Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
71/06/101
This document is owned and authorised by the Pavements and Surfacings Manager.
AUTHORISATION
..
PAVEMENTS AND SURFACINGS MANAGER
Date: __/__/__
Page 1 of 14
1.
INTRODUCTION....................................................................................................... 4
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
APPROVAL PROCESS.......................................................................................... 10
7.
Page 2 of 14
Latest
Revision
No.
Latest
Revision
Date
Revision
Description/Reference
New document
Page 3 of 14
1.
INTRODUCTION
This guideline describes the purpose and objectives of asphalt mix design, the design
procedure used by Main Roads Western Australia and the process for approving asphalt job
mix designs that ultimately creates specifications for asphalt properties. The relevant TDP
documents for asphalt are Specification 502 Stone Mastic Asphalt, Specification 504 Wearing
Course Asphalt, Specification 510 Full Depth Asphalt and Specification 511 Materials for
Bituminous Treatments.. The information in this guideline is specific to the types of hot mixed
asphalt listed in Section 2 and does not cover cold mixed asphalt, various types of warm mix
asphalt or thin open graded asphalts such as Novachip.
2.
TYPES OF ASPHALT
DGA, the most common type of asphalt, provides optimal structural strength and generally good
resistance to deformation. OGA is designed to drain water through the asphalt layer to remove
excess water from the tyre/road surface. OGA is used in high speed applications such as
Mitchell and Kwinana Freeways, Roe Hwy and locations where it is important to remove water
from the road surface such as hills like Greenmount on Great Eastern Hwy. SMA is similar to
OGA but has a high proportion of dust and high binder contents to achieve an improved fatigue
life. SMA has a textured surface but does not drain water through its layer as does OGA.
Further information on the selection and use of asphalt can be found in the following
documents:
3.
The aim of designing an asphalt mix is to determine the optimal proportions of bitumen and
crushed aggregates to produce asphalt that meets specified properties and is workable and
durable. To achieve an optimal mix design work needs to be undertaken in a materials laboratory
to determine the best proportions of the available aggregates and bitumen to give a product
(asphalt) that is durable, workable, has resistance to deformation and premature fatigue and
provides an adequate surface texture for its intended purpose. There has to be sufficient bitumen
in the asphalt to completely coat the aggregate particles and bond them together.
If the design of an asphalt mix is not optimised it is likely to have performance issues such as early
fatigue, rutting or shoving, ravelling of the aggregate particles, have a low surface texture creating
MAIN ROADS Western Australia
TRIM D11#103379
Page 4 of 14
a skid resistance problem or stripping of bitumen from the aggregate particles in service, any of
which may require premature replacement of the asphalt. Further information on the production of
asphalt can be found in Austroads Pavement Technology Series Part 4B Asphalt.
4.
Main Roads WA Specifications 504 and 510 provide two options for the contractor to use with
regard to asphalt mix design when tendering for the works, being:
Conforming Mix Design where Main Roads specifies the binder content and particle size
distribution (PSD) of various standard mixes which it is known will satisfy the Marshall
Properties. The standard mixes have been designed using granite aggregates from the
Perth region and are only applicable to asphalt produced using these aggregates. When a
contractor chooses to use a conforming mix design manufactured from Perth granite
aggregate, a job mix design is not required. Where other than granite aggregate from the
Perth region is used for the mix design the contractor shall produce a Job Mix Design.
Job Mix Design this is where a contractor produces an asphalt mix design to satisfy the
Marshall Properties and other requirements specified in Clause 504.26.03 or 510.26.04 of
the two specifications. A Job Mix design must be authorised before a contractor can
proceed with laying asphalt manufactured using a job mix design. .
4.1
Conforming Mixes
Open graded (OGA) and stone mastic asphalt (SMA) can ONLY be produced as a conforming
mix and job mixes are not allowed in the relevant specifications. Therefore this guideline will
focus on the process for the design of dense graded mixes only.
Conforming mix designs in Specifications 504 and 510 shall not be used for asphalt produced in
regional areas unless the asphalt supplier has transported Perth granite aggregates to the
region. Aggregates from different quarries will have varying specific gravities (density) and will
vary in size and shape of the aggregate particles. Differences in the properties of the crushed
aggregate impacts upon the properties of the produced asphalt and for this reason mix designs
for one region should not be used in another region where the properties of the aggregate differ.
For example some changes as a result of differing aggregates include:
Bunbury basalts have a higher density than Perth granite and as a result the
percentage by mass of bitumen in the mix design is lower than Perth mixes. This also
applies to any dolerite type aggregates used in regional areas.
Broome sandstone the density of this aggregate is much lighter than Perth granite and
as a result of this and absorption of bitumen in the aggregate the 14mm Intersection Mix
for Broome has a bitumen content 1.1% higher than the conforming Perth mix design.
Page 5 of 14
4.2
Job Mixes
Where Main Roads does not specify a conforming mix, such as for mixes outside the Perth
region, it is important that the asphalt supplier demonstrate that its job mix is capable of
satisfying the Marshall properties. There have been occasions where Main Roads has
instructed a contractor to produce a mix that may not conform fully to the Marshall properties or
the PSD and binder specification. An example could be where a sprayed seal is fatty with
active binder. Main Roads may instruct a contractor to produce a mix with higher design air
voids to cater for the potential of binder migration from the seal into the voids in the asphalt. In
this scenario an asphalt supplier may alter its mix proportions to change its PSD and possibly
reduce the binder content slightly.
5.
5.1
Design Method
The design method specified by Main Roads is the Marshall method of mix design. The aim of
the method is to determine via a series of laboratory produced trial mixes an optimal
combination of aggregates and bitumen to satisfy specified design criteria.
The first stage is to determine the type of mix required and what Marshall Properties have been
specified. The Marshall Properties for asphalt mixes produced for Main Roads WA are shown
in Attachment A. The first table shows properties for wearing course asphalt as shown in
Specification 504 whilst the second table shows properties of the mix for intermediate and
basecourse asphalt as shown in Specification 510. The properties in the tables include:
A critical aspect of the mix design is to ensure that the volumetric properties are fit for purpose.
This ensures that there is sufficient volume within the mix to accommodate the aggregates,
especially the fine aggregates, and sufficient air voids after mixing and compaction to allow for
expansion of binder when the pavement is subjected to its hottest condition. The latter
comment is not applicable to open graded asphalt which is designed to have in the order of
20% air voids.
5.2
Selection of Materials
The first stage is to identify sources of aggregates that could be used in a mix design. Typically
an asphalt supplier will use local aggregates unless those materials fail to meet specified
requirements for aggregates or are not suited to achieving an optimal gradation in the produced
asphalt or may be too variable in properties.
The aggregate shall meet the requirements specified for asphalt aggregates in Main Roads
Specification 511 Materials for Bituminous Treatments. Typically an asphalt supplier will use
MAIN ROADS Western Australia
TRIM D11#103379
Page 6 of 14
between three and six different sizes of aggregate from local quarries. The designer does a
desk top design by combining the gradings (PSD) of the relevant aggregates on a proportional
basis to achieve a PSD that when the materials are combined and mixed with bitumen are likely
to conform to the Marshall Properties. A designer would typically use a gradation envelope
used for previous works as a target PSD as a guide for a new mix. This provides better
assurance that the new mix design is likely to achieve the specified Marshall properties. An
example of the combination of different size aggregates to produce a 14mm dense graded
asphalt is shown in Table 1.
Aggregate Type and Size
Proportion in Mix
Design by Mass
14mm Granite
22.0
10mm Granite
12.0
7mm Granite
26.0
10.0
28.5
Hydrated Lime
1.5
Once the designer is happy with the preliminary design a trial mix will be manufactured at the
midpoint of the target PSD and bitumen content. Trial mixes are produced in the laboratory by
proportioning the various aggregates together, heating in an oven, adding bitumen and mixing
the asphalt in a bench mixer. The laboratory prepared mix is then tested for all properties
specified for compliance with the design requirements. The designer would review the results
from the preliminary design and adjust the proportions or ingredients used for the design.
Page 7 of 14
The designer may also produce a series of trial mixes at the target PSD and various bitumen
contents to determine the optimum bitumen content to achieve the midpoint air voids and VMA,
as shown in Figure 1. If necessary another trial mix at midpoint of the target PSD and bitumen
content would be produced to verify any design amendments.
When the midpoint of the mix design has been established the designer will produce further trial
mixes with the same PSD but bracketing the bitumen content by plus and minus 0.3%. From
the results graphical plots are prepared of the relationship between the bitumen content and:
An example of such plots is shown below. An optimal bitumen content is selected that satisfies
the Marshall Properties (usually the midpoint of a range) specified for the type of mix. This
bitumen content becomes the design binder content.
Page 8 of 14
At this stage the designer may be unable to satisfy all or some of the properties and may need
to review the proportions of or materials used for the mix. When the design mix (midpoint) has
been established tolerances are placed on the PSD and design binder content to accommodate
variations in PSD and binder content that occur during the production process from a plant.
This establishes a grading envelope for the asphalt. Table 2 shows tolerances for the PSD of a
mix design as shown in Specifications 504 and 510 for designing dense graded asphalts. The
tolerance for bitumen content is specified as 0.3% either side of the design binder content.
Tolerances on Percentage
by Mass Passing
0.150
2.5
0.075
1.5
Table 3 shows an example of the application of the tolerances based on an actual job mix
design for a 14mm Dense Graded Intersection Mix for a Perth based asphalt supplier. For the
0.075mm sieve a restriction on the tolerance has been placed by Main Roads on the fine or
upper limit of the PSD to reduce the maximum allowable mass of fines in the mix to 5.5%.
Particle Size
Distribution
AS Sieve Size (mm)
Coarse Limit
(lower)
19.0
100
100
100
13.2
91
98
100
9.5
76
83
90
6.7
61
68
75
4.75
48
55
62
2.36
32
37
42
1.18
21
26
31
0.60
15
19
23
0.30
12
16
0.15
7.5
10
0.075
4.5
5.5 (note)
% Passing
Midpoint PSD
Fine Limit
(upper)
Page 9 of 14
5.4
The designer then needs to then prepare a further six trial mixes at the coarse and fine limits of
the PSD. For each PSD condition three trial mixes are produced at the design binder content
plus and minus 0.3%. Again the mixes will be prepared in a laboratory, however proportioning
of the component materials as was done for the midpoint PSD will not produce either the coarse
or fine limits of the PSD. To achieve these limits the materials must be sieved or screened into
sieve fractions and then recombined to produce the correct gradation representing the coarse or
fine limit of the PSD. It may be necessary to wash excess dust from the aggregate particles to
achieve the coarse grading limits.
Specifications 504 and 510 include tolerances stating how close to the target fine or coarse limit
and the bitumen content the laboratory should get for the results of its laboratory prepared mix.
The tolerance allows for variation in the PSD or bitumen content of the laboratory prepared mix
that could be due to material breakdown during mixing or variation in obtaining a test portion.
The results of these trials are reviewed against the specified Marshall Properties to ensure that
at the extremes of the production specification that the mix conforms to the specified properties.
The final selected mix is termed the Job Mix and will nominate the type, source and
proportions of components, target PSD and binder content along with the Marshall properties. It
is important that the design procedure results in an asphalt mix that will perform satisfactorily
during placement and compaction or under long term trafficking.
Any change in the type and source of components or significant variation in proportioning
generally requires redesign of the mix and determination of a new job mix. An example is with
aggregates where a change in density of the stone will alter the binder content, which is
expressed as a percentage by mass. Therefore a heavier stone such as diorite or basalt may
occupy the same volume as granite aggregate but the density of diorite or basalt is greater,
resulting in a lower binder content by mass. Changes in the shape of the aggregate will affect
how the aggregate particles pack together, thus impacting upon the volumetrics in the mix
design. Implementation of a standard mix design specified for use with Perth aggregates in
different locations such as Kalgoorlie or Port Hedland would not be practical. It is very likely
that the aggregates in Kalgoorlie or Port Hedland, and other locations, differ markedly from the
properties of aggregates produced in the scarp quarries of Perth.
In addition to the design process described to ensure that a mix design has an appropriate PSD
to ensure that it meets the Marshall design criteria it is also important that the mix be resistant to
deformation during its service. A further laboratory produced mix must be made at the midpoint
PSD and binder content and compacted in a gyratory compactor for 350 cycles. This test
determines the refusal density and Specifications 504 and 510 require that the air voids in the
compacted mix shall not be less than 2.5%.
6.
APPROVAL PROCESS
Specifications 504 and 510 require that a Job Mix must be authorised before it can be laid on
the Works. For authorisation the asphalt supplier must submit the following information:
The information is submitted to the Materials Engineering Branch for evaluation. If the Job Mix
meets the specified requirements a number is assigned to the job mix and the asphalt supplier
MAIN ROADS Western Australia
TRIM D11#103379
Page 10 of 14
is advised in writing, including an attachment detailing the materials to be used in the mix, the
proportions of the materials, the binder and PSD specification, Marshall properties and limits on
the use of the mix, e.g. maximum and minimum thickness to be laid. At present there is not an
expiry date on the mix approval, however, the ongoing approval is subject to satisfactory
production records demonstrating conformance with specified properties and satisfactory field
performance.
An example of the attachment sent to an asphalt supplier advising of details of a job mix design
is shown in Attachment B. Details of the asphalt supplier have been removed from the
example. A listing of job mix designs approved by Main Roads is available on the Materials
Engineering page of the Main Roads website. The listing shows:
The type of aggregate used for the mix design is important as discussed previously but also
means that a mobile asphalt plant can use a mix away from the town where the quarry
supplying the aggregate used in the mix design is located. For example an asphalt supplier
may have an approved mix design using aggregate from the Holcim Quarry in Walkaway near
Geraldton. If the asphalt supplier carts that aggregate to another location such as Carnarvon or
Meekatharra that mix design can then be used to produce asphalt on site.
7.
FURTHER READING
The following publications provide further information on the selection, use, design and
application of asphalt.
Page 11 of 14
Attachment A
Specification 504
Marshall Properties for Dense Graded Asphalt
Nominal 5mm, 10 mm and 14 mm Mixes
Parameter
Min
Max
Marshall Stability
8.0 kN
Marshall Flow
2.00 mm
4.00 mm
4.0%
6.0%
4.0%
7.0%
nominal 5 mm
3.0%
5.0%
4.0%
7.0%
nominal 10 mm Laterite
15.0%
nominal 10 mm
15.0%
nominal 5 mm
16.0%
14.0%
TABLE 504.B1
Page 12 of 14
Attachment A
Specification 510
Marshall Properties for Dense Graded Asphalt
Intermediate Course and Base Course Mixes
Parameter
Min
Max
8.0 kN
2.00 mm
4.00 mm
4.0%
7.0%
3.5%
5.5%
1.5%
3.5%
14.0%
14.0%
Marshall Stability
Marshall Flow
Air Voids:
Page 13 of 14
Attachment B
MIX SPECIFICATION
Particle Size Distribution
Sieve Size (mm)
19.00
13.2
9.5
6.7
4.75
2.36
1.18
0.600
0.300
0.150
0.075
% Passing by mass
100
91 - 100
76 - 90
61 - 75
48 - 62
32 - 42
21 - 31
15 - 23
8 - 16
5 - 10
3 - 5.5
Binder
Class 320 Bitumen
Marshall Properties
Marshall Air Voids
Voids in Mineral Aggregate
Stability
Flow
4.0 7.0%
Not Less than 14.0%
Not Less than 8.0 kN
2.0 4.0 mm
Aggregate Details
Aggregate shall be sourced from the same location as nominated when the job mix design was
submitted for approval, as shown below:
Quarry, Location
14mm Granite
10mm Granite
7mm Granite
Washed Quarry Sand
Quarry Sand
Filler (Hydrated Lime)
22.0%
12.0%
26.0%
10.0%
28.5%
1.5%
Page 14 of 14