Statement Statement Statement Statement Statement Statement Statement Statement (EIS) (EIS) (EIS) (EIS) Different Names But the Same Document Environmental Impact Assessment report (EIA report) Environmental Impact Statement (EIS) Environmental Assessment report Environmental Assessment report (EA report) Environmental Effects Statement (EES) In Swahili: Taarifa ya Tathmini ya Athari kwa Mazingira (Taarifa ya TAM) Purposes of Effective Reporting Through EIS 1. To assist the proponent to plan properly and in a cost-effective manner. 2. To assist the decision-makers to 2. To assist the decision-makers to reach just and balanced decisions. 3. To help the public to clearly understand the proposal and its effects on their environment. Contents of an EIS 1. Executive summary 2. Description of proposal and its alternatives including zero alternative 3. Relationships to the current dev. plan, land use plan, administrative, policy, and legal requirements 4. Description of key baseline 4. Description of key baseline conditions 5. Description of impact prediction, analysis and evaluation 6. Evaluation of all alternatives 7. Environmental Management Plan (EMP). 8. Cited/used references 9. Appendices Producing an Executive Summary 1. Keep it short (3 to 10 pages) 2. Make it clear 3. Avoid jargon and terms not defined in the summary and which could be in the summary and which could be misinterpreted 4. Consider the needs of local readers as well as those of decision-makers 5. Include all significant findings 6. Check for accuracy and consistency Contents of EIS Executive Summary 1. Proposal title, description and location 2. Name of proponent 3. Name of organisation preparing the EIA report preparing the EIA report 4. Outline of proposal and alternatives considered 5. Major impacts 6. Recommendations for mitigation 7. Proposed EMP EIS - Describing the Proposal 1. Status of proposal 2. Planning, design and implementation strategies 3. Requirements for materials, land, water, energy, equipment, labour, etc. etc. 4. Planned processes and products 5. Visual aids (maps etc) 6. Alternatives/options (eg. sitting, layout, etc.) 7. Summary of technical, economic and environmental features EIS: Evaluating Impacts for Each Alternative 1. Assessment of impacts 2. Data and predictive methods used 3. Uncertainty and gaps in knowledge 4. Compliance with standards 4. Compliance with standards (guidelines) 5. Criteria used to assess significance 6. Proposed impact avoidance or mitigation EIS: Environmental Mgt Plan 1. Describe project implementation schedules 2. Describe proposed mitigation for all significant impacts 3. Propose community-based 3. Propose community-based development projects or programmes (if any) 4. Describe a tentative monitoring programme 5. Propose reporting schedules EIS: Appendix Materials 1. Terms of reference for the IA studies 2. Details of IA schedules 3. Details of special studies carried out 4. List of stakeholders involved in IA 5. Summary of public involvement programme programme 6. Detailed technical information/data 7. Copies of important permits/letters served to the proponent & consultants 8. Details of the study team members 9. List of acronyms and glossaries Common EIS Shortcomings (1) 1. Object of a proposal described too narrowly 2. Description does not adequately cover a proposed activity 3. Alternatives best not described (or insufficiently described) 4. Alternatives do not account for the environment 4. Alternatives do not account for the environment 5. Key problems not described 6. Sensitive elements in environment overlooked 7. Policies, plans, programmes, standards and legislation are not described or proposed measures do not comply with them Common EIS Shortcomings (2) 8. Mitigation measures not practical 9. Serious impacts are not mentioned or not correctly described 10.Outdated or ineffective prediction models/information used models/information used 11. Impacts are not compared with standards or targets 12. Incorrect or superficial conclusions drawn from the analyses