Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
Nagpur – Amaravati region is in the eastern most region of the state of Maharashtra.
Administratively, the region is divided into two divisions namely, Nagpur Division and
Amaravati Division. Nagpur and Amaravati divisions makeup the region of Vidarbha.
Nagpur division consists of five districts namely Bhandara, Chandrapur, Gadchiroli,
Gondia, Nagpur and Wardha. Amaravati division consists of five districts namely Akola,
Amravati, Buldhana, Washim and Yavatmal.
These two divisions together account for 31.6% of total area and hold 21.3% of total
population of Maharashtra. Vidarbha's economy is primarily agricultural. The region is
rich in forest and mineral wealth. The main cash crops of the region are cotton, oranges
pulses and soya beans. Traditional crops are sorghum (jowar), pearl millet (bajra) and
rice.
Based on the discussions with the Maharashtra State Agricultural Marketing Board
(MSAMB), and other stakeholders, out the ten districts stated above two districts -
Nagpur and Wardha- from Nagpur region and three districts - Akola, Amravati and
Yavatmal- from Amaravati region were selected for the purpose of detailed value chain
study. The table below summarizes the focus districts, selected production clusters in the
identified districts and focus crops in the each of the selected production cluster. The
production clusters were identified based on the inputs provided by MSAMB and state
agriculture department.
Apart from studying the focus production clusters, assessment of Agriculture related
infrastructure in Nagpur was carried out. Nagpur is the largest city and a major
aggregation and distribution location in the region.
Private Investment -
Collection, aggregation, No
Any other infrastructure
related to food in the Block No
Connectivity Related Issues
Nearest Large city Nagpur Kalmeshwar is 20 km from Nagpur
Connectivity by Road Good
Connectivity by rail Good
Connectivity by air Good from Nagpur
Assessment of Practices in the Mandi
Managed by Elected marketing Committee
While the availability of infrastructure has been assessed for each production cluster, the supply chain of
the identified focus crop remains same irrespective of the production cluster. The value chain for selected
focus crops is presented below:
Value Chain of Orange:
The production of orange is spread into two seasons namely Ambia bahar and Mrug bahar. Ambia Bahar
accounts for 20-30 % of the production. Arrivals for this seaons start in the month of October and end in
the month of January. Mrug Bahar accounts for the balance 70-80 % of the production and it starts in the
month of February and ends in the Month of April. The quality of fruit in Mrig Bahar is reportedly
superior and is suitable for long distance transportation.
Production Management:
Some salient features of production management are presented below:
Commission agent
Trader
Trader
Based on the point of sale, the above supply chains can be classified into three types:
1. At farm gate – Channel 1 – Accounts for 60 % of the produce
2. At APMC Mandis within Production Clusters – Channel 2 - Accounts for 35 %
3. At Distant consumption market – Channel 3 – Accounts for 5 % of the trade*
*As per the trade and market functionaries
Both in the case of Channel 1 and Channel 2, Oranges brought from garden by various means
of transport are properly heaped without causing any damages on the auction platforms
covered with paddy straw in the market yards and auctioned for price discovery.
Unit of Trade: Oranges are traded either in Numbers or by weight. Each market has its own unit
of trade. For example, in Kalamna APMC Market yard in Nagpur District, Oranges are traded by
weight while in Warud APMC Market yard in Amaravati district they are traded in Numbers.
The unit of trade in distant consumption markets is generally by boxes or crates.
Price Determination: Price fixation between the farmer and the Pre
harvest Contractor (PHC) is by Negotiation. The PHC offer a price
based on their information of price in their market, their experience and
their projection of supply. Generally, the unit of trade between the
farmer and PHC is in numbers. The PHC visits the orchards and
randomly some trees are selected and the number of fruits are counted
and then extrapolated for the entire garden. Though there is high
approximation in this method, most of the farmers prefer to sell by this
channels as there are no marketing costs, harvesting is the
responsibility of the PHC and the price risk is with the PHC. Price
discovery in the APMC market yards, is by Open Call Auction method.
Grading: In all the markets grading is done manually. The grading is done based upon the
size of the fruit. However, based on other physical properties like colour, shape, (oblong,
high collared, deformed), maturity, puffiness, blemishes, physical damage (bruised and
diseased) grading and sorting operations are carried out. Once the diseased and bruised fruits
are discarded, based on size, fruits are graded into 7 grades. Traditionally, the seven grades
have been identified on the basis of number of fruits of a particular size that will fill exactly a
standard wooden box. To understand the grades, it is important to understand the packaging
methods and packaging material. The seven grades and their characteristics are summarized
in the next section.
Packaging: After the grading the fruits are packed in either wooden boxes or in plastics
crates.
Wooden boxes made of mango wood or any other wood locally available is used. The
standard size of a wooden box is 18” x 12” x 12”. An empty wooden box weighs 2 to 2.5 kg.
The wooden box is fabricated on the spot by specially appointed box maker. The labour
charges for box making in Kalamna APMC market are Rs. 3.5 per box.
The fruits are stacked in layers in the wooden box. Depending on the size of the fruit the
layers vary from 4-6. To avoid friction between the layers of fruits and to avoid moisture loss
during transit each layer is separated from the other with paddy straw and waste papers. Once
the fruits are filled, the top of the box is closed with the same wooden sheets using iron nails.
They are then tightened using coconut fibre ropes. They are then marked
using non-edible grade water soluble permanent color with the name of the
trader so that it can be identified in the destination market. Packing cost with
wooden boxes works out to be in the range of Rs. 50-55 per box
These wooden boxes are not reusable. After they reach the destination
market, the boxes are either thrown away or used as fuel wood. As per trade,
nearly 40% of the trade at present is happening by wooden boxes. As per
trade because of the use of wooden boxes, many mango orchards have been
cut in the past few decades and at present there is virtually no mango
orchard left.
In the last few years the use of plastic crates has increased. Mostly, plastic crates of 542 mm
x 360 mm x 300 mm (outer dia) are in use. The weight of empty crate is comparable to a
wooden box at 2.1 to 2.3 kgs.
This standard crate can take 22-25 kg of fruit. Though the
return logistics cost adds to the cost of the product, the ease
of usage, easy availability and acceptance by trade in the
destination markets has increased the usage of plastic crates.
As per trade, 60 % of the volume is transported by plastic
crates. Unlike wooden boxes, in case of the plastic crates, the
fruit is not arranged in layers. The fruits are loosely packed in
the crate and the sides and top are covered with waste paper. Then the paper is tied to the crate
using nylon thread. The traders have their brand name/ trade name stenciled on the sides of the
crates for identification.
Cost of transportation using crates varies from market to market. For example for Nagpur to
Delhi, the cost of transportation including reverse logistics cost works out to be Rs. 65. While
the one way transport cost for wooden boxes is Rs. 55. The traders using plastic crates save
Rs. 45 per trip using crates in the subsequent trips to Delhi. However, because of the high
upfront costs (Rs. 180 to 200 per crate), traders continue to use wooden boxes.
Grades in Orange:
Grade Actual
name as number of Size in Grade
# Grade per trade fruits Layers of fruits mm rank
1 Extra Large 96 Dana 96 4 layers of 24 each 75-80 Third
4 layers of 30 each
2 Large - 1 141 Dana 148 and one layer of 28 70-75 First
4 layers of 35 each
3 Large -2 171 Dana 173 and one layer of 33 65-70 Second
4 Medium - 1 191 Dana 195 4 layers of 39 each 60-65 Fourth
5 Medium -2 205 Dana 210 4 layers of 45 each 55-60 Fifth
6 Small 245 Dana 288 6 layers of 48 each 50-55 Sixth
7 Waste All other Seventh
As can be observed from the table above, the number of fruits is higher than the grade name
(number) except in case of Extra Large. Higher number of fruits are packed to ensure that the
fruits are tightly packed. The trader compensates for the additional fruits by taking 100 fruits
extra for every 1000 fruits from the farmer.
Storage:
The traders in production clusters do not generally store the product. The operate in such a
way that the product reaches the destination market within 3 days of harvesting.
Transportation is carried out in ambient temperatures in open trucks. Oranges are generally
not stored for off-season sales in production clusters. If any trader wishes to store the product
for off season sale, the same is done in the distant consumption market.
A value chain, indicating the various activities in the value chain, actors performing the given
activity, cost buildup at every step has been mapped in this section. This value chain has been
mapped for the supply chain having following characteristics:
1. The marketing chain follows Channel 2, i.e, Farmer to PHC to Commission Agent to
Trader to Commission agent in Distant market to Trader/ retailer to Consumer
2. The cost of production for the farmer is only the variable cost for maintenance of one
acre orchard per year. It does not include the cost for the first five years of orange
orchard where there are no returns.
3. The Distant consumption market considered for this case is Azadpur APMC Mandi,
in New Delhi
4. The packing material is wooden box of standard dimension 18” x 12” x 12”
5. Net weight of oranges in each box is 24 kg
6. Cost of capital and opportunity cost for the all the intermediaries has not been
considered in cost build up and for calculating the spread
7. The Spread indicated is gross spread, excluding direct costs involved in handling of
product
8. The cost of retailing, which includes the cost of shop, wages, rent etc has not been
considered
9. The prices considered are average prices for the month of October in Nagpur and
Delhi Market based on the data corroborated from traders. The same has been cross
checked with the data from National Horticulture Board 2007-08 statistics
10. The grade mix for 1 mt of product has been considered based on feed back from only
one trader. The same has to be cross checked with some more traders.
11. Wastages have been accounted at the level of packaging only. The next level of
wastage is at the level of retailer, where data is not available
Actor in Value chain Activity Unit Value
Farmer Cost of production for the farmer Rs /Acre 30000
Farmer Total production Tons/ Acre 10.5
Farmer Cost of production per MT Rs per MT 2857
Farmer Pre-harvest Contractor price to farmer Rs per MT 9500
Farmer Net realization to the farmer Rs per MT 6643
PHC Harvesting Rs per MT 185
PHC Loading Rs per MT 60
PHC Transportation Cost to mandi Rs per MT 325
PHC Unloading cost Rs per MT 80
PHC Price discovered in Local mandi Rs per MT 12000
Commission Agent Commission charges @ 6 % Rs 720
PHC Miscellaneous Expenses Rs per MT 10
PHC Total Marketing Cost for PHC Rs per MT 1380
PHC Net Realization to the PHC Rs per MT 1120
APMC Mandi Marketing cess @ 1.05 % Rs per MT 126
Trader Sorting grading and packing charges Rs per MT 167
Trader Packaging material cost Rs per MT 1958
Trader Moisture loss, damaged fruit etc Kg per MT 50
Trader Value of wastage Rs 600
Trader Loading Cost Rs per MT 63
Trader Transportation to Delhi Market Rs per MT 2310
Trader Price discovered in Delhi market Rs per MT 20925
Commission Agent Commission Charges @ 8 % Rs per MT 1674
Trader Unloading cost at Delhi Rs per MT 84
Trader Miscellaneous Expenses at Delhi Rs per MT 50
Trader Total Marketing Cost for Trader Rs per MT 7032
Trader Spread for the trader Rs per MT 1893
Retailer Mandi Cess @ 1 % Rs per MT 209
Retailer Loading Charges Rs per MT 84
Retailer Transportation Cost to Point of Sale Rs per MT 210
Retailer Average Retail Sale Price Rs per MT 24463
Retailer Spread for the retailer Rs per MT 3035
The above table can be summarized as below:
Particular Farmer PHC Trader Retailer
Cost of Production/ Buying 2857 9500 12000 20925
Sale Price 9500 12000 20925 24463
Cost of Marketing incl. Commission Agent charges 0 1380 7032 503
Spread 6643 1120 1893 3035
• The price buildup from Farmer to Consumer is almost two and half times.
• There are 5 intermediaries in this case
• While the intermediaries are making decent profits, the cost benefit ratio for orange
farmer at 1:2.3 is also very good.
• The APMC mandi cess accounts for close to Rs. 335 per mt, which is close to 1.5 % of
the final price paid by the consumer
• The share of consumers rupee by various actors in the value chain emerges as below:
The other two facilities for Orange processing and are owned by NOGA – Nagpur
Orange Growers Association. Though, NOGA was originally a farmers association
involved in processing of Oranges and other fruit crops, it was eventually taken over by
the State Government through Maharashtra State Agriculture Infrastructure Development
Corporation (MAIDC). At present NOGA has two multiproduct fruit processing
facilities. One facility is at Katol and other is at Hingna Road, Nagpur. Of the two
facilities, NOGA, Hingna Road facility is being managed by the State government
through MAIDC and the Katol Facility has been given out on lease to one, Alliance Agro
Private Limited.
The Katol facility has a multi product fruit processing line, cold storage, aseptic filling
line and bottling line. Reportedly, there is a dispute between NOGA and Alliance Agro
and the matter is pending in the court of law. At present the facility is lying idle and is not
in use.
The Hingna Road Facility of NOGA has a multi product fruit processing line, and
bottling line, canning line only. In 2008-09, NOGA- Hingna Road has processed 2732 mt
of various fruits and vegetables of which 331 mt is Orange.
MahaOrange:
MahaOrange is a marketing co-operative society registered under the Maharashtra State
Co-operative Societies Rules 1961. It is a federal body of Orange cultivators in the state
of Maharashtra. It was formed in 10th Mar 2008, with head quarters at Nagpur. At present
11 block level co-operative societies are members of MahaOrange.
Orange is the only major horticultural crop produced in the region. With the availability
of oranges is spread across two seasons and for 5-6 months only, feasibility of setting up
Orange specific facilities has to be ascertained in greater detail before finalizing the
plans. Assuming that Orange specific facilities are to be constructed the following hub
and spoke locations emerge based on field survey.
Hub/ Spoke Location District
Hub Location 1 Butibori Nagpur
Hub Location 2 Amaravati Amaravati
Spoke 1 Karanja Wardha
Spoke 2 Katol Nagpur
Spoke 3 Kalmeshwar Nagpur
Spoke 4 Warud Amaravati
Spoke 5 Morshi Amaravati
Spoke 6 Ashti Wardha
Spoke 7 Chandurbazar Amaravati
Spoke 8 Narkhed Nagpur
A value chain, indicating the various activities in the value chain, actors performing the given
activity, cost buildup at every step has been mapped in this section. This value chain has been
mapped for the supply chain having following characteristics: