Behavior Behavior Approach to Approach to Teach Children Teach Children with Autism with Autism Mary Lynch Barbera, R, M!, BCBA Mary Lynch Barbera, R, M!, BCBA www"vbapproach"com www"vbapproach"com May #$$% May #$$% Autism &ne Con'erence Autism &ne Con'erence
My Autism Journey My Autism Journey July 2, 1999 Lucas was diagnosed with moderate to severe autism one day before his third birthday !e"tember 1999 !tarted #$ hours%w& A'A "rogram with Lovaas consultant coming monthly June 2$$$ (ounding )resident of Autism !ociety of 'er&s *ecember 2$$+ 'ecame a 'oard ,ertified 'ehavior Analyst and Lead 'ehavior Analyst for the )A -erbal 'ehavior )ro.ect May 2$$/ )ublished the results of a single sub.ect multi"le baseline study that 0 designed in 1he Analysis of -erbal 'ehavior May 2$$2 )ublication of my boo&3 The Verbal Behavior Approach: How to Teach Children with Autism and Related Disorders.
Lovaas !tudy Lovaas !tudy )ublished in 1942 /9 children 5+ years age or under6 diagnosed with autism 19 received #$ hours%w& 131 A'A for 2 years 2$ received 1$ hours%w& 2$ received standard s"ecial education classrooms%71%s"eech #28 of those receiving #$ hours%w& of treatment became 9indistinguishable from their "eers by first grade:
A'A as the treatment of choice A'A as the treatment of choice A""lied 'ehavior Analysis 5A'A6 is the only scientifically validated treatment for autism and is recommended by the ;! !urgeon <eneral A'A treatment became "o"ular in the mid= 199$>s when ,atherine Maurice, a "arent of two children with autism who both 9recovered: from autism using this a""roach, "ublished two boo&s detailing Lovaas ty"e A'A thera"y
An &verview o' An &verview o' ABA ABA
A""lied 'ehavior Analysis A""lied 'ehavior Analysis 5A'A6 5A'A6 *efinition 9A""lied behavior analysis is the science in which "rocedures derived from the "rinci"les of behavior are systematically a""lied to im"rove socially significant behavior: 5,oo"er, ?eron, and ?eward6
'asic )rinci"les of A'A 'asic )rinci"les of A'A 'ehavior is defined in ob.ective and measurable terms @Aamines the functional relationshi" between behavior and its controlling variables AnalyBes socially significant behavior in need of im"rovement AnalyBes behavior through a three term contingency
1hree 1erm ,ontingency 1hree 1erm ,ontingency Antecedent=='ehavior== ,onseCuences AD'D, Also *escribed As *iscriminative !timulus==Ees"onse== ,onseCuence M7%! * DEDEeinf or )unish
Basic Behavioral Basic Behavioral (rinciples (rinciples Antecedent - any stimulus that happens before a behavior Behavior - an observable and measurable act of an individual Consequence - any stimulus that happens after a behavior
1hree 5Eeally (our6 1erm 1hree 5Eeally (our6 1erm ,ontingency ,ontingency Antecedent=='ehavior==,onseCuences Motivation is now seen as "laying a significant role in this model 5Michael6
@Aam"les of 1hree 1erm @Aam"les of 1hree 1erm ,ontingency ,ontingency 91ouch nose: ,hild touches nose receives "iece of coo&ie 9*o )uBBle: ,hild falls to floor *emand withdrawn
Fou use the "rinci"les of Fou use the "rinci"les of A'A all day longG A'A all day longG A'A is used to3 0ncrease "ositive behaviors Language, self care s&ills, academic s&ills *ecrease negative behaviors 1antrums, biting, &ic&ing, crying
H1$$$ Activity H1$$$ Activity 1hin& of a child you &now with challenging behaviors3 0f 0 gave you H1$$$ for that child to have a 9good day: with little to no "roblem behavior, what would you doI
)ic& one or two target )ic& one or two target behaviors behaviors !elect the target behavior to be reduced by eAaminingJ 1he seriousness of the behaviorJif could in.ure self or othersJtarget these before behaviors such as hand fla""ing or "oor attention 1he freCuency of the behavior
*efine !etting @vent *efine !etting @vent As"ects of a "erson>s environment or daily routine that do not necessarily occur immediately before the behavior Medication ad.ustment Medical "roblems 5"in& eye, dia"er rash6 !lee" "roblems @ating routines%diet Kumber of "eo"le in room *aily schedule 5how "redictable%how much choice6
0mmediate Antecedents 0mmediate Antecedents Lhat triggered the behavior Lhat ha""ened immediately before "roblem behavior started3 ,om"uter was turned off 1old child to hang u" coat ,hild saw candy and wanted it
;sing the "rinci"les of ;sing the "rinci"les of A'A to reduce "roblem A'A to reduce "roblem behavior behavior *efine 'ehavior===='e !"ecificGG Mic&ing his feet against the chair, throwing boo&s, biting his own fingers, hitting his head with his fist K713 ?aving a tough time, frustrated, irritable
,onseCuences ,onseCuences Eeinforcement A conseCuence that results in increasing or maintaining the future rate of behavior it follows )unishment A conseCuence that results in decreasing the future rate of behavior it follows
,onseCuences ,onseCuences Any behavior that occurs re"eatedly is serving some useful function and "roducing some ty"e of reinforcement
,onseCuences ,onseCuences After a behavior has occurred the environment can change in several ways3 1 A neutral event can ha""en3 if nothing ha""ens that is relevant, the conseCuence will li&ely have no effect on the behavior 2 1hings can get better3 if things get better, the behavior will li&ely occur again under similar conditions 1his is called reinforcement + 1hings can get worse3 if things get worse, the behavior will li&ely not occur again under similar conditions 1his is called "unishment
1hings <et 'etter3 1hings <et 'etter3 Eeinforcement Eeinforcement Eeinforcement is a change in the environment following a behavior that increases the future "robability of that behavior under similar circumstances
1hings <et Lorse3 1hings <et Lorse3 )unishment )unishment Lhen things get worse following a behavior, the behavior is less li&ely to occur in the future under similar circumstances 1his is "unishment )unishment decreases the li&elihood of behaviorN Eeinforcement 5including negative reinforcement6 increases behavior
0s 1ime 7ut a 0s 1ime 7ut a Eeinforcement or a Eeinforcement or a )unishmentI )unishmentI Keed to loo& whether time out is increasing or decreasing the freCuency of the target behavior Most "eo"le thin& 1ime 7ut is a "unisher but it functions as a reinforcement for many children
1a&e *ata 1o 0dentify 1a&e *ata 1o 0dentify the A, ', and , the A, ', and , Lithout ta&ing baseline date and identifying the antecedent, behavior, and conseCuence, it is not wise to im"lement a behavior reduction strategy
(unctions of )roblem (unctions of )roblem 'ehavior 'ehavior 1o obtain something desirable 5Attention, 1angibles, !ensory !timulation6 1o avoid or esca"e something undesirable 51as& avoidance6
Antecedent 0nterventions Antecedent 0nterventions ,hanging the environment before the behavior occurs to "revent the behavior (ocus on "airing%manding 4 "ositives to every negative Eeconfigure class layout or ratio <ive more or less time at a center <et more slee" at night or na" @at brea&fast or serve snac& earlier )rovide transition warnings
Eeactive 0nterventions Eeactive 0nterventions 0nterventions im"lemented after "roblem behavior occurs !ome eAam"les3 ,ount and Mand 5use for attention only6 )lanned 0gnoring 5use for attention only6 1ime 7ut 5use for attention only6 Lor& through *emand 5use for esca"e only6
,ount and Mand ,ount and Mand @A"lained in ,ha"ter 2 of my boo& ;sed for access to tangibles%attention onlyG ,an also use count and give choice, count and EO, or count and give attention !te"s3 1 !to" the "roblem behavior 5hands down, be Cuiet, no &ic&ing6 2 !ilent count to +, /, or 1$Dif "roblem behavior resumes, return to P 1 + )rom"t the mand 9coo&ie:Dchild echoes 9coo&ie: EightJhow do you as&IJchild res"onds 9coo&ie:Jdeliver EO
,ombined A""roach ,ombined A""roach !"end 9/8 of your time "reventing "roblem behavior Lhen negative behaviors do occur, use reactive intervention conseCuences at the moment ,ount and Mand )lanned 0gnoring 1ime 7ut Lor& 1hrough *emand
0f you find yourself using 0f you find yourself using reactive interventions reactive interventions freCuently freCuently Fou need to continue to ta&e data or re= start data ta&ing to determine setting events, antecedents and functions of target behavior Four demands might be too high and%or reinforcement might be too low 1he environment might need to be changed
1hree things that matter no matter 1hree things that matter no matter what the age or functioning levelGG what the age or functioning levelGG 1 )roblem behaviors at or near $ 2 Ability to reCuest wants and needs to an unfamiliar adult + 0nde"endent toileting QQQQ2=minute activityQQQQ
,ase !tudies ,ase !tudies
,ase !tudy P 1 Amy>s mother re"orts that Amy is a "oor slee"er @ach Monday morning she arrives to daycare and begins to "lay Lhen she is called to circle, Amy cries and throws herself to the ground 1he staff tries to find something less aversive to Amy and usually tries bouncing Amy on the ball to get her calm Amy does usually Cuiet down on the ball
,ase !tudy Ruestions ,ase !tudy Ruestions Lhat might be a setting eventI Lhat is the immediate antecedentI Lhat is the behaviorI Lhat is the conseCuenceI *oes the conseCuence serve as a Eeinforcer or )unishmentI
,ase !tudy P1 5cont6 ,ase !tudy P1 5cont6 Lill the behaviors li&ely go u" or downI Lhat is the most li&ely the function of Amy>s behaviorI Lhat are some interventions you would recommend to hel" reduce Amy>s negative behavior
;sing A'A and -erbal ;sing A'A and -erbal 'ehavior 5-'6 to 'ehavior 5-'6 to 0ncrease )ositive 0ncrease )ositive 'ehaviors 'ehaviors 0ncreasing language and learning s&ills using the "rinci"les of A'A and '( !&inner>s Analysis of -erbal 'ehavior
)hat is Verbal Behavior* )hat is Verbal Behavior* Behavior that is rein'orced through the mediation o' another person+s behavior
Dual Path of Applied Behavior Analysis Research LOVAAS (UCLA) ABA Research Plus Discrete Trial Training (structure) !C"A#L ($U) ABA Research Plus Discrete Trial Training Plus Skinners Analysis of Veral Behavior (function)
,ommon terms for the -erbal ,ommon terms for the -erbal 7"erants 7"erants Mand , re-uest Tact , label .ntraverbal , conversation, answering a -uestion, responding when someone else tal/s 0choic , repeating what someone else says Receptive or Listener Responding , 'ollowing directions
Lhat is 9,offee:IIIIIII Lhat is 9,offee:IIIIIII .s it a1 MA2* TACT* .TRAV0RBAL*
ECHOIC INTRAVERBAL RECEPTIVE (FFC) TACT (FFC) MAND
-erbal 'ehavior Activity -erbal 'ehavior Activity As a result o'8 &ne has a tendency to8 This is a8 !eeing a grape !aying 5grape6 :earing a horn !aying 5truc/6 !omeone saying 5what says moo*6 !aying 5cow6 )anting a push on the swing !aying 5push6 Being told to 5stand up6 !tanding up !omeone 5winnie the6 !aying 5pooh6 !omeone says 5potty6 !aying 5potty6 !eeing a stranger !aying 5what+s your name*6 !eeing a tree !aying 5tree6
1wo other related s&ills3 1wo other related s&ills3 0mitation3 <iven another "erson>s motor action in the antecedent condition, the child "erforms the same action Match to !am"le3 matching activities involving either identical or non=identical items 51his is a very sim"listic definition for a very critical s&ill area also referred to as conditional discriminations6
Teaching the Teaching the Mand Mand
Lhy 1eaching Mands is Lhy 1eaching Mands is 0m"ortant 0m"ortant 0t hel"s children avoid frustration in communicating their needs and wants 0t is relatively easy to do because you are using the child>s own motivation as a tool 0t is a natural first ste" in teaching communication
1he Mand 1he Mand 5EeCuesting6 5EeCuesting6 All mands have one thing in common3 in the antecedent condition, there is a Motivative 7"eration 5or motivation6 in "lace AS thirst 5M76 'S 90 want .uice: ,S student gets .uice 0f a child does not want the item, you cannot teach them to mand for it
@Aam"les of contriving an @Aam"les of contriving an M7 M7 ?olding u" an MTM within eyesight of the child <iving the child a bottle with a tight lid 0n the bottle is his favorite toy <iving the child a bowl of cereal with no s"oon <iving the child a toy that reCuires batteries but withholding the batteries 'riefly turning on his or her favorite video <iving a bit of his or her favorite snac& to another child
Lhen Kegative 'ehaviors Lhen Kegative 'ehaviors 7ccur *uring Mand 1raining 7ccur *uring Mand 1raining *o not reinforce whining%crying or other negative behaviors ,ount and Mand ,hild has to learn that crying will not get them anythingJa""ro"riate manding willG
Mee" Kumber and @ffort of Mee" Kumber and @ffort of *emands Low at (irst *emands Low at (irst ,arefully assess s&ills <radually fade in more difficult tas&s Avoid esca"e oriented behaviors3 effort and demands should always be outweighed by easy res"onding Ma&e demands low at first3 deliver reinforcement much more often than you as& the child to "erform
The Assessment &' The Assessment &' Basic Language and Basic Language and Learning !/ills Learning !/ills The ABLL! The ABLL!
!tructure 7f A'LL! !tructure 7f A'LL! T h r e e C o m p o n e n t s A B L L S P r o t o c o l C r r ! c l m " S c o r ! n # R e c o r $ C h ! l $ S c o r e s S % ! l l s T r & c % ! n # S ' s t e m A B L L S ( ! $ e S c o r ! n # I n s t r c t ! o n s I E P D e ) e l o p m e n t ( ! $ e A n l * S c o r e s " E s t * P r ! o r ! t ! e s T e & c h ! n # L & n # & # e t o C h ! l $ r e n + ! t h A t ! s m V e r , & l B e h & ) ! o r - h & t " H o + t o T e & c h
Mason>s A'LL! Mason>s A'LL! o !"# o !"$ o !"% o !&' o !&( o !&) o !&* o !&" o !&& o !&+ o !&# o ,&# o -&# o !&$ o ,&$ o -&$ o !&% o ,&% o -&% o !+' o ,+' o -+' o !+( o ,+( o -+( o !+) o ,+) o -+) o !+* o ,+* o -+* o !+" o ,+" o -+" o !+& o ,+& o -+& o !++ o ,++ o -++ o !+# o ,+# o -+# o !+$ o ,+$ o -+$ o !+% o ,+% o -+% o !#' o ,#' o -#' o !#( o ,#( o -#( o !#) o .#) o ,#) o -#) o !#* o .#* o ,#* o -#* o !#" o .#" o ,#" o -#" o !#& o .#& o ,#& o -#& o !#+ o .#+ o ,#+ o -#+ o !## o .## o ,## o -## o B#$ o !#$ o .#$ o ,#$ o -#$ o B#% o !#% o .#% o ,#% o -#% o B$' o !$' o .$' o ,$' o -$' o B$( o !$( o .$( o ,$( o -$( o B$) o !$) o .$) o ,$) o -$) o B$* o !$* o .$* o ,$* o -$* o B$" o !$" o .$" o ,$" o -$" o B$& o !$& o .$& o ,$& o -$& o B$+ o !$+ o D$+ o .$+ o ,$+ o -$+ o B$# o !$# o D$# o .$# o ,$# o -$# o A$$ o B$$ o !$$ o D$$ o .$$ o ,$$ o -$$ o A$% o B$% o !$% o D$% o .$% o ,$% o -$% o A' o B' o !' o D' o /' o .' o ,' o -' o 0' o A( o B( o !( o D( o /( o .( o ,( o -( o 0( o A) o B) o !) o D) o /) o .) ,) o -) o 0) o A* o B* o !* o D* o /* o .* o ,* o -* o 0* o A" o B" o !" o D" o /" o ." o ," o -" o 0" o A& o B& o !& o D& o /& o .& o ,& o -& o 0& o A+ o B+ o !+ o D+ o /+ o .+ o ,+ o -+ o 0+ o A# o B# o !# o D# o /# o .# o ,# o -# o 0# o A$ o B$ o !$ o D$ o /$ o .$ o ,$ o -$ o 0$ Cooper&t!on " Re!nBorcers Jan 05 2005 .C.6C.116 Im!t&t!on Voc&l Im!t&t!on ReDests Recept!)e V!s&l PerBorm&nce L&n#&#e Intr&)er,&ls Spont&neos Voc&ls L&,el!n# Name: Mason DOB:
Eecommendations for Eecommendations for Mason 1%/%$/ Mason 1%/%$/ Matching 0dentical 7b.ects%)ictures 5(%+6 0ncrease -erbal 0mitation using Mand Lor& on (ill=ins with songs 'aseline Labels !et u" Mand !essions 526 1$=minute sessions%day Mee" demands low 5-E + or #6
Eecommendations for Mason Eecommendations for Mason 2%2/%$/ 2%2/%$/ )uBBles%easy toys 5sha"e sorter6 MatchingDstart categories ma&e sure he &nows tacts of eAem"lars )rom"t him to reCuest actions and missing items 'aseline labels 5buy flash cards6 MiA 4$8 easy to 2$8 hard w%-E + ,ontinue teaching songs )lay doh and coloring E((, to 1((, to 0((, with item as answer ,ount and Mand for access to tangibles
Lilly>s A'LL! Lilly>s A'LL!
A'LL!==Lucas A'LL!==Lucas
-' MA))==Lucas -' MA))==Lucas Key: Score Date Color Tester Child's name Lucas Barbera 1st test: 117.5 M. Barbera Date of birth 2nd test: 3rd test: LEVEL 3 Mand Listener VP/MTS Writing IV Group Ling. 15 14 13 12 11 LEVEL 2 Mand Tact Listener VP/MTS Imitation Echoic Play Social LRFFC IV Group/CR Ling. 10 9 8 7 6 LEVEL 1 Mand Tact Listener VP/MTS Imitation Echoic Play Social Vocal ` 5
Language 'arriers==Lucas Language 'arriers==Lucas Key Date Color Tester Child's name: Lucas Barbera 1st Asses. M. Barbera Date of birth: 2nd Asses. 3rd Asses. Inst. Control Behavior Prob. Defective Mand Defective Tact Defective Imit. Defective Echo Defective MTS / # + 2 1 1 2 + 1 2 + 1 2 + 1 2 + 1 2 + 1 2 + 1 2 + 1 2 + Defective List. Defective IV Prompt Dep. Generalization Scrolling Defective Scan Defective C D / # + 2 1 1 2 + 1 2 + 1 2 + 1 2 + 1 2 + 1 2 + 1 2 + Weak MOs RR Weakens MO Self-Stim Defective Artic. OCB Reinf. Depend. Attending / # + 2 1 1 2 + 1 2 + 1 2 + 1 2 + 1 2 + 1 2 + 1 2 + 08/2007 7/3/1996
Eecommendations for Lucas Eecommendations for Lucas 0ntensive teaching and K@1 sessions -E 1/ 5with 4$8 easy%2$8 hard6 1each "re"ositions%"ronouns 1each manding for attention%information @dmar& reading "rogram 1each coin and time identification Leisure and self care s&ills
1hirteen 0ntervention 1i"s 1hirteen 0ntervention 1i"s 1hirteen ti"s based on the science of A'A and '( !&inner>s analysis of -erbal 'ehavior that you can start using immediately with all children and adults with language delays and disorders
P 1 'e )ositive P 1 'e )ositive 1 'e )ositiveG ;se 4 "ositives for every negative *on>t overuse the child>s name es"ecially when saying 9no: or "lacing a demand
P2 )airing P2 )airing 2 9)air: yourself and the environment with reinforcement by giving the child lots of reinforcement with no effort reCuired
P + <iving *irections P + <iving *irections + Lhen giving a child a direction !im"lify the language Ma&e sure you are close enough and loud enough for him to hear <et down to child>s level to get child>s attention 7nly give directions you can ma&e the child do <ive the instruction only once and, if no res"onse, "rom"t the child to com"lete the tas& *on>t give the child a direction you>re not willing to follow through with
P# Eeinforcement P# Eeinforcement #Loo& for things that reinforce the child !et u" high interest activities3 bubbles, water "lay, balls, wind u" toys to see if any of these are motivators )ut these things out of reach so the child needs you to get them
P/ Mand 1raining P/ Mand 1raining / 1each the child to communicate his needs and wantsJfirst by "ulling, reachingJthen by using sign language, "ictures, or words 1each +=/ signs at a time
PV Matching PV Matching V 1each the child to match items and "ictures Label the item instead of using the command 9match: or 9"ut with same:
P 2 0mitation P 2 0mitation 2 1each imitation s&ills Lith ob.ects%toys <ross motorJ)ic& 2 or + movements to target at the same time )rovide as much "rom"ting as needed to ensure the child is successful
P 4 Eece"tive !&ills P 4 Eece"tive !&ills 4 1each rece"tive s&ills 1ouch body "arts, items or "icturesJ"ic& 2 or + rece"tive s&illsJ "rovide as much "rom"ting as needed to ensure the child is successful
P9 <ive *irections Fou ,an P9 <ive *irections Fou ,an )rom"t )rom"t 9 !ince you can>t force a child to s"ea&, do not use 9sayWWWWWW: if the child cannot s"ea& or if this is a hard s&ill 5!ay 9coo&ie, coo&ie, coo&ie: as you deliver a small "iece of coo&ie6
P 1$ 1each (ill=ins to !ongs P 1$ 1each (ill=ins to !ongs 1$ ;se music and familiar nursery rhymesJleave the last word of each line blan& to see if child fills it in
P 11 !abotage *aily Life P 11 !abotage *aily Life 11!abotage daily life to see if child notices%indicates%or reCuests3 <ive cu" without .uice ,ereal without s"oon ,oming u"stairs, do not turn off music !"ill mil&Jdon>t clean it u" immediately <o a different route in the mall
P 12 *o Kot Eeinforce )roblem P 12 *o Kot Eeinforce )roblem 'ehavior 'ehavior 12 *o not res"ond whining, &ic&ing, screaming and other negative behaviors
(or "roblem behavior related to access to attention%tangibles3 Lal& away, 0gnore, or use the ,ount and Mand "rocedure (or esca"e related "roblem behavior3 0gnore "roblem behavior and continue demand
P 1+ )revent and ,orrect P 1+ )revent and ,orrect @rrors throughout the dayG @rrors throughout the dayG 0nstructor3 )oints to an a""le and says Lhat is itI ,hild3 9bird: 0nstructor3 9Lhat is itDa""le: ,hild3 echoes 9a""le: 0nstructor3 Eight, what is itI ,hild3 9a""le: 0nstructor3 )resents 2=+ easy demands and then 9what is itI: ,hild3 9a""le:
!ome 1a&e ?ome )oints !ome 1a&e ?ome )oints for ;se Lith All ,hildren 5and Adults6 for ;se Lith All ,hildren 5and Adults6 )airing Manding 7nce the child can mand for items, ease in demands gradually )revent and ,orrect @rrors throughout the day *on>t reinforce "roblem behaviors