Filmhouse Cinemas Promoting the Commercial Viability of Nigerian Films in the Cinemas 2
A publication of the Nollywood Studies Centre 2014 3
Table of Contents 1. Introduction .............................................................. 5 2. Understanding Cinema Operations ............................ 9 A. The Theatrical Distributor................................... 10 B. Film Booking and Dating ..................................... 11 i) The Season ...................................................... 14 ii) Societal Current Affairs ................................... 14 iii) Competition with Other Films ........................ 15 iv) Monday Bookings ........................................... 16 C. Marketing and marketing strategy ..................... 17 3. Some Considerations Towards Promoting Commercial Viability ....................................................... 19 A. Defining the Filmmakers Purpose and Audience 19 i) Why Do Filmmakers Make Films? .................. 19 ii) Who Are the Cinema Goers? .......................... 20 B. What are people watching? ............................... 21 C. Genre .................................................................. 27 4. Final Points by Way of a Summary ......................... 29
4
Table 1: Actual and projected numbers of cinemas in Nigeria (2004 2020) ........................................................ 8
Figure 1: Sample of a Theatrical Release Calendar ........ 13 Figure 2 Global comparison for Avatar (2010) ............... 22 Figure 3 Gobal comparison for Clash of the Titans (2010) ........................................................................................ 23 Figure 4: Global comparison for Prince of Persia (2010) 24 Figure 5: Global comparison for Salt (2010) ................... 25 Figure 6: Global comparison for Avengers (2012) .......... 26
5
1. Introduction The history of film exhibition in Nigeria is a fairly long one that stretches as far back as the 1900s. The interest of Nigerians in theatrical exhibition only intensified following the introduction of indigenous filmmaking in 1970s. According to Adeleke, Between 1970s and the late 1980s, members of the public were eager to visit film houses to see their favourite stage artists who had taken to screen, and perhaps nostalgic drive to see the old stage plays on celluloid encouraged some to patronise the exhibition halls. (Adeleke, 2003, p. 52) 1
However, thanks to the prevailing economic depression and the consequent insecurity, activities at most of the Nigerian cinema houses ground to a halt from the late 1980s and into the 1990s. The cinema halls themselves were turned to other uses. The video film boom of the 1990s created even more of a distance from the cinemas. This, of course, is not to say that the cinemas died out all
1 Adeleke, D. A. (2003). Culture, Art and Film in An African Society: An Evaluation. Nordic Journal of African Studies, 12(1), 49-56.
6
together. In quite a few places, notably in the north of the country, the cinemas continued to function albeit at a very low scale. There are about 42 of such cinemas currently functioning in the north. But, it is necessary to make a distinction between these and what one could term modern cinemas with their upgraded facilities and offerings. Twenty plus years later, however, the economy has improved, and events have come full swing. There is now a renewed surge of interest in cinema halls. In terms of modern cinemas, the Silverbird Group set the ball rolling in 2004 with the establishment of its first cinema, a five screen multiplex, in Lagos, It was joined three years later, in 2007, by City Mall and the South African owned Nu Metro. Subsequent years would witness the openings of Ozone, Genesis Deluxe, iCinema and Filmhouse as well as more cinemas in different cities by Silverbird. In spite of the closing down of Nu Metro and iCinema (Port Harcourt) in 2009 and 2012, respectively, there are currently 15 cinemas, and it is expected that by the end of 2013, there will be 20 cinemas with 90 screens. This number is expected to rise to 30 cinemas and 135 screens by 2014, with a further expected jump by 2016 to reach 40 cinemas and 200 screens (see table 1). The average seating size per cinema screen is 120 seats. Given the size of the Nigerian populace, these numbers may not appear to be significant, but they remain important for the Nigerian filmmaker since they point to 7
the possibilities that exist. It can be said that the future is quite bright as regards the growth of the cinema. For instance, beginning in 2013, Filmhouse plans to open 25 cinemas over the space of 6 years. Ster Kinekor, the largest South African chain, is already showing interest in the Nigeria territory, and there are various plans, especially on the part of the Lagos State government, to build a chain of community cinemas.
2. Understanding Cinema Operations There have been various complaints from filmmakers, particularly in the last two years, who say that they have been poorly treated by the cinema owners. They have complained about having had problems with one or the other cinema; about the fact that their money was not remitted to them in time; that the cinema did not advertise or market their films as much as they expected; that the film was pulled out from the cinema earlier than was anticipated; or that they did not receive as much money as they expected for their film from the cinema. Some of these claims may or may not be valid, but oftentimes the criticism of the cinema chains arise from a misunderstanding about their mode of operation. It is therefore important for filmmakers to appreciate the way the cinema operates. It is useful, in the first place, to understand the difference between the use of the word cinema in terms of the building where films are shown as opposed to the use of the same term to refer to the film itself. The term is often used in a global way to refer to various things, filmmaking inclusive. The term, as used here, refers solely to the place where films are shown. The word 'theatre' is also used synonymously with cinema in this regard. It is also important to lay emphasis on the fact that the cinema, in the context being defined here, must 10
be distinguished from television, a school, a charity work or a medium for diffusing governmental public oriented messages. The relevance of making such a distinction will be drawn out later. A. The Theatrical Distributor The theatrical distributor is an important figure in cinema operations and can be described as the middleman between the filmmaker and the exhibitor or cinema owner. Although there are many organisations and persons that could be called distributors in Nigeria, there are very few of them that are actually theatrical distributors. The better known ones are Blue Pictures, Silverbird Distribution and Okhma Global Limited. While it is true that the filmmaker can choose to self- market his film, there are advantages to working with a theatrical distributor. In the first place, the theatrical distributor has more resources for the marketing and promotion of ones film. A distributor that is prepared to accept a film into his/her stable should also be prepared to be involved in the promotion and advertising of the film. This aspect of the process is essential and should be started months before the actual release of the film. A second advantage is that the distributor is in a better position not only to monitor the progress of a film in the cinema but also to oversee the collection and sharing of 11
revenue. In addition to this, the distributor has a better knowledge of the good cinemas as well as the best play dates for releasing ones films. All in all, it is highly recommendable for the filmmaker to work with a theatrical distributor because the distributor knows exactly how the cinemas operate. A good distributor is one that fights the cause of the filmmaker and the film as far as the cinemas are concerned. B. Film Booking and Dating In the cinema, the choice of the right play dates is often a determining factor in how well a film does in the box office. Cinemas plan their calendars months in advance. (See figure 2) Thus, anyone planning a theatrical release must book with the cinemas well ahead of time. It is important in making such bookings to be aware of possible dates or events that could either undermine or promote the successful performance of ones film in the cinema. For instance, whereas it makes good sense to make the release of ones film coincide with a public holiday, it may not be such a good idea if that public holiday coincided with a carnival and other momentous events that would make attendance at the cinema less attractive for the viewing audience. The calendar, to a large extent, is generated by the distributors. Although the cinema houses can influence dates, oftentimes the distributors have the dates and 12
exhibitors work with their calendar. Consequently, when the filmmaker approaches a distributor, before any deal is struck, the distributor opens the calendar to fix a date. However, and unfortunately, the frequency of release in the Nigerian market is sometimes detrimental to the success of the films themselves. Films are sometimes released every week, and this means that a film is not allowed to play long enough in the cinema in order to be truly profitable.
13
Figure 1: Sample of a Theatrical Release Calendar 14
In considering film bookings and dating, the following factors should also be taken into consideration: i) The Season It is important to understand the role that the season plays in the successful outing or otherwise of ones films. For the theatrical premiere of a film, the filmmaker must learn to capitalise on important seasonal events school holidays, Christmas and Easter holidays, etc. because these are the periods when the numbers of cinema goers are likely to peak. One therefore needs to place the season with ones film. The cinema calendars show public holidays, or religious holidays such as Ramadan or Easter. ii) Societal Current Affairs Societal happenings could also be an important factor in the success or failure of ones film at the cinema. This factor, however, is oftentimes not within the control of the filmmaker. For example, it was pure coincidence that the film, Last Flight to Abuja, was released at about the same time that a plane crash took place. That was a sad event. But things like that sometimes positively help a film. Films that connect with topical issues of society can often benefit positively from such connections, but in some cases it can work negatively against the film.
15
iii) Competition with Other Films The filmmaker must pay attention to the other films planned for release at the same time at the same time as his/hers. For instance, it would be a mistake to plan the release of ones film to coincide with that of a blockbuster film that is likely to draw away most of the audience. It is good to remember that even though a lot of people go to the cinema every weekend, they do so having already budgeted on what they will spend their leisure naira. So, if they decide to spend it on the blockbuster film A this weekend, and at the cinema they happen to see the poster for the Nigerian film B showing the same time, they will merely decide to return the following weekend for film B. However, for reasons that will be mentioned in the following section, 80% of the time that film would have already been yanked off the screening list and will not be available the following weekend. Rather than entering into competition with other films in this way, filmmakers can capitalise on the crowds that those films might attract to advertise the showing of their new films at a subsequent date. The highest selling Nigerian film in Nigerian cinemas, Ije was able to do so well (N59.3 million from 6 cinemas) because there were no other Nigerian films in the cinema at the same time to compete with it. The highest earning Nigerian films after that have all been in the range of N20 16
million because they were all released at about the same time, not giving each other space to recoup and do well. iv) Monday Bookings In cinema business, the week is calculated from Friday to Thursday, so the cinema week starts on a Friday and ends on a Thursday. However, the scheduling of films for the week is done on Mondays. The box office figures from the weekend are used to determine all the films that will be scheduled for the different days of the week ahead. Thus the opening weekend performance of a film is crucial to Monday bookings. The weekend figures will be the determiner as to whether the new film released will be scheduled at all in the week ahead or whether preference will be given to other films. If the weekend figures for the new film have been low, it will be taken out. Herein lies the danger of competition. If one releases a film at about the same time as the release of a blockbuster, one must be aware of the risks. This is related to the concept of the available leisure naira to spend, mentioned above. The audience being targeted for the films is the same one, and if there is competition with, for instance, Hollywood blockbusters, the Nigerian films are likely to do badly. So, it is best to try and find a date when there will be the least competition. 17
C. Marketing and marketing strategy Marketing is a key contributor to the success of films in the cinema. Marketing here involves publicity, advertising and promotion. One of the biggest problems for most Nigerian filmmakers is that they only begin the marketing of their new films on the day the film is released. This clearly is a problem because by the time the marketing kicks in it is too late to affect the figures of the opening weekend. And, come Monday, the cinema house will have to make a decision for scheduling it in the new week. Consequently, the film is likely to be dropped from four shows to one and at 10am or in the afternoon. Thus, the film ends up not making money. The advertising campaign should be started early. According to the formula used by the established film industries, the promotion of a film begins months before its release and even while production is still on. There is a need to understand that early marketing and publicity help the film to register in people's mind, and they will consequently plan towards when it eventually comes out. It is advisable, if possible, to work with a PR agency. Also, the stars of the film should be committed in their contracts to taking part to publicity and pre-release activities. The nature of such activities should be concretely spelt out. 19
3. Some Considerations Towards Promoting Commercial Viability Like every filmmaker knows, the planning stage in the filmmaking process contributes greatly to the success of the film. However, there are certain aspects of that planning stage that it is easy to overlook, and these are aspects that could make or break a film in the cinema. These aspects involve the definition of the filmmaker's purpose, the audience for the film and the genre that the film should fit into. A. Defining the Filmmakers Purpose and Audience One of the causes of failure of films in the cinema arises from the filmmakers inability to adequately define either his/her purpose for the film or the audience. In this regard, it is important to ask two questions: Why do filmmakers make films? Who are the cinema goers? i) Why Do Filmmakers Make Films? Each filmmaker will probably give a different answer to this question, and one cannot presume to generalise on what the motivations are. But oftentimes, there is a confusion between wanting to create a message driven film, an artistic film or a box office hit. Of course, this is 20
not to say that these three things are incompatible. But it is important to clearly define what the various intentions are in order to cater to each one adequately because certain decisions concerning the film will be guided by whatever the prevailing desire is. If ones desire is to make money, then it is important not to lose sight of the business angle of filmmaking. And in order to be a commercially viable and a worthwhile business, the film must contain the right ingredients that will make it sell. A primary motivation for the filmmaker, in this regard, must be to capture the attention of the audience such that they will want to pay to watch the film. In other words, the filmmaker must not lose sight of the need to entertain the audience. ii) Who Are the Cinema Goers? This question is linked to the previous one. Filmmakers need to understand the make up of the cinema going audience. The primary cinema goers are aged 15 35. The secondary ones, here in Nigeria, are 15 14. One might argue that overseas 11 to 14 year olds go to the cinema by themselves, but that is not the case in Nigeria where concerns for safety prevail. So, children of that age can go to the cinema only when there is an adult to accompany them. Another secondary group is constituted of the 36 to 50 year olds. Then there is the tertiary group of those that are 50 years and above that only come to the cinema on public holidays, festivals, etc. 21
The filmmaker cannot afford to be oblivious of the needs of those of the primary audience. The necessary question is whether the guiding factor in making films should be what the filmmaker wants to disseminate or what the audience wants to watch. B. What are people watching? In making films, it is important to think about whether the audience is watching those films. For this reason, it is useful to carry out some audience analysis to find out what people are watching. For the cinema owner, the figures tell it all. A global comparison of box office revenues shows that films do quite well in Nigerian cinemas, and that these cinemas are significant in the scheme of things. (Figures 2 to 6 show the revenues of various films across different countries). In Nigerian cinemas alone, some films have made from N50 million to over N150 million (Salt, Prince of Persia, Avatar, Ije etc). It is notable that in spite of the low number of cinemas in the country, films are making money in the cinema, and it is Nigerians that are watching them. Thus, if one's film does not do well in the cinema, it cannot be because people are unwilling to spend money in the cinema. 22
Figure 2: Global comparison for Avatar (2010) 23
Figure 3: Global comparison for Clash of the Titans (2010) 24
Figure 4: Global comparison for Prince of Persia (2010) 25
Figure 5: Global comparison for Salt (2010) 26
Figure 6: Global comparison for Avengers (2012) 27
It is worthwhile pointing out that some Nigerian films have made sums in the cinema within the range of N20 to N30 million (The Meeting, Tango with Me, Return of Jenifa, Phone Swap, Anchor Baby). The point is that it is possible for a Nigerian film to make such sums and more at the cinema. We may have very few cinemas, but it is still possible. But, of course, one must put all the right structures in place. C. Genre In order for films to have a greater chance of commercial viability, they should meet certain requirements. In the first place, they should be entertaining, and they should be fun. The action genre is a popular one, and it sells a lot. Comedy is another genre that sells a lot. Other genres include romantic comedy and science fiction. Although this does not qualify as a genre, emphasis must be given here to the use of known actors. Films that have a known name are also likely to sell well because people want to see the films that feature their favourite stars. Known names give a film an extra boost and provide the extra hook that will enhance the film's chances of selling. The importance of star power should not be underestimated. The experience in the cinema is that before going in to watch a film the audience always want to first find out who the main actors in the film are. Thus, in choosing actors for a film, the filmmaker should not 28
overlook the importance of keeping the preferences of the primary audience in mind. 29
4. Final Points by Way of a Summary 1. The filmmaker should decide why he/she wants to make a film: any reason is good, but there is a need to have clearly defined reasons. If one decides to go for a money making film, then it is important to ensure that the film contains some appeal for the targeted audience (this is especially important if one wants to target a non-Nigerian audience).
2. It pays to decide who the target audience is and to find out why they are watching. It never pays to take the audience for granted.
3. The filmmaker should identify other films similar to the one being planned, and aimed at a similar audience, and find out how such films have done in the box office. One must be realistic about this; it would be absurd to use a Hollywood blockbuster film with worldwide reach and a budget of fifty million dollars as a benchmark for a film that is aimed at a local audience and has a budget of a hundred thousand dollars.
4. The filmmaker has to enter into a contract with a theatrical distributor for the circulation of his/her film. 30
5. A film dating strategy should be agreed upon with the distributor, and competition with other films should be avoided where possible.
6. The filmmaker should have a concise marketing plan and strategy and should start the process early.
7. The film stars should be tied down, via a contract, to publicity and pre-release activities. Ensure that the contract with the film stars defines exactly what the publicity and pre-release activities will consist of; do not leave it vaguely expressed as just 'publicity'. The involvement of the actors in publicity activities is important because the power of the stars is phenomenal.
8. Get your publicity material to the cinema early enough, and time the display of such material to coincide with the release of other crowd-pulling films.