Critical Reflect Essays for Individual Project - Marking Criteria

Project Process Essay Project Process Essay: critical reflection on the process of planning and implementing the project
including your own and others contributions.

The critical reflection should include a comparison of the final project results to the expected timetable,
milestones and deliverable as defined in your Project Specification assessment. It should also reflect on
lessons learned and knowledge gained which can be applied to your further studies and professional life.
[Essay of about 1500 words]
/ 50 HD [50 42.5] A [42 37.5] B [ 37 32.5]: C [32 25] F [24.5 0]
The essay
addresses all
relevant areas.
Analysis of
project
problems and
(possible)
solutions is in
depth and
reflective.
Reflection is
well written
with lessons
learned and
knowledge to
be carried
forward
clearly
articulated.
The essay
addresses most
relevant areas.
Analysis of
project problems
and (possible)
solutions is
comprehensive.
Reflection is
mostly well
written with
lessons learned
and knowledge
to be carried
forward
identified.
The essay
addresses some
relevant areas.
Analysis of
project problems
and (possible)
solutions is
acceptable.
Reflection is
acceptably
written with
some lessons
learned and
knowledge to be
carried forward
identified.
The essay
addresses few
relevant areas.
Analysis of
project
problems and
(possible)
solutions is
poor.
Reflection is
poorly written
and lessons
learned and
knowledge to
be carried
forward have
not been
clearly
identified
Team
reflection was
either missing
or incomplete,
inaccurate or
unsuitable
Teamwork Essay Since you have not worked on a team project for this course, please base this critical reflection essay on other
previous work or team related experiences in which you were involved.
The objective here is for you to critically reflect on your own and others performance in a team environment
including: participation, role definition and fulfilment of assigned roles, collective decision-making, team member
support, communication skills, quality of work, and the explicit or at least implicit teams code of conduct. [Review
the Developing Teamwork Skills resource]
Your essay should also include an analysis of any problems the team faced and their (possible) solutions and should
also reflect on lessons learned and knowledge gained which can be applied to your further studies and professional
life.
[Essay of about 1500 words]
/ 50 HD [50 42.5] A [42 37.5] B [ 37 32.5]: C [32 25] F [24.5 0]
The essay
addresses all
relevant areas.
Analysis of
team
problems and
(possible)
solutions is in
depth and
reflective.
Reflection is
well written
with lessons
learned and
knowledge to
be carried
forward
clearly
articulated.
The essay
addresses most
relevant areas.
Analysis of team
problems and
(possible)
solutions is
comprehensive.
Reflection is
mostly well
written with
lessons learned
and knowledge
to be carried
forward
identified.
The essay
addresses some
relevant areas.
Analysis of team
problems and
(possible)
solutions is
acceptable.
Reflection is
acceptably
written with
some lessons
learned and
knowledge to be
carried forward
identified.
The essay
addresses few
relevant areas.
Analysis of
team
problems and
(possible)
solutions is
poor.
Reflection is
poorly written
and lessons
learned and
knowledge to
be carried
forward have
not been
clearly
identified
Team
reflection was
either missing
or incomplete,
inaccurate or
unsuitable
/100 TOTAL MARKS