Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
11-Mar-13
Group: 8A
We certified that the attached assignment/report is our own work and that all materials
drawn from other sources have been fully acknowledged.
MKT4855
Section:
403
Group Name
8A
Group Topic/Client
Please confirm that your report meets the following requirements (by ticking each box) before
submission:
The declaration below has been read, signed, and dated
The report is originally made and has not been submitted previously in other course units
Academic Honesty
All forms of plagiarism and unauthorized collusion are regarded as serious offense by the
university and could result in penalties including failure and possible disciplinary action. If in
doubt as to the authenticity and legitimacy of the report, immediate consultation with the course
lecturer is therein recommended.
Declaration
We have read and understood the information stated in Academic Honesty. We hereby accept and
acknowledge that this report is our own work, has been expressed in our words and has not been
previously submitted to other course units either as assignment or as project paper.
Student I.D. #
Signature
5110588
Chayakarn Ruangsangrob
Date
11/03/2013
5115733
Saharat Pholcharoen
11/03/2013
5213942
Nannapat Akkarawattanakul
11/03/2013
5238360
11/03/2013
5238371
11/03/2013
5238377
Khanh Ly Mai
11/03/2013
5245115
Panjaphol Moovoravit
11/03/2013
5313484
Sananporn Punyaratpukdee
11/03/2013
Group profile
Group Name: 8A
Ferm
Name:
ID:
Email:
Major:
Chayakarn Ruangsangrob
5110588
Mobile no.
:
086-653-4040
funny1910@hotmail.com
Marketing
Minor:
Boy
Name:
Saharat Pholcharoen
ID:
5115733
Email:
stitch_spirit127@hotmail.com
Major:
Marketing
Mobile no.
:
081-186-6650
Minor:
Boat
Name:
Nannapat Akkarawattanakul
ID:
5213942
Email:
aknnp12@hotmail.com
Major:
Marketing
Mobile no.
:
081-987-8558
Minor:
ii
Tea
Name:
ID:
5238360
Email:
vo.quynhthy@yahoo.com
Major:
Marketing
Mobile no.
:
083-545-3848
Minor: BIS
Thao
Name:
ID:
5238371
Email:
thuthao.ngtt@gmail.com
Major:
Marketing
Mobile no.
:
082-325-1490
Minor: FIN
Kelly
Name:
Khanh Ly Mai
ID:
5238377
Email:
maily0601@gmail.com
Major:
Marketing
Mobile no.
:
083-198-9212
Minor: HTM
iii
Warm
Name:
Panjaphol Moovoravit
ID:
5245115
Email:
Major:
Mobile no.
:
085-366-7303
henry_warm14@hotmail.com
Marketing
Minor:
Somm
Name:
Sananporn Punyaratpukdee
ID:
5313484
Email:
sommsp@gmail.com
Major:
Marketing
Mobile no.
:
084-614-5164
Minor:
iv
Table of Content
Contents
2. SAMPLE PROFILE...................................................................................................................................... 34
3. DATA ANALYSIS AND RESULTS ................................................................................................................ 36
a. Factor Analysis ................................................................................................................................... 36
b. Kano Model ........................................................................................................................................ 42
c. MLR with Mediator ............................................................................................................................. 44
d. One Sample T-test ............................................................................................................................... 51
e. Independent T-test ............................................................................................................................... 53
f. One way ANOVA ................................................................................................................................. 59
g. Chi-square .......................................................................................................................................... 69
vi
Chapter 1: Introduction
1. Background of the Study
Data from the present study is derived from questionnaire and consisted of video
and voice record. The primary data are from True website and secondary data from rerecording the information from telecommunication user such as True, Dtac, and AIS.
This comprehensive information of True Corporation provides the in-depth
strategic analysis of the company's businesses and operations. The information has been
compiled by Global Data to bring to clear and an unbiased view of the company's key
strengths and weaknesses and the potential opportunities and threats. The research helps to
formulate strategies that augment the business by enabling to understand the partners,
customers and competitors better.
2. Research Problems
a. Management Decision Problems
As we, analysis the secondary data of True Move, we can see that True Move has
the lowest market share in Thailand with approximately 25% (data in March 2012)1.
Therefore, the biggest management decision problem is how to gain more market share
from the market leader (AIS) and market challenger which is DTAC. Increasing market
share will also help to solve the problems of customer satisfaction. True Move H+ has the
weakness in customer loyalty because the unstable signal the smaller area coverage of
signal compare to other competitors. In addition, the share of voice (brands advertising
weight expressed as percentage of total market (or segment) in given time) of TrueMove is
just 17.8%2 compared with 35.6% of AIS and 45.6% of DTAC. So, in order to increase
the customer satisfaction as well as customer loyalty, the management decision problem
is should the Integrated Marketing Communication campaign and the service quality be
changed?
b. Marketing Research Problems
For this current situation of True Move and telecommunication industry in
Thailand, some key variables are used to determine marketing research problems. From
the analysis of secondary data, even though the market share of True Move is low, but
TrueMove has some significant competitive advantage in order to enhance the brand
1
2
http://telenor.com/investor-relations/company-facts/business-description/dtac-thailand/
http://www.adassothai.com/index.php/main/ad_expenditure
image as well as customer satisfaction. True Move has the advantage in the technology of
high speed internet on mobile phone. True is the leader of high speed internet. In order
to gain more market share as mention in management decision problem above, True Move
has to distinguish themselves among the competitors to attract more users. Moreover,
taking the advantage of industry growth rate is high, True Move has to determine the
effectiveness of IMC campaign and the important of service quality, therefore, can help
to attract the new users, especially by extend the target audiences. Lastly, it has to focus on
the factors that influence the customer satisfaction about True Move. It is required the
understanding on what are the preferences and purchase intentions of the actual users,
using strengths to grab the opportunities, avoid the threats and reduces its own weaknesses.
3. Research Objectives
To identify the relationship between customer satisfaction and repurchase intention
To understand customers repurchase intention
To understand the effect of customer loyalty to repurchase intention
To understand the important of customer repurchase intention
To study customer satisfaction and customer loyalty in order to increase sale.
To understand customers wants and needs.
To determine specific factors of SERVQUAL dimension that lead to customer
satisfaction.
4. Research Questions
Secondary data analysis
1.
2.
Who are the customers (the past, current and potential customers)?
3.
4.
6.
7.
intention?
8.
expectations)?
9.
What are the factors that customers use to evaluate the service (product
What are the impacts that the promotion programs have on True customers?
11.
Which kind/ type of True move promotion program will have the most
different brand?
13.
14.
What are the criteria of good product quality for customer to choose their
service provider?
15.
16.
17.
http://www.jtaer.com/aug2011/wong_hideki_george_p2.pdf
The two dimensional IPA model is divided into four quadrants with performance
on the x-axis and importance on the y-axis. Because of this, four quadrants namely
Concentrate Here, Keep up the Good Work, Low Priority, and Possible Overkill is created.
The quadrants can be used to generate suggestions for organization by differentiating
between them.
time to talk with company and company will call back later. Many customers feel annoyed
and disturbed. If company offer new service or promotion, company can use other
distribution channel such as advertisement.
http://archive.lib.cmu.ac.th/full/T/2552/mba0952rk_ch2.pdf
http://www.kanomodel.com/tutorial.html
1. BASIC (threshold)
Threshold (or basic) attributes are the expected attributes or must of a product,
and do not provide an opportunity for product differentiation. Increasing the performance
of these attributes provides diminishing returns in terms of customer satisfaction, however
the absence or poor performance of these attributes will results in customer dissatisfaction.
In the case of TRUE the basic product that the customer are expected to get are that they
are able to call and talk to people.
2. PERFORMANCE
Performance attributes are those for which more is generally better, and will
improve customer satisfaction. On the other hand, an absent or weak performance attribute
reduces customer satisfaction. Of the needs customers verbalize, most will fall into the
category of performance attributes. These attributes will form weighted needs against
which product concepts will be evaluated. The price for which customer is willing to pay
for a product is closely tied to this attributes. In the Case of TRUE, customers would be
willing to pay more to use their services if they can provide the customers a better signal.
3. EXCITEMENT
Excitement attributes are unspoken and unexpected by customers but can result in
high level of customer satisfaction, however their absence does not lead to dissatisfaction.
Excitement attributes often satisfy real needs of which customer are currently unaware. In
7
the case of TRUE and its telecommunication business competitor their products provide
similar performance, providing excitement attributes that address unknown needs can
provide a competitive advantage.
http://www.satisfactionstrategies.com/paper1.pdf
http://usatoday30.usatoday.com/money/smallbusiness/columnist/abrams/2006-04-14-creatingloyalty_x.htm?csp=34
6
Ruby Roy Dholakia, Miao Zhao, (2010) "Effects of online store attributes on customer
satisfaction and repurchase intentions", International Journal of Retail & Distribution Management,
Vol. 38 Iss: 7, pp.482 - 496
7
http://www.utexas.edu/research/cswr/survey/cssymposium/cspaper.pdf
company to create high degree of satisfaction is crucial for product differentiation and
developing strong relationship with customers. Customer satisfaction with the company
can make the customers become more loyal to True more than others telecommunication
service provider. Satisfaction of the customers with the company can help the brands to
build long and profitable relationships with its customers. Any business is likely to lose
market share, customers and investors if it fails to satisfy customers as effectively and
efficiently as its competitors is doing.
Intangibles, empathy, reliability, and responsiveness and assurance8
These five dimensions are come from SERVQUAL model or service quality.
Service quality has become a significant research topic in marketing in recent years.
SERVQUAL is presented a multidimensional construct. According to Parasuraman et al.
(1985), there are 10 dimensions of SERVQUAL, which are reliability, responsiveness,
competence,
access,
courtesy,
communication,
credibility,
security,
Sureshchandar, G., & Rajendran, C. A. (2002). The Relationship Between Service Quality and
Customer Satisfaction: A Factor Specific Approach. Journal of Services Marketing , 16 (4), 363379.
9
http://webdb.ucs.ed.ac.uk/operations/honsqm/articles/ServqualButtle.pdf
10
http://usatoday30.usatoday.com/money/smallbusiness/columnist/abrams/2006-04-14-creatingloyalty_x.htm?csp=34
more than that of maintaining a relationship with existing ones. Increased customer loyalty
is probably the one marketing goal with the most potential to improve profits. Although
frequent guests typically only account for about 15% of a businesss customer base, they
are usually providing at least 1/3 of the revenue. Business is all about relationships. Selling
has a lot to do with not just understanding the product but more importantly understanding
the needs of the customers. Identify what it is the customer are looking for and if they have
a need that company can fill and do the best it can to fill that need if possible with the
product. If the company can create positive customer experiences and relationships, it will
create customer loyalty, which in turn will create greater profits.
Price11
Price is the amount of money charged for a product or service, or the sum of the
values that customers exchange for the benefits of having or using the product or service.
Price fairness refers to consumers assessments of whether a sellers price is reasonable,
acceptable or justifiable or not. Price fairness is a very important issue that leads toward
satisfaction. Charging fair price helps to develop customer satisfaction and loyalty.
Customers decision to accept particular price has a direct bearing at satisfaction level and
loyalty. Customer satisfaction is directly influenced by price perceptions while indirectly
through the perception of price fairness. The price fairness itself and the way it is fixed and
offered have a great impact on satisfaction.
Promotion effectiveness12
Promotion is one media that the company can use to treat their customer and
increase the brand image as well as brand loyalty. However, if the company does not have
the effective promotion, it will go the other way around. The bad image will be created.
Therefore, in order to gain the benefit from promotion method, the company should have
careful promotion plan. For this research, we are using Promotion effectiveness method in
order to test the influence of it in customer satisfaction and repurchase intention.
11
12
In-depth Interview
In-depth Interview
10
2. Conceptual Model
A research framework defines the categories of outputs that research can produce.
It also defines a set of different research activities. Moreover, it defines what kind of
research activities (detailed the procedures necessary) can be used to produce specific
outputs and solve marketing research problem.
It starts with a problem that we have determined before; which is True Move has some
significant competitive advantage in order to enhance the brand image as well as customer
satisfaction. In addition, taking the advantage of industry growth rate is high; True Move
has to determine the effectiveness of IMC campaign.
The purpose of our research framework is to discover answers to research question (Chap
1) through the application of scientific procedures. Then, find out the truth which is hidden
and which has not been discovered yet.
In the conceptual framework, we assume with supported report that the independent
variables, which are Product Tangibility, Pricing Packaging, Promotion Effectiveness,
Reliability, Responsiveness, Assurance and Empathy, have effect directly on Customer
Satisfaction as well as have indirect effect on Repurchase Intention, Customer Loyalty,
which leads to build Repurchase Intention, is influenced by Customer Satisfaction.
Variables:
11
H1
Product
Tangibility
H2
H3
Loyalty
Pricing
H8
Package
H9
Promotion
H10
Effectivenes
H4
Customer
H15-21
H22
Repurchase
Customer
H11
Satisfaction
H23
Intention
H12
Reliability
H5
Responsiveness
H6
H13
H6
Assurance
H14
H7
Empathy
3. Hypothesis
1. Product Tangibility and Customer Satisfaction
The quality of tangible products is usually a straight-forward determination; for
customers, making a comparison between physical products is a matter of feature-tofeature analysis.13
Tangibility is the most important factor in determining customer satisfaction14
H8: Product tangibility has the relationship with customer satisfaction.
13
http://www.technovationentrepreneur.com/2010/07/customer-satisfaction-perception-of-productand-service-quality/
14
Ailin Sriyam.(2010).Customers Satisfaction towards Service Quality of Front Office Staff at the
hotel. Masters Project, M.A. Bangkok: Graduate School, Srinakharinwirot University.
12
15
Eugene W. Anderson. National Quality Research Center, School of Business Admistration, The
University of Michigan, Ann Arbor, Michigan 48109-1234
16
In-depth Interview
17
John L. Triplett, Oliver H.M. Yau, Cathy Neal, (1994), Assessing the Reliability and Validity
of SERVQUAL in a Longitudinal Study: The Experience of an Australian Organisation, Asia
Pacific Journal of Marketing and Logistics, Vol.6 Iss: 1 pp. 41 62.
18
Fujun Lai, Joe Hutchinson, Dahui Li, ChanghongBai, (2007), An empirical assessment and
application of SERVQUAL in mainland Chinas mobile communications industry, International
Journal of Quality & Reliability Management, Vol.24 Iss: 3 pp. 244 262.
13
19
20
14
25
http://www.tmcnet.com/channels/customer-experience-management/articles/
Roger Hallowells seminal 1996 Harvard Business School study.
http://www.business2community.com/loyalty-marketing/customer-satisfaction-and-customerloyalty-it%E2%80%99s-like-%E2%80%9Clike-vs-love%E2%80%9D-070774
27
Online business Advisor article http://www.onlinebusadv.com/?PAGE=158
28
Faculty of Tourism and Archeology, King Saud University
26
15
Aaker and Keller (1990) mentioned that a brand with high awareness and good image
can promote brand loyalty to consumers, and the higher the brand awareness is, the higher
brand trust and purchase intention are to consumers.29
Customers may also be loyal because they are satisfied with the brand, and thus
want to continue the relationship (Fornell, 1992).30
H22: Customer loyalty can influence repurchasing intension. (Simple Regression)
29
Department of Business Management, Science and Research Branch, Islamic Azad University,
Tehran, Iran, 2012
30
Published by Canadian Center of Science and Education
31
World Appl. Sci. J., 12 (Special Issue of Tourism & Hospitality): 35-43, 2011
32
School of Business Administration (DBA), University of South Australia, Australia article.
16
Exploratory Research
Exploratory research helps determine the data collection method and often relies on
secondary research (public information) and primary research (In-depth interview). The
objective of exploratory research is to gather preliminary information that will help define
problems and suggest hypothesis. Therefore, our group decided to use exploratory research
to explore and analyze the customers satisfaction of telecom/mobile services of TRUE
MOVE. This would help us to find out research problems and to understand the customers
satisfaction. Therefore, our group conducts a research on secondary data; we find out
information on many websites that provided the public information research to find the
factors that lead to purchase intention. Then, we conduct a research on primary research
(the In-depth interview from respondents); we use in-depth interview method for receiving
detailed information about consumers thoughts and behaviors. Moreover, it can help get
the information for the interviewee directly and deeply about their overview on the
telecom/mobile service company. It also uses to identify the factors that affect customer
17
Descriptive Research
Descriptive research helps to determine the independent and dependent variables
and it helps to explain the relationship between them. Furthermore, it helps to identify and
obtain information on the characteristics of a particular issue. The data collected are often
quantitative, and statistical techniques are usually used to summarize the information. We
decided to use questionnaires as our tool to get the information data from respondents. In
order to get the effective representative of overall population, we should randomly select
the respondents who have used TRUEMOVE telecom/mobile services within past five
months. The effective place to collect data is Assumption University and Bangkok
(outsider). The data we would get from this questionnaires survey are sample profile,
behavior, life style, attitude toward to TRUEMOVE telecom/mobile services, etc. in both
quantitative data and qualitative data.
3. Defines Population
Element: People who used the telecom/mobile service of TRUE MOVE in Thailand.
Sampling Unit: customers who use TRUEMOVE telecom/mobile services
Extend: Bangkok, Thailand
Time: 6 January 2013 to 18 January 2013
18
For the Occupation variable, as we know that, with difference purpose of using
mobile phone, the perceived value of each respondents also different. We categorize the
occupation in two big groups, whether he/she is a students or a worker (for any kind of
job). As we know, the budget of spending for each group will determine the attitude as
well as the expectation on True Move. Therefore, using this variable to judgment the
respondents is also helpful.
300 respondents
The reason why we distribute 300 is because this number is same or closed to the
similar researches which are usually have 200-300 questionnaires collected ( Rakshit Negi,
(2009), Birgit Leisen, Charles Vance, (2001) or Karen Kueh, Boo Ho Voon, (2007)).
Those researches have similar purpose with us so using 300 respondents is enough for our
research. We are using the maximum number of respondents in this range because it might
have some unusable result; therefore, in order to reduce the error, 300 samples will be a
good choice.
19
Scales
Question
Level of scale
Type of Question
Nominal
Open-ended question
Nominal
Determinant-choice
Nominal
Simple dichotomy
Nominal
Determinant-choice
Nominal
Determinant-choice
Nominal
Determinant-choice
Nominal
Determinant-choice
Nominal
Simple dichotomy
Interval
10
Interval
11
Interval
12
Interval
13
Interval
14
Interval
15
Interval
16
Interval
17
Interval
18
Interval
Nominal
Simple dichotomy
20
Nominal
Simple dichotomy
21
Nominal
Determinant-choice
22
Nominal
Determinant-choice
23
Nominal
Determinant- choice
24
Nominal
Determinant-choice
20
Definition
Intangible
References
personnel,
Hst,
Michael
communications materials
Responsiveness
Reliability
credibility
in
providing
Hst,
Michael
Knie-Andersen, (2004)
Michael
Knie-Andersen, (2004)
Hst,
Hst,
Michael
a Knie-Andersen, (2004)
Hst,
Michael
Language
Promotion
effectiveness
Satisfaction
and
the
actual
Intention
(Attitudinal
or
Loyalty)
patronize
preferred
or same brand-set
purchasing,
despite
situational
the
potential
to
efforts
cause
switching behavior
6. Develop Measures
Measurements
Variables
Intangible
Measurement
True Move has up-to-date equipment.
Reference
Fujun
Lai,
Hutchinson,
Joe
Dahui
for
Information Sharing.
Police Chief , 70
(11), 18-20.
John
Oliver
L.
Triplett,
H.M.
Yau,
Lai,
Hutchinson,
Joe
Dahui
Foundation
for
Information Sharing.
Police Chief , 70
(11), 18-20.
John
Oliver
L.
Triplett,
H.M.
Yau,
Lai,
Hutchinson,
Joe
Dahui
for
Information Sharing.
Police Chief , 70
(11), 18-20.
John
Oliver
L.
Triplett,
H.M.
Yau,
Lai,
Joe
Dahui
for
Information Sharing.
Police Chief , 70
(11), 18-20.
John
Oliver
L.
Triplett,
H.M.
Yau,
Lai,
Joe
Dahui
23
appearance is good.
for
Information Sharing.
Police Chief , 70
(11), 18-20.
John
Oliver
L.
Triplett,
H.M.
Yau,
Lai,
Hutchinson,
Joe
Dahui
for
Information Sharing.
Police Chief , 70
(11), 18-20.
John
Oliver
L.
Triplett,
H.M.
Yau,
Lai,
Hutchinson,
Joe
Dahui
for
Information Sharing.
Police Chief , 70
(11), 18-20.
John
Oliver
L.
Triplett,
H.M.
Yau,
24
Lai,
Hutchinson,
Joe
Dahui
for
Information Sharing.
Police Chief , 70
(11), 18-20.
John
Oliver
L.
Triplett,
H.M.
Yau,
Move
staff
can
promptly Fujun
Lai,
Joe
Dahui
for
Information Sharing.
Police Chief , 70
(11), 18-20.
John
Oliver
L.
Triplett,
H.M.
Yau,
Lai,
Hutchinson,
Joe
Dahui
for
Information Sharing.
Police Chief , 70
25
(11), 18-20.
John
Oliver
L.
Triplett,
H.M.
Yau,
Lai,
Hutchinson,
Joe
Dahui
for
Information Sharing.
Police Chief , 70
(11), 18-20.
John
Oliver
L.
Triplett,
H.M.
Yau,
Lai,
Joe
Dahui
(2007)
Schmid, K. (2003).
Foundation
for
Information Sharing.
Police Chief , 70
(11), 18-20.
John
Oliver
L.
Triplett,
H.M.
Yau,
Fujun
Lai,
Hutchinson,
Joe
Dahui
26
Foundation
for
Information Sharing.
Police Chief , 70
(11), 18-20.
John
Oliver
L.
Triplett,
H.M.
Yau,
Lai,
Hutchinson,
Joe
Dahui
for
Information Sharing.
Police Chief , 70
(11), 18-20.
John
Oliver
L.
Triplett,
H.M.
Yau,
Fujun
Lai,
Hutchinson,
Joe
Dahui
for
Information Sharing.
Police Chief , 70
(11), 18-20.
John
Oliver
L.
Triplett,
H.M.
Yau,
Lai,
Hutchinson,
Joe
Dahui
27
for
Information Sharing.
Police Chief , 70
(11), 18-20.
John
Oliver
L.
Triplett,
H.M.
Yau,
Fujun
Lai,
Hutchinson,
Joe
Dahui
for
Information Sharing.
Police Chief , 70
(11), 18-20.
John
Oliver
L.
Triplett,
H.M.
Yau,
Lai,
Hutchinson,
Joe
Dahui
for
Information Sharing.
Police Chief , 70
(11), 18-20.
John
Oliver
L.
Triplett,
H.M.
Yau,
28
Fujun
Lai,
Hutchinson,
Joe
Dahui
for
Information Sharing.
Police Chief , 70
(11), 18-20.
John
Oliver
L.
Triplett,
H.M.
Yau,
Lai,
Hutchinson,
Joe
Dahui
for
Information Sharing.
Police Chief , 70
(11), 18-20.
John
Oliver
L.
Triplett,
H.M.
Yau,
Lai,
Hutchinson,
Joe
Dahui
for
Information Sharing.
Police Chief , 70
29
(11), 18-20.
John
Oliver
L.
Triplett,
H.M.
Yau,
Lai,
Hutchinson,
Joe
Dahui
for
Information Sharing.
Police Chief , 70
(11), 18-20.
John
Oliver
L.
Triplett,
H.M.
Yau,
Fujun
Lai,
Hutchinson,
Joe
Dahui
for
Information Sharing.
Police Chief , 70
(11), 18-20.
John
Oliver
L.
Triplett,
H.M.
Yau,
Lai,
Hutchinson,
Joe
Dahui
30
Foundation
for
Information Sharing.
Police Chief , 70
(11), 18-20.
John
Oliver
L.
Triplett,
H.M.
Yau,
Move
has
convenient to all.
operating
hours Fujun
Lai,
Hutchinson,
Joe
Dahui
for
Information Sharing.
Police Chief , 70
(11), 18-20.
John
Oliver
L.
Triplett,
H.M.
Yau,
Lai,
Hutchinson,
Joe
Dahui
for
Information Sharing.
Police Chief , 70
(11), 18-20.
John
Oliver
L.
Triplett,
H.M.
Yau,
31
In-depth interview
True
Move
has
many
effectiveness
Customer
Satisfaction
my expectations.
Ayden
and
2005;
Turkyilmaz
and
Ozkan
Ozer
2007;
Levesque
and
McDougall 1996
Your fulfillment of using True Move Ho, Svein, (2012)
service is pleasant.
Overall, you are satisfied with True
Move.
Turkyilmaz
Ozkan
and
2007;
Anderson
and
Aydin
and
Intention
2005; Turkyilmaz
and
Ozkan
Ozer
2007;
2002;
McDougall
Ching-
and
(Attitudinal
Loyalty)
Holbrook 2001
Reynolds 2000
Fujun
Lai,
Hutchinson,
Joe
Dahui
The American Heritage Dictionary of the English Language, Fourth Edition copyright
2000 by Houghton Mifflin Company. Updated in 2009. Published by Houghton Mifflin
Company.
Fujun Lai, Joe Hutchinson, Dahui Li, Changhong Bai, (2007),"An empirical assessment
and application of SERVQUAL in mainland China's mobile communications industry",
International Journal of Quality & Reliability Management, Vol. 24 Iss: 3 pp. 244 262
John L. Triplett, Oliver H.M. Yau, Cathy Neal, (1994),"Assessing the Reliability and
Validity of SERVQUAL in a Longitudinal Study: The Experience of an Australian
Organisation", Asia Pacific Journal of Marketing and Logistics, Vol. 6 Iss: 1 pp. 41 62
33
2. Sample Profile
We use one-way frequency testing to test for sample profile. It shows the
percentage of respondents in each sub-group for example: gender, income, occupation,
monthly allowances. This data describes the overall profile of the respondents. Our
sample is a good represent
4. Package
Pre-paid
Post-paid
35. Gender
Female
Male
36. Nationality
Non-Thai
Thai
38. Marriage status
Divorce
In the relationship
Married
Single
Frequency
Percent
265
55
82.81
17.19
Frequency
Percent
166
154
51.88
48.13
Frequency
Percent
67
253
20.94
79.06
Frequency Percent
12
77
51
180
3.75
24.06
15.94
56.25
34
39. Occupation
Frequency Percent
Business Owner
Freelancer/ Self-employed
Government-employed
Others
Private-employed
Student
Unemployed
46
34
12
9
51
153
15
14.38
10.63
3.75
2.81
15.94
47.81
4.69
141
40
48
59
32
44.06
12.50
15.00
18.44
10.00
From the sample profile above, we can see that more than 80% of our respondents
are pre-paid respondents. It shows that our sample is quite a good representative of the
population since according to the True report, pre-paid customer acquired for more than
80% of True Move customers.33
Our respondents mostly are Thais people. 47.81% of respondents are student so it
also reflects the truth that monthly allowance less than 30,000 baht/ month is acquired the
largest portion in our sample profile. Lastly, most of them are single.
1-4 hours
4-8 hours
Less than 1 hour
More than 8 hours
Frequency Percent
138
66
71
45
43.13
20.63
22.19
14.06
According to the table above, most of our respondents spend 1-4 hours per day for mobile
phone with 43.13%
33
http://true.listedcompany.com/misc/PRESN/20121211-TRUE-glanceDecember2012.pdf
35
Friends
Newspaper/Magazines
Others
Parents/Relatives
Social network/Internet
Television
Frequency Percent
72
26
5
45
44
128
22.50
8.13
1.56
14.06
13.75
40.00
For the question about how the respondents know about True Move, 40% of respondents
(128 out of 320 respondents) know through Television. 22.5% of them know by their
friends. The third popular way of knowing True Move is through their parents or relatives
with 14.06%; and 13.75% of the respondents know about True from Social network and
Internet.
6. First thing come to your mind Frequency Percent
Good signal
High speed internet
Others
Promotion Effectiveness
Reasonable price
32
170
10
65
43
10.00
53.13
3.13
20.31
13.44
According to the results, 53.13% of respondents answer that high-speed internet is the first
thing come to their mind about True Move. 65 respondents out of 320 answers it is
promotion effectiveness. With 13.44%, reasonable price is the third answer of our
respondents. Lastly, only 10% of them tell True Move has good signal.
36
From eigenvalue, there is only one number that over 1, we can conclude that Tangibles 1,
Tangibles 2, Tangibles 3, Tangibles 4 and Tangibles 5 are correlated and can reduce to one
factor.
Reliabilities
From eigenvalue, there is only one number that over 1, we can conclude that Reliabilities
1, Reliabilities 2, Reliabilities 3, Reliabilities 4, Reliabilities 5 and Reliabilities 6 are
correlated and can reduce to one factor.
37
Responsiveness
From eigenvalue, there is only one number that over 1, we can conclude that
Responsiveness 1, Responsiveness 2, Responsiveness 3, Responsiveness 4 and
Responsiveness 5 are correlated and can reduce to one factor.
Assurance
From eigenvalue, there is only one number that over 1, we can conclude that Assurance1,
Assurance 2, Assurance 3, Assurance 4, and Assurance 5 are correlated and can reduce to
one factor.
38
Empathy
From eigenvalue, there is only one number that over 1, we can conclude that Empathy1,
Empathy 2, Empathy 3, Empathy 4 and Empathy 5 are correlated and can reduce to one
factor.
Pricing package
From eigenvalue, there is only one number that over 1, we can conclude that Pricing
package 1, Pricing package 2, Pricing package 3 and Pricing package 4 are correlated and
can reduce to one factor.
39
Promotion attractive
From eigenvalue, there is only one number that over 1, we can conclude that Promotion
attractive 1, Promotion attractive 2, Promotion attractive 3 and Promotion attractive 4 are
correlated and can reduce to one factor.
Customer satisfaction
From eigenvalue, there is only one number that over 1, we can conclude that Customer
satisfaction 1, Customer satisfaction 2 and Customer satisfaction 3 are correlated and can
reduce to one factor.
40
Customer loyalty
From eigenvalue, there is only one number that over 1, we can conclude that Customer
loyalty 1, Customer loyalty 2 and Customer loyalty 3 are correlated and can reduce to one
factor.
Repurchase intention
From eigenvalue, there is only one number that over 1, we can conclude that Repurchase
intention 1, Repurchase intention 2 and Repurchase intention 3 are correlated and can
reduce to one factor.
41
b. Kano Model
18. Signal
elevator
available
in
19. Free 3G
20. Free Wi-Fi
21. Problems can be solved
through Call center
22. Call Center is available 24
hours
23. Online Call Center
respond within 15 minutes.
24. More Kiosks
25. Giving extra 50% refill
amount on Songkran
26. Free SMS to other True
users on birthday
27. Reduces 50% price
package for roaming
28. Lucky draw to win the
trip to Europe once a year
29.
Giving
reward
to
customer who use over
500B/month (free SMS and
MMS)
30. Free snacks and drinks in
outlets/kiosks.
31. VIP lounge for executive
users in service center
32. True has 4G network in
near future
33. True offers a money
transfer service from sim to
sim.
34. Miss called alert via text
messages when your phone is
out of battery
Total
Grade
114
54
88
46
12
320
135
24
127
25
320
120
28
122
46
320
33
117
116
51
320
42
109
66
66
289
47
75
93
98
320
105
16
70
121
320
131
14
90
82
320
162
12
82
58
320
144
102
64
320
152
10
62
93
320
104
40
75
98
320
80
47
43
149
320
81
41
48
141
320
122
29
116
49
320
125
20
71
101
320
45
69
59
140
320
42
43
H1
Tangibility
Customer
Loyalty
Pricing
H2
H3
Package
H9
Promotion
H10
Effectivenes
H4
H8
H15-21
H22
Repurchase
Customer
H11
Satisfaction
H23
Intention
H12
Reliability
H5
Responsiveness
H13
H6
Assurance
H14
H7
Empathy
Model 1
H8 H14: Customer Satisfaction is influenced by Product tangibility, Pricing
Package, Promotion effectiveness, Reliability, Responsiveness, Assurance and
Empathy
Model: Linear_Regression_Model
Dependent Variable: 15.Customer Satisfaction
Analysis of Variance
Source
Sum of Mean
DF Squares Square F Value Pr > F
Model
4 87.91532 21.97883
Error
315 86.30551 0.27399
Corrected Total 319 174.22083
80.22 <.0001
Root MSE
0.52344R-Square
0.5046
Dependent Mean
3.73125Adj R-Sq
0.4983
Coeff Var
14.02845
44
Parameter Estimates
Parameter Standard
Standardized
DF Estimate
Error t Value Pr > |t|
Estimate
Variable
Intercept
10.Responsiveness
12.Empathy
13.Pricing Package
14.Promotion Attraction
1
1
1
1
1
-0.22434
0.33051
0.21792
0.16844
0.32853
0.22590
0.05552
0.05541
0.05533
0.05231
-0.99
5.95
3.93
3.04
6.28
0.3214
<.0001
0.0001
0.0025
<.0001
0
0.28820
0.20800
0.14897
0.28589
Decision: Ho is rejected
Conclusion: Pricing Package, Promotion effectiveness, Responsiveness and Empathy have
influences on Customer satisfaction
Model:
Customer satisfaction = -0.22434 + 0.33051 * (Responsiveness) + 0.21792 * (Empathy) +
0.16844 * (Pricing) + 0.32853 * (Promotion)
Model 2
H1-H7: The Repurchase Intention of True Move customer is influenced by Product
tangibility, Pricing Package, Promotion effectiveness, Reliability, Responsiveness,
Assurance and Empathy
Dependent Variable: 17.Repurchase Intention
Source
Analysis of Variance
Sum of
DF Squares
Model
Error
Corrected Total
4
315
319
Mean
F
Square Value Pr > F
79.56037
92.07539
171.63576
19.89009
0.29230
68.05 <.0001
Root MSE
0.54065R-Square0.4635
Dependent Mean 3.70521Adj R-Sq0.4567
Coeff Var
14.59163
Variable
Intercept
9.Reliability
10.Responsiveness
12.Empathy
14.Promotion Attraction
Parameter Estimates
Parameter Standard
Standardized
DF Estimate
Error t Value Pr > |t|
Estimate
1
1
1
1
1
0.00788
0.28062
0.21606
0.15364
0.32779
0.22719
0.06182
0.06466
0.05393
0.05305
0.03
4.54
3.34
2.85
6.18
0.9724
<.0001
0.0009
0.0047
<.0001
0
0.25248
0.18982
0.14774
0.28739
Decision: Ho is rejected
45
Analysis of Variance
Sum of Mean
DF Squares Square F Value Pr > F
Model
7 92.2530513.17901
Error
312 79.38272 0.25443
Corrected Total 319 171.63576
51.80 <.0001
Root MSE
0.50441R-Square0.5375
Dependent Mean 3.70521Adj R-Sq0.5271
Coeff Var
13.61360
Variable
Label
Intercept
8.Tangibles
14.Promotion Attraction
15.Customer Satisfaction
tan*sat
relia * sat
relia * sat*loy
resp *sat
Intercept
tan*sat
relia * sat
relia * sat*loy
resp *sat
Parameter Estimates
Parameter Standard
Standardized
DF Estimate
Error t Value Pr > |t|
Estimate
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
-0.81306
0.19552
0.14936
0.65931
-0.06696
0.18841
-0.02868
0.04160
0.54408
0.09080
0.05569
0.14171
0.02507
0.04027
0.00949
0.01688
-1.49
2.15
2.68
4.65
-2.67
4.68
-3.02
2.46
0.1361
0.0321
0.0077
<.0001
0.0080
<.0001
0.0027
0.0142
0
0.15006
0.13095
0.61236
-0.37874
1.13226
-0.94037
0.25397
46
Full Model:
Repurchase Intention = -0.81306 + 0.19552 * (Tangibles) + 0.14936 * (Promotion) +
0.65931 * ( Customer Satisfaction) 0.06696 * (Tangibles * Sat) + 0.18841 * (Reliability
* Sat) 0.02868 * ( Reliability * Sat * Loy) + 0.04160 * (Responsiveness * Sat)
H1
Product
Tangibility
H2
H3
Pricing
Package
Promotion
H10
Effectivenes
H4
H8
H9
Reliability
H11
Customer
Customer
Satisfaction
H23
Loyalty
H12
H5
Responsiveness
H13
H6
Assurance
H14
H7
Empathy
47
Model 1
Hypo: Customer Satisfaction is influenced by Product tangibility, Pricing Package,
Promotion effectiveness, Reliability, Responsiveness, Assurance and Empathy
Model: Linear_Regression_Model
Dependent Variable: 15.Customer Satisfaction
Analysis of Variance
Sum of Mean
DF Squares Square F Value Pr > F
Source
Model
4 87.91532 21.97883
Error
80.22 <.0001
0.52344R-Square
0.5046
Dependent Mean
3.73125Adj R-Sq
0.4983
Coeff Var
Variable
Intercept
10.Responsiveness
12.Empathy
13.Pricing Package
14.Promotion Attraction
14.02845
Parameter Estimates
Parameter Standard
Standardized
DF Estimate
Error t Value Pr > |t|
Estimate
1
1
1
1
1
-0.22434
0.33051
0.21792
0.16844
0.32853
0.22590
0.05552
0.05541
0.05533
0.05231
-0.99
5.95
3.93
3.04
6.28
0.3214
<.0001
0.0001
0.0025
<.0001
0
0.28820
0.20800
0.14897
0.28589
Decision: Ho is rejected
Conclusion: Pricing Package, Promotion effectiveness, Responsiveness and Empathy have
influences on Customer satisfaction
Model:
Customer satisfaction = -0.22434 + 0.33051 * (Responsiveness) + 0.21792 * (Empathy) +
0.16844 * (Pricing) + 0.32853 * (Promotion)
48
Model 2:
Hypo: The Customer Loyalty of True Move customer is influenced by Product
tangibility, Pricing Package, Promotion effectiveness, Reliability, Responsiveness,
Assurance and Empathy
Dependent Variable: 16.Customer Loyalty
Analysis of Variance
Sum of Mean
DF Squares Square F Value Pr > F
Source
Model
5 62.5621212.51242
Error
314 85.49864 0.27229
Corrected Total 319 148.06076
Root MSE
Dependent Mean
Coeff Var
Variable
Intercept
10.Responsiveness
11.Assurance
12.Empathy
13.Pricing Package
14.Promotion Attraction
45.95 <.0001
0.52181R-Square
3.77604Adj R-Sq
13.81904
0.4225
0.4133
Parameter Estimates
Parameter Standard
Standardized
DF Estimate
Error t Value Pr > |t|
Estimate
1
1
1
1
1
1
0.37716
0.18182
0.14340
0.11772
0.11607
0.33741
0.22955
0.06170
0.06863
0.05827
0.05533
0.05261
1.64
2.95
2.09
2.02
2.10
6.41
0.1014
0.0035
0.0375
0.0442
0.0367
<.0001
0
0.17198
0.13023
0.12188
0.11136
0.31850
Decision: Ho is rejected
Conclusion: Promotion effectiveness, Responsiveness, Assurance, Pricing and Empathy
have influences on Customer Loyalty
Model:
Customer Loyalty = 0.037716 + 0.33741 * (Promotion) + 0.18182 * (Responsiveness) +
0.1434 * (Assurance) + 0.11772 * (Empathy) + 0.11607 * (Pricing)
49
Source
Analysis of Variance
Sum of Mean
DF Squares Square F Value Pr > F
Model
6 72.7169612.11949
Error
313 75.34381 0.24072
Corrected Total 319 148.06076
50.35 <.0001
Root MSE
0.49063R-Square0.4911
Dependent Mean 3.77604Adj R-Sq0.4814
Coeff Var
12.99316
Variable
Label
Intercept
Intercept
11.Asurance
12.Empathy
14.Promotion Attraction
tan*sat
tan*sat
emp*sat
emp*sat
Promo*sat
Promo*sat
Parameter Estimates
Parameter Standard
Standardized
DF Estimate
Error t Value Pr > |t|
Estimate
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1.38838
0.15572
-0.56992
0.70268
0.03531
0.18762
-0.13486
0.28922
0.06074
0.16915
0.15412
0.01491
0.04586
0.04249
4.80
2.56
-3.37
4.56
2.37
4.09
-3.17
<.0001
0.0108
0.0008
<.0001
0.0185
<.0001
0.0017
0
0.14141
-0.59008
0.66330
0.21505
1.26418
-0.90304
Full Model:
Customer Loyalty = 1.38838 + 0.15572 * (Assurance) 0.56992 * (Empathy) + 0.070268
* (Promotion) + 0.03531 * (Tangibles * Sat) + 0.18762 * (Empathy * Sat) 0.13486 *
(Promotion * Sat)
50
Empathy,
Pricing
Packages,
Promotion
Attraction,
Customer
N
320
Mean
3.9531
t Test
The TTEST Procedure
Variable: 8. Tangibles
Std Dev
Std Err
Minimum
0.5630
0.0315
2.0000
DF
319
N
320
Mean
3.7495
Mean
3.7594
Pr > |t|
<.0001
Variable: 9. Reliability
Std Dev
Std Err
Minimum
0.6600
0.0369
1.3333
DF
319
N
320
t Value
125.62
t Value
20.31
Maximum
5.0000
Maximum
5.0000
Pr > |t|
<.0001
N
320
Mean
3.7800
t Value
Pr > |t|
104.36
<.0001
Variable: 11. Assurance
Std Dev
Std Err
Minimum
0.6187
0.0346
1.4000
Maximum
5.0000
Maximum
5.0000
DF
319
N
320
N
320
Mean
3.7525
t Value
Pr > |t|
109.29
<.0001
Variable: 12. Empathy
Std Dev
Std Err
Minimum
0.7054
0.0394
1.4000
Maximum
5.0000
Mean
3.7766
DF
t Value
Pr > |t|
319
95.17
<.0001
Variable: 13. Pricing Package
Std Dev
Std Err
Minimum
0.6536
0.0365
1.7500
Maximum
5.0000
DF
319
t Value
103.36
Pr > |t|
<.0001
51
N
320
Mean
3.8328
t Value
106.61
Maximum
5.0000
Pr > |t|
<.0001
320
Mean
3.7313
Std Dev
0.7390
DF
319
Std Err
0.0413
t Value
17.70
Minimum
1.3333
Maximum
5.0000
Pr > |t|
<.0001
Mean
3.7760
Std Dev
0.6813
DF
319
Std Err
0.0381
Minimum
1.3333
t Value
20.38
Pr > |t|
<.0001
Maximum
5.0000
Mean
3.7052
Std Dev
0.7335
DF
319
Std Err
0.0410
Minimum
1.3333
t Value
17.20
Pr > |t|
<.0001
Maximum
5.0000
Decision: Ho is rejected
Conclusion: The level of Customer satisfaction in Tangibles, Reliability, Responsiveness,
Assurance, Empathy, Pricing Packages, Promotion Attraction, Customer Satisfaction,
Loyalty and Repurchase intensions are significant high.
52
e. Independent T-test
Gender
Hypothesis: People who have different gender perceive promotion effectiveness
differently
Ho: People who have different gender between male and female perceive promotion not
effectiveness differently
35. Gender
Female
Male
Diff (1-2)
Mean
Std Dev
Std Err
Minimum
Maximum
166 3.7861
0.6509
0.0505
2.0000
5.0000
154 3.8831
0.6328
0.0510
1.7500
5.0000
-0.0970 0.6423
0.0719
Female
Male
Pooled
Equal
153
1.06
0.7245
Compare Variances
Conclusion: Equal Variances assumed
35. Gender
Female
Male
Mean
Std Dev
Std Err
Minimum
Maximum
166 3.7189
0.6661
0.0517
1.3333
5.0000
154 3.7825
0.6538
0.0527
1.6667
4.8333
0.6602
0.0739
Diff (1-2)
-0.0636
Female
Male
Variances DF
Pooled
Equal
-41.47 <.0001
318
153
1.04
0.8163
Compare Variances
Conclusion: Equal Variances assumed
Female
0.0515
1.4000
5.0000
Male
0.0449
2.2000
5.0000
-0.1537 0.6149
0.0688
Diff (1-2)
Mean
54
Female
Male
Variances DF
Pooled
Equal
-45.84 <.0001
318
153
1.42
0.0276
Compare Variances
Conclusion: Unequal Variances assumed
35. Gender N
Mean
Female
0.0597
1.4000
5.0000
Male
0.0508
2.0000
4.8000
-0.0665 0.7057
0.0790
Diff (1-2)
Female
Male
55
Method
Variances DF
Pooled
Equal
-38.84 <.0001
318
153
1.49
0.0124
Compare Variances
Conclusion: Unequal Variances assumed
Post-paid/ pre-paid
Hypothesis: People who use different promotion package perceive promotion
effectiveness differently
Ho: People who use package between post-paid and pre-paid perceive promotion
effectiveness differently
3. Package using
Post-paid
Pre-paid
Diff (1-2)
Equality of Variances
Method Num DF Den DF F Value Pr > F
Folded F
264
54
1.34 0.1915
Compare Variances
Conclusion: Equal Variances assumed
Decision: The null hypothesis is rejected.(Pr <.0001)
Conclusion: People who use post-paid have higher reliability than those who use prepaid
58
59
Hypothesis: People who have different age perceive product tangibility differently
Ho: People who have different age have no different perception on product tangibility
Hypothesis: People who have different age perceive product reliability differently
Ho: People who have different age have no different perception on product reliability
3.6667 214 18 - 35
3.4773 22 Less than 18
Hypothesis: People who have different marriage status perceive product assurance
differently
Ho: People who have different marriage status have no different perception on product
assurance
Dependent Variable: 11.Asurance
Source
DF Sum of Squares Mean Square F Value Pr > F
Model
3
8.3658352
2.7886117
7.75<.0001
Error
316
113.7461648
0.3599562
Corrected Total319
122.1120000
R-Square Coeff Var Root MSE 11.Asurance Mean
0.068510 15.87205 0.599964
3.780000
Source
DF Anova SS Mean Square F Value Pr > F
8. Marriage status 38.36583516 2.78861172
7.75<.0001
Means with the same letter are not significantly
different.
Duncan Grouping
Mean
N 8. Marriage status
A
4.1216 51 Married
61
B
B
B
A
A
C
C
C
4.0167
12 Divorce
3.7377
77 In the relationship
Hypothesis: People who have different age have different customer satisfaction
Ho: People who have different age have no different customer satisfaction
Dependent Variable: 15. Customer Satisfaction
Source
DF Sum of Squares Mean Square F Value Pr > F
Model
3
9.2915209
3.0971736
5.93 0.0006
Error
316
164.9293125
0.5219282
Corrected Total319
174.2208333
R-Square Coeff Var Root MSE 15.Customer Satisfaction Mean
0.053332 19.36204 0.722446
3.731250
Source DF Anova SS Mean Square F Value Pr > F
37. Age 39.29152086 3.09717362
5.93 0.0006
Means with the same letter are not
significantly different.
Duncan Grouping Mean N 37. Age
A
4.1449 23 More than 50
A
B
A
3.9508 61 35 - 50
B
B
C
3.6433 214 18 - 35
C
C
3.5455 22 Less than 18
Decision: the null hypothesis is rejected
Conclusion: People who have different age have different customer satisfaction. Customer
with age more than 50 years old have significantly concerned on customer satisfaction in
product choosing. For people with age less than 18, the customer satisfaction is less
concern.
62
63
Hypothesis: People who have different spending per month have different customer
satisfaction
Ho: People who have different spending per month have no different customer satisfaction
Dependent Variable: 15.Customer Satisfaction
Source
DF Sum of Squares Mean Square F Value Pr > F
Model
3
13.0276818
4.3425606
8.51<.0001
Error
316
161.1931515
0.5101049
Corrected Total319
174.2208333
R-Square Coeff Var Root MSE 15.Customer Satisfaction Mean
0.074777 19.14148 0.714216
3.731250
Source
DF Anova SS Mean Square F Value Pr > F
7. Spending per mont 313.02768182 4.34256061
8.51<.0001
Means with the same letter are not significantly
different.
Duncan Grouping Mean N 7. Spending per month
A
3.9825 114 More than 1000 Baht
B
B
B
B
B
Hypothesis: People who have different spending per month have different customer
loyalty
Ho: People who have different spending per month have no different customer loyalty
Dependent Variable: 16.Customer Loyalty
Source
DF Sum of Squares Mean Square F Value Pr > F
Model
3
5.0868614
1.6956205
3.75 0.0114
Error
316
142.9739025
0.4524491
Corrected Total319
148.0607639
R-Square Coeff Var Root MSE 16.Customer Loyalty Mean
64
3.776042
Source
DF Anova SS Mean Square F Value Pr > F
7. Spending per mont 35.08686141 1.69562047
3.75 0.0114
Means with the same letter are not significantly
different.
Duncan Grouping Mean N 7. Spending per month
A
3.9444 114 More than 1000 Baht
A
B
A
3.7207 37 Less than 400 Baht
B
B
3.6752 78 701-1000 Baht
B
B
3.6740 91 400-700 Baht
Decision: the null hypothesis is rejected
Conclusion: People who have different spending per month have different customer
loyalty. People who spend more than 1,000 Baht per month significantly have high on
customer loyalty. Next, people who spend 400-1000 baht per month have lesser loyalty.
Hypothesis: People who have different age have different customer loyalty
Ho: People who have different age have no different in customer loyalty
Dependent Variable: 16.Customer Loyalty
Source
DF Sum of Squares Mean Square F Value Pr > F
Model
3
9.1096566
3.0365522
6.91 0.0002
Error
316
138.9511073
0.4397187
Corrected Total319
148.0607639
R-Square Coeff Var Root MSE 16.Customer Loyalty Mean
0.061526 17.56106 0.663113
3.776042
Source DF Anova SS Mean Square F Value Pr > F
37. Age 39.10965660 3.03655220
6.91 0.0002
Means with the same letter are not
significantly different.
Duncan Grouping Mean N 37. Age
A
4.1594 23 More than 50
A
B
A
3.9727 61 35 - 50
B
A
B
A
3.9394 22 Less than 18
B
B
3.6620 214 18 - 35
65
Hypothesis: People who have different occupation have different customer loyalty
Ho: People who have different occupation have no different customer loyalty
Dependent Variable: 16.Customer Loyalty
Source
DF Sum of Squares Mean Square F Value Pr > F
Model
6
10.9506711
1.8251118
4.17 0.0005
Error
313
137.1100928
0.4380514
Corrected Total319
148.0607639
R-Square Coeff Var Root MSE 16.Customer Loyalty Mean
0.073961 17.52773 0.661855
3.776042
Source
DF Anova SS Mean Square F Value Pr > F
39. Occupation 610.95067106 1.82511184
4.17 0.0005
Means with the same letter are not significantly different.
Duncan Grouping
Mean
N 39. Occupation
A
4.3333 15 Unemployed
A
B
A
4.0362 46 Business Owner
B
A
B
A
3.9722 12 Government-employed
B
B
C
3.7157 34 Freelancer/ Self-employed
B
C
B
C
3.7102 153 Student
B
C
B
C
3.6144 51 Private-employed
C
C
3.5185
9 Others
Decision: the null hypothesis is rejected
Conclusion: People who have different occupation have different customer loyalty. People
who are unemployed is significantly have customer loyalty while people who have other
jobs have lesser loyalty.
DF
11.4590454
1.9098409
313
160.1767184
0.5117467
171.6357639
Error
R-Square
0.066764
3.73 0.0013
0.715365
3.705208
Source
DF Anova SS Mean Square F Value Pr > F
39. Occupation 611.45904544 1.90984091
3.73 0.0013
Means with the same letter are not significantly different.
Duncan Grouping
Mean
N 39. Occupation
A
4.0833 12 Government-employed
A
A
4.0725 46 Business Owner
A
B
A
3.9333 15 Unemployed
B
A
B
A
3.6569 34 Freelancer/ Self-employed
B
A
B
A
3.6078 153 Student
B
B
3.5817 51 Private-employed
B
B
3.4815
9 Others
Decision: the null hypothesis is rejected
Conclusion: People who have different occupation have a different repurchase intention.
People who are government-employed and business owners have more repurchase
intention. Private-employed and others have less repurchase intention.
Hypothesis: People who have different marriage status have a different repurchase
intention
Ho: People who have different marriage status have no different repurchase intention
Dependent Variable: 17.Repurchase Intention
Source
DF Sum of Squares Mean Square F Value Pr > F
Model
3
5.0483439
1.6827813
3.19 0.0239
Error
316
166.5874200
0.5271754
Corrected Total319
171.6357639
67
B
B
3.5779 214 18 - 35
g. Chi-square
Hypo: There is a difference in top of mind telecommunication brand among groups
of people, who spend differently for mobile phone per month.
Ho: There is no difference in top of mind telecommunication brand among groups of
people, who spend differently for mobile phone per month.
Table of 7. Spending per month by 1. First brand in mind
1. First brand in mind
AIS DTAC True move Total
7. Spending per month
20
14
57 91
Frequency
59.434
400-700 Baht
Expected 16.209 15.356
27.27
Col Pct 35.09 25.93
19
15
44 78
Frequency
50.944
701-1000 Baht
Expected 13.894 13.163
21.05
Col Pct 33.33 27.78
9
5
23 37
Frequency
24.166
Less than 400 Baht Expected 6.5906 6.2438
11.00
Col Pct 15.79 9.26
9
20
85 114
Frequency
74.456
More than 1000 Baht Expected 20.306 19.238
40.67
Col Pct 15.79 37.04
57
54
209 320
Total
Frequency
Statistics for Table of 7. Spending per month by 1. First brand in mind
Statistic
DF Value Prob
Chi-Square
613.18880.0401
0.2030
Contingency Coefficient
0.1990
Cramer's V
0.1436
69
Hypo: There is a difference in monthly allowance among group of people, who spend
differently for mobile phone per month.
Ho: There is no difference in monthly allowance among group of people, who spend
differently for mobile phone per month.
Table Analysis
Results
The FREQ Procedure
Table of 7. Spending per month by 40. Monthly Allowance
40. Monthly Allowance
10.000 - 30,001 50,001 - Less than More than
30,000
50,000
100,000
10,000
100,000
Baht
Baht
Baht
Baht
Baht Total
7. Spending
per month
400-700
Baht
701-1000
Baht
Less than
400 Baht
More than
1000 Baht
Total
Frequency
Expected
Col Pct
Frequency
Expected
Col Pct
Frequency
Expected
Col Pct
Frequency
Expected
Col Pct
41
40.097
29.08
46
34.369
32.62
17
16.303
12.06
37
50.231
26.24
15
11.375
37.50
7
9.75
17.50
5
4.625
12.50
13
14.25
32.50
7
13.65
14.58
9
11.7
18.75
2
5.55
4.17
30
17.1
62.50
19
16.778
32.20
13
14.381
22.03
12
6.8219
20.34
15
21.019
25.42
9 91
9.1
28.13
3 78
7.8
9.38
1 37
3.7
3.13
19 114
11.4
59.38
Frequency
141
40
48
59
32 320
Statistic
DF Value Prob
Chi-Square
1241.4804<.0001
Likelihood Ratio Chi-Square 1241.4655<.0001
Mantel-Haenszel Chi-Square 1 5.5253 0.0187
Phi Coefficient
0.3600
Contingency Coefficient
0.3387
Cramer's V
0.2079
70
Hypo: Male and female have a difference among groups of different in monthly
allowance.
Ho: Male and female have no difference among groups of different in monthly allowance.
Table of 35. Gender by 40. Monthly Allowance
40. Monthly Allowance
30,001 50,001 - Less than More than
10.000 50,000
100,000
10,000
100,000
30,000 Baht
Baht
Baht
Baht
Baht Total
35.
Gender
Frequency
Female Expected
Col Pct
Frequency
Male Expected
Col Pct
Total
74
73.144
52.48
67
67.856
47.52
24
20.75
60.00
16
19.25
40.00
18
24.9
37.50
30
23.1
62.50
38
30.606
64.41
21
28.394
35.59
141
40
48
59
Frequency
Statistics for Table of 35. Gender by 40. Monthly Allowance
Statistic
DF Value Prob
Chi-Square
411.41190.0223
Likelihood Ratio Chi-Square 411.53030.0212
Mantel-Haenszel Chi-Square 1 0.27420.6005
Phi Coefficient
0.1888
Contingency Coefficient
0.1856
Cramer's V
0.1888
Sample Size = 320
12 166
16.6
37.50
20 154
15.4
62.50
32 320
Hypo: There is a difference in time using mobile phone/day among groups of people,
who have different marriage status
Ho: There is no difference in time using mobile phone/day among groups of people, who
have different marriage status
71
38.
status
Frequency
Expected
Col Pct
Frequency
In the
Expected
relationship
Col Pct
Frequency
Married
Expected
Col Pct
Frequency
Single
Expected
Col Pct
Divorce
6
5.175
4.35
28
33.206
20.29
25
21.994
18.12
79
77.625
57.25
2
2.475
3.03
15
15.881
22.73
15
10.519
22.73
34
37.125
51.52
3
2.6625
4.23
12
17.084
16.90
10
11.316
14.08
46
39.938
64.79
1 12
1.6875
2.22
22 77
10.828
48.89
1 51
7.1719
2.22
21 180
25.313
46.67
138
66
71
45 320
Total
Frequency
Statistics for Table of 8. Marriage status by 4. How long use mobile phone / d
Statistic
DF Value Prob
Chi-Square
924.17710.0040
Likelihood Ratio Chi-Square 924.63550.0034
Mantel-Haenszel Chi-Square 1 1.48360.2232
Phi Coefficient
0.2749
Contingency Coefficient
0.2650
Cramer's V
0.1587
Sample Size = 320
Decision: The null hypothesis is rejected. (Pr 0.0040<0.05)
Conclusion: There is a difference in time using mobile phone/day among groups of people,
who have different marriage status.
72
Thai
Total
Frequency
Expected
Col Pct
Frequency
Expected
Col Pct
24
28.894
17.39
114
109.11
82.61
20
13.819
30.30
46
52.181
69.70
10
14.866
14.08
61
56.134
85.92
13 67
9.4219
28.89
32 253
35.578
71.11
Frequency
138
66
71
45 320
Statistic
DF Value Prob
Chi-Square
38.27850.0406
Likelihood Ratio Chi-Square 38.08320.0443
Mantel-Haenszel Chi-Square 10.80250.3704
Phi Coefficient
0.1608
Contingency Coefficient
0.1588
Cramer's V
0.1608
Decision: The null hypothesis is rejected. (Pr 0.0406<0.05)
Conclusion: There is a difference in time using mobile phone/day among different
nationality
73
74
satisfaction and customer loyalty higher than those who use Pre-paid package. Similarly,
male customers perceive six independent variables (excluding product tangibility),
customer satisfaction and customer loyalty higher than female customers. Therefore,
company should divide the target market by gender and usage package: post-paid and prepaid to make it easier to satisfy different wants and needs of different segments.
In addition, TrueMove should focus on customers in term of age, occupation and
marriage status to have quick response to different needs of each group. Thanks to oneway ANOVA results, we can see that there are significant differences among groups of
age, marriage status and occupation in perceiving customer loyalty and repurchase
intention. When mentioning about different perception in customer loyalty, we should
consider the difference in age. Senior group, who are more than 50 years old, with the
highest mean of 4.1594 perceive different from young group aged between 18 and 35 with
the lowest mean of 3.662. It is reasonable for the young to have low level of loyalty,
because young people always want to take risk trying new things, contracting to the
elderly. The next factor under concern is occupation. Unemployed people with highest
level of customer loyalty are different from people with other jobs taking the least level of
loyalty. It can be explained that people with no job usually stick to current brand since they
do not concern anything else but finding job. In term of repurchase intention, customers
with different age have a different repurchase intention. The result shows that people who
are 35 years old and older have more repurchase intention while people who are 18-35
years old have less repurchase intention. As the matter of fact, we have mentioned above,
young people want to change to new brand when they find it interesting. Therefore, the
chance for them to repurchase the previous brand is quite low. Moreover, people with
different marriage status also have different repurchase intention. Married people have
more repurchase intention than people do in a relationship. Finally, repurchase intention is
perceived differently among people who have different occupation. Government-employed
and business owners have different repurchase intention from private-employed and others
have less repurchase intention.
75
2. Recommendation
For this current situation of True Move and telecommunication industry in
Thailand, some key variables are used to determine marketing research problems.
According to the problem that we mentioned above in Chapter 1 which is to determine the
effectiveness of IMC campaign and the important of service quality by taking the
advantage of industry growth rate; we implemented both exploratory and descriptive
analysis to find out those factors. It is required the understanding on what are the
preferences and purchase intentions of the actual users, using strengths to grab the
opportunities, avoid the threats and reduces its own weaknesses. Across the
telecommunication industry, the same challenges arise again and again; how to acquire and
retain customers when competition is so intense. We found that the increasing on product
tangibility, promotion attractiveness, reliability, Responsiveness, assurance, empathy and
the decreasing on pricing package will lead to the increasing in customer satisfaction then
finally effect on repurchase intension through customer loyalty.
In order to improve those variables, we use the analyzing results from Analysis part to
recommend True Move as following:
1. Reliability: Fast and effective resolution of network outages is a critical
requirement for any telecommunications business seeking to improve efficiency
while delivering excellent customer service. This is especially true now that it is
easier than ever for customers to change providers or to vent their frustration in
public on internet forums and social networking sites. True Move must ensure their
communications are reaching the right customer, with the right message, over the
right channel and at the right time.
2. Product tangibility, assurance and empathy: True Move must consider offering
customers online self-service facilities that are convenient for them and which help
company themselves to collect payments faster, more efficiently and at lower cost.
In addition, the company should provide easy-to-understand graphical information
on the customers usage patterns, enabling them to choose the most beneficial tariff
for their circumstances.
3. Promotion attractiveness: True should pay their attention in deliver timely, relevant
marketing and advertising messages to mobile customers via SMS, which will
prove to result in higher click-through rates than email. On the other hand, True
tries to draw the attention of the consumer by price-promotions along with some
76
others, such as Free 3G; Giving extra 50% refill amount on Song-kran; Free SMS
to other True users on birthday; Reduces 50% price package for roaming.as we
mentioned in what customer over expected from True.
4. Pricing package: Price is the amount of money charged for a product or service, or
the sum of the values that customers exchange for the benefits of having or using
the product or service. Price fairness refers to consumers assessments of whether a
sellers price is reasonable, acceptable or justifiable or not. True should think more
about their number of pricing package to approve the different groups of
customers. Moreover, because students are more price sensitive than other
occupations, they are willing to pay less for high quality services. True should
primarily target more on other groups and then target on students. However, True
could provide price off for students due to the number of student users are
increasing in order to lower the level of their perceived price.
5. Repurchase intension: Aside from the seven variables described above that
associated to increase True Move repurchase intension; there is other one factor in
which the company should concern- that is the service brand purchased. According
to the result, people who have the highest service repurchase are the brand loyalty
customers. True Move should be more offensive to build and take more market
share by take this opportunity.
In conclusion, to increase the service repurchase intension, True should undertake the
several marketing tools such as WOM, buzz, advertising, price off promotion and other
promotional tools. It also must be both offensive and defensive for its market share in
telecommunication industry. Moreover, students should not be the primary target market;
the business owners and private employees should be initially focuses. Importantly, True
Move should acquire new customers.
77
References
http://telenor.com/investor-relations/company-facts/business-description/dtac-thailand/
http://www.adassothai.com/index.php/main/ad_expenditure
http://www.jtaer.com/aug2011/wong_hideki_george_p2.pdf
http://archive.lib.cmu.ac.th/full/T/2552/mba0952rk_ch2.pdf
http://www.kanomodel.com/tutorial.html
http://www.satisfactionstrategies.com/paper1.pdf
http://usatoday30.usatoday.com/money/smallbusiness/columnist/abrams/2006-04-14creating-loyalty_x.htm?csp=34a
Ruby Roy Dholakia, Miao Zhao, (2010) "Effects of online store attributes on customer
satisfaction and repurchase intentions", International Journal of Retail & Distribution
Management, Vol. 38 Iss: 7, pp.482 - 496
http://www.utexas.edu/research/cswr/survey/cssymposium/cspaper.pdf
Sureshchandar, G., & Rajendran, C. A. (2002). The Relationship Between Service Quality
and Customer Satisfaction: A Factor Specific Approach. Journal of Services Marketing ,
16 (4), 363-379.
http://webdb.ucs.ed.ac.uk/operations/honsqm/articles/ServqualButtle.pdf
http://usatoday30.usatoday.com/money/smallbusiness/columnist/abrams/2006-04-14creating-loyalty_x.htm?csp=34
http://www.technovationentrepreneur.com/2010/07/customer-satisfaction-perception-ofproduct-and-service-quality/
vii
Hallowells
seminal
1996
Harvard
Business
School
study.
http://www.business2community.com/loyalty-marketing/customer-satisfaction-andcustomer-loyalty-it%E2%80%99s-like-%E2%80%9Clike-vs-love%E2%80%9D-070774
viii
ix
Appendix
Questionnaire about True Move Service Provider
Part I: General Information
1. What is the first brand of telecommunication service provider first come to your
mind?_____________________________________
2. Your current service provider of your mobile phone is TrueMove. (if yes, continue
to question 3, if no, go to question 35)
1. Yes
2. No
3. What is the package that you use for you mobile phone?
1. Pre-paid
2. Post-paid
4. How long that you use your mobile phone per day (approximately)?
1. Less than 1 hours
2. 1-4 hours
3. 4-8 hours
5. How do you know about True Move before you use? (choose only 1)
1. Newspaper/ Magazines
2. Parents/Relatives
3. Television
4. Friends
6. Others
6. What is the first thing come to your mind when talk about True Move?
1. High speed internet
2. Reasonable price
3. Promotion Effectiveness
4. Good signal
5. Others
7. How much do you spent for mobile phone per month approximately?
1. Less than 400 baht
2.
3.
4 = Agree
3 = Neutral
Strongly Disagree
5
8. Tangibles
8.1 True Move has up-to-date equipment.
8.2 True Move store facilities are eye-catching.
8.3 True Move staff is well dressed and neat in appearance.
8.4 True Move store decorations are suitable with the type
of services provided.
8.5 Overall, the quality of True Move in tangibles area, such
as equipment and appearance is good.
9. Reliability
9.1 When True Move promises to do something, it does so.
9.2 When customer has problems, True Move is supportive
to customer and shows sincere interest in solving problems.
9.3 True Move is trustworthy.
9.4 True Move provides services at the time it promises.
9.5 True Move keeps statement accurately.
9.6 Overall, service reliability of True Move is good.
10. Responsiveness
10.1 True Move tells you exactly when services will be
performed.
10.2 You are received prompt service from True Move staff.
10.3 True Move staff are always willing to help you.
10.4 True Move staff can promptly response to your
requests even when they are busy.
10.5 Overall, service responsiveness of True Move is good.
11. Assurance
11.1 True Move staff can be trusted.
11.2 You feel safe to use the service of True Move.
xi
xiii
I like
it
It is
basic
need
I dont
care
I can
live
dislike
with it
it
xiv
2. Female
36. Nationality
1. Thai
2. Non-Thai
37. Age
1. Less than 18
2. 18-35
3. 36-50
4. More than 50
2. In relationship
4. Divorce
39. Occupation
1. Student
2. Freelancer/Self-employed
3. Private-employed
5. Business Owner
6. Unemployed
4. Government-employed
7. Others
40. Monthly Allowance
1. Less than 10,000 Baht
2. 10,000 30,000 Baht
3. 30,001 50,000 Baht
4. 50,001 100,000 Baht
5. More than 100,000 Baht
Thank You
xvi
____________________________________________________
1
1.
_____________________________________
2.
(3)
3.
1.
2.
4.
1.
3. 4-8
5.
2. 1-4
4.
1.
/
3.
5. Social network/ Internet
6.
(
)
2.
4.
6.
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
/
7.
1.
2.
5.
7.
400
400 700
701 1,000
1,000
xvii
5=
4=
3=
2=
1=
8.1
8.2
8.3
8.4
8.5
9.1
9.2
9.3
9.4
9.5
9.6
10.1
10.2
10.3
10.4
10.5
11.1
11.2
11.3
11.4
11.5
13.
.1
13.2
13.3
xviii
13.4
13.5
14.
13.1
13.2
13.3
13.4
14.1
14.2
14.3
14.4
15.1
15.2
15.3
16.1
16.2
16.3
17.1
17.2
17.3
xix
It is
basic
need
()
I can
live
dislike
with it
it
18a.
18b.
19a. 3G
19b. 3G
20a. Wi-Fi
20b. Wi-Fi
21a.
21b.
22a. 24
22b. 24
23a. ()
/
15
23b. ()
/15
24a.
24b.
25a.
25b.
xx
26a.
26b.
27a.50%
27b. 50%
28a.
28b.
29a.
500
(100 )
29b. 500
(100 )
30a.
30b.
31a.
31b.
32a. 4G
32b. 4G
33a.
33b.
34a.
34b.
xxi
35.
1.
36.
1.
2.
2.
37.
1.
18
3. 36-50
38.
1.
3.
39.
1.
3.
5.
7.
2. 18-35
4.
50
2.
4.
2.
4.
6.
40.
/
1.
10,000
2. 10,000 30,000
3. 30,001 50,000
4. 50,001 100,000
5.
100,000
xxii