigation Judge fr the
preaation of a new decision ad, if she dees apprprate, aditonal heags to resolve te
issues presented in tis case. The fllowing orde is enteed.
ORDER: Te record is rete to te Immigation Judge fr te ent of a new decision
ad fer action as she dees appropriate.
I
m
m
i
g
r
a
n
t

&

R
e
f
u
g
e
e

A
p
p
e
l
l
a
t
e

C
e
n
t
e
r

|

w
w
w
.
i
r
a
c
.
n
e
t
Cite as: Oligario Tonche Medina, A091 767 234 (BIA May 27, 2014)
J
MGKAN CUK
9b CCA KAD
JtKN GA Jb
D LDO MdLLOl O
CdSO NO. AJ~b~29
JNCHE MEDNA lGAK
KOSgODOODL
hEK OF HE MMGKAN UDGE
{
D1S 1S d SU00dly O LDO OldJ OOC1B1OD

ODLOlOO ,; . }O /
D1S 0O0OIdDOD0 lS SOJOJy Ol LDO CODVOD1ODCO O LDO p lL1OS LDO
glOCOOO1DgS SDOUJO DO dQgOdJOOOl ODOO LDO OlB w1JJ OOCO0O
rDO

L1C1dJ OQ1D1OD lD LDO

CdSO
+
DO lOSgODOODL wS OlOOlO
Ol 1D LDO dJCOlDdL1VO LO
] KOBgODOODLS dgQJ1CdL1OD O
lOSgODOODL wdS OlOOlOO IO0O
dJLOlDdL1VO LO .
KOSgODOODL`S dgQJ1CdL1OD Ol VOJUDLdly OOQdlLUlO wdS gldDLOO UDL1J
UQOD QOSL1Dg d OODO 1D LDO d0OUDL O $
w1LD dD dJLOlDdLO OlOOl O1 lO0OVdJ LO .
KOSODOODCB dQgJ1CdL1OD Ol(
[ ] ASyJU0 wdS | } gldDLOO } OGD1OO| } w1LDOldwD
[ ] w1LDDOJO1Dg O LO0OVdJ wdS | ) gldDLOO | } OOD1O } w1LDOldw
[ ] A wd1VOl UDOOl SOCL1OD wdS | } gIdDLOO j }OOD1O | }w1LDOldw
I ] CdDCOJJd1OD O 1O0OVdJ UDOOl SOCL1OD 29Ajd} wdB j )gldDLOO | }OGD1OO
| }w1LDOldwD.
OSgODOODL'S dQg1CdL1OD Ol:
[ ] CdDCOJJd1OD UDOCl BOCL1OD 29A |D}|J} wdS | } gldDLOO } OOD1OO
[
| } w1CDOlwD gldDO, 1L 1S

OlOOlOO LDdL LDO lOSQODOODL OO 1SSUOO

dJJ dQQlOgl1dLO OOCU0ODLS DOCOSSdTy LO g1VO OOCL LO

LD1S OlOOl.
.J CdDCOJJdC1OD UDOl SOCL1OD 29AjD} |2} wdS | }gldDLOO j }OOD1OO
j )w1LDOldwD gldD1OO it is OlOOlOO LDdL LDO lOSQODOODL DO 1SBUOO
dJ dQQlOgl1dLOO OOCU0OD\S DOCOSSdly LO g1VO OOCL to LD1S OlOOl.
AO_USL0ODL O SLdLUS UDOl SOCL1OD wdS | }gldD1OO ( )OOD1OO
( }w1LDOldwD gldDLOO1L 1B OlOOlOO DdL LDO lOBQODOODL DO 1SSUOO
dJJ dgglOgl1dOO OOCU0ODLS DOCOSSdly 1Og1VO OOCL LO LD1S OlOOl
KOSgODOEDL'B dQQ1CdL1OD O | } w1LDDOJO1Dg O1 LO0OVdJ ( } OOOlldJ O
.7O0OVdJ DDOOl Al1CJO of LDO CODVODL1OD Agd1DSL OlLUlO wdS
| } gLDLOO | } OOD1 OO | I w1LDOldwD
KOSgODOGDL`S SLdLUS wdS lOSC1DOO UDOel SOCL1OD 296.
KOSgODOODL 1S dO01LLOO LO LDO UD1LOO SLdLOB dS d
-
UDL1J
AS d CODO1L1OD O dO01SS1OD lOSgODOODL 1S LO gOBL d $ OODO
KOBgODOOD1 KDOw1DgJy 1JOO d l1VOJOUS dSy1U0 6Qg1CdL1OD dLOl QlOgOl
DOL1CO.
KOSgODOODL wdS dOV1 SOO O LDO J101LdL1OD OD O1S
d1JUlO L
O dQQGdl dS OlOOlOO 1D LDO 001gldL3O
ElOCOOO1DgS

wOlO LOl01Dd\OO
1DOI.
UdLO' -
S
AgQOd PQgOdJ DUO By:
3;7
n
I
m
m
i
g
r
a
n
t

&

R
e
f
u
g
e
e

A
p
p
e
l
l
a
t
e

C
e
n
t
e
r

|

w
w
w
.
i
r
a
c
.
n
e
t