POSTMENTALISM
ALVO STOCKMAN
The Effect
Before a major event (football game, election, etc), you
offer to make a prediction to one of your friends. However
in the interest of security, you don’t want to hold on to the
prediction yourself, nor do you want your friend to. You offer
to mail the prediction in the form of a letter to your friend’s
house, using the US Postal Service. In this way, it would be
a felony to tamper with it!
You write the prediction, put it in an envelope, address it, put
a stamp on it, and hand it to your friend. You then invite him
to put the letter in any mailbox in town.
The following day (or whenever the letter happens to arrive),
alone at home, your friend’s brain will slowly disassemble
itself and finally shut down, trying to figure out how you
knew.
YES. It’s as clean and straight-forward as it sounds. There’s
absolutely nothing misleading in this description. Get ready
to have some fun, this is a reputation maker.Introduction
In envelopes, pockets, folded billets, and boxes, written
predictions have become a standard theme in magic.
Its easy to see why. The ability to predict the future is
something central to being human. In fact, some consider it
the most important measure of intelligence. The ability to be
prepared for future events is a critical survival skill. Even in
our day to day lives, weathermen, stock analysts, marketers,
politicians, lawyers, and hundreds of other occupations are
focused around the outcome of future events. Predicting the
future is a theme everyone can relate to and see the value
of.
The focus of any prediction effect inevitably comes down to
its integrity.
When a television escape artist puts on chains, traditionally
he will have a privately hired member of the local police
force examine them to make sure the handcuffs he is using
are legitimate. In this way, a 3rd party has vouched to the
audience for the effect’s integrity.
There are a couple of drawbacks to this when performing
casually for friends. First, most of us are not under 24 hour
police surveillance. This makes contracting a member of
local law enforcement impractical. And second, even when a
privately or even “randomly” selected police officer is chosen
from an audience during a stage show, their legitimacy is still
in question. Are they really a police officer or an actor who is
part of the show? Each time a question like this is asked, it
chips away precious credibility from the performance.
In a written prediction effect (particularly between a mentalist
and a single individual), there is a dilemma of who to entrust
with the prediction until the time of revelation.+ If the mentalist holds onto it, the details could be discretely
changed (as they often are), compromising the integrity of
the prediction.
+ If the spectator holds onto it, they could read it and possibly
change the outcome, also compromising the original
prediction.
Ideally we would have an escrow style trusted 3rd-party
agent who could hang on to the prediction for us until after
the predicted event. There would also be severe penalties
for either side to tamper with the prediction.
The solution | propose in Postmentalism is to use the US
Postal Service to mail a prediction to your friend’s home.Benefits
Buildup
Anticipation is a huge part of pleasure. It’s what makes
Christmas mornings, 16th birthdays and Fridays so much
juicier. In Postmentalism, your spectator will be looking
forward to receiving this mysterious prediction from you for at
least a day or two, listening for the mailman and anticipating
what it could be.
Private Reaction
| touched on this concept in my effect “Mix Tape’.
Regardless of whether you’re performing on stage or walk-
around, it’s impossible to get a truly honest reaction from
someone as long as you're watching them. By sending the
prediction to their home, your spectator is somewhere they
feel safe, comfortable, relaxed and most importantly, alone
to react completely genuinely to your performance. It’s
obviously a different kind of performance where you don’t get
to see a “freak-out” moment, but one that hits hard and will
be remembered forever.
Souvenir
In many tricks, the spectator is left with some scrap of
signed card that the magician gives to them (usually to avoid
having to walk it over to the waste basket) with the belief
that they will cherish it and remember them fondly forever.
The problem is that usually it’s a meaningless shred of a
performance. In Postmentalism, the spectator receives
an envelope, addressed and mailed to them, delivered to
their door the old fashioned way (which is only getting more
memorable as email takes over), that they personally put
in the mail. This envelope contains a full recount of what
happened during the performance and any time they lookback at it they will be able to relive the moment.
Posial Integrity
As far as middlemen go, it doesn’t get much better than
the USPS. It’s actually a felony to tamper with the mail.
Assuming both you and your spectator are performing
outside the walls of a prison, this should be more than
enough to convince them that no one has changed the
prediction.Benefits
Buildup
Anticipation is a huge part of pleasure. It's what makes
Christmas mornings, 16th birthdays and Fridays so much
juicier. In Postmentalism, your spectator will be looking
forward to receiving this mysterious prediction from you for at
least a day or two, listening for the mailman and anticipating
what it could be.
Private Reaction
| touched on this concept in my effect “Mix Tape”.
Regardless of whether you’re performing on stage or walk-
around, it’s impossible to get a truly honest reaction from
someone as long as you’re watching them. By sending the
prediction to their home, your spectator is somewhere they
feel safe, comfortable, relaxed and most importantly, alone
to react completely genuinely to your performance. It’s
obviously a different kind of performance where you don’t get
to see a “freak-out” moment, but one that hits hard and will
be remembered forever.
Souvenir
In many tricks, the spectator is left with some scrap of
signed card that the magician gives to them (usually to avoid
having to walk it over to the waste basket) with the belief
that they will cherish it and remember them fondly forever.
The problem is that usually it’s a meaningless shred of a
performance. In Postmentalism, the spectator receives
an envelope, addressed and mailed to them, delivered to
their door the old fashioned way (which is only getting more
memorable as email takes over), that they personally put
in the mail. This envelope contains a full recount of what
happened during the performance and any time they lookback at it they will be able to relive the moment.
Postal Integrity
As far as middlemen go, it doesn’t get much better than
the USPS. It’s actually a felony to tamper with the mail.
Assuming both you and your spectator are performing
outside the walls of a prison, this should be more than
enough to convince them that no one has changed the
prediction.Method Summary
The key elements to the method for Postmentalism are a
special time-delayed disappearing ink pen combined with a
clever switch.
The general idea is as follows:
While performing, you use the special Postmentalism
pen (provided) to write out the name and address of your
spectator on the prediction envelope. After putting a stamp
onit, you hand this envelope to your friend and ask that they
drop it in a mailbox. Once this has been done and you are
alone, you will re-write their address on a new envelope (with
a normal pen), and wait till the event you are predicting has
been completed. Now it’s simply a matter of writing a new
“prediction” and mailing it to them.
The result will be that the original envelope is blank by the
time the postal system gets their hands on it and they will be
unable to deliver it and thus forced to throw it away for you.
The copy that your friend receives will be indistinguishable
from the original and as accurate as you want it to be.Method Step-by-Step
Supplies
2 identical postage stamps
2 identical envelopes
2 identical pieces of paper
1 Postmentalism pen (included)
1 non-gimmicked pen (matching ink color)
Preparation
The special ink in the Postmentalism pen takes roughly
24 hours to vanish, however you could (if you reeeeeeally
wanted to) carefully read the residue or imprints the tip of
the pen leaves on the envelope after the ink vanishes. This
creates a tiny (teeny tiny) possibility that some Dudley
Do-Right working for the postal service may attempt to
deliver your unmarked letter.
Here is the solution:
You will prepare the envelopes you use by wrting out an
arbitrary address (or two) on them with the Postmentalism
pen a couple days before you perform the trick. This will
ensure that the envelope already has some imprints in it
before you write down your spectator’s address. When your
spectator’s address disappears, the resulting combination of
imprints will be unreadable to a postal employee.
The Pen
The Postmentalism pen is a specially developed gimmick
with ink that disappears slowly. This makes it perfect for this
effect. It’s disguised in a very common, brand name office
pen tube to throw off any suspicion. You will also need asecond (ordinary) pen that has a similar color ink. This ink
does *not* need to match exactly. In fact, as long as it is
roughly the same shade it will work. Almost any major office
supply store will have such a pen. Again, keep in mind that
at least a day or two will pass before your spectator will see
the envelope again. Our brains are not wired to recognize
subtle differences in colors over long periods of time.
One thing | will suggest is to use non-white envelopes. This
will help hide some of the minor residue left over by the ink.
Timing
In deciding when to perform Postmentalism, here are some
considerations:
It should be close enough to the event that you can write
your second prediction soon after to avoid a strange delay in
the letter arriving to your friend.
Ideally, you want to begin performing just after the daily mail
pickup. This gives you a full 24 hours (important as we'll see
in a moment) to write your prediction and get it delivered, as
well as at least 24 hours for the ink to completely vanish.
Writing the Original Prediction
Have ready your envelope, stamp and a piece of paper.
Then propose to your company that you'd like to make a
prediction.
At this point, you can simply write a very broad and vague
prediction (or a bold guess) to your friend. In the off-chance
that he or she is compelled to tear it open right then and
there, you'll be covered. You might be wrong, but you’re
covered.Next you will put the prediction in an envelope and seal it.
It’s at this point you must start paying careful attention to the
envelope.
The Stockman Switch
The Stockman Switch is based on a combination of (1) the
fact that it is almost impossible to distinguish two pieces of
writing from the same person unless they are side-by-side
and (2) that handwriting is inherently unique.
Ask your friend their address and write it carefully on the
envelope. If you make a mistake, just scribble it out and
keep going.
Memory
Remember where you scribbled and made mistakes on the
envelope. You will need to re-create them later. Mistakes
are not actually bad! In fact, | suggest you make one or two
little ones just to subtly make this envelope seem unique.
If you’re having trouble remembering someone’s address or
how you wrote it and you have a cell phone with a camera,
you can discretely take a picture of the envelope when
you’re done. Your ability to remember these things will
improve over time.
To subtly create a seeming uniqueness to the envelope,
draw a smiley face, star or some other symbol.
Practice!
It’s integral to Postmentalism that the spectator believe they
have received the same exact letter in the mail. What you
already have working in your favor is that1. Different copies of one person's hand writing is difficult to
differentiate unless compared side-by-side.
2. At least a day or two will go by between comparisons
which means their memory will be a little fuzzy anyway.
3. The fact that you casually ask their address subtly implies
that you don’t have it in memory.
This being said, it doesn’t hurt to practice a few handy
seemingly unique symbols you can consistently doodle onto
your envelope (smiley face or other).
Dropping into a Mailbox
Having finished writing on the envelope, pay attention to
where you stick the stamp and hand the envelope to your
friend.
Take your time. There’s no rush. In fact, to build suspense
and anticipation even more, | encourage writing the
prediction and actually letting your friend hang on to the
prediction for a while. This will anchor the notion of both
permanence and control to the envelope and your friend
respectively. Perhaps make the prediction before dinner,
give the envelope to your friend, eat, then walk to the
nearest mailbox together.
Ask your friend to put the envelope into any mailbox they’d
like. Drive to a distant one if you’d like or simply walk
together. In any case, it’s in their hands and ready to go.
When you both arrive at the mailbox, note the pickup time.
This isn’t mission critical, but if it’s not been picked up yet,
note that you should really try to get your second prediction
in that same day’s batch to avoid delays and to get the
correct date stamped on it. Delays are normal however andit wouldn't make or break your effect if an extra day went
by. In fact, if you’re performing on a Friday or Saturday, you
have even more time to wait comfortably. However the date
is stamped on letters when they are mailed, so the timing is
still important.
Making a Duplicate Envelope
As soon as you’re alone again, it’s time to create a duplicate
envelope. Even if the event you’re predicting is not for
several hours, you should still make this envelope as soon
as possible to avoid forgetting some obvious and distinctive
element of it your friend may remember.
Once the event has passed, you can write out your
prediction any way you'd like and mail it to your friend.
Distance vs Time
An interesting opportunity is when your friend lives far away.
Perhaps they are in town on holiday or a business trip. The
time it will take to deliver a letter or simply for them to receive
the letter may be extended. In these cases, it helps to write
a bit longer of a letter to both jog their memory and to weave
it in to a genuinely friendly letter for someone you don’t see
often.
Postmarks
It is important to understand how postmarks work.
Envelopes are stamped with the current date as they’re
being processed by the Postal Service. It is not necessarily
the same day you’re sending it however. If you mail after-
hours it won't get stamped until the next day. If mailed on
a weekend, it could be postmarked as late as Monday. As
long as you can get your real prediction in before the cut-off
for the day it would have been stamped, you’re set.Polish
The brilliant improvisationalist Michael W. had some fantastic
suggestions for Postmentalism that I’d like to share with you
here.
If you’re willing to take a little extra time (and | hope you
are—this is a miracle after all!) set yourself up ahead of
time by arranging to meet your friend at a coffee shop or
restaurant where you know they would give you an envelope
and paper on polite request. Mention you have a wild idea,
then go up to the counter, pretend to borrow a pen, and
actually ask for an envelope and a piece of paper to use for
your performance. What this will do is take any attention
away from the tools you’re using (pen, paper, envelope, etc)
and focus it purely on the effect. Optionally, to further add
spontaneity you can use napkins. And if you can’t get an
envelope, save that part till you get to the post office.
A lovely touch that Michael also suggested was to put
something ridiculous on your pen (masking tape, stickers,
feather, rubber bands) like servers do to identify their pens.
Just take a look at your local bar & grill to see examples
of this. This further sells the fact that you just went up and
found a pen on the counter of the cafe, for instance.
One of the benefits of this is taking the attention off the
slight weirdness of the color of the Postmentlism pen ink.
However in the future, even as the technology improves and
the ink looks more normal, | would still suggest “borrowing”
the pen as it gives a much more off-the-cuff style of
performance which is preferable with such a bold miracle.
If you can't get a stamp from the establishment, either have
one ready in your wallet or accompany your friend to the
nearest post office and mail it together.Dressing
There’s an opportunity every time you perform
Postmentalism to uniquely dress it up to fit the situation.
Here are just a few examples.
Premonition
The most obvious use for Postmentalism is to predict
outcomes of large scale events. This is absolutely fine,
it’s a great opportunity to make a huge impact with
someone. | would present it as a premonition that you're
getting. Perhaps tell your friend that you need to write
them something about the upcoming event. In the case of
agame, maybe write just the score, but not which number
belongs to which team, or make a tiny error (off by a point,
say). It’s my strong belief that it’s a bit fishy when you're
perfectly accurate as to what the outcome is. It takes some
of the mystery out of it.
This style of performance is obviously great for use on
friends. However, one other situation it’s great for is in
making a big impact for a potential business relationship. If
you’re trying to book a show, sign a deal or get your “foot in
the door’ in any way, try performing this at the interview. Not
only will it hit them between the eyes and completely floor
them, but they'll get it a day or two after your meeting forcing
them to remember you, and nine times out of ten, call you
back.
Number Cruncher
For predictions about game scores, stock prices, weather or
anything else heavily involving numbers, you may want to try
pretending that you are doing some hard core calculations.
Write down some funny looking equations, or bring in some
information from the internet and crunch those numbers intosomething that looks like a prediction.
When doing mentalism, it’s a good idea to give people a
hook to latch on to. For example, one of the things that
makes Derren Brown so appealing is his ability to blur the
line between psychology and magic, constantly pushing the
line of what people will believe is possible.
Good Fortune
This performance best justifies the spectator not immediately
being allowed to see the prediction you write since it directly
involves their actions. Write your friend a letter that they
are not to read until a later date. Have them mail it to
themselves as they would in the standard presentation.
Later that evening, pay attention to any interesting things
that may occur. A phone call with good news comes during
dinner, they trip and fall on the steps to the subway, a blonde
in a red dress gives him her phone number. Anything that
they might consider significant and remember. Write this in
a letter as though you were seeing into their future. Sprinkle
on some more cold reading style messages for a forecast of
the next week’s fortune!
Baby Gender +
If a friend or relative is pregnant, and you know she is going
to find out the gender the next morning, make a prediction
based on reading her palm! This is a great opportunity but
sadly will not come up very often. Imagine the impact if it
turns out she’s having twins!Example Timeline
Friday
7:00 pm Visit local coffee shop and ask politely for a sheet
of paper (for real prediction) and an envelope (for dummy
prediction). Prepare envelope (write arbitrary address). Find
nearest post office. Go inside and make sure stamp machine
is working, buy two first class stamps and put in wallet.
Saturday
9:00 pm Meet friend at same coffee shop. Tell them you
had a dream about them and Sunday’s Football game. Go
to “borrow” a pen, paper/napkin and envelope. Switch
envelope out for prepared one. Return to table. Write the
prediction and seal in envelope.
9:30 pm Have friend drive you to Post Office. Go inside.
Have them pick the kind of stamp, or if they want mixed
postage. Address envelope. Take a picture of them holding
the envelope with your cell phone. Take a picture of them
mailing the envelope
Sunday
10:00 am Review photo of envelope and prepare duplicates.
Wait for outcome of game. Send your prediction from same
post office.
Monday/Tuesday
Your friend gets the envelope in the mail. They call you. Tell
them to meet you so you can take another picture of them
holding the prediction. Buy a copy of the newspaper with the
headline showing the final score of the game.
A Month Later
Send your friend the photo of them holding the paper and
your prediction.Acknowledgements
I'd like to thank Michael W. for his suggestions and feedback.
I'd also like to give a very big thank you to Luke Jermay. His
creativity has been an inspiration to me.
Post Analysis
Have fun performing Postmentalism. It may not be your
everyday worker’s solution, but when you need a true
miracle and the opportunity presents itself, | think you’ll be
very pleased with the results.
If you have any exciting stories to share or questions
regarding the effect, you may contact me directly at
alvo.stockman@gmail.com
Alvo’s PRO tips for being a
successful Postmentailist.
. ALWAYS prep your envelopes
(write an arbitrary address).
. ALWAYS walk with your friend
to the mailbox.
. TEST new envelopes before
you use them in a show. Some
work better than others. Make
sure the ink is vanishing.
. DON'T perform Postmentalism
in extreme cold. It may affect
the timing of the ink
4. When in doubt, MAIL YOURSELF.www.PenguinMagic.com
Cure Et ae ee kt dl