Vous êtes sur la page 1sur 4

Progress in NUCLEAR SCIENCE and TECHNOLOGY, Vol. 1, p.

77-80 (2011)

ARTICLE

Reliability Analysis on the Container of Radioactive Material Transport


Based on Monte Carlo

+:CO:0'


 

" "&''('#%'#"%#''#"+(""*%#)" "

$%'!"'# ""%"+&&"&"(")%&'+" "




-=: G:A>67>A>IN D; I=: 8DCI6>C:G D; G69>D68I>K: B6I:G>6A IG6CHEDGI 8DCI6>C:G ;DG H=DGI >H :HH:CI>6A >C G69>D68I>K:
B6I:G>6A IG6CHEDGI H6;:IN  6>AJG: ;JC8I>DC D; I=:8DCI6>C:G 86C 7: 9:9J8:9 7N=>HIDGN G:8DG9H :ME:G>B:CI6A 96I6 DG
DI=:G B:6CH  DCH>9:G>C< I=: G6C9DBC:HH D; B6>C 6HH:HHB:CI E6G6B:I:GH HJ8= 6H B:8=6C>86A HIG:HH A:K:A 6C9 ;>G:
I:BE:G6IJG:>BEDGI6C8:H6BEA>C<&&DCI:6GADH>BJA6I>DCB:I=D9>HJH:9>CI=>HLDG@ID8DBE>A:68DBEJI:G
EGD<G6B>C&-%ID86A8JA6I:8DCI6>C:G;6>AJG:EGD767>A>IN>C68:GI6>C%8DC;>9:C8:A:K:A -=:G:HJAIHH=DL
I=6I & B:I=D9 86C G:EG:H:CI D7?:8I>K: JC8:GI6>CIN D;6HH:HHB:CI E6G6B:I:GH6C9 >I >H 6C :;;:8I>K:8DBEA:B:CIID
=>HIDG>86AG:8DG9H6C9:ME:G>B:CIH 

KEYWORDS: container of radioactive material transport, reliability, Monte Carlo, importance sampling




I. Introduction 1

-=: K6AJ:H D; ;6>AJG: I=G:H=DA9H 6G: JH:9 ID 9:I:GB>C: I=:
8DCI6>C:G ;6>AJG: EGD767>A>IN >C 6C 688>9:CI  -=:G:;DG: I=:
K6AJ:H>BE68II=:;>C6AG>H@<G:6IAN 
-=:G: 6G: I=G:: B:I=D9H ID 68=>:K: ;6>AJG: I=G:H=DA9H D;
I=:8DCI6>C:G (C:>HI=GDJ<=:ME:G>B:CIH6CDI=:G>HI=GDJ<=
I=:DG:I>86A 86A8JA6I>DC I=: I=>G9 >H I=GDJ<= I=: HNCI=:H>HD;
:ME:G>B:CIH6C9I=:DG:I>86A86A8JA6I>DC 
-=DJ<= K6AJ:H D; ;6>AJG: I=G:H=DA9H D; I=: 8DCI6>C:G
9:G>K:9 I=GDJ<= :ME:G>B:CIH 6G: 8G:9>7A: >I 8DHIH IDD BJ8= 
:C:G6AANI=:DG:I>86A86A8JA6I>DCDGHNCI=:H>HD;:ME:G>B:CIH
6C9 I=:DG:I>86A 86A8JA6I>DC >H 69DEI:9 >CI:GC6I>DC6AAN  I
EG:H:CI I=: .C>I:9 ,I6I:H #6E6C 6C9 HDB: JGDE:6C
8DJCIG>:H=6K:9:K:ADE:9HDB:8DGG:HEDC9>C<HD;IL6G:HHJ8=
6H ',2, '%(+ 6C9 !-"'  I=: G:HJAIH D; L=>8=
6<G::L>I=:ME:G>B:CI6A96I6K:GNL:AA 
DG :M6BEA:H :GB6C ,-(+ /
!0 8DCI6>C:G
JH:9 >C !%%0 =><= A:K:A A>FJ>9 L6HI: G6>A IG6CHEDGI 6C9
G:C8= %+ 8DCI6>C:G JH:9 >C !%%0 GD69 IG6CHEDGI I=:>G
;6>AJG:I=G:H=DA9H6G:H=DLC>CTable 1 

H 6C >BEDGI6CI 6HE:8I D; CJ8A:6G H6;:IN G69>D68I>K:


B6I:G>6A IG6CHEDGI H6;:IN =6H 7::C L>9:HEG:69 8DC8:GC:9
>CI:GC6I>DC6AAN  :C:G6AAN G69>D68I>K: B6I:G>6A IG6CHEDGI
H6;:IN 9:E:C9H DC I=: FJ6A>IN D; I=: E68@6<:  DG H6;:IN
( '#"&#%'%"&$#%'##') '% D;
"I6@:HI=:@:ND;H6;:G:A>67>A>IN;DGE68@6<:9:H><C HD
I=:G:A>67>A>IND;I=:8DCI6>C:G>H:HH:CI>6A>CIG6CHEDGIH6;:IN 
,6;:IN
G>H@ 6HH:HHB:CIH ID IG6CHEDGIH D; G69>D68I>K:
B6I:G>6A >C =>C6 6G: >BEDGI6CI I6H@H ;DG :E6GIB:CI D;
!:6AI= )=NH>8H 6C9 'J8A:6G ,6;:IN >C =>C6 "CHI>IJI: ;DG
+69>6I>DC )GDI:8I>DC  -=: G>H@ D; G69>D68I>K: G:A:6H: >C 6
IG6CHEDGI D; G69>D68I>K: B6I:G>6A >H I=: EGD9J8I D; 8DCI6>C:G
;6>AJG:EGD767>A>IN6C9I=:8DCH:FJ:C8:HD;I=:688>9:CI ),
)GD767>A>HI>8H6;:IN6HH:HHB:CIB:I=D9DAD<NL6H6EEA>:9ID
6HH:HHG>H@D;6IG6CHEDGID;G69>D68I>K:B6I:G>6A>CG:;:G:C8:
4 5 !DL:K:G),>H8DBEA>86I:9ID>BEA:B:CI ";688JG68N
D; I=: G:HJAIH >H CDI HIG>8IAN G:FJ>G:9 JH>C< I=: B:I=D9
EGDEDH:9 >C I=>H HIJ9N 8DCI6>C:G ;6>AJG: EGD767>A>IN 86C 7:
9>G:8IAN:HI>B6I:9 -=:C688DG9>C<IDI=:8DCH:FJ:C8:HD;I=:
688>9:CIG>H@6HH:HHB:CID;6IG6CHEDGI86C7::K6AJ6I:9 
DCH>9:G>C< I=: G6C9DBC:HH D; B6>C 6HH:HHB:CI
E6G6B:I:GH HJ8= 6H B:8=6C>86A HIG:HH A:K:A 6C9 ;>G:
I:BE:G6IJG: >BEDGI6C8: H6BEA>C< & H>BJA6I>DC B:I=D9 >H
JH:9 >C I=>H LDG@ ID 8DBE>A: 6 8DBEJI:G EGD<G6B >C
&-% ID 86A8JA6I: 8DCI6>C:G ;6>AJG: EGD767>A>IN >C 6
8:GI6>C% -=>HB:I=D9>HI=:C8DBE6G:9L>I=9>G:8I>CI:<G6A
B:I=D9 


Table 16>AJG:I=G:H=DA9HD;ILD!%%08DCI6>C:GH

"BE68I
>G:
@B
=
B>C
,-(+
 
  
%+
 
 
2. Stress-Strength Model
,IG:HHHIG:C<I= BD9:A 6H H=DLC >C Fig. 1 =6H 7::C
LDGA9L>9:AN HIJ9>:9 >C G:A>67>A>IN :C<>C::G>C<  -=: BD9:A
L6H ;>GHI EGDEDH:9 7N )GD;:HHDG >GC76JB >C .C>K:GH>IN D;
6A>;DGC>6:G@:A:N>C 6C9>I=6H7::CL>9:ANJH:9>C
B6CN ;>:A9H :HE:8>6AAN >C HIGJ8IJG6A 6C6ANH>H 6C9 6K>6I>DC
>C9JHIGN 
:C:G6AAN E=NH>86A FJ6CI>I>:H >BE68I>C< DC HNHI:BH DG
8DBEDC:CIH HJ8= 6H HIG:HH EG:HHJG: I:BE:G6IJG: 6G: 86AA:9
HIG:HH D; HNHI:BH DG 8DBEDC:CIH  -=: :MI:CI D; HNHI:BH DG
8DBEDC:CIHIDL>I=HI6C9HDB:HIG:HH>H86AA:9I=:HIG:C<I=D;
HNHI:BH DG 8DBEDC:CIH  "; I=: HIG:C<I= >H <G:6I:G I=6C I=:


II. Container Failure Probability


1. Failure Thresholds of the Container
-=: HD86AA:9 ;6>AJG: I=G:H=DA9H D; I=: 8DCI6>C:G 6G:
B>C>BJBI:BE:G6IJG: 6C9 B>C>BJB HIG:HH A:K:A >C 6C
688>9:CIL=>8=86CA:69ID8DCI:CIHG:A:6H:>CI=:8DCI6>C:G 

DGG:HEDC9>C<JI=DGB6>ALGO    8DB
Q=>C6 "CHI>IJI: ;DG +69>6I>DC )GDI:8I>DC
Atomic Energy Society of Japan


"BE:C:IG6I>DC
@B
=
 
 

77

78

Renze WANG

*6C9"*>HH=DLC>CFig. 2 -D;68>A>I6I:I=:86A8JA6I>DC
HI6C96G9 9:K>6I>DC D; * >H CDI HI6C96G9 9:K>6I>DC >C G:6A
B:6C>C< 6C9 >I >H :MEG:HH:9 6H I=: HI6C96G9 9:K>6I>DC  D;
"* 

Strength PDF
Stress PDF



Intersection






Stress,Strength

Interference Region



Fig. 1,IG:C<I=BD9:

HIG:HH> : I=:HIG:HH>H>CI=:AD69G6C<:>CI:<G>IND;I=:HNHI:B
DG8DBEDC:CI86C7:B6>CI6>C:9I=:HNHI:BDG8DBEDC:CI>H
67A:ID8DBEA:I:I=:G:FJ>G:9;JC8I>DCH6C9L=>8=>H@CDLC6H
HJ88:HH  "; I=: HIG:C<I= >H A:HH I=6C I=: HIG:HH I=: HIG:HH L>AA
9:HIGDN ;JC8I>DCH DG HIGJ8IJG:H D; I=: HNHI:B DG 8DBEDC:CI
6C9 I=:C G:FJ>G:9 ;JC8I>DCH 86C CDI 7: 8DBEA:I:9 L=>8= >H
@CDLC 6H ;6>AJG:  ,IG:HH 6C9 HIG:C<I= 6G: G6C9DB K6G>67A:H
L=>8= 6G: HJ7?:8I:9 ID HI6I>HI>86A 9>HIG>7JI>DCH 6C9 7DI= D;
I=:B 6G: G:<6G9:9 ID 7: HJ7?:8I:9 ID CDGB6A 9>HIG>7JI>DC >C
B6CN86H:H 
6A8JA6I>DCD;8DCI6>C:G;6>AJG:EGD767>A>IN86C7:76H:9DC
I=:HIG:HHHIG:C<I=BD9:A 
3. Probabilistic Distribution of Stress and Strength
-6@>C< G6>A
GD69 IG6CHEDGIH 6H :M6BEA:H 688DG9>C< ID
EDHH>7A:>BE68I>C<BD9:HI=:G:6G:;>K:8DC9>I>DCH>CKDAK:9
>CG6>A
GD69688>9:CIH> : ;>G:>BE68IEG:HHJG:>BE:C:IG6I>DC
6C9 HJ7B:GH>DC  6>AJG: 6C6ANH>H D; ,-(+ 6C9 %+
8DCI6>C:GH H=DL I=6I L=:I=:G GD69 IG6CHEDGI DGG6>A IG6CHEDGI
DCAN >BE68I 6C9 ;>G: 86C A:69 ID G69>D68I>K: G:A:6H:
688>9:CIH  =6G68I:G>HI>8 E6G6B:I:GH D; >BE68I >CI:CH>IN 6G:
>BE68I HE::9 6C9 6C<A: 6<6>CHI I=: HJG;68:  =6G68I:G>HI>8
E6G6B:I:GHD;;>G:>CI:CH>IN6G:;>G:I:BE:G6IJG:7JGC>C<I>B:
6C9 I=:9>HI6C8: ID I=: ;>G:  DG I=:G:A>67>A>IN 86A8JA6I>DC D;
I=:8DCI6>C:GDCANI=:BDHI>BEDGI6CIDGHNCI=:I>8:;;:8I>K:
8=6G68I:G>HI>8 E6G6B:I:G D; 6C >CI:CH>IN >H 8DCH>9:G:9 L=>A:
I=: DI=:G E6G6B:I:GH 6G: 9:;6JAI  DG :M6BEA:H ;DG >BE68I
DCAN B:8=6C>86A HIG:HH 6<6>CHI I=: 8DCI6>C:G HJG;68: >H
8DCH>9:G:9L=>A:;DG;>G:DCAN;>G:I:BE:G6IJG:>H8DCH>9:G:9
7JGC>C< I>B: >H 9:;6JAI ADC< :CDJ<= 6C9 I=: 9>HI6C8: ID I=:
;>G: >H 9:;6JAI 8ADH: :CDJ<=  &:8=6C>86A HIG:HH 6C9 ;>G:
I:BE:G6IJG:6G:7DI=86AA:9HIG:HH6HB:CI>DC:967DK: 
 ,IG:HH 9>HIG>7JI>DC <:C:G6AAN 688DG9H L>I= CDGB6A
9>HIG>7JI>DC6C9HIG:HH>H9:CDI:97NG6C9DBK6G>67A:L=:G:
>HHJEEDH:9ID7:HJ7?:8I:9ID6CDGB6A9>HIG>7JI>DCL=DH:
B:6C >H  6C9 L=DH: HI6C96G9 9:K>6I>DC >H  6C9 I=:
EGD767>A>IN9:CH>IND;*>H"* 8IJ6AAN7DI=D; B:8=6C>86A
HIG:HH 6C9 ;>G: I:BE:G6IJG: ID I=: 8DCI6>C:G 6G: CDCC:<6I>K: 
"CBDHICDGB6A8>G8JBHI6C8:HI=:G:>HCDB:8=6C>86AHIG:HHDG
;>G: ID I=: 8DCI6>C:G > :  I=: EGD767>A>IN 9:CH>IN D;  >H I=:
B6M>BJB HD HIG:HH >H HJ7?:8I:9 ID 6 CDGB6A 9>HIG>7JI>DC
L=>8= =6H DCAN EDH>I>K: >CI:GK6A  -=6I >H ID H6N 68IJ6AAN
67DK:B:CI>DC:9 ;DG* 6C9;DGCJB7:GCDGB6A>O6I>DC
I=:EGD767>A>IN9:CH>IND;*>H* "* -=:G:A6I>DC7:IL::C

 











 

 




 



Fig. 2 +:A6I>DC7:IL::C;M6C9CM
DCI6>C:G ;6>AJG: I=G:H=DA9 >H :FJ>K6A:CI ID I=: HIG:C<I= >C
I=: HIG:HHHIG:C<I= BD9:A L=>8= >H 9:CDI:9 7N  6C9  >H
HJ7?:8I:9ID6CDGB6A9>HIG>7JI>DC>C<:C:G6A 
) EGD767>A>IN 9:CH>IN ;JC8I>DC D; I=: I=:GB6A
HIG:HH6<6>CHI D 2* BD9:A E68@6<: 6C9 >IH ;6>AJG:
I=G:H=DA9 6G: H=DLC >C Fig. 3  .C>I D; =DG>ODCI6A 67H8>HH6
>H  >C I=: ;><JG: 6C9 K:GI>86A DG9>C6I: >H 8DGG:HEDC9>C< ID
EGD767>A>IN9:CH>IN  







 



 

     

Fig. 3-1 Failure threshold








 

Fig. 3-2 Stress











Intersection











      

Fig. 3-3 Overview






 

Fig. 3-4 Part View

Fig. 3)D;I=:HIG:HH6C9;6>AJG:I=G:H=DA9

D 2* BD9:A E68@6<: L=>8= >H B6CJ;68IJG:9 6C9


C6B:97N6=>C:H:8DBE6CN7:ADC<HID.BD9:AE68@6<:
6C9>I>H9:H><C:96H6:FJ>EB:CI>CHE:8>6AJH:;DGIG6CHEDGID;

D G69>D68I>K: HDJG8: L=>8= >H JH:9 >C  D I:A:I=:G6EN
B68=>C: 6C9 7ADD9 >GG69>6I>DC >CHIGJB:CI  -=: E68@6<:
6EEA>:HIDGD69G6>A6C9H=>EIG6CHEDGIHE68@6<:FJ6CI>IN>C6
IG6CHEDGI >H CDI A>B>I:9 6C9 I=: 9:H><C:9 H:GK>8: A>;: D; I=:
E68@6<:>H N:6GH 
6>AJG: I=G:H=DA9 >H 68=>:K:9 7N 8DB7>C:9 B:I=D9H D;
I=:GB6A :ME:G>B:CI 6C9 H>BJA6I>DC 86A8JA6I>DC 7N
',2,  HD;IL6G:  ME:G>B:CI6A 8DC9>I>DCH 6C9
688:EI6C8: 8G>I:G>6 6G: 688DG9>C< ID ( '#"& #% ' 
%"&$#%' # #') '%       6
=>C:H: C6I>DC6A HI6C96G96C9 ( '#"& #% ' 
%"&$#%' # #') '%  -,+  D; "  >H
PROGRESS IN NUCLEAR SCIENCE AND TECHNOLOGY

Reliability Analysis on the Container of Radioactive Material Transport Based on Monte Carlo

8DCHJAI:9 
Fig. 3-1H=DLH)8JGK:D;I=:;6>AJG:I=G:H=DA9Fig. 3-2
H=DLH ) 8JGK: D; I=: HIG:HH 6C9 Fig. 3-3 H=DLH 6C
DK:GK>:LD;ILD8JGK:HEADII:9>CI=:H6B:G:;:G:C8:;G6B: 
)GD767>A>IN9:CH>IND;I=:HIG:HHC:6GI=:B:6CD;I=:;6>AJG:
I=G:H=DA9 >H HD HB6AA I=6I I=: HIG:HH 8JGK: >H 8ADH: ID
=DG>ODCI6A 6M>H  Fig. 3-4 H=DLH E6GI K>:L D; >CI:G;:G:C8:
G:<>DC L=DH: 6G:6 >C 7A68@ H=69DL >H I=: 8DCI6>C:G ;6>AJG:
EGD767>A>IN;DGI=>HHIG:HH 
4. Expression of Container Failure Probability
"C I=: 76H>8 I=:DGN D; HIGJ8IJG: HNHI:B G:A>67>A>IN ;6>AJG:
;JC8I>DCG:EG:H:CIHHNHI:B;6>AJG:HJG;68: 6>AJG:HJG;68:> : 
A>B>I HI6I: HJG;68: 9>K>9:H I=: HI6I: HE68: >CID ILD E6GIH D;
;6>AJG: HE68:    6C9 H6;: HE68: & -=: HIG:HH 6<6>CHI I=:
8DCI6>C:G>H9:CDI:97NL=>A:I=:I=G:H=DA9>H9:CDI:97N
7DI= D; L=>8= 6G: K:8IDGH ;6>AJG: ;JC8I>DC      >H H=DLC
6H;DAADLH
                          
       &
                
        

-=: G:A>67>A>IN D; I=: 8DCI6>C:G 86C 7: :MEG:HH:9 6H


;DAADLH
&         9          


L=:G:
     >H ) D; I=: HIG:HH >BE68I HIG:HH >H 9:CDI:9 7N
* 6C9 ;>G: I:BE:G6IJG: >H 9:CDI:9 7N * -=:N 6G: G6C9DB
K6G>67A:H >C9:E:C9:CI D; :68= DI=:G       >H H=DLC 6H
;DAADLH
       *    *               
-=: :K6AJ6I>DC D; 8DCI6>C:G ;6>AJG: EGD767>A>IN  >H I=:
@:NED>CI

 



   9 

   

   9       

III. Importance Sampling Monte Carlo Method


-=:>CI:<G6A:FJ6I>DC>HBJAI>9>B:CH>DC6A&B:I=D9
>HEG>B6G>ANJH:9>CI=>HHIJ9NID:K6AJ6I:I=::FJ6I>DCL=>8=
>H:FJ>K6A:CIID:FJ6I>DC 
  4    5    9



"C :FJ6I>DC  4    5  >H 6C >C9>86I>K: ;JC8I>DC  ";


     8DCI6>C:G;6>AJG:>H>C9>86I:9I=:C 4    5  ";
      8DCI6>C:G G:A>67>A>IN >H >C9>86I:9 I=:C
4    5   "CI:<G6A 9DB6>C   9:CDI:H I=: :CI>G: HE68: 
H 8DCI6>C:G ;6>AJG: EGD767>A>IN >H JHJ6AAN K:GN HB6AA >C 6
9>G:8I H6BEA>C< B:I=D9 ID 86A8JA6I: :FJ6I>DC  A6G<:
CJB7:GH D;H6BEA>C< C::9 7: 86GG>:9 DJI ID 68=>:K: I=:
HE:8>;>:9:GGDGA:K:A ;I:G:68=H6BEA>C<8DCI6>C:G;6>AJG:>H
ID7:9:I:GB>C:9I=:8DBEJI6I>DCLDG@>HIDDBJ8= -=:7:HI
L6N ID HDAK: I=>H EGD7A:B >H ID G:EA68: 9>G:8I H6BEA>C<
B:I=D9L>I=>BEDGI6C8:H6BEA>C<B:I=D9 "C6C>BEDGI6C8:
  

H6BEA>C< B:I=D9 I=: HI6I>HI>86A FJ6CI>IN 4    5
  
Vol. 1, FEBRUARY 2011

79

G:EA68:H 4    5  HD :FJ6I>DC  86C 7: :MEG:HH:9 6H


;DAADLH
  

  4    5
  9

  
!:G:     >H6C>BEDGI6C8:H6BEA>C<;JC8I>DC6C9>I>H
CDCC:<6I>K:6C9>HHJ7?:8I:9IDCJB7:GCDGB6A>O6I>DC H6C
JC7>6H:9 :HI>B6I: D; I=: 8DCI6>C:G ;6>AJG: EGD767>A>IN I=:
  
 >HH=DLC6H;DAADLH
B:6CD; 4    5
  

 M   

 
4  M  5
'  
 M  
-=: @:N ED>CI D; >BEDGI6C8: H6BEA>C< & B:I=D9 >H ID
8=DDH: 6 HJ>I67A: >BEDGI6C8: H6BEA>C< 9:CH>IN ;JC8I>DC ID
:;;:8I>K:AN G:9J8: I=: K6G>6C8:  -=: BDHI 8DBBDCAN JH:9
B:I=D9 >H ID 69DEI 6 CDGB6A 9>HIG>7JI>DC ) 6H 6C
>BEDGI6C8: H6BEA>C< 9:CH>IN ;JC8I>DC  "IH B:6C >H I=:
9:H><C:9ED>CI6C9>IHK6G>6C8:>HCDIA:HHI=6CI=:K6G>6C8:D;
I=: DG><>C6A G6C9DB K6G>67A:   "C I=>H H6BEA>C< B:I=D9
A6G<: CJB7:GH D; H6BEA>C< ED>CIH 6G: AD86I:9 C:6G I=:
9:H><C:9 ED>CI  "; CDCA>C:6G 9:<G:: D; I=: ;6>AJG: HJG;68: >H
CDIK:GN=><=H6BEA>C<:;;>8>:C8N>HJHJ6AAN67DJI  
.% 8DC;>9:C8: JEE:G A>B>I 6I 6 8:GI6>C % 86C 7:
86A8JA6I:96HI=:;DAADL>C<HI:EH
 8DCI6>C:G;6>AJG:EGD767>A>I>:H

        6G:86A8JA6I:97N>BEDGI6C8:
H6BEA>C<&B:I=D9 

         6G:HDGI:97N6H8:C9>C<DG9:G6H
;DAADLH





                    




         
HD     >HI=:6EEGDM>B6I:.%


D;  6II=:%D;




IV. Compiling of MATLAB Program


Calculation of Container Failure Probability

and

1. Compiling of MATLAB Program


6H:9DCI=:67DK:76H>8EG>C8>EA:H6&-%EGD<G6B
>H 8DBE>A:9 ID 86A8JA6I: 8DCI6>C:G ;6>AJG: EGD767>A>IN  -=:
>BEDGI6C8:H6BEA>C<9:CH>IN;JC8I>DC>H6CDGB6A9>HIG>7JI>DC
)>IHB:6C>HI=:>CI:GH:8I>DC7A68@9DI6HH=DLC>C>< 
 DG ><   C:6G I=: DG><>C 7:IL::C ;6>AJG: I=G:H=DA9 8JGK:
6C9HIG:HH8JGK:L=>A:>IHK6G>6C8:>H:FJ6AIDI=:K6G>6C8:D;
I=: HIG:HH  AA CDGB6A 9>HIG>7JI>DCH 6G: HI6C96G9>O:9 ID
HI6C96G9 CDGB6A 9>HIG>7JI>DC >C I=: EGD<G6B 7:;DG:
86A8JA6I>DC 
-=: ."<G6E=>86AJH:G>CI:G;68:D;8DBE>A:9&-%
EGD<G6B>HH=DLC>CFig. 4 
"CI=:JEE:GE6GID;I=: .">H6E6G6B:I:G>CEJI6G:6 "C
I=:B>99A:E6GID;I=: .">H6CDE:G6I>DC6G:6 "CI=:ADL:G
E6GI D; I=: ." >H 6 86A8JA6I>DC 6G:6  -=: HE:8>;>:9 ;JC8I>DC
D; :68= E6GI >H H=DLC >C Table 2  "C DG9:G ID LG>I: H>BEAN
6C98DCK:C>:CIANC6B:D;:68=)EJH=7JIIDCDG-:9>I

80

Renze WANG

Table 3 6A8JA6I>DC:M6BEA:

-
%
   

B
H
.%:

>G:
"BE68I@)6

   


        

Table 4 DBE6G>HDC7:IL::CILDB:I=D9H


%



Fig. 4

%
 

 

+:A6I>K:GGDG
 
 

V. Conclusion

I:MI>H677G:K>6I:96HI=:;>GHIA:II:GH:ID;I=:C6B:THLDG9H  
DG:M6BEA:")>HI=:677G:K>6I>DCD;R6A8JA6I:"BE>C<>C<
)GD767>A>INS 
Table 2JC8I>DCA>HID;:68=E6GID;I=: ."

)
-
JC8I>DC
"CEJII=:B:6CD;I=:;6>AJG:I=G:H=DA9 

-
"CEJII=:HI6C96G99:K>6I>DCD;I=:

;6>AJG:I=G:H=DA9 
,
 "CEJII=:HI6C96G99:K>6I>DCD;I=:HIG:HH
)
DC;>GBI=:>CEJIE6G6B:I:GH?JHI67DK:
)
)ADI;><JG:H 

A:6G96I6>CI=:LDG@HE68: 
%
"CEJI6% 

DC;>GBI=:% 
)
6A8JA6I:;>G:.% 
)
.%
,=DL;>G:.% 
")

 

.%:
 
   

." D; 8DCI6>C:G ;6>AJG: EGD767>A>IN 86A8JA6I>DC

EGD<G6B

")

>G:
"BE68I

 

>G:8I
"CI:<G6A
&:I=D9
:
 
 


6A8JA6I:>BE>C<>C<.% 

.%
,=DL>BE>C<>C<.% 
)
6A8JA6I:I=:IDI6A;6>AJG:EGD767>A>IN 
88DG9>C< ID :ME:G>B:CIH 6C9 H>BJA6I>DC 86A8JA6I>DCH 7N
HD;IL6G: ;>G: I:BE:G6IJG: >BE68I HIG:HH 6C9 8DGG:HEDC9>C<
;6>AJG:I=G:H=DA9HD;D 2*BD9:AE68@6<:6G:EG:H:CI:9
>CTable 3, 86A8JA6I>DCG:HJAIH6G:6AHD>CI=:I67A: 
2. Comparison between Two Methods
>G:8I >CI:<G6A B:I=D9 ;DG >CI:<G6I>DC D; F   >H 6AHD
JH:9>C&-%6C9I=:C8DCI6>C:G;6>AJG:EGD767>A>IN86C
7:68=>:K:9 9DEI>C<76H>896I6>C-67A:I=:8DBE6G>HDC
D;I=:G:HJAIHD7I6>C:97NI=:&B:I=D96C99>G:8I>CI:<G6A
B:I=D9 >H H=DLC >C Table 4, L=>8= EG:H:CIH I=6I G:A6I>K:
:GGDGD;ILDB:I=D9H>HA:HHI=6C  

-=: D7I6>C:9 DJI8DB: D; I=: >BEDGI6C8: H6BEA>C< &


B:I=D9 6<G::H L>I= I=: DJI8DB: D; 6C >CI:<G6A B:I=D9
I=:G:;DG:I=:HIJ9NH=DLHI=6II=:8DCI6>C:GG:A>67>A>IN>HK:GN
=><= -=:.%D;I=:8DCI6>C:G;6>AJG:EGD767>A>IN6I68:GI6>C
% 86C 7: 6AHD 68=>:K:9 7N & B:I=D9  -=DJ<=
8DBEJI6I>DC I>B: >C8G:6H:H HID8=6HI>8 8=6G68I:G>HI>8H D; I=:
6HH:HHB:CI E6G6B:I:GH 6G: G:EG:H:CI:9 K:GN L:AA HD >I >H 6C
:;;:8I>K:8DBEA:B:CIID=>HIDG>86AG:8DG9H6C9:ME:G>B:CIH 

References
 +:<JA6I>DCH ;DG I=: ,6;: -G6CHEDGI D; +69>D68I>K: &6I:G>6A
  9>I>DC" ,6;:IN ,I6C96G9H ,:G>:H 'D  -,+ 
"CI:GC6I>DC6AIDB>8C:G<N<:C8N "   
 >C< 3=6D #>6C<6C< 3=6C< 1J:M>C 06C< :I 6A  ), 
B:I=D9 >C IG6CHEDGI D; G69>D68I>K: B6I:G>6A -=: DJGI=
,NBEDH>JBD;DGJB;DG+69>6I>DC)GDI:8I>DC6I:<>CC>C<D;
I=: HI:CIJGN:>?>C<=>C6#JC:    4>C
=>C:H:5 
  0 :CC>H # - DA:N 0  !6GIB6C :I 6A  ,:K:G>I>:H D;
IG6CHEDGI6I>DC 688>9:CIH >CKDAK>C< A6G<: E68@6<:H
,' . , ,6C9>6%67DG6IDG>:H  
 3 & >GC76JB  (C 6 JH: D;  I=: &6CC0=>IC:N ,I6I>HI>8 
)GD8::9>C<HD;I=:-=>G9:G@:A:N,NBEDH>JBDC&6I=:B6I>86A
,I6I>HI>8H6C9)GD767>A>IN:G@:A:N6A>;DGC>6:8:B7:G 
#JAN6C9J<JHI /DAJB:" P   
 $:CI %6LG:C8: ',2, 0DG@7:C8= -JIDG>6A +:A:6H: 
,8=GD;;:K:ADEB:CIDGEDG6I>DC&>HH>DC$6CH6H 
 +:<JA6I>DCH ;DG I=: ,6;: -G6CHEDGI D; +69>D68I>K: &6I:G>6A
    :C:G6A9B>C>HIG6I>DCD;*J6A>IN,JE:GK>H>DC
"CHE:8I>DC 6C9 *J6G6CI>C: D; ) + =>C6  ,I6C96G9>O6I>DC
9B>C>HIG6I>DCD;) + =>C6   
 6C< 1>6D ->6CIJD %> &DCI: 6GAD &:I=D9 >C ,NHI:B
+:A>67>A>IN C6ANO>C< ,8>:C8: )G:HH :>?>C<    4>C
=>C:H:5

PROGRESS IN NUCLEAR SCIENCE AND TECHNOLOGY

Vous aimerez peut-être aussi