Vous êtes sur la page 1sur 47

EXHIBIT A

Case 1:14-cv-00250-AT Document 1-1 Filed 01/14/14 Page 1 of 47


iverything You Wanted To Know Aboutthe Kanye-Inspired 'Coinye' B... http://www.usnews.com/news/articles/2014/01/02/everything-you-wa...
H ^ f f l N E WS
Everything You Wanted To Know About the Kanye-Inspired 'Coinye' But
Were Afraid To Ask
Some entrepreneurs are using Kanye West to launch a cryptocurrency - so what does that mean, again?
By TIERNEYSNEED
January 2,2014
You would think a Twitter account that popped up
Tuesday called "Coinye West" was a parody
account created by some econ nerd-cum-Yeezy
fan. It in fact is the handle of a new digital
currency inspired by Kanye West that, as the
creators confirmed to VICE Thursday, will launch
Jan. 11. Confused yet? So were we. Here's a
primer.
$
yfl
J
aip
So Kanye has his own currency now?
Not exactly. It looks like West - surprisingly,
considering the lengths he'll go to for self
promotion - has nothing to do with it. Some techie
monetary entrepreneurs who for the time being
"want to stay sorta anonymous in case Kanye
gets pissed off' - are launching a cryptocurrency
using West' s likeness and some clever punning
called "Coinye West."
A now digital currency namad Coinye looks to capitalize on the fame of rapper Kanye West
[READ: U.S. Unveils New $100 Bill to Fight
Counterfeiting]
Cryptocurrency... excuse me, what?
Cryptocurrencies are digital monetary systems. Users can use these networks to buy and sell things online, usually anonymously and almost like
PayPal, but in a decentralized fashion. You may have heard of Bitcoin, the 4-year-old form of digital currency that attracted congressional attention in
November. It went on a boom-and-bust ride last year, with the price of a bitcoin skyrocketing above $1,000 in November only to crash 50 percent.
Because it is online, anonymous and decentralized, Bitcoin and other cryptocurrencies get a reputation as being especially useful for illicit purchases (it
was the accepted currency of the recently shut down illegal drug trafficking website, Silk Road). However, the rise of BitPay, BitGive and other platforms
that use Bitcoin have given it some legitimacy, and attention now has turned to how it could be regulated.
So how does this ail work?
Similar to how a treasury prints cash, bitcoins are released in a process known as "mining," in which users' computers compete to solve algorithms to
win bitcoins (the algorithm gets increasingly harder so that the race will occur every 10 minutes or so and the bitcoin rewarded is halved every four
years, meaning the bitcoin supply is finite). Coinye's creators say they will release their own front-end mining program called CoinyeMiner, which
according to them will be more user-friendly than the mining programs used by other cryptocurrencies.
Wait - they named the mining program 'CoinyeMiner,' and not'Gold Digger'?
I know, missed opportunity, right?
[ALSO: Silk Road Shuttered: Online Drug Market's 100,000 Patrons May Be in Hot Water]
What' s the point of naming your weird online currency after a megalomaniac, Kardashian-loving rapper?
Well, this is the point: attention. For these currencies to work they must have users, and the more users they have the more stable they'll be. Just last
month, some Internet geeks created a cryptocurrency called Dogecoin - inspired by 2013's Meme of the Year, a Shiba Inu dog named Kabosu - and its
value surged 900 percent in a week while its competitor currencies stumbled.
"There was this trend effect of people thinking it was associated with something cool and trendy," says Reuben Grinberg, a lawyer in the financial
1/8/2014 8:06 PM 1 of 2
Case 1:14-cv-00250-AT Document 1-1 Filed 01/14/14 Page 2 of 47
Everything You Wanted To Know Aboutthe Kanye-Iiispired 'Coinye' B... http://www.usnews.coin/news/articles/2014/01/02/everything-you-wa...
institutions group of the law firm Davis Polk & Wardwell LLP. The Coinye creators likely are hoping for a similar effect. "My guess would be is that they're
trying to profit on something associated with [Kanye's] name."
As Coinye creators told VICE, "We chose to represent Kanye because he is and always has been a trendsetter, and he's always keeping things
unique."
Shoul d I buy Coinye?
Though the Coinye creators say their program will be more accessible than other cryptocurrencies, they haven't really specified how.
"As more people get involved in mining this currency, it's going to be difficult for everyday people to get access to these coins and it's going to be people
with professional setups who profit the most," Grinberg explains. So you might be better off sticking to the more established Bitcoin.
Also worrisome, Grinberg says, is the kind of users Coinye seeks to attract: Kanye fans, rather than economists, math whizzes and techies who are
known to get involved in cryptocurrenices. Cryptocurrencies are very risky, and non-economists buying in out of a love for Kanye could lose a lot of
money if they don't know what they're doing.
"These are not the people I would say who should be getting involved in digital currencies," Grinberg says.
[MORE: Group Seeks to Solicit Charitable Donations in Bitcoins]
How many Coinye will it take t o buy a ' mayonnaise colored Benz' ?
We won't know until the currency launches, but as of press time, a $300,000 Mercedes-Benz costs about $384.73 in bitcoin.
I bet Twitter is l ovi ng thi s.
Too much.
More News:
House Weighs Bill to Crack Down on Coin Counterfeits
Dollar Coin Advocates Renew Push to Banish $1 Bill
How Did Bitcoin Become a Real Currency?
Tags: money, internet, art
Copyright 2014 U. S. News & World Report LP. Use of this website constitutes acceptance of our Terms and Conditions of Use / Privacy Policy.
1/8/2014 8:06 PM 2 of 2
Case 1:14-cv-00250-AT Document 1-1 Filed 01/14/14 Page 3 of 47
http://www.hollywoodreporter.com/priiit/668324
10:55 PMPST 1/2/2014 by Kevin Rutherford, Billboard
10
22
0
j l
ai
' ftv
1 f
\
}:
ml
Wf
4
i
/ W
zWrnM:
Kanye West
Coinye West launches Jan. 11, with its creators saying they wish to remain anonymous "in case
Kanye gets pissed off."
This story first appeared at BUlboard.com.
our editor recommends
From One Direction to Kanve West. Why Grandiose Tours RuledlilJ Best of 2013:
In
Kanve West Kim Kardashian Named Least Desirable Neighborsl
Kanve West on Grammy Snub: ' F Those Nominations!' fVideoli' IJ
First it was Bitcoin. Then came Dogecoin. Now, a group of Internet denizens are creating a new form of e-currency and it's got that New God Flow.
As Noisev renorts. a new cryptocurrency named after Kanye West is about to hit the marketplace. Deemed Coinve West, the currency is supposed to
become available Jan. 11.
STORY: From One Direction to Kanve West. Why Grandiose Tours Ruled in 2013
In an interview with Noisey, the creators of Coinye West said they're remaining anonymous "in case kanye gets pissed off," but the currency is totally
legitimate. With a tagline of "we ain't minin', we pickin'," Coinye West is created in the spirit of, according to its creators, making it "easier for people
to use cryptocurrency."
"We chose to represent Kanye because he is and always has been a trendsetter, and he' s always keeping things unique," the Coinye creators added. "I
can picture a future where Coinye is used to buy concert tickets, with cryptographically verified virtual tickets, and other ideas I can't give away just
yet."
Yeezus himself isn't exactly behind the idea just yet, but that hasn't stopped the creators of Coinye West from reaching out to the rapper in the hope
that he'll invest or, at least, not get mad about its existence.
"Have you ever invested in bitcoin or litecoin?" its creators asked West via Twitter. In the Noisey interview, they also invited West to get in contact
with them, offering the rapper 100,000 "COINYE," as it's being called.
No word on how the rapper feel s about having a form of currency named after him just yet.
1 of 2 1/8/2014 8:07 PM
Case 1:14-cv-00250-AT Document 1-1 Filed 01/14/14 Page 4 of 47
http://www.hollywoodreporter.coin/print/668324
The website encountered an unexpected error. Please try again later.
2 of 2
1/8/2014 8:07 PM
Case 1:14-cv-00250-AT Document 1-1 Filed 01/14/14 Page 5 of 47
New Bitcoin-Esque Cryptocurrency Named After Kanye West Launching... http://www.billboard.com/articles/news/5855158/new-bitcoin-esque-...
billboard
New Bi t coi n-Esque Crypt ocurrency Named Af t er Kanye
West Launchi ng
By Kevin Rutherford | January 02, 2014 9:44 PM EST
Coinye West , in t he vei n of Bitcoin and Dogecoin, launches Jan. 11
First it was Bitcoin. Then came Dogecoin. Now, a group of Internet denizens are creating a new form of e-currency - and it's
got that New God Flow.
As Noisey reports, a new cryptocurrency named after Kanye West is about to hit the marketplace. Deemed Coinye West, the
currency is supposed to become available Jan. 11.
In an interview with Noisey, the creators of Coinye West said they're remaining anonymous "in case kanye gets pissed off,"
but the currency is totally legitimate. With a tagline of "we ain't minin', we pickin'," Coinye West is created in the spirit of,
according to its creators, making it "easier for people to use cryptocurrency."
"We chose to represent Kanye because he is and always has been a trendsetter, and he's always keeping things unique,"
the Coinye creators added. "I can picture a future where Coinye is used to buy concert tickets, with cryptographically verified
virtual tickets, and other ideas I can't give away just yet."
Yeezus himself isn't exactly behind the idea just yet, but that hasn't stopped the creators of Coinye West from reaching out
to the rapper in the hope that he'll invest - or, at least, not get mad about its existence.
Follow
Coinye
Coi nyeCoi ns
@kaiiye\vest Kanye, have you ever invested in bitcoin or
litecoin? What do you think of @CoinyeWest ?
7:52 A M- 3 1 Dec 2013
51 RETWEETS 15 WORI TES
"Have you ever invested in bitcoin or litecoin?" its creators asked West via Twitter. In the Noisey interview, they also invited
West to get in contact with them, offering the rapper 100,000 "COINYE," as it's being called.
No word on how the rapper feels about having a form of currency named after him just yet.
1/8/2014 8:07 PlV 1 of 2
Case 1:14-cv-00250-AT Document 1-1 Filed 01/14/14 Page 6 of 47
New Bitcoin-Esque Cryptocurrency Named After Kanye West Launching... http://www.bilIboard.coni/articIes/news/5855158/new-bitcoin-esq
ue-...
You' ve successful l y shar ed usi ng Po.st! Share again!
2 0
Privacy Powered by Po.st I
2 of 2
1/8/2014 8:07 PM
Case 1:14-cv-00250-AT Document 1-1 Filed 01/14/14 Page 7 of 47
Coinye West, a Bitcoin Clone Named After Kanye West, Set to Launch |... htLp://www.digital trends.com/cool-tech/coinye-west-kanye-west-real/
222
K
89
K
25
K
PRODUCT REVIEWS VIDEOS NEWS FEATURES
KANYE WEST IS NOW A BITCOIN CLONE
Januar y 2, 2014 By A n d r e w Co u t s
32 64 1 ; 2 1
mc; '>(
wmn
mmm
mMSM
T 0 ^
c
z&t)
S
->*
Si
1
F'o
0
"
" C
TRENDI NG
v ? J
^ J v *-
Di gi tal Tr ends Best of CES 2014 award
f i nal i st s
& K j y J
rt*
fvy
Myo' s gest ure-cont rol bracel et makes usi ng
Ki nect l ook like drunk charades
lii'illi'BHIIIIi'
Ri ppi ng ar ound CES 2014 on an E- Go, t he
worl d' s l i ghtest motori zed...
If you thought Internet-meme-based cryptocurrency Dogecoin was ridiculous, then Kanye-
West-based altcoln Coinye West will probably just make you angry.
Gr avel ki ckers rej oi ce! Someone l eaked t he
2015 Subar u WRX STI
Named after Yeezus himself, Coinye West is set to launch on January 11, at 11 pm ET, according to
the cryptocoin's creators, who tell Vice's Noisey blog that they hope it will help bring the nebulous
world of digital currencies into the mainstream.
Insi de out : Audi reveal s stunni ng next-gen
TT i nt eri or at CES 2014
"Our goal with Coinye West is to make it easier for people to use cryptocurrency," Coinye Wesf s
unnamed creators tell Noisey. "Right now, it's kind of a dark art for people to mine coins. We plan on
releasing a front end to the "mining" programs called CoinyeMiner. It will make things a lot more
simple and people will be able to make their own coins."
The 2015 Vol kswagen Golf R begs t he
quest i on: Why get anything el se?
MOST COMMENTED
Coinye West' s creators say they chose Kanye as their cryptocurrency mascot because "he is and
always has been a trendsetter." But despite the creators' enthusiasm for the rapper, West has not
endorsed the crypotocurrency, and is apparently no way involved with it - and that could be a
problem.
MOST SHARED
LATEST REVIEWS
"We're really not sure how Kanye is gonna react to this," says Coinye's creators. "We hope he
loves it, but if he doesn't, he really isn't someone we want to piss off."
Typo keyboard case revi ew
Coinye West is only the latest so-called altcoin to launch over the past year. Some, like Litecoin,
trade at a fairly high value - though nothing close to the $750+ exchange rate Bitcoin currently
enjoys. Most wallow in the fraction-of-a-penny range - a place where Coinye should probably get
comfortable.
Our Score
House of Marl ey Li berat e
review
::
Our Score
Noki a Lumi a
1/8/2014 8:10 PM 2 of 4
Case 1:14-cv-00250-AT Document 1-1 Filed 01/14/14 Page 8 of 47
Cryptocurrency Named After Kanye West - XXL http://www.xxlmag.com/news/2014/01/kanye-west-cryptocurrency-coi...
CLICK FOR SOUND
728 News
THE MOST POPULAR
mi
(httD://www.xxl mag.com)
HOME(HTTP://WWW.XXLMACCOM) > NEWS(HTTP://WWW.XXLMAG.COM/NEWS/J > CRYPTOCURRENCYNAMEDAFTERKANYEWEST
Cryptocurrency Named After Kanye West
JAN 2ND, '14 NEWS {HTTP-7/WWW.XXLMAG.COM/NEWS/) . by CHRISTIAN BONOAN (HTTP:/M'WW,XXLMAG.C0M/AUTH0R/CHR1ST1AN/J . NO COMMENTS (HTTP://WWVjO<XLMAG,COM
/NEWS/2014/Ol/KANYE-WEST^RYPTOCURRENCY-COINYE-WEST/#COMMENTS) Like .46
il
' ?
4
MM
\ /
:*-z
.. l l S f l
^
i
f ht t p: / / www. xxl mag. com/ wD^ont ent / uD[ oads/ 2013/ 09/ kanve- west - l at e- nf ght - i i mmV' f al l on. p
Whi l e many can argue whether o r not Kanye West is the God he proclaims t o be, Yeezus can add another convincing argument to his case. Now the face and inspiration of the newly
emerging f or m of cryptocurrency, Coinye West, Kanye seems to be well on track as starting 01/ 11/ 14, Ye" will have a currency named in his honor and he di d nothing to launch i t
Cryptocurrency is a decentralized peer-to-peer utilized medium used for digital exchanges on global-friendly internet platforms. The most celebrated and acknowledged type of cryp-
tocurrency is "Bitcoin," a currency exchange infamously known for it's frequent trade on b!ack markets t o purchase firearms and drugs. In the past the currency's value was listed at
$1,000 perBi tcoi n.
The College Droupout isn't i n anyway affiliated wi t h the proj ect but in an interview wi t h Noisey (httpy7noisey.vice.com/en_ukA'ead/screw-bitcoin-and-dogecoin-theres-a-new-kanye-
west-themed-cryptocurrency-on-the-way}- the Coinye creators explained their thought process behind namingtheir Cyprtocurrency after 'Ye."We chose to represent Kanye be-
cause he is and always has been a trendsetter, and he's always keeping things unique. I can picture a f ut ure where Coinye is used to buy concert tickets, wi t h cryptographically verified
vi rtual tickets, and other ideas i can' t gi ve away just yet"
The start-up founders also reassured thei r company's name isn't a publicity plea, even adding an open invitation to the G.O.O.D. Music head-honcho, "We'd love if Kanye named
dropped Coinye" said the f ounder.
M
l t hi nk he's gonna love that there's a CURRENCY named i n his honor. We don' t want t o pay him off t o name check us. but i t'd be sick if he does so.
In-fact we're making an open i nvi t at i on to Kanye: Get hold of us at coinyewestcom and we'll send you 100,000 COINYE on launch. A hundred t housand Bitcoin started small too.
1/8/2014 8:13 PM 1 of 3
Case 1:14-cv-00250-AT Document 1-1 Filed 01/14/14 Page 9 of 47
Zryptocurrency Named After Kanye West - XXL http://www.xxlinag.coiri/news/2014/01/kanye-west-cryptocurrency-coi...
and now l ook where i f s at "
Af t er reading the i ntervi ew in it's enti rety, you'd be convinced the group' s founders are die-hard Yeezy stans. In true Kanye fan fashion, Coinye's official' s website
(http' /Zcoi nyewestcom/) quotes one of t he rapper' s most popul ar punchlines as thei r mant ra: "! don' t know whats better, getti n l ai d or get t i n paid...*
No w I ain't sayin she a Gol d Digger...
Ll k. { ] Twoet 45] KANYE WEST ( HTTP: / / WWW. XXL MAG. COM/ TAG/ KANYE- WEST/ ) TAGS:
a
NEWS {/NEWS/) XXLTV {/VIDEO/) SNEAKERS
(/LIFESTYLE
/SNEAKERS/)
(http://wwwjo<!mag.com/news/2014
^Ol/french-montana-releasing-
m a c-cheese-4-sophomore-album/)
[httpV/wwwj al mag.com/vi deo
'2014/01/problem'solves-xxl-staffs-
ssues/)
Ihttpy/www.xxlmag.com/lifestyle
/2014/01/fila*95-og-fila/)
FRENCH MONTANA RELEASING ' MAC
& CHEESE 4' AS HIS SOPHOMORE
ALBUM (H TT P.Y/WWW.XXLM AG XZ OM
/NEWS/2014/Ol/FRENCH-MONTANA-
RELEASING-MAC-CHEESE-
4-SOPHOMORE-ALBUM/)
PROBLEM SOLVES XXL STAFF'S ISSUES
[VIDEO] {HTTP://WWWOO<LM ACCOM
/VIDEO/2OI4/OI/PROBLEM-SOLVES-
XXL-STAFFS-ISSUE5/)
FILA95"0GFILA"
{ HTW/ WWWXXUvl AGOM
/LIFESTYLE/2014/01/FIIA-95-OG-
FI LM
{http://www.xxlmag.com/video
/2013/12/xx]s-2013*eye-candy-
year-teaser video/) WHO IS XXL'S
2013 EYE CANDY OF THE YEAR?
[VIDEO]
{HTTP://WWW.XXLMAGOM
/VIDEO/2013/12/XXLS-2013-EYE-
CANDY-YEAR-TEASER-VIDEO/)
(http:/ / wwwj (xl magconvhews/ 2014
/01Arak-artlst-will-flle-lawsuit-
II l-klm-end-week/) MAKEUP ARTIST
WIL1FILE LAWSUIT AGAI NSTLI LKI M
BY THE END OF THE WEEK
(HTTP://WWWJO(LMAGJCOM
/NEWS/2014/01/MAKE-ARTIST-
WILL-F1LE-LAWSUIT-LIL-KIM-
END-WEEK/)
(http://www.xxlmag.com/lifestyle
/2014/01/adidas-orlg!nals-ssl4-stan-
smith/) ADIDAS ORIGINALS SS14
STAN SMITH
(HTTP://WWW.XXLM AG.COM
/LIFESTYLE/2014/0i/ADIDAS-
0RIGINALS-SS14-STAN-SMITH/)
(http://www.xxlmag.com/video
/2013/12/video-50-cent-kendrld<-
lamar-Interview/) SOCENTON
KENDRICK: "THERE'S A HUGE
DIFFERENCE IN THE TWOOF US"
[VIDEO]
(HTTP://WWW.XXLMAGJCOM
/VIDEO/2013/12/VIDEO-SO-CENT-
KENDRICK-LAMAR-1NTERVIEW/)
MORE > (/ VIDEO/ )
(hUp://wwwJ(xlmag.com/llfestyle
/2014/01/jef f-staples-worst-
sneakers-2013/) THE WORST
SNEAKERS OF 2013 ACCORDING TO
JEFF STAPLE
(HTTP://WWWXXLMAGCOM
/L1FESTYLE/2014/01/JEFF-STAPLES-
WORST-SNEAKERS-2013/)
(http://www.xxlmag.comAiews/2014
/01/chrls-brown-re]ects-plea*deal/)
CHRIS BROWN REJECTS PLEA DEAL
(HTTP://WWWXXLMAG.COM
/NEWS/2014/Ol/CHR|S-BROWN-
REJECTS-PLEA-DEAL/)
MORE >//NEWS/)
MOfiE> (/LIFESTYLE/SNEAKERS/)
0 comments + * 0
Start the discussion...
Best Communi t y Loaui
GALLERIES
BIRDMAN'S FAVORITE
POSE. I TS FOR THE
THINKERS.
HERE'SHOW'STAR
WARS'WOULD
1
VE
LOOKED WI TH TUPAC
2 CHAINZ AND ALL HIS
FRIENDS
{HTT P: //WWW.XXLMAG.
THE EARLY DAYS OF KTE
CUBE
(HTTP://WWW.XXLMAG.
19OF BIG BOI'SFOOT
SELFIES
(HTTP://WWW^XLMAG.
Copyright <5*2014. Harris Publications. I nc All rights reserved | Terms of Use fterms-of-use/) | Privacy Pol icyt/privacy-policv-O
1/8/2014 8:13 PM 2 of 3
Case 1:14-cv-00250-AT Document 1-1 Filed 01/14/14 Page 10 of 47
Bitcoin duplicate inspired by Kanye West launches to avoid legal action... http://www.independent.co.uk/life-style/gadgets-and-tech/bitcoin-dupli...
THE INDEPENDENT THURSDAY 09 JANUARY 2014 EicpStiiiU Appciii ebooks i Jobs Dating Shop Register Login
[>
1
NEWS : IMAGES i VOI CES SPORT TECH i LIFE PROPERTY i ARTS + ENTS
;
TRAVEL MONEY INDYBEST . BLOGS STUDENT ! OFFERS
Fashion Food & Drink Health & Families History Gadgets &Tech Motoring Dating Crosswords Gaming Competitions Christinas
Technology Life > Gadgets & Tech
ELEP HAHTArat ODH ilTI 88W >
Bitcoin duplicate inspired by Kanye West
launches to avoid legal action
Search The Independent
p
Advanced Search Article archive Topics
Most Viewed Most Commented Most Shared
Spoon-fed babi es mor e likely t o
b e overweight
^ - - c ^
#^0
Masoni c conspi racy or MI 6
r ecr ui t ment tool? I nt er net
myst er y Cicada 3301 st art s up
agai n
O
' f "
h b OJfe
. ^
J
>1 .<*
; O Intel i nt roduces Edi son: a
comput er t he size of an SD car d
t o kickstart t he ' i nt ernet of
t hi ngs'
Government ' buri ed' release of
key evidence on mi ni mum
alcohol pri ce bef or e policy
U- t ur n
o - c a i ,
i
\
C vVSB
^r.
\ V
C - t
M
4
= 0
~ . . v
"Q
N
I nt d dr ops t he McAfee
ant i -vi ms br and, J ohn McAfee
says he is ' everlastingly grat eful '
'
Un*
rNDEPENDENT IMAGES
Creators claim that "the name 'Coinye' is intended solely as parody,
not an indication or implication of endorsement or involvement"
2ACHAKYBOItEN Wednesday 08 taumy 2014
l
fEET ^ SHftRE ; i n SHARE REDDIT SHARE
Shares: 14 PRINT AAA
FILM
Kanye Wes t has d e ma n d e d t hat Coinye Coin, t he Bitcoin-dupl icate he
i nspi r ed, shoul d i mme di a t e l y end "devel opment , sale, di st ri but i on and
pr omot i on" or el se f a c e l i t i gat i on. BEST PHOTOS OF AMERICAN 'BIG FREEZE
On J anuar y 6, t he creat ors of t he
cxyptocurrency, who have capital ised on t he ' Di s gus t i ng killer*
medi a' s r ecent fasci nat i on wi t h Bitcoin,
received a cease-and-desi st l et t er from West ' s
l aw f i r m, Pr yor Cashman.
Ads by Google
Need NYC Servi ced
Office?
High Profile New Serviced
Offices: Unbeatable Rates
Get 2 Months Free!
regus.conVServiced.OfTlcd.Sp
Toy Siory ond Full Metal
Jacket actor criticised for
posing proudly with two
dead lions
The r apper ' s at t orney, Br ad D Rose, accused
Coinye West, as it was known at t he t i me, of
t r a de ma r k i nf r i ngement , t r ademar k dilution,
unf ai r compet i t i on and cyberpiracy.
NEWS
aee
Sf*
ITT Tech - Official Si t e
Associate, Bachelor Degree
Programs Browse Programs
Now & Learn More.
www.itt-tech.edii
"Given Mr West' s wi de-rangi ng
ent r epr eneur i al accompl i shment s, cons umer s
a r e likely t o mi st akenl y believe t hat Mr West
i s t he sour ce of your services or [ had]
endor sed t he ci ypt ocurrency, " Mr Rose wrot e.
Whi ch UK t own
s p e n d s t he mo s t
time on p o m?
AduiC site's trends report
contains some surprising
results
Legal Case Review (Free)
Know Your Rights, Connect
ForA Free Criminal Case
Review By Lawyer
www.totaterirrinatdefense.com
Despi t e Mr West ' s t hr eat t hat h e will sue any
bus i nes s t hat accept s t he novel t y currency, Coinye l aunched l ast ni ght , 4
days ear l i er t han i t ha d ori gi nal l y i nt ended, and post ed on i t s website, "We
a r e bei ng at t acked wi t h f i shst i cks a nd mus t l aunch sooner. "
FILM
The al t coi n' s devel oper s have r esponded t o t he r apper ' s at t empt s t o shut it
down b y changi ng t h e n a me f r om Coinye West t o Coinye, al t eri ng t he l ogo
i mage a nd l a unc hi ng t he cur r ency early.
Martin Sc o r s e s e ' s
o pe n letter t o hi s
1/8/2014 8:14 PM 1 of 5
Case 1:14-cv-00250-AT Document 1-1 Filed 01/14/14 Page 11 of 47
Bitcoin duplicate inspired by Kanye West launches to avoid legal actioa.. http://www.independent.co.uk/life-style/gadgets-and-tech/bitcoin-dupli...
On t he f or um bi t coi nt al kcor a, CoinyeCoin devel opers also expl ai ned t hat
"The name' Cor nye' i s i nt ended solely as par ody, not a n i ndi cat i on or
i mpl i cat i on of e ndor s e me nt or i nvol vement . "
VIDEO
Int ervi ews given t o t h e Wall St reet J our nal a nd ArsTechni ca i ndi cat e t hat
t he anonymous c r e a t or s of Coinye hol d ant i - est abl i shment a nd
ant i -capi t al i st bel i efs, havi ng been quot ed as saying t hat "anar cho-
capi t al i sm is comi ng, i t can' t be st opped. Whet her it has a symbol t hat
l ooks like a dol l ar, a dog, or a cart oon pi ct ur e of a r apper , it' s all t he s a me
lim Papsons
U F E
rheBig
Bang Theory
Theme Song
(Glamour
Magazine)
t hi ng. "
The creat ors, who i dent i f y t hemsel ves "just a few guys who want t o t ake
cr ypt ocur r ency t o t h e mai ns t r eam, " t weet ed the r a p i con in December t o
ask hi m hi s t hought s o n t he project, a nd mo r e recent l y t ol d Vice t hey
"hope he l oves t hi s. "
Gisele
Bundchen
Frolics In Bikini
Wi t h t hi s devel opment , t he creat ors pr obabl y have t hei r answer.
c 13
i n SHARE m SHARE TWfET ******
You may also tike t h e s e
iw
Taylor Swift
Causing
Outrage After
Building Sea
Wall
11
M -*^3
it
Jenni f er Lawrence 25 Celebrities You If you have Gmail, Five reasons I
i n Dior, One of Di dn' t Know Were try t hi s email trick prefer t he Pebble
Vogue' s Best Black! (bijansabet.com) sinartwatch over
Dressed at t he (Styleblazer) the Samsung
Met Gala Galaxy Gear
(Vogue) (ZDNet)
%
P M
Sofia Vergara
Isn't Ashamed
of Her Riches
From around t he web
Don' t Touch t hat Ket chup: Keep
Heal t hy by Avoiding t he s e 8 Germ
Havens (AARP)
More from The Independent
British ex-soldier fears def ence
evidence may be blocked as he faces
mur der trial before Congo military
t ri bunal (06 January 2014)
Recommended by
Acne Spring 20a l (Vogue)
SPORT
Gone wi t h t he Wi nd actress Alicia
Rhet t dies aged 98 (05 January 2014)
* Katie Hopki ns 'axed* from This
Make Your Own I nf ogr aphi c in 5 Morni ng af t er Scottish life
Easy St eps (Graphic Stock Blog) expectaucy tweet (05 December 2013)
25 Celebrities You Di dn' t Know
Were Black! (Styleblazer)
Britney Spears* Team St unned By Chi nese scientists ' increasingly
' Unapproved' Ques t i on On ' Good confi dent ' about invisibility cloak
Morni ng Ameri ca' (RadaiOnline.com) af t er maki ng a cat disappear (11
December 2013)
Atlardyce r e ac he s
poi nt of no return as
H ammers are
crus hed by City
Plastic Surgery Di sast ers: Lil Kiin,
Meg Ryan. & Mor e (Hollyscoop) Masoove conspiracy or MI6
recrui t ment tool? I nt er net myst ery
Cicada 3301 st art s up again (07
January 2014)
Manchester City 6 West
Ham 0: Negredo runs riot
in Capital One Cup
semi-final first leg to leave
West Ham manager on the
News in brief: Ex-Dragon' s store Sci-fi wri t er Isaac Asimov predicted
chai ns r oar ahead, Smal l busi ness t he world of 2014 in 1964: here' s
l oans on t he up, J o h n s o n Services what he got wrong (03 January 2014)
boss st ands down (Evening Standard)
brink
TECH
MSI
m
Recommended by
m
Ads by Google
Free Publicity for You
100s Of Journalists Need Your Story. Free Submissions!
helpareporter.com
Life i s a lot s weet er
with t he aid of a 3D
printer
Kim Kardashian' s New Home
Stunning photos of Kim Kardashian and Kanye West's luxurious home.
www.lonny.co rr/celebrtty*- hones
Intricate, beautiful sugar
cubes could be the key to
getting the devices into the
kitchen
What is Your Claim Wort h?
Free* Ask a Local Lawyer Now. Get Compensated for Pain & Suffering!
VftYW.pe rsonaMnjury-he Ipois
PROM.AROUND THE WEB .
NEWS
Wz
Lumos'rty Brain Ga me s
Challenge memory a nd attention with scientific brain games.
www.iumo8tty.com
I
M the Nicole Farhi
mens wear...
(StyleBistro)
Katie Hol mes Wears
Tiny...
(Tasty Articles)
Sugge s t e d Topi cs : Wail St. J our nal Rap Hip-Hop
The Wall St r eet J o u r n a l Parody Capi t al i sm Ent r epr euneur shi p
Workers'
co- operat i ves: One
for all, all f or one
They haven't had a great
press of late, but one food
1/8/2014 8:14 PM 2 of 5
Case 1:14-cv-00250-AT Document 1-1 Filed 01/14/14 Page 12 of 47
EXHIBIT B
Case 1:14-cv-00250-AT Document 1-1 Filed 01/14/14 Page 13 of 47
Top 10 Albums | Top 10 Everything of 2013 - Arts and Entertainment | TIME.com Page 1 of 6
\ Wliy the rules of h u n t l n e ; ^ Apps
Entertainment
m
Search TIME
H ome I NewsFeed I U^. I Pol i ti cs I World | Busi ness I Tech ! H ealth i Sci ence ! Entertainment I Video 1 TIME 100 Photos
Home j Movies { Television [ Books ( Music | Populist | Video Games j Photos | Sports
AdChgtee!>
ESSM
111
"*
11
|!||
' ' ' ' '
1
"'I,, : '
Top 10 of Everything: Arts and Entertainment
TIME
f ottUH e tioitmH
ERROR- PAGE NOT FOU1
'!
The page you' ve request ed has been move
We apol ogi ze f or t he i nconveni ence.
The r e are several ways you can fi nd t he in
<<!!: I ' Iiiliii.i i
1
1
1
ih I'liiiiLiii.uil.ii.iii.i.!!!!!!!!.!.!..:!!.!!.!.!'!.
Uke- ^Sk] | Twae. | {i i i 1 S- 1 : J S , ^ S h a n , . ! 2 j Read Later Cnn*''*!* 'I'Iii>i ii'
Top 10 Albums
By Douglas Wolk I Dec. 04, 2013 I 26 Comment s
30/ 17
VIEW ALL
See the rest of TIM E'S Top 10 of Everything 2013 lists here
10. M atangi, M. I . A.
Pop pr ovocat eur s t end t o age awkwar dl y, a nd M.I A. of t en t ri es a little t oo har d t o
foment out r age (al t hough i t ' s ha r d t o t r u mp havi ng Jul i an Assange as an openi ng act ).
Still, her f our t h al bum is pl ent y pr ovocat i ve a nd out rageous-soundi ng: dance musi c
t hat ' s t wi t chy l i ke a sl ug of Thi r d Wor l d- expl oi t i ng coffee, shot t hr ough wi t h neon-
bri ght digital di st or t i on and mut a t e d So u t h Asi an i nst r ument at i on. And her most
pot ent weapon is still her dr y, ve nomous , wor d- savor i ng voice.
Hi
Interscope
RECOMMENDED FOR YOU
by Tabool e
9. M ole City, Qua s i
Twent y year s i nt o t hei r col l abor at i on, si nger / gui t ar i st / keyboar d- abuser Sam Coomes
and feral d r u mme r J a ne t Wei ss ar e st i l l o n such a roll t hat t hei r ni nt h al bum is a
doubl e, j us t ' cause. They' r e as wi t t i l y i ndi gna nt as ever, and Coomes ai ms his bi l e
i nward as of t en as out war d. The s ha r pe s t of M ole City's many homebr ewed
evocat i ons of t he earl y-' yos mome nt w h e n Queen and Todd Rundgr en and Badfi nger
wer e get t i ng l oud and wei r d is, nat ur al l y, cal l ed "Nostalgia Kills."
Voted Best City in the World Eveiy TIME Person of the
Year in 30 Seconds
Kill Rock Stars
8. The Electric Lady, J a n e l l e Mo n d e
2013 Person of the Year Pope Pereon of the Year2013: Why
Francis Relmaglnes t... TIME Chose Pope Fra...
Par t soul revivalist, par t r et r o- Af r of ut ur i s t , all robot oh, fine, s he j us t plays one on
YouTube Mon&e is t he ki nd of s i nger w h o l l b e t he subj ect of Ph. D. di ssert at i ons a
cent ur y f r om now. Her second a l bum i s pr e s e nt e d as "suites* 4 and 5 in a n ongoi ng
sci-fi epic, f eat ur i ng convi nci ng pa s t i c he s of St evi e Wonder , t he Jackson 5, and, most
of all, Pr i nce ( who also t ur ns u p in t he f l e s h) . Moni e' s reach somet i mes exceeds her
grasp, but bl ess her f or ai mi ng s o d a mn hi gh.
LATEST FROM OUR PARTNERS
gpFf*
50 St at es' Bi ggest Snow
Days Weather
' ml !
Wondaland Arts Society
v;-
http://enteitaiiiment.time.corn/20 1/9/2014
Case 1:14-cv-00250-AT Document 1-1 Filed 01/14/14 Page 14 of 47
Top 10 Albums | Top 10 Everything of 2013 - Arts and Entertainment | TIME.com Page 2 of 6
Jewish Surnames Explained-Slate
m
Win a Lone Survivor Prize Pack! - Rot t e n Tomatoes
Sllii
Sjffi
POPULAR AMONG SUBSCRIBERS SUBSCRIBE
!,
A
! !' i!|.'
ll,!'!'
Janet Yellen: The Sixteen Trillion H |gi||
Dollar Woman UeBm
llfU flr-fii
laffil
J' I v "'iiwl'iii!,! """,'
7. Cut 4 M e, Kel el a
Japan' s Booming Sex Niche:
Elder Porn
B||
lii&f
Ever y so of t en, s omebody fi gures out h o w t o br i ng t he s ounds of under gr ound dance
d u b s i nt o pop. Thi s year , i t ' s t he L. A. -based vocal i st Kelela Mi zanekri st os, whose
debut al bum (rel eased as a f r ee downl oad) is bui l t on t he hal f -t i me beat s and
unset t l i ng negat i ve- space ar r angement s of t he "bass musi c" collectives Ni ght Slugs
a nd Fade t o Mi nd. I t ' s f or bi ddi ng st uff, b u t it mes hes wi t h t he sweet ' 90s R&B
i nf l ect i ons of Kelela' s si ngi ng her aest het i c, as she put s it, is "Brandy but weirder. "
111
The Autism Debate: Who' s Afraid
of Jenny McCarthy?
Fade to Mind
Inside Prince Charles' World As
He Quietly Takes Charge
6. Electricity by Candlelight, Al ex Chi l t on
AI . CX C H I L T ON
On a Febr uar y ni ght i n 1997, t he power we n t out at t he cl ub wher e t he late cult her o
Chi l t on was pl ayi ng but s omebody h a d an acoust i c gui t ar, and somebody else had a
casset t e r ecor der , and so t hi s t hri l l i ng, of f - t he- cuf f set of covers was preserved.
Chi l t on was al ways a cont r ar i an, and he s t oppe d maki ng bi g art i st i c st at ement s af t er
hi s ear l y- ' yos b a n d Big St ar br oke up, s o t hi s i s j ust a document of a great ent ert ai ner
havi ng a ri di cul ousl y good ni ght .
Get ail a c c e s s t o digital and print SUBSCRIBE
Most Popular I
FROM ENTERTAINMENT
Bar None Records
*1 Where's Mindy Kalintfs Body? Elle Crops Star's
Curves
2 Top 10 of Everything: Arts and Entertainment
5. The Wor s e Things Get, The Harder I Fight, The Ha r de r 7
Fight, The M ore J Love You, Ne ko Case
3 A Slimmed-Down Jessica Simpson Talks Harsh
Weight Scrutiny VStiile Pregnant
You can' t even call Case "al t ernat i ve count r y" any mor e, despi t e t he t wang t hat will
never l eave her voice and t he ache t hat c a s t s a war mi ng s hadow over all of her musi c.
He r ne w songs circle ar ound t he idea of exi l e f r om feel i ng, f r om l oved ones, f r om
recei ved i deas about womanhood, and especi al l y f r om home . To see her lyrics on a
page, you' d t hi nk t hey wer e arch ar t - s onga; whe n you he a r her sing t hem, t hey cut as
deepl y as a f r i end' s l at e- ni ght conf essi on.
y.
4 The 25 Best Songs of 2013 (The Entire Year)
5 The 25 Best Songs of 2013 (So Far)
ANTI Records
FROM T1ME.COM
^ Colorado^ Pot Shops Say They'll Be Sold Out Any
Day Now
2 5 Tech Products That VMII Be Dead in 5 Years
4. Who Is William Onyeabor?, Wi l l i am Onyeabor
On y o u b o r ?
-
3 Kate Winsiet Strikes Back At Pregnancy Critics
Bet ween t he l at e- ' yos and t he mi d- ' 8os , Wi l l i am Onyeabor rel eased eight al bums on
hi s own Wi l fUms l abel in Ni geri a. Then h e dr opped out of publ i c view altogether, and
t he pecul i ar geni us of hi s percol at i ng, synt hesi zer - cent er ed grooves was l ost t o
ever yone but f anat i cal r ecor d col l ectors. Thi s l ong- over due career survey is riveting
a nd unf ai l i ngl y f unky, you can hear t he i ns pi r at i on of Fel a Kuti' s Afrobeat , and
s ounds t hat woul d t ur n i nt o new wave a f e w year s l at er, b ut Onyeabor mostly sounds
l i ke nobody el se on t he pl anet .
4 Dont Call Him A Freak: Colin Kaepemick Opens Up
On Quarterback Sodology, Tattoos, Adoption
*
0 Men Are Obsolete
Luako Bop
MORE ON TIME
http://entertainment.time.coin/2013/12/04/arts-and-entertainment/slide/top-10-albums/ 1/9/2014
Case 1:14-cv-00250-AT Document 1-1 Filed 01/14/14 Page 15 of 47
Top 10 Albums | Top 10 Everything of 2013 - Arts and Entertainment | TIME.com Page 3 of 6
Assad Regime
Airstrike Hits
Damascus
Neighborhood, Say
Activists
World of Ash as
Indonesian Volcano
WHAT
BOYS REALLY
I AI ft K I T
WANT
Er u p t s
i
ii
fSfc
1
.::t-
IBtiliiSfif iif
Anyone Can Find
Love in 2014
The Best 25 Songs of
2013
3. m bv, My Bl oody Val ent i ne
Twent y- one year s af t er My Bl oody Val ent i ne' s epochal Loveless, gui t ari st / si nger
Kevin Shi el ds' endl ess st r i ng of as s ur ances t hat t hey wer e alm ost done wi t h a new
al bum wer e abr upt l y repl aced, one ni ght , b y a n announcement t hat it was done and
r eady f or downl oad. Boom. ( The l at e- ' ?os- st yl e dr um- ' n' - bass r hyt hms of "Wonder 2"
suggest t ha t t h e y real l y had be e n wor ki ng on it all along.) Shi el ds is appar ent l y t he
ki nd of per f ect i oni st who can act ual l y l et go of somet hi ng once it' s perfect : m bv's
t or r ent i al was h of mi l l i on-l ayers-deep gui t ar s a nd purri ng honey- power voices i s as
gl ori ous as he wa nt e d it t o be.
CONNECT WITH TIME
\ Follow (gmi EU 5.3M followers j ^ 2.3m | Like
TIME
: Follow +1
+ 5.009,466
!
mbv
Sign up for TIME'S top stories
newsletter, and more info
Go
2. M odem Vam pires of the City, Vampi r e Weekend
A
Vampi r e We e k e n d does t he s a me t hi ng wi t h mus i c t hat really clever wri t ers do wi t h
wor ds: t hei r vocabul ar y' s i mmens e, and s o is t hei r command of i di om a nd t one, and
t hey use t hos e gi ft s t o be t hought f ul and evocat i ve r at her t han j us t to show off.
( Unsur pr i si ngl y, si nger Ezra Koeni g does t hat wi t h words, too. ) You can spend days
unpacki ng t hei r t hi r d al bum' s al l usi ons a n d j uxt aposi t i ons, or you can j us t r i de t he
ri ppl es of its wr y, ri di cul ousl y cat chy medi t at i ons on t he shi ft f r om over - comf or t abl e
yout h t o uncer t ai n mat ur i t y.

POPUUS T
TELEVISION
Archer Gets Naked for Reddit
Hit comedy promotes 5th season whh (almost)
NSFWads XL
MOVIES
Yule Be Sorry: 10 Movies You
Forgot Were Set During
Christmas
POP CULTURE
j j t p ^ The Sprite Stuff: 10 Great Pop-
KKf el Culture Elves
i . Yeezus
9
Kanye Wes t
" vii
Kanye is t he be s t t her e is, a nd he' s still n o t as good as he t hi nks he is. Has t her e ever
been a not he r gr eat al bum t hi s bi t t er , t hi s ent i t l ed, t hi s abrasivel y unsat i sfi ed or t hi s
sel f -aware a b out it? (See its mos t - quot ed j oke: "In a Fr ench- ass r es t aur ant / Hur r y up
wi t h my d a mn croi ssant s. ") Yeezus i s br i ef , spar e, nast y, and as char i smat i c as a cul t
l eader . I t s mus i c gr i nds sourl y or l ur ches like an old rol l ercoast er; West ' s voi ce dr i ps
cont empt or hi des behi nd fri gi d Aut o- Tune effects. But Yeezus, has he ever got r aw
power .
I
a
i.
ii, j '
TIME populist
'i I #
What are the best
movies, albums, and
TV shows of all time?
Roca-A-Fella
Think we m issed som ething? Tell us using hashtag #TIM Esoi3
| Follow TIME | >{ 5.3M followers j
Download
TIME'S Populist
a pp and And out fea
NEXT^ To p 10 S o n g s
^"l A , j.1 t 11 iri-
U App St ore
SSWffPjlt:
i
Share Comment Follow @T1MECulture Print Email
FROM TH E WEB Sponsor ed Cont ent by Tboota
The Wine Club You'll Want
To Join
T/ifi Huffington Post
55 Free, Downloadable
Templates for Visual...
HubSpat
VIDEO: Habits for improving
credit in 2014
Better M oney Habits
8 College Degr ees That
Ar ent Worth t he Money
Salary.com
http://entertainment.time.corn/2013/12/04/arts-and-entertainment/slide/top-10-albums/ 1/9/2014
Case 1:14-cv-00250-AT Document 1-1 Filed 01/14/14 Page 16 of 47
Top 10 Albums | Top 10 Everything of 2013 - Arts and Entertainment | TIME.com Page 4 of 6
Sponsored Unks
WE RECOMMEND FROM AROUND TH E WEB
StandUp Comedy ClintonNJ
Come See Our Grand Opening Show. Tickets $20 RSVP On Website
Todayl
www.gardenstatecomedycIub.com
And 2013' s Worst Fictional Sex Sc e ne Is. . . * Jenny McCarthy Chops Off H er H airSee The View
Cohos f s Makeover^/ Online)
' Tonya H arding Says Attack on Nancy Ke ny a n Knee*
Capped H er Career
' ' 127 H ours' Guy Who Survived Canyo n Fall By Cutting
Off H is Own Arm Gets Arrested for Domes t i c Violence * Christine Lahti on Looking Fabulous at Sfyufescript)
* 10 H idden Sexual Innuendos in Animated FilmfCe/eirify
Gossip Answers)
' Tina Turner ReKnquishes U.S. Ci ti zenshi p
* Catching Fire Nude Scene: 'Faithful t o the Adaptati on
* 4-Year-Old Dies After Be ng Found Uncons cbus in
Midtown Luxury Butldingp/MMo;
* The Best Books Of 2013fOa7yCandyJ
Recommended by Outbraln [?)
26 Comments
livefyrefa
Sign in
+ Follow ' Pos t commert
Newest | Oldest
McBtzzy
Hell yeah it's Yeezus
MattCasale
Seriously, you put Kanye on h e r e but not Eminem? Shame on you.
ScottValentine
Full Circle by Half Moon Run. Ha n d s Down.
| | | j
Greg Mason
No list is complete without The National' s Trouble Will Find Me.
MeeBrr
No no no no no no no. Kanye is t o music what Kim Kardash' an is to television: fake, ridiculous and a piss-poor
representation of intelligent life o n t he planet.
I Lit rig ol
No, I mean, where ar e Kurt Vile a nd Arcade Fire ones ?
JoshVi ckers
Everytime s ome one says somet hi ng positt/e about Kanye West, a fairy dies.
Al exandert i ukov
God is dead in the world wher e yeezus is on top.
M JeffConanVargon
It's great to s ee this Alex Chilton al bum on this listl Thanks Doug!
JE
p g g ' The Sectric Lady" by Janeile Mona e featuring Miguel, Erykah Badu, Cee Lo, and Prince was so good and
. ^ i r f r r f Ti T r evotitionary. She raps and s i n g s like Lauryn Hill. It's a shame it didnt get any Grammy nomhations.
Austi n James
this is t he biggest joke of a list 1 ha ve s een. How ar e you rat hg t hese albums. How do you leave off an Artist
who had t i e two number 1 a l b ums in t he s ame year and t he biggest selling album of the year in Justin
http ://entertainment.tinie. com/2013/12/04/arts-and-entertainment/slide/top-10-albums/ 1/9/2014
Case 1:14-cv-00250-AT Document 1-1 Filed 01/14/14 Page 17 of 47
Top 10 Albums | Top 10 Everything of 2013 - Arts and Entertainment | TIME.com Page 5 of 6
Timbertake. If I didn't stumble upon this article I would have never seen this same as no on reads TIME
magazi ne. . . . you ar e a joke of a magazi ne and aiicle writer.
Vi duaDi abot usNl ger
Music is not your busi ness but still better than very specialized magazines, pity is that rock is dead t o you, and
this is idiocy primary! ...Like Clockwork is a masterpiece of an artist with Rock in the veins, music is art!!! M8V??
Makes me sl eep. The Real Rock i s dead b you, unfortunately
lordmeta
ftjl Really? ht t p^/ www. t ayl crci ark. co/ wp-cont ent / Lpl oads/ 2013/ 04/ pi card. j pg
I ndi eSongADay
I'll never get music like Yeezus, let alone it making a Top 10 of the Year list.
The best songs of 2013 ar e he r e
i ndi e b e s t of 2013( @j ndi es ongaday)
c o y o t e b a n d t 3
(>MattCasale Probably b/c MMLP2 is a pretty bad album.
| | | | j ^ l . Fucki ngMagi c
jSlll| @Mat t Casal et hey both suck
c o y o t e b a n d t 3
^ @MeeBrr Uhh, no. Ther e' s a r eas on etery single one of his albums has been widely critically acclaimed and has
inspired basically everyone n rap. There' s a reason h'e album MBDTF is considered one oft he greatest albums
every created in music.
Ker us Nl aw
i bet you love nirvana, t he beat l es, and pinkfioyd you sheep :
A
)
St evenTanner
@Litrigol Arcade Fire must be t he most overrated band In theworld. They' re alright, but very pretentious and
over wr ou^i t
| | | . c o y o t e b a n d t 3
@J os hVi cker s Kanye V\fest is a great producer. Kanye West is an influential icon in rap. Kanye West created
m
one of t he greatest albums in musi c. Kanye West has one of t he most consistent discographies in music right
now with all 6 of his albums getting HUGE critical acclaim.
c o y o t e b a n d t 3
@Al exander Zhukcv u mad cuz u bad
mossi tabrenancb
@Aust i n J a me s Britney Spear s had planty of number one albums, but her mus e sucks!
s cot t s ur et t e
@Aus tin J a me s a number 1 a b u m on t i e charts has absolutely nothing to do with how good the album is. I love
t he 20/20 experience, but t hat ' s j ust a silly argument. One Direction's album r eadi ed number 1 and sold a ton of
copies, does that mean in your view it belongs on this list?
D. Ubben
@ln die Song A Day I personally think some of the songs on your pl ^l i st are awful, but I do agree on Yeezus. So
overrated.
Emt l i aBaj ena
@St evenTanner @Lt t r i gol They have been mak' ng musi c for a very long time, I've been af an for almost a
decade. I don' t think that just b e c a us e the world started recognizing their talent recently makes them pretentious.
If I wa s in t he industry for that l ong I wouldn't give a crap either.
DamienWiUis
@St evenTanner @Lf t r i gol But i loves dem
http://entertainment.time.com/2013/12/04/arts-and-entertainment/slide/top-10-albums/ 1/9/2014
Case 1:14-cv-00250-AT Document 1-1 Filed 01/14/14 Page 18 of 47
Top 10 Albums | Top 10 Everything of 2013 - Arts and Entertainment | TIME.com Page 6 of 6
iphone iPad Android TIME TV Populist The Page
I U. S. i Politics i World ] Busi ness I Tech I Health Sci ence I Ent ert ai nment i Phot os I Vi deos I Lists I Magazi ne Ne ws Fe e d
2014 Time inc. All rights reserved [ Privacy Poficy {Your California Privacy Rights {RSS | Newsletter! Mobile | TIME For Kids Subscribe
| Contact Us | Terms of Use | Media Kit | Reprints & Permissions j Help | Site Map 1 Ad Choices ' 1 1 Custom Content
Powered byWordPress.com VIP
our partners
http://entertainment.time.com/2013/12/04/arts-and-entertainment/slide/top-10-albvims/ 1/9/2014
Case 1:14-cv-00250-AT Document 1-1 Filed 01/14/14 Page 19 of 47
Page 1 of38
EoaC
best music of 2013
50 favorite albums
NPR Music's 50 Favorite Albums Of 2013
December 10,2013 8:07 AM
i
ft
L.
If
If &
f/'frl
I
<!'
|a
Source: NPR
Credit Meredith Rizzo
Conversations About Our
Al bums Of The Year
These are the albums we loved the most this
year. In what we've written about each one
below, you can see what we felt should be
rewarded, what shook us up and what sucked us
in over the 12 months of 2013.
The Best Indie Pop Of
2013
5 mln 24 sec
Not every one of the 22 different people with
bylines here agree on which albums did any of
that to them we don't listen the same way, or
for the same reasons but you'll read the word
"warm" more than once (as applied to an indie
songwriter, a country singer and two electronic
producers). We were seduced by darkness at
least five times (electronic, rock, classical, metal)
and loved sounds that we call "delicate" (three
out of four made by men). "Wry" hit the spot
twice (country singer again, and a pair of
More Than Jus t
'Yeezus': The Year In
H ip-H op
Classical And World
Music H ighlights
http://www.npr.org/blogs/bestmusic2013/2013/12/10/249243 87 l/npr-musics-50-favorite-al... 1 /9/2014
Case 1:14-cv-00250-AT Document 1-1 Filed 01/14/14 Page 20 of 47
Page 21 of 38
KACEY MUSGRAVES
SAME TRAILER DIFFERENT PARK
The biggest quiet story in popular music this year involved women
singer-songwriters who kept their tongues in their mouths and told
the truth of ordinary lives. Texas-born, Nashville-based Kacey
Musgraves set the standard with a major label debut that sounded
like current country while avoiding all the cliches about Chevys and
flags and spring break debauchery. Instead, Musgraves sang in her
been-there-done-that drawl about restaurant workers waiting for a
break, small-town kids slowly morphing into the parents they resent
and strong women who know that a hook-up might be just a hook-up
and Prince Charming is sometimes best kept as a memory. Then
there's the anthem "Follow Your Arrow," the "Same Love" of country,
which turned YOLO into a means of real liberation. By year's end,
Same Trailer Different Park was winning awards, Musgraves was
writing songs with Katy Perry, and she had fully proven that country
belongs as much to women with smarts as to men with trucks. Ann
Powers
"Merry Go 'Round"
-
iw
KANYE WEST
YEEZUS
http://www.npr.org/blogs/bestmusic2013/2013/12/10/249243 87 l/npr-musics-50-favorite-al... 1 /9/2014
Case 1:14-cv-00250-AT Document 1-1 Filed 01/14/14 Page 21 of 47
Page 22 of 3 8
Right before Yeezus, his sixth studio album, crashed into the public
sphere in June, Kanye West told the New York Times, "I understand
culture. I am the nucleus." The album almost justifies such supreme
egotism. Soundwise, it builds something new, juxtaposing avant-
garde industrial and electronic innovations with the High Romantic
hip-hop West had already perfected. And then there's what West
says in its forty rampaging minutes. Sex fantasies and a dirty lover's
despairing mea culpas emerge from West's confused id, while his
exacting superego places his urges within the context of American
racism, international celebrity and the infinite void of consumerist
decadence. (There are jokes, too, Richard Pryor style.) The most
Blood On The Leaves
Kanye West
6:00

LA SANTA CECILIA
TREINTA DIAS
2013 was a big year for the LA-based La Santa Cecilia after years of
touring, recording and hustling a place for themselves in Latin music.
The group was signed by a major label. Its stellar vocalist La Marisol
was invited to sing on the Elvis Costello/Roots collaboration released
this year. The band was featured in the pages of major U.S.
newspapers and of course we at Alt.Latino continued to appreciate
its unique musical vision, and especially Treinte Dias, a forward-
looking mix of folklore, jazz, cumbia and rock 'n' roll spirit. Felix
Contreras
http://www.npr.org/blogs/bestmusic2013/2013/12/10/249243871/npr-musics-50-favorite-al... 1/9/2014
Case 1:14-cv-00250-AT Document 1-1 Filed 01/14/14 Page 22 of 47
Page 1 of 3
< s
fc
BUY BEFORE YOU DIE: $500TODD LIFE POLICY FOR $S7/I10WTH
PICK YOUR ACES
Mt - S S
C a l c a l a t e Heii P&vm ent
l fl -55 SL- bS ^ 7 5 2 b - 3 5 3L- MS Ov e r 7 5
SEARCH... Submit Qu<
+616k +327k +8k
STYLE | SNEAKERS | ART+DESIGN I CITY GUIDE } TECH j RIDES MUSIC | POP CULTURE i SPORTS } GIRLS | VIDEO GAMES LATEST | LISTS COMPLEX TV
Tlie 50 Best Albums oi 2013 MUSIC 1. Kanyo Wesrt, Voezos
The 50 Best Al bums of 2013
BY INSANUL AHMED, ALEXANDER GLECKMAN, ANGEL DIAZ, BRANDON JENKINS, BRENDAN FREDERICK, CLAIRE
LOSENFELD, DAVE BRV, DAVID DRAKE, DHARMIC X. EDWIN ORTIZ, FOSTER KAMER. JACOB MOORE, JASON
PARHAM. JUSTIN DAVIS, KHAL, KYLE KRAMER, NOAH CALLAHAN-BEVER, ROB KENNER, ROSS SCARANO, SASHA
HECHT | DEC 0, 2013 11:30 PM | PERMAUNK
ED JL
Uke
Q
SUBSCRIBE
Recent Videos
jJL I , RiFF RAFF REALM |
' 499111 H Episode 7
51 OF 51
11
4%
47 g 4 4 4
o
Yeezus and 5 Other Live
Shows You Don't Want To
Miss in Early 2014
isf
HI
ifmmm
j
1
' i" '' I
Sif"
Most Anticipated Albums of
2014
i'
1
^
V
ifc
1
-, Freddie Gibbs | Complex
t f S Individuals
il
i ji
1
I!'.'"'
i
i'l
j;
KRS-One puts MC Funky J
In His Place m
Test Tags
DFP Sltename: -
Silo:
Tier
Zone:
Keywords:
Exclude:
Campaign ID: <
i-j
Vi ew MORE AT:
COMP LEX.COM/TV
.1
Jii
M ' v ' : ' ' :
: " * " V
Reset Form ^i'. .A f .,'11
' y
I ' m sti l l goi ng s
st r ong, a n d
sti l l l ovi ng
We i g h t Wa t c h e r s , j t ' k / , ^
' / - / / - . .'e : r f , I ^
weightwatchers
' I ' . ' . l t al l ! , ,l! .1,""' S i'iiiiij::
imane via Wklpedla

7 f ' .
's
rp
On Sight
m Kanye West
4 0 I N M E |
2:37
MOST POPULAR: MUSIC
What ar e you gonna do? It' s t h e best .
8
The Most Anticipated Albums of 2014
Sur e you want t o be di f f erent , y o u don' t want t o be a sheep, blindly fol l owi ng the herd wher ever it
goes. You don' t wanna be a " st an, " unabl e t o see any faul t wi t h t he new work of an arti st whose
wo r k you' ve l oved before. But wh a t are you gonna do? Li e? Just so you can be di fferent, j ust t o
buck a t r end? Just to pr ove a poi nt ? That ' d be st upi d.
Chance The Rapper and James Biake Will Be
Moving Into a House Together In Los Angeles
This Year
||^j|||||
Dra>te
> Kendrick Lamar, and J. Cole Ranked on
Five New Rappers Most Likely To Blow Up In
2014 (Video)
Mu c h l i ke t hr ee year s ago, wh e n Kanye West t opped every year-end i i st in t he uni verse wi t h My
Beautiful Dark Twisted Fantasy album, and its cent erpi ece song "Runaway, " we seem t o f i ndi ng a
si mi l ar st at e of unani mi t y in f eel i ng about t hi s year ' s Yeezus and " New Sl aves." You got t a gi ve in. i f
you' r e gonna be honest at l e a s t Kanye' s operat i ng at a hi gher l evel of artistry t han any ot her arti st
on t he pl anet right now.
Why Nas* "It Wss Written
1
' Is Belter Than
i ; "Hlmstic"
LINKS WE LIKE
SHARE

http://www.complex.coin/music/2013/12/the-50-best-albums-of-2013/kanye-west-yeezus 1/9/2014
Case 1:14-cv-00250-AT Document 1-1 Filed 01/14/14 Page 23 of 47
Page 2 of 3
It's apparent from jump. Right from the opening synth squalls of "On Sight" From the electro tick-
tick-tick. From the bass turned way past distortion. This is something new. Sounds you haven't hear
before. Like a spaceship crashing in your backyard. You can't help but look, you can't help but
approach. Out of curiosity if nothing else at first. You're being pulled forward by your ears. Kanye's
making a statement. "I'm from the future. I'm here to show you how ifs going to be."
5
DO ANDROIDS DANCE
H Todd Terry Made a Trap Album
PEPS! PULSE
Five Unexpected Cameos in Music Videos This
Year
PIGEONS & PLANES
Watch Videos of Famous Musicians Before They
Got Famous
tmskMi
SUPERGLUED
It's not all going to be pretty. It' s not all going to fun. The sounds are discordant, abrasive. The lyrics
harsh, abusive. It's nasty. But it's thrilling. Through the whole album. There's no let up. Song after
song. Start to finish. (Only ten songs. That's all it takes.) Especially now, six months after its
release, Yeezus has revealed itself to be one coherent set piece. With its sound, and its themes.
On message, on point.
I Video: Danny Brown (AKA Black Brad Pitt} Plays
NYU
FOUR PINS
The Myth Of "IDGAF"
BOOST MOBILE WORLDS COLUDE
Be Heard
"My momma was raised in an era when/Clean water was only served to the fairer skin."
Complex Magazine That's the world I'm coming from, he's saying. That's the world you made. I didn't make it, and I
don't like it. So I'm tearing the whol e thing down and starting a new one. Like
That's what art is, right? Making something new. Even if it's just a little different (and Yeezus is a lot
different), making something new that can show people a different perspective, a different
viewpoint.
619,079 people like Complex Magazine.
W ~
Musically, Kanye is glowing right now. Like a piece of Kryptonite. Yeezus is something we've never
seen before. It's a huge accomplishment. A triumph.
f-'acc-tsook codftt piutr'4
What are you gonna do? It's t he best. Dave Bry
MOST POPULAR: COMPLEX.COM
y follow jj66.4K followers] STAY CONNECTED WITH COMPLEX MUSIC The Hottest Wearable Tech From CES 2014 Like 16k
Why It's Nol Lame to Be Labeled a Siioakerhead
Tags: kanya^west
10 Predictions We Have for Pitti Uomo
More Noteworthy Cars You Should See at the
L.A. Auto Show
How to Offend Your Friends Using HBO's "Sarah
Silverman: We Are Miracles"
YOU MIGHT ALSO LIKE:
W
Test
DFP
Silo:
Zone:
KeywortliCraziest Things
ExciudShat Happened in
CampatyX< ttn-2013
x
iis
The Drunkest
Things That
Happened in 2013
The Biggest Art
News Stories of
2013
Sango - "BB Don't Art Basel 20131
Cry (It's Gon' Be Nie! "Shoe"
OK)" Meulman
Doandroldsdance.com Comptex.tv
Reset Form Show Form
TRENDING ARTICLES:
m
M
The Most Hated
Player on Every
NBA Team
Desusvs. Mero
Episode 3: The
Caucacity of
Cheese
Here's the Raptors
x OVO T-Shirt That
Will Be Given
Away to Toronto Pifjeons&Pianes
Fans During
"Drake Night"
15 Free Songs You
Should Download
Right Now
Slussy Spring
2014 Pullover
Oxford
Buttondowns
Qr^en-label.com
OLDER MUSIC NEWER
Tlmbaland Backs Down From
Critidsm of Drake's Aaliyah
Watch Migos Get In the
Christmas Spirit in the "Hannah
* 7 906 comments
Join the discussion..
Share E2 Login - Best ^ Comnui ni ty
Rafi a mD?;ih
The fact that Fr ench Montana's album is even on this list makes me question it's
credibility.
420 6 ^ Reply Share >
SHARE

http://www.complex.coxri/music/2013/12/the-50-best-albums-of-2013/kanye-west-yeezus 1/9/2014
Case 1:14-cv-00250-AT Document 1-1 Filed 01/14/14 Page 24 of 47
Page 3 of 3
OIT-Dtny Ninja Style
Dinner us Theater: A GIF Guide to NYC's Tablesidc Service
Rcvivnl
Jordan Bimid Unveils 'TCDT of the Horse" Pack
T>3wnIoa<I BOIUJOK Collaborator Ed Tliomas' Debut Solo Sony
'"On My Own"
J.R. Smith Fined 3Ok for Repented Shoelace Untying Efforts
10 Video Craine OulftUs We'd Acluully Wear
Treasure Fingers & ' fl i c Knocks - "DYWT"
14 Artists itifluenccd b>' Elton Jolm's Wild Stage Style
Short Terra !2 j DVD Release
Test TA^ane I News | Style | Music J Sneakers | Girls | Sports | Pop Culture {Video Games | Rides j Tech | Art + Design | City Guide | Buyers Guide | Lists (Complex TV
DFP Si t e j ^ ^ g s i contact Us | Careers j Feeds J Site Map
Silo:
Tien
Zone:
Keywords:
Exclude:
Campaign ID:
Reset Form Show Form
<S> Complex Media {Privacy Policy | Terms of Use
ballerstatus Wu Affiliate Shyheim Arrested For Fatal HH-And-Run SHARE

http://www.complex.comymusic/2013/12/the-50-best-albums-of-2013/kanye-west-yeezus 1/9/2014
Case 1:14-cv-00250-AT Document 1-1 Filed 01/14/14 Page 25 of 47
Top 10 | 10 Best Albums of'13: Nick Catucci's Picks | Photo 10 of 10 | EW.com Page 1 of 4
TV Movies Music Books Stvle mttoFamikfccorrfiaoe'
Movie Guide (httD:Htww.ew.com/ewlDackage)0..20483133.00.htinl) | TV Retans (httpjltvrecaDS.ew.coml) |
Stage (httP ://www.ew.coin/ew< Dackage< 0..20364394.00.html) | Golden Globes (httn:Hwww.ew.com/ewlnackage)0..20327336.00.htnil) j
Best of 2013 thttD:/lwww.ew.coinlew)nackagel0..20326356.00.htiiil) ! Bloes (httD:llwww.ew.conilewlblogs)
HSubscribe
WSUBSCRl gf e TO EW
lig
' H
ESSENCE Festival
July 4th weekend | New Orleans, LA
EssenceFestival.com PRINCE
Music Hewhnusic) EWs 2013 Ton 10 Lists (httD:l)www.ew.com(ew)package/0..20760444.00.htntl)
10 Best Albums of '13: Nick Catucci's P icks
Hard-twerker, last great gangsta rapper, renewed rock band ~ and EW critic's No. 1
By Hick Catuccf (httDHsearch.ew.com/results.htmlfNttqa22NlckCatuccWB22&tvpegew%3AHlck*Catucc^
5Fsort%7C0) on Die 06, 2013 ^ ec at u c d (httprlltwlttereninineiluccl)
ADVERTISEMENT
10 Of 10
i liil'i lui " i ii i i I i
y. I l l
'i i|i|
.jsiiiiiaH
W
J ,
1
: " : .
SlL.i
: /T'
1
.>
5
'r>
ill
i
i
1
?
!'ii'
i i i i i
i
1
k
.iWiSTrmj-iisiw
Uto {T] | ; 8* i Commentt fsz) Tweet
Also Check Out
L Yeezus, Kanye West
He can't be serious. Thafs what aB the late-night hosts and lists of "craziest Kanye quote? told us about Kanye
West in 2013. And sure, he's the one who said that thing about being a god, and that other thing about hunying
up with his damn massage. But like any human (even one who raps, "No sports bra/Lefs keep it bouncing"),
Kanye's got every right to be serloui Asserting that freedom on Yieezus, he exposes the rage of a wildly
ambitious artist confounded by the wfly shape of racism today. He smashes the atoms of his fears, ego, and sax
drive together for tracks tike "Black Skinhead,' featuring fhymes about "coon s" and a beat deckledty free of
Under Armour. (It ended up soundtracking apopular TV spot for smartphonea) Mostly, his sound obsession
runs riot, from the btam-speaker fiis of "On Sighf to the abundanceof dancehafi singers and samples to
"Blood on the Leaves/
1
with its unflindiing appropriationof Nina Simonefe "Strange Fruit" The overriding
message: Listen dosely. Kanye will never vaBdate anyone's celebrity worship. On Yeezus, though, he throws
down serious thunderbolt.
Best Track: "Blood on tie Leaves" (htto:/AM w.mtv.cornAffdeosAntsc/948751/bloockin-1he-leaves live.ihtmn
pofnTwfo P)
Zac Efron Bounces Back at First Official
flnnearanee Since l aw I ni urv
(httn://www.peoDle.com/Deonle/article/0..2073 3734. 00.
Watch Ni na Dobrev & I an Somerhal der l oke
Onstage About Thei r Breakup
(httD: www.oeonle.com/Deoalelstvlewatch/na kage/ arl
Mor e from P eoDle.com
(htta/ Jwww. peori e. coni / Deonl e)
You
Might
Uke
http://www.ew.com/ew/gallery/020760444_20760449
s
00.html 1/9/2014
Case 1:14-cv-00250-AT Document 1-1 Filed 01/14/14 Page 26 of 47
Top 10 | 10 Best Albums of '13: Nick Catucci's Picks | Photo 10 of 10 | EW.com Page 2 of 4
agsMte
a Ion;
TV Movies Music Books Stvle
Qf l ^ f f e f r / f wwv v Cb t t g d h i / ! ^ <h;
a
ishh
i:fiwww.iustiarei
m
i M
-coniDlexf?ref=nartnerew)
Leonardo DiCaprio & Margot Robbie: 'Wolf
of Wall Street' UK P remiere
(httP :>/www.iustiared.coni/2Q14/0U09lleonan o
-dicaDrio-margot-robbie-wolf-of-wall-
street-uk-nremierel?ref=Dartnerew)
More from Just iared
(httn: www.iustiared.com)
10 Best Movies of
13: Chris
Nashawaty P icks...
Recommended
by
rrrrrrnvi mi i' nriiiiiuiiifriiii imnrii ti n'li
1
^ n i r'lii
| Ads by Google
I 1 Free P sycNc Readng
| Our Online Psychics Wll Astound. Get Your Free Online Reading Todayl
| vAsw.califomiapsychicsxorrVReadlngs
| Download a Free Audiobook
| Try Audible vu'th a free audiobook No Shipping, No Veiling. Try Nowl
f www.audible.com
Nava Rivera Debuts Lighter Locks At The
P eople's Choice Awards
(httP :Owww.huffingtonDost.coml2014fOH09lr ava
-rivera-blond-hair n 4569273Jitml)
Kellv Osbourne Hangs Out With Justin
Bieber After Ending Her Engagement
(httn:IJwww.huffingtonnost.comJ2014>Qll09/tellv
-osbourne-iustin-bieher-
graffiti n 456815Lhtml)
More from Huffington P ost
(httP :llwww.huffingtonDost.com)entertainmenfl
Get Album Cover Art
Tunellp Plugs into iTunes to Add Missing Album Art to Your MP3sl
www.tuneupmedia.com
< 0 52 comments
(httptfWWWJIWjC^
nHHVM the discussion...
W
Shord Ei Login IT unity
9 Humorous Family
Pei | | t emht f wi nd. i nMnth-scjo
P
! ^5aL
L o v e d 4 l a t
y
o u , l a d
Kacey and Miley where you did, but, what, no Daft Punkl
sodf t y'
0
' one t hat EW didn't even review bu most incredible was Patty Griffin's
Americi in Kid. Maybe one day before I'm in the ground I'll 'get' Kanye, but so far
it's just loise.
A v Reply Share:
| | ^ Color Me Impressed^ InxiKt s mcnlh ago
afe. Wow thi s list is a joke. Earl Sweatshirt? Ok. Drake?. Fine. Local Natives
is a poor attempt to insert "indie cred." Miley Cyrus at number 3? Wtf?l
That album was awfull The only ones on this list I agree with are
Vampire Weekend and Kanye.
Where's Tegan & Sara? Daft Punk? Deerhunter? Sad, sad list...
4 ~ v Reply . Share
Brenda Barrett** Color Mo month ago
tsmbk. ITA. Not sure what Kool-Aid EW and other music critics have
been drinking, but this latest steaming Kanye effort is nothing but
noise. It's baffling the credence and attention that is given to this
talentless, toneless hack.
(httpVAvww.parentsociety.com/parenfng/fun ^ ^ ^
and
The Beta Max* i month VKJO gai
j Liked Yeezus but no EMINEM? wow.
g ^ . Repl y . Share >
family
pet | Kyle Sharp* -> ivwur- avo
Marshall Mathers LP2 and Ariana Grande's Yours Truly top my list.
4 /s i v . Repl y Share >
shi
p U
lasperComKirgsi>' Kyis Sharp' s aoo
I fours Truly > Bangerz
I ; ^ ^ . Reply Share ?
; Kyl e Sharp-* Jasperi>
r
r-KirK^ o -Twnih afx-
PREACHI Julia Roberts Walks
the Red Carpet With
Her Best Friend
^ ^ Reply Share *
http://www.ew.com/ew/gallery/020760444_20760449,00.html
1/9/2014
Case 1:14-cv-00250-AT Document 1-1 Filed 01/14/14 Page 27 of 47
Top 10 | 10 Best Albums of' 13: Nick Catucci's Picks | Photo 10 of 10 | EW.com
Page 3 of 4
Sponsored by
POPSUGAR Celebrity
I V Movies Music Books Stvle
( ht t p: f l www. ewj mn/ t ^^
More from Our P artners
Family CaoeTown Subscribe
Rov and Claudia
Asnrer Help Their
(httD:www.thedailvbedst.com)articlesJ2014l01l09)fiigter Kids Cet an
-spoils-of-babvlon- Education
ifc-s-cheekv-
miniseries-starring-
will-ferrell-kristen-
wiig-and-more)
A Camnv. Star-
Studded Romp
Nava Rivera Debuts
lighter Locks At The
People's Choice
[wards
(httP:www.people.coin Deoplelarticle)0..20773781.00itfcelfl>ww.huffingtnnnn!;t.com)201'
xid-rss- -rivera-hlond-
topheadlines) hair n 4569273.html)
(httD:)lwww.huftingtonoost.coml2014/01/09lnava
(http:llwww.th^(iailYb^a?t.QQnilart'Ql??)2014)pifg9)t)y):o|e Kidman Poses Tooless for Her Latest t ^M^ ^ ^ nSt i f r agemen' t ^
U5t
'
n B
'
el
'
er
?"pgr-??xv Jimmy Chpp Ad? (htto:)/www.huffingtonpost.com)2014l01l09lkellv
(http://stYlenews.peoplestYlewatch.coni/2014/01 Mjyffilferne-iustin-bieber-
:kidin?n-?eXY-iimmY-thpp-phpto?l?xid.r^- graffitin4568151.html)
tonheadlines)
Q
-sooils-of-babvlon-ifc-s
(htioHfcalw.ffliiBisBnmm/Julla
Rc^SmgrMMerrel k
- kristen-wiig-and-more)
August
(http:l/www.peonle.comloeoplelstvlewatchlpack^gelarticle/0..20768378 20773793.00.html?
32gByfl|4]|ust Wanna Have Fun xid=rss-tonheadlines)
Britney Soears Brings Her Boyfriend To The
People's Choice Awards
I
ailvbeast.com/articlesl2014/01l)9)the
irls-is-|Ust-Ropd-oan-we- Jessica Chastain Poses As Brave's Merida for
Disnev
(httP :Hwww.peoole.comlpeople)article)0..20773832.00.html7
PS Are UPPn U; I xid=rss-topheadlines)
io
l
ij^
:
VvTh
W
^
et
'f
ilVbeast
-
c

n
'
farti
'
:
'
es
'
2014
'
01
''
)8
''
hc
ffifeplvmnics-Are-upon-us)
(httO:/lwww.huffingtonppst.com/2Q14l01l09lbritnev
-snears-david-lucado n 4S67640.htmn
" lustin Timberlake Wins Three Peonle's Choice
Awards. Heads To Taco Bell
oPlSl Kelly Osboume Paints Graffiti with lustin
Bieber After Announcing Split from Flancl
Did Kim P hotosho'p Her Butt Selfie? (httP:Hwww.people.comloeoplelarticle)0..20773795.00.html?
(httP:www.thediilvbeast.com/article5/2014/01)|)8lj|ja-r5S.tODhead|ines)
-kim-kardashianJnhotoshop-her-butt-selfie-
ves-she-probablvl-did)
(httP:Hwww.huffingtonnost.coml2014l01)09)iustin
-timberlake-taco-bell n 4567652.htnil)
Jensen's P icks
* Madonna Reportedly Has A New. Younger
Boyfriend
(http:llwww.huffingtonnost.com/2014l01l09linadnni ia
BAEEiLSYSS (httP:/lwww.people.com/neoplelstvlewatchlpackjgela^iclelO
'Gravity'(httP :(/www.thedailvbeast.com/articlesl|201<(HP^ttBflaaiiline5)
-nominations-gravity-beats-out-hritish-
favorite-12-vears-a-slave)
* Golden Globes 2014: Sandra Bullock. Emma
Stone & Zog Saldana Named as Presenters
* lessica Alba Is White Hot At The People's
Choice Awards
* Khlo6 Kardashian and Lamar Odom's LA. Home
Goes on the Market
(http://www.huffingtonpost.com)2014l01(09liessica
. _ -alba-oeoples-choice-awards n 4567252.htnin
(httD:)lwww.DeoD!e.comfpeoDle)art<cle(0..20773808.OO.html?
WhyWeBinee-WatchTV
(httP:)lwww.thedailvbeast.com)articles)2014/01ll)8/ijjyrss.tonheall|ines)
-we-binge-watch-television)
More from HuffingtonP ost.com
fhttp://www.huffinQtonDost.com/taQ/%
40entt
More from P eoDle.com
More from TheDailvBeast.com
(http://www.people.com)
f http://www.the dallvbeast.com)
(http://www.ew.com/ew/gallery/0.,20760444 20760447.0Chtmn
Advertisement
R f ) T n I f I T I F SHOP OVER 1, 500 MUST-HAVE ITEMS! nSFISTl
* v S w WHSUHHEOIIHE 14
Vanessa Wi1IIams
,
Surprising DNA
Test
Sponsored by
Ancastry.com
Get Instant Access to this Week's Issue!
IN THIS WEEK'S ISSUE
This Week's Cover: David Fincher shoots EW's cover for his Bone g/Wthriller
with Ben Affleck (httD:/)poDwatch.ew.coml2014/01/08lcover-david-fincher-
gone-girll)
http://www.ew.coxn/ew/gallery/020760444_20760449,00.html
1/9/2014
Case 1:14-cv-00250-AT Document 1-1 Filed 01/14/14 Page 28 of 47
Top 10 | 10 Best Albums of' 13: Nick Catucci's Picks | Photo 10 of 10 | EW.com Page 4 of 4
| o c k s t 0 | o n g shots, pur
vanessaredicts who wi(i get gooffriews fro
car ru
Style Family CaoeTown Subscribe i
fl 6
00 KS
idemv
explainfireed Is Awesome. Wo. Wait...Awful! In The Wolf of Wall Street inrdan
how Belfort's addiction to money makes him do very bad things. Why is the movie
so eager to forgive him? (httD:l/www.ew.comlew/article<0..20773197.00.htmO
dna
powers
CHOOSE AN OPTION BELOW FOR INSTANT ACCESS
her
^"SUBSCRIBE TO EW GET THE DIGITAL EDITION
t^nP SiffSUBSCRIP TIOWOTJHIV^^
tre
Hsubscrintion-
asset5.ew.com/DroJ/asset5lthemesfniaga2inesidefault) template
-resources/htmWEW/allaccessflcarnmore.htffll).
Digital Edition inducfed.
Learn more. (httai/ZsubscriDtion-
a5sets.ew.eon1/prod/a5setsltherne5Imaga1InesidefaultitemDlate
-resources/html/EW/aHaccess/Iearnmore.html)
fhtto^/subscriptiofv
assets.ew.com/prod/asetsAhemes/maoazines/defauiytemDlate-
resourcestitml/EW/allaccess/learnmorehtmn
Privacy Policy
(httD:)/cgi.timeinc.netlcgi-
binlmail/dnD/Drivacvcentralized.cgi/ew?to-entertainment-
weeklvllinkll002014.html)
Subscribe
(httos:>lsubscrintion.ew.comfs:orefrontl
Contact Us
(htto:www.ew.com/ewlcontact usl)
In partnership with
Staff
Copyright 2013 Entertainment
Weekly Inc. All rights reserved.
dno source=E)
(httD:llwww.ew.com(ewlaboutusl)
Your California Privacy Give a Gift
(httDS:Ksubscriotion.ew.comlstorefrontl
(httDS:)lsubscrintion.timeinc.com/storeftortWaaiilaM'eneric nrivacv new.hti
weeklv/linkll001325.html)
Jobs at Time Inc.
(httP t/lwww.timeinc.comlcareers/)
Rights
Advertise
dnD-source=B#california)
(httn-.llwww.ew.comlewlstaticladvertisinglmission.htmll
Ad Choices Site Man
(httP i/lwww.ew.com/ewlstatic/siteman)
assets.timeinc.comlprodlassetslthemeslmagazinesldefaultlteniDlate
(httD.-l/subscriDtion-
-resourceslhtmHlegallti-corp
-behavioral.html)
Terms of Service
(http:>lcgi.timeinc.netlcgi-
binlmailldnplterms of service.ceilew)
http://www.ew.com/ew/gallery/020760444_20760449,00.html 1/9/2014
Case 1:14-cv-00250-AT Document 1-1 Filed 01/14/14 Page 29 of 47
joogle Play is giving away 'Yeezus' and top singles from 2013 | The Verge Page 1 of 1
4
D*
25
TRENDING NOW
1 * w f WJ '
T-Mobile will pay you upto $3o toleave your existing carrier NEW ARTICLES
CULTURE ENTERTAINMENT GOOD DIAL
Google Hay isgiving away 'Tgezus'
and top angles frcm 2a3
By Jacob Kastrenakes (http://www.theverge.c0in/users/Jac0b%20Kastrenakes) o n December 27, 20131 0 : 4 3 a m E m a i l (mailto:j acob.kastrenakesisitheverge.com) @j ake_k
(https:/ / tMtter.com/ mtent/ user?screen_name=j ake_k)
DON'T MISS SU MS FO LLO W TfE V IRG E
" I V :
It:
'iij ;>
I
m
rmii
I'liiii
r'ir f Tl ' i
ilniRflBi!!!
HEADLINES
fib? ,
ACLU joins Inane Clown
P osse in dwsuit against
the FBI
1
'H
1
1
m
Watch TMobile CEO John
Legere's CES 2014 press
conference in just QBT S
minutes Google's making it easy to catch up on some of the best music of the year. As part of what
it's calling Play Picks 2013
(https://play.google.com/store/music/collection/series_overview_theme_201041b_dis_play_picks)
it's offering Kanye West's (http://www.theverge.eom/a/the-verge-50/kanye-west) Yeezus
and Chvrches' The Bones of What You Believe free for a limited time it's also giving
them the superlatives album and breakout-artist of the year, respectively. Alongside the
two albums, Google's also offering 20 singles for free, including Arcade Fire's "Reflektor,"
Drake's "Started From The Bottom," and Disclosure's "When A Fire Starts To Burn". While
they're all free, there is one small catch: you'll have to give Google your credit card
number, even though you aren't paying.
Nokia briigs foldersto
Windows Bione with its
Lumia Black rollout
p* m
Bi
^ You cannow letany
I I Google+ user send you
S an email
Watch allof The Verge's
CES video here p
With Play Music getting a bigger emphasis than ever
(http://www.theverge.com/2013/5/15/4333464/google-takes-o n-spotify-with-google-play-
music-all-access) this year, it's no surprise to see Google looking to attract new customers
with some of the top music around. And once you've got your credit card in the store,
Google is happy to point to plenty of other deals offered as part of Play Picks for you to buy
next. Lorde's Pure Heroine, Janelle Monde's (http://www.theverge.com/a/the-verge-
50/janelle-monae) The Electric Lady, Danny Brown's Old, and Katy Perry's Prism are
LATEST MEDIA
P layback: TMobile's CIS
2014 press conference h
just o\erfive minutes
ittp ://www.theverge.com/2013/12/27/5247628/google-play-offering-kanye-west-chrvches-new-albums-free 119/ 201 <
Case 1:14-cv-00250-AT Document 1-1 Filed 01/14/14 Page 30 of 47
joogle Play is giving away 'Yeezus' and top singles from 2013 | The Verge
Spotify, now may be your be s t chance to catch up on the year's biggest hits.
Updat e: Googl e tells us that different promotions are being offered in different regions.
Cust omers should be able t o s e e what promotion is available to them at the Music on
Googl e Play homepage (https://play. google. com/store/music).
Page 2 of 1'
Gi gabyt e Ao r us X7 ha nds -
o n
a b o u t 1 h o u r a g o 1 c o m m e n t s
Fi rst! CE> 2 a 4 vr ap- up a n d
t h e Oc ul us Ri f t
Crys t al Cove
VIA STEREOGUM
SOURCE
GOOGLE P U Y
( HTTPS: / / PLAY. GOOGLE. COM/ STORE/ MUSI C/ COLI ECTI ON/ SERI ES_ OVERVI EW_ THEME_ 2 0 1 0 4 1 B_ DI S_ PLAY_ PI CKS)
RELATED ITEMS MUSIC FREE KANVEWEST DEAL GOOGLE PUY YEEZUS CHVRCHES PLAY nCKS
a b o u t 2 h o u r s a g o
Re e bok Che c kl i ght
c o ns c i o us ne s s
s e ns o r h a n d s o n
a b o u t 2 h o u r s a g o
Nuanc e ' s f i t ur e o f
t o u c hi ng and t al ki ng
t o gadge t s
I
a b o u t 4 h o u r s a g o
df
r Tn
Q P
I
DI SCUSSI ONS
GDOGLEPLE*WTTP://WWW.THEVERGE.COM/FORUMS/GOOGLEPLEX)
Seems l i ke Gbogle fc bet t hg bg o n
l ocal i si ng Androi d.
22 minutes ago by Karan Deshmukh
(http^/www.theverge.conyusers/Karan%20Deshnukh)
3 comments
META (HTTP://WWW.THEVERGE.COM/FORUMS/HETA)
Ford Sync t ddngove r tKs si t e f or me
about 2 hours ago by MosqultoControl
(http://www.theverge.conVusers/MosquitoControl)
3 comments
OFF-TOPIC I CHIT-CHAT lHTrP://WVW.THEVERGE.COM/FORUMS/OFF-
T0PIC)
The Indi an \ 6rge do ne
about 3 hours ago by vSpolntO
(httpJ/www.theverge.corrfusers/vSpointO) 6 comments
APPLE CORE (HTTP://WWW.THEVERGE.COM/FORUMS/APPLE-CORE)
Anti -Appl e Propaganda B ai Issue?
about 3 hours ago by Wetware.
(httpJ/www.theverge.com'users/Wetware.) 18 comments
MICRQSOFTTRIBE|HTTP://WWW.THEVERGE.COM/FORUMS/MICROSOFT-
TRIBE)
The be s t 2in-i wi ndo ws 8 devi ce f or t he price.
about 3 hours ago by harshpwd
(http^/www.theverge.comfusers/harshpwd) 1 comment
ittp://www.theverge.com/2013/12/27/5247628/google-play-^^ 1/9/201'
Case 1:14-cv-00250-AT Document 1-1 Filed 01/14/14 Page 31 of 47
EXH IBIT C
Case 1:14-cv-00250-AT Document 1-1 Filed 01/14/14 Page 32 of 47
Int. Q.: 9
Prior U.S. Qs.: 21, 23, 26, 36, and 38
Reg. No. 3,648,799
United States Patent and Trademark Office Registered June 30,2009
TRADEMARK
PRINCIPAL REGISTER
SSOTl f Si P
MASCOTTE H OLDINGS, INC. (CALIFORNIA
CORPORATION)
410 PARK AVE., 10TH FLOOR
C/0 PRYOR CASH MAN LLP
NEW YORK, NY 10022
FIRST USE 2-0-2004; IN COMMERCE 2-0-2004.
TH E MARK CONSISTS OF STANDARD CH AR-
ACTERS WITH OUT CLAM TO ANY PARTICULAR
FONT, STYLE, SIZE, OR COLOR.
FOR: MUSICAL SOUND RECORDINGS; AUDIO-
VISUAL RECORDINGS, NAMELY, COMPACT
DISCS, TAPE CASSETTES, AUDIO CASSETTES,
AUDIO TAPES, AUDIO DISCS, RECORDS, CD-
ROMS, VIDEO TAPES, VIDEO CASSETTES, VIDEO
DISCS, DVDS, DATS, MP3S, AND LASER DISCS,
ALL FEATURING MUSIC; DOWNLOADABLE MU-
SICAL SOUND RECORDINGS; DOWNLOADABLE
VIDEO RECORDINGS FEATURING MUSIC; SUN-
GLASSES, IN CLASS 9 (U.S. CLS. 21,23, 26, 36 AND
TH E NAME "KANYE WEST' IDENTIFIES A LIV-
ING INDIVIDUAL WH OSE CONSENT IS OF RE-
CORD.
SN 78-499,390, FILED 10-13-2004.
JOH N WILKE, EXAMINING ATTORNEY
38).
Case 1:14-cv-00250-AT Document 1-1 Filed 01/14/14 Page 33 of 47
Int. CI.: 16
Prior U.S. Qs.: 2, 5,22,23,29, 37, 38, and 50
Reg. No. 3,648,800
United States Patent and Trademark Office Registered June 30,2009
TRADEMARK
PRINCIPAL REGISTER
KANlflSlST
MASCOTTE H OLDINGS, INC. (CALIFORNIA
CORPORATION)
C/O KELLOGG AND ANDELSON ACCOUNTANCY
CORPORATION, 14724 VENTURA BOULE-
VARD2ND FLOOR2ND FLOOR
SH ERMAN OAKS, CA 91403
FOR; POSTERS; PH OTOGRAPH IC PRINTS; PH O-
TOGRAPH S , I N CLASS 16 (U.S. CLS. 2,5,22,23,29,37,
38 AND 50).
FIRST USE 2-0-2004; IN COMMERCE 2-0-2004.
TH E MARK CONSISTS OF STANDARD CH AR-
ACTERS WITH OUT CLAIM TO ANY PARTICULAR
FONT, STYLE, SIZE, OR COLOR.
TH E NAME "KANYE WEST" IDENTIFIES A LIV-
ING INDIVIDUAL WH OSE CONSENT IS OF RE-
CORD.
SN 78-499,402, FILED 10-13-2004.
JOH N WILKE, EXAMINING ATTORNEY
Case 1:14-cv-00250-AT Document 1-1 Filed 01/14/14 Page 34 of 47
Lit. CL: 25
Prior U.S. C3s.: 22 and 39
United States Patent and Trademark Office
Reg. No. 3,648,801
Registered June 30, 2009
TRADEMARK
PRINCIPAL REGISTER
KANYEWEST
MASCOTTE H OLDINGS, INC. (CALIFORNIA
CORPORATION)
C/O KELLOGG AND ANDELSON ACCOUNTANCY
CORPORATION, 14724 VENTURA BOULE-
VARD2ND FLOOR2ND FLOOR
SH ERMAN OAKS, CA 91403
TH E MARK CONSISTS OF STANDARD CH AR-
ACTERS WITH OUT CLAIM TO ANY PARTICULAR
FONT, STYLE, SIZE, OR COLOR.
TH E NAME "KANYE WEST" IDENTIFIES A LIV-
ING INDIVIDUAL WH OSE CONSENT IS OF RE-
CORD.
FOR; CLOTH ING, NAMELY, T-SH IRTS, TANK
TOPS, SWEAT SH ORTS, IN CLASS 25 (U.S. CLS. 22
AND 39).
FIRST USE 2-0-2004; IN COMMERCE 2-0-2004.
SN 78-499,409, FILED 10-13-2004.
JOH N WILKE, EXAMINING ATTORNEY
Case 1:14-cv-00250-AT Document 1-1 Filed 01/14/14 Page 35 of 47
Int CI.: 26
Prior U.S. Os.: 37, 39, 40,42, and 50
Reg. No. 3,648,802
United States Patent and Trademark Office Registered June 30,2009
TRADEMARK
PRINCIPAL REGISTER
Ml r a Wi W
MASCOTTE H OLDINGS, INC. (CALIFORNIA
CORPORATION)
C/O KELLOGG AND ANDELSON ACCT. CORP.
14724 VENTURA BOULEVARD, 2ND FLOOR
SH ERMAN OAJKS, CA 91403
TH E MARK CONSISTS OF STANDARD CH AR-
ACTERS 'WITH OUT CLAIM TO ANY PARTICULAR
FONT, STYLE, SIZE, OR COLOR.
TH E NAME "KANYE WEST" IDENTIFIES A LIV-
ING INDIVIDUAL WH OSE CONSENT IS OF RE-
CORD.
FOR; ORNAIvIENTAL NOVELTY BUTTONS, IN
CLASS 26 (U.S. CLS. 37, 39,40,42 AND 50). SN 78-499,411, FILED 10-13-2004.
JOH N WILKE, EXAMINING ATTORNEY
FIRST USE 4-16-2008; IN COMMERCE 4-16-2008.
Case 1:14-cv-00250-AT Document 1-1 Filed 01/14/14 Page 36 of 47
Int. Q.: 35
Prior U.S. Cls.: 100,101, and 102
United States Patent and Trademark Office
Reg. No. 3,648,803
Registered June 30, 2009
SERVICE MARK
PRINCIPAL REGISTER
TCSv a f - j ui :
MASCOTTE H OLDINGS, INC. (CALIFORNIA
CORPORATION)
C/O KELLOGG AND ANDELSON ACCT. CORP.
14724 VENTURA BOULEVARD, 2ND FLOOR
SH ERMAN OAKS, CA 91403
FOR; ON-LINE ORDERING SERVICES AND ON-
LINE RETAIL STORE SERVICES, ELECTRONIC
RETAILING SERVICES VIA COMPUTERS, AND
RETAIL STORE SERVICES AVAILABLE TH ROUGH
COMPUTER COMMUNICATIONS, ALL OF TH E
AFORESAID FEATURING RECORDED PRODUCT,
MUSIC RELATED ITEMS, CLOTH ING AND AC-
CESSORIES TH EREFOR, PRINTED PROMOTION-
AL MATTER SUCH AS POSTERS, BOOKS AND
PUBLICATIONS, NOVELTY ITEMS AND ORNA-
MENTS, IN CLASS 35 (U.S. CLS. 100,101 AND 102).
FIRST USE 2-0-2004; IN COMMERCE 2-0-2004.
TH E MARK CONSISTS OF STANDARD CH AR-
ACTERS WITH OUT CLAIM TO ANY PARTICULAR
FONT, STYLE, SIZE, OR COLOR.
TH E NAME "KANYE WEST" IDENTIFIES A LIV-
ING INDIVIDUAL WH OSE CONSENT IS OF RE-
CORD.
SN 78-499,413, FILED 10-13-2004.
JOH N WUJKE, EXAMINING ATTORNEY
Case 1:14-cv-00250-AT Document 1-1 Filed 01/14/14 Page 37 of 47
Int. CI.: 41
Prior U.S. Os.: 100,101, and 107
Reg. No. 3,648,804
United States Patent and Trademark Office Registered June 30,2009
SERVICE MARK
PRINCIPAL REGISTER
i Pf f f EWBi f '
MASCOTTE H OLDINGS, INC. (CALIFORNIA
CORPORATION)
C/O KELLOGG & ANDELSON ACCOUNTANCY
CORP.
14724 VENTURA BOULEVARD, 2ND FLOOR
SH ERMAN OAJCS, CA 91403
CAL VIDEOS, PH OTOGRAPH S, AND OTH ER MUL-
TIMEDIA MATERIALS; ENTERTAINMENT
SERVICES, NAMELY, PROVIDING PRERECOR-
DED MUSIC, ALL ONLINE VIA A GLOBAL COM-
PUTER NETWORK; ENTERTAINMENT IN TH E
NATURE OF TRAVELING TOURS FEATURING
MUSIC, IN CLASS 41 (U.S. CLS. 100, 101 AND 107).
FOR: MUSIC COMPOSITION AND TRANSCRIP-
TtON FOR OTH ERS; ENTERTAINMENT IN TH E
NATURE OF A LIVE MUSICAL PERFORMER,
MUSICAL BAND OR MUSICAL GROUP; ENTER-
TAINMENT I N TH E NATURE OF LIVE PERFOR-
MANCES BY A MUSICAL ARTIST, MUSICAL
GROUP OR MUSICAL BAND; ENTERTAINMENT
IN TH E NATURE OF VISUAL AND AUDIO PER-
FORMANCES BY A MUSICAL ARTIST, MUSICAL
GROUP AND MUSICAL BAND; ENTERTAIN-
MENT, NAMELY, LIVE MUSIC CONCERTS; EN-
TERTAI NMENT, NAMELY, PERSONAL
APPEARANCES BY A MUSICIAN, MUSICAL
GROUP OR MUSICAL BAND; ENTERTAINMENT
SERVICES, NAMELY, PROVIDING A WEB SITE
FEATURING MUSICAL PERFORMANCES, MUSI-
FIRST USE 8-0-2004; IN COMMERCE 8-0-2004.
TH E MARK CONSISTS OF STANDARD CH AR-
ACTERS WITH OUT CLAIM TO ANY PARTICULAR
FONT, STYLE, SIZE, OR COLOR.
TH E NAME "KANYE WEST' IDENTIFIES A LIV-
ING INDIVIDUAL WH OSE CONSENT IS OF RE-
CORD.
SN 78-499,414, FILED 10-13-2004.
JOH N WILKE, EXAMINING ATTORNEY
Case 1:14-cv-00250-AT Document 1-1 Filed 01/14/14 Page 38 of 47
EXH IBIT D
Case 1:14-cv-00250-AT Document 1-1 Filed 01/14/14 Page 39 of 47
Kjarberg^^an^S.
REDACTED
From: Matthew Mellon <777menon@,gmail.com<mailto:777mellon@.grnail.com>>
Date: January 5, 2014 at 9:09:13 PM EST
To: Michael Guido <mgmdo@ccgglaw.com<mailto:mgiiido@ccgglaw.com>>
Subject: Fwd: Kanye West Legal council Michael Guido
Forwarded message
From: Coinye West <coinvewest@gmail.com<mailto:coinvewest@gmail.com>>
Date: Sat, Jan 4, 2014 at 6:54 PM
Subject: Re: Kanye "West Legal council Michael Guido
To: Matthew Mellon <777meUon@gmail.com<mailto:777rnel1nn@gTn3i1.cnrn>>
i
Case 1:14-cv-00250-AT Document 1-1 Filed 01/14/14 Page 40 of 47
I dont know. I don't want to inconvenience him. A simple few second video of him telling us he
wants coinyes would suffice, but i understand you might be concerned about that hitting the
media. As I'm well aware you guys are going to try and get my identity I'm not comfortable with
a phone call, and skype would be too slow through the proxies i use.
I'm totally willing to discuss things with you guys. In email, or on IRC which is internet relay
chat. I can give, you the step by step to get connected if you dont have access to a geek when its
time to talk. It's just that before we actually risk ruining the currency by "printing" a crapload of
it to give to kanye, I'm going to need some kind of proof its actually going to him, by getting
some sort of verification from the man himself.
Thank you
On 1/4/2014 4:39 PM, Matthew Mellon wrote:
How would like to Kanye to confirm that?
On Sat, Jan 4,2014 at 6:35 PM, Coinye West
<coinvewest@,gmail.com<mailto:coinvewest@,smail.com>> wrote:
I didn't say yes. Someone else with access to this email said yes. I'm not talking on any telephone
and neither is anyone else involved.
If you want to talk, contact me in email. We're anonymous and we're keeping it that way.
Also, I'm not giving up a single millionth of a percent until i get some kind of verification that
kanye actually knows a deal is being made. I still don't trust you, and I sure as hell don't trust
lawyers.
On 1/4/2014 4:16 PM, Matthew Mellon wrote:
I am happy to talk prior to 10:00am.. Let me know I can give you the lay of the land..
+19174599067<tel:
<
yo2B19174599067>
On Sat, Jan 4,2014 at 6:03 PM, Coinye West
<coinvewest@gmail.com<mailto:coinvewest@gmail.com wrote:
Yes.
On Sat, Jan 4, 2014 at 3:00 PM, Matthew Mellon
<777mellon@gmaiLcom<mailto:777mellon@gmail.com wrote:
I am happy to speak then.. Coinye shall I patch you in?
On Sat, Jan 4, 2014 at 3:38 AM, Michael Guido
<mmiido@,ccgglaw.com<mailto:mguido@.ccgglaw.com>> wrote:
Ok. As you know I am 10 hours ahead of NY. And boarding a plane now. I will be free at
2
Case 1:14-cv-00250-AT Document 1-1 Filed 01/14/14 Page 41 of 47
about 10 am my time tomorrow which will be about 11:30pm my time Saturday evening. Is that
something that can work?
On Jan 4,2014, at 1:15 PM, "Matthew Mellon"
<Matthew@coinapex.com<mailto:Matthew@coinapex.com>> wrote:
Hi Michael:
Coinye has requested to speak to you directly being Kanye West's legal council.
Best,
Matthew
"CONFIDENTIAL"
Information Classification: Confidential
The information contained in this e-mail, and any attachment, is confidential and is intended
solely for the use of the intended recipient. Access, copying or re-use of the e-mail or any
attachment, or any information contained therein, by any other person is not authorized. If you
are not the intended recipient please return the e-mail to the sender and delete it from your
computer. Although we attempt to sweep e-mail and attachments for viruses, we do not
guarantee that either are virus-free and accept no liability for any damage sustained as a result of
viruses.
"CONFIDENTIAL"
Information Classification: Confidential
The information contained in this e-mail, and any attachment, is confidential and is intended
solely for the use of the intended recipient. Access, copying or re-use of the e-mail or any
attachment, or any Lnformation contained therein, by any other person is not authorized. If you
are not the intended recipient please return the e-mail to the sender and delete it from your
computer. Although we attempt to sweep e-mail and attachments for viruses, we do not
guarantee that either are virus-free and accept no liability for any damage sustained as a result of
viruses.
3
Case 1:14-cv-00250-AT Document 1-1 Filed 01/14/14 Page 42 of 47
"CONFIDENTIAL"
Information Classification: Confidential
The information contained in this e-mail, and any attachment, is confidential and is intended
solely for the use of the intended recipient. Access, copying or re-use of the e-mail or any
attachment, or any information contained therein, by any other person is not authorized. If you
are not the intended recipient please return the e-mail to the sender and delete it from your
computer. Although we attempt to sweep e-mail and attachments for viruses, we do not
guarantee that either are virus-free and accept no liability for any damage sustained as a result of
viruses.
"CONFIDENTIAL"
Information Classification: Confidential
The information contained in this e-mail, and any attachment, is confidential and is intended
solely for the use of the intended recipient. Access, copying or re-use of the e-mail or any
attachment, or any information contained therein, by any other person is not authorized. If you
are not the intended recipient please return the e-mail to the sender and delete it from your
computer. Although we attempt to sweep e-mail and attachments for viruses, we do not
guarantee that either are vims-free and accept no liability for any damage sustained as a result of
viruses.
4
Case 1:14-cv-00250-AT Document 1-1 Filed 01/14/14 Page 43 of 47
EXHIBIT E
Case 1:14-cv-00250-AT Document 1-1 Filed 01/14/14 Page 44 of 47
r t .*
* "' *! +
M PRYOR CASHMAN LLP New York J Los Angeles
WW.piyorcashmkLCOm 7 Times Square, New York, NY 10036-< 5569 Tel: 212-4214100 Fax:212-326-0806
Brad D. Rose
P artner
Direct Tei;2l2-326-0?75
Direct Fsoc 212-79S-6369
bfose@ptj
,
orcashtn an.com
January 6, 2014
VIA E-MAIL fcoin vewestfcdamail. com]
Re: Infringement of KAYNE WEST Mark and Other Violations
Dear Sir or Madam:
This law firm acts as litigation counsel for Kanye West and his affiliated companies. As
' > film
director and fashion designer, to name just a few of Mn West's endeavors. Mr. West has won
twenty-one Grammy Awards, making him one of the most awarded artists of all-time. He has
been named one of the 100 most influential people by Time magazine and is routinely listed by
Forbes as one of the most successful people in the world.
Mr. West's tremendous success and notoriety has catapulted the KANYE WEST brand
into a commercial asset of incalculable value. In addition to his common law rights, Mr. West
and services as well as several pending applications. See, e.g., U.S. Reg. Nos. 3,648,799;
3,648,800; 3,648,801; 3,648,802; 3,648,803; and 3,648,804. Without doubt, the KANYE WEST
mark is famous and is entitled the broadest protection under the law.
We write to you concerning your unauthorized use of the COINYE WEST mark in
connection with a purported cryptocurrency that may be available on January 11, 2014. We have
recently learned that you are promoting the COINYE WEST cryptocurrency through the
<coinvewest.com> website, on Facebook at <facebook.com/coinvewest> and on Twitter at
<twitter.com/CoihveWest>. The COINYE WEST mark is substantially similar to the KANYE
WEST mark in sight, sound, meaning and commercial impression. Interviews with the founders
of the COINYE WEST cryptocurrency leave no doubt that your clear intent is to trade upon the
goodwill associated with die KANYE WEST mark and Mr. West's international fame and
notoriety. In particular, several news sources have quoted the developers as stating "We chose
Kanye because of his trendsetting abilities and his originality," and also that you have decided to
remain anonymous "in case Kanye gets pissed off." Such statements support a Ending that your
infrmgement is blatant and willful.
Given Mr. West's wide-ranging entrepreneurial accomplishments, consumers are likely
to mistakenly believe that Mr. West is the source of your services or is, at the very least,
affiliated with, or has sponsored or endorsed the cryptocurrency. The likelihood that consumers
will be confused is heightened by the unauthorized use of an image of Mr. West on the coin:
1200471 v2
10859. 00017
Case 1:14-cv-00250-AT Document 1-1 Filed 01/14/14 Page 45 of 47
% PRYOR CASHMAN LLP
January 6,2014
Page 2 of 3
MM
K ' . J - '/'
i-ggg
Your actions constitute, zrer alia, willful trademark infringement, unfair competition,
infnngement.
misappropriation of Mr. West's music videos embedded in the <coinyewest.com> website.
Your actions also violate Mr. West's right of publicity under state law, which subjects you to
further liability.
Mr. West takes these violations of his intellectual property very seriously and seeks to
resolve: this matter without resort to litigation including filing an. application for a temporary
restraining order. Accordingly, please immediately confirm that you and all of your affiliated
companies, employees, consultants, agents and representatives will immediately:
versions of that mark including COINYE;
2. cease and desist from any and all development, sale, distribution and
promotion of any and all products and services in connection with the mark
KAIsfYE WEST, or any names or marks confusingly similar to KANYE
WEST, including, but not limited to, the COINYE WEST and COINYE
marks;
3. cease and desist from any and all use of Mr. West's copyrighted material
including his music videos;
4. deactivate the website located at <coiiivewest.com>> unlock the domain
name to allow it to be transferred and provide us with the authorization
code to facilitate such transfer;
5. deactivate all social media accounts created and/or used in connection with
the COINYE WEST mark, including, but not limited to, the Facebook
account located at <facebook.com/coinvewest> and the Twitter account
located at <twitter. com/CoinveWest>: and
1290471 v2
10859. 00017 2
Case 1:14-cv-00250-AT Document 1-1 Filed 01/14/14 Page 46 of 47
HPRYOR CASHMAN LLP
January 6,. 2014
Page 3 of 3
6.
IT.,
product or service.
p.m. E.S.T. on January 6. 2014, your intent to comply prpinptly with our demands, failing
4 * ^.1 |Y ... ^ j i.r: i|..' ; . ' . . it "i * !' -J! - ii* J*-'- >17'
including treble damages, attorney's fees and costs.
large of your infringing actions and pursue all legal remedies against any business that accepts the
purported COINYE WEST currency. Specifically, Mr, West will pursue claims of contributory
trademark infringement and contributory unfair competition, among others, against any entity that
accepts or exchanges the COINYE WEST currency.
Should you wish to discuss any aspect of this matter, we suggest that you have your legal
representative contact the undersigned before the above-referenced deadline.
The foregoing is not intended as a comprehensive statement of our client's rights or position,
and nothing herein shall be deemed to be a waiver of any of our client's rights at law or in equity.
Very truly yours,
Brad D, Rose
cc: Michael Guido, Esq.
1290471 v2
10859. 00017 3
Case 1:14-cv-00250-AT Document 1-1 Filed 01/14/14 Page 47 of 47

Vous aimerez peut-être aussi