!"#$%&%"'%#(&#!")%*+,-#).

%(+/
!"#$%&'(%$")'"*+,),-./"#$./,%0"
012#345617

81#9:55:;42<#=71#>;:#5:2<#12?2:>1@#AB!2>1<7=5#)81:7C#D@E#F74>4G=5#+1=54@HIJ#BK=2L@CG84@HIMN#=2?#:21#
1OG17L>#AB!2>1<7=5#K5P7=54@HIMN#97:H#HC#71G12>5C#Q24@81?#6::RN#1$23"4.+0.3"*+$.),5,)6N#;84G8#4@#S:5PH1#
T#:9#>81#0:@H:@#)745:<CN#;8:@1#Q7@>#D:5PH1#4@#1$23"7-'/'863"1&,+,)9./,)6E#)81@1#2:>1@#;171#;74>>12N#42#L=7>N#
42#71@L:2@1#>:#K=P5#U=7@8=55V@#=7>4G51#B):;=7?#=2#!2>1<7=5#+1=54@HI#ALP654@81?#42#>84@#4@@P1MN#=2?N#;8451#=LW
L71G4=>42<#G17>=42#=@L1G>@#:9#F74>4G=5#+1=54@HN#G:H1#:P>#@>7:2<5C#42#9=D:7#:9#!2>1<7=5#)81:7CE#

IntegralTheoryvs.CriticalRealism
!2>1<7=5#)81:7C#A!)M#=2?#F74>4G=5#+1=54@H#AF+M#@8=71#H=2C#4>1H@#42#G:HH:2N#6P>#>8171#=71#@:H1#?11L#?49917W
12G1@#=@#;155E#):#61<42#;4>8N#F+#@1L=7=>1@#1L4@>1H:5:<C#=2?#:2>:5:<CN#=2?#H=R1@#:2>:5:<C#>81#51D15#:9#>81#
B71=5IJ#;8171=@N#9:7#!2>1<7=5#)81:7CN#1L4@>1H:5:<C#=2?#:2>:5:<C#G=22:>#@:#61#97=<H12>1?#=2?#97=G>P71?N#6P>#
7=>817#=71#>;:#G:7715=>4D1#?4H12@4:2@#:9#1D17C#38:51#:GG=@4:2#AL=7>#:9#>81#>1>7=W?4H12@4:2#:9#1D17C#8:5:2ME#
F+#H=42>=42@#>8=>#>8171#=71#:2>:5:<4G=5#71=54>41@#>8=>#=71#2:>#?1L12?12>#PL:2#8PH=2@#:7#8PH=2#>81:741@X42W
G5P?42<#HPG8#:9#>81#51D15#:9#>81#B71=5IX42G5P?42<#4>1H@#@PG8#=@#=>:H@N#H:51GP51@N#G155@N#1>GEX=2?#!)#=<711@N#
;4>8#:21#4HL:7>=2>#?4991712G1Y#!)#4@#&.(&%6-:,-#A=#>17H#!VH#2:>#9:2?#:9N#L71917742<#BL=242>174:74@>NI#H1=242<#
=55#6142<@#8=D1#42>174:7@#:7#L7:>:WG:2@G4:P@21@@N##5=#384>181=?N#K147G1N#-14624>ZN#1>GEMX>:#;4>N#=>:H@#?:#2:>#
?1L12?#PL:2#6142<#R2:;2#6C#8PH=2@N#6P>#>81C#?:#?1L12?#PL:2#6142<#R2:;2#6C#1=G8#:>817E#)81#BL71812W
@4:2I# =@L1G># :9# =>:H@# AL7:>:WR2:;42<N# L7:>:W911542<N# L7:>:WG:2@G4:P@21@@M# 815L@# >:# G:W12=G># >81# 6142<# :7#
:2>:5:<C#=@L1G>#:9#>81#=>:H@#9:7#1=G8#:>817X>8147#:;2#1L4@>1H:5:<C#=2?#:2>:5:<C#=71#>8P@#42@1L=7=651#=2?#
G:WG71=>4D1E#)81#=>:HV@#L71812@4:2#4@#L=7>#:9#4>@#D17C#:2>:5:<C#A=2?#D4G1#D17@=MN#=2?#=@#1=G8#=>:H#L71812?@#
4>@#L71?1G1@@:7N#4>#4@#42@>7PH12>=5#42#6742<42<#4>#9:7>8#:7#12=G>42<#4>N#[P@>#=@#4>@#:;2#6142<#;455#?1L12?#42#L=7>#
:2#6142<#L71812?1?\R2:;2\42G5P?1?#6C#4>@#:;2#@PGG1@@:7E#!9N#9:7#>81#H:H12>N#;1#51=D1#]P=2>PH#H1G8=24G@#
:P>#:9#>81#L4G>P71#A@11#615:;MN#2:21#:9#>84@#?1L12?@#:2#8PH=2@#9:7#4>@#1O4@>12G1#:7#6142<N#=2?#C1>#>81#=>:HV@#
L71812@4:2W911542<WR2:;42<#4@#=2#42>742@4G#L=7>#:9#>84@#51D15#:9#>81#B71=5EI#F:2@G4:P@21@@#4@#2:>#@:H1>842<#
>8=>#G=2#61#@PGR1?#:P>#:9#6142<#>:#51=D1#=2#=;=7121@@W9711#B:2>:5:<CI#5C42<#=7:P2?#;=4>42<#>:#61#R2:;2#6C#
@:H1#:>817#@12>412>#6142<J#consciousness,rather,goesallthewaydownN#=2?#9:7H@#L=7>#:9#>81#42>742@4G#=;=71W
21@@#=2?#42>742@4G#G71=>4D4>C#:9#1=G8#:2>:5:<4G=5#6142<#:7#8:5:2E#384>181=?V@#BP5>4H=>1#G=>1<:7CIX2=H15CN#
B>81#G71=>4D1#=?D=2G1#42>:#2:D15>CIX4@#L=7>#:9#>81#L71812@4:2#:9#1=G8#=2?#1D17C#6142<#42#1O4@>12G1N#=2?#>81#
G71=>4D1WL=7>#G=22:>#61#74LL1?#97:H#>81#6142<L=7>#;4>8:P>#@1D171#D4:512G1E#):#L:@>P5=>1#>81#H:@>#9P2?=H12>=5#
51D15#:9#71=54>C#=@#H1715C#:2>:5:<CX6142<#;4>8:P>#R2:;42<#:7#G:2@G4:P@21@@#:7#G71=>4D4>CX4@#6=@4G=55C#=#
Q7@>W>417#H:D1#>8=>#@8=>>17@#>81#38:5121@@#:9#>84@#=2?#1D17C#71=5#:GG=@4:2E
#
-4R1;4@1N#@L474>P=5#>7=2@G12?12G1#A%7:@M#71=G81@#=55#>81#;=C#?:;2#=@#;155E#!2#!)V@#21:W384>181=?4=2#
D41;N#1=G8#21;#H:H12>#G:H1@#>:#61#=@#=#@P6[1G>#A;4>8#=55#9:P7#]P=?7=2>@MN#=2?#4>#L71812?@#A>1>7=WL71812?@M#4>@#
L71?1G1@@:7N#;84G8#4@#2:;#=2#:6[1G>#A42#=55#9:P7#]P=?7=2>@M#9:7#>84@#21;#@P6[1G>E#)81#21;#@P6[1G>#B>7=2@G12?@#
=2?#42G5P?1@I#>81#:5?#@P6[1G>#A2:;#=@#:6[1G>MN#=2?#>8P@#>81C#HP>P=55C#G:WG71=>1#1=G8#:>817Y#>81#:5?#@P6[1G>#
>8=>#4@#2:;#:6[1G>#=2?#4@#42G5P?1?#42#>81#21;#@P6[1G>#815L@#@8=L1#>81#21;#@P6[1G>#4>@159N#6C#>81#@4HL51#9=G>#:9#
6142<#42G5P?1?#42#4>N#=G>P=55C#1H67=G1?#6C#4>N#=2?#>8P@#>:#@:H1#?1<711#?1>17H4242<#4>E#-4R1;4@1N#>81#21;#@P6W
[1G>N#42#42G5P?42<#>81#:5?#@P6[1G>N#4@#42@>7PH12>=5#42#6742<42<#4>#9:7>8#:7#12=G>42<#4>N#G:WG71=>42<#4>@#D17C#6142<#
=@#=#21;#:6[1G>#=@#4>#?:1@#@:X=2?#>81#21;#@P6[1G>#>812#=??@#4>@#:;2#?1<711#:9#G71=>4D4>CN#G:2@G4:P@21@@N#:7#
JournalofIntegralTheoryandPracticeN#T^_TN#`AaMN#LLE#abcdT

K.WILBER

2:D15>CN#=2?#>8P@#=G>P=55C#G:WG71=>1@#=#21;#6142<#42#>81#D17C#=G>#:9#L71812@4D1#P24QG=>4:2E#)84@#B>7=2@G12?#
=2?#42G5P?1I#<:1@#=55#>81#;=C#?:;2#>:#>81#@H=551@>#H4G7:@P6=>:H4G#L=7>4G51@N#=2?#=55#;=C#>87:P<8#>81#=G>P=5#
H1@:W?1D15:LH12>=5#51D15@#A;8171N#=@#01<=2#LP>@#4>#9:7#8PH=2#?1D15:LH12>N#B>81#@P6[1G>#:9#:21#51D15#61W
G:H1@#>81#:6[1G>#:9#>81#@P6[1G>#:9#>81#21O>IX;84G8#4@#>81#H1@:#D41;#:9#384>181=?V@#L71812@4:2X2=H15CN#
>8=>#B>81#@P6[1G>#:9#>84@#H:H12>#61G:H1@#>81#:6[1G>#:9#>81#@P6[1G>#:9#>81#21O>IX6P>#=G>42<#2:;#:2#=#5=7<17N#
84<817N#H:71#G:HL51ON#H:71#G:2@G4:P@#51D15MN#=2?#=55#>81#;=C#>:#>81#H=G7:#L7=G>4G1@#:9#H1?4>=>4:2N#;8171#
>7=2@G12?12G1#4@#>81#:D17=55#<:=5#=2?#:GGP7@#>87:P<8#>81#:6[1G>4QG=>4:2#:9#@>=>1W@>=<1@#97:H#<7:@@#>:#@P6>51#>:#
G=P@=5#>:#)7P1#'159#>:#P5>4H=>1#'L474>#A;4>8#1=G8#@>=>1W@>=<1#>7=2@G12?42<#=2?#42G5P?42<#4>@#L71?1G1@@:7X>81#
@P6[1G>#:9#:21#61G:H42<#>81#:6[1G>#:9#>81#21O>ME#)84@#%7:@#A;84G8#G17>=425C#G=2#61#D41;1?#=@#@L474>P=5M#4@#=#
L74H=7C#?74D17#:9#1D:5P>4:2#4>@159N#@>=7>42<#=55#>81#;=C#6=GR#;4>8#>81#e4<#e=2<#=2?#=55#>81#;=C#>87:P<8#>:#P5>4W
H=>1#%254<8>12H12>E#,@#%74G8#f=2>@G8#LP>#4>N#1D:5P>4:2#4@#B@159W:7<=24Z=>4:2#>87:P<8#@159W>7=2@G12?12G1NI#=2?#
>8=>#B>7=2@G12?#=2?#42G5P?1I#4@#>81#D17C#9:7H#:9#>81#H:H12>W>:WH:H12>#P29:5?42<#:9#71=54>CE
#
&P7>817N# ;8=># F+# ?1@G7461@# =@# B71=5IX:7# B>81# 42>7=2@4>4D1# 51D15IX4@# =G>P=55C# =2?# H:@>5C# >P7]P:4@1#
71=54>CE#)84@#4@#2:>#>81#@=H1#B71=5I#>8=>#4@#9:P2?#=>#>81#71?#51D15N#>81#=H617#51D15N#>81#:7=2<1#51D15N#>81#<7112#
51D15N#:7#>81#42?4<:#51D15E#!9#F+#?1@G7461?#;8=>#4>#H1=2>#6C#B:2>:5:<CI#>:#@:H1:21#=>#71?N#>81C#;:P5?#g=>5C#
?4@=<711N#;4>8#F+V@#D17@4:2#:9#:2>:5:<C#6142<#B:D17#>8147#81=?@EI#!2#9=G>N#;8=>#H:@>#@:L84@>4G=>1?#>842R17@#
>:?=C#G=55#B:2>:5:<CI#4@#=G>P=55C#>81#>P7]P:4@1#51D15#:9#6142<WG:2@G4:P@21@@X=2?#2:>#=@#=#H171#?1@G74L>4:2N#
6P>#=#71=5#:2>4GW1L4@>1H4G#@>7PG>P71#:9#>81#P24D17@1E#)81@1#51D15@#:9#6142<WG:2@G4:P@21@@#=71#2:>#[P@>#51D15@#
:9#=#8PH=2#6142<N#6P>#51D15@#:9#>81#0:@H:@#4>@159#A=2?#>8:@1#?4991712>#51D15@#are#?4991712>#;:75?@hME#':#!#=H#
G17>=425C#2:>#@=C42<#>8=>#>84@#B>P7]P:4@1#71=54>CI#:7#:2>:5:<C#4@2V>#71=5N#:25C#>8=>#4>#4@#42@1L=7=651#97:H#>81#L71W
812@4D1WR2:;42<WG:2@G4:P@21@@#:9#>81#>P7]P:4@1#51D15#:9#6142<WG:2@G4:P@21@@#4>@159E#)8171#4@#2:#;=C#=7:P2?#
>84@XL71G4@15C#61G=P@1#:9#L=2L@CG84@H#A@PG8#=@#@P6@G7461?#>:#6C#-14624>ZN#384>181=?N#:7#K147G1ME#)81#>P7W
]P:4@1#51D15#5::R@#=>#>81#=>:H4G#51D15N#>81#H:51GP5=7#51D15N#>81#G155P5=7#64:5:<4G=5#51D15N#1>GEN#=2?#G:2G5P?1@#
>81C#8=D1#=#71=54>C#42#=2?#:9#>81H@15D1@X=2#:2>:5:<CX6P>#2:>#:25C#4@#4>#?1@G74642<#>8:@1#51D15@#=@#;8=>#>81C#
5::R#54R1#97:H#>P7]P:4@1X1D12#49#;1#4<2:71#>8=>#L=7>X>81C#=71#:D175::R42<#>81#L71812@4D1WG:2@G4:P@21@@W
R2:;42<#?4H12@4:2#:9#>81#=>:H@N#H:51GP51@N#=2?#G155@#>81H@15D1@N#=2#1L4@>1H4G#?4H12@4:2#>8=>#G:WG71=>1@#>81#
:2>4G#?4H12@4:2#;4>8#>81#6142<#=@L1G>#:9#>8:@1#8:5:2@#A=2?#D4G1#D17@=MX=<=42N#1L4@>1H:5:<C#=2?#:2>:5:<C#
=71#>;:#?4991712>#?4H12@4:2@#:9#>81#@=H1#38:5121@@#:9#>81#71=5#:GG=@4:2N#=2?#G=22:>#61#97=<H12>1?#;4>8:P>#
<12P421#D4:512G1#>:#>81#0:@H:@E
#
)8P@N#9:7#1O=HL51N#>=R1#H:51GP51@#?P742<#>81#H=<4G#17=E#BU:51GP51@I#?4?#2:>#B1OW4@>I#AH1=242<N#B@>=2?#
:P>IM#=2C;8171#42#>81#H=<4G#;:75?X>8171#;=@#2:>842<#42#>81#G:2@G4:P@21@@#:9#42?4D4?P=5@#=>#H=<4G#>8=>#G:7W
71@L:2?1?#;4>8#BH:51GP51@EI#eP>#;1#H:?172@X;1#=>#>P7]P:4@1X=@@PH1#>8=>#>81#H:51GP51@#1O4@>1?#2:21W
>8151@@X49#>81C#?4?2V>#1OW4@>N#>81C#?4?#;8=>#;1#H4<8>#G=55#subsist#A!#=<711ME#)84@#4@#@4H45=7#>:#F+V@#>7=2@4>4D1#
A1OW4@>M#=2?#42>7=2@4>4D1#A@P6@4@>M#;4>8#:21#H=[:7#1OG1L>4:2Y#=@#2:>1?N#!)#4@#L=2L@CG84GX1L4@>1H:5:<C#=2?#
:2>:5:<C#\#G:2@G4:P@21@@#=2?#6142<#G=22:>#61#>:72#=@P2?17E#38=>#;1#G=55#BL71W8PH=2#:2>:5:<CI#4@#=G>P=55C#
a &+$;:90.(" %$(),$()" :'/'(<%" $&,%)$0,-;'(),-" =:'/$($%%N# =2?# 2:># H1715C# =# ?4@1H6:?41?N# g:=>42<N# BD41;W
97:HW2:;8171I#:2>:5:<CE#,#H:51GP51V@#L71812@4:2WR2:;42<WL7:>:W911542<#4@#=2#42@1L=7=651#L=7>#:9#4>@#6142<W
:2>:5:<4G=5#H=R1PL#=>#>81#H:51GP5=7#51D15N#=2?#6:>8#=71#21G1@@=7C#>:#G:WG71=>1#1=G8#:>817E#!<2:742<#L71812W
@4:2#A=2?#G:2@G4:P@21@@M#[P@>#51=D1@#:2>:5:<CW6142<#9:7#>81#H:51GP51N#=2?#1L4@>1H:5:<CWG:2@G4:P@21@@#4@#[P@>#
<4D12#>:#8PH=2@#A:7#84<817#H=HH=5@MN#2:>#>:#=55#@12>412>#6142<@X>81C#:25C#<1>#6142<N#2:>#R2:;42<E#eP>#49#=#
8PH=2#G:2@G4:P@21@@WR2:;42<#4@#2:>#42D:5D1?#42#G:WG71=>42<#>81#:2>:5:<C#:9#=>:H@N#H:51GP51@N#:7#G155@N#their
own#G:2@G4:P@21@@WL71812@4:2#4@#42D:5D1?N#=55#>81#;=C#?:;2#A#5=#K147G1#=2?#384>181=?ME
#
&P7>817N#;812#;1#=G>P=55C#<1>#?:;2#>:#1OL5=4242<#;8=>#>84@#@P6@4@>12G1#71=54>C#4@X>81#B71=5IX4>#G8=2<W
1@#;4>8#1=G8#21;#@>7PG>P71#A71?N#=H617N#:7=2<1N#<7112N#1>GEME#38=>#;1#<5465C#G=55#B=>:H@I#1OW4@>#=>#:7=2<1J#
>8:@1# 61G:H1# @P6W@P6=>:H4G# L=7>4G51@# =># <7112# AH1@:2@N# 6:@:2@N# <5P:2@N# 1>GEMJ# >8:@1# 61G:H1# iW9:5?W;=C#
]P=7R@#=>#>1=5J#>8:@1#61G:H1#__W?4H12@4:2=5#@>742<@#=>#>P7]P:4@1E#31#G=2V>#say#;8=>#>81#=>:H4G#51D15#4@#1OG1L>#
97:H#@:H1#@>7PG>P71#:9#6142<WG:2@G4:P@21@@N#=2?#1=G8#@>7PG>P71#?4@G5:@1@#=#21;#:2>:5:<CN#=#21;#;:75?E#A)8=>#
44JournalofIntegralTheoryandPractice

INTEGRALTHEORY

:2>:5:<C#4@#>8171N#4@#71=5N#6P>#4@#G:WG71=>1?#6C#>81#L71812@4D1#8:5:2@#=>#>8=>#51D15EM#,<=42N#>84@#4@#2:>#>:#71?PG1#
:2>:5:<C#>:#1L4@>1H:5:<CN#6P>#7=>817#G5=4H#>81C#=71#G:HL51H12>=7C#=@L1G>@#:9#>81#@=H1#38:51#:GG=@4:2E#A!2#
@8:7>N#!#?4@=<711#;4>8#6:>8#0=2>#=2?#e8=@R=7X:7#!#=<711#;4>8#>81H#6:>8N#?1L12?42<#:2#8:;#C:P#5::R#=>#4>EM
#
)84@#71H42?@#H1#:9#.PH617>:#U=>P7=2=#=2?#&7=2G4@G:#S=715=V@#674554=2>#=2=5C@4@#:9#>81#;:75?#A>81#B71W
=54>CIM#:9#=#97:<E#K74:7#>:#U=>P7=2=#=2?#S=715=N#H:@>#64:5:<4@>@#9:55:;1?#@:H1#9:7H#:9#1G:@C@>1H@#>81:7C#=2?#
?1@G7461?#>81#71=54>C#:9#>81#97:<#=@#1O4@>42<#42#D=74:P@#@C@>1H@#:9#2=>P71E#eP>#U=>P7=2=#=2?#S=715=#L:42>1?#:P>#
>8=>#>8=>#;=@#=G>P=55C#;8=>#>81#97:<V@#71=54>C#5::R1?#54R1#fromthescientists#L:42>#:9#D41;N#6P>#2:>#97:H#>81#
97:<V@E#)81#97:<V@#BD41;#97:H#;4>842I#AZ:21#_M#G:2@4@>1?#:25C#:9#D=74:P@#L=>G81@#:9#G:5:7#=2?#H:>4:2N#@H155@#
=2?#@:P2?@J#4>#?4?#2:>#8=D1#>81#G:<24>4D1#G=L=G4>C#>:#@>=2?#:P>@4?1#4>@159#=2?#L4G>P71#>81#12>471#@C@>1H#:9#;84G8#
4>#;=@#=#L=7>X:25C#>81#@G412>4@>#?4?#>8=>#AP@42<#Z:21#iME#+1=54>CN#9:7#>81#97:<N#;=@#>81#4HH1?4=>1#D41;#97:H#
Z:21#_N#=2?#>81#61@>#>81#@G412>4@>#G:P5?#?:#;=@#=>>1HL>#>:#G=L>P71#>8=>#P@42<#Z:21#dX=#bL#O#_WL#O#bLX2=H15CN#
>81#:6[1G>4D1#@G412>4@>N#;8451#@>P?C42<#=2#:6[1G>4D1#:7<=24@H#AbLMN#=>>1HL>@#>:#>=R1#>81#:7<=24@HV@#BD41;#97:H#
;4>842I#:7#B64:5:<4G=5#L812:H12:5:<CI#A_WLMX>;:#L87=@1@#S=715=#:9>12#P@1?E#S=715=#L:42>1?#:P>#>8=>#>84@#
BD41;#97:H#;4>842I#;=@#2:>#>81#=G>P=5#Q7@>WL17@:2#D41;#:9#>81#97:<#4>@159#>8=>#>81#@G412>4@>#4@#?471G>5C#:6@17D42<#
A>8=>#;:P5?#61#>81#97:<V@#Z:21#_MN#6P>#>81#1O>174:7#D17@4:2#:9#>81#97:<V@#42217#D41;#A:7#Z:21#dJ#4E1EN#>81#D41;#
97:H#>81#42@4?1#:9#>81#jLL17#+4<8>N#2:>#>81#42@4?1#:9#>81#jLL17#-19>ME#)81#L:42>#4@#>8=>#>81#97:<#12=G>@#4>@#:;2#
71=54>CX4>@#:;2#1L4@>1H:5:<C#:7#G:2@G4:P@21@@#6742<@#9:7>8#=2?#G:WG71=>1@#4>@#:;2#:2>:5:<C#:7#;:75?#A>81#
G5:@1@>#>:#;84G8#>81#@G412>4@>#G=2#<1>#4@#Z:21#dMX=2?#>81#@G412>4@>#84H@159#54R1;4@1#12=G>@N#:7#G=2#12=G>N#84@#
:;2#D41;#:9#>81#97:<V@#71=54>CN#;84G8#H=2C#@G412>4@>@#61541D1#4@#<1217=55C#=#@C@>1H@#D41;#AZ:21#iMN#6P>#H:71#
>7P>89P55C#4@#=#Z:21Wd#D17@4:2E#eP>#42#6:>8#G=@1@N#>81#6142<#=2?#R2:;42<#=71#>;:#?4H12@4:2@#:9#>81#@=H1#=G>P=5#
:GG=@4:2N#;8=>1D17#4>#4@E#eP>#H1715C#P@42<#=#@C@>1H@#D41;#4@#=#?11L5C#=2>87:L:G12>74G#D41;#:9#>81#97:<V@#71=5#
;:75?N#=2?#G5=4H42<#>:#R2:;#>81#97:<V@#=G>P=5#;:75?#AZ:21#_M#6C#P@42<#>81#@G412>4@>V@#>::5@#AZ:21#iM#?:1@#<7=D1#
D4:512G1#>:#>81#97:<V@#=G>P=5#42>174:7E#
#
)8P@N#=GG:7?42<#>:#!)N#>81#51D15#:9#>81#B71=5I#?1@G7461?#6C#F+#?:1@2V>#1O4@>#=@#F+#?1@G7461@#4>E#+=>817N#
42#!)V@#D41;N#42#=G>P=54>C#4>#4@#14>817#>81#L7:?PG>#:9#6:>8#>81#L71812@4D1W911542<WR2:;42<#L5P@#8:5:24GW6142<W
4@21@@#:9#1=G8#:9#>81#8:5:2@#=>#>81#L=7>4GP5=7#51D15#:9#>81#71=5#6142<#?1@G7461?#A1E<EN#]P=7R@N#=>:H@N#H:51GP51@N#
<121>4G@M#=2?#>8147#715=>4:2@X=55#:9#;84G8#=71#>1>7=W12=G>1?#=2?#>1>7=W1D:5D1?J#=2?\:7#4>#4@#>81#71@P5>#:9#>81#
;=C#>81#;:75?#1H17<1@#=2?#4@#>1>7=W12=G>1?#=>#=2?#97:H#=#L=7>4GP5=7#51D15#:9#G:2@G4:P@21@@W6142<#A1E<EN#>P7W
]P:4@1M#:9#>81#@G412>4@>E#!2#>81#5=>>17#G=@1N#>81#71=5#4@#2:>#G71=>1?#6C#4>@#H171#?1@G74L>4:2#6C#>81#L=7>4GP5=7#51D15#
:9#G:2@G4:P@21@@W6142<N#6P>#7=>817#=G>P=55C#1H17<1@#=@#=#51D15#:9#>81#71=5#;4>8#>81#1H17<12G1#:9#>81#?11L#
@>7PG>P71@#:9#>81#L=7>4GP5=7#51D15#:9#6142<WG:2@G4:P@21@@E#A,<=42N#>81@1#51D15@#:9#6142<WG:2@G4:P@21@@#=71#2:>#
[P@>#51D15@#:9#8PH=2#6142<@#6P>#51D15@#:9#>81#71=5#0:@H:@EM#)81@1#51D15@#:9#6142<WG:2@G4:P@21@@#A71?N#=H617N#
:7=2<1N#<7112N#>P7]P:4@1N#1>GEM#=71#2:>#?4991712>#42>17L71>=>4:2@#:9#=#:21N#@42<51N#L71<4D12#71=54>C#:7#;:75?N#6P>#
=71#>81H@15D1@#=G>P=55C#differentworlds#42#?11L#@>7PG>P71#A=2#4297=71?#;:75?N#=#71?#;:75?N#=2#=H617#;:75?N#=2#
:7=2<1#;:75?N#=#<7112#;:75?N#=#>P7]P:4@1#;:75?N#1>GEN#$.-:"'>"?:,-:",%"-'0&'%$@"'>"A.)9+$<%"'+"4'%0,-":.B,)%"
tetracreatedbythesentientholonsatthoselevels,#=@#=71#=>:H4GN#H:51GP5=7N#G155P5=7N#1>GEN#;:75?@ME#
#
)81#?11L#@>7PG>P71@#:9#>81@1#;:75?@#=71#>81#2:2?P=5#1L4@>1H4GW:2>4G#38:51#:GG=@4:2@N#6P>#>84@#?:1@2V>#
L71D12>#>81H#97:H#6142<#9=554651#;812#4>#G:H1@#>:#8PH=2@V#=>>1HL>@#=>#?4@G5:@42<#=2?#?4@G:D1742<#=2?#?1W
@G74642<#>81#71=5#G8=7=G>174@>4G@#:9#>81#38:51J#4E1EN#>81#@P79=G1#1L4@>1H4GW:2>4G#=LL7:=G81@#=71#9=554651#A;84G8#
4@#:21#:9#>81#71=@:2@#>8=>#HP5>4L51#methodologiesX1L4@>1H:5:<41@#>8=>#G:W12=G>#=2?#G:WG71=>1#G:7715=>4D1#:2W
>:5:<41@N#=2?#D4G1#D17@=X=71#@:#4HL:7>=2>MY#>81#H:71#H1>8:?:5:<41@#P@1?N#>81#54R15417#>81#?11L17#38:5121@@#
A>81#?11L17#P24>C#:9#6142<WG:2@G4:P@21@@M#;455#61#=GGP7=>15C#?4@G5:@1?#=2?#12=G>1?#42#H:71#:9#4>@#?4H12@4:2@E#
#
)81@1#?11L#91=>P71@#:9#>81#71=5#=71X#5=#K147G1X2:>#1>172=5#L71<4D12#71=54>41@#:9#=#:21#;:75?N#6P>#
"=>P71V@#habits#>8=>#8=D1#6112#12<7=D1?#42#>81#P24D17@1#>87:P<8#>81#42>17=G>4:2#:9#@1H4:>4GW@12>412>#6142<@#
A>8=>#<:#=55#>81#;=C#?:;2X42G5P?42<#]P=7R@#=2?#=>:H@X;84G8#4@#;8C#>8171#=71#L7:>:WG:2@G4:P@W911542<W
R2:;42<#6142<@#L71@12>#fromthestart#>:#=G>P=55C#G71=>1#8=64>@X>81C#=71#54D42<#=2?#G:2@G4:P@#6142<@#ca
&.B/$#:9#9:7H42<#8=64>@hX42@>1=?#:9#L71812@4:2W9711#:2>:5:<41@#>8=>#8=D1#2:#54D42<#G8:4G1@N#=2?#>8P@#HP@>#
JournalofIntegralTheoryandPractice45

K.WILBER

6542?5C# :61C# 5=;@N# @:H1>842<# 6:>8# K147G1# =2?# !N# =H:2<# :>817@N# Q2?# P242>1554<4651E# &P7>817N# =GG:7?42<# >:#
K147G1N#4>#4@#>81#9=G>#>8=>#1=G8#@1H4:>4G#6142<X=55#>81#;=C#?:;2X8=@#42#4>@#>74L=7>4>1#H=R1PL#=2#,()$+&+$
tant#>8=>#H1=2@#>81#8:5:2V@#6142<#4@#?1>17H421?#42#L=7>#6C#42>17L71>=>4:2N#=55#>81#;=C#?:;2X=2?#>84@N#81#@=C@N#
4@#B421@G=L=651IME#
#
384G8#6742<@#P@#>:#=2:>817#L:42>E#(74<42=55CN#F+#;=@#G71=>1?#=@#=#;=C#>:#1OL5=42#=2?#[P@>49C#>81#71W
@P5>@#:9#@G412>4QG#1OL174H12>@#A=@#0=75#K:LL17#=@R1?N#L=7=L87=@42<N#B.:;#4@#4>#>8=>#@G412G1#=G>P=55C#;:7R@k#
!>#;:7R@#61G=P@1#>8171#4@#=#71=5#:2>:5:<C#>8=>#G=2#716P99#4>IME#eP>#4>#4@#2:>#G51=7#=>#=55#>8=>#>81#>CL1@#:9#71=54W
>41@#?4@G5:@1?#6C#@G412G1#=2?#@G412>4QG#1OL174H12>@#=71#>81#@=H1#:21@#>8=>#;:7R#;4>8#H:7=5@N#817H121P>4G@N#
=1@>81>4G@N#=2?#42>7:@L1G>4:2N#>:#2=H1#=#91;#:9#>81#HP5>4L51#H1>8:?:5:<41@#>8=>#1O4@>#:P>#>8171#=2?#=??71@@#
?4991712>#:6[1G>#?:H=42@#=2?#Z:21@E#):#G5=4H#>8=>#:25C#@G412>4QG#1OL174H12>@#<4D1#B71=5I#71@P5>@#4@#L1745:P@5C#
G5:@1#>:#@G412>4@HN#=2?#@4HL5C#=??42<#:>817#?4@G4L5421@#:2#>:L#:9#@G412G1#4@#=G>P=55C#>:#71?PG1#>8:@1#?4H12W
@4:2@#>:#H1715C#@G412>4QG#H1>8:?:5:<C#4>@159E#+1?PG42<#=55#?4H12@4:2@#>:#@G412G1#G17>=425C#@>74R1@#H1#=@#6142<#
9=7#97:H#=2#42>1<7=5#H:D1E#!#=H#HPG8#H:71#@=>4@Q1?#;4>8#>81#A=>#51=@>M#14<8>#9P2?=H12>=5#H1>8:?:5:<41@#>8=>#
?4@G5:@1#?4991712>#:6[1G>#?:H=42@#A=2?#;8:@1#42[P2G>4:2@#:7#L=7=?4<H@#12=G>#:7#6742<#9:7>8#:7#G:WG71=>1#>8:@1#
D=74:P@#?:H=42@N#;84G8N#=<=42N#=71#2:>#[P@>#5C42<#=7:P2?#:P>#>8171#;=4>42<#>:#61#@>PH651?#:2#6C#=#@G412>4QG#
H1>8:?:5:<CX>8=>#615419#4@#;8=>#'155=7@#G=55@#B>81#HC>8#:9#>81#<4D12IME
#
U:71#71G12>5CN#e8=@R=7#8=@#42>7:?PG1?#@L474>P=5#71=54>41@#=2?#G:2@G4:P@21@@#42>:#84@#@G81H1E#eP>#?PHLW
42<#G:2@G4:P@21@@#:2#>:L#:9#=2#:2>:5:<4G=5#@G81H1#>8=>#;=@#?1D15:L1?#;4>8:P>#4>#4@N#;155N#G81=>42<E#)81#;8:51#
@G81H1#8=@#>:#61#?:21#:D17N#P@42<#G:2@G4:P@21@@#=@#=2#42>742@4G#L=7>#:9#>81#@G81H1#97:H#>81#D17C#61<42242<N#
=2?#2:>#@4HL5C#4HL:7>42<#4>#=9>17#>81#@G81H1#8=@#6112#?1D15:L1?#;4>8:P>#4>E#)81#G8=2G1@#>8=>#>81#@G81H1#
;455#8=D1#=2C>842<#71=5#>:#?:#;4>8#=G>P=5#G:2@G4:P@21@@#4@#@54H#42?11?N#=@#G:2@G4:P@21@@#61G:H1@#=#deusex
machina#>:#>81#H=42#97=H1E
#
&42=55CN#!#;:P5?#61#71H4@@#49#!#?4?2V>#=>#51=@>#6741gC#H12>4:2#>81#G5=4H@#H=?1#:2#618=59#:9#]P=2>PH#
H1G8=24G@#AlUMN#;84G8#8=@N#49#2:>842<#15@1N#6112#>=R12#=@#>81#H:@>#@PGG1@@9P55C#L71G4@1#@G412>4QG#H:?15#1D17#
42D12>1?#A:21#1@>4H=>1#LP>#4>#=>#=#H4554:2#>4H1@#H:71#L71G4@1#>8=2#"1;>:24=2#L8C@4G@ME#)81#G12>7=5#G:2G172#
:9#lU#G12>17@#=7:P2?#;8=>#4@#G=551?#>81#BG:55=L@1#:9#>81#;=D1#L=GR1>I#A;84G8#H1=2@N#@4HL54@>4G=55CN#>84@Y#
=7:P2?#_mTdN#6:>8#.14@12617<#=2?#'G87:1?42<17#G=H1#PL#;4>8#=#@1>#:9#H=>81H=>4G=5#1]P=>4:2@#?1@G74642<#
>81#1O4@>12G1#:9#=#@P6=>:H4G#L=7>4G51E#.14@12617<V@#;=@#=#G:HL54G=>1?#'H=>74O#1]P=>4:2N#=2?#'G87:1?42<17V@#
=#@4HL517#G=5GP5P@#;=D1E#)81C#;171#]P4GR5C#@8:;2#>:#61#42>17G8=2<1=651#42#71@P5>@N#=2?#>8P@#'G87:1?42<17V@#
;=D1#1]P=>4:2N#6142<#>81#@4HL517#:9#>81#>;:N#@::2#61G=H1#>81#@>=2?=7?#9:7H#:9#lUXB>81#G:55=L@1#:9#>81#
;=D1#L=GR1>I#71917@#>:#>81#G:55=L@1#:9#'G87:1?42<17V@#;=D1#1]P=>4:2#D17@4:2ME#U=O#K5=2GR#A;8:#8=?#42>7:W
?PG1?#>81#]P=2>PH#71D:5P>4:2#42#_m^d#6C#@P<<1@>42<#>8=>#1217<C#?:1@#2:>#G:H1#42#=#G:2>42PPH#6P>#7=>817#
1O4@>@#42#?4@G71>1#L=GR1>@#:7#]P=2>=M#2:>4G1?#>8=>#49#C:P#>=R1#>81#@]P=71#:9#>81#71@P5>@#:9#>81#'G87:1?42<17#
1]P=>4:2N#C:P#;:P5?#<1>#>81#L7:6=6454>C#:9#>81#@L1G4QG#5:G=>4:2#A=2?\:7#=#@1>#:9#:>817#G8=7=G>174@>4G@M#:9#>81#
L=7>4G51#42#]P1@>4:2#A6P>#C:P#<1>#:25C#>;:#G8=7=G>174@>4G@#=>#=#>4H1X=2?X>81#G=>G8X>81#more#C:P#Q2?#:9#
:21N#>81#less#C:P#can#Q2?#:9#>81#:>817ME#)81#71@P5>@#:9#>84@#42=6454>C#>:#?1>17H421#6:>8#D=74=651@#;=@#=651#>:#61#
LP>#42#=#L71G4@1#9:7H#=@#;8=>#61G=H1#9=H:P@5C#R2:;2#=@#>81#.14@12617<#j2G17>=42>C#K742G4L51N#;84G8#6=@4W
G=55C#67:P<8>#=2#12?#>:#@>74G>#G=P@=54>C#42#>81#L8C@4G=5#@G412G1@#A=2?#L71@PH=65C#71H:D1?#BG=P@=54>CI#97:H#
>81#+1=54@>@#51D15#:9#>81#B71=5IME#eP>#>81#71=5#R4GR17#G=H1#97:H#>81#9=G>#>8=>N#L74:7#>:#=G>P=55C#H1=@P742<#>81#
L=7>4G51#>:#<=42#@:H1#429:7H=>4:2#=6:P>#4>N#>81#L=7>4G51#1O4@>1?#:25C#=@#=#L7:6=6454>CXC:P#literally#G:P5?2V>#
@=C#4>#1O4@>1?#:7#4>#?4?2V>#1O4@>E#U:71:D17N#>81#>CL1#:9#H1=@P71H12>#>8=>#C:P#L179:7H1?#:2#>81#L=7>4G51#?1>17W
H421?#>81#>CL1#:9#6142<#>8=>#C:P#=G>P=55C#1D:R1?X?4991712>#H1=@P742<#H1>8:?@#<=D1#C:P#?4991712>#6142<@#
;4>8#?4991712>#]P=54>41@E#)84@#51?#f:82#3811517#>:#@=C#>8=>#;1#54D1?#42#=#BL=7>4G4L=>:7CW:6@17D=>4:2I#P24D17@1E#
lU#8=@#2:;#6112#9:P2?#=LL54G=651#42#@G=51@#97:H#>81#D17C#@H=551@>#>:#>81#D17C#5=7<1@>N#=@#;155#=@#42#67=42#
42>17=G>4:2@N#64:5:<CN#1>GEN#=2?#71H=42@N#9:7#;8=>#4>#?:1@N#B>81#H:@>#@PGG1@@9P5#L8C@4G=5#>81:7C#:9#=55#>4H1EI
#
38=>#4@#71H=7R=651#=6:P>#>84@#>81:7C#4@#8:;#Q7H5C#4>#P24>1@#1L4@>1H:5:<C#=2?#:2>:5:<CX>81#>;:N#42#
9=G>N#G:W1D:R1#1=G8#:>817E#,#?4991712>#1L4@>1H:5:<C#6742<@#9:7>8#=#?4991712>#:2>:5:<CN#=2?#=#?4991712>#:2>:5:<C#
46JournalofIntegralTheoryandPractice

INTEGRALTHEORY

;455#G:7715=>1#;4>8#=#@L1G4QG#=2?#?4991712>#1L4@>1H:5:<CX1=G8#:9#>81HN#=@#4>#;171N#6742<42<#9:7>8#>81#G:7715=W
>4D1#?4H12@4:2#A:7#G:WG71=>42<#4>ME
#
!#?:2V>#;=2>#>:#:D17W1HL8=@4Z1#>81#7:51#:9#lU#42#!2>1<7=5#)81:7CE#!#?:#;=2>#>:#L:42>#:P>N#8:;1D17N#
>8=>X@>=7>42<#;4>8#0=75#K:LL17X>81#7:51#:9#@G412G1#42#F+#8=@#6112#L17D=@4D1N#6P>#@G412G1#8=@#6112#G8=2<42<#
42#L7:9:P2?#;=C@#>8=>#F+#@11H@#2:>#>:#8=D1#R1L>#PL#;4>8E#!9#1D17#>8171#;=@#=#G=@1#:9#BH1=2@#:9#R2:;42<I#
<:D17242<#42#H=2C#;=C@#BH:?1@#:9#6142<NI#lU#4@#4>N#P2?124=65CE#,2?#<4D12#>8=>#lU#4@#>81#H:@>#@PGG1@@9P5#
L8C@4G=5#>81:7C#42#84@>:7CN#:21V@#B:2>:5:<CI#@8:P5?#L7:6=65C#5421#PL#;4>8#4>E
#
!#H4<8>#H12>4:2#>8=>#4>V@#2:>#[P@>#>81#1O4@>12G1#:9#>81#9:P7#]P=?7=2>@#>8=>#4@#4HL:7>=2>XH=2C#>81:74@>@#
42G5P?1#>81#9:P7#]P=?7=2>@X6P>#7=>817#>8147#6142<#9:P7#?4991712>#?4H12@4:2@#:9#>81#@=H1#:GG=@4:2N#H:H12>#
>:#H:H12>N#>8=>#4@#?4@>42G>4D1#;4>8#!)E#)81#9:P7#]P=?7=2>@N#9P7>817N#<:#=55#>81#;=C#?:;2N#=2?#>84@#H1=2@#>8=>#
G:2@G4:P@21@@#4>@159#<:1@#=55#>81#;=C#?:;2N#=@#=2#42>742@4G#L=7>#:9#>81#D17C#9=674G#:9#>81#0:@H:@#4>@159E#)84@#
4@#;8=>#@1>@#!2>1<7=5#)81:7C#=L=7>#97:H#@:#H=2C#:>817#>81:741@E#,@L1G>@#:9#G:2@G4:P@21@@X;84G8#4>@159#4@#
L74H=745C#=2#:L1242<#:7#G51=742<#42#;84G8#@P6[1G>4D1#=2?#:6[1G>4D1#L812:H12=#G=2#1H17<1X42G5P?1Y
n#
n#

n#

G71=>4D4>C#A=@#L=7>#:9#>81#D17C#:L1242<#42#;84G8#21;21@@#=2?#2:D15>C#can#=LL1=7N#=2?#>81#
H1=2@#bywhich4>#G=2#=LL1=7M
=2#=P>:H=>4G#1L4@>1H4GWL71812@4:2#:9#>81#L71G1?42<#H:H12>#A;84G8#G:WG71=>1@#:7#815L@#
6742<#9:7>8#>81#6142<#:7#:2>:5:<C#:9#>81#L71@12>#H:H12>X4>@#6142<#B<7=@L1?I#4@#;8=>#
6742<@#4>#9:7>8N#=2?#4>@#6142<#L71812?1?#6C#=2#,()$+&+$).()N#=#5=#K147G1N#4@#;8=>#<4D1@#>81#
P2=D:4?=651#42>17L71>4D1#>;4@>#>:#4>@#6142<M
;8451N#=>#>81#@=H1#>4H1N#>81#B42G5P?1I#L=7>#A:9#B>7=2@G12?#=2?#42G5P?1IM#H1=2@#>81#L71D4W
:P@#H:H12>N#:2G1#@P6[1G>#6P>#2:;#:6[1G>#:9#>81#21;#@P6[1G>N#4@#42G5P?1?#:7#54>17=55C#taken
into#>81#6142<#:9#>81#21;#@P6[1G>N#>8P@#=5>1742<#>81#21;#@P6[1G>V@#D17C#6142<#:7#:2>:5:<C#
42#>81#@L1G4QG#=G>#:9#42G5P@4:2X=<=42N#1L4@>1H:5:<CWG:2@G4:P@21@@#=2?#8:5:24GW6142<#
=71#G:WG71=>4D1#=2?#G:W?1>17H4242<#=@#>;:#=@L1G>@#:9#>81#38:51#71=5#:GG=@4:2E#'PGR42<#
1L4@>1H4GWG:2@G4:P@21@@W911542<#:P>#:9#>81#8:5:2N#51=D42<#:25C#4>@#?1=?#=2?#?12P?1?#6142<#
:7#:2>:5:<C#4@#1991G>4D15C#>:#R455#>81#6142<#42#]P1@>4:2N#=2?#=2>87:L:G12>74G=55C#>:#>7=2@917#
=55#>81#1L4@>1H4GWR2:;42<W911542<WG:2@G4:P@21@@#?4H12@4:2@#>:#8PH=2@#=5:21N#;8:#>812#
L7:L:@1#>81:741@#=6:P>#>84@#?12P?1?#51D15#:9#6142<#>8=>#>81C#G=55#B>81#71=5EI#)84@#4@#>7=<4GE
# &P7>817N#;8451#>81#B>7=2@G12?I#L=7>#4@#%7:@N#:7#'L474>W42W=G>4:2#A:7#'L474>W42W@159W:7<=W
24Z=>4:2MN#=2?#4@#42[1G>42<#'L474>P=5#G71=>4D4>C#42>:#1D17C#H:H12>#A>8P@#H=R42<#1D:5P>4:2#
B@159W:7<=24Z=>4:2#>87:P<8# @159W>7=2@G12?12G1NI# =@# %74G8# f=2>@G8# LP># 4>MX;8451# >8=># 4@#
8=LL1242<N#>81#42G5P?1#L=7>#4@#>=R42<#G=71#:9#>8:@1#=@L1G>@#<1217=55C#R2:;2#=@#BG=P@=5W
4>CI#=2?#42?PG>4:2E#!9#>81#?1<711#:9#G71=>4D4>C#:7#2:D15>C#42#=#8:5:2W6142<#4@#1O>71H15C#
@H=55#A=@#;4>8N#@=CN#=#]P=7RMN#>812#>81#L71D4:P@#H:H12>V@#42G5P?42<#G:HL:212>#;455#61#6C#
9=7#>81#@>7:2<1@>#?1>17H42=2>#:9#>81#21;#@P6[1G>N#=2?#>81#21;#@P6[1G>#;455#@11H#G:HL51>1W
5C#?1>17H424@>4G#A8=D42<#54>>51#G71=>4D4>C#>:#G:P2>17#>81#G=P@=54>CME#eP>#384>181=?#L:42>@#
:P>#>8=>#2:#6142<V@#G71=>4D4>C#4@#=6@:5P>15C#Z17:N#:25C#D=24@842<5C#@H=55N#=2?#>8P@#@>74G>#
?1>17H424@H#:7#@>74G>#G=P@=54>C#?:1@2V>#1O4@>#A>81#@=H1#=@#H=42>=421?#6C#lUME#U:71:D17N#
>81# 84<817# :2# >81# *71=># "1@># >8=># =# 8:5:2# =LL1=7@N# >81# H:71# 2:D15>C# =2?# G71=>4D4>C# 4>#
L:@@1@@1@X@:#=#L8C@4G4@>#G=2#L71?4G>#;8171#j7=2P@#;455#61N#H:71#:7#51@@N#=#_N^^^#C1=7@#
97:H#2:;N#6P>#2:#64:5:<4@>#G=2#>155#C:P#;8171#HC#?:<#;455#61#_#H42P>1#97:H#2:;E#eP>#9:7#
>8:@1#8:5:2W6142<@#;4>8#54>>51#G71=>4D4>CN#>81#B>7=2@G12?#=2?#42G5P?1I#H1G8=24G@#=GG:P2>@#
9:7#=2#=2@;17#>:#.PH1V@#G74>4]P1#:9#6:>8#G=P@=54>C#=2?#42?PG>4:2#A4E1EN#=GG:P2>@#9:7#>8147#
1O4@>12G1N#1D12#=@#6:>8#61G:H1#51@@#=2?#51@@#>81#84<817#>81#?1<711#:9#?1D15:LH12>#=2?#
1D:5P>4:2ME

JournalofIntegralTheoryandPractice47

K.WILBER

!#?:#;=2>#>:#71L1=>#>8=>#>8171#4@#HPG8#42#F+#>8=>#!#=LL71G4=>1E#!#L=7>4GP5=75C#=LL71G4=>1#8=D42<#=2#=55C#
=<=42@>#>81#715=>4D4@H#:9#1O>71H1#L:@>H:?1724@H#A1D12#49N#=5=@N#!#@>455#Q2?#L7:651H@#42#8:;#F+#<:1@#=6:P>#
?:42<#>84@N#6C#74LL42<#G:2@G4:P@21@@#:P>#:9#>81#0:@H:@#=2?#51=D42<#B>81#71=5I#>:#61#H1715C#=#?12P?1?#B:2W
>:5:<CIME#eP>#4>@#81=7>#4@#42#>81#74<8>#L5=G1N#:21#H4<8>#@=CN#=2?#+:C#e8=@R=7#84H@159#4@#=#>7P5C#1O>7=:7?42=7C#
8PH=2# 6142<N# =2?# 1D17C>842<# =# L845:@:L817# @8:P5?# 61N# 42# HC# 8PH651# :L424:2# A4># 71H42?@# H1N# @:H1;8=>#
<7=2?4:@15CN#!#<P1@@N#:9#;8=>#.=617H=@#@=4?#=6:P>#&:PG=P5>#=9>17#>8147#9=H:P@#H11>42<XB.1V@#=#71=5#L84W
5:@:L817IXL7=4@1#42?11?#97:H#.=617H=@ME#)81#9P22C#>842<#4@N#@1D17=5#>81:74@>@#8=D1#L:42>1?#:P>#8:;#F+#
=2?#!)#G=2#61#67:P<8>#42>:#<1217=5#A=2?#1D12#]P4>1#G5:@1M#=<711H12>N#;4>8#=#91;#9P2?=H12>=5#G8=2<1@Y#!)N#
=GG1L>#:2>:5:<C#=@#B>81#71=5IJ#=2?#F+N#=GG1L>42<#1L4@>1H4GW:2>4G#=@#G:7715=>4D1#?4H12@4:2@#:9#>81#@=H1#=G>P=5#
38:5121@@#:9#@12>412>#8:5:2@#<:42<#=55#>81#;=C#?:;2E#,@#!#71=?#F+N#!#R11L#@1142<#4>#@P6>5CXD17C#@P6>5CX
71?PG42<#1D17C>842<#>:#P5>4H=>1#=2G8:7=<1#42#>81#1@@12>4=55C#L71812@4:2W9711#+4<8>W.=2?#]P=?7=2>@#A=2?#!VH#
@P71#F+#@11@#!)#=@#@P6>5C#71?PG42<#1D17C>842<#>:#>81#-19>W.=2?#]P=?7=2>@ME#eP>#HC#L:@4>4:2#4@N#=2?#71H=42@N#
>8=>#=55#9:P7#]P=?7=2>@#=71#1]P=55C#71=5N#1]P=55C#L71@12>N#>1>7=W12=G>42<N#=2?#>1>7=W1D:5D42<N#=2?#=2C>842<#51@@#
>8=2# >8=># A=5:2<# ;4>8# 51D15@N# 5421@N# @>=>1@N# =2?# >CL1@N# 9P5G7PH@# =2?# @;4>G8WL:42>@N# !2>1<7=5# U1>8:?:5:<4G=5#
K5P7=54@HN#=2?#!2>1<7=5#K:@>WU1>=L8C@4G@M#G=2#@G=7G15C#61#G=551?#B42>1<7=5EI

Panpsychism
3812#;1#@=C#>8=>N#9:7#1O=HL51N#=>:H@#?:#2:>#B1OW4@>I#9:7#H=<4G#42?4D4?P=5@N#;1#H1=2N#=@#2:>1?N#>8=>#>8171#4@#
2:>842<#42#>81#G:2@G4:P@21@@#A:7#71G:7?@M#:9#>81#H=<4G#42?4D4?P=5#>8=>#42?4G=>1@#=2C#R2:;51?<1#:9#=>:H@#=>#=55E#
'>455N#;1#42#>81#H:?172#=2?#L:@>H:?172#;:75?X@=CN#>P7]P:4@1X=@@PH1#>8=>#@:H1>842<#54R1#B=>:H@I#2:21W
>8151@@#;171#71=5#=2?#1O4@>1?#42#@:H1#@12@1#?P742<#>81#H=<4G#1L:G8X=2?#>8=>#@12@1#;1#G=55#B@P6@4@>12G1EI#
,>:H@#?4?#2:>#1OW4@>N#6P>#>81C#?4?#@P6@4@>E#
#
eP>#>;:#4HL:7>=2>#L:42>@#=6:P>#>8=>E#(21N#!2>1<7=5#)81:7C#4@#=#D17@4:2#:9#&.(&%6-:,%0#A=#>17H#!VH#
P2G:H9:7>=651# ;4>8N# L71917742<# BL=2W42>174:74@>NI# H1=242<# =55# 8:5:2@# 8=D1# 6:>8# 1O>174:7@# =2?# 42>174:7@N# =55#
>81#;=C#PLN#=55#>81#;=C#?:;2E#)81#42>174:7@#=71#>81#BL71812@4:2@I#:9#384>181=?N#;84G8N#=@#;1VD1#L:42>1?#
:P>N#;1#@>71>G8#>:#B>1>7=WL71812@4:2@IME#,2?#>84@#H1=2@N#619:71#8PH=2#6142<@#1D12#1H17<1?X619:71N#42#9=G>N#
H:51GP51@#1D12#1H17<1?X=55#9:P7#]P=?7=2>@#:9#=>:H@#;171#42D:5D1?#42#G:G71=>42<#1=G8#:>817E#)81#=<12GC#:9#
1=G8#=>:H#G:2>746P>1?#>:#>81#:L1242<#:7#G51=742<#42#;84G8#:>817#=>:H@#G:P5?#=LL1=7#>:#1=G8#:>817X42#@8:7>N#
>81#L7:>:WG:2@G4:P@21@@#:7#L71812@4:2#:9#1=G8#=>:H#G:2>746P>1?#>:#>81#6142<#:7#:2>:5:<C#:9#1=G8#=>:HE#)84@#
;=@2V>#[P@>#=#51D15#:9#:2>:5:<C#G:HL51>15C#?4D:7G1?#97:H#1L4@>1H:5:<CN#6P>#=2#:GG=@4:2#;8171#R2:;42<#=2?#
6142<N#G:2@G4:P@21@@#=2?#9:7HN#;171#>;:#G:HL51H12>=7C#=@L1G>@#:9#>81#@=H1#8=LL1242<N#=2?#G:P5?#2:>#61#
@1L=7=>1?#:7#>:72#=@P2?17#;4>8:P>#<7=D1#D4:512G1#>:#>81#71=54>C#:9#>81#=>:H4G#6142<@E#':#42#>84@#9P2?=H12>=5#
@12@1N#1L4@>1H:5:<C#=2?#:2>:5:<C#G=22:>#61#@1L=7=>1?#A:7#H:71#@L1G4QG=55CN#38:#O#.:;#O#38=>N#1L4@>1H:5W
:<C#O#H1>8:?:5:<C#O#:2>:5:<CN#=71#@:#H=2C#?4H12@4:2@#:9#1=G8#=G>P=5#:GG=@4:2#o@11#615:;pME
#
":7#G=2#>81C#61#@1L=7=>1?#;812#4>#G:H1@#>:#>81#8PH=2#6142<E#!>#4@#G:HH:2#9:7#@G8::5@#:9#71=54@H#
=2?#L:@4>4D4@H#>:#H=42>=42#>8=>#B=>:H@I#1O4@>#;4>8:P>#6142<#R2:;2#6C#8PH=2@#A=2?#?4?#1O4@>#;812#8PH=2@#
;1712V>#1D12#C1>#1D:5D1?MX;8171=@N#42#=G>P=55CN#=>:H@#subsist#A2:>#1OW4@>M#;4>8:P>#6142<#R2:;2#6C#8PH=2@E#
eP>#=>:H@#=71#R2:;2#6C#1=G8#:>817X=2?#>8147#HP>P=5#R2:;42<#G:2>746P>1@#>:#>8147#HP>P=5#6142<X>8147#1L4@W
>1H:5:<C#=2?#:2>:5:<C#=71#42@1L=7=65C#542R1?#foreachother#A8PH=2@#2:>#71]P471?N#6P>#9:P7#]P=?7=2>@#=71ME#
"14>817#6142<#2:7#G:2@G4:P@21@@#G=2#61#@1L=7=>1?#97:H#>81#:>817N#=>#=2C#51D15N#;4>8:P>#<7=D1#D4:512G1E#)81#
9:P7#]P=?7=2>@#<:#=55#>81#;=C#PLN#=55#>81#;=C#?:;2E#
#
&P7>817N#;812#4>#G:H1@#>:#@=C42<#1O=G>5C#;8=>#4>#4@#>8=>#@P6@4@>@#=>#>81#=>:H4G#51D15N#8PH=2#G:2@G4:P@W
21@@N#R2:;42<N#=2?#42>17L71>=>4:2#=71#421D4>=65C#67:P<8>#42>:#>81#L4G>P71E#)81#9P2?=H12>=5#9=G>#71=54@H#=2?#
L:@4>4D4@H# R11L# :D175::R42<# 4@# >8=># ?4991712># 51D15@# :9# 6142<WG:2@G4:P@21@@# A=2?# ?4991712># H1>8:?:5:<41@M#
6742<#9:7>8#?4991712>#;:75?@E#!>#4@#2:>X=@#>81#BHC>8#:9#<4D12I#H=42>=42@X>8=>#>8171#4@#:21N#@42<51N#L71<4D12#
;:75?#>8=>#4@#42>17L71>1?#?4991712>5C#6C#?4991712>#;:75?D41;@#A=5>8:P<8#>8=>#:9#G:P7@1#G=2#8=LL12MN#6P>#7=>817#
48JournalofIntegralTheoryandPractice

INTEGRALTHEORY

>8=># >81@1# ?4991712># 51D15@# :9# 6142<WG:2@G4:P@21@@# 6742<# 9:7>8# different worlds# >81H@15D1@X>8171# 4@# =# 71?#
;:75?N#=2#=H617#;:75?N#=2#:7=2<1#;:75?N#=#<7112#;:75?N#=#>1=5#;:75?N#=#>P7]P:4@1#;:75?N#=2?#@:#:2N#=2?#1=G8#
:9#>81H#8=@#?4991712>#L812:H12=#;4>8#?4991712>#:2>:5:<41@E#,>:H@X;84G8#8=D1#subsisted#@42G1#@8:7>5C#=9>17#
>81#e4<#e=2<X?:2V>#exist#P2>45#:7=2<1N#;8171#>81C#=71#L4G>P71?#=@#=#54>>51#L5=21>=7C#@C@>1H#;4>8#@P22PG51P@#
=2?#L5=21>=7C151G>7:2@E#,>#<7112N#>81#=>:H4G#;:75?#2:;#=LL1=7@#>:#61#G:HL:@1?#2:>#:25C#:9#151G>7:2@N#L7:W
>:2@N#=2?#21P>7:2@N#6P>#H1@:2@N#6:@:2@N#51L>:2@N#=2?#:>817#@P6W@P6=>:H4G#L=7>4G51@E#,>#>1=5N#>81@1#2PH17:P@#
L=7>4G51@#=71#67:P<8>#>:<1>817#42#=#P24Q1?#@C2>81@4@#R2:;2#=@#>81#BiW9:5?#;=CIX;4>8#>81#?4@G:D17C#:9#>81#
.4<<@#6:@:2#L=7>4G51#<4D42<#=??1?#G71?46454>C#>:#>8=>#L=7=?4<HE#eP>#=>#>P7]P:4@1N#=2#12>4715C#21;#L=7=?4<H#:9#
@PL17W84<8W1217<C#G:554?17@#8=@#@P<<1@>1?#>81:741@#R2:;2#D=74:P@5C#=@#B@>742<#>81:7CNI#BU#>81:7CNI#B@PL17W
@>742<# >81:7CNI# =2?# B=# >81:7C# :9# 1D17C>842<IX;8171# >81# P24D17@1# 4@# @112# =@# G:HL:@1?# :9# __# ?4H12@4:2@N#
;84G8#<4D1@#74@1#>:#BHP5>4L51#P24D17@1@I#:7#BHP5>4D17@1@EI#'>742<#>81:7C#4@#>81#:25C#>81:7C#>8=>#L7:H4@1@#>:#61#
=#B>81:7C#:9#1D17C>842<NI#LP5542<#>:<1>817#4>1H@#>8=>#L71D4:P@#L8C@4G=5#>81:741@#;171#P2=651#>:#?:X6P>#4>#4@#@:#
G:HL54G=>1?#=2?#@:#=6@>7=G>N#4>#4@#<1217=55C#=<711?#>8=>#2:#1HL474G=5#1OL174H12>#;455#1D17#61#=651#>:#61#?1D4@1?#
>8=>#G:P5?#L7:D1#:7#?4@L7:D1#>81#>81:7CE#K8C@4G@N#2:;#9=7#71H:D1?#97:H#>81#B1HL474G=5#]P112#:9#>81#@G412G1@NI#
8=@#61G:H1#>81#B=6@>7=G>#>81:7C#:9#>81#@G412G1@I#L=7#1OG15512G1N#;4>8#=#?11L5C#KC>8=<:71=2#;:75?D41;E
#
)81#L:42>#4@#>8=>#>81@1#?4991712>#>81:741@X=2?#?4991712>#1L4@>1H:5:<41@#=2?#?4991712>#:2>:5:<41@XG=H1#
42>:#6142<#;4>8#42G71=@42<5C#P29:5?42<#51D15@#:9#6142<WG:2@G4:P@21@@N#=2?#L:42>@#:2G1#=<=42#>:#>81#9=G>#>8=>#
;8=>#6:>8#;8=>#B1OW4@>@I#=2?#;8=>#B@P6@4@>@I#?1L12?#:2#>81#51D15#:9#1L4@>1H:5:<C#A=2?#D=74:P@#H1>8:?:5:W
<41@M#G:WG71=>42<#=#L=7>4GP5=7#51D15#:9#:2>:5:<CE#,<=42N#>81@1#>;:X1L4@>1H:5:<C#=2?#:2>:5:<CN#R2:;42<#=2?#
6142<X=71#2:>#>;:#12>4715C#@1L=7=>1#1D12>@#6P>#>;:#G:HL51H12>=7C#=@L1G>@#:9#>81#@=H1#:GG=@4:2N#=2#:GG=W
@4:2#>1>7=W12=G>1?#6C#=55#9:P7#]P=?7=2>@#@4HP5>=21:P@5C#A;84G8#H1=2@N#H:71#9P55CN#=#38:#O#.:;#O#38=>N#:7#=#
@P6[1G>\1L4@>1H:5:<C#O#=#Z:21#H1>8:?:5:<C#O#Z:21\:6[1G>N#=>#=#H424HPH#9:7#0:@H4G#=??71@@#o@11#615:;pME

IntegralPluralism
U=2C#:9#>81@1#4HL:7>=2>#?4@>42G>4:2@#=71#;155#1O1HL54Q1?#6C#'1=2#%@6[q72W.=7<12@#AT^_^M#42#84@#=7>4G51N#
B,2#(2>:5:<C#:9#F54H=>1#F8=2<1Y#!2>1<7=5#K5P7=54@H#=2?#>81#%2=G>H12>#:9#UP5>4L51#(6[1G>@EI#.1#@>=7>@#;4>8#
=#;155W=GG1L>1?#>121>#:9#!2>1<7=5#)81:7C#>8=>#=2#:6[1G>#:7#L812:H12:2#4@#2:>#H1715C#@:H1>842<#>8=>#4@#5C42<#
=7:P2?#:P>#>8171#;=4>42<#>:#61#@>PH651?#:2N#6P>#4@#12=G>1?N#;8171#B12=G>1?I#G:2@4@>@#:9#=>#51=@>#=#38:#A1L4@W
>1H:5:<CM#O#.:;#AH1>8:?:5:<CM#O#38=>#A:2>:5:<CME#.1#L:42>@#:P>#>8=>N#42#84@#D41;N#;8171#!2>1<7=5#)81:7C#
;155#1HL8=@4Z1@#L5P7=54@>4G#38:V@#=2?#L5P7=54@>4G#.:;V@N#4>#:9>12#=@@PH1@#=#@42<51#:6[1G>#A;8451#>84@#4@#:9>12#
>7P1N#!#>842R#4>#L178=L@#:D175::R@#HC#42@4@>12G1#>8=>#?4991712>#1L4@>1H:5:<41@\H1>8:?:5:<41@#12=G>#?4991712>#
;:75?@L=G1@X4E1EN#?4991712>#:6[1G>@#:7#:2>:5:<41@N#;84G8#!#1HL8=@4Z1#:9>12#=2?#@174:P@5CN#=2?#1D12#H:71#@:#
42#71G12>#;74>42<@ME#eP>#:D175::R42<#>8=>#<1217=54Z1?#42=GGP7=GC#A=2?#'1=2#=?H4>@#4>V@#=#H=>>17#:9#1HL8=@4@N#
=2?#>8=>#>81:71>4G=55C#!2>1<7=5#)81:7C#4@#9P55C#=;=71#:9#>84@#L:42>#=2?#42@4@>@#:2#4>MN#84@#?4@GP@@4:2#:9#L5P7=54@>4G#
:2>:5:<41@#4@#455P@>7=>4D1E
#
.1#61<42@#6C#L:42>42<#:P>#>8=>#42?11?#!2>1<7=5#)81:7C#H=42>=42@#>8=>#@42<51#:6[1G>@#=71#:25C#:21#42>17W
L71>=>4:2#:9#:2>:5:<CN#=2?#>8=>#HPG8#H:71#P@19P5#A=2?#H:71#=GGP7=>1#42#=#G17>=42#@12@1M#4@#>8=>#1=G8#:6[1G>#4@#
=G>P=55C#=#HP5>4L5C#?4991712>#:6[1G>X=2#1HL>C#@:?=#6:>>51N#9:7#1O=HL51N#G=2#61#P@1?#9:7#=#D=741>C#:9#LP7L:@1@#
A=#HP@4G=5#42@>7PH12>N#=#g:;17#D=@1N#:7#=2#:LL:7>P24>C#9:7#=#?1L:@4>#719P2?ME#B!2#1=G8#G=@1NI#81#@=C@N#B>81#
:2>:5:<4G=5#@>=>P@#:9#>81#6:>>51#4@#12=G>1?#42#L=7>#6C#>81#H1>8:?#:9#42>17=G>42<#;4>8#4>rEE#!2#:>817#;:7?@N#>81#
:2>:5:<4G=5#@>=>P@#:9#=2#:6[1G>#4@#2:>#12>4715C#42?1L12?12>#:9#>81#=G>:7#:7#=G>4:2#42D:5D1?EI#!>V@#4HL:7>=2>#>:#
2:>1#>8=>#>84@#4@#=#71=5#?4991712G1#42#:2>:5:<CX42#>81#=G>P=5#B>842<NI#;84G8#54>17=55C#G8=2<1@#;4>8#?4991712>#
P@1@X=2?#2:>#H1715C#=#?4991712G1#42#?1@G74L>4:2#:7#G5=@@4QG=>4:2#A42#HC#:L424:2N#>84@#4@#=2#4HL:7>=2>#?49W
91712G1#'1=2#>12?@#>:#:D175::RN#;84G8#51=?@#>:#=2#:D171@>4H=>4:2#:9#F74>4G=5#+1=54@HN#=@#;1#;455#@11ME#eP>#
9:7#>81#H:H12>N#51>#P@#G=55#=#71=5#G8=2<1#42#>81#=G>P=5#2=>P71#:7#71=5#:2>:5:<C#:9#=2#:6[1G>#6C#>81#>17H#B71=5#
:2>:5:<4G=5#G8=2<1I#A:7#B71=5#:2>:5:<4G=5#:6[1G>IM#=2?#=#G8=2<1#>8=>#4@#?P1#H1715C#>:#?4991712>#?1Q24>4:2@N#
JournalofIntegralTheoryandPractice49

K.WILBER

G5=@@4QG=>4:2@N#:7#D41;@N#6C#>81#>17H#B?1@G74L>4D1#:2>:5:<CI#A:7#=#B?1@G74L>4D1#:2>:5:<4G=5#:6[1G>IME#
'1=2#;4@81@#>:#D41;#G54H=>1#G8=2<1#AFFM#=@#=#71=5#:2>:5:<4G=5#HP5>4L51#:6[1G>N#=2?#2:>#H1715C#=#?1W
@G74L>4D1#:2>:5:<4G=5#:6[1G>#:7#=#@42<51#:6[1G>N#=#D41;#!#9P55C#@8=71#A;1#6:>8#71=54Z1#4>#G=2#61#D41;1?#=@#=#@42<51#
:6[1G>N#6P>#2:>#1991G>4D15CME#B(2>:5:<4G=5#L5P7=54@H#4@#12=G>1?#>87:P<8#=2#42G71=@1#=5:2<#>8711#=O1@Y#$&,%)$0'
logicaldistanceN#methodologicalvarietyN#=2?#'()'/'8,-./"-'0&/$2,)6IX;84G8#81#@4HL54Q1@#=@#38:#O#.:;#
O#38=>#=2?#!#8=D1#L71D4:P@5C#@4HL54Q1?#=@#]P=?7=2>#O#]P=?74D4=#O#?:H=42#A=5>8:P<8#!VH#D17C#9:2?#:9#38:#
O#.:;#O#38=>ME#'1=2#=GR2:;51?<1@#>8=>#!2>1<7=5#)81:7C#=>#51=@>#71G:<24Z1@#>84@#>74L51#L5P7=54@H#A42G5P?42<#
:2>:5:<4G=5Y#BU1>8:?:5:<4G=5#L7=G>4G1@#6742<#L812:H12=#42>:#6142<IME#!#;:P5?#@=CN#BL=7>4=55CI#6742<#>81H#
42>:#6142<N#6P>#>81#L:42>#4@#G51=7#12:P<8E#!#=5@:#?49917#@54<8>5CN#!#61541D1N#42#>8=>#!#H=42>=42#>8=>#A=>#51=@>M#=55#
>8711#:9#>81@1#G:W1O4@>N#=2?#C:P#G=2V>#8=D1#:21#;4>8:P>#>81#:>817@E#!#;455#:9>12#[P@>#@=C#B1L4@>1H:5:<C#=2?#:2W
>:5:<C#=71#>;:#G:HL51H12>=7C#=@L1G>@#:9#>81#@=H1#:GG=@4:2NI#:7#=>#:>817#>4H1@N#B)81#@>7PG>P71#:9#>81#@P6[1G>#
G:WG71=>1@#>81#2=>P71#:9#>81#L812:H12=#L17G14D1?IX6P>#=@#!#H=R1#G51=7N#!#>842R#=55#>8711#L7:G1@@1@#A38:#O#
.:;#O#38=>N#=5:2<#;4>8#=#91;#:>817@M#=71#=2#42@1L=7=651#L=7>#:9#!2>1<7=5#U1>8:?:5:<4G=5#K5P7=54@H#A42#>81:7C#
=2?#inrealityME#,55#>8711#:9#>81@1#=71#:9>12#?4991712>X:9>12#]P4>1#?4991712>X6P>#=55#>8711#:9#>81H#=71#=5;=C@#
=571=?C# L71@12># 42# =2C# :GG=@4:2# A42G5P?42<# L71W8PH=2# 8:5:2@N# ;84G8# L71812?# 1=G8# :>817# >87:P<8# D=74:P@#
H1>8:?@#G:L7:?PG42<#D=74:P@#?:H=42@ME#,2?#>84@#H1=2@N#;4>8:P>#?:P6>N#>8=>#G8=2<42<#>81#38:#:7#G8=2<42<#
>81#.:;#;455#G8=2<1#>81#38=>X812G1N#42>1<7=5#:2>:5:<4G=5#L5P7=54@HE#U:71:D17N#;8451#;1#G=2#@=C#>8=>#>81#
38=>#@P6@4@>@#A4>#L:@@1@@1@#;8=>#345974?#'155=7@N#L4:2117#G74>4G#:9#B>81#HC>8#:9#>81#<4D12NI#G=55@#B42>742@4G#
91=>P71@IMN#;1#G=2V>#@=C#;8=>#>8:@1#=G>P=55C#=71#A:7#;8=>#>8:@1#42>742@4G#91=>P71@#=71M#;4>8:P>#@L1G49C42<#>81#
38:#=2?#>81#.:;#A1OL54G4>5C#:7#4HL54G4>5CME
":;N#'1=2#@=C@#>8=>#42#84@#.:;N#81#4@#42G5P?42<N#=H:2<#:>817#4>1H@N#!2>1<7=5#)81:7CN#F74>4G=5#+1=54@HN#
,G>:7W"1>;:7R#)81:7CN#'G412G1#=2?#)1G82:5:<C#'>P?41@N#=2?#(2>:5:<4G=5#K:54>4G@E#!#@4HL5C#;=2>#>:#L:42>#:P>#
>8=>#>81#.:;#;455#G8=2<1#?1L12?42<#:2#exactly#;8=>#>81#G:H642=>4:2#:9#>8:@1#H1>8:?@#=71E#31#G=2V>#@4HL5C#
@=C#>81C#=71#=55#4HL:7>=2>#A42#H=2C#;=C@N#>81C#=71#42?11?#=55#4HL:7>=2>N#=@#=71#?:Z12@N#L178=L@#8P2?71?@N#:9#
:>817#H1>8:?:5:<41@ME#!#R2:;#'1=2#71=54Z1@#>84@J#!#[P@>#;=2>#>:#H=R1#G7C@>=5#G51=7#8:;#@12@4>4D1#>8=>#9:7HP5=#
A38:#O#.:;#O#38=>M#4@#>:#1D17C#G8=2<1#H=?1#42#1=G8#:9#4>@#D=74=651@#A=2?#!#;:P5?#=??N#>:#61#42G5P?1?#42#>8=>#
54@>N#2=H1@#@PG8#=@#fs7<12#.=617H=@N#U4G815#&:PG=P5>N#U=7>42#.14?1<<17rE#>:#K5:>42P@N#K=?H=@=H68=D=N#
'8=2R=7=N#%GR8=7>rE#3155N#C:P#<1>#>81#!2>1<7=5#L4G>P71E#)81#9=G>#>8=>#!2>1<7=5#)81:7C#?:1@2V>#2=H1#1D17C#
@42<51#>81:74@>#>8=>#;12>#42>:#4>#?:1@2V>#H1=2#>81C#;1712V>#>=R12#@174:P@5CE#!2#IntegralPsychologyN#!#<4D1#:D17#
_^^#?1D15:LH12>=5#>81:741@N#=55#:9#;84G8#8=D1#6112#>=R12#42>:#=GG:P2>#42#G71=>42<#>81#B=5>4>P?1I#G:HL:212>#:9#
>81#!2>1<7=5#97=H1;:7RN#1D12#49#:25C#=#91;#=71#P@P=55C#H12>4:21?#1OL54G4>5C#;812#1OL5=4242<#>8=>#?4H12@4:2N#
6P>#=2C#:7#=55#:9#;84G8#G=2#61#G=551?#:2N#=@#21G1@@=7CN#>:#g1@8#:P>#>81#97=H1;:7RN#;84G8#;=@#G71=>1?#L71G4@15C#
>:#61#=651#>:#42G5P?1#:>817#>81:741@#=@#211?1?EM
eP>#>8=>#?:1@2V>#H1=2#>8=>#;1#G=2#@4HL5C#42G5P?1#=#5:2<#54@>#:9#2=H1@#=2?#G5=4H#>81C#=71#L=7>#:9#=#21;#
=2?# 1OL=2?1?# !2>1<7=5#)81:7CN# 1@L1G4=55C# 49# @:H1# :9# >8:@1# 2=H1@# 7=>817# ?7=H=>4G=55C# ?49917# ;4>8# >81# G:71#
>121>@#:9#!2>1<7=5#)81:7C#:7#!2>1<7=5#%2=G>H12>#)81:7C#4>@159E#31#HP@>#61#G=719P5N#9:7#1O=HL51N#;4>8#F74>4G=5#
+1=54@HV@#>71=>H12>#:9#B:2>:5:<CNI#;84G8#4>#>12?@#>:#L74D451<1E#!2#>::#H=2C#G=@1@N#;8=>#F74>4G=5#+1=54@H#G=55@#
B:2>:5:<CI#4@#2:>#B71=5#:2>:5:<CI#6P>#B?1@G74L>4D1#:2>:5:<CIX4>#@4HL5C#?:1@#2:>#<7=@L#>81#?1L>8@#:9#;8=>#
12=G>H12>#4@#=G>P=55C#?:42<#A1D12#;812#4>#P@1@#>8=>#>17HME#,@#'1=2#=LL7:D42<5C#@PHH=74Z1@#U:5V@#=7<PH12>N#
B)8P@N# L7=G>4G1@# :7# H1>8:?@# P@1?# >:# P2?17@>=2?# FF# ?:# 2:># [P@># ?1@G7461# 4>N# 42@>1=?N# >81C# =G>P=55C# 815L# >:#
L7:?PG1#:7#12=G>#4>EI#,2?#f:82#-=;N#B)81#=7<PH12>#4@#2:#5:2<17#>8=>#H1>8:?@#?4@G:D17#=2?#?1L4G>#71=54>41@E#
!2@>1=?N#4>#4@#>8=>#>81C#L=7>4G4L=>1#42#>81#12=G>H12>#:9#>8:@1#71=54>41@EI#):#;84G8#'1=2#G:2G5P?1@N#B3812#;1#
=55:;#9:7#>81#12=G>4D1#:7#L179:7H=>4D1#2=>P71#:9#H1>8:?@N#;1#61<42#>:#P2?17@>=2?#8:;#>81#P@1#:9#HP5>4L51#
H1>8:?@#>:#P2?17@>=2?#=2#=551<1?#@42<51#L812:H12:2#54R1#FF#71@P5>@#42#HP5>4L51X6P>#21>;:7R1?X:6[1G>@EI#
,2?#>8=>#H1=2@#2:>#[P@>#?1@G74L>4D1#:6[1G>@#6P>#71=5#:6[1G>@E
/1>#42#1D17C#1O=HL51#>8=>#'1=2#L7:?PG1@#:9#F74>4G=5#+1=54@HN#G5=4H42<#4>#@PLL:7>@#84@#!2>1<7=5#K5P7=5W
4@HN#>81#=P>8:7#=7<P1@#9:7#HP5>4L51#?1@G74L>4D1#:6[1G>@N#2:>#HP5>4L51#71=5#:6[1G>@E#)4H#&:7@C>8V@#B>CL:5:<C#:9#
50JournalofIntegralTheoryandPractice

INTEGRALTHEORY

12D47:2H12>=5#L7:651H@NI#9:7#1O=HL51N#?4D4?1@#>8:@1#L7:651H@#42>:#9:P7#H=[:7#:D175=LL42<#G=>1<:741@X5:W
G=5#=2?#<5:6=5#71=54>41@#@112#=@#B67P>1#9=G>@I#:7#B42@>4>P>4:2=5#9=G>@EI#)81#67P>1#9=G>@#=71#[P@>#@>7=4<8>9:7;=7?#
1HL474G=5#B9=G>@EI#38=>#=71#1O=HL51@#:9#B42@>4>P>4:2=5#9=G>@Ik#.1#54@>@#B@849>42<#GP5>4D=>4:2N#12D47:2H12>=5#
DP5217=6454>CN#<5:6=5#?19:71@>=>4:2N#=2>87:L:<124G#G54H=>1#G8=2<1EI#&:7@C>8#@>=>1@#>8=>#B12D47:2H12>=5#t67P>1#
9=G>@V#A:7#64:L8C@4G=5#L7:L17>41@M#=71#?4D4?1?#5:G=55C#:7#<5:6=55C#o4E1EN#>8147#?4991712G1@#=71#H=>>17@#:9#5:G=>4:2N#
2:>#:2>:5:<4G=5#71=54>CpE#)81#t42@>4>P>4:2=5#9=G>@V#A:7#?1Q24>4:2@#:9#?1<7=?=>4:2M#=71#G:2>7:551?#6C#?4@GP7@4D1#
L7=G>4G1@#o4E1EN#=@#81#@=C@N#t?1Q24>4:2@VpEI#$4991712>#?4@GP7@4D1#L7=G>4G1@#<4D1#74@1#>:#?4991712>#>:L4G@#=2?#?1Q24W
>4:2@#:9#?4@GP@@4:2N#2:>#>:#>81#?11L#71=54>41@#:9#>8:@1#>:L4G@#>81H@15D1@E#.4@#H=[:7#G:HL5=42>#=6:P>#8:;#FF#
4@#>71=>1?#4@#>8=>#>81@1#9:P7#G155@#<1>#G:29P@1?X=2?#2:>#>8=>#>8171#=712V>#12:P<8#71=5#H1>8:?:5:<41@#:7#=#;4?1#
12:P<8#L5P7=54@H#:9#1L4@>1H:5:<41@#>:#L7:?PG1#=2?#12=G>#=#;4?17#P2?17@>=2?42<#:9#>81#real#HP5>4L51#:6[1G>#
R2:;2#=@#FFE#!2#:>817#;:7?@N#84@#=7<PH12>#4@#5:=?1?#;4>8#@849>42<#?1@G74L>4D1#:2>:5:<41@N#6P>#2:#71=5#:2>:5:W
<41@#A;84G8#81#>12?@#>:#1]P=>1#;4>8#71=5#64:L8C@4G=5#:2>:5:<41@N#L174:?ME#!#?:2V>#?4@=<711#;4>8#84@#L:42>@J#!#
?4@=<711#>8=>#>81C#@PLL:7>#!2>1<7=5#K5P7=54@H#42#=2C#71=5#@12@1#=>#=55#A2:>#42#>81#9P2?=H12>=5#@12@1#>8=>N#=@#
'1=2#@=C@N#B(2>:5:<4G=5#@>=>P@#4@#12=G>1?#42#L=7>#6C#>81#H1=2@#:9#42>17=G>42<#;4>8#4>IX;8171#B12=G>1?I#H1=2@#
BG:WG71=>1?IME
,2?#!#G:2@>=2>5C#Q2?#>8=>#;4>8#F74>4G=5#+1=54@H#42#<1217=5X>81#L5P7=54>41@#4>#=GR2:;51?<1@#>8=>#=71#
12=G>1?#A:7#;8:@1#:2>:5:<41@#=G>P=55C#?1L12?#42#L=7>#:2#>8147#1L4@>1H:5:<41@M#>12?#>:#61#5=7<15C#?1@G74L>4D1#
:2>:5:<41@N#2:>#71=5#:2>:5:<41@#A;84G8#>12?#>:#61#?1Q21?#6C#@G412G1#=2?#@G412G1#=5:21N#<:42<#=55#>81#;=C#
6=GR#>:#0=75#K:LL17ME#":7#?:1@#F74>4G=5#+1=54@H#61541D=65C#42>1<7=>1#>81#D=74:P@#R2:;51?<1#?:H=42@#4>#=GW
R2:;51?<1@E#'1=2#=>#51=@>#=GR2:;51?<1@#!2>1<7=5#)81:7C#?:1@#=#61>>17#[:6#:9#>84@Y#B(21#:9#>81#>842<@#>8=>#@1>@#
!2>1<7=5#)81:7CX=2?#>81#!2>1<7=5#K5P7=54@H#!#L71@12>#42#>84@#=7>4G51X=L=7>#4@#>8=>#:9#=#H1>=W97=H1;:7R#>8=>#
815L@#G::7?42=>1#1L4@>1H:5:<4G=5N#H1>8:?:5:<4G=5N#=2?#:2>:5:<4G=5#D=74=651@#=2?#>8147#G:HL51O#42>17=G>4:2W
@84L@E#%D12#F74>4G=5#+1=54@H#?:1@#2:>#:9917N#42#HC#H42?N#=@#L:;179P5#=2?#=@#=GG1@@4651#=#97=H1;:7R#9:7#?:42<#
>84@I#ALE#_u`ME
'1=2#=5@:#]P:>1@#F=7:5=2N#;8:#42#84@#1O=HL51@#:9#HP5>4L51#:6[1G>@#@=C@N#B!2#:>817#;:7?@N#>81#:6[1G>#
G8=2<1@# >87:P<8# >7=2@5=>4:2N# 6P># >81# A@P6M@>7PG>P71# ?:1@# 2:>EI# '1=2# L:42>@# :P># >8=># F=7:5=2# =774D1@# =># >84@#
G:2G5P@4:2#6C#=2=5CZ42<#>;:#=O1@#AO#v#G:HL51O4>C#=2?#C#v#1L4@>1H:5:<4G=5#?4@>=2G1ME#'1=2#=<711@#;4>8#F=7:W
5=2V@#G:2G5P@4:2@N#>812#@=C@N#B!#8=D1#=??1?#=#>847?#o=O4@p#>8=>#71L71@12>@#H1>8:?:5:<4G=5#D=741>CI#ALE#_uTME#!9#
F=7:5=2#8=?#?:21#>81#@=H1N#81#H4<8>#71=54Z1#>8=>#@:H1#9:7H@#:9#>7=2@5=>4:2#=G>P=55C#G8=2<1#>81#A@P6M@>7PG>P71#
:9#>81#:6[1G>#=@#;155X=2?#thatisareal#G8=2<1#=2?#=#real#HP5>4L51#:6[1G>N#BL7:?PG1?#=2?#12=G>1?I#A=@#'1=2#
LP>@#4>M#6C#>81#.:;N#=2?#2:>#H1715C#=#?1@G74L>4D15C#?4991712>#:6[1G>E#F=7:5=2N#42#:>817#;:7?@N#4@#2:>#@PLL:7>42<#
=#<12P421#!2>1<7=5#K5P7=54@H#A6P>#7=>817#=#?1@G74L>4D1#L5P7=54@HME#(7=2<1#@>7PG>P71@#5::R#=>#=>:H4G#71=54>41@#
42#42G71?465C#?4991712>#;=C@#>8=2#>P7]P:4@1#@>7PG>P71@#5::R#=>#>81HX2:>#[P@>#?4991712>#?1@G74L>4D1#:2>:5:<41@N#
;84G8# F=7:5=2# <4D1@N# 6P># ?4991712># A@P6M@>7PG>P71@# =@# ;155X71=5# :2>:5:<41@E#,<=42N# !# ?:2V># ?4@=<711# ;4>8#
1D17C>842<#>8=>#F=7:5=2#4@#@=C42<J#!#=H#L:42>42<#:P>#4>#?:1@#2:>#@PLL:7>#=#>7P5C#!2>1<7=5#K5P7=54@H#=2?#71=5#
12=G>H12>E#
'1=2#6742<@#PL#=#L:42>#7=4@1?#6C#e74=2#%??CN#2=H15CN#>8=>#42#=??4>4:2#>:#38:#O#.:;#O#38=>#;1#G=2#
=??#B38171I#=2?#B3812NI#=2?#>84@#4@#1@L1G4=55C#4HL:7>=2>#42#G:2>1O>P=54Z42<#>81#R2:;51?<1E#!#9P55C#=<711N#
6P>#;:P5?#54R1#>:#L:42>#:P>#>8=>#42#!2>1<7=5#)81:7CN#4>#<:1@#;4>8:P>#@=C42<#>8=>#>81#@P6[1G>#A>81#38:M#>8=>#4@#
?:42<#>81#AHP5>4L51M#H1>8:?:5:<C#:2#>81#AHP5>4L51M#:6[1G>#4@#=5;=C@#=571=?C#9P55C#G:2>1O>P=54Z1?#D4@WwWD4@#>81#
-:;17W-19>#]P=?7=2>#A;84G8#4HL54G4>5C#:7#1OL54G4>5C#42G5P?1@#=#B38171I#=2?#=#B3812IME#eP>#4>#4@#G17>=425C#
:R=C#>:#H=R1#>8=>#1OL54G4>#6C#=??42<#4>#>:#>81#0:@H4G#=??71@@E
&42=55CN# '1=2# ]P:>1@# =# L17@:2=5# G:HHP24G=>4:2# 97:H# U=7R# %?;=7?@N# ;8:@1# ;:7R# !# =?H471N# @>=>42<#
>8=>#!2>1<7=5#)81:7C#211?@#>:#@L12?#H:71#>4H1#@>=>42<#8:;#4>#=774D1?#=>#4>@#:;2#0:@H4G#=??71@@N#6P>#%?;=7?@#
R2:;@#!2>1<7=5#)81:7C#G=2V>#?:#4>E#B":#:21#@C@>1H#4@#PL#>:#>84@#>=@RE#.12G1#>81#P5>4H=>15C#42=?1]P=>1#2=>P71#
:9#=55#H=4542<#@C@>1H@EI#eP>#!2>1<7=5#)81:7C#8=@#=571=?C#@>=>1?#>84@#=@#>81#B!(j#>121>IXB1D17C#@C@>1H#4@#
14>817# 42G:HL51>1# :7# P2G17>=42NI# =2?# >8=># ?1Q24>15C# 42G5P?1@# !2>1<7=5# )81:7CE# eP># !2>1<7=5# )81:7C# 9P7>817#
JournalofIntegralTheoryandPractice51

K.WILBER

G5=4H@#>8=>#B%HL>421@@#71?11H@#=55#!(j@EI#)8=>#4@N#>81#715=>4D1#;:75?#4@#9:71D17#42G:HL51>1#:7#P2G17>=42J#:25C#
P5>4H=>1#R2:;51?<1X<4D12#6C#L7=[2=#:7#2:2?P=5#=;=7121@@N#=2?#2:>#D4[2=2=#:7#?P=54@>4G#=;=7121@@XG=2#
?4@G5:@1#P5>4H=>1#71=54>C#A'L474>#:7#%HL>421@@ME#)8=>#71=54>C#4@#71=5J#4>#4@#P5>4H=>1J#4>#4@#P2]P=54Q=651#A42G5P?42<#
>8=>#G5=4HMJ#6P>#4>#G=2#61#BR2:;2I#42#=#G17>=42#@12@1#D4=#%254<8>12H12>#:7#,;=R1242<#A4E1EN#@=>:74N#@=8=[=N#
H1>=2:4=N#<2:@4@N#;PN#H:R@8=MN#;84G8#!2>1<7=5#)81:7C#LP>@#=>#>81#G12>17#:9#4>@#97=H1;:7RE#)81#:25C#D=5P1#
:9#=#@>=>1H12>#@PG8#=@#%?;=7?@VX49#4>V@#2:>#>:#61#H1715C#=#:21WPLH=2@84L#H:D1X4@#>:#71H42?#P@#>:#@>=>1#
=@#9P55C#=@#L:@@4651#=55#:9#>81#L5P7=54>41@#>8=>#<:#42>:#=2C#@C@>1H#:7#?1G4@4:2#>8=>#;1#H=R1#AR2:;42<#4>#;455#61#
P5>4H=>15C#42=?1]P=>1N#6P>#;455#H=R1#4>#H:71#;8:51#>8=2#>81#:L>4:2@MX=2?#>8=>#4@#>81#:21#9:P2?42<#=2?#H:@>#
9P2?=H12>=5#>121>#:9#!2>1<7=5#)81:7CE

Postscript
(2#6=5=2G1N#!#;=2>#>:#G:2<7=>P5=>1#'1=2#%@6[q72W.=7<12@#:2#=#>7P5C#Q21#=7>4G51E#UC#:25C#H=[:7#G:HL5=42>#
4@#>8=>N#49#=2C>842<N#81#?:1@2V>#>=R1#84@#:;2#=7<PH12>@#@>7:2<5C#12:P<8E#)8=>#;1#8=D1#real#HP5>4L51#:6[1G>@#
A>842R#=6:P>#;8=>#>8=>#71=55C#H1=2@hM#HP@>#H1=2#;1#8=D1#@:H1#L:;179P55C#G:G71=>4D1#12=G>H12>@#6142<#12W
<=<1?X>8=>#1L4@>1H:5:<CN#H1>8:?:5:<CN#=2?#:2>:5:<C#=71#421O>74G=65C#42>17>;421?N#=2?#G8=2<42<#=2C#:21#:9#
>81H#G8=2<1@#>81#:>817@E#%D12#42#'1=2V@#42>12>4:2=55C#@4HL54@>4G#:L1242<#1O=HL51X:9#=#6:>>51#6142<#P@1?#42#
@1D17=5#?4991712>#;=C@N#1=G8#>4H1#L7:?PG42<#=#<12P4215C#?4991712>#=7>4G51#:7#:6[1G>X>81@1#=71#<12P4215C#=2?#
>7P5C#?4991712>#:6[1G>@N#2:>#[P@>#?4991712>#?1@G74L>4:2@E#)84@#@8:;@#>81#71=5#L:;17#:9#12=G>H12>N#P@42<#'1=2V@#
;:7?@N#>:#61#<12P4215C#BL179:7H=>4D1I#=2?#BL7:?PG>4D1EI#eP>#81#>12?@#>:#@8C#=;=C#97:H#>84@#@>7:2<#=@@17>4:2N#
42#L=7>N#L178=L@N#?P1#>:#84@#71G12>#429=>P=>4:2#;4>8#F74>4G=5#+1=54@HN#=2?#42#L=7>N#L178=L@N#?P1#>:#>81#G:55=L@1#
:9#1O>71H1#L:@>H:?1724@HN#;84G8#8=@#71@P5>1?#42#=2#=>H:@L8171#>8=>#8=@#<:21#>:#>81#1O>71H1#:LL:@4>1#:9#>81#
0=2>4=2#D41;N#=2?#42@>1=?#:9#G5=4H42<#A>::#@>7:2<5CM#>8=>#=55#R2:;51?<1#4@#=#@:G4=5#L7:?PG>4:2N#=2C>4H1#1L4@W
>1H4G#:7#H1>8:?:5:<4G=5#=G>4:2@#=71#67:P<8>#42#=@#L=7>#:9#>81#G:G71=>4:2#:7#12=G>H12>#:9#=2#:6[1G>N#>81:74@>@#
G7C#B1L4@>1H4G#9=55=GCIX=2?#>8P@#:2>:5:<C#=5:21#4@#>=R12#>:#61#G:2@>4>P4>4D1#:9#>81#6142<#:9#=2#:6[1G>#A42@>1=?#
:9#=#Q215C#42>17;:D12#38:#O#.:;#O#38=>#O#3812#O#38171X>81#B38=>I#=5:21#4@#@=4?#>:#1O4@>N#=55#:2#4>@#:;2N#
;4>8:P>#=2C#12=G>H12>#:7#G:G71=>4:2#=>#=55ME#)84@#4@#=#L:@>H:?172#71=G>4:2#42#>81#1O>71H1N#=2?#>87:;@#>81#6=6C#
:P>#;4>8#>81#6=>8;=>17#A:7#=@#+:2=5?#+1=<=2#;:P5?#@=CN#>87:;@#>81#6=6C#:P>#;4>8#>81#?4@81@ME#B)81#HC>8#:9#
>81#<4D12I#4@#@>455#=#HC>8#=2?#4@#@>455#:L17=>4D1N#=2?#4@#?471G>5C#G:2>7=?4G>1?#6C#>81#1O4@>12G1#:9#HP5>4L51#:6[1G>@N#
=H:2<#H=2C#:>817#G74>4G4@H@E#)81#9=G>#>8=>#>8171#=71#=>#51=@>#14<8>#L74H:7?4=5#L17@L1G>4D1@N#1=G8#42D:5D1?#42#
>81#G:G71=>4:2#=2?#12=G>H12>#:9#14<8>#:2>:5:<4G=5#Z:21@N#4@#=2:>817#=7<PH12>#=<=42@>#B>81#HC>8#:9#>81#<4D12EI#
,??#>:#>8:@1#14<8>#Z:21@#A:7#9:P7#]P=?7=2>@M#=2C;8171#97:H#QD1#>:#>;15D1#51D15@#:9#6142<WG:2@G4:P@21@@X
1=G8#:9#;84G8#6742<@#9:7>8#=2?#@PLL:7>@#=2#:2>:5:<4G=55C#?4991712>#;:75?X=2?#C:P#8=D1#1D12#9P7>817#1D4W
?12G1#A>84@#4@#;8=>#'1=2#?:1@#;4>8#84@#14<8>#51D15@#:9#1G:5:<4G=5#;:75?D41;#=2?#1G:5:<4G=5#@15D1@X>8:@1#=71#
71=5#=2?#<12P4215C#?4991712>#;:75?@N#2:>#H1715C#?4991712>#?1@G74L>4:2@#:9#:21#P2G8=2<42<#;:75?ME#BUP5>4L51#
:6[1G>@I#67:P<8>#9:7>8#6C#L179:7H=>4D1N#L7:?PG>4D1N#12=G>42<N#G:G71=>42<#38:V@#=2?#.:;V@#4@N#42#H=2C#;=C@N#
1O=G>5C#;8=>#F74>4G=5#+1=54@H#4@#Q<8>42<N#61G=P@1#4>#8=@#2:>#C1>#9:P2?#=#;:7R=651#@C2>81@4@#61>;112#4?1=54@H#
=2?#71=54@HN#;84G8N#!#61541D1N#4@#;8=>#6:>8#!2>1<7=5#)81:7C#=2?#!2>1<7=5#K5P7=54@H#8=D1#@PGG11?1?#42#?:42<E

REFERENCES

%@6[q72W.=7<12@N#'E#AT^_^ME#,2#:2>:5:<C#:9#G54H=>1#G8=2<1Y#!2>1<7=5#L5P7=54@H#=2?#>81#12=G>H12>#:9#HP5>4L51#:6[1G>@E#
JournalofIntegralTheoryandPracticeN5A_MN#_abW_`aE

52JournalofIntegralTheoryandPractice