Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
E
x
a
c
e
r
b
a
t
i
o
n
h
i
s
t
o
r
y
mMRC #2
CAT # 10
R
i
s
k
G
O
L
D
c
l
a
s
s
i
c
a
t
i
o
n
o
f
a
i
r
o
w
l
i
m
i
t
a
t
i
o
n
Patient Group A
Low risk
Less symptoms
GOLD grade 1 or 2
Exacerbations/yr 0-1
Symptoms mMRC 0-1 or CAT <10
Patient Group B
Low risk
More symptoms
GOLD grade 1 or 2
Exacerbations/yr 0-1
Symptoms mMRC #2 or CAT #10
Patient Group C
High risk
Less symptoms
GOLD grade 3 or 4
Exacerbations/yr #2
Symptoms mMRC 0-1 or CAT <10
Patient Group D
High risk
More symptoms
GOLD grade 3 or 4
Exacerbations/yr #2
Symptoms mMRC #2 or CAT #10
When assessing risk, choose the highest risk according to GOLD
spirometry grade or exacerbation history
mMRC: Modied Medical Research Council dyspnea scale
CAT: COPD Assessment Test
SeverlLy
osLbronchodllaLor
lLv1/lvC
lLv1 pred.
AL rlsk
(Smokers, +famlly hx, eLc)
>0.7 >80
Mlld CCu <0.7 >80
ModeraLe CCu <0.7 30-80
Severe CCu <0.7 30-30
very severe CCu <0.7 <30
Celli et al Eur Respir J 2004; 23:932-946
A1S]LkS C|ass|hcanon of CCD
Stag|ng by Sp|rometry
uesnon 1
33 year old man presenLed wlLh a 3 year hlsLory of
shorLness of breaLh on exeruon, worse followlng a vlral
resplraLory lnfecuon. Pe had asLhma as a chlld and was a
smoker (1u) for 23 years. ulmonary funcuon Lesung
showed a moderaLely severe degree of obsLrucuon. Whlch
of Lhe followlng LesLs have been shown Lo dlsungulsh
asLhma from CCu?
uesnon 1
Wh|ch of the fo||ow|ng tests best d|snngu|sh asthma
from CCD?
Choose the best answer
a) 8ronchlal lnhalauon challenge wlLh meLhachollne
b) An lLv1 response Lo a shorL acung beLa agonlsL
of > 12 lmprovemenL (and > 200 cc lncrease)
c) MeasuremenLs of lung volumes (1LC, l8C, 8v)
d SpuLum eoslnophll counL
D|snngu|sh|ng Asthma and CCD
8oLh may lead Lo xed alrow obsLrucuon buL mosL show
reverslblllLy Lo shorL-acung bronchodllaLors
ulerences ln lung funcuon LesLs (dluslng capaclLy, resldual
volume,
a
C
2
) sLausucally slgnlcanL buL Lhere ls large overlap
CCu has hlgher emphysema score on P8C1
Lxhaled nC hlgher ln asLhmaucs buL Lhere ls overlap
AsLhmaucs have slgnlcanLly more eoslnophlls ln Lhe perlpheral
blood, spuLum and 8AL, CCu, lncreased neuLrophlls spuLum
and 8AL
CCD and AS1nMA: D|erent D|seases
.
COPD
Affects elderly,
especially smokers
Slowly progressive
Inflammatory cells
Partially reversible
? 10%
ASTHMA
Affects all ages,
especially childhood
Episodic course
Inflammatory cells
Eosinophilc bronchitis
Neutrophils in severe disease
Overlap syndrome
May be fully reversible
Neutrophilic bronchitis
Eosinophils during
exacerbation
Airway remodeling and
Lung destruction
Airway remodelling
no destruction
Some patients with asthma cannot be distinguished from COPD with
the current diagnostic tests. The management of these patients should
be similar to that of asthma. ATS Guidelines 2004
D|snngu|sh|ng Asthma and CCD*
Fabbri et al AJRCCM 2003;167:418-24
Sputum Eosinophils >4.6% Exhaled NO is
distinguish the 2 diseases not able to distinguish
*FEV1= 56% predicted
Fabbri et al AJRCCM 2003;167:418-24
atho|og|c Changes: Asthma vs CCD
Asthma shows |mmunosta|n|ng for eos|noph||s (8)
and th|ckened basement membrane (D)
*
Sputum Neutroph||s S|gn|hcant|y
Increased Dur|ng a CCD Lxacerbanon
Fujimoto K, et al. Eur Respir J. 2005;25:640-646.
Results of nonsmokers from a stable phase and during an exacerbation in patients who developed
an exacerbation during the study.
*P<0.01 vs nonsmokers.