1 Faculty of Design, University of Art, Braunschweig and Dept. Interior Design & Scenography, Academy of Art and Design, Basel ABSTRACT The perception of atmosphere is a function of various dimensions, like colour, illumination, surface, sound, odour, temperature as well as room structure, where colour is one of the key factors. Colour is a natural phenomenon and there are various categories and systems available describing quality and quantity of colour. In the work presented here the perception of colour on the atmospheric quality of a landscape has been analysed in a longitudinal setting. Parameters of the colour space were correlated with psychometric dimensions (human perception). An analytical tool has been used which was developed in an earlier design research project allowing the characterisation of atmosphere with six independent dimensions. Two test candidates did observe bi-weekly over a period of a year from a fixed position a specific view into nature. The natural change of light and colours through the seasons and different weather conditions led to a continuous change of the observed environmental situation. The result of this research demonstrates an unexpected correlation between colour attributes and their perception, especially relating to the opulence of the colour space. The primary attribute was the complexity of the colour variance and not the colour saturation. 1. INTRODUCTION Along with technological progress the aesthetical sentiments and human ideals are changing. Today it seems to be important that the perception of scenes is intensifying our existence. (Bhme 1993) This is in particular important for the perception of architecture that is experienced with its integrated material and comprised spiritual essence. (Pallasmaa 2012) Atmospheric attributes can be e.g. sound, odour, haptic, luminance and colour. Today we would speak of an atmospheric effect. Colours communicate to space a certain mood. (Bhme 2010) Today there is evidence that colour and light has psychological and physical effects, however many question remain still unanswered. (Gilliam 1988, van Hagen 2009) What is of interest to us in this investigation is colour in relation to the perception of atmosphere. This perception starts with objective elements like the excitation of the receptors and ends individual subjective emphasis. On the other hand there is high cultural concordance, where designer and architects can rely on. But the amount of terms for the characterisation of atmosphere is small. Therefore it seems to be important to further investigate the objective description of product appearances. (Blijlevens 2009) This can be helpful for the communication between designer/ architect and users. In this study an attempt is made to decipher the complexity of perception of atmosphere by investigating the influence of colour. As analytical tool the model according to Findeli, von Wyl and Stterlin has been used. (Findeli 2012) For colour characterisation the model was already tested in laboratory setting (von Wyl private communication). In this study the model was
2 amended for use in the exterior space and the correlation between colour and the six atmosphere dimensions has been tested. 2. METHODS AND STRATEGY The approach is practice oriented and shall lead to answers pertinent to design relevant solutions. Methods of social science and phenomenology as well as design instruments have been used. The analytical tool was used as described by Findeli but the terms (38 descriptors) were adapted for the description of a landscape. 5 terms of the initial list were deleted and 25 added resulting in a questionaire of 63 terms (Table 1). The six dimensions cosiness, liveliness, grandness, openness, dispassion and emotional security to characterise atmosphere remained unchanged. Table 1. Terms of questionnaire.
In preparation of the observations place and settings has been determined. Aim was to find a place where over the course of a year the only expected changes related to the weather and season. Finally a countryside has been selected with view towards a lake and mountains and grassland and forest in the foreground. Analogue to a eye-tracking method ten focus points within the landscape view have been selected based on the view directions of the two test persons. The focus points were transcribed onto a photo of this view for the subsequent colour determination. Two test persons did observe about every two weeks over a period of a year a specific the landscape from the predetermined place in the morning with a total of 23. A photo was taken at the beginning of each observation. Later the photography was transferred onto a Mac Book. At the predetermined ten focus points the CMYK values were taken in InDesign. Two values were calculated to characterise each photo: a) average C, M, Y and K value across the ten focus points called Saturation, b) the corresponding standard deviations for each of the four colour values, i.e. the complexity, called Variance. Following a 3-minute observation period the questionnaire had been completed. For each observation the perception of the atmosphere of the test persons was calculated resulting in one value for each of the six dimensions. The correlation coefficient between Saturation (each CMYK value) or Variance (each CMYK value) respectively and each of the six dimension values was calculated according Bravais-Pearson. (Bortz 1993)
3 3. RESULTS Table 2 shows the correlation coefficient between Saturation or Variance and each of the dimensions describing the perception of the atmosphere. Saturation was significantly correlated between Cyan and the dimension grandness. Variance of Yellow was signifcantly correlated with five of the 6 dimensions, Magenta with 4, Cyan with two and Black with one. Table 2. Correlation coefficient, significant values in bold (! = 0.05, two side testing) Dimensionen der atmosphrischen Wirkung (Variance)
1 Behaglichkeit (cosiness) 2 Lebendigkeit (livelivness) 3 Erhabenheit (grandness) 4 Offenheit (openess) 5 Sachlichkeit (dispassion) 6 Geborgenheit (em. security) S a t u r a t i o n Cyan C 0.15 0.14 0.36 0.00 -0.01 0.15 Magenta M -0.11 -0.01 0.14 -0.17 0.05 -0.08 Yellow Y 0.07 0.16 0.23 0.05 0.05 0.07 Black K 0.06 0.13 0.23 0.07 0.15 0.06 V a r i a n c e
Cyan C 0.24 0.22 0.35 0.17 0.05 0.31 Magenta M 0.33 0.45 0.42 0.23 -0.12 0.39 Yellow Y 0.41 0.44 0.42 0.30 -0.04 0.36 Black K 0.17 0.26 0.37 0.13 0.08 0.17
Each of the six dimensions correlates differently with Variance or Saturation. Grandness correlates positively with the Variance of all four CMYK values, Emotional Security correlates positively with the Variance of CMY, whereas cosiness and liveliness correlate with M and Y. Openness does correlate only with the Variance of Y. Dispassion has no significant correlation. Figure 1 shows four representative observations. The line diagram below the picture shows the ten focus points on the x-axes (starting at the top left) and their respective variance on the y-axes. The net diagram shows the value of each of the six atmospheric perception dimensions (1 = cosiness at the top, 2 6 following clockwise) at the respective observation. The positions for colour extraction are shown in the first picture.
Figure 1: Variance and perception diagram for four representative observations. 4. DISCUSSION AND CONCLUSIONS Overall the data demonstrate a positive correlation between Colour Variance, i.e. the complexity, and the perception of space atmosphere whereas the Colour Saturation seems to be of limited importance. Of the six dimensions grandness was most determined through the complexity of light and also through the saturation of Cyan. In contrary the dimension
4 dispassion did not at all correlate with the quality of light but it might well be determined by other attributes (e.g. structure). The variance of the colour yellow, positively correlating with five dimensions, was clearly the most important. It is interesting to mention that Goethe did characterise yellow as a colour has a warming effect. (van Biema 1997) The study has its limitations. Firstly the small number of test persons, secondly the colour analysis within the CMYK colour space opposed to the larger LAB colour space. But the results are interesting for hypothesis generation and warrant further investigation. Not only will it be interesting to see whether the positive correlation of colour complexity with perception of atmosphere can be confirmed. Also the influence of other sensations on the perception of atmosphere shall be tested with the analytical model. The intuition of designers and architects could be enriched through substantiated understanding of how the character of atmosphere is determined. ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS A. Findely contributed to the concept of this study and M. Urmi to the observations. The manuscript was reviewed by W. Beck. REFERENCES Blijlevens, J., M. E. H. Creusen, and J. P. L. Schoormans. 2009. How Consumers Perceive Product Appearance: The Identification of Three Product Appearance Attributes. Internationals Journal of Design 3 (3): 27-35. Bortz, J., and N. Dring. 1993. Statistik fr Sozialwissenschaftler. Zrich: Springer. Bhme, G. 1993. Atmosphere as the Fundamental Concept of a New Aesthetics. Thesis Eleven 36: 113-126. Bhme, G. 2010. On Beauty. The Nordic Journal of Aesthetics. 39: 22-33. Findeli, A., N. von Wyl, and J. Stterlin. (2012) Une method de characterisation des ambiances lumineuses en architecture dintrieur. In Ambiance in action, 2 nd
International congress on Ambiances, Proceedings, ed. by J.P. Thibaud and D. Siret. Montreal: Canadian Centre for Architecture, 203-208. Gilliam, J.E., and D. Unruh. 1988. The Effect of Baker-Miller Pink on Biological, Physical and Cognitive Behaviour. Journal of Orthomolecular Medicine 3 (4): 202-206. Pallasmaa, J. 2012. The Eyes of the Skin: Architecture and the Senses. West Sussex: Wiley & Sons. van Biema, C. 1997. Farben und Formen als Lebendige Krfte. Ravensburg: Ravensburger Buchverlag. Van Hagen, M., M. Galetzka, A. Pruyn, and J. Peters. 2009. Effects of colour and light on customer experience and time perception at a virtual railway station. In Experiencing Light 2009. International conference on the Effects of Light on Wellbeing, Proceedings, ed. by Y. A. W. de Kort, W. A. Ijsselsteijn, I. M. L. C. Vogels, M. P. J. Aarts, A. D. Tenner, & K. C. H. J. Smolders. Eindhoven: University of Technology, 137-145. Address: Nolle von Wyl, Department of Interior Design & Scenography Academy of Art and Design, Spitalstrasse 8, CH 4056 Basel E-mails: noelle.vonwyl@fhnw.ch, info@noelle.vonwyl.ch