Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
November 2005
Convener
Member
Member
Member
Member-Secretary
Executive Summary
IRS-P5 (Cartosat-I) satellite, launched on May 05, 2005, is designed to deliver highresolution spatial data of better than 2.5m in stereo. The twin cameras, with a fixed
base-to-height ratio better than 0.6, image the terrain through in-track stereo almost
simultaneously. The primary mission goal is to generate a Digital Elevation Model (DEM)
at national level for the benefit of various user communities of remote sensing and
cartography.
Following the IRS MC recommendation, the Director, NRSA has constituted a Study
Team to assess the user requirements from the application and data processing
perspective. The team, through intense deliberations, examined the possible DEM
resolutions, height sensitivity of the mission, level of automation, and adequacy of
control points, processing issues and arrived at the specifications of the national level
DEM from Cartosat-I (referred to as CARTODEM).
CONTENTS
Project Summary
1.
Introduction
Study Team Recommendations
Need for DEM
2. Project Objectives
Befits to the stakeholders
Key Differentiators
3. Implementation methodology
Product Development
Essential stages
4. Manpower
5. Work Components
Role of the Contributing Centres
6. Time Goals
7. Product Specifications
8. Project management
9. Facility Definition
10. Budget
1.0
Introduction
The Department of Space (DOS) is committed to meeting the nations needs for current base
geographic data and maps. The objective of the present mission is to provide a current, accurate and
nationally consistent elevation information in spatial domain derived from stereo data of CARTOSAT
satellite series. This can serve as a foundation for interpreting all geo-information and developing
derived data sets continuously. This is expected to be of immense help for RS&GIS applications
community across the country. The users will be able to access the DEM data by tiles or by defining a
geographic area of interest in which case, a seamless mosaic of contiguous tiles is delivered.
The National DEM set contains the following layers:
Elevation
Ortho-image
The development of digital elevation models and digital ortho-imagery at 1:25,000 scale will provide a
level of detail and accuracy highly suitable for medium to large scale mapping and analysis.
The DEM product will be extremely useful in the GIS environment, providing a dependable base for
multiple corresponding theme layers and enabling terrain characterization with parameters like slope,
drainage network, watershed definition and contour maps. Topographic data are fundamental to
resource modeling and will be an essential element of the database.
The ortho images will be useful as raster base maps to define and demarcate the features like:
landuse/land cover, topography, roads, rivers, open water bodies and forest density. By virtue of in
built correspondence between DEM and ortho-image, a few perspective views will be generated.
These views provide the user an appreciation of terrain relief and other visually discernible
characteristics.
The purpose of constituting the National DEM study team is to study the quantum of the effort, and
suggest a mechanism to realize the DEM at the national level. Scope of the envisaged project is to
generate DEM for entire India using the stereo data from the about-to-be-launched CARTOSAT-I.
It is anticipated that the CARTODEM will be useful in a variety of ways. First, the models provide an
elevation reference of the existing topographic conditions. They will provide valuable information for
preparing land management plans, enforcing environmental regulation, identifying critical areas
within the watershed and developing inundation vulnerability maps.
Second, DEM product will be extremely useful in the GIS environment, providing a terrain model to
facilitate drainage network analysis, watershed demarcation, erosion mapping, contour generation
and quantitative analysis like volume-area calculation. Topographic data are fundamental to
watershed modeling and is a critical ingredient of the project.
Third, DEM will enable generation of ortho rectified images in the DP facility on operational basis. The
elevation profiles will help quantify the local displacements (due to relief), for further carrying out
geometric corrections. Other applications include scene simulation, fly through visualization and for
military application.
This will be the first time in the country that this type of elevation information will be created for land
use and mapping application and therefore could be featured as a national model. The DEM thus
realized is intended to be available for users.
Study Team Recommendations
Following the IRS MC recommendation, the Director, National Remote Sensing Agency (NRSA) has
constituted a Study Team to assess the user requirements from the application and data processing
perspective (Annexure 1). The team, through intense deliberations, examined the possible DEM
resolutions, height sensitivity of the mission, level of automation, and adequacy of control points,
processing issues and arrived at the specifications of the national level DEM from CartosatI(CARTODEM).
The Study Team, Constituted by Director, NRSA, recommended that: (1)The Level-IA DEM product
should be an operational data product; (2) The Level-IB DEM to be initiated simultaneously to meet
the user requirements for better quality DEMs in a phased manner by ISRO/DOS Centres with
entrepreneurial participation.; (3) The Level-II DEM to be taken up to meet the site-specific user
requirements for better quality DEMs in a phased manner by ISRO/DOS Centres with entrepreneurial
participation.
WGS 84 for both plannimetry and elevation of CARTODEM data; elevations defining the topographic
surface.
Based on the recommendations of the inter-centre task team constituted by Director, NRSA,
Hyderabad a project proposal for preparation of National Digital Elevation Model (NDEM) has been
submitted to Secretary, DOS by NRSA. In order to review and recommend to Secretary, DOS for
approval of the project, a meeting was held by Director, EOS on September 26, 2005 at ISRO HQ,
Bangalore. After detailed deliberations, under the overall guidance of Dr V Jayaraman, Director, EOS,
Dr PS Roy, Dy. Director, NRSA (RS&GIS), NRSA and Dr PK Srivastava, GD, RESIPA, SAC a Task Team
comprising of Shri Murali Mohan, NRSA, Shri B Gopalakrishna, SAC and Dr S Srinivasa Rao, RRSSC-N and
Dr J Krishnamurthy, ISRO Hqrs has been constituted to technically fine-tune the project proposal taking
into account the outcome of discussions and prepare the final document. This document identifies the
work elements, implementation methodology, responsibilities, infrastructure, and budgetary
requirements.
The sub-committee has recommended that CARTODEM with national coverage be taken up using the
indigenously developed software. The project is targeted to be realized in 1 year.
methods come into their own. In the context of acquiring terrain elevation data over larger areas,
photogrammetry-based approaches have a merit as they are largely automated.
It is seen from the global scenario that the photogrammetric methods offer the greatest flexibility in
data collection for terrain modelling in that the density of sampling, the accuracy of the elevation
data, etc., can all be varied according to the needs of the user. This can be done by utilizing
photography/imagery taken at different scales and at different flying heights and by employing various
alternative types of photogrammetric instrumentation of varying capability in terms of accuracy,
degree of automation, etc. By contrast, field survey methods are constrained to large-scale modelling
of limited areal extent and are less flexible in terms of the accuracy, data sampling patterns, etc., that
can be implemented, though these deficiencies will be less apparent to a civil engineer or surveyor
often interested in a single specific site covering a relatively limited area.
On the wider (regional or national) scale, again photogrammetric methods of data acquisition offer
much to surveying and mapping agencies, especially in terms of acquiring dense terrain elevation
data of a reasonable metric quality by automated means covering huge areas of terrain. These
methods have been implemented in many countries, e.g., in Western Europe in conjunction with
statewide programmes of orthophotomapping, and in North America where highly automated systems
such as the GPM-2 have been introduced into national mapping agencies and collect elevation data
on a massive scale. The alternative method of acquiring digital elevation data on a national scale
through the digitization of the contours on existing topographic map series and subsequent
interpolation will almost inevitably result in elevation data of a lower metric quality.
In India, there is an increasing demand for DEM and its derivatives from users. The requirements are
highly variable: they range from coarse resolution DEMs for draping satellite data fly through simulations
and, at the other end, a fine DEM that enables applications like line-of-sight. Priorities for most users
seem to be: full coverage, reliability ease-of-use, and off-the-shelf availability. A segment of
applications (like city modeling) demand custom-made DEMs that include surface details, and
structural data.
There is considerable urgency, to generate a base line DEM product at national level and make it
available to RS & GIS and mapping communities as an over-the-counter (OTC) product. Considering
the huge effort involved in making the product for the vast stretches of the country, a moderate cost
immediate solution needs to be planned. The product, so generated, may be further fortified with
terrain semantics in a phased manner.
Cartosat-1 is the first cartographic application satellite in the IRS- series that has the stereo viewing
capability and provides the stereo pairs within the same pass. This has been possible with two identical
panchromatic cameras, mounted on the satellite to view the earth in two angles of 5deg (AFT
camera) and +26deg (Fore camera) in the plane of the orbit. Each camera has nadir resolution of
about 2.5meters and cover a swath of about 30km. The stereo pairs provide a base to height ratio of
about 0.6m and this gives a height resolution of about 4m. The satellite has been conceived and
realized with state of the art technologies and was launched into polar sun-synchronous orbit by PSLV
C6 launch vehicle on 5th May 2005. The satellite was established in the orbit and the imageries have
started coming from the very second day of the launch. The complex data processing and product
generation systems were made ready for generating the products. From the products, with the height
information available, it is possible to generate absolute maps of 1: 25000 scale and thematic maps
upto better than 1:10000 scale. The applications of these products are in the areas of Cartography,
GIS, land use management, rural, town & urban planning, Construction activities of Dams, roads, rail
lanes, tanks, canals, etc., river interconnections, and also strategic applications.
Considering the above, this project has been proposed for creation of DEM at national level.
2. Project Objectives
The Department of Space (DoS) is committed to meeting the nations needs for current base
geographic data and maps. The objectives of the mission translate to providing current, accurate and
nationally consistent elevation information in spatial domain derived from stereo data of CARTOSAT
satellite series. This can serve as a foundation for interpreting all geo-information and developing
derived data sets continuously. This is expected to be of immense help for RS&GIS applications
community across the country.
The CARTODEM set contains the following layers: Elevation and Orthoimage
The development of digital elevation models and digital ortho-imagery at 1:25,000 scale will provide a
level of detail and accuracy highly suitable for medium to large scale mapping and analysis.
The DEM product will be extremely useful in the GIS environment, providing a dependable base for
multiple corresponding theme layers and enabling terrain characterization with parameters like slope,
drainage network, watershed definition and contour maps. Topographic data are fundamental to
resource modeling and will be an essential element of the database.
This will be the first time in the country that this type of elevation information will be created for land
use and mapping application and therefore could be featured as a national model.
The stakeholders of the Project are DoS users, State RS Centres, Research bodies, the industry,
international bodies, the academia etc.
The perceived applications are RS&GIS applications, base mapping, direct and primary NRDB layers;
environmental risk and hazard assessment modeling, what-if scenarios simulation; Utility mapping,
corridor analysis, reconnaissance surveys, project estimates, adherence to global standards; and
familiarization & exploitation of 3D information and many more.
The success of CARTODEM Project needs to be evaluated after its implementation, by verifying the
above benefits have actually been realized.
Key Differentiators
CARTODEM Project will be implemented as one-time rigorous exercise to create this important
database. Some of the differentiators are:
CARTODEM
Satellite photogrammetry
SOI
Aerial Photogrammetry
Information
Plan reference
Heights
MSL heights
Everest
Bare-earth (DTM)
Strategy
Data collection
Instrumentation
Height
accuracy
Plan accuracy
Cell size
Coverage
DEM
generation
Dynamic
contouring,
point
heights
Largely automatic
Manual
Indigenous software
Analogue & semi-analytical
plotters
8 m, yielding contours at of 7m if CI is 20m (general case);
20m Interval;
15m in high hills when 40-50m
CI is adapted.
1. Accuracy= 1/3rd of Contour
Interval 2. 1:50 000 scale info
assumed.
3. At 1: 25000, 10m contours
are drawn. However, Partial
coverage at this scale.
15m
-(12.5m is the reading error at
1:50 000 scale)
1 arc sec
NA
(~30m at equator);
National
Direct,
through
matching;
National
image Interpolated from digitization of
contours, points heights and
other breaklines
3. Implementation Methodology
Given the vast size and complexity of the task, it is proposed to implement the CARTODEM project
through SST based autonomous DEM generation
The salient specifications of the product (as production goals) are summarized below:
ELEMENT
Process
Strategy
GCPs
Cartodem
Largely automatic
No Zoning
GCPL points covering the entire country
Software
Height accuracy
LE90
Plan &Height reference
SST (modified)
8m
(Contour Interval 20m)
WGS84 Elliposid
15m
Cell size
Semantics
1 arc sec
Automatic extraction, interactive validation
Coverage
Indicative applications
National
Slope, aspect, drainage maps, orthorectification upto
1:25000, GIS applications, fly-thru
SSTS Specification
No. of passes for a day
Pass length (long pass)
Segment Length
No. of Segments
No. of GCPs required
4.0 MANPOWER
1. Departmental: Necessary scientific manpower of the Department will be identified and
redeployed to form a team to realize the Product.
2. 3 programmers (2 for 5 month duration for MSST development and the third for 12 months)
3. 4 JRFs / Research Associates will be recruited for the Project duration.
6. Time Goals
CARTODEM to be realized in ONE year; subject to the availability of cloud-free data.
Schedule (Quarter-wise)
Activity
Systems Procurement
Data procurement
Benchmarking
Production
Q1
Q2
Q3
Q4 & Q5
7. Product Specifications
The following table provides the product specifications of CARTODEM project.
DEM Specifications
Posting Interval
1 arc-second (~30m at equator)
Datum
WGS-84 Ellipsoid
Plan accuracy
CEP90 15m
Height accuracy
LE90 8m (surface heights)
Orthoimage Specifications
Spacing
2 metre
Datum
WGS-84 Ellipsoid
Plan accuracy
CEP90 15m
Projection
As per NNRMS standard
8. Project Management
An appropriate inter-centre project team will be identified to execute the project.
A CARTODEM- Project Management Board will be constituted to oversee the project
implementation including progress monitoring, budget, inter-centre related activities etc.
The overall policy guidance will be provided by NRR-MC
9. Facility Definition
The broad requirements are tabulated here. SSTS Development Team desires to have a replica of highend production systems (SSTS operations) at SAC also, to support the production facility.
To optimize the use of resources like mass storage, peripherals, it is planned to configure the systems at
one single place.
The high performance servers are meant for executing the compute and i/o intensive DEM matching
using the MSST software.
The photogrammetric workstations are for data import, pre-processing, photogrammetric operations,
quality checks, and post-processing. Two of them will be located at RRSSCs for DEM generation.
System Requirement for CARTODEM FACILITY
(For Production, Quality Checks,, Post-processing operations; all co-located at NDC)
Sl.No.
1.
Item Description
Quantity
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
8.
9.
10.
12.
13.
14.
Cost In
lakhs
4 No.
300
12
4 no.
1 No.
50
70
1 No.
1 set
2 Nos.
12
5
16
3 Nos.
3 Nos.
12
30
1 No.
16
1 No.
12
1 no.
4
18
3 Nos.
557
10. Budget
Activity
Details
1 GCPs #
2 Systems cost (as listed in the Table)
3 Cost of s/w maintenance for 2 yrs.(incl compression)
4 Cost of h/w maintenance for 2 yrs.
10% p.a.
5 Manpower cost(4 JRFs/Sci.Assts + 4programmers
Sub Total
Project Management@10% except on Data
Unit rate
(Rs.)
Qty
Total (Rs.)
in Lakhs
6600
500
300000
33.00
557.00
12.00
111.40
19.36
713.40
71.34
784.74
Annexure -I
Intended Use: For compressing the Orthoimages for effective storage and dissemination.
Appendix-II
`Storage Estimates
= 3 TB
Appendix-III
TOTAL
1056000
880000
1936000
SST Operations
(RAD files, Model parameters)
Automatic Breaklines
(ABL)
Post-processing
Time-composition,
Mosaicing, tiling, etc.
NAS operations
Archiving DEM, Orthoimage
Benchmarking
It is mandatory that benchmarking is done to check/refine the product specs (and establish
the operational work-plan) before embarking on the productionisation of this national level
project.
The benchmarking mechanism and the schedules are documented here. The following
parameters (for minimum two areas covering the mixed terrain of forests, water, urban) are
suggested:
1. Extent of Each area: 1 square degree
2. Minimum and desired control points for triangulation
3. Triangulation accuracy at the independent check points (at least twice the number of
control points): GCPs from GCPL database are to be sourced for this. In case of
inadequacy, fresh acquisition has to be initiated.
4. DEM matching speed (points/minute)
5. Breaklines (adequacy, and accuracy)
6. DEM evaluation (visual and quantitative).
7. DEM editing mechanism
8. DEM Mosaicing: geometric quality
9. Orthorectification: accuracy, seam (geometric and radiometric)
10. Time compositing
11. Total system time and elapsed time for the process
Acknowledgments:
Following RSAM_MC recommendation, an inter-centre Study Team was constituted by Director,
NRSA in Jan 2005. This team, after several intense deliberations, brought out a technical
document. The inputs from terrain-specific case-studies form the backbone of this document.
On the recommendation of the Director, NRSA, a projectisation proposal is developed. These
proposals are presented to Chairman, ISRO by the Director, NRSA. In addition, it was presented
to the IRS-P5 PMB by the Convenor of the Study Team. Based on the observations made by the
Chairman, a meeting was held in ISRO HQ, Bangalore to discuss the proposal. The meeting was
headed by Dr.V. Jayaraman and attended by Dr. PS Roy, Dr. P.K.Srivastava, Dr.J Krishnamurthy,
Dr.. S.S.Rao and Sri Murali Mohan. The report was presented, and deliberated for possible
refinements and optimizations. Consequently, a sub-committee was identified by the Director,
EOS to incorporate the suggestions and finalise the proposal considering the post-launch
experiences. The sub-committee comprised of Sri B.Gopla Krishna, Dr.J Krishnamurthy, Dr.S.S.Rao,
Sri Murali Mohan with Dr.P.S.Roy as its Convenor. The suggestions/inputs of the participating
members are incorporated through a rigorous consultative process. In this endeavor, many
colleagues directly and indirectly participated/assisted: