Chapter 18: Allocation of Support Activity Costs and Joint Costs
MULTIPL C!"IC #USTI"$S
1. Which of the following would be considered a service department for an airline? A. Maintenance. B. Information Systems. . !urchasing. ". #light atering. $. All of the above. Answer% $ &'% 1 (ype% ) *. Which of the following would not be considered a service department in a hospital? A. Security. B. ardiac are. . !atient +ecords. ". Accounting. $. ,uman +esources. Answer% B &'% 1 (ype% + -. onsider the following statements about service department costs% I.(he costs of the ,uman +esources "epartment in a manufacturing organi.ation must be allocated to production departments in order to achieve a correct costing of inventory. II.(he allocation of service department costs re/uires that an organi.ation select both an allocation base and an allocation method. III.Service department cost allocations are more relevant for firms involved in service industries 0e.g.1 repair1 health care2 than for those involved with manufacturing. Which of the above statements is 0are2 correct? A. I only. B. II only. . I and II. ". II and III. $. I1 II1 and III. Answer% &'% 1 (ype% +1 ) 3. Which of the following methods ignores the fact that some service departments provide service to other service departments? A. "irect method. B. Indirect method. . Step4down method. ". +eciprocal method. $. "ual4cost allocation method. Answer% A &'% 1 (ype% + 44 Hilton, Managerial Accounting, Sixth Edition 5. onsider the following statements about the direct method of service department cost allocation% I.6nder the direct method1 all service department costs are eventually allocated to production departments. II.(he order in which service department costs are allocated to production departments is important. III.'nce a service department7s costs have been allocated1 no costs are re4circulated bac8 to that department. Which of the above statements is 0are2 correct? A. I only. B. II only. . I and II. ". I and III. $. I1 II1 and III. Answer% " &'% 1 (ype% + 9. (he Milrose linic has two service departments 0,uman +esources and Information +esources2 and two :production: departments 0In4patient (reatment and 'ut4patient (reatment2. (he service departments service each other1 and studies have shown that Information +esources provides the greater amount of service. Which of the following allocations would occur if Milrose uses the direct method of cost allocation? A. Information +esources cost would be allocated to In4patient (reatment. B. Information +esources cost would be allocated to ,uman +esources. . ,uman +esources cost would be allocated to Information +esources. ". In4patient (reatment cost would be allocated to 'ut4patient (reatment. $. 'ut4patient (reatment cost would be allocated to Information +esources. Answer% A &'% 1 (ype% ) ;. (rac8ster orporation has two service departments 0Maintenance and ,uman +esources2 and three production departments 0Machining1 Assembly1 and #inishing2. Maintenance is the largest service department and Assembly is the largest production department. (he two service departments service each other as well as the three producing departments. 'n the basis of this information1 which of the following cost allocations would not occur under the direct method? A. Machining cost would be allocated to Assembly. B. Maintenance cost would be allocated to #inishing. . Maintenance cost would be allocated to ,uman +esources. ". ,uman +esources cost would be allocated to #inishing. $. Allocations :A: and :: would not occur. Answer% $ &'% 1 (ype% ) 45 Hilton, Managerial Accounting, Seventh Edition <. Which of the following methods recogni.es some 0but not all2 of the services that occur between service departments? A. "irect method. B. Step4down method. . Indirect method. ". +eciprocal method. $. "ual4cost allocation method. Answer% B &'% 1 (ype% + =. When the step4down method is used1 the service department whose costs are allocated first is often the department that% A. obtains the highest yield. B. has the lowest cost. . is the newest. ". serves the greatest number of other service departments. $. serves the fewest other service departments. Answer% " &'% 1 (ype% + 1>. onsider the following statements about the step4down method of service department cost allocation% I.6nder the step4down method1 all service department costs are eventually allocated to production departments. II.(he order in which service department costs are allocated is important. III.'nce a service department7s costs have been allocated1 no costs are re4circulated bac8 to that department. Which of the above statements is 0are2 correct? A. I only. B. II only. . I and II. ". I and III. $. I1 II1 and III. Answer% $ &'% 1 (ype% + Chapter 18 46 11. "uluth orporation has two service departments 0Maintenance and ,uman +esources2 and three production departments 0Machining1 Assembly1 and #inishing2. (he two service departments service each other1 and studies have shown that Maintenance provides the greatest amount of service. 'n the basis of this information1 which of the following cost allocations would li8ely occur under the step4down method? A. Machining cost would be allocated to Assembly. B. Maintenance cost would be allocated to #inishing. . Maintenance cost would be allocated to ,uman +esources. ". ,uman +esources cost would be allocated to Maintenance. $. Allocations :B: and :: above. Answer% $ &'% 1 (ype% ) 1*. (he ,opwood linic has two service departments 0,uman +esources and Information Systems2 and two :production: departments 0In4patient (reatment and 'ut4patient (reatment2. (he service departments service each other1 and studies have shown that Information Systems provides the greatest amount of service. Which of the following allocations would not occur if ,opwood uses the step4down method of cost allocation? A. Information Systems cost would be allocated to ,uman +esources. B. ,uman +esources cost would be allocated to Information Systems. . ,uman +esources cost would be allocated to In4patient (reatment. ". In4patient (reatment cost would be allocated to 'ut4patient (reatment. $. Allocations :B: and :": above. Answer% $ &'% 1 (ype% ) 1-. Which of the following methods accounts for 1>>? of the services that occur between service departments? A. "irect method. B. Indirect method. . +eciprocal method. ". Step4down method. $. "ual4cost allocation method. Answer% &'% 11 9 (ype% + 13. +eno orporation has two service departments 0Maintenance and ,uman +esources2 and three production departments 0Machining1 Assembly1 and #inishing2. (he two service departments service each other1 and studies have shown that Maintenance provides the greatest amount of service. @iven the various cost allocation methods1 which of the following choices correctly denotes whether Maintenance cost would be allocated to ,uman +esources? "irect Step4"own +eciprocal A. Aes )o Aes B. Aes )o )o . Aes Aes Aes ". )o Aes )o $. )o Aes Aes Answer% $ &'% 11 9 (ype% ) 47 Hilton, Managerial Accounting, Seventh Edition 15. Which of the following methods would be of little use when allocating service department costs to production departments? A. (he direct method. B. (he reciprocal method. . (he step4down method. ". (he net4reali.able4value method. $. (he dual4cost allocation method. Answer% " &'% 11 *1 3 (ype% ) 19. +yan1 Inc.1 has two service departments 0,uman +esources and Building Maintenance2 and two production departments 0Machining and Assembly2. (he company allocates Building Maintenance cost on the basis of s/uare footage and believes that Building Maintenance provides more service than ,uman +esources. (he s/uare footage occupied by each department follows. ,uman +esources 31>>> Building Maintenance 111>>> Machining 191>>> Assembly **1>>> Assuming use of the direct method1 over how many s/uare feet would the Building Maintenance cost be allocated 0i.e.1 spread2? A. 151>>>. B. -<1>>>. . 3*1>>>. ". 5-1>>>. $. More information is needed to Budge. Answer% B &'% 1 (ype% A Chapter 18 48 1;. !eterson ompany has two service departments 0afeteria and ,uman +esources2 and two production departments 0Machining and Assembly2. (he number of employees in each department follows. afeteria 3> ,uman +esources 9> Machining *>> Assembly ->> !eterson uses the direct method of cost allocation and allocates cost on the basis of employees. If ,uman +esources cost amounts to C11<>>1>>>1 how much of the department7s cost would be allocated to Machining? A. C9>>1>>>. B. C;*>1>>>. . C=>>1>>>. ". C11*>>1>>>. $. Some other amount. Answer% B &'% 1 (ype% A 1<. "urango1 Inc.1 has two service departments 0,uman +esources and Building Maintenance2 and two production departments 0Machining and Assembly2. (he company allocates Building Maintenance cost on the basis of s/uare footage and believes that Building Maintenance provides more service than ,uman +esources. (he s/uare footage occupied by each department follows. ,uman +esources 51>>> Building Maintenance =1>>> Machining 151>>> Assembly **1>>> Assuming use of the step4down method1 over how many s/uare feet would the Building Maintenance cost be allocated 0i.e.1 spread2? A. 131>>>. B. -;1>>>. . 3*1>>>. ". 511>>>. $. More information is needed to Budge. Answer% &'% 1 (ype% A 49 Hilton, Managerial Accounting, Seventh Edition 1=. Anniston1 Inc.1 has two service departments 0,uman +esources and Building Maintenance2 and two production departments 0Machining and Assembly2. (he company allocates Building Maintenance cost on the basis of s/uare footage and ,uman +esources cost on the basis of employees1 and believes that Building Maintenance provides more service than ,uman +esources. (he s/uare footage and employees in each department follow. S/uare #ootage $mployees ,uman +esources 31>>> 1> Building Maintenance 1>1>>> 15 Machining 151>>> 3> Assembly *11>>> 9> Assuming use of the step4down method1 which of the following choices correctly denotes the number of s/uare feet and employees over which the Building Maintenance cost and ,uman +esources cost would be allocated 0i.e.1 spread2? Building Maintenance ,uman +esources A. -91>>> 1>> B. 3>1>>> 1>> . 391>>> 11> ". 5>1>>> 11> $. Some other combination of figures not listed above. Answer% B &'% 1 (ype% A *>. Western1 Inc.1 has two service departments 0,uman +esources and Building Maintenance2 and two production departments 0Machining and Assembly2. (he company allocates Building Maintenance cost on the basis of s/uare footage and believes that Building Maintenance provides more service than ,uman +esources. (he s/uare footage occupied by each department follows. ,uman +esources -15>> Building Maintenance <1;>> Machining =1=>> Assembly 151>>> 'ver how many s/uare feet would the Building Maintenance cost be allocated 0i.e.1 spread2 with the direct method and the step4down method? "irect Method Step4"own Method A. *31=>> *<13>> B. *31=>> -;11>> . *<13>> *31=>> ". -;11>> *31=>> $. Some other combination of figures not listed above. Answer% A &'% 1 (ype% A Chapter 18 5 *1. Saunders ompany has two service departments 0afeteria and ,uman +esources2 and two production departments 0Machining and Assembly2. (he number of employees in each department follows. afeteria *> ,uman +esources -> Machining 1>> Assembly 15> Saunders uses the step4down method of cost allocation and allocates cost on the basis of employees. ,uman +esources cost amounts to C11*>>1>>>1 and the department provides more service to the firm than afeteria. ,ow much ,uman +esources cost would be allocated to Machining? A. C>. B. C3*<15;*. . C3331333. ". C3<>1>>>. $. Some other amount. Answer% &'% 1 (ype% A **. ,unt orporation has two service departments 0S1 and S*2 and two production departments 0!1 and !*21 and uses the step4down method of cost allocation. Management has determined that S1 provides more service to the firm than S*1 and has decided that the number of employees is the best allocation base to use for S1. (he following data are available% "epartment )umber of $mployees S1 1> S* *> !1 5> !* ;> Which of the following statements is 0are2 true if S1 and S* have respective operating costs of C*<>1>>> and C-5>1>>>? A. S* should allocate a portion of its C-5>1>>> cost to S1. B. S17s cost should be allocated 0i.e.1 spread2 over 13> employees. . S17s cost should be allocated 0i.e.1 spread2 over 15> employees. ". S* should allocate a total of C-=>1>>> to !1 and !*. $. Statements :B: and :": are both correct. Answer% $ &'% 1 (ype% A 51 Hilton, Managerial Accounting, Seventh Edition 6se the following to answer /uestions *-4*5% (he "ollar Store has a ,uman +esources "epartment and a Danitorial "epartment that provide service to three sales departments. (he ,uman +esources "epartment cost is allocated on the basis of employees1 and the Danitorial "epartment cost is allocated on the basis of space. (he following information is available% ,uman +esources Danitorial Sales E1 Sales E* Sales E- Budgeted cost C351>>> C->1>>> Space in s/uare feet 31>>> 11>>> *>1>>> ->1>>> 5>1>>> )umber of employees 5 1> 15 35 -> *-. 6sing the direct method1 the amount of Danitorial "epartment cost allocated to Sales "epartment no. * is% A. C<15;1. B. C<1953. . C=1>>>. ". C1>1-5>. $. C131*1>. Answer% &'% 1 (ype% A *3. 6sing the step4down method and assuming that ,uman +esources is allocated first1 the amount of ,uman +esources cost allocated to Sales "epartment no. - is% A. C1*1>>>. B. C1*1<5;. . C1-15>>. ". C151>>>. $. C**15>>. Answer% &'% 1 (ype% A *5. 6sing the step4down method and assuming ,uman +esources is allocated first1 the amount of Danitorial cost allocated to Sales "epartment no. * is% A. C<15;1. B. C=1>>>. . C=1<5;. ". C1>1*3;. $. C1>1-5>. Answer% $ &'% 1 (ype% A Chapter 18 5! 6se the following to answer /uestions *94*<% (he "eFter Manufacturing ompany has two production departments 0Assembly and #inishing2 and two service departments 0,uman +esources and Danitorial2. (he proBected usage of the two service departments is as follows% 6se of 6se of ,uman +esources Danitorial ,uman +esources 444 5? Danitorial 1>? 444 Assembly 9>? 3>? #inishing ->? 55? (he budgeted costs in the service departments are% ,uman +esources1 C=>1>>> and Danitorial1 C5>1>>>. *9. 6sing the direct method1 the amount of Danitorial "epartment cost allocated to the #inishing "epartment is% A. C*11>5-. B. C*31<3-. . C*51>>>. ". C*<1=3;. $. C-3115;. Answer% " &'% 1 (ype% A *;. 6sing the step4down method and assuming the ,uman +esources "epartment is allocated first1 the amount of ,uman +esources cost allocated to the Assembly "epartment is% A. C*11>5-. B. C*<1=3;. . C531>>>. ". C9>1>>>. $. C;<1<3*. Answer% &'% 1 (ype% A *<. 6sing the step4down method and assuming the ,uman +esources "epartment is allocated first1 the total amount of service department cost allocated to the #inishing "epartment is% A. C5<1=3;. B. C91115<. . C;31>>>. ". C;<1<3*. $. C<11>5-. Answer% B &'% 1 (ype% A 5" Hilton, Managerial Accounting, Seventh Edition *=. (he process of allocating fiFed and variable costs separately is called% A. the separate allocation procedure 0SA!2. B. diverse allocation. . reciprocal4cost allocation. ". common4cost allocation. $. dual4cost allocation. Answer% $ &'% * (ype% + ->. 6nder dual4cost allocation1 fiFed costs are allocated on the basis of a user department7s% A. long4run usage of a service department7s output. B. short4run usage of a service department7s output. . long4run usage and short4run usage of a service department7s output. ". neither long4run usage nor short4run usage of a service department7s output. $. either long4run usage or short4run usage of a service department7s output. Answer% A &'% * (ype% + -1. onsider the following statements about dual4cost allocation% I."ual4cost allocation prevents a change in the short4run activity of one department from affecting the cost allocated to another department. II."ual4cost allocations create an incentive for user department managers to understate their eFpected long4run service needs. III."ual4cost allocations are generally preferred over lump4sum allocations1 or those that combine variable and fiFed costs together. Which of the above statements is 0are2 true? A. I only. B. III only. . I and II. ". II and III. $. I1 II1 and III. Answer% $ &'% * (ype% + -*. When allocating service department costs1 companies should use% A. actual costs rather than budgeted costs1 and separate rates for variable and fiFed costs. B. budgeted costs rather than actual costs1 and separate rates for variable and fiFed costs. . budgeted costs rather than actual costs1 and a rate that combines variable and fiFed costs. ". actual costs rather than budgeted costs1 and a rate that combines variable and fiFed costs. $. a rate that is based on matriF theory. Answer% B &'% * (ype% + Chapter 18 54 --. @annon orporation allocates administrative costs on the basis of staff hours. Short4run monthly usage and anticipated long4run monthly usage of staff hours for 'perating "epartments 1 and * follow. "ept. 1 "ept. * (otal Short4run usage 0hours2 3>1>>> 9>1>>> 1>>1>>> &ong4run usage 0hours2 351>>> 551>>> 1>>1>>> If @annon uses dual4cost accounting procedures and variable administrative costs total C*>>1>>>1 the amount of variable administrative cost to allocate to "epartment 1 would be% A. C<>1>>>. B. C<51>>>. . C=>1>>>. ". C1>>1>>>. $. some other amount. Answer% A &'% * (ype% A -3. +onan orporation allocates administrative costs on the basis of staff hours. Short4run monthly usage and anticipated long4run monthly usage of staff hours for 'perating "epartments 1 and * follow. "ept. 1 "ept. * (otal Short4run usage 0hours2 <>1>>> 1*>1>>> *>>1>>> &ong4run usage 0hours2 =>1>>> 11>1>>> *>>1>>> If +onan uses dual4cost accounting procedures and fiFed administrative costs total C11>>>1>>>1 the amount of fiFed administrative cost to allocate to "epartment 1 would be% A. C3>>1>>>. B. C35>1>>>. . C5>>1>>>. ". C<5>1>>>. $. some other amount. Answer% B &'% * (ype% A 55 Hilton, Managerial Accounting, Seventh Edition -5. )ashville orporation allocates administrative costs on the basis of staff hours. Short4run monthly usage and anticipated long4run monthly usage of staff hours for 'perating "epartments 1 and * follow. "ept. 1 "ept. * (otal Short4run usage 0hours2 351>>> 551>>> 1>>1>>> &ong4run usage 0hours2 3<1>>> 5*1>>> 1>>1>>> Gariable and fiFed administrative costs total C1<>1>>> and C3>>1>>>1 respectively. If )ashville uses dual4cost accounting procedures1 the total amount of administrative cost to allocate to "epartment * would be% A. C->119>>. B. C->;1>>>. . C-1-19>>. ". C-1=1>>>. $. some other amount. Answer% B &'% * (ype% A -9. A company that uses activity4based costing would li8ely allocate costs from% A. service departments to production departments. B. service departments to products and services. . service departments to production departments and then to products and services. ". activity4cost pools to production departments. $. activity4cost pools to products and services. Answer% $ &'% - (ype% + -;. (he point in a Boint production process where each individual product becomes separately identifiable is commonly called the% A. decision point. B. separation point. . individual product point. ". split4off point. $. Boint product point. Answer% " &'% 3 (ype% + -<. (he Boint4cost allocation method that recogni.es the revenues at split4off but does not consider any further processing costs is the% A. relative4sales4value method. B. net4reali.able4value method. . physical4units method. ". reciprocal4accounting method. $. gross margin at split4off method. Answer% A &'% 3 (ype% + Chapter 18 56 -=. Which of the following methods should be selected if a company terminates all processing at the split4off point and desires to use a cost4allocation approach that considers the :revenue4 producing ability: of each product? A. @ross margin at split4off method. B. +eciprocal4accounting method. . +elative4sales4value method. ". !hysical4units method. $. )et4reali.able4value method. Answer% &'% 3 (ype% ) 3>. Which of the following choices correctly denotes the data needed to allocate Boint costs under the relative4sales4value method? Sales Galue of !roduct at Split4'ff Separable ost Sales Galue of !roduct After !rocessing Beyond Split4'ff A. Aes Aes )o B. Aes Aes Aes . Aes )o )o ". )o Aes Aes $. )o )o Aes Answer% &'% 3 (ype% + 31. When allocating Boint costs1 Wolstein calculates the final sales value of the various products manufactured and subtracts appropriate separable costs. (he company is using the% A. gross margin at split4off method. B. reciprocal4accounting method. . relative4sales4value method. ". physical4units method. $. net4reali.able4value method. Answer% $ &'% 3 (ype% + 3*. Webster manufactures A1 B1 and 1 all of which are Boint products1 and "1 which is classified as a by4product. If Boint manufacturing costs amount to C35>1>>> and the company is using a popular accounting method1 the firm will% A. allocate C35>1>>> among A1 B1 and . B. allocate C35>1>>> among A1 B1 1 and ". . increase C35>1>>> by the net reali.able value of " and then allocate the total among A1 B1 and . ". decrease C35>1>>> by the net reali.able value of " and then allocate the total among A1 B1 and . $. decrease C35>1>>> by the net reali.able value of " and then allocate the total among A1 B1 1 and ". Answer% " &'% 3 (ype% + 57 Hilton, Managerial Accounting, Seventh Edition 3-. Ithaca orporation uses the physical4units method to allocate costs among its three Boint products% H1 A1 and I. (he following data are available for the period Bust ended% Doint processing cost% C<>>1>>> (otal production% 15>1>>> pounds Share of Boint cost allocated to H% C19>1>>> Share of Boint cost allocated to A% C3>>1>>> Which of the following statements is true? A. (he company would have relied on the sales value of each product when allocating Boint costs to H1 A1 and I. B. Ithaca produced ->1>>> pounds of I during the period. . Ithaca produced 351>>> pounds of I during the period. ". Ithaca produced 1>51>>> pounds of I during the period. $. Based on the data presented1 it is not possible to determine Ithaca7s production of I during the period. Answer% &'% 3 (ype% +1 A 33. @arvin orporation manufactures Boint products ! and J. "uring a recent period1 Boint costs amounted to C<>1>>> in the production of *>1>>> gallons of ! and 9>1>>> gallons of J. @arvin can sell ! and J at split4off for C*.*> per gallon and C*.9> per gallon1 respectively. Alternatively1 both products can be processed beyond the split4off point1 as follows% ! J Separable processing costs C151>>> C-51>>> Sales price 0per gallon2 if processed beyond split4off C- C3 (he Boint cost allocated to J under the relative4sales4value method would be% A. C3>1>>>. B. C9*13>>. . C931>>>. ". C9519>>. $. some other amount. Answer% B &'% 3 (ype% A Chapter 18 58 35. @unniston orporation manufactures Boint products W and H. "uring a recent period1 Boint costs amounted to C->>1>>> in the production of *>1>>> gallons of W and 9>1>>> gallons of H. Both products will be processed beyond the split4off point1 giving rise to the following data% W H Separable processing costs C3>1>>> C19>1>>> Sales price 0per gallon2 if processed beyond split4off C13 C1* (he Boint cost allocated to W under the net4reali.able4value method would be% A. C;51>>>. B. C<>1>>>. . C<31>>>. ". C=>1>>>. $. some other amount. Answer% " &'% 3 (ype% A 6se the following to answer /uestions 3943<% +oc8y Mountain ompany produces two products 0H and A2 from a Boint process. $ach product may be sold at the split4off point or processed further. Additional processing re/uires no special facilities1 and production costs of further processing are entirely variable and traceable to the products involved. Doint manufacturing costs for the year were C9>1>>>. Sales values and costs were as follows% If !rocessed #urther 6nits Sales Galue Sales Separable !roduct Made at Split4off Galue osts H =1>>> C3>1>>> C;<1>>> C1>15>> A 91>>> <>1>>> =>1>>> ;15>> 39. If the Boint production costs are allocated based on the physical4units method1 the amount of Boint cost assigned to product H would be% A. C*>1>>>. B. C*31>>>. . C->1>>>. ". C-91>>>. $. C3>1>>>. Answer% " &'% 3 (ype% A 3;. If the Boint production costs are allocated based on the relative4sales4value method1 the amount of Boint cost assigned to product H would be% A. C*>1>>>. B. C*;1>>>. . C--1>>>. ". C3>1>>>. $. some other amount. Answer% A &'% 3 (ype% A 59 Hilton, Managerial Accounting, Seventh Edition 3<. If the Boint production costs are allocated based on the net4reali.able4value method1 the amount of Boint cost assigned to product A would be% A. C*>1>>>. B. C*;1>>>. . C--1>>>. ". C3>1>>>. $. some other amount. Answer% &'% 3 (ype% A 3=. Which of the following statements about Boint4cost allocation is false? A. Doint4cost allocation is useful in deciding whether to further process a product after split4 off. B. Doint4cost allocation is useful in ma8ing a profit determination about individual Boint products. . Doint4cost allocation is helpful in inventory valuation. ". Doint4cost allocation can be based on the number of units produced. $. Doint4cost allocation can be accomplished by using several different methods that focus on sales value and product :worth.: Answer% A &'% 5 (ype% ) 5>. onsider the following statements about Boint product cost allocation% I.Doint product cost is allocated because it is necessary for inventory valuation. II.Doint product cost is allocated because it is necessary for ma8ing economic decisions about individual products 0e.g.1 sell at split4off or process further2. III.Doint cost may be allocated to products by using several different methods. Which of the above statements is 0are2 correct? A. I only. B. III only. . I and II. ". I and III. $. I1 II1 and III. Answer% " &'% 5 (ype% + 51. $astside ,ospital has two service departments 0!atient +ecords and Accounting2 and two :production: departments 0Internal Medicine and Surgery2. Which of the following allocations would li8ely ta8e place under the reciprocal4services method of cost allocation? A. Allocation of Accounting cost to !atient +ecords. B. Allocation of !atient +ecords cost to Internal Medicine. . Allocation of Surgery cost to Accounting. ". Allocation of Internal Medicine cost to Surgery. $. Allocations :A: and :B: above. Answer% $ &'% 1 (ype% ) Chapter 18 6 5*. Westside ,ospital has two service departments 0!atient +ecords and Accounting2 and two :production: departments 0Internal Medicine and Surgery2. Which of the following allocations would not ta8e place under the reciprocal4services method of cost allocation? A. Allocation of Accounting cost to !atient +ecords. B. Allocation of !atient +ecords cost to Internal Medicine. . Allocation of Surgery cost to Accounting. ". Allocation of Internal Medicine cost to Surgery. $. Allocations :: and :": above. Answer% $ &'% 1 (ype% ) 61 Hilton, Managerial Accounting, Seventh Edition %&CISS 'unda(entals of )irect and Step*)o+n Methods 5-. )ovaturn orporation has three service departments 0S1 and S*2 and two production departments 0!1 and !*2. S1 and S* both use the number of employees as an allocation base. (he following data are available%
)umber of $mployees Budgeted ost S1 3> C1;*1>>> S* 9> *5>1>>> !1 ->> 99>1>>> !* 5>> <3>1>>> +e/uired% A. Assuming use of the direct method% 1. 'ver how many employees would S17s budgeted cost be allocated? *. ,ow much of S*7s cost would be allocated to !1? -. ,ow much of !17s cost would be allocated to S1? B. Assuming use of the step4down method% 1. ,ow much of S17s cost would be allocated to S*? )ovaturn allocates S17s costs prior to allocating those of S*. *. ,ow much of S*7s total cost would be allocated to !*? -. ,ow much of S*7s total cost would be allocated to S1? &'% 1 (ype% A Answer% A. 1. <>> 0->> K 5>>2 *. C=-1;5> LC*5>1>>> F 0->>M<>>2N -. )one1 because production department costs are not allocated to service departments. B. 1. S17s costs are allocated over <9> employees 09> K ->> K 5>>2. (hus1 C1*1>>> will be allocated to S* LC1;*1>>> F 09>M<9>2N. *. S*7s costs total C*9*1>>> 0C*5>1>>> K C1*1>>>21 resulting in C19-1;5> being allocated to !* LC*9*1>>> F 05>>M<>>2. -. )one1 because S17s costs are allocated prior to those of S*. 'nce a department is closed1 no costs are allocated bac8 to it. Chapter 18 6! )irect and Step*)o+n Methods of Service )epart(ent Cost Allocation 53. Wyoming State ollege has two service departments1 the &ibrary and omputing Services1 that assist the School of Business and the School of ,ealth. Budgeted costs of the &ibrary and omputing Services are C<>>1>>> and C11<>>1>>>1 respectively. 6sage of the service departments7 output during the year is anticipated to be% !rovider of Service 6ser of Service &ibrary omputing Services &ibrary 444 1>? omputing Services 444 444 School of Business *>? 9>? School of ,ealth <>? ->? +e/uired% A. 6se the direct method to allocate the costs of the &ibrary and omputing Services to the School of Business and the School of ,ealth. B. +epeat re/uirement :A: using the step4down method. Wyoming allocates the cost of omputing Services first. &'% 1 (ype% A Answer% A. School of Business School of ,ealth #raction Amount #raction Amount &ibrary C <>>1>>> *M1> C 19>1>>> <M1> C 93>1>>> omputing Services 11<>>1>>> 9M= 11*>>1>>> -M= 9>>1>>> (otal C*19>>1>>> C11-9>1>>> C11*3>1>>> B. omputing services 0C11<>>1>>>2% &ibrary 01>?2 C 1<>1>>> School of Business 09>?2 11><>1>>> School of ,ealth 0->?2 53>1>>> &ibrary 0C<>>1>>> K C1<>1>>> O C=<>1>>>2% School of Business 0*>?2 C 1=91>>> School of ,ealth 0<>?2 ;<31>>> 6" Hilton, Managerial Accounting, Seventh Edition )irect and Step*)o+n Methods of Service )epart(ent Cost Allocation 55. hicago1 Inc.1 manufactures gauges for automobile dashboards. (he company has two production departments1 Molding and Assembly. (here are three service departments% ,uman +esources1 Maintenance1 and $ngineering. 6sage of services by the various departments follows. ,uman +esources Maintenance $ngineering ,uman +esources 44 44 44 Maintenance 5? 44 44 $ngineering 5? 1>? 44 Molding 3>? 3>? ;5? Assembly 5>? 5>? *5? (he budgeted costs in hicago7s service departments are% ,uman +esources1 C1<>1>>>P Maintenance1 C*;>1>>>P and $ngineering1 C*>>1>>>. (he company rounds all calculations to the nearest dollar. +e/uired% A. 6se the direct method to allocate hicago7s service department costs to the production departments. B. "etermine the proper departmental se/uence to use in allocating the firm7s service costs by the step4down method. . Ignoring your answer in part :B1: assume that ,uman +esources costs are allocated first1 Maintenance costs second1 and $ngineering costs third. 6se the step4down method to allocate hicago7s service department costs. &'% 1 (ype% A1 + Chapter 18 64 Answer% A. Molding Assembly #raction Amount #raction Amount ,uman +esources C1<>1>>> 3>M=> C <>1>>> 5>M=> C1>>1>>> Maintenance *;>1>>> 3>M=> 1*>1>>> 5>M=> 15>1>>> $ngineering *>>1>>> ;5M1>> 15>1>>> *5M1>> 5>1>>> (otal C95>1>>> C-5>1>>> C->>1>>> B. #irst% ,uman +esources 0serves two other service departments2 Second% Maintenance 0serves one other service department2 (hird% $ngineering 0serves no other service departments2 . ,uman +esources 0C1<>1>>>2% Maintenance 05?2 C =1>>> $ngineering 05?2 =1>>> Molding 03>?2 ;*1>>> Assembly 05>?2 =>1>>> Maintenance 0C*;>1>>> K C=1>>> O C*;=1>>>2% $ngineering 01>?2 C *;1=>> Molding 03>?2 11119>> Assembly 05>?2 1-=15>> $ngineering 0C*>>1>>> K C=1>>> K C*;1=>> O C*-91=>>2% Molding 0;5?2 C1;;19;5 Assembly 0*5?2 5=1**5 Molding% C;*1>>> K C11119>> K C1;;19;5 O C-911*;5 Assembly% C=>1>>> K C1-=15>> K C5=1**5 O C*<<1;*5 65 Hilton, Managerial Accounting, Seventh Edition )irect and Step*)o+n Methods of Service )epart(ent Cost Allocation 59. Bec8ers orporation is developing departmental overhead rates based on direct labor hours for its two production departments1 Molding and Assembly. (he Molding "epartment wor8ed *>1>>> hours during the period Bust ended1 and the Assembly "epartment wor8ed 3>1>>> hours. (he overhead costs incurred by Molding and Assembly were C1511*5> and C33>1;5>1 respectively. (wo service departments1 +epair and !ower1 directly support the two production departments. (hese service departments have costs of C=>1>>> and C*5>1>>>1 respectively. (he following schedule reflects the use of +epair and !ower7s output by the various departments% +epair !ower Molding Assembly +epair 0repair hours2 5>> 5>> 31>>> !ower 08ilowatt hours2 1*>1>>> 3*>1>>> 9>1>>> +e/uired% A. Allocate the company7s service department costs to production departments by using the direct method. B. alculate the overhead application rates of the production departments. ,int% onsider both directly traceable and allocated overhead when deriving your answer. . Allocate the company7s service department costs to production departments by using the step4down method. Begin with the !ower "epartment1 and round calculations to the nearest dollar. &'% 1 (ype% A Answer% A. Molding Assembly #raction Amount #raction Amount +epair C =>1>>> >.5M3.5 C 1>1>>> 3.>M3.5 C <>1>>> !ower *5>1>>> 3.*M3.< *1<1;5> >.9M3.< -11*5> C-3>1>>> C**<1;5> C1111*5> B. Molding Assembl y Allocated service department costs C**<1;5> C1111*5> 'verhead costs1 traceable to production departments 1511*5> 33>1;5> (otal overhead costs C-<>1>>> C55*1>>> "irect labor hours
*>1>>>
3>1>>> 'verhead rate per hour C1=.>> C1-.<> Chapter 18 66 . !ower 0C*5>1>>>2% +epair 01*>M9>>2 Molding 03*>M9>>2 Assembly 09>M9>>2 C 5>1>>> 1;51>>> *51>>> +epair 0C=>1>>> K C5>1>>> O C13>1>>>2% Molding 05>>M315>>2 Assembly 031>>>M315>>2 C 151559 1*31333 Molding% C1;51>>> K C151559 O C1=>1559 Assembly% C*51>>> K C1*31333 O C13=1333 Understandin, Service )epart(ent Allocations 5;. onsider the following independent cases that relate to service department cost allocations% Ca#e A% Stric8land ompany has two service departments L,uman +esources 0,M+2 and Information SystemsN and two production departments 0Machining and Assembly2. ,uman +esource cost is allocated by using the direct method based on the number of personnel in each department. #or the period Bust ended1 there were 1<= employees in Machining1 and Machining received C=>1>>> of ,M+7s overhead of C*>>1>>>. ,ow many employees are in the Assembly "epartment? Ca#e $% Walter Bur8e1 controller of AleFander $nterprises1 wants service department managers to be aware that their use of other service departments costs the firm a substantial amount of money. Would Bur8e prefer the direct method or the step4down method of cost allocation? Why? Ca#e C% &oc8wood ompany has four service departments 0S11 S*1 S-1 and S32 and two production departments 0!1 and !*2. (he costs of S1 are allocated first1 followed in order by the costs of S*1 S-1 and S3. &oc8wood uses the step4down method1 and the costs of S* are allocated based on the number of computer hours used. omputer hours logged during the period were as follows% S11 319>>P S*1 ;11>>P S-1 1>13>>P S31 1;19>>P !11 -;1>>>P and !*1 3<19>>. 'ver how many hours would S*7s cost be allocated? Ca#e %% A recently hired staff accountant noted that given the nature of the allocations1 the total cost allocated to production departments is typically less under the step4down method than under the direct method. "o you agree with the accountant? Why? +e/uired% Answer the /uestions that are raised in ases A1 B1 1 and ". &'% 1 (ype% A1 ) 67 Hilton, Managerial Accounting, Seventh Edition Answer% ase A% Machining has been allocated 35? of ,M+7s cost 0C=>1>>> Q C*>>1>>>2 because it has 35? of the employees in the production departments. Since 1<= represents 35? of the total1 there are 3*> employees in production 01<= Q >.352. (hus1 Assembly has *-1 personnel 03*> 4 1<=2. ase B% Bur8e would prefer the step4down method because service department costs are allocated to other service departments 0although not all2. Such a practice ma8es managers aware that services are not cost4free to the organi.ation. ase % 11-19>> 01>13>> K 1;19>> K -;1>>> K 3<19>>2 ase "% )o. 6nder both approaches1 all service department costs are allocated to production departments. (his process yields e/ual totals for each method. Chapter 18 68 )ual*Cost Allocations 5<. +enaissance1 Inc.1 has centrali.ed much of its speciali.ed data processing operation1 with the omputer "epartment performing services for "epartments A and B. Service hours consumed during /uarter no. 1 and /uarter no. * follow. A B Juarter no. 1 9> 9> Juarter no. * 3> 9> omputer "epartment operating costs were% Gariable 0!er ,our2 #iFed Juarter no. 1 C5> C3>1>> > Juarter no. * 35 -<1>>> ompany policy currently re/uires that total variable and fiFed costs be combined and allocated as a lump4sum to users based on service hours. +enaissance has been financially healthy for a number of years but began to eFperience problems toward the end of /uarter no. 1. In response to these problems1 management issued a directive to closely monitor costs and computer usage1 effective with the start of /uarter no. *. +e/uired% A. ompute /uarter no. 17s total computer cost and determine the allocation to "epartment A and "epartment B. B. ,ow much cost would be allocated to "epartments A and B during /uarter no. *1 and how would the heads of these departments li8ely react to the allocations in light of management7s directive? . Assume that at the beginning of /uarter no. *1 the company switched to dual4cost allocations1 with variable costs allocated based on current usage and fiFed costs allocated based on long4run average utili.ation. An analysis of proBected usage found that wor8 for "epartment A was eFpected to consume 55? of the omputer "epartment7s time over the forthcoming year. ,ow much cost would be allocated to A and B in /uarter no. *? ". @iven the use of dual allocations1 how1 if at all1 would a short4term increase or decrease in A7s current usage affect the /uarterly cost allocation that is charged to "epartment B? &'% * (ype% A1 ) 69 Hilton, Managerial Accounting, Seventh Edition Answer% A. Gariable cost% 09> K 9>2 F C5> C 91>>> #iFed cost 3>1>> > (otal cost C391>> > Since each department consumed 9> hours of services1 the cost would be split e/ually% C391>>> Q * O C*-1>>>. B. Gariable cost% 03> K 9>2 F C35 C 315>> #iFed cost -<1>> > (otal cost C3*15> > "epartment A% 03> Q 1>>2 F C3*15>> O C1;1>>> "epartment B% 09> Q 1>>2 F C3*15>> O C*515>> (he head of A would be pleased because the department7s decreased usage resulted in a C91>>> reduction in cost 0C*-1>>> 4 C1;1>>>2. In contrast1 the head of B would li8ely be unhappy. Although unable to reduce usage1 usage did remain constantRa situation that produced a C*15>> increase in cost 0C*515>> 4 C*-1>>>2 despite the fact that overall cost declined. . A B Gariable% 3> hours F C35 C 11<>> 9> hours F C35 C *1;>> #iFed% C-<1>>> F 55? *>1=>> C-<1>>> F 35? 1;11>> (otal C**1;>> C1=1<>> ". (here is no effect on B. (he variable costs charged to "epartment A would increase or decrease1 with other allocations remaining the same. Chapter 18 7 Joint*Cost Allocations 5=. Suppose that one hog yields ->> pounds of ham1 *>> pounds of chops1 and 1>> pounds of miscellaneous items. (he sales value of ham is C1.*> per poundP chops1 C1.5> per poundP and miscellaneous items1 C>.=> per pound. (he hog costs C5<>1 and processing costs are C*>. +e/uired% A. "etermine the proper allocation of Boint costs to the three products by using the physical4 units method. B. +epeat part :B: by using the relative4sales4value method. &'% 3 (ype% A Answer% A. Weight at the Split4'ff !oint +elative !roportion Allocation of Doint ostS ,am ->> pounds -M9 C->> hops *>> pounds *M9 *>> Miscellaneous items 1>> pounds 1M9 1>> 9>> pounds C9>> SC5<> K C*> B. Sales Galue at Split4'ff +elative !roportion Allocation of Doint ost ,am 0->> F C1.*>2 C-9> -9M;5 C*<< hops 0*>> F C1.5>2 ->> ->M;5 *3> Miscellaneous items 01>> F C>.=>2 => =M;5 ;* C;5> C9>> 71 Hilton, Managerial Accounting, Seventh Edition 'unda(entals of Joint*Cost Allocations 9>. ,iggins orporation manufactures two chemicals 0#leFtra and ,ydro2 in a Boint process. "ata from a recent month follow. "irect materials used% C-9>1>>> "irect labor% C15>1>>> Manufacturing overhead% C9=>1>>> Manufacturing output% #leFtra% 3>1>>> gallons ,ydro% 1*>1>>> gallons #leFtra sells for C15 per gallon and ,ydro sells for C*> per gallon. +e/uired% A. ompute the total Boint costs to be allocated to #leFtra and ,ydro. B. ompute the Boint costs that would be allocated to #leFtra by using the physical4units method. . ompute the Boint costs that would be allocated to ,ydro by using the relative4sales4value method. ". Assume that ,ydro can be converted into a more refined product1 ,ydro4+1 in a totally separable process at an additional cost of C3 per gallon. ,ydro4+ can be sold in the mar8etplace for C*9 per gallon. 1. ompute the net reali.able value of ,ydro4+. *. If ,iggins allocated C<>>1>>> of Boint cost to ,ydro4+ and sold =>? of the production completed1 determine the cost of remaining ,ydro4+ that would be transferred to the companyTs month4end balance sheet as finished4goods inventory. &'% 3 (ype% A Answer% A. C11*>>1>>> 0C-9>1>>> K C15>1>>> K C9=>1>>>2 B. #leFtra constitutes *5? of the productive output L3>1>>> Q 03>1>>> K 1*>1>>>2N and would therefore absorb C->>1>>> of Boint cost 0C11*>>1>>> F *5?2. . (he total sales value of the two products is C-1>>>1>>>% #leFtra 03>1>>> gallons F C15 O C9>>1>>>2 K ,ydro 01*>1>>> gallons F C*> O C*13>>1>>>2. Since ,ydro has <>? of the sales value 0C*13>>1>>> Q C-1>>>1>>>21 the company will allocate C=9>1>>> of Boint cost 0C11*>>1>>> F <>?2. ". 1. Sales value 01*>1>>> gallons F C*9 O C-11*>1>>>2 4 costs beyond split4off 01*>1>>> gallons F C3 O C3<>1>>>2 O C*193>1>>>. *. (he total cost of production is C11*<>1>>> 0C<>>1>>> K C3<>1>>>2. Since =>? of the production is sold1 1>? of the cost1 or C1*<1>>>1 remains as inventory. Chapter 18 7! Joint*Cost Allocations 91. 'hio hemical manufactures two industrial chemicals in a Boint process. In 'ctober1 direct material costing C1*>1>>> was processed at a cost of C->>1>>>1 resulting in 191>>> pounds of !enteF and 31>>> pounds of @laFco. !enteF sells for C-5 per pound and @laFco sells for C9> per pound. Management generally processes each of these chemicals further in separable processes to produce more refined products. !enteF is processed separately at a cost of C;.5> per pound1 with the resulting product1 !enteF4+1 selling for C35 per pound. @laFco is processed separately at a cost of C1> per pound1 and the resulting product1 @laFco4+1 sells for C1>> per pound. +e/uired% A. ompute the company7s total Boint production costs. B. Assuming that total Boint production costs amounted to C5>>1>>>1 allocate these costs by using% 1. (he physical4units method. *. (he relative4sales4value method. -. (he net4reali.able4value method. &'% 3 (ype% A Answer% A. Doint production costs total C3*>1>>> 0C1*>1>>> K C->>1>>>2. B. 1. Weight at the Split4'ff !oint +elative !roportion Allocation of Doint ost !enteF 191>>> 19M*> C3>>1>>> @laFco 31>>> 3M*> 1>>1>>> *>1>>> C5>>1>>> *. Sales Galue at Split4'ff +elative !roportion Allocation of Doint ost !enteF 0191>>> F C-52 C59>1>>> 59M<> C-5>1>>> @laFco 031>>> F C9>2 *3>1>>> *3M<> 15>1>>> C<>>1>>> C5>>1>>> -. Sales Galue of #inal !roductS osts !ast Split4offSS )et +eali.able Galue +elative !roportion Allocation of Doint ost !enteF4+ C ;*>1>>> C1*>1>>> C9>>1>>> 9>M=9 C-1*15>> @laFco4+ 3>>1>>> 3>1>>> -9>1>>> -9M=9 1<;15>> C111*>1>>> C19>1>>> C=9>1>>> C5>>1>>> S !enteF4+% 191>>> F C35P @laFco4+% 31>>> F C1>> SS!enteF4+% 191>>> F C;.5>P @laFco4+% 31>>> F C1> 7" Hilton, Managerial Accounting, Seventh Edition $et*&eali-a.le*/alue Method0 1ross Mar,in Calculation 9*. "ouglas ompany1 a new firm1 manufactures two products1 D and U1 in a common process. (he Boint costs amount to C<>1>>> per batch of finished goods. $ach batch results in *>1>>> liters of output1 of which <>? are D and *>? are U. (he two products are processed beyond the split4off point1 with "ouglas incurring the following separable costs% D1 C* per literP U1 C5 per liter. After the additional processing1 the selling price of D is C1* per liter1 and the selling price of U is C15 per liter. +e/uired% A. "etermine the proper allocation of Boint costs if the company uses the net4reali.able4value method. B. Assume that "ouglas sold all of its production of U during the current accounting period. ompute U7s sales revenue1 cost of goods sold1 and gross margin. . Is the firm7s cost4of4goods4sold figure influenced by the choice of a Boint4cost allocation method? Briefly eFplain. &'% 31 5 (ype% A1 ) Answer% A. Sales Galue of #inal !roduct osts !ast Split4'ff )et +eali.able Galue +elative !roportion Allocation of Doint ost D 0191>>> F C1*2 C1=*1>>> C-*1>>> C19>1>>> 19>M*>> C931>>> U 031>>> F C152 9>1>>> *>1>>> 3>1>>> 3>M*>> 191>>> C*>>1>>> C<>1>>> B. Doint costs C191>>> osts beyond split4off *>1>>> ost of goods sold C-91>>> Sales revenue C9>1>>> ost of goods sold -91>>> @ross margin C*31>>> . Aes. ost of goods sold is based on both separable costs and Boint cost. (he choice of an allocation method will influence the amount of Boint cost charged to the product. Chapter 18 74 Analysis of Joint Costs: 2or3in, 4ac3+ard 9-. Barry ompany manufactures H41111 H411*1 and H411- from a Boint process. (he following information is available for the period Bust ended% H4111 H411* H411- (otal 6nits produced 91>>> 131>>> ->1>>> 5>1>>> Doint cost allocation ? C1<13>> ? C <>1>>> Sales value at split4off C1>31>>> ? ? C*9>1>>> +e/uired% A. "oes Barry allocate Boint costs by using the physical4units method? $Fplain. B. Assume that Barry does not use the physical4units method but instead allocates Boint costs by using the relative4sales4value method. #ind the four un8nowns in the preceding table. &'% 3 (ype% A1 ) Answer% A. )o. H411* comprises *<? of the total units produced 0131>>> Q 5>1>>>2P however1 the product was allocated *-? of the total Boint cost 0C1<13>> Q C<>1>>>2. Apparently1 then1 another method is being used. B. H4111 has 3>? of the sales value 0C1>31>>> Q C*9>1>>>21 resulting in 3>? of the Boint cost 0C<>1>>> F 3>?21 or C-*1>>>. (his leaves C*=19>> to be allocated to H411- 0C<>1>>> 4 C-*1>>> 4 C1<13>>2. (he sales values follow by using the same percentages that are used in the cost allocation 0C1<13>> Q C<>1>>> O *-?P C*9>1>>> F *-? O C5=1<>>2 and 0C*=19>> Q C<>1>>> O -;?P C*9>1>>> F -;? O C=91*>>2. H4111 H411* H411- (otal 6nits produced 91>>> 131>>> ->1>>> 5>1>>> Doint cost allocation C -*1>>> C1<13>> C*=19>> C <>1>>> Sales value at split4off C1>31>>> C5=1<>> C=91*>> C*9>1>>> 75 Hilton, Managerial Accounting, Seventh Edition Joint Costs5 Analysis of Joint Production Process 93. Mercury orporation allocates Boint costs by using the net4reali.able4value method. In the company7s Michigan plant1 products " and $ emerge from a Boint process that costs C*5>1>>>. $ is then processed at a cost of C**>1>>> into products # and @. "ata pertaining to "1 #1 and @ follow. " # @ osts beyond split4off C5>1>>> C*;1>>> C*51>> > Selling price 3> -< 5> !ounds produced 1>1>>> 31>>> *1>>> +e/uired% A. Allocate the C**>1>>> processing cost between products # and @. B. #rom a profitability perspective1 should product $ be processed into products # and @? Show your calculations. . Assume that the net reali.able value associated with $ is .ero. ,ow would you allocate the Boint cost of C*5>1>>>? &'% 3 (ype% A1 ) Answer% A. Sales Galue of #inal !roduct osts !ast Split4'ff )et +eali.able Galue +elative !roportion Allocation of Doint ost # 031>>> F C-<2 C15*1>>> C*;1>>> C1*51>>> 1*5M*>> C1-;15>> @ 0*1>>> F C5>2 1>>1>>> *51>>> ;51>>> ;5M*>> <*15>> C*>>1>>> C**>1>>> B. )o1 the company is losing C*>1>>>% )et reali.able value 0C*>>1>>>2 4 Boint costs 0C**>1>>>2. . (he C*5>1>>> cost is a Boint cost between " and $. Since product " has a positive net reali.able value of C-5>1>>> L01>1>>> pounds F C3>2 4 C5>1>>>N and $7s is .ero1 all C*5>1>>> would be charged to ". Chapter 18 76 )ISCUSSI"$ #USTI"$S "vervie+ of Service*)epart(ent Cost Allocation Methods 95. ompanies are free to use the direct1 step4down1 and reciprocal allocation methods when dealing with service4department costs. +e/uired% A. ,ow does the direct method wor8? What is its chief limitation? B. Is the step4down method an improvement over the direct method? $Fplain. . Which of the three methods is the most correct from a conceptual viewpoint? Why? &'% 11 9 (ype% +1 ) Answer% A. (he direct method allocates Boint costs solely to producing departments. (his method does not allocate costs to other service departments and is based on the erroneous assumption that service departments do not service each other. B. (he step4down method is an improvement over the direct method1 as it recogni.es that service departments service both producing departments and other service departments. osts are allocated accordingly. (he step4down method is slightly more compleF than the direct method1 re/uiring a determination of the proper order of departmental allocations. . (he reciprocal method is the most correct approach from a conceptual viewpoint. (his method fully recogni.es all services provided by service departments. (he direct method completely ignores the fact that service departments service each other. (he step4down method recogni.es only some of these services1 as once a department is closed out1 no cost is reallocated bac8 to it. 77 Hilton, Managerial Accounting, Seventh Edition )ual &ate /ersus Sin,le &ate 99. Many companies use the dual4rate method of cost allocation. +e/uired% A. ,ow does the dual4rate method wor8? B. Is there any advantage of the dual4rate method over a method that uses a combined1 lump4 sum single rate? Briefly eFplain. &'% * (ype% + Answer% A. (he dual4rate method involves creating two overhead rates1 one for variable costs and another for fiFed costs. (he variable costs are normally allocated on the basis of short4run usage of the service department7s outputP fiFed costs are allocated on the basis of long4run usage. B. Aes. When a single rate is used1 the cost allocated to a user department may be influenced by the amount of service consumed by another department. #or eFample1 a user department7s service consumption could remain flatP yet the amount of cost allocated to that department could increase or decrease over previous amounts based solely on actions of other users. "ual rates eliminate this problem. Chapter 18 78