Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
on
Compressors
and
Compressed Air Systems
CONTENTS
Chapter
Page. No
About the Manual
II
III
10
IV
15
19
VI
21
VII
Accessories
28
VIII
33
41
Annexure
57
IX
CHAPTER I
Types of Air Compressors
Air compressors are mainly classified into two types, based on their construction and
operation.
! Positive displacement type
! Dynamic type
They are as described below in detail:
1.1
1.1.1
1.2
CHAPTER II
Sizing and Selection of Air Compressors
The selection of type of compressor and capacity to be installed is very critical. This
plays a major role in total compressor energy consumption during normal operation
in the plant.
2.1
Load factor plays a vital role in estimating the total compressed air requirement at the
design stage. Depending on the plant and the operating conditions appropriate load
factor has to be considered for intermittent air requirements while estimating the
total air requirement.
For establishing the load factor, it is highly desirable to utilize experiences with
similar plants. The load factor can be determined with the help of work-study.
Another source of information and guidance would be equipment suppliers and
compressor manufacturers.
2.2
Selection of compressors
For the selection of type of compressor the choices are many. This makes the
decision of the factory manager on the selection, tougher. He has to select the right
compressors for the manufacturing process, so as to be cost competitive. For this,
the emphasis should be on energy efficiency (life cycle cost analysis) and minimum
maintenance (high reliability).
Having calculated the total average capacity requirement, the factory manager can
select the type of compressors required, from the figure.
The chart has the capacity (calculated average air consumption) across the X axis and
pressure across the Y axis. Having known the pressure requirement and the average
air consumption, the type of compressor best suited can be selected from the given
curves. The graph is self-explanatory.
Annexure 2 gives a few examples on the various types of compressors and
capacities required, for various applications / industry. While selecting the
compressors, the following points should be kept in view:
a) As a first step, identify the base load and fluctuating load.
b) For base (Steady) loads: Select centrifugal compressors (best for very high
capacity) or screw compressors.
c) For fluctuating loads: Select screw compressor with built-in VFD (the best
option) or reciprocating compressors.
2.3
2.4
Velocities between 6 and 10 m/sec are usual in compressed air mains. This velocity
range is sufficiently low to prevent excessive pressure drops on most systems and
also will allow moisture to precipitate.
The volume airflow changes if any of the following changes.
! Operating pressure
! Temperature
! Both Pressure and Temperature
The law dealing with the expansion of air wherein pressure and temperature are
changing together is given below.
P1 V1 / T1
P2 V2 / T2
Where P1, V1 and T1 are the original pressure, volume and temperature and P2, V2
and T2 are the new pressure, Volume and Temperature respectively.
The following procedure can be adopted for estimating the size of a compressed air
line.
For an example
Quantity of compressed air flow
200 cfm
5.66 m3/min
Working pressure
Velocity limitation
Apply gas laws P1 V1 /T1
P2 V2
V2
=
=
P1 V1 / P2
5.66 m3/min x 1.013 kg/cm2
7.0 kg/cm2
0.819 m3/min
0.01365 m3/sec
=
=
Quantity of air flow
0.01365 m3/sec
Area of pipe line
/4 x D2
Diameter of pipeline
=
=
=
=
=
2.5
10
CHAPTER - III
Testing of Air Compressors
Over a period of time performance of the compressors and compressed air systems
get deteriorated. This could be due to various reasons such as poor maintenance,
wear & tear, use of poor quality lubricants etc.
The reduction in performance of air compressors leads to increase in overall power
consumption, installation of additional compressors and increase in cost of
compressed air. Hence a periodic check on the performance of compressors is
required to ensure rated compressed air delivery, operating efficiency and specific
power consumption.
The compressed air leakage level has to be periodically monitored. The increase in
leakage level leads to increased energy loss. The leakage level in the plant can be
monitored by carrying out leakage test. In this chapter the leakage test procedure is
discussed in detail.
3.1
Performance test
The following are determined by carrying out the performance test on the
compressors.
Free air delivery (FAD)
Free air delivery is the quantity of compressed air delivered by the compressor at
ambient pressure.
Volumetric efficiency
Volumetric efficiency is the ratio of the actual free air delivered to the compressor
swept volume.
Specific power consumption
Specific power consumption of the compressor is the ratio of actual power
consumption to the quantity of free air delivered.
After carrying out the performance test the actual performance of the compressor
has to be compared with the design values. Suitable measures could be taken to
improve the operating efficiency.
3.2
11
12
The nozzle used for the flow measurement has to be selected based on the installed
capacity of the compressor. As per IS standard IS 10431: 1994 the recommended
nozzle dimensions for flow measurement for various capacity of compressors is
given below.
Nozzle size
6
10
16
22
33
50
80
125
165
Capacity m3/hr
3-9
9-30
27-90
60-170
130-375
300-450
750-2000
1800-5500
3500-10000
The experiment can be carried out for different discharge pressure of compressors.
The discharge pressures can be 40%, 60%, 100% and 110% of normal operating
pressure of compressor.
Start the compressor and discharge the compressed air to the atmosphere through
the nozzle. It should be ensured that the pressure drop through the throttle valve
should be equal to or twice the pressure beyond throttle.
Once the system is stabilized and the pressure in the receiver is maintained constant
for a period of time the following measurements have to be carried out.
The quantity of free air delivered by the compressor can be calculated using the
following formula.
Free air delivered Qf =
Where
K
d
Ra
P1
T1
P2
T3
P3
S
P3 - P4 -
13
Volumetric efficiency
P2 - P1 X V Nm3/min
T
Patm
Where
P2
P1
Patm
V
T
While estimating the volume of compressed air storage the volume of after cooler,
volume of pipeline from the after cooler to the receiver should be included along
with receiver volume.
14
Also, since the compressed air temperature at discharge is higher than the ambient
temperature, the free air delivered has to be multiplied by the following correction
factor.
Correction factor
Tatm + 273
T1 + 273
Where
T1
Tatm
3.3
3.4
Load time
Load time + Unload time
% leakage
(of air compressor capacity)
Air leakage
Compressor capacity
x Capacity of
compressor
x 100
Orifice size
(mm)
0.8
1.6
3.1
6.4
Energy loss
(kW)
0.2
0.8
3.0
12.0
15
CHAPTER IV
Compressed Air Plant Layout and Distribution
The design of compressed air plant layout and distribution of compressed air plays a
significant role in the total energy consumption. While selecting the compressed air
layout and distribution, at the design stage itself it should be ensured that the
pressure drop in the system is very minimal, so that the minimum operating pressure
set point for the compressor can be maintained.
4.1
Plant Layout
Compressed air layout can be of two types such as centralized compressor system
and decentralized compressor system. Suitable compressed air system can be selected
based on the plant. Each system has its own advantages.
The location of the compressors, suction pipe work and discharge pipe work are vital
in configuring the plant layout.
16
The compressed air system exposed to extremely high temperatures can result in
higher specific power consumption, unscheduled shutdowns, increased maintenance
and decrease in lubricant life.
Ventilation is equally important for all compressors regardless of type of cooling.
It would be interesting to note that for every 4oC reduction in intake air
temperature there is 1% reduction in compressor power consumption.
At design stage, it is important to plan for proper ventilation and access to
compressor location. The locations exceeding temperature of 45oC should be
avoided. A free space of about 1 m around the compressor needs to be provided for
maintenance and 1 m for motor starter access panel.
Addressing the issue of ventilation at the design stage can help in increasing the life
of the compressor, Lubricating oil and the coolant.
The following points should be considered while locating the compressors.
!
!
!
!
17
! The air receiver should be located close to the air compressor and the pipe work
should be as short as possible.
! Safety valve should be fitted for positive displacement compressors Normally, it
is set to release when the line pressure exceeds the operating pressure by 5-10%.
4.2
4.2
18
Out of these four headers, loop header is the most desired and energy efficient layout
to minimum pressure drop. In some cases, where there is a minimal usage of
compressed air at farthest ends, a dedicated small capacity compressor can be
installed.
The following points should be considered for the distribution pipe work.
! The drainage points should be installed with the aid of equal Ts. Due to sudden
change in direction of flow these fittings assist the separation of water drops
from the air.
! The pipe work should fall in the direction of flow. The gradient can be kept at
approximately 1 in 100.
! Distribution branch connections should be taken from the top of the main to
reduce water entrainment in the air.
! Drain traps should be provided at all low points
! The drain traps should be protected from the ingress of foreign matter by
installing a strainer.
! The drain traps in the main line can be installed at every 30-40 m for effective
water removal.
! Install pressure gauges in various sections of the entire distribution system for
monitoring the pressure in different sections of the network
! The number of joints and bends in the distribution network should be minimum
possible. Further to minimising the joints, it should be ensured that joints are
welded, instead of flexible or screwed joints wherever possible. This facilitates in
minimizing the leakages and pressure drop.
19
CHAPTER - V
Compressor Cooling System
Cooling of air compressors merits tremendous improtants since it affects the energy
efficiency. Cooling systems could be either air cooled or water cooled :
a) Air cooled compressors: These compressors use fan for forced cooling of the
compressors. Due to the low cooling efficiency, this type of cooling is mostly used
for low capacity compressors having intermittent usage.
b) Water cooled compressors: For heavy duty or continuous applications water
cooling system is adopted, as the efficiency of cooling is high.
5.1
! Power consumption/CFM
(Typical 20 m head pump)
Soft, clean water is required for cooling the compressor cylinder jackets, intercooler
and after cooler. The temperature of cooling water should be as low as possible.
Lower the temperature of the cooling water better will be the volumetric efficiency.
Ultimately this will result in reduction in overall power consumption.
5.2
Cooling tower
Cooling tower is an area which merits due importance, since it also consumes power.
For compressors the cooling tower should be designed for heat duty specified by the
compressor manufacturer. To select a cooling tower the water flow rate, water inlet
temperature, water outlet temperature and ambient wet bulb temperatures must be
considered.
Confederation of Indian Industry
CII Sohrabji Godrej Green Business Centre
20
At design stage any margin on wet bulb temperature is not recommended. In some
cases it is useful to provide design margins on cold well temperature. The margin on
cold well temperature will result in increase in capital cost. It is usually not
economical to design a tower with approach below 3oC.
Film flow fills are utilized for compressor applications in case where clean water is
available. If the water quality is poor i.e suspended solids > 100 ppm splash fills may
be used.
Usually, the cooling tower fans operate continuously throughout the year. The load is
lower during nights and higher during day time. This fluctuation has to be kept in
view and a temperature indicator controller (TIC) has to be incorporated in cooling
tower fan. This temperature control should automatically cut off cooling tower fan at
30 o C and start the cooling tower fan at 32o C (Suggested temperatures are typically
desired temperatures).
21
CHAPTER VI
Compressed Air Dryers
6.1
6.2
Dew point at
atmospheric pressure
(oC)
0
-5
-10
-20
-30
-40
-60
-80
6.3
Moisture
content (PPM)
3800
2500
1600
685
234
80
6.5
0.3
22
When the air leaves the after cooler and passes through the compressed air lines, the
temperature of the compressed air further reduces. The remaining water vapour in
the air starts condensing.
The effects of water particles in the compressed air are given below.
! The water particles travel at the same velocity of compressed air and damages the
pneumatic valves or instruments at the user ends.
! Corrosion in the distribution pipe work
! Impaired finishing processes particularly in paint spraying
6.4
6.4.1
23
24
25
After getting filtered in the After-filter, air goes to process, which is dry to an
atmospheric dew point of -40o C. The heating cycle is normally for 2 1/2 hours
duration.
Cooling
26
Capital
cost
Running
cost
Dew
point oC
Pressure
drop
Best
suitable for
Max allowable
pressure drop
Kg / cm2
heatless
Low
High
-40
Medium
150 cfm
0.5
Desiccant
heated
blower
reactivated
type
High
Medium
-20 to 40oC
High
100-750 cfm
or decided
by dew point
0.5
Desiccant Heat
compression
High
Very low
-20 to 40oC
High
>1000 cfm
for
lubricated
compressor
0.5
Medium
Low
+3
Low
100 cfm
0.2 0.3
Desiccant
purge type
Refrigeration
dryer
of
type
27
6.6
28
CHAPTER VII
Accessories
Some of the accessories used in compressed air system are Drain traps,
compressed air filters, oil/water separators, Pressure regulators. These
accessories play a major role in maintaining the quality of compressed air, effective
utilisation and enhancing energy efficiency.
7.1
Drain valves
Condensate from compressed air is always detrimental to the life of pneumatic
equipments. This condensate should be removed as and when formed at various
stages.
Condensation formation takes place at after coolers, air receivers, filters, pipe lines,
drop legs etc. The effective removal of condensate will reduce the moisture load on
the air dryers and ensure the quality of air at the user ends.
Removal of condensate is done by automatic drain valve. In automatic drain valve
there is no need for manual intervention. The automatic drain valves can be classified
as follows:
a. Electronic timer based drain valves
b. Condensate sensing drain valves
a. Electronic timer based drain valve:
The drain valve is controlled by an electronic timer. The opening of drain valve is
based on the preset timings. The cycle time of the drain valve opening is
adjustable.
The cycle time can be set based on the condensate formation rate.
29
7.2
Filters
The compressed air treatment for ensuring the quality of compressed air is not only
limited to moisture removal. The other contaminants present in the compressed air
such as dust, oil, rust, Bacteria & Viruses etc will lead to detrimental effects.
Filters are used to remove the contaminants especially dust, oil and moisture. Some
of the filter media used is Ceramics, Sintered Bronze, Boro Silicate glass micro fibre
and activated carbon.
The contaminants and various ways & means of effective removal of those
contaminants are explained in detail below.
30
7.2.1 Solids
Solids, i.e., dust is found in compressed air depending on :
! Suction air quality
! Desiccant, activated carbon provided in dryers
! Pipeline rust and scale
It is preferable to remove dust to the extent required at the point of use. Filters
should have a low-pressure drop, as the energy loss across the filter is in the form of
pressure drop. A surface filter like pleated paper, ceramic or sintered bronze
filter can be used for dust removal. Pleated paper / cellulose are best suited,
as they offer very low-pressure drop and can handle high dust loads without
significant pressure drop. A pressure drop of 0.3 to 1.0 psi is allowable.
7.2.2 Oil
Oil from the compressor comes as vapour and liquid aerosol. The vapour cools and
becomes liquid in the line. For most industrial applications only the liquid oil need to
be removed and is done by a coalescing filter. Coalescers are depth filters and most
energy efficient. E.g. a wet 0.01 micron filters @ 99.999% efficiency has a pressure
drop of 6 psi, while a 0.01 micron filters @ 99.97% efficiency has a pressure drop of
3 psi only.
Hence it is recommended to install 99.97 % efficiency, 0.01 micron coalescing
filter for industrial applications.
7.2.3 Bacteria /Viruses
In food and pharmaceutical plants the intake air must be free from bacteria and
viruses. This can be achieved by heating the compressed air above 180oC then
cooling it to normal temperature. The compressed air can also be passed through
sterile filters, which capture bacteria of sizes 0.3 2.0 and viruses.
7.3
31
It is advisable to change the filters, when the pressure drop reaches 0.5 ksc. A standby filter can also be arranged to facilitate the changing of filters. Typically a filter
element should have a working life of 12 months or 6000 working hrs.
7.4
Separators
Moisture is found in liquid as well as in suspended form. Moisture in liquid form is
called as condensate and the moisture in suspended form is called as aerosol.
Aerosol is normally removed using water separators. The common types of water
separators are:
" Ceramic cartridge
" Baffle plate
" Demister pad type
The demister pad type is the most desired and energy efficient water separator, as it
is good in removing water droplets and has a lower pressure drop also.
7.5
Pressure Switches
The possibility of lowering the compressor delivery pressure settings should be
explored by a careful study of pressure requirements of various equipment and the
pressure drop in the line between compressed air generation and utilization points.
Confederation of Indian Industry
CII Sohrabji Godrej Green Business Centre
32
33
CHAPTER VIII
Energy Conservation Aspects in Compressed Air System
Energy conservation opportunities in air compressors and compressed air systems
are tremendous. Many of the energy savings ideas can be adopted either at the design
stage or during operation.
The energy saving potential in compressed air systems vary from 20 30%. The
following are some of the aspects to be considered :
8.1
34
For smaller capacity of compressors i.e < 100 cfm ON/OFF type compressors can
be selected instead of Load / Unload type compressors. In ON/OFF type, once the
required pressure is achieved the compressor is switched off. Hence there is no
unload power consumption.
In case of the belt driven reciprocating compressors the speed can be permanently
reduced by altering the pulley sizes to minimize the unload power consumption.
Precaution has to be taken that the speed reduction in reciprocating compressor does
not exceed 20% of the rated speed of the compressor. In reciprocating compressors
the lubricating oil pump is directly connected to the main drive. Hence any further
reduction in speed of the compressor may affect the lubrication system.
8.2
8.3
35
They are:
" Reduces the leakages proportionally, as the leakage levels are high at higher
pressures.
" Reduces the overall operating cost. Say a 20 % reduction in pressure results in
20% reduction in power consumption of the compressors. Moreover, the wear &
tear of the compressors are less at low pressures.
8.4
8.5
Install screw compressors with built-in variable frequency drives (VFD) for
fluctuating loads
Variable speed drives eg. (variable frequency drives) can be installed for all types of
air compressors. However, it is best suited for screw air compressors. The
advantages of installing VFD for screw air compressors are:
" All the compressors connected to a common system operate at a constant
pressure. The operating pressure will be lesser than the average operating
pressure of loading / unloading system. Hence, energy saving is achieved due to
pressure reduction.
" The compressors will not operate in load / unload mode. This saves the unload
power consumption.
" Air leakages in the compressed air system also come down since the average
operating pressure is less.
Generally, high capacity air compressors are operated with loading / unloading
control, as in the case of screw & reciprocating compressors and with inlet vane
control for centrifugal compressors.
36
37
If the pressure is simply reduced, that would result in negative impact on production
such as decrease in efficiency of production and quality related problems. Hence a
proper balancing of supply and demand is needed to satisfy the production without
creating an artificial demand. This can be achieved by installing an intermediate
controller between the compressor and the end users.
The intermediate controller creates a useful storage by introducing a controlled
differential pressure across an upstream receiver. This storage isolates the
compressor from demand side. Peaks are dealt with the reserve energy stored.
Thus by providing air at controlled differential at an optimum pressure, mass of air is
reduced and high pressure storage is created to increase the unload time of
compressors. The increase in unload time leads to reduction in overall energy
consumption of compressors.
8.7
38
" Initiate a system to replace the flexibles, rubber hoses, joints, packings, etc., in
regular intervals (Say once in 3 months).
" The compressors are to be provided with hour meters for measuring the loading
/ Unloading periods. The increase in the loading period for the same production
levels, indicates the increase in leakage levels.
" Normally, most of the engineering plants operate for two shifts only. However,
some units (eg.,heat treatment shops, etc.,) have to operate continuously in these
plants. In order to support this activity the whole compressed air system has to
function continuously. In such large size plants, having many individual work
shops and a centralized compressor house, individual shop-wise solenoid control
valves for compressed air lines have to be installed.
" The solenoid valve helps in cutting the compressed air supply to the individual
shop when there is no activity. This minimise the leakage loss and pressure drop
to a considerable level. Hence, it is recommended to install individual shop wise
solenoid control valves for the compressed air line at design itself, so as to
minimise the compressed air leakages during non-active periods.
The relation between hole size, quantity of compressed air leakage and power loss is
given below.
8.8
Hole Diameter
(mm)
1
3
5
10
0.06
0.6
1.6
6.3
39
40
8.10
Hither to, the electrical tools had some design problems like overweight, overheating,
frequent armature failures, etc,. Now these have been taken care of and new
generation of high frequency electrical tools is also available. So it is recommended
to consider electrical tools in place of pneumatic tools at design stage itself.
41
CHAPTER - IX
Case Studies on Energy Conservation in
Compressed Air Systems
Case study - 1
Optimally utilize the compressor depending upon the requirement
Background
In a textile industry a screw compressor 600 cfm capacity is in continuous operation.
Majority of compressed air users are pneumatic instruments, pneumatic valves and
actuators. In addition to the above-mentioned users, compressed air is also utilized to
remove the yarn whenever there is a yarn breakage.
During normal operation the quantity of compressed air requirement in the plant is about
100 cfm. Whenever there is a yarn breakage, there is a sudden increase in quantity of
compressed air requirement, which breakage is as high as 500-550 cfm.
Since the compressed air requirement during normal operating condition is much lower than
the installed capacity majority of time the compressor is getting unloaded. During
unloading there is no useful work done by the compressor. The unload power
consumption is used only to overcome the internal frictional losses.
Hence substantial energy saving can be achieved by minimizing / avoiding unloading of the
compressor.
42
Previous status
The operating parameters of the compressor during normal operating condition are as
below.
Table. Operating parameters
Loading time
%
Unloading time
%
Load power
kW
Unload power
kW
17
83
108
38
43
Case study 2
Replace old inefficient compressor with new efficient compressor
Background
Over a period of time the compressor operating efficiency comes down and the quantity of
free air delivered reduces due reasons such as poor maintenance, wear and tear etc.
If the operating efficiency of the compressor is low the specific power consumption
(kW/cfm) increases and hence the cost of compressed air goes up.
The quantity of free air delivered, operating efficiency and the specific power consumption
of the compressor can be determined by carrying out a performance test.
If the specific power consumption increases by 25 - 30 % as compared to a new efficient
compressor, it makes economic sense to replace the compressor with new efficient
compressor.
Previous status
In one of the cement industry a reciprocating compressor of capacity (Free air delivered)
34.32 m3/min was in operation. The normal operating pressure is 6.0 kg/cm2.
Performance test was carried out and results are as follows:
" Actual free air delivered
" Specific power consumption
26.08 m3/min
6.82 kW/m3/min
The specific power consumption was observed to be very high. Typically for reciprocating
compressor the specific power consumption at an operating pressure of 6 kg/cm2 would be
about 5.5 kW/m3/min.
Energy saving project
The existing old inefficient compressor was replaced with energy efficient compressor of the
same capacity.
Implementation methodology and time frame
The plant team did not face any major problem during implementation of the above project.
The project was implemented in two weeks.
The performance of the compressor has to be monitored by carrying out performance test
atleast once in 6 months. Any increase in specific power consumption is an indication of
inefficient operation.
The reason for increase in power consumption should be identified and attended during
regular maintenance.
44
Benefits
There was a significant reduction in specific power consumption and hence the cost of
compressed air.
Reduction in specific power consumption -
1.2 kW/m3/min.
Financial Analysis
The annual energy saving achieved was Rs 6.28 Lakhs. This required an investment of
Rs 6.00 Lakhs, which was paid back in 12 Months.
45
Case study 3
Segregate high pressure and low pressure compressed air users
Background
The compressed air pressure requirement varies depending upon the process requirement.
The operating pressure of the compressor is set in such a way that the maximum pressure
requirement in the plant can be met. For other low pressure applications air regulators are
used to reduce the compressed air pressure at user ends.
Use of compressed air regulators is an inefficient practice. The pressure loss across the air
regulator leads to energy loss.
In compressors, the power consumption is proportional to the operating pressure.
The loading power consumption reduces with reduction in operating pressure and vice
versa.
Hence energy saving can be achieved by segregating high pressure and low pressure
compressed air users and compressors can be dedicated for low pressure applications
supplying compressed air at lower pressure matching with the requirement.
Present status
In one of the process industry 5 Nos of reciprocating compressors of 2700 m3/hr capacity
each are available for compressed air generation. Three compressors are in continuous
operation. The total quantity of compressed air supply at a pressure of
6.5 kg/cm2 is about 7000 m3/hr.
Compressed air is utilized for both instrumentation applications and in interlacers. The
maximum compressed air pressure and quantity requirement for both the users are given
below.
Quantity
Area
Pressure
m3/hr
kg/cm2
Instrumentation
6.0
2600
Interlacers
4.0
4400
For the interlacers air regulators are installed at the user ends and the compressed air
pressure is reduced from 6.0 kg/cm2 to 4.0 kg/cm2.
The pressure loss across the air regulator is about 33%.
Energy saving project
The following measures were taken up for energy saving.
" The low pressure (interlacers) and the high-pressure users (instrumentation) were
segregated.
46
" The existing line was utilized for the high-pressure compressed air supply and separate
compressed air line was laid for the low-pressure applications.
" Two compressors were dedicated for low-pressure compressed air supply and operated
at a pressure of 4.5 kg/cm2. The air regulators at the user end were kept fully opened.
Implementation methodology and time frame
Identification of low pressure compressed air users was easier. The existing compressed air
line was utilized for high pressure compressed air supply and a separate compressed air line
was laid for the low pressure applications.
Only after the compressed air lines were in place, two compressors were connected to the
low pressure lines and operated at lower pressure. The process was not disturbed during the
implementation of the project.
The implementation of project was completed in 4 months.
Cost benefit analysis
The annual energy saving achieved was Rs 31.86 Lakhs. This required an investment of
Rs 8.25 Lakhs for dedicated compressed air line, which was paid back in 4 Months.
47
Case study 4
Install variable frequency drive for the screw compressor with feed back control
Background
The compressors go on unload mode if the installed capacity is more than the compressed
air requirement. During unloading, there is no useful work done, the power consumption is
used to overcome only the internal frictional losses.
In screw compressors the unload power consumption can be eliminated by installing
variable frequency drive with feed back control. The pressure sensor provided at the
discharge side of the compressor continuously senses the pressure and gives signal to the
variable frequency drive.
The variable frequency drive varies the speed of the compressor to maintain the same set
pressure. The unload power consumption of the compressor can be totally eliminated.
48
The compressor was getting loaded at 6.0 kg/cm2 and unloaded at 7.0 kg/cm2. An average
operating pressure of 6.5 kg/cm2 was maintained.
The unloading percentage of the compressor was about 50% of the operating time. The
unloading power consumption of the screw compressor was about 27 kW.
Energy saving project
The following energy conservation measures were taken up.
The screw compressor, which was getting loaded and unloaded was installed with variable
frequency drive with feed back control. The unloading power consumption of the screw
compressor was totally eliminated.
The operating pressure of the compressors was precisely set at 6.0 kg/cm2. Since the overall
system pressure is reduced and reduction in power consumption is achieved in all the
compressors.
Implementation methodology and time frame
When a battery of compressors is in operation and connected to a common receiver,
installation of variable frequency drive for one screw compressor is sufficient. This will take
care of the fluctuation in compressed air requirement of the entire system.
For standby compressors, the VFD can be installed with change over contactors, so that
whenever change of compressor is required the VFD control can be changed to the
compressor in operation.
The plant team did not face any major problem during implementation. The VFD was
installed with feed back control with a day time.
Cost benefit analysis
The annual energy saving achieved was Rs 10.83 Lakhs. This required an investment of
Rs 12.00 Lakhs for installation of variable frequency drive with feed back control, which
was paid back in 14 Months.
49
Case study 5
Install intermediate controller and minimize the pressure fluctuation in the
compressed air system
Background
The quantity of compressed air requirement varies depending upon the users. The variation
in quantity is substantial due to sudden requirement in the intermittent users. This leads to
fluctuation in overall system pressure and compressor air requirement.
The system operates for artificial demand and not for the real demand. The compressor
must be always ready to satisfy these peaks in their anticipation.
A proper balancing of supply and demand is needed to satisfy the production without
creating an artificial demand. This can be achieved by installing an intermediate controller
between the compressor and the end users.
The intermediate controller creates a useful storage by introducing a controlled differential
pressure across an upstream receiver. This storage isolates the compressor from demand
side. Peaks are dealt with the reserve energy stored.
Thus by providing air at controlled differential at an optimum pressure, mass of air is
reduced and high pressure storage is created to increase the unload time of compressors.
The increase in unload time leads to reduction in overall energy consumption of
compressors.
Previous status
In one of the textile mills two numbers of compressors of capacity 200 cfm were in
operation.
The operating pressure fluctuation was monitored over a period of time. The variation in
the pressure fluctuation was about +/- 7 psi.
The total energy consumption per day was about 1579 kWh.
50
variation
in
the
compressed
air
system
is
maintained
at
The energy consumption per day is reduced from 1579 kWh to 1325 kWh.
Implementation methodology and time frame
Installation of intermediate controller requires an additional receiver for the compressed air
storage.
The plant team did not face any problem during implementation of the intermediate
controller. The project was completed in two days time.
Cost benefit analysis
The annual energy saving achieved was Rs 3.27 Lakhs. This required an investment of
Rs 3.00 Lakhs for the total project, which got paid back in 11 Months.
51
Case study 6
Replace compressed air with blower air for agitation in Effluent Treatment Plant
(ETP)
Background
In effluent treatment plant, generally the agitation is carried out by supplying compressed
air. The compressed air is tapped from the main header at normal operating pressure of
5.0-6.0 kg/cm2.
For agitation, only the volume of air flow is the criteria not the pressure. The maximum
pressure requirement is not more than 0.5 kg/cm2. The effective agitation can be achieved
by using blower air.
The comparison between the specific power consumption of compressed air and blower air
is given below.
! Compressed air
! Blower air
16 kW/100 cfm
2 - 4 kW/100 cfm
Hence significant energy saving can be achieved by replacing compressed air with blower air
for agitation applications.
Previous status
In one of the engineering industry compressed air is utilized for the agitation application.
The compressed air is taken from the main header, which is at a pressure of 5.5 kg/cm2. A
control valve is utilized for controlling the pressure and supply compressed air to match
with the requirement.
The quantity of compressed air utilized for agitation application is about 50 cfm.
52
50 cfm
0.5 kg/cm2
Compressed air was replaced with blower air for agitation applications.
Implementation methodology and time frame
The plant team did not face any major problem for implementing the project. The project
was implemented in two days.
Cost benefit analysis
The annual energy saving achieved was Rs 1.26 Lakhs. This required an investment of
Rs 0.50 Lakhs for installation of positive displacement blower, which got paid back in
5 Months.
53
Case study 7
Install Transvector nozzles for cleaning applications
Background
Use of compressed air for cleaning applications is normally practiced air in any industry. In
engineering, foundry and textile industries majority of compressed is used for cleaning
application alone.
For cleaning applications only the volume of airflow is the criteria not the operating
pressure. The cleaning can be effectively achieved with maximum pressure of
3-3.5 kg/cm2.
The latest trend is utilizing transvector nozzles for cleaning applications. The transvector
nozzle is working based on the venturi principle. The nozzle has holes at periphery. When
compressed air at higher pressure passes through the nozzle, it sucks in atmospheric air
through the holes at the periphery. Air at a pressure of 3.0-3.5 kg/cm2 is supplied for the
cleaning application, which is sufficient.
In this system, atleast 30-40% of the compressed air is replaced with atmospheric air. Hence
the over all compressed air consumption reduces.
Previous status
In one of the engineering industry there were about 25 compressed air cleaning points
available. Compressed air at a pressure of 6.0 kg/cm2 was utilized for the cleaning
applications. The quantity of compressed air utilized for the cleaning application alone was
in the range of 125-150 cfm.
Energy saving project
Transvector nozzles have been installed in all the cleaning points. Air at a pressure of
3.5 kg/cm2 is utilized for the cleaning applications.
This has resulted in reduction in compressed air usage of about 50 cfm.
Implementation methodology and time frame
Awareness among the operators needs to be created about the effective use of compressed
air.
The plant team did not face any problem in implementing the projects. The project was
implemented in two days time.
In case of larger industry the project can be taken up in phases.
Cost benefit analysis
The annual energy saving achieved was Rs 1.30 Lakhs. This required an investment of
Rs 0.50 Lakhs for installation of Transvector nozzles, which got paid back in 5 Months.
54
Case study 8
Utilize electrical tools in place of pneumatic operated tools
Background
Use of pneumatic tools is quiet common in engineering industry. Pneumatic tools require
compressed air at a pressure of 5.5 6.0 kg/cm2. When compressed air is utilized for
pneumatic applications, from compressed air generation to end-use many energy
transformations take place. i.e (electrical energy to compressed air and then compressed air
to mechanical energy)
In each stage of energy transformation, due to inefficiency of individual equipment certain
amount energy is lost. This can be eliminated if electrical energy is directly utilized for
producing mechanical work.
The theoretical estimation reveals that use of compressed air is about 25% costlier than
direct use of electrical energy for producing mechanical work.
Previous status
In one of the engineering industry about 40 pneumatic grinders were utilized for the
grinding application.
Compressed air at a pressure of 6.0 kg/cm2 was being utilized for the pneumatic grinders.
Energy saving project
All the 40 numbers of pneumatic grinders are replaced with the electrical grinders.
This has resulted in substantial energy savings.
Implementation methodology and time frame
While utilizing the electrical equipment for the grinding applications, the safety aspects have
to be taken into consideration.
The project can be taken up in a phased manner for large installations.
The plant team did not face problem in implementing the project. The project was
implemented in a phased manner in two months time.
Cost benefit analysis
The annual energy saving achieved was Rs 6.50 Lakhs. This required an investment of
Rs 11.00 Lakhs for procuring electrical grinders, which got paid back in 21 Months.
55
Case study 9
Replace desiccant heater dryer with Heat of compression type dryer
In conventional desiccant dryers electrical heaters are utilized for heating the desiccant. In
addition to the electrical heating, compressed air is utilized for purging and removal of
moisture from the desiccant. Due to these two, a significant amount of energy is wasted.
Heat of compression dryer is a break-through in drying technology where the operating cost
is zero or very minimal. Compressed air, directly from compressor discharge, which is at a
temperature of 135 o C (in the case of reciprocating compressor), is used to regenerate the
desiccant. There are no electrical heaters and no purging loss. This makes the dryer very
attractive in terms of operating cost.
The desiccant can be Activated Alumina or Silica gel depending on the dew point required.
HOC dryers are available from 400 cfm to 5000 cfm capacity.
Previous status
A process industry had an Adsorption type, heater reactivated dryer of capacity 50 M 3 /min.
The heater capacity for reactivation was about 32 kW. This apart, the dryer had a purge loss
of about 10 %.
Energy saving project
The plant team has replaced the heater reactivated adsorption type dryer with heat of
compression type dryer.
Use of electrical heater has been avoided and there is no compressed air purge loss.
56
57
Annexure - 1
Approximate air consumption of pneumatic machine tools
Free Air
Consumption at
6.0 0.5 bars
(m3/min)
Description of
Pneumatic Machine
0.65
0.30 to 0.65
0.35 to 0.80
0.7
Description of Pneumatic
Machine
Core Blower
Moulding Machine
Sand Blast (Shot)
0.75
Sander
0.3
8 mm jet
3 @ 4.2 bars
9 mm jet
11 mm jet
62 mm
1.35
13 mm jet
7 @ 4.2 bars
62 to 100 mm
1.65
Blow Gun
0.5
0.0035 per
operation
62 mm
1.35
75 mm
1.65
100 mm
1.9
Air Host
Light (upto 2 kg)
Scaling Hammer
2.5
Valveless,
work
5.8
Chipping Hammer
for
surface
0.2
0.6
Grinders
0.35 to 0.50
13 to 20 mm dia wheels
0.25
0.50 to 0.70
0.75
0.75 to 1.00
1.3
0.68 to 0.73
1.5
Angle
grinder
polishers
0.75
Riveting Hammer
20 to 25 mm hot rivets
31 mm hot rivets
0.82
34 mm hot rivets
and
58
Free Air
Consumption at
6.0 0.5 bars
(m3/min)
0.37
0.45 to 0.60
0.75 to 0.90
1.00 to 1.20
1.30 to 1.75
1.50 to 1.60
1.65 to 1.80
1.80 to 2.40
Description of Pneumatic
Machine
Free Air
Consumption at 6.0
0.5 bars (m3/min)
Drill Sharpener
Small
Large
Forging Hammer (Power)
50 Kg
150 Kg
250 kg
500 kg
1000 kg
1.5
3.6
1.8
3.9
5.7
9.6
16
Concrete Breaker
7 mm nuts
0.15 to 0.25
35 to 40 kg weight
9 mm nuts
0.45 to 0.50
25 kg weight
1.35
13 to 25 mm nuts
0.75 to 1.00
15 kg weight
0.9
22 to 25 mm nuts
1.00 to 1.20
Pile driver
1.8
Spike Driver
1.8
0.6
32 mm
1.1
1.65 to 2.20
0.17
Carving
Wrench, Tapping
0.45
Medium dressing
0.3
0.6
0.4
0.9
Considerable
variation according
to prevailing
conditions
0.1
1.50 to 3.60
0.007 per operation
Air Motors
Small
Medium
Upto 1 kw
Over 5 kw
1.00 per KW
Air Cylinder
Cement Gun
4.8
Grouting Machine
59
60
Annexure - 2
Compressors recommended: segment / application wise
S.
No
Industry
Application of
compressed air
Capacity
requirement
Recommend compressor
type
Workshop / Auto
Garage
30 CFM
Construction, Mines,
Borewell, Borewell,
Rings, Quarry &
Tunnel
Pneumatic tools,
Moulding M/c. Spray,
Painting & Cleaning
Large Engineering,
Forging & Foundries
Pneumatic Tools,
Moulding M/c. Spray,
Painting & Cleaning
2. Screw compressor
2. Screw compressor
*Oil free preferred
Spinning M/c.
Autoconer & Splicers
100 CFM
Spinning M/c.
Sutoconer & Splicers
Instruments, Conveying
& Agitators
Gas separation
61
S.
No
Industry
Application of
compressed air
Capacity
requirement
Recommend compressor
type
10
Sugar
300 CFM
Cement
2000 CFM
11
Root blowers
Two stage
Reciprocating Compressors
12
Glass
Furnace combustion
instruments
1500 CFM
13
Food processing
14
1000 CFM