7/18/2014 Drafted & Waiting: Domestic Workers Remain Voiceless | JustHere

http://www.justhere.qa/2013/07/drafted-waiting-domestic-workers-remain-voiceless-2/ 1/3
FEATURED POST
JUSTHERE TV
ECONOMIC
Qatar Cost of Living: The
JustHere Survival Matrix
January 30, 2014
0 Tweet 14
Qatar in Focus SOCIAL
Drafted & Waiting: Domestic Workers
Remain Voiceless
A weekly day off is one of the most contentious issues that stalls
the passing of a law to govern domestic workers in Qatar. And
its also one of the main issues that has slowed down the process
of a GCC unified contract for domestic workers.
That one point alone surmises the immediate and desperate need to assure the protection of the large number of
domestic workers, mainly female and from Asia, who travel to the region for employment.
In this report we assess two draft documents.
One is the Qatar draft law of 2008 regarding Domestic Workers under the earlier Emir HH Sheikh Hamad bin Khalifa Al
Thani, the other is the unified GCC contract for workers.
While both are moves in the right direction, they still leave a lot to be desired.
The first has been stalled (mainly over the weekly day off issue) and the second, still in the pipeline, is for the most part
ambiguous.
JustHere spoke to experts on domestic workers issues.
There are roughly about 2,092,382 domestic workers in the GCC, according to the 2013 estimates of ILO. In Qatar there
are 80,300 domestic workers, of whom more than half are female (48,147).
One of the dos as per this brochure by Qatar Foundation for Combatting Human Trafficking is:
Remember there is a caste system. People have status for a whole range of reasons, including; race,
Vani
Saraswathi
On July 9,
2013
5 Like
One Comment
July 18, 2014, 3:04 pm
Search...
Opinion People Qatar in Focus Make It Home Business JustHere TV Team JustHere
JustHere | July 18, 2014 About Us Advertise Contact Us
7/18/2014 Drafted & Waiting: Domestic Workers Remain Voiceless | JustHere
http://www.justhere.qa/2013/07/drafted-waiting-domestic-workers-remain-voiceless-2/ 2/3
Pages: 1 2
TAGS
Domestic Workers human rights MAIDS Migrant Workers
family, education.
GCC unified contract: Problematic clauses
Migrant Forum Asia notes that several provisions of the contract were not explicit, but rather subject to negotiations
between employers and employees. Such provisions are problematic because domestic workers often lack bargaining
power or the resources to make informed choices.
Associate Professor of Sociology, Institute for Migration Studies, Lebanese American University in Beirut, Dr Ray
Jureidini lays threadbare the many ambiguities and causes for concern in the proposed unified contract.
Dr Jureidini also served as a research consultant on the Qatar Foundation Migrant Worker Welfare Initiative.
There are a few clauses that Dr Jureidini deems highly problematic.
The clauses that lists the commitment of the employer to employee makes medical treatment the responsibility of the
former, unless the injury/harm was deliberately self-inflected (sic) by the worker.
Dr Jureidini finds this an interesting exception to quote. It suggests that maybe there would be such a case (but) if
such a thing were to happen, there might have been a trigger.
And that trigger cannot be overlooked, he stresses, and points out another insidious clause.
Maintain the property of the First Party and his family members, and the Second Party shall compensate for any the
damages (sic) she may inflict on to such property, arising from her mistake, in accordance with the provisions set forth
in the applicable national legislation in this regard.
This can be exploited, and it is an insidious clause, says Dr Jureidini. There
has to be a distinction between accidental and deliberate. I know this actually
happens, penalising the worker for accidental damages, and it shouldnt be
allowed.
Rima Khalush of Migrant Rights says: This provision may facilitate illegal wage
deductions. Domestic workers would have difficulty defending themselves from
these allegations, particularly as access to legal representation or translation
services remain limited.
The unified contract also states:
The death of the First Party, or his separation from his family, or his absence outside the country for more than six
months for any reason, unless a family member requests the transfer of the license to hire the worker for his own
interest.
In this case, this family member shall replace the First Party in this contract.
This is akin to indentured labour system, says Dr Jureidini. The choice of the worker is not even taken into account here.
And the agreement of the worker has to be free of coercion.
Copyright 2013 JustHere Qatar. Reproduction of material from any JustHere Qatar pages without written permission is strictly prohibited.
Comments
Submit a Comment
Logged in as JustHere Qatar. Logout.
MESSAGE*
GCCstateshistoricallyfail
toputsignificantforce
behindlabourreforms,
renderingcompliance
sporadicatbest.
Edit Post
Post Comment
7/18/2014 Drafted & Waiting: Domestic Workers Remain Voiceless | JustHere
http://www.justhere.qa/2013/07/drafted-waiting-domestic-workers-remain-voiceless-2/ 3/3

Copyright 2013 JustHere.qa
Home | Columns | Faces | Qatar in Focus | Lifestyle | Make it home | Art & Culture | JustHere TV | Team
JustHere | Advertise | Contact Us | About Us
Connect with us
RECEIVE NEWS UPDATES VIA EMAIL FROM THIS SITE