Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
1 of 4
http://www.expertctr.com/ch_5.php
4/21/2014 1:37 AM
2 of 4
http://www.expertctr.com/ch_5.php
bubbles that can migrate into a pump en masse and cause problems when ingested. Often, the
problem occurs when a second pump is started and the rapid velocity increase causes a pump to suck
in an air bubble that formed in the piping.
To reduce the formation of big air bubbles, eccentric fittings should be used in the suction line with
the top of the pipe remaining "flat". The pipe can also be pitched slightly up toward the pump to
encourage small bubbles to be steadily metered into the pump.
Avoid vertical risers into multiple pumps off a common header for pumps that cycle. The riser to an
idle pump will slowly fill with air as its neighbor operates.
Discharge piping is less critical but like all piping should be installed as symmetrically as possible on
multi-cell installations to provide a naturally balanced flow throughout the system. Cooling towers
with gravity flow hot water basins that accept water directly from elevated piping must have flow
control valves to allow field adjustment. Even then, flow balance is typically diffcult. It is better to
have the main discharge header below the tower with risers to the individual inlets. Systems with
spray nozzles, on the other hand, display a natural tendency to balance and don't require flow control
valves unless the towers are woefully asymmetrical or of different style or height.
When headering multiple cooling towers together, the system designer must connect the basins
together with an equalizer line. This line is necessary no matter how symmetrical the piping. Even if
the inlet and outlet flows to each tower are perfectly matched, it can be demonstrated that they will
soon become imbalanced if one nozzle collects some debris or something like a plastic sandwich
wrapper gets caught in a strainer. One basin would begin to overflow while the other became dry. A
generously sized equalizer line will combat any imbalances and essentially force the sump levels to be
nearly equal. It is common to assume for design purposes that an equalizer will flow 15% of the water
to the largest cell , that a difference in level of 1/2" is acceptable, and that the equalizer line pressure
drop is equivalent to 50' of straight pipe. The resultant equalizer sizes are tabulated here. This is one
manufacturer's sizing criteria and it has been demonstrated to work over many years.
123-239
240-627
628-1167
1168-1925
10
1926-2820
12
2821-3465
14
2336-3850
(2)10
3851-5640
(2)12
5641-6930
(2)14
Since the equalizer line will equalize the water levels, it is critical that the design operating level of each tower be at the same elevation. It
may be necessary to locate the base of one cooling tower slightly higher than its neighbor when they are of different styles or made by
different manufacturers.
The operating levels must be ascertained from the manufacturer(s). Maintenance manuals should give this information. Do not assume
operating levels based on apparent overflow levels.
It is not appropriate to expect a suction line to perform as an equalizer- even if it is oversized.
When mixing blow-thru and draw-thru towers, locate the operating levels of blow-thru towers about 1in. below the operating levels of
draw-thru towers to help account for the affect of the blow-thru towers fan on water level. This figure helps optimize the tower elevations.
Fan cycling, two speed motors and VFDs on blow-thru towers prevent selection of a perfect elevation difference. When possible, run
the blow-thru towers full speed and limit fan speed control to the draw-thru towers.
Equalizer lines that exit the cold water sump from the bottom tend to collect debris and become restricted over time. It is, therefore, a
good idea to provide removable flanges at the ends of the horizontal pipe run for clean out.
The elevation and inlet pressure requirements for multiple water inlets should also be considered when mixing cooling towers. Open
gravity hot water basins should always be very close in elevation. Otherwise, the flow will favor the lowest basins. And, while flow control
valves can correct for small height differences, such valve settings will be good for a particular flow only and lower basins will again be
favored under reduced flow conditions.
Multiple gravity flow tower inlets at different elevations can be made to balance properly by pumping the water to a point above the highest
inlet and letting the water fall- not siphon- into the individual inlets. Siphoning can be prevented by venting the top of the inlet to the
atmosphere.
Even when multiple gravity flow inlets are at the same level, equal flow distribution is hard to achieve. Keep the main supply header below
the operating level of the towers cold water basin and branch off to the individual inlets. This way, the branch flow originates where there
is considerable back pressure causing more even flow distribution.
Similarly, spray tree water distribution systems should be close to the same level and fitted with nozzles requiring the same spray
pressure.
The worst case would occur when mixing crossflow (draw-thru, gravity water distribution) towers with counterflow (blow-thru, spray tree)
towers. The designer must be extremely careful. In general, avoid mixing tower types whenever possible.
Turn-down is another consideration. This is the difference in maximum and minimum flow rate that any cooling tower can be expected to
see. It is common for cooling towers to accommodate reduced flow rates during low load situations.
Cooling towers like to see the flow for which their water distribution systems were designed. They are typically forgiving for small
increases or decreases in flow but the designer should always make sure that his maximum and minimum flows can be accommodated. It
4/21/2014 1:37 AM
3 of 4
http://www.expertctr.com/ch_5.php
would not be correct to look in a manufacturer's brochure and assume that it is satisfactory to operate a cooling tower at any flow
between the maximum and minimum figures indicated. What isn't apparent is that there may be as many as six different nozzle
combinations required for the entire flow regime indicated. The astute designer will tell the manufacturer the maximum and minimum flow
he expects for each tower and confirm that the application is appropriate. Manufacturer's can juggle nozzle sizes and types in order to
optimize the water distribution system for the flow requirements of specific projects.
When the inlet flow rate to a cooling tower becomes too low, it is appropriate to shut off selected cells in order to force more water into
others. This keeps the wetdeck drenched thereby preventing scale and ice formation. It also prevents a sharp rise in CFM due to the
reduced restriction offered by reduced water flow reducing any tendency to "spit" -- fling water droplets out of the cooling tower. Finally, it
will prevent possible fan motor overloading on centrifugal fan cooling towers.
Don't forget that when one water inlet is closed, the corresponding water outlet must also be closed. Otherwise, a major imbalance will
occur between cells that even a generously sized equalizer cannot overcome. (Remember, equalizers are typically sized for 15% of the
flow to one cell -- not 100%)
Bypass is an outmoded method of capacity control that isn't often seen. This is the practice of diverting a portion of the water from the
tower inlet into the tower basin as a method of capacity control. Regulating airflow is the best way to control capacity, not water flow.
Bypasses shouldn't be used because of their turn down limitations and inability to conserve fan horsepower. They are, however,
acceptable for short lived situations for systems employing centrifugal chillers and the like to prevent unnecessarily cold water at start-up.
Don't skimp on isolation valves- particularly on projects with multiple cells where the system must run 24/7. The inability to fully isolate a
cell can be a real problem when it is necessary to perform repairs- such as applying coatings- and water continues to seep into the tower
from the inlet, outlet or equalizer.
Make sure there is enough city water pressure at the cooling tower to satisfy make-up and reasonable quick-fill requirements. 15 psi is
the typical minimum.
Also, make sure the pressure isn't too high. If it exceeds approximately 50 psi, a pressure reducing valve should be installed. Too much
pressure can pin a mechanical make-up valve open and can make solenoid make-up valves prone to water hammer.
Water hammer in the make-up line is difficult to predict. When it occurs, it can be addressed several ways:
-Add a globe valve or fixed orifice at the discharge end of the make-up valve to provide some back pressure.
-Add a vertical air column in the make-up line to act as an air cushion.
-Reroute the make-up line changing its length so as to cause a change in its natural frequency. Orienting this line in X, Y, and Z
directions makes it more shock absorbent.
-Install a commercially available shock arrester.Or finally,
-Use a Cla or Griswold type pilot operated make-up valve; they are naturally slow closing and therefore less likely to cause water hammer.
Sizing the make-up line is relatively easy. Calculate the evaporation rate, double it as a generous allowance for bleed and select the line
for about 7 feet/second velocity.
A quick-fill connection is a good idea to get the tower back on line quickly and assist in overfilling the sump prior to initial start-up.
Adding a bleed connection capable of handling the evaporation rate is a good idea to facilitate the water treater who will want a place to
bleed water from the system. It should be high to keep from draining the system should the bleed valve stick open. To insure enough
pressure, place this fitting about 6' below the inlet of a gravity water distribution tower.
Routing the bleed line to a convenient "open sight" drain will benefit the water treater allowing him to measure the bleed rate with a bucket
and stopwatch.
When installing a tower, jack any vibration isolators down to the operating height before fitting the pipework. Then, when the tower is filled
with water and the jack screws backed off, there will be no undue misalignment of the flex connections. Without flex connections, the rigid
piping will "ground out" the isolation and defeat its effectiveness.
All piping connections to the cooling tower basin such as quick-fills, equalizers, filter connections, etc., should be factory ordered so as
to maintain the integrity of the corrosion protection system on steel cooling towers. Welding to the basin can burn off protective zinc.
When connections must be added in the field, it is best to weld the appropriate fitting to a plate, galvanize it (if the tower is galvanized),
and bolt this subassembly to the tower to minimize damage.
Stainless steel basins have stainless steel connection fittings that can be welded to mild steel piping using welding rod 308-16.
CLOSED CIRCUIT FLUID COOLER piping considerations for closed systems are fairly straightforward.
First, select pipe that is large enough so as not to create excessive pressure drop. Typically velocities near 7ft/sec fill this need.
Also important is the need to provide fill and vent fittings in the piping. The vent must be at the highest point in the system.
The fill is typically at the bottom and the fluid pumped into the system to prevent 'burping' during filling.
The piping must be arranged so that it will fill without trapping air. Pitch the piping slightly to ensure that all air will migrate to the top during
filling.
Secondary vents should be added at strategic locations where air traps cannot be avoided.
Include a pot feeder for the addition of chemicals. Connect it in parallel with the system pump and isolate it with valves. Opening the
valves causes system fluid to circulate through the pot feeder thereby introducing chemicals into the system. Be sure to fill the pot feeder
with water before opening the valves to avoid the introduction of air.
An expansion tank is needed to absorb the fluid volumetric changes that will occur due to temperature changes in a closed system. The
ASHRAE Systems Handbook and various expansion tank manufacturers give descriptions of various tank types along with sizing
methods.
Rather than make the calculation, call any expansion tank rep and be prepared to advise system volume, fluid (water, glycol, etc.), max
temp, system height, initial fill temp, elevation, type of piping (copper or steel) and system pressure. They have computer programs that
make tank selection easy.
Generally, it is best to use a diaphragm type tank to protect the integrity of the system fluid and because it doesn't have to be installed at
the highest point in the system. Unlike a cooling tower, a fluid cooler does not have to be installed as the highest system component.
4/21/2014 1:37 AM
4 of 4
http://www.expertctr.com/ch_5.php
For years it has been customary for system water to enter from the top of a closed circuit tower and be cooled as it progresses 'down'
through the inside of the coil toward the outlet. Spray water covers the outside of the coil while fans direct air 'up' and around the coil's
outer surfaces. The coldest air and spray water are at the bottom of the coil where the air quickly assumes near wet bulb temperature just
after entry. This counterflow arrangement is the most efficient allowing the coldest air to extract maximum heat from the system water just
prior to exiting.
Some newer closed circuit designs reduce the coil size, add conventional cooling tower wet deck and pump the cold water leaving the wet
deck over the top of the coil. For this design, it is necessary to reverse the direction of water through the coil to maintain the most
efficient counterflow arrangement.
Manufacturers place large 'inlet' and 'outlet' stickers near their coil connections but just remember piping is no longer a 'no brainer'.
To calculate the required volume of Ethylene Glycol as a percentage of weight or determine freeze/boil points, see the Glossary.
4/21/2014 1:37 AM