Section (no) : 2 Group members : Vivien Lai Mei Yen (CE093314) Veronica Kelly A/P David (CE093814) NurFatin Binti Abdul Rahaman (CE093472) Siti Nur Ilyana Ahmad Safari (CE093734) Date of report submission : 14/8/2014 Lecturer : Dr. Mohd Hafiz Bin Zawawi Table of Content 1. Introduction 1 2. Literature Review 2 3. Green Roof Concept 3 4. Green Roof Model 4-5 5. Advantages 6 6. Disadvantages 6 7. Green Roof Scenario in Malaysia 7 8. Stormwater Management 8-9 9. Design Concept of Stormwater using MSMA 9-10 10. Conclusion 11 References 12
1. Introduction Depleting natural resources has appealed to sustainable developments. Green technology or green innovation is the common term for a particular method which can improve quality of natural resources such as water and air by inducing no or minimal pollutants to the nature. Malaysia is a developing country and it is inevitable that more natural resources are sacrificed for purpose of development and commercial activities. One of the prominent depleting natural resource in densely built urban areas is green spaces. It is a norm that green spaces in urban areas are replaced with impervious surfaces like concrete and roadways and phenomenon like Urban Heat Island (UHI) and flash flood are pertinent to excessive impervious surfaces. Green Building Index (GBI) aims to evaluate the design and performance of local buildings with responses to degree of damages to environment and energy consumption. Green roof is suggested as one of the environmental friendly innovation under category of sustainable site planning and management. In fact, Urban Stormwater Management Manual for Malaysia (MSMA) was firstly introduced in 2001 as a guideline to adopt and design Best Management Practices (BMPs) in controlling stormwater in term of quantity and quality to achieve least impacts of post-development hydrologically [7]. Recently, MSMA second edition was released in 2012 whereby additional BMPs like bioretention was compiled and revised into the manual. However, green roof was not compiled under MSMA yet though it is one of the BMPs as well. As other stormwater manuals applied at overseas like SUDs (UK), LID [ Lower Impact Development] (USA), and WSUD[Water Sensitive Urban Design] (Australia) have been suggesting that green roofs can be used as a practice for stormwater quantity and quality controls, thus there is a urge to study the performances of green roof under local tropical climate. The scientific data obtained can be applied to develop design guideline of green roof system for Malaysia in future.
2. Literature Review on Green Roof Performances Numerous studies and researches conducted overseas have proven that extensive green roof gives positive effects on peak discharge reduction and thermal reduction. Green roofs reduce runoff by delaying the initial time of runoff due to absorption of water in the green roof, reducing the total runoff by retaining part of the rainfall, and spreading the residual runoff over a long time period through a relatively slow release of the excess water that is stored in the substrate layer [2]. Two extensive green roofs installed at North Carolina of America indicated that both of these roofs retained 64% of the total precipitation recorded and each green roof showed reduction in average peak flow by more than 75% [3]. Water storage capacity or stormwater retention ability has close relationship with rainfall intensity [4][5], the ability decreases during heavy storm events Green Roof contributes to building insulation and energy efficiency by trapping air layer within the plant mass so that the building surface is cooled in summer and warmed in water[5]. Vegetation of green roof act as a cooling agent by dissipating portion of city heat via evapotraspiration, thus green roof is applied as a way to combat urban heat island effect and to conserve more energy which is initially used to cool the buildings. Green roof were able to reduce solar energy hained up to 90% when compared with non- greened top buildings, indoor temperature for green roofs building was reported to have reduction of 3-4C as outdoor temperature ranges between 25 to 30C[4]. Performance of green roof in enhancing water quality is debatable since it sometimes can be a source of nutrients/pollutants to the outflow. Green roofs did remove phosphorus concentration during moderate storms but not the efficient filter for pH, BOD, and COD [5]. However, higher concentration of TN and TP were observed in the green roof outflow during the first two years of green roofs life and its media was the origin of the nutrients [3].
3. Green Roof Concept Green roofs are made of a system of manufactured layers deliberately placed over roofing structures which support growing medium and vegetation. Green roof systems can be generally divided into extensive green roof (Eco-roofs) and intensive green roof (Podium Garden & Sky Gardens) [1][6]. Extensive green roof is low-weighted and requires only minimal maintenance. On contrary, intensive green roof is much heavier and requires higher construction cost and constant maintenance. Its substrate layer over 150mm is a common. The basic components of a green roof system regardless of extensive or intensive are vegetation, growth media, drainage layer, filter layer, water proofing layer and protection layer. The type of vegetation selected for the green roof system in HTC is Zoysia Japonica (Japan Grass). Figure 1 shows the configuration of green roof components in HTC(Humid Tropics Center) Kuala Lumpur, while Figure 2 shows the retrofitted green roof system for surau located in HTC.
4. Green Roof Model
Figure 3: The layer of a green roof system from the roof to the plants Source: Spala et al, 2008.
Figure 4: The components of green roof systems installed on the conventional roofing system Source: Liu and Baskaran, 2003.
Figure 5: Cross-section of a typically used layer of extensive green roof system. Source: Getter and Rowe, 2006.
Figure 6: A roof between 5 and 20 degrees is ideal for a green roof because it allows the water to drain naturally. [Illustration of courtesy of Bauverlag GmbH, Germany.
5. Advantages Green roofs can Filter pollutants in the air. Contribute to Leadership in Energy & Environmental Design (LEED) points. Create a habitat for wildlife. Extend the lifetime of a roof. Reduce the heat island effect. Reduce heating and cooling bills. Help to insulate a building for sound. Absorb carbon dioxide and release oxygen. Become healing gardens or herb and vegetable gardens. Turn an unattractive, unused space into a park-like setting. Become a source of income, by leasing the space out for events. Reduce storm water runoff and therefore decrease the size of a water retention pond.
6. Disadvantages
Initial costs of installing a green roof can be double that of a normal roof.
Some types of green roofs do have more demanding structural standards especially in seismic regions of the world.
Some existing buildings cannot be retrofitted with certain kinds of green roof because of the weight load of the substrate and vegetation exceeds permitted static loading.
Depending on what kind of green roof it is, the maintenance costs could be higher, but some types of green roof have little or no ongoing cost.
Some kinds of green roofs also place higher demands on the waterproofing system of the structure, both because water is retained on the roof and due to the possibility of roots penetrating the waterproof membrane.
Another detractor is that the wildlife they attract may include pest insects which could easily infiltrate a residential building through open windows.
7. Green Roof in Malaysian Scenario
In Malaysia, the information on green roof technology is still lacking. Until now, it is hard to get the previous research done by Malaysian researchers regarding to this kind of technology. However, this technology has been implemented in Singapore by a group of researchers from National University of Singapore and the result shows the positive impact. The green roof is said to be able to mitigate the urban heat island effect in the tropical environment. However, to retrofit the roof with green roof technology is not an easy job. The physical structural of most existing building might prevent the establishment of green roof since the green roof requires the roof structure, which can support heavy loads. According to livingroofs.org, the load values for saturated weight of extensive green roof are from 60 kg/m 2 to 150 kg/m 2 while for intensive green roof is 200 kg/m 2 to 500 kg/m 2 .
Therefore, most of the existing building only can support extensive green roof system. This saturated weight was obtained from standards outlined in German National Standard DIN 1055 Design Loading for Buildings. The initial cost of green roof also becomes one of the major considerations when thinking of constructing a green roof. According to previous researches done by well known researchers, the initial cost of green roof tends to be higher than the conventional roof system. The cost of green roof is 7% higher than that of conventional roof system. The net present value of extensive green roof ranges from 10% to 14% more expensive than the conventional type (Carter & Keeler, 2007 cited Lee, 2004) (see Carter & Keeler, 2007). However, even though the cost of installation of green roof is doubled from the conventional roof, it is worthy in terms of roof life span and maintenance after several years of installation. Currently in Malaysia, the contractors that specialized in green roof construction are very limited. Therefore the technical information on how to build the green roof is quite hard to get. In order to encourage the construction of green roof in Malaysia, extensive research must be carried out. Knowledge and awareness would help to educate the public so that the implementation of green roof design can be widespread.
8. Stormwater Management Managing the quantity and quality of stormwater is termed Stormwater Management(SWM). The term Best Management Practice (BMP) is often used to refer to both structural or engineered control devices and systems (e.g. retention ponds) to treat polluted stormwater, as well as operational or procedural practices (Ismail, 2012). There are many forms of stormwater management and BMPs, including:
I. Manage stormwater to control flooding and erosion Ii. Manage and control hazardous materials to prevent release of pollutants into the environment (source control) Iii. Plan and construct stormwater systems so contaminants are removed before they pollute surface waters or groundwater resources Iv. Acquire and protect natural waterways where they still exist or can be rehabilitated. V. Build "soft" structures such as ponds, swales or wetlands to work with existingor "hard" drainage structures, such as pipes and concrete channelsvi. Revise current stormwater regulations to address comprehensive stormwater needs Vii. Enhance and enforce existing ordinances to make sure property owners consider the effects of stormwater before, during and after development of their land Viii. Educate a community about how its actions affect water quality, and about what it can do to improve water quality Ix. Proper planning to create solutions before problems become too great.
Wet weather green infrastructure (Green Roof) encompasses approaches and technologies to infiltrate, evapotranspire, capture, and reuse stormwater to maintain or restore natural hydrologies.
Green roofs can help ease this problem because they absorb and recycle rainwater. The soil layer and plants soak up water that would otherwise immediately run off into storm sewer. On average, 75% of water is retained on an extensive green roof, stored in plants and the soil layer. Only about 25% of water becomes runoff, but this occurs several hours after the peak flow. When the green roof reaches full saturation, excess water slowly percolates through the vegetation layer toa drainage outlet. The soil layer traps sediments, leaves and other particles, treating runoff before it reaches the outlet. Of course, different soil substrates and vegetation provides different water retention capacities. On average, a 1-inch deep moss and sedum layer over a 2-inch gravel bed retains about 58% of water, a 2.5-inch deep sedum and grass layer retains about 67%, and a 4-inch layer of grass and herbaceous vegetation retains about 71% of water.4 In a major 2-inch rainstorm, generating about 1.25 gallons of water per square foot, a 2.5- inch thick extensive green roof would retain approximately 0.5 gallon of water per square foot, or 40%.5 The greatest cost benefit is provided by the first inch of soil and vegetation cover. However, it is recommended to install a 2.5 to 3-inch soil cover to support and maintain a diverse and healthy plant community.
9. Design Concept Of Stormwater Management Using MSMA
Initially, peak discharges is the main variables of hydrology in drainage system design which related to the highest water surface level during storm event. It can be defined as the maximum volume flow rate that passes a 2 particular site during a storm event, and it has units of volume per time, such as cubic meter per second(m3/s) and cubic feet per second (ft3/s). John Roe carried out the first analysis in1852. He published an observations record for London sewers. In 1857, Hawksley built analytical expressions to Roes data to make a correlation between the magnitude of peak discharge and the drainage area. Over the half century that followed, Hawksleys formula produced a generation of pseudo empirical equations of peak flow estimation. However, he particularly did not consider meteorological variables such as rainfall intensity and frequency of estimated peak discharges. In 1879, Major E.T.C Myers developed the Myers formula which computes the area of waterway, Ac. The area was independent of landuse and rainfall, although coefficient Cm corresponded to the rainfall intensity. Nevertheless, it has limited to small catchment areas.
Where Ac is the area of the waterway in acres, Cm is a coefficient which reflects the slope of the drainage area, and A is the drainage area in acres. A Swiss Hydraulic Engineer, A. Burkli-Ziegler introduced The Burkli-Ziegler Formula in 1880. He computed the unit discharge (ft3/sec/acre), qm using
in which Cb is a runoff coefficient, i is the average rainfall intensity (in/hr) during heavy rainfall, S is the average ground slope (ft/1000 ft), and A is the drainage area
in acres. Cb depends on the landcover, with special emphasis on the relative imperviousness.
Professor A.N. Tablot from the University of Illinois carried on the studies on the determination the drainage areas in 1887. He presented the Talbot Formula which as generated from the Burkli-Ziegler.
Where a is waterway cross-sectional area in ft2, Ct is a runoff coefficient, and A is the drainage area in acres.
Ac = CmA0.5
qm = Cbi (S/A)0.25
a = CtA0.75
10. Conclusions Findings show that the performances of extensive green roof system in HTC (Humid Tropics Center) are promising under local tropical climate. Simulations in design storms and actual storm events indicated that it could reduce the peak discharge relative to impervious brown roof. However, its ability reduced for storms with intense rainfall. The water quality of the outflow produced by the green roof was generally good and achieved high WQI.(Water Quality Index)However, it was a source of PO4 and basic outflow were noticed producing from the green roof during storms. Substrates of the green roof could be the essential factor in affecting the quality of the outflow.Cooler environment was created inside the green roof building since reduction of indoor temperature was noticed after installation of the green roof system
References [1] Derek T 2007 Study on Green Roof Application in Hong Kong Final Report 77- 81&100-104 [2] Mentens J, Raes D, Hermy M 2006 Green Roof as a Tool For Solving the Rainwater Runoff Problem in The Urbanized 21st Century? J. of Landscape and Urban Planning 77 217-226 [3] Moran A, Hunt B, Jennings G 2005 A Field Study of Green Roof Hydrologic and Water Quality Performance American Society of Agricultural and Biological Engineer ISSN 0001- 2351 [4] Ni J Y 2009 Green Roof Study: Stormwater Quantity, Quality and Thermal Performance M.S thesis (University of Pittsburgh, USA) [5] Villarreal E L and Bengtsson L 2005 Response of a sedum green-roof to individual rain events Ecological Engineering 25 1-7 [6] Kah H K, Lariyah M S, Mohamed Roseli Z A, Hidayah B, Salmia B, Shuhairy N and Herdayati K 2012 Green Roof as an Option of Green Technology for Urban Stormwater Management Controls 5th Engineering Conference (EnCon 201) 10-12 July 2012 (Kuching, Sarawak) [7] Lariyah M S, Mohd Nor M D , Mohamed Roseli Z A, Zulkefli M, Amirah Hanim M P 2011 Application of Water Sensitive Urban Design at Local Scale in Kuala Lumpur 12th International Conference on Urban Drainage (12ICUD) 10- 15 September 2011 (Porto Alegre, Brazil)