Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
Prepared for
Jennifer Riegert
COMM 363
Written Communication in Organizations
Xavier University
Prepared by
Amy Windhorst
English Major
Xavier University
Xavier University
3800 Victory Parkway
Cincinnati, OH 45207
December 9, 2009
ii
CONTENTS
1
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
Patrick Tucker (2009), “The beginning of 2009 saw the greatest decline in
newspaper profitability in U.S. history” (pg. 8). Current difficulties come from
news on any topic at any time. The internet has also vastly diminished
shrunk if not disappeared; The Washington Post Co.’s newspaper division lost
$53.8 million in the first quarter of 2009; during the same time period, The
New York Times Co. lost $74.5 million (Rieder, 2009). Circulation is down
more than 5% from this time ten years ago (U.S. Census Bureua, 2006).
As a result of this decline, many news outlets are significantly cutting back
on their newsroom staff. New problems arise once staff cuts have been
fear that this is inhibiting the news industry’s role as political watchdog and
social informant.
million and 22 million visitors per month (Pontin, 2009). However, attracting
an audience nearly 14 times as large as its print circulation only accounts for
12% of The New York Times Co.’s revenue (Callahan, 2008). The inability for
In order to combat the many problems facing them, the news industry needs
legislation, and ultimately figure out how to make the internet a source of
revenue.
Those interested in breaking into the news writing field need to maintain
I. INTRODUCTION
A. Report Goals
American newspaper and news writing industry for a college audience. The
report will examine recent trends in news consumption, the opinions of both
scholarly and popular sources, and will also feature input from professionals
news writing industry itself and students who are interested in advancing in
the industry. The report will demonstrate why news journalism is an essential
Sometimes described as the “Fourth Estate,” journalism has played the role
Tucker, 2009, pg. 8). The relay of non-partisan, investigative, and hard-
American democracy. Paul Starr (2009) points to the closing of the Cincinnati
Post, which, due to the loss of regular community coverage, “reduce[d] voter
turnout and the likelihood that challengers can unseat incumbents. Other
studies suggest that when news diminishes, corruption increases” (pg. 53).
Since the first newspaper was published in the 17th century, news writing and
journalism has been a significant facet of our culture, politics, businesses and
publication in the United States—this number only grew as the century went
the late 19th century, photography was also incorporated into print
Thriving into the 20th century, the print industry had dominion over news
Circulation of newspapers has seen steady decline since the early 1900’s. In
owned newspaper businesses went public (Jost, 2006). This, however, has
pressure that some argue has “softened” news writing in America (Jost,
2006). This pressure has also placed many news organizations in a state of
crisis near the end of the 20th century and the beginning of the 21st. With the
advent of the internet, the print industry has suffered an accelerated loss of
around the country (Jost 2006). Under pressure from shareholders to boost
profits while simultaneously reeling from the loss of readers and advertisers
to online sources, large companies such as The New York Times Co. and
Knight Ridder were forced to cut back hundreds of positions (Jost 2006).
Paradoxically, most newspapers were still making profits during that time—
the industry was financially healthy, even excelling (Jost 2006). However, this
newspaper profitability in U.S. history” (pg. 8). The Washington Post Co.’s
newspaper division lost $53.8 million in the first quarter of 2009; during the
6
same time period, The New York Times Co. lost $74.5 million (Rieder, 2009).
Such losses have forced many newspapers around the country to cease
printing. Fig. 1.0 shows the steady decline of American newspapers since the
and the Christian Science Monitor, both of which discontinued their print
versions.
Currently, many newspapers are looking to the World Wide Web as their
profits equal to those from print media. One of the largest issues in the
industry is how to harness these millions of readers and turn them into
advertising dollars.
7
investigative reporters are still trying to find their place among a “softer”
and faster moving news industry. News writers must also take on more roles
audience.
A. Finances
According to the U.S. Census Bureau (2008) (Fig. 2.0), America’s newspaper
industry was still making profits in the mid-2000’s. The gap between
revenues and expenses could be seen narrowing slightly in 2006; for the
despite competition from the internet. Paul Farhi (2006) called newspapers’
apparently not enough for investors who’ve come to expect even higher
40,000
million in the first quarter of
0
2004 2005 2006
same period (Rieder, 2009). The following statistics indicate just a few of the
• Revenue from print editions was down nearly 30% in the first quarter
• Classified ad purchases fell 42% in the first quarter of 2009, likely due
While steep declines in advertising revenues make the situation appear grim,
B. Circulation
9
been in decline since 1985 (Fig. 2.1). As the figure shows, the number of
papers sold daily in the U.S. has decreased nearly 10% since 1960.
Statistics from the U.S. Census Bureau (2006, 2008) show similar declines.
Daily newspaper circulation was fairly stable from 1980 to 1990; however,
with the rise of the internet throughout the 90’s, a trend of steeper decline
60
55
50
45
1980 1990 1995 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006
While almost all newspapers have reported losses in circulation in past years,
specific types of newspapers have struggled more than others. Figure 2.3
their audience has decreased in recent years. Evening papers have seen the
60
Morning
40 Evening
20 Sunday
0
1970 1980 1985 1990 1995 2000 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007
C. Readership
11
One of the largest concerns plaguing newspapers is not only the decline in
readership, as evidence by Fig. 2.4, but the increasing age of the average
online sources for news (or no news at all) rather than subscribe to
newspapers. Jost’s figure shows just how steep the decline has been since
While the figures provided by the U.S. Census Bureau (Fig. 2.5) are slightly
more optimistic (65% of 18-24 year-olds say they’ve read a newspaper in the
past week), it still indicates that newspapers are still most popular among an
older audience.
12
0 55 - 64 years old
2007 65+ years old
D. Employment
2004 (as cited in “Who Killed the,” 2006). Over the past five years,
• The Chicago Tribune shut down its City News wire service as part of a
• The Los Angeles Times cut 10% of its work force (Callahan, 2008).
• Gannet Co., publisher of USA Today, cut 3,000 jobs (Callahan, 2008).
Laura Bishop, reporter and videographer for the Cincinnati Enquirer, also
noted cutbacks in the newsroom. “In the features department, we had more
than twice the reporters and editors we have now, and we had a standalone
features section–it’s now part of the Local section,” said Bishop. “Everyone
writes a little bit of everything, and we’re all much busier than we used to
be.” As a result of the cutbacks, which included both staff writers and staff
veterans, Enquirer reporters now have less time to write stories and are no
regularly obtain news from the internet is significantly larger than among
older age groups (with the exception of 30-49 year-olds) (Fig. 3.1).
Jason Pontin (2009) notes, “the number of people who read newspapers and
million visitors per month (compared to their circulation of just one million).
Pontin also estimates that on any day, 32 million Americans go online to get
their news.
While these numbers are optimistic, it is useful to note that many newspaper
providers still have intense competition once they break the digital barrier.
15
Sites such as Google News, Yahoo!, and other aggregate news sources
newspaper sites.
(2006) writes that “the current Web-publishing model that newspapers are
16
using isn’t likely to become financially viable anytime soon” (pg. 174). James
O’Shea, the managing editor of the Chicago Tribune says that “no one has
figured out how to finance news-gathering on the web” (as cited by Farhi,
2006, pg. 30). Even Jason Pontin (2009), who optimistically cites the growth
of online readership, agrees that newspapers need to figure out “how to pay
Still, online’s future is looking brighter than that of print, even if the medium
revenue—an optimistic start for newspapers trying to grow their business via
the web.
As the news transitions to the digital side, several different formats are
stories that are simply transferred from their print format to a digital
one. This format is still used but not as popular as it once was (Jost,
2006).
17
post content at any time. Blogs are seen as more “personal” and have
(Jost, 2006).
2006).
often coupled with other multimedia, and more open to audience discussion
and response.
Kerry Duke (2009), the managing editor of KYPost.com, says that today’s
reports for not only television, but for 4 different websites as well.”
Journalists are expected not only to write, but to be able to photograph, take
multiple roles.
While this means a lot more work for journalists, Duke points out that there
are many positive aspects of having one journalist control many facets of a
story. “The reporters, as storytellers, can have a lot more control over the
story if they see that story through from start to finish,” said Duke. “The
whole presentation will have a lot more continuity and will be more powerful
Not only do journalists have more control over content—so do the readers.
Print formats are experimenting with new layouts and editorial tactics that
(2008) notes that bloggers don’t need an editor to tell them what the readers
want—“they already know, because the readers are on their blogs, telling
them who they are and what they’re curious about” (pg. 51). This new breed
of interactivity also allows journalists to “put the call out” for information and
sources from readers, where the audience is actually providing the news
Journalists have the opportunity to function without news outlets and editors,
develop their own audiences, and create their own content (Hirschorn,
2006). Many see this “civic journalism” as a way for any individual—not just
the newsroom. As a result, quality goes down, and [then] circulation goes
down, and you leave an opportunity for competitors to come into the market,
leading to taking more resources out of the newsroom” (as cited in Jost,
capacity has already been severe, limiting news outlets’ abilities to carry out
their democratic duties towards the American public. After layoffs at the
Hartford Courant, Karen Hunter wrote that “there is no way that a news staff
that has been reduced by more than 120 people in 10 years…can produce
the same newspaper it once did” (as cited by Farhi, 2006, pg. 29). Because
Paul Starr (2009), meanwhile, sees a shift towards partisan reporting as the
The downward trend in readership means that only those with vested
interests in political parties will be left reading and funding the news.
Newspapers are not the only medium that concerns those in the industry.
Many experts fear that making the transition to the internet will spell out
serious changes in the way news reporting is carried out and delivered—and
University, says that online stories will be shorter and less substantive, with
hard news concerning politics and the government being replaced by stories
This trend can already be seen in blogging practices. Paul Bradshaw (2008)
notes that journalist bloggers are more likely to pursue rumors while doing
However, Kerry Duke (2009) of the KYPost.com—a company that has made
the leap across the digital divide—claims that the standards of “good”
journalism still hold. “I still believe that the basics of good news writing have
not changed, despite the other changes that have been going on,” he said.
21
The Economist (2006) also believes that newspapers’ decline isn’t going to
companies such as the New York Times and the Wall Street Journal as being
A. Key Points
and Craigslist.com.
• New roles for those still in the news writing field, including use of
B. Conclusions
22
The role of journalism has traditionally been one of the watchdog and the
maintain their readers, their advertisers, and their workforce. The one-two
punch of the rise of the internet and the economic recession has seen an
significant as news print has begun losing money. Though young news-
seekers still exist, news outlets have yet to figure out how to turn this young,
can be offered for restructuring the news writing industry. These include:
in the future.
private ownership.
news. However, it is still one way that news outlets might consider
For those looking to enter the news writing industry at such turbulent times,
• Consider independent journalism: The internet has opened the door for
way to interact with readers from around the world with similar
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
REFERENCES
Bradshaw, P. (2008). When Journalists Blog: How It Changes What They Do.
Callahan, S. (2008, Nov. 10). Bad News for Newspapers. B to B, 93. Retrieved
Farhi, P. (2006, Feb.). Under Siege. American Journalism Review, 28, 26-31.
Rieder, R. (2009, June). Fears for the Future. American Journalism Review,
database.
Review, 48, 53. Retrieved Dec. 4, 2009, from Communication & Mass
Tucker, P. (2009). Newspapers Face the Final Edition. The Futurist, 43, 8-9.
http://www.census.gov/compendia/statab/
http://www.census.gov/compendia/statab/
http://www.census.gov/compendia/statab/
http://www.census.gov/compendia/statab/
Who Killed the Newspaper? (2006). Economist, 380, 9-10. Retrieved Dec. 4,