Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
An introduction
to groups
syllabus ref
efer
erence
ence
Core topic:
Introduction to groups
In this cha
chapter
pter
4A
4B
4C
4D
Groups
The terminology of groups
Properties of groups
Further examples of groups
transformations
166
M a t h s Q u e s t M a t h s C Ye a r 1 1 f o r Q u e e n s l a n d
Groups
Up until now, when you used the term algebra you probably thought of variables and
operations with those variables. However, algebra exists in a wide variety of forms,
from Boolean algebra to group algebra. In its most simple form it can be thought of as
the science of equations.
At this stage in your mathematics studies you would be familiar with the use of
classical algebra to solve equations such as x2 9 = 0, yielding the solutions of x = 3.
However, in the 19th century, mathematicians gradually realised that mathematical
symbols did not necessarily have to stand for numbers, if anything at all! From this
idea, modern or abstract algebra arose.
Modern algebra has two main uses:
1. to describe patterns or symmetries that occur in
nature and mathematics, such as different crystal
formations of certain chemical substances
2. to extend the common number systems to
other systems.
In algebra, symbols that can be manipulated are elements of some set and the manipulation is done by performing certain operations
on elements of that set. The set involved is
referred to as an algebraic structure. The symbols
may represent the symmetries of an object, the position
of a switch, an instruction to a machine or design of a statistical experiment. These
symbols may then be manipulated using the familiar rules used with numbers.
A group is a system of elements with a composition satisfying certain laws.
It is hoped that this brief introduction to groups expands your understanding of the
versatile and all-encompassing concept of algebra. The following section of work fits
into this field of study by virtue of the fact that it deals with symbols and operations.
Algebraic structures
Research the topic of algebraic structures examining early algebraic systems that
developed in ancient civilisations such as the Indian, Arabic, Babylonian, Egyptian
and Greek. Highlight differences and similarities among the various forms.
But first a new tool to help you deal with some notions used in groups.
Modulo arithmetic
Not to be confused with the modulus of a number (see chapter 1 on real numbers, R,
where the modulus of 4, written | 4 | = 4), modulo arithmetic uses a finite number
system with a finite number of elements. This is sometimes referred to as clock
arithmetic because of the similarities with reading the time on an analog clock.
167
Consider reading the time shown on the clock face to the right.
Whether it is 2 am or 2 pm we would say it is 2 oclock,
but in 24-hour time the 2 pm would be 1400 hours. In effect
we have subtracted 12 hours from the 1400 (14 hours) to give
an answer of 2. In this case we say that 2 is the residue, or
what is left over when 12 hours is subtracted from the 14.
11 12
1
2
10
9
4
7
WORKED Example 1
Draw up a Cayley Table that shows the residues using addition modulo 4.
THINK
1
WRITE/DRAW
0
1
2
3
0
1
2
3
0
1
2
3
0
1
2
3
1
2
3
0
2
3
0
1
3
0
1
2
0
1
2
3
168
M a t h s Q u e s t M a t h s C Ye a r 1 1 f o r Q u e e n s l a n d
remember
remember
4A
4.1
SkillS
HEET
Groups
b mod 9
mod 11.
3 Draw up a Cayley Table that shows the residues for each of the following:
a addition mod 6
1
b multiplication mod 4
c multiplication mod 5.
WORKED
Example
Definition of terms
Groups that we will deal with consist of a system that involves a set of elements (often
numbers) and a binary operation. Lower case letters: a, b, c are used to refer to
elements of the set and the symbol denotes whatever operation is involved.
For a non-empty set of elements S = {a, b, c, } involved in the binary operation
to be a group, G = [S, ], the following properties must hold.
169
1 Closure
An operation is closed if the result of that operation is an element of the same set
as the 2 inputs.
For example 2 + 3 = 5 could be written 2 3 where S = {Real numbers} (or R) and
is
the operation of addition.
This operation is closed because 5 R
But consider 2 3 = 1 where S = {Natural numbers} (or N) and is the operation of
subtraction. Because the result (1) is not a member of the set of natural numbers this
operation is not closed. That is, the answer is not part of the initial set of natural
numbers.
2 Associativity
If an operation is associative, the order in which operations are performed does
not affect the answer.
Often brackets are employed to determine the order of operations.
For example, consider (2 3) 4 and 2 (3 4)
(2 3) 4 = 6 4
2 (3 4) = 2 12
= 24
= 24
In this case, both answers are the same. Note that only the position of the brackets
changes and the order of the numbers remains the same.
But consider the operation of division:
(20 2) 4
and
20 (2 4)
= 10 4
= 20 0.5
= 2.5
= 40
Here the answers are not the same.
Division, like subtraction, is not associative. You would have realised this in your
earlier junior mathematics studies.
3 Identity
For all elements of a set, if a unique element exists in the set such that a u = a
then u is the identity element (IE) for that operation.
That means that there is only one element that leaves every element unchanged when
the operation has been applied.
For example, 3 + 0 = 3 then 0 is the identity element for addition (IE+) for real
numbers.
However, 3 0 = 0 so 0 is not the identity element for real numbers under the operation
of multiplication.
Note: The one identity element must work for all elements of the set so 5 + 0 = 5
and 8 + 0 = 8.
4 Inverse
For each element of a set there is a unique element a1 such that a a1 = u where
u is the identity element for that operation.
Unique means that every element has only one inverse.
2 1--2- = 1 where 1 is the identity element for multiplication (IE)
Therefore 1--2- is the multiplicative inverse of 2.
Now consider 2 + 2 = 0 where 0 is IE+; in this case 2 is the additive inverse of 2.
However, note that the set involved here would have to be integers (that is, both positive and negative) not just whole numbers because 2 {Whole numbers}.
170
M a t h s Q u e s t M a t h s C Ye a r 1 1 f o r Q u e e n s l a n d
Commutativity
If the order of the elements involved has no effect on the outcome, then the operation is
commutative.
For example
2 5 = 10
and
5 2 = 10
Hence multiplication with real numbers is commutative. Note the stated condition,
with real numbers because you have already worked with matrices where multiplication in not commutative.
However, consider 10 2 = 5 and 2 10 = 0.2
So division is not commutative. You would be familiar with other operations as well
that are not commutative.
WORKED Example 2
Find a the identity element and b inverse for the operation defined as a b = a + b + 2.
THINK
WRITE
b Therefore a + b + 2 = 2
(where b is the inverse of a and 2 = IE from
part a)
a + b = 4
b = 4
WORKED Example 3
Find the identity element for the operation defined as
a + b = a.
THINK
WRITE
a +b =a
let b = IE
Square both sides:
a2 + b2 = a2
therefore
b2 = 0
and
b = 0 therefore IE = 0
171
History of mathematics
NIELS HENRIK ABEL (18021829)
During his life . . .
Lord Byron, the
English poet,
writes Don Juan.
Napoleon
Bonaparte
becomes
emperor of
France.
Jean-Baptiste
Lamarck, the
French biologist,
proposes that
acquired traits are
inherited by individuals in a population.
Questions:
1. How did Abel financially support his
family?
2. Which property do groups bearing his
name exhibit?
remember
remember
A set S forms a group under the operation if and only if (iff) all of the
following are true:
1. it is closed under ; that is, the result is an element of S
2. the order in which operations are performed has no effect on the results; that is,
it is associative
3. there is only 1 identity element (IE), u, such that a u = a
4. there is a unique inverse a1 for every element such that a a1 = u, where
u = IE.
5. If the property of commutativity also holds, then it is an Abelian group.
4B
a+b
1 a Show that a b = ------------ is not closed with respect to whole numbers.
2
b State its identity element.
2
172
WORKED
Example
M a t h s Q u e s t M a t h s C Ye a r 1 1 f o r Q u e e n s l a n d
3 Find a the identity element and b the inverse for the operation on real numbers
where a b = a + b 1.
WORKED
Example
5 The operation a b = 4ab2 is defined for positive real numbers a and b. Find the
identity element for this operation.
a+b
6 Develop a proof to show that a b = ------------ has no identity.
ab
7 An operation is defined with respect to an ordered pair of integers as
(a, b) (c, d) = (ad + bc, bd ). Show that (0, 1) is the identity element for the operation.
8 Show that a b = (a + b)2 has no identity for real numbers.
Properties of groups
WORKED Example 4
WRITE
THINK
WRITE
b Commutativity
a+b=b+a
Therefore the group is Abelian.
173
Note that the test for commutativity is performed last because the first 4 properties are
necessary to state that it is a group in the first place, before it is shown to be Abelian.
This group, G = [Z, +] is an infinite group, having an unlimited set of elements. You
will also deal with finite groups which have a countable number of elements.
WORKED Example 5
Verify that the set of odd integers does not form a group under addition.
THINK
WRITE
Closure: a + b S
Let a = 3 and b = 5
3 + 5 = 8 and 8 S
Therefore G [S, +]
WORKED Example 6
Construct a Cayley Table for [{1, i, 1, i}, ] and determine whether this constitutes a
group.
THINK
1
WRITE
1
i
1
i
Continued over page
174
M a t h s Q u e s t M a t h s C Ye a r 1 1 f o r Q u e e n s l a n d
THINK
2
WRITE
1
i
1
i
1
i
1
i
i
1
i
1
1
i
1
i
i
1
i
1
Leading diagonal
WORKED Example 7
Construct a Cayley Table for [{mod 5}, +] and determine whether it is an Abelian group.
THINK
1
WRITE
+
0
1
2
3
4
0
1
2
3
4
1
2
3
4
0
2
3
4
0
1
3
4
0
1
2
4
0
1
2
3
THINK
175
WRITE
Note: There are 9 axioms that relate to operations and whole numbers that require no
proof: they are assumed to be true. The associativity statement in the example above
relied on one of these axioms and you can state that these axioms have been used.
They are given here with no explanation.
1. Closure Law of Addition
2. Commutative Law of Addition
3. Associative Law of Addition
4. Identity Law of Addition
5. Closure Law of Multiplication
6. Commutative Law of Multiplication
7. Associative Law of Multiplication
8. Identity Law of Multiplication
9. Distributive Law of Multiplication over addition, where a(b + c) = ab + ac
remember
remember
1. To determine whether a set forms a group under an operation () test each of
the four properties; that is, test whether it is closed and associative, whether
there is an identity element and a unique inverse.
2. To determine whether the group is Abelian, show that the operation is
commutative (e.g. a b = b a).
176
M a t h s Q u e s t M a t h s C Ye a r 1 1 f o r Q u e e n s l a n d
4C
4.1
WORKED
Example
SkillS
HEET
Properties of groups
1 a Verify that the set of real numbers, [R, +], forms a group under addition.
b Is this group Abelian?
2 a Consider the set of even numbers (2n) where n Z.
b Does this form a group under addition? (Note: 0 {even numbers})
c Does it form a group under multiplication?
3 Does the set of powers of 1 form a group under:
a addition?
b multiplication?
WORKED
Example
4 Verify that the set of even integers does not form a group under division.
5
WORKED
Example
5 Construct a Cayley Table for [{mod 5 excluding 0}, ] and determine whether this
constitutes a group.
6 a Draw up a Cayley Table for the set of even powers of 2 under addition.
b Does this form a group under addition?
c Does this form a group under multiplication?
WORKED
Example
7 Construct a Cayley Table for [{mod 3}, ] and determine whether it is an Abelian
group.
8 Determine whether each of the tables below forms a group.
a
a
b
c
c
a
b
a
b
c
b
c
a
a
b
c
a
b
c
b
b
b
c
c
a
a
b
c
a
b
c
b
a
d
c
c
a
a
b
c
b
c
a
c
a
b
a
b
c
ET
SHE
4.1
10 The movements of a robot are restricted to no change (N), turn left (L), turn right (R),
turn about (A): { N, L, R, A}. Construct a Cayley Table and show that this set of
movements forms a group.
177
Application of groups
permutations
A symmetry of a square (or any other shape) may be
written as a permutation by changing the positions of
the vertices. For example, referring to the figure at right,
we could write:
P1 = 1 2 3 4 5 and P3 = 1 2 3 4 5
1 2 3 4 5
1 5 4 3 2
Determine whether these permutations form a group under the operation meaning
followed by.
Further examples
of groups
transformations
Consider all the transformations that a shape
could undergo. Rotations about its centre and
reflections about its axes of symmetry involve
changes in the vertices only. Carefully examine
the diagram below. Make sure you understand
the symbols and the new positions of the vertices.
Rotations anticlockwise:
R90 90
R180 180
R270 270
Reflections:
178
M a t h s Q u e s t M a t h s C Ye a r 1 1 f o r Q u e e n s l a n d
D
D
R0
RL
RL
R 90
B
A
B
RL
RR
D
RV
A
C
RH
C
R180
RH
RV
RR
C
D
R 270
WORKED Example 8
Find the result of R180 Rv .
THINK
1
WRITE/DRAW
D
C
B
B
C
THINK
179
WRITE/DRAW
Functions
1
1
Consider functions f(x) = x, g(x) = x, h(x) = --- and k(x) = --- (where x 0).
x
x
When these functions are involved in composition of functions such as g[h(x)], the
function h(x) is substituted as the inner function into the outer function which is g(x).
1
1
That is g[h(x)] = --- where --- (the inner function) is substituted into g(x) which is (x).
x
x
1
Similarly, k[g(x)] = ---------- where g(x) = x (the inner function) is substituted into
(x)
1
1
1
k(x) = --- (the outer function). That is, k[g(x)] = ---------- = --- = h(x).
x
(x) x
WORKED Example 9
1
1
Show that functions f(x) = x, g(x) = x, h(x) = --- and k(x) = --- form a group under
x
x
composition.
THINK
1
WRITE
f
g
h
k
f
g
h
k
g
f
k
h
h
k
f
g
k
h
g
f
Continued over page
180
M a t h s Q u e s t M a t h s C Ye a r 1 1 f o r Q u e e n s l a n d
THINK
WRITE
History of mathematics
A R T H U R C AY L E Y ( 1 8 2 1 1 8 9 5 )
During his life . . .
Thomas Edison
invents the
phonograph.
Slavery is
officially
abolished
throughout the
western world.
Alfred Nobel
invents dynamite.
Arthur Cayley, a famous English mathematician, was born on 16 August 1821. His published mathematical papers are classics and
include discussions on the concept of
n-dimensional geometry. At the age of 25 he
began practising law which he continued to
do until 1863. In his spare time he wrote
more than 300 mathematical papers. In 1863
remember
remember
The binary operation that combines any two transformations (for example,
rotation and reflection) is called composition, when one operation follows another.
181
4D
1 a Draw a Cayley Table for the rotation of an equilateral triangle. Label each vertex.
b Does it form a group? Is it Abelian?
2 a Draw a Cayley Table for the reflections of
an equilateral triangle through each of the
vertices R0, RV, RL, RR.
b Does it form a group?
RL
RR
RV
WORKED
Example
3 Explain what the following diagrams represent about the group shown below.
R240
2 2
31
2
2
2
R240
2 1
33
4 Describe the symmetries of the following figures, using fully annotated diagrams.
a a non-square rectangle
b a non-square rhombus
c an ellipse
5 Consider an infinitely long strip of Hs, printed on transparent paper, as shown below
..H H H H H H .
Describe the axes of symmetry of this group.
6 Locate the axes of symmetry for the following figures.
WORKED
Example
182
M a t h s Q u e s t M a t h s C Ye a r 1 1 f o r Q u e e n s l a n d
matrix
matrix
matrix
matrix
i 0 , where i =
0 i
183
e
a
b
c
b
c
d
e
a
7 Prove that if G is a group such that the square of every element is the identity,
then G is Abelian.
8 Examine whether
a rotations and
b reflections
as stated earlier in this section, form Abelian groups.
9 Quaternions
The concept of a set of elements called quaternions was first developed by the
Irish mathematician, William Hamilton (see page 118). Quaternions are
ordered sets of four ordinary numbers, satisfying special laws of equality,
addition and multiplication. Quaternions are useful for studying quantities
having magnitude and direction in three-dimensional space and this has
enabled great advances in quantum theory, relativity, number theory and group
theory.
The 4 numbers are 1, i, j and k and have the following properties:
12 = 1
i2 = j2 = k2 = ijk = 1
1i = i1
1j = j1
1k = k1
ij = ji = k
i(jk) = (ij)k = ijk
All real and complex numbers do commute with i, j, and k but they are not
commutative with each other.
Follow this example that shows that jk = i
ijk = 1
from the definitions
i ijk = i 1
multiply both sides by i on the left (or pre-multiply
by i)
2
i jk = i
associativity
1 jk = i
from the definitions
1 1 jk = 1 i pre-multiply both sides by 1
jk = i
Because multiplication between these elements is not commutative it is
essential that all multiplication is done from a particular side of an expression
and to perform this multiplication on both sides of the equal sign. You must
respect the order of placement of terms in this system.
a Show that i jk = kj
ii ki = j
b Show that i1 = i
c If q = s + wi + vj + yk and p = m + ni + oj + jk, find the product of the two
quaternions.
184
M a t h s Q u e s t M a t h s C Ye a r 1 1 f o r Q u e e n s l a n d
10 Pauli Matrices
The ideas introduced in the section on quaternions above can be extended to
represent matrices. One 2 2 set is:
1= 1 0
0 1
i=
j=
0 1
1 0
k=
0 1
1
0
While the matrices for i and k might look a little daunting, they can be
simplified by replacing the 1 elements with complex i.
The last three of these matrices are used in the study of quantum theories to
explain and predict the behaviour of electrons. They are called the Pauli Spin
Matrices and students of chemistry will appreciate the importance of the spin
of electrons in atomic bonding and the strength of different materials.
A variation of these matrices used in the study of nuclear physics is shown
below:
P= 1 0
0 1
Q=
0 1
1 0
R = 0 1
1 0
S = 1 0
0 1
T= 0 i
V = i 0
U= i 0
W = 0 i
i 0
0 i
0 i
i 0
On examination of the first and second rows of the matrices above you will
notice that the second row is a reflection of each matrix in the first row,
multiplied by i.
a Construct a Cayley Table to display the results of matrix multiplication
using these 8 matrices. Arrange them in the order given; that is, from P to
W.
b Determine whether the total set forms a group.
c Mark off the top left-hand 4 4 corner. Examine this section of the table
and show that this subset forms a group. This is an example of a subgroup,
where a subset of a group forms a complete group of its own.
11 Internet search
The real life applications of groups are quite complex. Use the internet to
research this field of study. Include a list of distinct topics and a more detailed
report that highlights the use of group theory.
185
summary
Groups
Properties of groups
A set forms a group under an operation if elements of the set are closed and
associative, and there is an identity element and a unique inverse.
The group is an Abelian group if the operation is commutative (e.g. a b = b a).
Transformations
The set of all transformations (for example, rotations and reflections) and the binary
operation that combines any two of these transformations is referred to as a
composition.
186
M a t h s Q u e s t M a t h s C Ye a r 1 1 f o r Q u e e n s l a n d
CHAPTER
review
4B
4C
4C
4 There are two lights in a room, one on the ceiling and one on the wall with 4 possible states
for the two lights both on, both off, wall light on only, or ceiling light on only. There are
4 possible changes of state: no change, both change, ceiling light change and the wall light
change. These changes are denoted by N, CW, C and W respectively. Show that the set
{N, C, CW, W} forms a group with respect to the operation followed by.
4C
4C
4C
7 Determine whether the set of all moves that can be made by a knight on a chessboard forms
a group or not.
8 a Verify that the set m 0 , where m 0 forms a group under matrix multiplication.
0 m
b Verify that all p q matrices form a group under matrix addition.
4D
4D
9 Show that the following set of matrices forms a group under multiplication.
1 0
0 1
4D
CHAPTER
test
yourself
1 0
0 1
i 0
0 i
i 0
0 i
0 1
1 0
0 1
1 0
0 i
i 0
0 i
i 0
10 Determine whether or not the following functions form a group under composition of
functions. Assume that they are associative.
1
1
x
x+1
f3(x) = 1 + x f4(x) = -----------f5(x) = -----------f6(x) = -----------f1(x) = x f2(x) = --x
1+x
x+1
x