Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
PageID 1
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
VERIFIED COMPLAINT
For its Complaint, Plaintiff Radio One, Inc. (Radio One) presents claims for relief of
trademark infringement, false designation of origin, deceptive acts and practices, and unfair
competition against Defendant Flinn Broadcasting Corporation (Defendant or Flinn
Broadcasting) and states as follows:
PARTIES
1.
Plaintiff Radio One is a corporation organized under the laws of the State of
Delaware and has its principal place of business at 1010 Wayne Avenue, 14th floor, Silver
Spring, Maryland 20910.
2.
State of Tennessee and has its principal place of business at 6080 Mount Moriah Road Ext,
Memphis, Tennessee 38115-2645.
This Court has original jurisdiction over this action pursuant to 15 U.S.C. 1121
and 28 U.S.C. 1331 and 1338, inasmuch as this action arises under the Trademark Act of
PageID 2
1946 (the Lanham Act), as amended, 15 U.S.C. 1051 et seq., and supplemental jurisdiction
over any state-law claims pursuant to 28 U.S.C. 1367.
VENUE
4.
Defendant Flinn Broadcasting is a corporation that is deemed to reside in this judicial district, as
that term is defined in 28 U.S.C. 1391(c).
5.
substantial part of the events giving rise to the claims in this Complaint occurred in this judicial
district.
FACTUAL BACKGROUND
Plaintiffs Trademarks
6.
Radio One is a diversified media company and one of the nations largest radio
broadcasting companies. Directly and through subsidiaries, Radio One currently owns and/or
operates fifty-four broadcast stations located in sixteen urban markets in the United States.
Radio One operates radio stations in Georgia, Indiana, Maryland, Massachusetts, Michigan,
Missouri, North Carolina, Ohio, Pennsylvania, Texas, and Virginia.
7.
applications and possesses trademark rights in the BOOM and BOOM FM marks (collectively
the BOOM Marks).
8.
On October 6, 2008, CBS Radio Holdings, Inc. filed with the United States Patent
and Trademark Office (USPTO) an application to register the BOOM FM mark for radio
broadcasting services on the Principal Register. On December 29, 2009, the USPTO registered
the BOOM FM mark to CBS Radio Holdings, Reg. No. 3732472. The registration is valid and
PageID 3
subsisting, uncancelled, and unrevoked. A true and correct copy of the BOOM FM registered
trademark is attached hereto as Exhibit 1 and is incorporated by reference.
9.
On October 31, 2012, CBS Radio Holdings, Inc. effected a merger with CBS
Radio Stations, Inc. and executed an assignment of the BOOM FM mark to CBS Radio
Stations, Inc. (CBS). The assignment was recorded with the USPTO on October 2, 2014. A
true and correct copy of the assignment is attached hereto as Exhibit 2 and is incorporated by
reference.
10.
On October 3, 2014, CBS filed with the USPTO an application to register the
BOOM mark on the Principal Register for radio broadcasting services and entertainment
services, namely, audio programming services for dissemination via radio broadcasting and
streaming on the global communications network. A true and correct copy of the application to
register the BOOM mark (Serial No. 86413893) is attached hereto as Exhibit 3 and is
incorporated by reference.
11.
On December 19, 2014, CBS executed an assignment to Radio One of the BOOM
Marks. The assignment was recorded with the USPTO on December 22, 2014. A true and
correct copy of the assignment is attached hereto as Exhibit 4 and is incorporated by reference.
12.
From 2008 to late 2014, CBS used the BOOM FM mark for certain radio
Since October 2014, Radio One has used the BOOM FM and BOOM marks,
shown below, for its radio stations that specialize in playing only classic hip-hop music and to
identify its services, prominently displaying the mark on advertisements and its associated radio
station internet websites.
14
4.
PageID 4
Radio
o One is onee of the firstt broadcasterrs to adopt aan all classic hip-hop foormat
Radio
o
Statiions,
RollingStone
R
e.com
(Dec.
28,
22014),
http://ww
ww.rollingsto
one.com/mu
usic/news/claassic-hip-hopp-format-resscuing-radio-stations20141228; Ben Sisarrio, Classic Hip-Hop
H
is Spreading
S
oon the Radio Dial, nytim
mes.com (Decc. 15,
2014), htttp://www.nytimes.com//2014/12/16//business/meedia/classic--hip-hop-is-sspreading-onn-theradio-diaal.html?_r=1 (attached heereto as Exh
hibit 5). As a result, Raddio One has achieved naationwide reco
ognition for its BOOM-b
branded radiio stations.
15.
f
and diistinctivenesss of the BO
OOM Markks is also reecognized inn the
The fame
Memphiss broadcastin
ng area and business com
mmunity. SSee Greg Akkers, 96X Chhanges Form
mat to
Throwba
ack
Hip--Hop
(D
Dec.
8,
2014,
11:33
PM),
bizjournals.com,
http://ww
ww.bizjournaals.com/mem
mphis/blog/m
morning_calll/2014/12/966x-changes-format-tothrowbacck-hip-hop.h
html (attacheed hereto as Exhibit
E
6).
16.
Radio
o One operattes its BOOM
M-branded cclassic hip-hhop radio stattions in Houuston,
Boom 92, KR
ROI-FM, lau
unched on October
O
13, 22014); Philaddelphia, Pennnsylvania (B
Boom
Texas (B
107.9, WPHI-FM,
W
launched on November 6, 2014); D
Dallas, Texas (Boom 994.5, KSOC
C-FM,
PageID 5
launched on November 17, 2014); and Atlanta, Georgia (Boom 102.9, WAMJ-HD2 and
W275BK, launched on November 25, 2014). Radio One also offers all of the aforementioned
radio stations for streaming over the internet. See Exhibit 7.
17.
Radio One uses the BOOM Marks in advertising on each of its respective radio
The BOOM Marks symbolize the extensive good will and consumer recognition
Radio One, and before it CBS, has created in programming classic hip-hop radio stations through
a substantial investment of time and effort in advertising and promotion.
19.
television stations throughout the United States. Flinn Broadcasting operates television stations
in Alabama, Florida, Minnesota, Mississippi, and Tennessee. Flinn Broadcasting operates radio
stations in Alabama, Arkansas, California, Florida, Georgia, Iowa, Louisiana, Mississippi,
Missouri, Montana, Nevada, Oklahoma, and Tennesse. See http://flinn.com (attached hereto as
Exhibit 9).
21.
began its unauthorized use of the BOOM Marks in connection with two of its newly re-formatted
radio stations, WIVG-FM 96.1 from Memphis, Tennessee, and Tunica, Mississippi; and WOXFFM 105.1 from Oxford, Mississippi. Both stations are known as Boomin 96 Throwback Hip
PageID 6
Hop and specialize in playing only classic hip-hop music. See Lance Venta, Classic Hip-Hop is
Boomin in Memphis, RadioInsight.com, http://radioinsight.com/blog/headlines/netgnomes/
91097/flinn-scraps-memphis-sports-move-launching-classic-hip-hop (last updated Dec. 8, 2014,
8:15 AM) (attached hereto as Exhibit 10).
22.
Flinn
Broadcasting
advertises
its
radio
stations
via
its
website,
http://flinn.com/index.php. See Exhibit 9. Flinn Broadcasting uses the infringing marks on its
website in advertising the radio stations:
com_content&view=article&id=98&catid=97;
and
24.
via
its
PageID 7
Flinn Broadcasting also uses the infringing marks to advertise its radio stations
Twitter
Page
(@Boomin96)
and
via
its
page
(https://
On December 17, 2014, CBS sent a letter to Duane Hargrove, General Manager
of WIVG-FM 96.1, to demand that it cease and desist the use of its confusingly similar Boomin
96 marks in connection with WIVG-FM 96.1 or any other Flinn Broadcasting station in light of
CBS ownership of the BOOM Marks. A true and correct copy of the letter from counsel for
CBS to Duane Hargrove is attached hereto as Exhibit 13 and is incorporated by reference.
26.
Upon information and belief, Flinn Broadcasting did not respond to the December
One, Radio One sent a second letter to Duane Hargrove, reiterating the previous demand that
Flinn Broadcasting immediately cease and desist the use of its confusingly similar Boomin 96
marks in connection with WIVG-FM 96.1 or any other Flinn Broadcasting station in light of
Radio Ones ownership of the BOOM Marks. A true and correct copy of the letter from counsel
for Radio One to Duane Hargrove is attached hereto as Exhibit 14 and is incorporated by
reference.
28.
At the time of the filing of the instant Complaint, Flinn Broadcasting has not
Upon information and belief, after Flinn Broadcasting received the two cease-
and-desist letters, it began offering smart-phone apps for streaming its Boomin 96-branded
classic hip-hop radio stations to various smart devices, including smart phones and tablets. Both
PageID 8
the Apple and Android Boomin 96 apps incorporate the Boomin 96 logo that contains the
unauthorized use of the BOOM Marks.
30.
According to the Google Play website, the Boomin 96 streaming app for
See https://play.google.com/store/
Flinn Broadcasting has been engaging in the willful infringement of the BOOM
Marks since at least its receipt of the December 17, 2014 cease-and-desist letter.
32.
Flinn Broadcasting has no license, authority, or other permission from Radio One
to use the BOOM Marks in connection with radio broadcasting services or audio programming
services for dissemination via radio broadcasting and streaming on the global communications
network.
33.
knowingly and intentionally or with reckless or willful disregard to Radio Ones rights, or with
bad faith, for the purpose of trading on Radio Ones goodwill and reputation in its mark.
34.
impression and deceive consumers, the public, and the trade into believing that there is a
connection, association, or sponsorship between the infringing services and Radio One.
35.
PageID 9
Upon information and belief, Flinn Broadcasting does not have any state or
federal trademark registration for its Boomin 96 mark, nor any pending state or federal
trademark applications for such a mark.
36.
manufacture, advertise, promote, import, distribute, sell, and/or offer for sale the infringing
products and services, unless otherwise restrained.
37.
Count by reference.
39.
with its Boomin 96-branded radio stations is in violation of Radio Ones rights as a trademark
owner.
40.
The foregoing acts of Defendant are intended to cause, have caused, and/or are
likely to continue to cause confusion or mistake, or to deceive consumers, the public, and the
trade into believing that Defendants infringing services are licensed, authorized, affiliated with
or sponsored by Radio One.
41.
Upon information and belief, Defendant has acted with knowledge of Radio
Ones ownership of the BOOM FM mark, and has acted with deliberate intention or willful
blindness to unfairly benefit from the incalculable goodwill inherent in the mark.
42.
43.
PageID 10
Upon information and belief, Defendant has made and will continue to make
Defendants acts have damaged and are likely to further damage Radio One and
trademarks, Radio One will suffer irreparable injury for which there is no adequate remedy at
law.
COUNT II: FALSE DESIGNATION OF ORIGIN OR SPONSORSHIP AND UNFAIR
COMPETITION
46.
Count by reference.
47.
The BOOM Marks have been used in conjunction with radio stations since at least
2008. Radio One has used the BOOM Marks with its radio stations that specialize in the classic
hip-hop format since October 2014.
48.
the infringing services is intended, and likely, to confuse, mislead, or deceive consumers, the
public, and the trade as to the origin, source, sponsorship, or affiliation of the infringing services,
and is intended, and likely, to cause such parties to believe in error that the infringing services
have been authorized, sponsored, approved, endorsed, or licensed by Radio One, or that
Defendant is in some way affiliated with Radio One.
49.
10
50.
PageID 11
Upon information and belief, Defendant has made and will continue to make
substantial profits and gains to which they are not entitled in law or equity.
51.
Upon information and belief, Defendant intends to continue its infringing acts,
As a result of Defendants actions, Radio One has suffered irreparable harm to its
valuable trademarks and the goodwill associated therewith and has no adequate remedy at law.
Radio One has been, and, unless Defendant is preliminarily and permanently restrained from its
actions, will continue to be, irreparably harmed.
53.
As a direct and proximate result of Defendants conduct, Radio One has suffered,
The conduct of Defendant, as described herein, was, and is, being undertaken
maliciously, fraudulently, deliberately, and willfully, and with knowledge of the BOOM Marks
owned by Radio One. As a result, this is an exceptional case within the meaning of Section
35(a) of the Lanham Act, 15 U.S.C. 1117(a), entitling Radio One to recover its reasonable
attorneys fees.
COUNT III: COMMON-LAW UNFAIR COMPETITION
55.
Count by reference.
56.
Tennessee.
57.
By reason of Defendants actions, Radio One has suffered irreparable harm to its
valuable trademarks and the goodwill associated therewith. Radio One has been and, unless
11
PageID 12
Defendant is preliminarily and permanently restrained from its actions, will continue to be
irreparably harmed.
58.
As a direct and proximate result of Defendants conduct, Radio One has suffered
WHEREFORE, Radio One respectfully requests prays for the following relief:
1.
A finding that: Defendant has violated Section 32 of the Lanham Act (15 U.S.C.
1114), Section 43(a) of the Lanham Act (15 U.S.C. 1125(a)), and has engaged in unfair
competition under the common law of Tennessee;
2.
U.S.C. 1116, preliminarily and permanently restraining and enjoining Defendant, its officers,
agents, employees, and attorneys, and all those persons or entities in active concert or
participation with them from:
a. manufacturing, importing, advertising, marketing, promoting, supplying,
distributing, offering for sale, or selling any products or services which bear the BOOM
Marks, or any other mark or design element substantially similar or confusing thereto,
including, without limitation, the infringing products and services, and engaging in any
other activity constituting an infringement of any of Radio Ones rights in its trademarks;
and
b. engaging in any other activity constituting unfair competition with Radio One,
or acts and practices that deceive consumers, the public, and/or trade, including without
limitation, the use of designations and design elements associated with Radio One; and
12
3.
PageID 13
An order requiring Defendant to recall from distribution and for the destruction or
other disposition of all remaining inventory of all infringing products, including all
advertisements, promotional and marketing materials therefore, as well as means of making
same;
4.
An order requiring Defendant to file with this Court and serve on Radio One
within thirty (30) days after entry of the injunction a report in writing under oath setting forth in
detail the manner and form in which Defendant has complied with the injunction;
5.
An order directing such other relief as the Court may deem appropriate to prevent
consumers, the public, and/or the trade from deriving any erroneous impression that any product
or service at issue in this action that has been manufactured, imported, advertised, marketed,
promoted, supplied, distributed, offered for sale, or sold by Defendant, has been authorized by
Radio One, or is related in any way with Radio One and/or its products and services;
6.
An order directing Defendant to disgorge all profits and other gains obtained as a
An order to Defendant to pay to Radio One all actual damages Radio One has
9.
law;
provided by law;
10.
An order that this is an exceptional case under 15 U.S.C. 1117(a) and awarding
Radio One its costs and reasonable attorneys fees and any applicable pre- and post-judgment
interest; and
13
11.
PageID 14
An award to Radio One of any such additional and further relief as the Court
14
PageID 15