three Nkandla reports Nkandla ministerial task team Public Protector Special Investigating Unit* *Report expected to be completed this week NKANDLA NKANDLA Exonerates President Jacob Zuma from wrongdoing and blames ofcials Actual security installation cost R71 million and R135 million was spent on operation- al needs and basic facilities. Consultants charged 24%, which was too much Does not focus on the architect Minenhle Makhanya Points ngers at former public works minister Geoff Doidge and his deputy Hendrietta Bogopane-Zulu Estimated state costs at R206.4 million (by December 2012) Calls it a re pool Zuma derived substantial benet from the non-security features of the upgrades Zuma failed in his duties by not questioning expenditure and must repay costs for non- security upgrades Zuma was in close consultation with Makhanya on the security and other upgrades, and Makhanya overcharged Conduct by former public works minister Geoff Doidge and his deputy Hendrietta Bogopane-Zu- lu was not improper and doesnt amount to maladministration Estimated state costs at R246 million Calls it a swimming pool Doesnt focus on pointing ngers at Zuma Notes overcharging by some of the consul- tants, who were supposed to charge 18.5% but charged 25% of contract value Goes after Makhanya to repay R155 million Suggests there might have been undue interference by former public works minister Geoff Doidge and his deputy Hendrietta Bogopane-Zulu in appointing contractors Says state costs for Nkandla upgrades should only have been R28 million Calls it a re pool How the three reports on security spending at President Jacob Zumas Nkandla home compare