Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
a r t i c l e
i n f o
Article history:
Received 29 May 2008
Accepted 2 July 2008
Available online 15 July 2008
Keywords:
Casting
Chilled cast iron
Hardness
Microstructure
Foundry methods
Computer simulation
a b s t r a c t
In the present study, the mechanical and metallographic properties of camshafts produced from chilled
cast iron were examined experimentally and numerically relating with the solidication, cooling rate and
metal ow. First of all, with the help of the 3-dimensional drawing and design programs the whole casting methodology was planned. This planning was analyzed with casting simulation software. After that
camshafts were produced experimentally at the foundry. Chill material was used in order to get rapid
cooling. The phases, dendrite structure and dendrite arm spacing on the lobes of camshaft were examined
with an optic microscope and XRD. The Brinell, Rockwell and Vickers hardness tests were carried out on
surfaces of lobes and camshafts. On the rapid cooling areas, the ledeburitic phase and high hardness values, on the slow cooling surfaces, rosette like graphite in pearlitic and low ferrite phase and low hardness
values were examined. On the chill areas 215 lm DAS (dendrite arm spacing) were measured.
2008 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
1. Introduction
In recent years, numerical simulations and computer aided modeling of casting solidication are receiving increasing attention because of its great quantity of potential in increasing productivity of
the metal casting industry by reducing the time associated with
the traditional experimental based design of casting [1]. There
is an extensive and increasing effort in the numerical simulation of
a wide range of processes involving solidication and heatingcooling, including a variety of casting processes [2]. In order to identify
the conditions and optimum values, simulation of solidication process is done by running indigenously developed computer software
for the casting process selected for investigation [3]. The program
output provides the details on determination of the stress concentration level [4], porosity caused by gas entrapment, humidity of
sand, micro segregation [5], timetemperature prole, heat transfer
coefcient values, ow rate, thermal modulus, solidication process
which plays a key role in the effective design of castings [6,7]. Further, the computer simulation of solidication of castings offers a
basis for predicting the solidication simulation package depends
to a large extent on the use of accurate thermo-physical data and
boundary conditions by the solidication modeler [1,8].
The structural integrity of shaped castings is closely related to
their temperaturetime evolution during solidication. In the last
two decades to treat heat transfer during solidication a number
of analytical and numerical models were developed and the conse* Tel.: +90 2642955790; fax: +90 2642955608.
E-mail address: lkumruoglu@sakarya.edu.tr
0261-3069/$ - see front matter 2008 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
doi:10.1016/j.matdes.2008.07.008
928
and thermal) in front of the chilling interface results in the development of cellular dendrite growth of the graphite into a form recognized as exploded graphite. The microstructures of gray iron and
ductile irons are determined by cooling rate, composition, nucleation and growth conditions prevailing during solidication [13].
Fig. 1. Intake (I) and Exhaust (E) lobes, cylinders, camshafts and their location in the casting branch.
good machinability, even at hardness high enough to impart excellent wear resistance, and high vibration absorption. Also, gray cast
iron could be chilled to improve its wear surface properties [14]
maintaining the inside structural body easily machineable, and
reducing the manufacturing costs [15]. Also mechanical properties
especially good wear resistance and hard surface hardness could be
achieved by starting from the same molten metal to which small
amounts of some elements are added, or by a variation of the cooling rate during solidication or solid-state transformation [16].
In general, the cooling rate during casting is largely governed by
the design and thermal nature of the casting procedure, one significant factor being the mould material. Metalmoulds generally offer higher chilling action on the solidifying mass due to their higher
heat diffusivity. Therefore, the inuence of higher cooling rate is
normally responsible for the superior properties of chilled castings.
The use of chills rstly favors the renement of microstructure.
929
Table 1
Chemical composition of examined camshaft (wt.%)
Chilled area
Center of lobe
Fe
Si
Mn
Cr
Cu
Ni
Mo
Sn
Ti
Ceq
91.53
91.27
3.54
4.09
2.25
2.21
0.79
0.702
0.68
0.555
0.06
0.059
0.03
0.03
0.4
0.453
0.2
0.17
0.41
0.385
0.03
0.027
0.014
0.014
4.31
4.84
Fig. 3. Chills assembly on camshafts (a), and the original cam shafts branch (b).
930
3. Experimental details
Variable camshaft consisting of two cam lobes, one inside the
other, in which the exhaust cams are connected rmly to the camshaft tube, and the intake cams are joined to the inside cam lobe by
a connecting element. This achieves the functionality of two
adjustable camshafts using just one camshaft. Fig. 1 shows Intake
(I) and Exhaust (E) lobes, cylinders, camshafts and their location
in the casting branch with feeder, riser, and sprue.
3.1. Experimental and computer aided evaluation
Flow of liquid metal and mould lling phenomena is one of the
most important parameter when producing camshafts and the
other plenty of cast material by casting techniques. In order to obtain soundness casting; pouring speed, casting temperature, total
casting time, feeder, sprue, ingate, pour basin, chills location, chills
material and mould design are very crucial parameters by using
trial and error methods the optimization of these parameters is
so difcult therefore computer simulation has a great importance
on optimizing.
Fig. 5. Physical properties of silica sand and gray iron (chill) material obtained by computer analysis.
These models were converted into STL (STereo Lithography) formats and imported into simulation software for mesh generation.
The initial settings of parameters used in simulation were as
follows.
Dimension of sand mould box was 600 mm width, 450 mm
length, 230 mm height. Minimal mould thickness was 25 mm.
According to the nite element method, total number of cells
55877640 and total number of casting cells 2223868. The mould
material was chosen as silica sand and initial mould temperature
was 20 C. The volume of casting 2744,926 cm3 and volume of
chilled cast iron branch 883,458 cm3 were measured. Pouring temperature 1280 C, liquidus temperature 1157 C and solidus temperature 1045 C were selected.
4. Results and discussion
4.1. Foundry technology for producing camshafts and simulation
studies
The melts utilized in the present study were produced by using
a 500 kg induction melting furnace in Camshaft Company Turkey.
931
The foundry technology is illustrated in Fig. 2. AFS grain nes number of silica sand 5055 is used as sand mould material. CaSi (to
promote uniform structure) inoculants were used in crucible. The
camshaft material is gray cast iron with a carbon equivalent of
4.314.32%. Chemical composition of camshafts is given in Table
1. The pouring temperature is approximately 13801400 C. Inoculation is carried out in a ladle. All eight cams are chilled using grey
cast iron chills, the chills location of each camshaft and the original
casting equipment are shown in Fig. 3.
The simulation software called JMat-Pro was used to obtain
heat conduction, specic heat, density properties of chilled cast
iron, gray cast iron mould (chill) material. These properties are
shown in Fig. 4. In addition, the simulation software was used to
obtain physical and thermal properties of both gray iron chill that
is set in mould for rapid cooling and silica sand. The thermal and
physical properties of these materials are shown in Fig. 5.
To obtain meaningful results the thermocouples were located in
camshaft lobes and cylinders. The detail of location is presented in
Fig. 6. The numbers 18 were located as X shape in lobes and the
numbers 911 were located as X shape in cylinders. CS1CS4 are
acronyms of camshaft. After the liquid metal was poured in the
Fig. 7. Simulated cooling curve by computer simulation software for camshaft 2 and camshaft 3.
Fig. 8. Simulated cooling curve by computer simulation software for camshaft 1 and camshaft 4.
932
mould cavity, each thermocouple supplied temperature and cooling curve data. CS2CS3 and CS1CS4 cooling curves are given in
Figs. 7 and 8, respectively, for each lobe.
According to the simulation results, the cooling curves of CS2
and CS3 are same therefore they were shown in the same graphic.
As shown in Fig. 7 the lobes 2, 3, 6, 7 which belong to CS2 and CS3
got cold faster than the lobes 1, 4, 5, 8.
As the situation happened in CS2 and CS3, the cooling curves of
CS1 and CS4 are the same, therefore they are shown in the same
graphic too. As shown in Fig. 8 the lobes 2, 3, 6, 7 got cold faster
than the lobes 1, 4, 5, 8. Despite the fact that the cooling curves
in CS1CS4 and CS2CS3 look the same; the cooling rate in CS1
CS4 was obtained a little faster than the cooling rate in CS2CS3.
In Fig. 9 the cooling curves were shown for bearings 911. Compared with the cooling curves in CS2CS3 and CS1CS4, the cooling
rate in the bearings 911 was obtained more slowly.
To characterize the chilled and non-chilled area, the CuCl2 test
was carried out. The CuCl2 test gives macroscopic vision. Cu is
deposited on the chilled cast iron and the Fe dissolves by forming
Fe2+. Fe is spontaneously oxidized to Fe2+ by Cu2+. The Cu2+ is spon-
933
Electrons ow from anode to cathode because the cathode has a lower electrical potential energy than the anode. On the atomic level, a
Cu2+ (aq) ion comes into contact with a Fe(s) atom on the surface of
the lobe. The Cu(s) atoms supply better vision to have a macroscopic
view on the chilled (ledeburitic) area and non-chilled area.
In order to understand the cooling phenomena in the lobes
clearly, 14 thermocouples were located in each lobe as shown in
Fig. 10 and the computer simulation was carried out. The results
of the computer solidication and cooling simulation showed that
on the outer surface of the lobes solidication was occurred more
rapidly. The transformed ledeburitic phase was examined on the
outer surface of the lobes because of the rapid cooling rate.
Flow of liquid metal is one of the most important parameters
when producing camshafts by casting techniques. After the liquid
metal poured into mould cavity, metal ows in sprue, runner, ingates, respectively, then lls mould cavity. The ow simulation results shown in Fig. 11 that the liquid metal rstly reaches the last
feeder which is at the end of the runner then ows into bearing 3,
lobe 8 and 7, respectively, then reaches bearing 2 and ows towards lobe 4 and 3. Because of rstly contacting, chill materials
of these lobes are heated by liquid metal. Heated chills supply slow
cooling rate as compared with to the other chills. At the same time
because of the lobe 8 locations near the feeder, the high thermal
modulus feeder cools slowly and heats around. Lobe 1 has the
same cooling conditions, due to the nearest location of high thermal modulus feeder. Total casting time was measured as 10 s. Flow
of liquid and solidication simulation steps are illustrated in Fig.
11. The numbers 18 in Fig. 11 were presented as step by step of
ow-solidication simulation.
4.2. Metallographic studies
Fig. 11. Flow simulation of camshaft branch.
934
935
The microstructure at average cooling rates is occurred as mottled iron and the carbon in this structure is as primary cementite
and graphite. Very slow cooling of irons that contain large percentages of silicon and carbon is likely to produce considerable fer-
Table 2
Rockwell hardness values of camshaft lobes alone X- and Y-axis
1 Lobe
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
8.
9.
10.
2 Lobe
3 Lobe
4 Lobe
5 Lobe
6 Lobe
7 Lobe
8 Lobe
X-axis
Y-axis
X-axis
Y-axis
X-axis
Y-axis
X-axis
Y-axis
X-axis
Y-axis
X-axis
Y-axis
X-axis
Y-axis
X-axis
Y-axis
57
50
38
34
31
33
38
46
51
56
54
48
33
36
31
35
40
44
50
54
50
46.5o
36.5
39
31
42
51
53
54
52.5
48
42
39
39
40.5
48
54
54
53
50
42
39
36
35
40
48
56
52
49
46
43
39
26
35
35
47
52
49
41
35
32
35
27
40
45.5
54
54
49
45.5
38
35
34
35
40
50
52.5
48
44
38
37
30
39
45
54.5
54.5
52
49
47
39
37
34
39
50
54
50
43
44
36
36
34
43
46
50
54
54
48
46
41
36
36
40
45
56
55
50
46
40
36
38
41
44
54
55
54
47
47
38
35
37
42
47
51
51
43
40
40
40
35
37
40
53
54
49
45
43
39
40
34
41
51
54
936
rite and pearlite throughout the matrix, together with coarse graphite akes.
As shown in Figs. 1214 the ledeburitic structure was obtained
at the top area and the bottom area. Especially it was examined
that there was a great amount of ledeburitic phase depth at the
top area. The mottled graphite was also examined in the center
of the lobe. That kind of microstructure was approximately 30
35 HRc hardness. On the other way ledeburitic structure hardness
was between 45 HRc and 57 HRc.
4.3. Hardness testing
The hardness tests methods, micro-hardness, Rockwell C and
Brinell hardness, were used on the surface of the camshafts lobes.
The hardness tests performed on cross-sectional surface are shown
in Fig. 15.
937
Fig. 19. XRD data obtained from the chilled zone of lobe.
formed for each lobe in order to be understood well. Micro-hardness tests as shown in Fig. 18 were carried out from top to the bottom. According to the micro-hardness tests results, various values
from 350Hv0.3 (Hardness Vickers) to the 750Hv0.3 were obtained. It
was examined that there was cementite phase in high hardness
areas, graphite phase in lower hardness areas. In Fig. 18, the dark
line symbolizes an average micro hardness values.
The Fe3C and Fe phases were determined by XRD studies and
the detailed results are given in Fig. 19. The phase composition
investigation of the samples was carried out on the polished metal
surface using RIGAKU diffractometer Cu Ka, radiation, 1.54050 ).
As can be seen in Fig. 19, the rapid cooling area consist Fe3C carbides in matrix. The carbides phases improve hardness, wear and
abrasion resistance. The microstructure of the unalloyed iron generally consists of M3C carbides and pearlite. On the other hand, carbides and perlite do not supply sufcient properties for some
engineering applications. For instance, toughness is as signicant
as hardness for camshafts. Ni, Cr, Mo and Co additions both increase the hardness and toughness.
5. Conclusion
As the result of this work, the following conclusions are derived.
The cooling rate of a casting is primarily a function of its section
size. Increasing the cooling rate renes both hard transformed
ledeburitic phase and ne pearlitic (without ferrite inclusions)
matrix structure (on nose area of the lobes) therefore the hardness
increases. Lobe 6, 7, 2 and 3 have rapid cooling rate therefore harder values are expected than the other lobes.
Because of the strong cooling effect of chill, top of lobes are rapidly solidied under the high cooling rate therefore deeper chill
zone occurs and the DAS(dendrite arm spacing) is between 2 lm
and 15 lm. In lower cooling areas the DAS rises but in the central
areas of the lobes DAS doesnt occur.
Thermal characteristics such as cooling time, cooling ow rate,
chill and feeder locations, have shown the most pronounced effect
on microstructure. The casting simulation software is very useful
for predicting chill effect and casting parameters. So trial and error
period could be decreased.
Acknowledgements
The author gratefully acknowledge the technical supports extended by Mr. Hakan Bogatur and ESTAS Company (Sivas).
References
[1] Gafur MA, Haque MN, Prabhu KN. Effect of chill thickness and superheat on
casting/chill interfacial heat transfer during solidication of commercial pure
aluminium. J Mater Process Technol 2003;133:25765.
[2] Spim JA, Garcia A. Numerical analysis of solidication of complex shaped
bodies: coupling of mesh elements of different geometries. Mater Sci Eng
2000;A277:198205.
[3] Vijayaram TR, Sulaiman S, Hamouda AMS, Ahmad MHM. Numerical simulation
of casting solidication in permanent metallic molds. J Mater Process Technol
2006;178:2933.
[4] Bayrakceken H, Ucun I, Tasgetiren S. Fracture analysis of a camshaft made from
nodular cast iron. Eng Failure Anal 2006;13:12405.
[5] Attar E, Homayonifar P, Babaei R, Asgari K, Davamil P. Modelling of air pressure
effects in casting moulds. Modell Simul Mater Sci Eng 2005;13:90317.
[6] Kalpakjian S, Schmid SR. Manufacturing engineering and technology. 4th
ed. International Edition Prentice-Hall; 2001.
[7] Kim C, Kim CW. Numerical simulation of casting solidication in automotive
applications. The minerals, metals and materials society. USA: TMS; 1991.
[8] Su X. Computer aided optimization of an investment bi-metal casting process.
PhD thesis, University of Cincinnati; 2001.
[9] Santos CA, Quaresma JMV, Garcia A. Determination of transient interfacial
heat transfer coefcients in chill mold castings. J Alloys Compd 2001;319:
17486.
938
[10]
[11]
[12]
[13]
Bishop HK, Brandt FA, Pillini WS. Trans Am Foundryman Soc 1951;59:435.
Berry JT. Trans Am Foundryman Soc 1970;78:421.
Sun GX, Loper CR. Trans Am Foundryman Soc 1983;91:841.
Hemanth J. Effect of cooling rate on dendrite arm spacing (DAS), eutectic cell
count (ECC) and ultimate tensile strength (UTS) of austempered chilled ductile
iron. Mater Des 2000;21:18.
[14] Ipek R, Selcuk B, Karamis Kuzucu V, Ycel A. An evaluation of the possibilities
of using borided GG25 cast iron instead of chilled GG25 cast iron (surface
properties). J Mater Process Technol 2000;105:739.
[15] Ferreira JC. A study of cast chilled iron processing technology and wear
evaluation of hardened gray iron for automotive application. J Mater Process
Technol 2002;121:94101.
[16] Oliveira MJ, Malheiros LF, Ribeiro CAS. Evaluation of the heat of solidication
of cast irons from continuous cooling curves. J Mater Process Technol
1999:2530.
[17] Seah KHW, Hemanth J, Sharma SC, Rao KVS. Solidication behaviour of watercooled and subzero chilled cast iron. J Alloys Compd 1999;290:17280.
[18] Yang Y, Rosochowski A, Wang X, Jiang Y. Mechanism of black line
formation in chilled cast iron camshafts. J Mater Process Technol 2004;145:
2647.
[19] Hemanth J. The solidication and corrosion behaviour of austempered chilled
ductile iron. J Mater Process Technol 2000;101:15966.
[20] ASM handbook. Properties and selection: irons, steels, and high performance
alloys, vol. 1. 10th ed. USA; 1990.