Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
Feasibility Study
Authors:
Prof. Ing. Jozef Gnap, PhD., Prof. Ing. Marin ulgan, PhD.,
Prof. Ing. Jozef Majerk, prof. Ing. Libor Ivolt, PhD.,
Doc. Ing. Jozef Gapark, PhD.,
Ing. Juraj Jagelk, PhD. , Ing. Jn Libetin, PhD.
www.chemlog.info
FEASIBILITY STUDY
FEASIBILITY STUDY
Development of railway transport of chemicals in
Slovakia in relation to adjacent countries and prepared
combined transport terminals
CHEMLOG PROJECT PARTNER
ZVZ CHEMICKHO A FARMACEUTICKHO PRIEMYSLU SLOVENSKEJ REPUBLIKY
ASSOCIATION OF CHEMICAL AND PHARMACEUTICAL INDUSTRY OF THE SLOVAK REPUBLIC
PREPARED BY:
Prof. Ing. Jozef Gnap, PhD., Prof. Ing. Marin ulgan, PhD., Prof. Ing. Jozef Majerk, PhD.,
prof. Ing. Libor Ivolt, PhD., Doc. Ing. Jozef Gapark, PhD.,
Ing. Juraj Jagelk, PhD. , Ing. Jn Libetin, PhD.
University od ilina, Faculty of Operation and Economics of Transport and Communications
October 2010
Association of chemical and pharmaceutical industry of the Slovak republic, University of ilina, 2010
FEASIBILITY STUDY
Content
Introduction ................................................................................................... 6
1.
Chemical industry in Slovakia and international trade ...................... 6
1.1.
2.
2.1.
3.
4.
4.1.
4.2.
4.3.
4.4.
5.
5.1.
5.2.
5.3.
5.4.
FEASIBILITY STUDY
6.
6.1.
6.2.
7.
8.
8.1.
8.2.
9.
Feasibility of selected projects and measures ..................................83
Literature......................................................................................................87
List of abreviations ........................................................................................89
Annex of the study on CD ..............................................................................90
FEASIBILITY STUDY
Introduction
Within the frame of doing SWOT analysis of transporting chemicals in Slovakia, there were
formulated problems relating to transport logistic, in the project ChemLog:
This created conditions for rail and intermodal transport of chemicals. Therefore, the study of
viability is focused on Development of railway transport of chemicals in Slovakia in relation to
adjacent countries and prepared combined transport terminals1.
1.
Chemical industry is mainly located in Western Slovakia around Bratislava. This industry was built as
a part of eastern chemical industry based on Russian supplies. Big chemical companies use supplies
carried via pipeline network of crude petroleum Druba and natural gas. Small companies usually use
supplies of raw material from Europe.
The area of basic chemicals is represented by the companies as Slovnaft Bratislava, Duslo aa,
Novcke chemick zvody and Chemko Strske.
In Bratislava as a business centre of Slovakia there are several chemical companies as refinery
Slovnaft and Duslo Istrochem.
Several companies e.g. Duslo a.s. aa, Chemolak Smolenice, Zentiva Hlohovec, Slovkord Senica are
located in western Slovakia.
Middle part of Slovakia is represented by NCHZ Novky, Petrochema Dubov, Chemosvit Flie Svit,
Matador Continental Pchov.
1
Given the well-established terminology of Ministry of Transport, Construction and Regional Development of the
Slovak Republic, in the next part oft he study, we will use the term intermodal transport.
FEASIBILITY STUDY
Eastern part of Slovakia is represented by Chemko Strske, Chemes Humen, Diakol Stske, Duslo
Hnojiv Strske.
The area of waste processing is represented by Detox Bansk Bystrica, MACH trade Sere and Sita
Slovensko. Paints, varnishes and similar coatings are represented by Chemolak Smolenice, SlovZink
Koeca, Farbol Bratislava, EuroVat Alekince, Primalex Slovakia Doln Kubn, Pam-ak Chorvtsky
Grob, Inex Bratislava. Primalex Slovakia, Novochema Levice,
Pharmaceutical industry is represented by Zentiva Hlohovec and Degussa Slovakia Slovensk upa.
The biggest Slovak pharmaceutical producer - Zentiva Hlohovec is the part of the corporation Zentiva.
The biggest chemical company in Slovakia is refinery SLOVNAFT, a.s. located in Bratislava. The
company core business is production, warehousing, wholesale and retail sales and distribution.
SLOVNAFT Plc. dispose with the largest retail network in SK offering top quality motor fuels and
lubricants as well as related customer services.
After intensive modernisation is these refinery very flexible and one of the tree most modern
refineries in Europe.
Installed conversion processes and high-density deep desulfurization allow produce of only sulphurfree fuels.
Duslo a.s. aa is oriented on processing of natural gas to ammonia, urea, fertilizer based on
ammonium nitrate and other inorganic nitrogen products. Within organic chemistry there are rubber
industry chemicals, glues, agrochemicals, glues, dispersions, polypropylene fibres. Duslo as a part of
AGROFERT Holding is a part of the second biggest producer and distributor of fertilizers. In Bratislava,
there is located former company Istrochem, which is now fully integrated into the organizational
structure of Duslo a.s. This company produces rubber additives and agrochemicals. In the area of the
former company Istrochem is located branch office of the company Explozia Pardubice (continuator
of the Alfred Nobel tradition) as producer industrial explosives.
NCHZ Novky are focused on processing industrial salt by electrolysis to products of inorganic
chemistry (chlorine, sodium hydroxide, hydrogen, hydrochloric acid). In the field of inorganic
chemistry, NCHZ Novky are the most important exporter of the calcium carbide, next in the field of
organic chemistry, they produce PVC and PVC products (window profile, siding, granulation products)
and also some products of organic chemistry and polyols.
Chemko is located in Strske and in it`s area there are located several companies - Chemza, Diakol,
Duslo Hnojiv. Distribution of chemicals represent Brenttag Slovakia, BASF Slovensko, Messer
Tatragas, SIAD Slovensko, Safina Slovensko.
The start of the Millennium has brought new challenges as significant increase in competition from
Asia, strong globalization trends, strengthening of the Slovak crown course, strong growth of the
Slovak automotive and electronics industries, thanks to the state support too. Production volume of
chemical industry compared to named fields did not increase a lot, so the proportion of chemical and
pharmaceutical industry decreased from 17,2 % in 2000 to 15 % of Slovak industry turnover in 2006.
Similarly, the number of workers dropped from 18 791 to 11 573 in years 2000-2006 in the field of
FEASIBILITY STUDY
chemicals and chemical products production. Share of export dropped from 26,7 % in 2000 to 23,1 %
in 2006.
At present, the chemical industry tries to keep its position in intensification international
competition, strict chemical legislation and total despite of the public to chemistry.
Actual crisis threatens chemical industry by decrease in sales and drop in prices of products.
Chemical industry is developing as a supplier of plastics and rubber products for the evolving
branches of automotive and building industry.
Fig. 1
1.1.
International trade
The data for international trade are available in Slovakia only according to TARIC. Following TARIC
chapters are presented for chemical industry.
FEASIBILITY STUDY
Chapter
Name
27
MINERAL FUELS, MINERAL OILS AND PRODUCTS OF THEIR DISTILLATION; BITUMINOUS SUBSTANCES; MINERAL WAXES
28
INORGANIC CHEMICALS; ORGANIC OR INORGANIC COMPOUNDS OF PRECIOUS METALS, OF RARE-EARTH METALS, OF RADIOACTIVE
ELEMENTS OR OF ISOTOPES
29
ORGANIC CHEMICALS
30
PHARMACEUTICAL PRODUCTS
31
FERTILISERS
32
TANNING OR DYEING EXTRACTS; TANNINS AND THEIR DERIVATIVES; DYES, PIGMENTS AND OTHER COLOURING MATTER; PAINTS
AND VARNISHES; PUTTY AND OTHER MASTICS; INKS
33
34
SOAP, ORGANIC SURFACE-ACTIVE AGENTS, WASHING PREPARATIONS, LUBRICATING PREPARATIONS, ARTIFICIAL WAXES, PREPARED
WAXES, POLISHING OR SCOURING PREPARATIONS, CANDLES AND SIMILAR ARTICLES, MODELLING PASTES, DENTAL WAXES AND
DENTAL PREPARATIONS WITH A BASIS OF PLASTER
35
36
37
38
39
40
54
55
FEASIBILITY STUDY
Tab. 1
Export quota in %
5,49
5,53
5,15
4,07
3,98
3,93
3,93
2,93
2,65
4,46
4,59
4,83
4,68
4,72
4,99
5,20
4,50
3,66
10
FEASIBILITY STUDY
Tab. 2
Export quota in %
2000
2001
2002
2003
2004
2005
2006 2007
6,63%
6,41%
6,18%
4,50%
4,54%
4,60%
4,28%
N/A
5,39%
5,32%
5,80%
5,18%
5,38%
5,84%
5,66%
N/A
TARIC
2000
2001
2002
2003
2004
27
3432,9
3607,4
3328,8
3302,8
3940,5
28,29
601,6
608,1
583,1
552,7
623,8
31
28,2
33,4
32,1
26,3
39,5
32
176,1
194,5
208,8
222,8
249,9
30
532,5
627,2
709,4
709,3
895,4
33,34
190,7
231,2
250,4
250,8
291,5
35,36,37,38
292,5
356,0
395,3
362,1
386,4
54,55
223,1
265,8
270,0
262,6
255,8
2838,54,55
2044,6
2316,1
2449,1
2386,6
2742,1
40
283,0
331,8
417,8
557,3
585,8
39
734,8
39,40
11
FEASIBILITY STUDY
2005
2006
2007
2008
4664,0
5882,2
5350,9
6535,8
28,29
715,4
809,7
773,7
742,4
31
39,3
54,6
78,9
140,6
32
269,9
330,8
330,5
316,3
30
985,9
1074,1
1147,7
1236,0
33,34
319,3
335,2
362,5
370,6
35,36,37,38
422,9
462,0
532,8
530,2
54,55
248,6
260,0
241,0
195,6
28-38,54,55
3001,3
3326,4
3467,1
3531,7
40
615,5
744,8
837,4
847,0
39
1498,4
1814,3
1942,9
2005,0
39,40
2113,9
2559,2
2780,4
2852,1
TARIC
27
Source: Statistical office of the Slovak Republic Data for 2007, 2008 are preliminary data
Fig. 4
FEASIBILITY STUDY
The continuous increase of import of chemical to Slovakia from 2000 is notable. The development of
the industry requires more chemical imports. Basic chemicals and pharmaceuticals have the highest
share.
IMPORT - Manufacture of plastic and rubber products
3 000,0
2 500,0
Mil. EUR
2 000,0
1 500,0
1 000,0
500,0
0,0
2000
2001
2002
2003
Fig. 5
2004
2005
2006
2007
2008
There is a continuous increase of especially plastic products import in this segment. Because of
development of automotive industry in recent years, there is a need for more imports of plastics.
TARIC
2000
2001
2002
2003
2004
27
1273,9
1336,6
1311,6
1381,8
1910,5
28,29
526,8
526,5
521,9
426,9
465,9
31
88,1
107,9
91,8
97,8
124,9
32
15,9
17,3
13,5
12,5
14,5
30
114,4
141,7
150,3
143,2
178,0
33,34
74,8
89,4
91,8
84,6
86,6
35,36,37,38 97,6
117,2
161,2
142,9
150,3
54,55
300,2
308,0
292,5
332,5
290,5
13
FEASIBILITY STUDY
TARIC
2000
2001
2002
2003
2004
2838,54,55
1208,1
1300,2
1338,5
1200,5
1352,7
40
333,1
434,3
559,3
653,2
755,6
39
648,0
644,4
695,7
728,2
847,9
981,1
1078,8
1255,0
1381,5
1603,5
TARIC
2005
2006
2007
2008
27
2236,6
2408,1
2301,7
2589,1
28,29
515,1
542,7
513,2
524,9
31
126,7
132,9
138,4
201,9
32
25,3
151,7
77,8
66,4
30
245,1
261,6
247,5
265,2
33,34
100,0
113,2
118,9
186,1
35,36,37,38
177,0
202,1
203,0
217,2
54,55
324,2
345,5
308,7
258,2
28-38,54,55
1513,4
1749,7
1607,5
1719,8
40
850,4
924,8
933,3
945,3
39
1070,1
1389,6
1530,9
1425,2
39,40
1920,5
2314,4
2464,2
2370,5
Source: Statistical office of the Slovak Republic Data for 2007, 2008 are preliminary data
14
FEASIBILITY STUDY
Fig. 7
There is an increasing trend with a slight decrease in 2008 in this sector. The most dominating share
has manufacture of plastic products.
15
FEASIBILITY STUDY
EU 15
Estonia, Latvia,
Lithuania, Malta,
Poland, Slovenia,
Czech Republic,
Hungary, Cyprus
2000
2001
2002
2003
2004
2005
2006
2007
2008
Bulgaria, Romania
2,51
2,56
2,70
2,70
2,74
3,01
2,72
2,89
2,86
Rest of Europe
5,37
5,30
5,08
4,92
5,93
6,75
7,12
7,44
7,51
2,92
2,31
1,92
1,83
2,10
1,97
1,24
0,87
0,66
0,38
0,32
0,25
0,20
0,29
0,34
0,33
0,33
0,42
Asia
3,40
3,48
3,09
2,79
2,74
3,39
3,10
2,08
2,11
Africa
0,29
0,35
0,56
0,38
0,45
0,48
0,52
0,56
0,63
Australia / Oceania
0,22 0,15 0,15 0,19 0,14 0,13 0,05 0,05 0,05
Source: Statistical office of the Slovak Republic Data for 2007, 2008 are preliminary data.
Geografic breakdown of chemicals export is for TARIC codes 28-40, 54-55
Fig. 8
More than 90 % of all export of chemicals is to European countries with more than 40 % to EU 15.
16
FEASIBILITY STUDY
2000
EU 27
EU 15
2001
2002
2003
2004
2005
2006
2007
2008
0,32
0,21
0,27
0,25
0,40
0,32
0,31
0,37
0,40
Rest of Europe
7,04
7,01
6,42
5,82
5,67
5,56
6,22
6,37
6,35
2,79
2,80
3,00
2,63
2,47
2,09
1,97
1,86
1,99
0,22
0,17
0,17
0,52
0,94
0,98
1,05
1,01
1,03
Asia
4,81
5,10
5,76
5,82
6,56
5,98
7,16
8,12
8,48
Africa
0,08
0,09
0,11
0,11
0,13
0,15
0,17
0,11
0,16
Australia / Oceania
Fig. 9
About 90 % of all imported chemicals are from European countries with about 60 % from EU 15.
The above analysis shows, that there are sources of transportation for the application of intermodal
rail transport of chemicals from Slovakia to Europe and conversely.
17
FEASIBILITY STUDY
Because of this volume of chemicals export and import listed above, it is clear, that the basic
transport infrastructure can not be built just for chemical industry. On the opposite site, the
transportation of chemicals is very important and because of road transport restrictions on
chemicals, railway and intermodal transport can be alternative to road transport.
2.
By now, there has not been established the classification of tunnels according to ADR in Slovakia (the
transport of dangerous goods is banned in all tunnels) and new bans are introduced in transporting
of dangerous goods on the important international transit roads, what have the impact to reducing
the safety and efficiency of transporting dangerous goods in road freight transport.
Below road traffic bans for transport of dangerous goods in Slovakia, also on the main motorway
network. These prohibitions in road freight transport create the opportunities for the development
of intermodal transport of dangerous goods in Slovakia.
Slovak Road Administration, Department Road Databank, focuses also on variable and non-variable
parameters of road communications.
Road Databank department collects data by track-measuring cars, all kinds of traffic signs but
because of their large number, the collection is realized according to certain rules.
There are only 49 traffic signs B21 a B22 (January 15, 2010) in database of Slovak Road
Administration (see Fig. 11). They are collected only on the new build road network sections, where
measurements were carry out over the last months
Fig. 10 Traffic signs B21 and B22 on the Slovak road network (Source: Road Databank of Slovak
Road Administration)
18
FEASIBILITY STUDY
Following figures show more detailed maps of bans for transport of dangerous goods in selection
sections of Slovakia road network.
Fig. 11 Traffic signs B21 and B22 in the area of Bratislava (D1, D2 Sitina Tunnel and motorway
connection to Austria) and the area of Pieany (no entry to D1 and alternative route through the
Pieany city)
19
FEASIBILITY STUDY
Fig. 12 Total bans for transport of dangerous goods through the Branisko tunnel and alternative
routes over Branisko mountain range.
2.1.
By now, there has not been established the classification of tunnels according to ADR in Slovakia. At
present, the transport of dangerous goods is banned in all tunnels in Slovakia (including vehicles
carrying empty not cleaned packages and tanks). Classification of tunnels is prepared according to
ADR.
Building motorways through the north part of Middle Slovakia is technically and financially very
difficult. It is needed to build many bridges and road tunnels in this area. Figure 14 show the planned
location of road tunnels in Slovakia. Operated tunnels are Sitina, Horelica, Brik and Branisko (black
colour). Branisko tunnel is the longest tunnel (4975 m) at present. Oviarsko, Poana and Viove
tunnels are under construction (red colour). When Viove tunnel is in operation, it will be the
longest tunnel in Slovakia with a length of 7460 m. By gradual construction of motorway D1 between
Bratislava and Koice, planned motorway D3 from ilina to Warsaw and Bratislava bypass, it should
be constructed another 15 road tunnels.
20
FEASIBILITY STUDY
FEASIBILITY STUDY
3.
In regard of the scope of the feasibility study for development of intermodal transport of chemicals,
we had to analyse intermodal transport equipments for chemical industry.
In practice, we recognize a number of loading units3 for cargo transport, the chemical industry
including. Transportation of chemicals can be divided as follows:
Chemicals can be classified as safe and dangerous cargo. Method of transport unit selection depends
on this basis. The cargo can be divided into general cargo and bulk cargo in solid, liquid and gaseous
state. The selection of the adequate transport unit for intermodal transport is based on the kind of
cargo.
According to the regulations for the transport of dangerous goods, this transport can be divided into
transportation:
General cargo (packages, IBC containers, large packages)
o By Open-top vehicles, wagons, containers and swap bodies
o By closed vehicles, wagons and containers
o Sheeted vehicles, wagons and containers
Bulk cargo
In tanks
o Road tankers, tank wagons
3
In practice, it is using the concept: intermodal transport unit, the loading unit of intermodal transport.
22
FEASIBILITY STUDY
o
o
o
o
o
o
Demountable tanks
Battery vehicles
MEGC - Multiple-Element Gas Container
Tank containers
Portable tanks (IMDG, ADR, RID)
Tank swap bodies
FEASIBILITY STUDY
Large container can be used for transportation only if it was structurally serviceable.
In the case of transport of dangerous goods in road tanker, tank wagon and portable tanks, the
deciding thing for the correct choice of transport unit is the code of the tank according to ADR, RID or
the code of the portable tank according to IMDG, ADR, RID and chemical compatibility of the tank
material with transported substance.
ADR, RID, IMDG definitive also a hierarchy of tanks, i.e. there can be transported the substance with
its code with substance with lower code in hierarchy in one tank, if it is in regard to chemical
compatibility.
Class
6.2 8
9 Grand total
Code of tank
L1.5BN
K
L4BH
43
L4BN
65
43
82
276 2
15
2 362
202 1 283
LGAV
1
Kd cisterny
LGBF
330
2 3
330
LGBV
14
Grand total
522 3
29
2 20
276 2
202 7 1041
from1328liquids
Fig. 14 Container EMT5 ADR/RID - L4BH - 37 000 L in stainless boiler design it can be
transported 78 % liquids according to ADR/RID, where the transport of liquids is allowed
Fig. 15 22T6 ADR/RID/IMDG portable tanks UN T22 for dangerous liquid 17 500 l for
substances with instructions T1 to T22
24
FEASIBILITY STUDY
Fig. 16 22T9 portable tank for not chilling liquefied gases UN T50 with sun protection 24 000 l 68 substances in class 2
Tab. 7 Number of dangerous substances which are suitable for transportation in type approved
vehicles for transport in tanks according to ADR agreement
Vehicle/ Classes of dangerous
AT
EX/III
FL
373
375
97
77
55
229
558
12
572
4.1
62
68
130
4.2
82
23
105
4.3
85
31
126
5.1
144
21
167
5.2
16
20
6.1
592
707
6.2
10
22
25
325
11
367
16
23
39
Grand total
1415
671
2872
10
2
106
31
782
25
FEASIBILITY STUDY
Tank containers and portable tanks owned by carrier hauliers or hired in abroad are using in practice.
Some road carrier hauliers use portable tanks instead of road tanker. For overseas transportations,
producers of chemicals and forwarding companies use hired tank containers from their owners
respectively landlords. Rental price for tank container is from 7 to 15 per day4.
Standard ISO shipping containers are held by marine carriers and can be used mainly for maritime
transport.
Inland containers park with doors on the side of the SKDS Intrans period has tumbled-down and
now they are not available. They are available in abroad to a lesser degree (eg MSC).
There are a very few swap bodies in Slovakia, same as manipulable road trailers.
There are many reasons and they can be summarized as follows. Not all intermodal terminals are
equipped with technical equipments for handling of swap bodies and manipulable road trailers, i.e.
pairs of tongs, which are assembling as a folding fitted in the most modern execution to the
spreader. So comes into existence the universal container hanging frame for all known and
standardized intermodal loading units. According to the surveys and ascertaining of the Ministry of
transport, posts and telecommunications of the Slovak Republic, from the November 1, 2010
Ministry of Transport, Construction and Regional Development of the Slovak Republic, the existing
operators of containers terminals privatized in the 90`s and intermodal terminals, that has been built
later from private sources are aimed at so-called hinterland port service, it means overseas
intermodal transport realized only in containers according to ISO. According to surveys, these
terminal operators do not think about the introduction of continental intermodal transport that is
usually realized in swap bodies or manipulable road trailers. Exceptions are only tank containers,
which are used in overseas as well as in continental intermodal transport. It implies the recognition,
that there is minimal interest in continental intermodal transport at present. Continental intermodal
transport is much extended in Western Europe, especially in chemical industry and already, there is a
pressure from forwarders to implement this kind of transport to Central and Southeast Europe and it
will rise.
Owners of swap bodies or manipulable road trailers are forwarding companies and carrier hauliers,
which realize continental intermodal transport. There is a major producer of swap bodies KEREX
Michalovce in Slovakia, but these the most exported. Important producer of wagons for intermodal
transport is TatraVagnka Poprad. Based on the recorded information from the producer of trailers,
the different between the price of platform trailer and trailer designed for vertical reloading is
approximately 2000 .
Tankcontainers for chemical industry can carry several types of chemical products, but there are also
specialized tankcontainers, which can carry only one product.
Source: Podstawka,V.: Tankkontejner: Prostedek pro vce druh peprav. In: Nebezpen nklad 5/2010,
str.10-12, ISSN 1803-1579
26
FEASIBILITY STUDY
Bogies for tank containers and portable tanks are usually design for 20` and 30` dimensions and they
are shorter than for 40` containers, and it can be saved about 1 ton from 44 tons of total weight of
road train and it can be very interesting. There is a problem in Slovakia because of the legislation5,
which determines the maximum permissible weight of vehicles and road trains and it says about total
weights 44 tones of road train for transporting ISO container (40 feet) in intermodal transport. In
preparation of this legislation we sent the comments to creators on this formulation, where we were
reminded the issue of higher total weight also for 20`and 30`containers, but our comments weren`t
incorporated. The legislative Council of the Government did not pass the proposal of the
Government about allowance of the total weight not only for transport of tank containers, but also
for manipulable road trailers in the territory of Slovakia. European Union allows exceptions like this
for the territory of Member states and for Member states is this ability for intermodal transport
sufficient, because it is sufficient for collection or distribution to the nearest appropriate intermodal
terminal.
Nariadenie vldy 349/2009 Z.z. o najvch prpustnch rozmeroch vozidiel a jazdnch sprav, najvch
prpustnch hmotnostiach vozidiel a jazdnch sprav, alch technickch poiadavkch na vozidl a jazdn
spravy v svislosti s hmotnosami a rozmermi a o oznaovan vozidiel a jazdnch sprav (Government
Regulation No. 349/2009 about the largest allowable dimensions of vehicles and road trains, the largest
weights of vehicles and road trains, other technical requirements for vehicles and road trains in relation to
weights and dimensions and about marking of vehicles and road trains.
27
FEASIBILITY STUDY
market collapse in countries of the Council for Mutual Economic Assistance (CMEA),
formation of the Slovak Republic
changes in regulations of a market economy
Between years 1991 1994 there was a decrease in intermodal transport, but since 1995 volume of
the intermodal transport has grown up. In 1994 the share of intermodal transport in total railway
transportation increased to the 0,33 % and in 2002 to 1,53 %. In this year, there has been
transported 756 300 tons in intermodal transport. From 1993 to 2006 intermodal transport in
Slovakia developed with 16 % of annual increment. Big share of the intermodal transport had transit
transport and its share in total volume of transportation has still declined and it has come up to
Slovak import and export. In 2006 the growth of intermodal transport slowed down and in 2007 it
increased about 12 %, what was due to the start of production in KIA MOTORS in Teplika nad
Vhom, the start of the terminal operation in Dunajsk Streda and expansion of container terminal in
ilina.
The following table shows the volumes of the transported goods in intermodal transport in 2009.
Fig. 17 Volume of transported goods to the year 2009 [Source: Ministry of Transport, Construction
and Regional Development of the Slovak Republic]
28
FEASIBILITY STUDY
29
FEASIBILITY STUDY
With exception of the intermodal terminals in Dunajsk Streda and Dobr, the location of all other
intermodal terminals are not suitable for next widening to be according to AGTC, especially track
length, capacity and layout of areas and connection to the major rail and road network. All the
existing intermodal terminals do not verify non-discriminatory demand of access to terminal services,
i.e. openness and trade neutrality (all of them are owned by private operators, who realize here
especially their own commercial activities and activities for their needs).
FEASIBILITY STUDY
Battioni e Pagani with load capacity of 35 tons. Intermodal terminal is suitable for transhipment,
storage, marking of chemicals and dangerous substances (in tank containers, respectively tank swap
bodies and trailers). There are connections to thermal containers in terminal. Terminal is enclosure
and guarded by SBS. From terminal, container trains lead to Koper, with transhipment via Prague to
Hamburg, Bremerhaven and Rotterdam.
FEASIBILITY STUDY
(motorways D1 and D2). Operator of this terminal is Maersk. Total area of the terminal is 15 000 m2,
the storage area is 12 700 m2. It has three transhipment tracks with a useful length of 250 m. The
terminal is equipped with two gantry cranes KSB with load capacity of 32 and 20 tons and with three
crane lifts with a boom LUNA with load capacity of 40, 40 and 42 tons. There can be transhipment
only large containers (including thermal and tank containers) in the terminal. From the terminal are
dispatched complete container trains on relation Bratislava Melnik Bremerhaven.
Next expansion of the terminal is not possible because of geographic terms.
FEASIBILITY STUDY
Certificate (authorized economic operator), whose main advantages are simplified and accelerated in
customs procedure.
33
FEASIBILITY STUDY
34
FEASIBILITY STUDY
35
FEASIBILITY STUDY
Fig. 28 Overhead container crane in intermodal terminal Sldkoviovo (source: Green Integrated
Logistics)
36
FEASIBILITY STUDY
Tons
802 178
221 980
133 900
196 225
12 835
59 887
13 044
1 440 049
ITU
64 847
22 040
6 905
16 600
1 406
2 114
282
114 194
Ruomberok Liskov
37
FEASIBILITY STUDY
38
FEASIBILITY STUDY
Fig. 31 Unloading of road trains at the railway station Trsten (source: authors)
4.2.9.4 Intermodal terminal ierna nad Tisou
Intermodal terminal was situated at premises of railway station in ierna nad Tisou. Because of the
lack of load and existing of nearly new modern terminal in Dobr, terminal in ierna nad Tisou was
cancelled. At present, handling area of the former terminal and gantry overhead track crane are used
for transhipment of steel products.
39
FEASIBILITY STUDY
Fig. 32 Intermodal terminals relation to road and rail network in Slovakia and selected companies
of chemical industry
40
FEASIBILITY STUDY
41
FEASIBILITY STUDY
Road to ensure mutual access to mobile front ramps for loading and unloading of
road trains transported under the RO-LA system
Entrance and exit group of tracks with one track for RO-LA transport
Handling tracks of terminal
Terminal
Road for circumvention of the terminal
Reserve space for future storage and handling areas for spoil-tit
Intermodal terminal ilina will be a powerful terminal with a big capacity and it will performe a
function of terminal in connection to logistic centres and because of that, there are designed
equipments and technology below:
FEASIBILITY STUDY
Logistics services
Advisory and information services
In the time of the anticipated starting-up operation of the terminal (it is expected earliest in 2012), in
the first year of terminal operation, transport flow inbound to the attraction circuit should achieve
around 200 000 tons of goods for intermodal transport and transport flow outbound from attraction
circuit around 300 000 tons (without volumes of goods from KIA Motors). In routine operation, it can
be expected gradual growing of the volume of transported goods. This implies the need for
intermodal transportation around 500 000 tons per year of goods in the region. This volume of good
represent around 30 000 ITU per year, if there are 16,5 tons in one ITU. The total number of ITU in
the crane radius is 3598 TEU. The total number of empty ITU in the storage area is 1998 TEU. There
are 33 lay-bys for swap bodies in terminal. The area of stored ITU in the crane radius is 31 587 m2.
The area of empty stored ITU is 23 817 m2. Length of the crane track is same for both cranes - 750 m,
so it is possible to serve whole train without sliding. Minimal length of the tracks under the crane
must be 750 m, according to AGTC. In the interest of using crane track, all designed handling tracks
are longer than 750 m.
Prochc E.: Terminal of intermodal transport ilina, Conference Infrastructure of intermodal transport
www.intermodal.sk
43
FEASIBILITY STUDY
Terminal rail yard will be connected to general track gauge through the Interport private siding tracks
to ST Vek Ida. Connected to broad track gauge is proposed through the U.S. Steel Koice (USSK)
private siding tracks to Haniska pri Koiciach broad track gauge railway station. But the location of
intermodal terminal complex Koice in presented area does not allow independent and unconditional
connection to rail infrastructure. Location with a large number of lands in private ownership expects
difficult and long solutions in property composition. To satisfy above requirements, it was verified
alternative terminal location with direct rail connection to SR infrastructure. The new terminal
location is proposed near the original location, between the SR track line (track line Zvolen Koice)
and rail yard USSK (rail yard CPR). Connection to the general track gauge railway line is planned by
construction of new station of Hutnky railway station. Connection to the existing broad track gauge
railway line is planned by the self-connecting track from Haniska railway station near Koice broad
track gauge.
Technical parameters of terminal:
Number of handling tracks (4) 2 tracks with general track gauge, 1 track with broad track
gauge, 1 X HK ((RoLa general track gauge, broad track gauge)
Length of tracks 750 m in the gantry crane radius
Handling equipments 2 gantry cranes (load of 45 tons), 1 mobile reach stacker (15 tons) for
empty loading units
Stacking 4 layers
Containers 2 rows in span + overhang, 378 positions (ISO1A), 252 positions (ISO1C)
Swap bodies 3 rows in span + overhang, 101 (SAL), 235 (WAB)
Trailers 28 positions with recommendation of sitting under the overhang of gantry crane
Parking places 280 vehicles per day, 56 in rush hours 45 places/entrance, 30 places/ exit
2 inside-areal traffic lanes, 2 handling traffic lanes
Gate a part of object of administrative and operational building (dispatching, forwarding,
customs, banking, food services)
44
FEASIBILITY STUDY
45
FEASIBILITY STUDY
Buovsk, J.: Terminal of intermodal transport Bratislava, Conference Infrastructure of intermodal transport
www.intermodal.sk
46
FEASIBILITY STUDY
Galanta on the both ends of terminal, in the direction to Siladice by construction of individual track
to the railway station Siladice or with direct connection from open track line in self station. There
should be placed 4 handling tracks under cranes in terminal with direct length of 750 m and in the
direct impact of gantry cranes. One of these tracks should be designed for RO-LA transport.
Road transport in intermodal terminal area will be provided by new road network of inside-area
service communications, which road load will be constructed for road trains with total weights of 44
tons. Layout of local roads and design of their routing must be based on future transport
organization in intermodal terminal. Intermodal terminals will be connected with existing road
network road II/513 by crossroad.
47
FEASIBILITY STUDY
4.4. Multimodal transport corridors and their impact on the solved issue
Continually change of the political orientation of central and eastern states in Europe evocated
demand on extension and linking of the transport infrastructure towards these countries for purpose
of producing uniform Pan-European transport network.
Common mission of countries in Western, Central and Eastern Europe is to ensure trade exchange
and economic development with respect of democratic values and social standards of national
cultures. With this intent European Commission developed transport line conception corridor
conception linking Western Europe with Eastern on the multimodal base. In this study, we dealt
with the amount of the European transport corridors, which pass Slovakia. Detailed analysis of
multimodal corridors is defined in Annex no. 1 of this study.
Under the new Regulation (EU) No 913/2010 of the European Parliament and of the Council of 22
September 2010 concerning a European rail network for competitive freight member states of
European Union have to take into account the new legislation, which establishes international rail
freight corridors and strong preference for freight transport on these corridors.
Provisions which were in contrary to this regulation, must be revised by European Union member
states. New European Regulation helps to create rail freight corridors and its purpose is to improve
interstate freight transport.
For every rail corridor should be created separate management structure, respectively corridor
management. It should consist of several agencies (Executive board, Administration board), in which
would be represented particular countries. Administration board establishes the procedure for
handling requirements for international railway lines. For handling requests about railway lines is
necessary to establish so-called One Stop Shop for every corridor, which processes and allocates
requirements for railway lines and its decision sent to the national place for railway lines allocation.
It also defined the proceeding for operation management in corridor in the case of disturbances or
disruption. Regulation also recommends to infrastructure managers to impose sanctions to rail
companies for booked but not used railway lines, i.e. cancellation reservation. In the case of disputes
decides National regulatory agency to which is prescribed international cooperation.
Executive board provides the volume of freight transport. It means in practice partial withdrawal of
infrastructure control by its national operator.
There is a supposition in the regulation, that international good-trains will have a priority in defined
corridors in allocation of routes, what can affect passenger regional and long-distance transport.
Some member states are concerned that this Regulation will have a bad affect to passenger
transport. But the there is pointed the fact in the regulation that passenger transport must be
reflected.
In regulation were approved following freight corridors (including date of the latest establishment):
1. Rotterdam/Zeebrugge Antwerp Duisburg Basel Milan Genova (established to 10
november 2013)
2. Rotterdam Antwerp Luxembourg Metz Dijon Lyon/Basel (established to 10
november 2013)
48
FEASIBILITY STUDY
49
FEASIBILITY STUDY
50
FEASIBILITY STUDY
51
FEASIBILITY STUDY
Fig. 39 Transhipment facility, there is broad track gauge in the foreground and general track gauge
in the background with attached tanks
52
FEASIBILITY STUDY
53
FEASIBILITY STUDY
FEASIBILITY STUDY
capacity of 10 000 m2, builds a fuel station and washing machine of road vehicles. The importance of
the terminal should increase by the construction and opening of new border crossing with Ukraine
and new road links with Hungary.
First integrated trains, that passed through the terminal Dobr in renting by the TransContainer,
were loaded with components of computers and later with magnesite and talc, which went to Poland
and Austria. Currently, the terminal operator managed to provide relatively regular transportations
from Pescara (Italy) to Tichonov (Russian Federation). There are carrying 40-feet HC containers with
spare parts for cars of brand Fiat in the trains. These transportations are realized in two pairs of
trains a week. By the beginning of September 2010 were transported 23 of integrated trains with
empty containers from terminal Dobr to Pescara and 22 of integrated trains with loaded containers
from Pescara to the terminal Dobr and then to the Tichonov.
Companies Intercontainer Austria, TransContainer, Far East Landbridge and Hungaria Intermodal
operate a train connection Vladislav Container Shuttle with connections Vienna - Budapest BILK,
Budapest BILK - Dobr and Dobr - Moscow with the coverage of Germany, Switzerland, Austria, Italy
via Vienna, Hungary across Budapest and Czech Republic and Slovakia across Dobr.9
1400
1200
1000
800
600
400
200
0
I
II
III
IX
VI
VII
Fig. 43 The increase of transportations of containers through the terminal Dobr in 2010
5.3.1. Zkon . 514/2009 Z.z. o doprave na drhach (Act No. 514/2009 Coll. on
Railway Transport)
There is the basic definition of intermodal transport that is formulated in Directive 92/106/EEC on
the establishment of common rules for certain types of intermodal transport of goods between
Member States in 2, section 4. Intermodal transport is the movement of goods, during which the
road vehicle, trailer, semi-trailer with or without truck, swap body or shipping container uses in the
initial or final section of the journey a roads and in the another section of the journey a railways,
inland waterways or maritime transport, if this part of the movement of goods exceeds 100 km as
9
55
FEASIBILITY STUDY
the crow flies and it makes the initial or final section of the journey by road either between the point
at which the goods were loaded and the nearest suitable terminal of loading in the initial section of
the journey and the nearest suitable terminal of unloading of goods and the point at which the goods
were unloaded for the final section of the journey, or inside a radius of less than 150 km as the crow
flies from the inland waterway port or seaport of loading or unloading goods.
According to 22 a subsidy in the context of intermodal transport = combined transport from the
budget chapter of the Ministry for the financial year can be provided. The subsidy may be granted for
the financing of projects and parts of projects in the financial year for operation of lines in the system
of unaccompanied, but also accompanied intermodal transport. The subsidy may be granted to the
applicant, if he proves that he has secured for the financing of project at least 70% of the cost from
other sources. The subsidy may be granted up to 30% of the costs necessary for realization of the
project. The subsidy may be also granted up to 15% also for the purchase of technical equipment
which are necessary for the implementation of intermodal transport. Granting of subsidies is subject
to the approved ways for the financial year.
From 2006 until the end of 2010, the state budget allocated for this purpose each year 20 million
Slovak crowns, which is currently 663 878 EUR. For the 2011 the budget is determined to 0 EUR.
5.3.3 Zkon . 8/2009 Z.z. o cestnej premvke (Act No. 8/2009 Coll. on Road
Traffic)
The Act provides in 39 restrictions of a journey of certain types of vehicles. Motor vehicles or road
trains over 7,5 tonnes are prohibited from driving on highways, expressways and first class roads on
the first working day and on Saturday, if this Saturday follows after working day, and this in the
period from 1 July to 31 August at the time of 7:00 to 19:00 hours and on Sunday and on the last
non-working day at the time of 00:00 to 22:00 hours. These prohibitions do not apply to motor
vehicles and road trains that are used in intermodal transport.
56
FEASIBILITY STUDY
The support of construction new Intermodal terminals (IT), respectively upgrading of existing
IT in the Czech Republic
For years 2006 - 2010 - The approved amount is 55,7 million EUR.
57
FEASIBILITY STUDY
Increased max. allowable total weight of the road train with the ITU to 44 tonnes,
Restrictions for journeys during holidays and weekends do not apply.
58
FEASIBILITY STUDY
Simplification and cheaper access to railway transport route (it concerns the railway
infrastructure manager),
Support of system of consignments transportation in different cars (it concerns the national
freight carrier ZSSK CARGO).
6.1.
In the railway sector in accordance with the rules and directives of EU the transformation took place,
after that the state usually owns the infrastructure. Railway companies (operators) operates the
transport on that infrastructure when they fulfill the conditions.
Access to railway infrastructure is:
-
The allocation of the train journey may be long-term (within the validity of timetable - one
year) or short-term (ad hoc).
Within the allocation of the train journey it is necessary to determine basic technical and
technological normative for a train journey:
-
Number of axles,
Planning of row HDV (HDV volatility and other technical characteristics which are listed in
regulation SR SR 1013),
FEASIBILITY STUDY
Allocation of the capacity in the Slovak Republic is determined by legislative standards and
regulations of the infrastructure manager, especially by:
-
Directive 2001/14/EC Of The European Parliament and Of The Council of 26 February on the
allocation of railway infrastructure capacity, levying of charges for using of railway
infrastructure and safety certification,
Implementing rules: Vyhlka MDPT 351/2010 Z. z. o dopravnom poriadku drh (Decree of the
MTPT SR No. 351/2010 Coll. on traffic order of railways ,
SR - Work schedule for the report of train traffic diagram (TTD) and its changes,
Fig. 44 The process of the preparing of the timetable - calendar of activities RNE
60
FEASIBILITY STUDY
marshalling yards,
storage sidings,
The price for using of these facilities is included in price for using of road infrastructure. Except the
minimum access package the infrastructure manager can provide additional services and facilities
and these on the basis of separate contracts which were concluded with the railway transport
company.
RD determines the charge for using of railway infrastructure in inland transport in the form of
maximum prices by category of lines (track).
61
FEASIBILITY STUDY
Currently, on the Railways of the Slovak Republic there is a change of the charging system of railway
infrastructure. So far, the price for access to infrastructure of SR has been determined as a global
price, which has taken into account the traveled distance (vlkm=train-kilometers), the transport
performance (hrtkm=gross tonne-kilometers) and trains route. The advantage is a simplicity and
clarity and accountability of this charging. Rates depend on traveled distance of gross trains weight
and on number of trains, respectively this component is known as the Access component. Weight of
individual rates is determined approximately in ratio 80% in relation to the component - trainkilometers, 15% in relation to the component - gross tonne-kilometers and 5% in relation to the
component - Access. However, this ratio varies depending on the parameters of the train, such as the
distance, the weight, etc. High weight of the charge for transport route in relation to the component
train-kilometers, so at the traveled distance of the train, motivates carriers to extract trains to the
standard of the weight, or length of the train, thereby it extends a transportation time. As an
example ZSSK Cargo, which in 2009 extended residence time in the marshalling yards from 6 to 12
hours. However, carriers, who do not particularly use complementary services, which are included in
the global price, are in disadvantage, which could be understood as a distortion of a competition.
However, it is important to realize that this charge includes all services - ie shift services and
technical offices (ancillary services, which should be specially allocated to unregulated prices),
marshalling yards, using of equipments of traction supply system, using of passenger stations and
their equipments, using of stations for formation of trains (hump, rail brakes, etc..), using of freight
terminals, rail scales. There are not these services and from those resulting costs included in the
foreign charges in the base (minimum) access package.
A current charge for the transport route with its price level and structure is no longer suitable for
new conditions of sale of the transit route which is already in use in Western Europe and it is
gradually promoted in surrounding countries. In terms of comparison of price levels of countries
which are applying the system of charges for using of railway infrastructure, the Slovak Republic
belongs to the most expensive countries. This high charge for using of railway infrastructure defends
the competitiveness of railway transport against other modes of transport, especially road transport.
High price for using of road transport has a major impact on transit transport flows that bypass the
infrastructure of SR. High price for using of road transport is a consequence mainly of low total
investment subsidies granted by the State.
Risks arising from the unequal conditions in the transport market, especially in a comparison to road
transport. To the price for using of railway infrastructure costs for operation and maintenance as well
as other activities that do not burden carriers of other modes of transport are included. Partially, this
has changed in the freight transport by charging (a toll) of highways, expressways and parallel first
class roads.
Ministry of Transport, Construction and Regional Development of the Slovak Republic (Ministerstvo
dopravy, vstavby a regionlneho rozvoja SR) currently has prepared the proposal to amend the
charge structure for using of railway infrastructure. The new concept of charging of a railway
infrastructure is based on the following principles:
62
FEASIBILITY STUDY
maximum prices for using of railway infrastructure and individual components of a transport
route will be followed to zkon 513/ 2009 o drhach,
maximum prices (rates) for the minimum access package will be the same for all modes of
transport,
prices of the minimum access package and of the track access to service facilities are among
regulated prices,
prices of ancillary services and other facilities are among unregulated prices and zkon NR SR
. 18/1996 o cench (Act of the National Council of the Slovak Republic No. 18/1996 Coll. on
Prices as amended) subjects to these prices.
A new charging concept defines two categories - the minimum access package and the track access in
this structure of the charge:
Charge for train ride
+ Reservation charge
+ Charge for using of electrical equipments
+ Access charge for technical equipments
= The total charge for the access to railway infrastructure
rad pre regulciu elezninej dopravy (Railway Regulatory Authority) has designated in its
Vnos . 3/2010 o uren hrad za prstup k elezninej infratruktre (Decree No. 3/2010 on the
determination of charges for access to railway infrastructure) of 2 December 2010 from 1.1.2011
maximum payments for the access to railway infrastructure within the minimum access package and
the track access to service facilities.
The payment system for services of the minimum access package consists of maximum payments for:
-
The payment system for services of the track access to service facilities consists of maximum
payments for:
a) using of the electrical supply equipment for traction power,
63
FEASIBILITY STUDY
whereas:
whereas:
vlkm
train-kilometers,
hrtkm
gross tonne-kilometers,
i -
category of the track; for the necessity of regulation tracks are divided into categories
according to the list, which is described in Section III point a) of this Annex,
U1i
maximum payment for ordering and for the allocation of a capacity in EUR per train-km for
the corresponding category of a track,
U2i
maximum payment for the management and organization of transport in EUR per train-km
for the corresponding category of the track,
U3i
maximum payment for ensuring the operability of the railway infrastructure in EUR per
thousand gross tonne-kilometers for the corresponding category of the track,
Ump
total payment for using of the railway infrastructure within the minimum access package
for the train, regardless of a type of provided transport services in EUR,
U1
total payment for ordering and allocation of capacity in EUR for the train, it shall apply
regardless of the actual use of the ordered and allocated capacity,
U2
total payment for the management and organization of transport in EUR per the train,
64
FEASIBILITY STUDY
U3
total payment for ensuring the operability of the railway infrastructure in EUR per the train,
Li
total length between individual transport points of the track of a relevant category, which is
expressed in kilometers at three decimal places,
Qi
total gross weight of the train in tonnes on the relevant category the track, which is
rounded to whole tonnes upwards,
ke
coefficient that accounts a ride of the train with an active traction railway vehicle of the
independent traction on electrified lines (tracks) of the relevant category, whose height is
1,2 and the height of a coefficient for other trains is 1,0.
1.
0,0207
2.
0,0190
3.
0,0188
4.
0,0160
5.
0,0141
6.
0,0096
1.
0,958
2.
0,881
3.
0,871
65
FEASIBILITY STUDY
U2i
Category of the
track
4.
0,742
5.
0,651
6.
0,445
1.
1,311
2.
1,261
3.
1,243
4.
1,064
5.
0,934
6.
0,649
Maximum payment for using of electrical supply equipment for the traction power,
Maximum payment for using of passenger stations, their buildings and facilities,
Maximum payment for an access to marshalling yards and facilities for formation of trains
and to cargo terminals owned or in management of a regulated entity.
For an illustration there is a current price for using of railway infrastructure with a type transit freight
train (This trains is transporting cargo between stations, mostly in the territory of one State) in the
section Koice - Bratislava, as well as the estimated price after the introduction of the new charging
system in the Tab. 9. There is an example of a price for a handling train for type section Koice Spisk Nov Ves, which is determined for collection of individual wagon consignments to the
marshalling yard too. The proposal of prices is processed according to Vnos . 3/2010 radu pre
regulciu elezninej dopravy (RD) (Decree No. 3 / 2010 of the Railway Regulatory Authority) of 2
66
FEASIBILITY STUDY
December 2010. In the example it is about regular trains. In the item of train-kilometers
performances are for handling trains valued by a special rate of 60% of the maximum price. There is
also a comparison of the level of toll for a road vehicle on the route Bratislava - ilina Koice for an
equivalent weight of 2000 tonnes in the Tab.9.
Tab. 9 Comparison of the price for using of railway infrastructure for type trains and
vehicle combinations
Characteristics
of the
train
Length
of the
train
track
Transit
freight
train(Tf)
Koice
freight
st.
Bratislava East.
Weight of
the train and
additional
notes
Global price
according to
the current
price decree
(cenov
vnos RD
545/2008)
Price
according
to the new
price decree
(cenov
vnos RD
2/2010 *)
Toll which
is set for 40
tonnes road
train, 5
axles, Euro
3 and 50
transportations as an
equivalent
of 2000
tonnes
Toll which
is set for 36
tonnes
road train,
4 axles,
Euro 3 and
55,5
transportations as an
equivalent
of 2000
tonnes
2000 t,
444 km
shove Spisk
N. Ves - trba
6082,70
2474,50
399,579
km
3640,433
4162,835
75 km
700 t
519,58
406,92
A track is
not
charged
A track is not
charged
A track is not
charged
Handling
freight
train(Hf)
Koice
Spisk
Nov Ves
Charged
length
of the
road
journey
* The price includes services of the minimum access package (a booking fee, a ride of the train) and of the track
access to service facilities (an electric traction, using of technical equipments for freight transport), the price
does not include services
The above example shows that for the integrated train weighing 2000 tonnes in section Koice Bratislava the charge for using of railway infrastructure will be reduced by 60%.
A new method of charging provides the reduction of the charge for using of railway infrastructure in
the order of 50% for the type train, thus to support of the development of freight railway transport
will be reached.
67
FEASIBILITY STUDY
10
9
8
/ train km
7
6
5
4
3
2
1
0
HR DK SP SE PT SI FR BE HU SF NL NO IT DE CH AT UK PL RO CZ SK BG LT EE LV
Fig. 45 A comparison of prices for using of railway infrastructure after the reducing of the charge
on SR
6.2.
dispatching/technological
scattering / gradual
single-grouped/multi-grouped
In the segment of integrated trains it is necessary to find international relations and to create system
trains for Combined transport.
In addressing the forming of trains it is necessary to focus on single wagon consignments that are
currently for the unsuitable technology are experiencing a in significant decline.
68
FEASIBILITY STUDY
stations with the authorization for filing and issuing of wagon-consignments stations of base network,
satellite marshalling yards,
main marshalling yards.
Stations of base network belong to the attraction circuit of only one satellite or main marshalling
yards, it means it considers the one-way operation of track sections. Each satellite marshalling yard
belongs to the attraction circuit of the only one main marshalling yard. Wagons are transported from
the stations of base network by service trains (handling, private siding) to the nearest satellite or
main marshalling yard. In the satellite station sets of service trains are connected to the segmental
transit train that carries those trains into the main marshalling yard. The main marshalling yard
creates direct single or multi-grouped trains and scattering transit trains to other main marshalling
yards, which create segmental trains to satellite yards of their attraction circuit, in which with the
69
FEASIBILITY STUDY
simple disconnecting the service trains are created that transport wagons to their destination
station.
2005
2006
2007
2008
2009
2010
Decisive trains-forming
stations
Other trains-forming
stations
47
31
25
25
24
17
Other trains-forming
stations (the carrier
realizes a movement)
10
Sum
53
41
34
34
33
32
An innovation lies in the fact that the main marshalling yard creates only direct single-grouped transit
trains, and this to all other main marshalling yards. The advantage is less reassignments (max. 2), this
leads to a reduction of average time of the wagon relocation on the network.
The proposed technology can be applied as:
-
all-day forming of trains in the mode of a wagons collecting on the normative of utilization, it
means the time-continuous trains-forming,
FEASIBILITY STUDY
It is important to determine the number of main marshalling yards. It is based on the criterion of an
average time of the wagon relocation, respectively a time loss of the wagon (a solution was proposed
by the professor ern). In terms of SR network four main marshalling yards devolve into account
(Bratislava East, ilina-Teplika, Koice freight station, Zvolen freight station)
A model of the time-continuous trains-forming requires a large number of directional rails and it
causes an increase of delays in the process of gathering.
Time-discrete model of trains-forming is based on these principles:
-
However, trains are created and these trains go only in the specified period during the day with a
compliance of the timetable. It is based on the customer requirement for the realization of cargo
handlings in the day time during working days.
direct single-grouped Tf
trains
Hf trains
Hf trains
departmental
trains
departure on
the day A in
evening
departmental
trains
arrival on the
day B(C) in the
morning
the afternoon
FEASIBILITY STUDY
activity in main marshalling yards declines after the leaving of these trains until late afternoon. In
satellite yards Tf trains are distributed to service trains which transport their wagons to the
destination station in the early morning. An activity in marshalling yards at weekends is declined to a
esential degree.
Technology in the main marshalling yard assumes:
-
executive hump,
fast service of target and source freight trains it can be solved by focusing of all crews at
first on service of target trains and then their movement,
reduction of the time of wagons relocation loading on the day "A", unloading on the day
"B" (exceptionally on the day "C"),
high productivity of operating workers in the marshalling yard that is focused on night hours.
Benefits of the concept of the trains-forming for the transportation of chemical substrates:
-
unified concept and networks technology of the relocation of each wagons consignment
within the network SR,
The introduction of the innovation of trains-forming in the form of night jump is considering the
organizational structure of the ZSSK necessary to coordinate between the ZSSK Cargo Slovakia, a. s.
and between the manager of railway infrastructure SR.
An comparison of times of the delivery wagons consignments on selected sessions currently and an
assumption after the introduction of a new system of the organization of trains-forming is presented
in the following table.
72
FEASIBILITY STUDY
7.
Delivery time
Delivery time by
after the
Actual delivery
RTR / F ZSSK
introduction of a
times
CARGO
new organization
of trains-forming
66 h
78 h
24 h
Relation
Distance
Bratislava - Koice
440 km
aa - Strske
590 km
78 h
72 h
27 h
337 km
42 h
48 h
22 h
On the basis of defined lacks in the connecting of Slovakia territory by lines of intermodal transport
we suggest considering the creation of new lines with priority in axis north - south through the
territory of Central Europe.
We suggest to comprehensively complete a network of intermodal transport lines, so that the
territory of Slovakia was connected to all directions and also it was able to link Central Europe in
direction of north - south. We propose to develop these links:
1. Swinoujscie/Gdynia ilina,
2. ilina Wien Wels / Novara
3. ilina Lovosice.
Line of intermodal transport Swinoujscie/Gdynia ilina
It is directed in line of corridor: Gdynia Katowice Ostrava ilina Bratislava/Wien Klagenfurt
Venice/ Trieste /Bologna/Ravenna; Graz Maribor Ljubljana Koper/Trieste. According to the new
approved REGULATION (EU) No 913/2010 OF THE EUROPEAN PARLIAMENT AND OF THE COUNCIL
of 22 September 2010 concerning a European rail network for competitive freight EU member
states are obliged to take into account a new legislation, which establishes international railway
corridors of freight transport and a strong preference of freight transport on those corridors and the
above mentioned corridor must be established to 10 November 2015. It also creates a time for
creation of action plan for development of railway and intermodal transport in this route.
There have already been registered almost 192 000 vehicles to the electronic toll system in the
Slovak Republic. Up to 66% of the total number of registered vehicles are from abroad. There are
registered to the electronic toll system in addition to Slovak vehicles most vehicles from Poland (35
233), Czech Republic (28 320) and Hungary (20 737). There are up to 140 709 vehicles of the total
73
FEASIBILITY STUDY
number of registered vehicles in the category of 12 tonnes or more. On average 26 581 vehicles over
3,5 tonnes daily uses defined road sections.
There were selected 0,39 mil. EUR within the transit ticketing for the state last month. Most used
transit routes are the section of the highway D2 from Brodsk to unovo and the section Svrinovec unovo (which is in route of the proposed line of intermodal transport). Almost 100% of tickets on
these routes have been purchased for vehicles from abroad. Sources of information of electronic toll
collection should be an important base for the detection of transport flows. Most of transports pass
in the direction north-south and vice versa particularly in terms of vehicles from Poland.
Line of intermodal transport ilina Wien Wels / Novara
In terms of North-South link in Central Europe we suggest a line ilina - Wels and ilina - Novara. In
the case of lower line utilization it can be possible to keep these two lines in the section ilina - Wien
together, where the train would be divided in the direction of Wels and Novara. At the same time it
can be considered with a stay of this train in the railway station Lepoldov where the load from
terminal Leopoldov would be added. Trains departure of this line would be preferred to trace from
ilina as a connection to the line Swinoujscie / Gdynia - ilina, so that consignments from the north
could continue to Wels, respectively to Novara.
Line of intermodal transport ilina - Lovosice
In terms of the transport market in Slovakia in the transport of chemical products and other products
it is important to connect Slovak Republic to lines of intermodal transport. These links go to
Germany. It is s crucial export and import partner of the Slovak Republic. Therefore, we propose to
link the intermodal terminal with functional terminal Lovosice in the Czech Republic. This line would
cover the western and northern part of Germany (through Hamburg and Duisburg). Next we propose
to secure a cover of the southern part of Germany with the line ilina - Wien - Wels with the
connection to lines that continue from Wels.
There are listed operational and technical parameters of the proposed intermodal transport lines in
the Table 13. There are alternately considered as transport units large containers and articulated
vehicles, whereas there is considered the weight of goods in a large container 16,5 tonnes and 25
tonnes in a articulated vehicle. Number of wagons in the train is under consideration for container
wagons of Sggrmss series (6-axles wagons with the tare weight of 29,8 tonnes) and Basket Wagons of
Sdgnss series for the transportation of road semi-trailers with a tare weight of 26,5 tonnes.
74
FEASIBILITY STUDY
winoujcie
Bohumn
ilina
ilina
Leopoldov
Wien Wels
ilina
Leopoldov
Wien
Novara
1500
1500
1400 / 1600*
1100 / 1600*
1500
600
600
600 / 650*
550 / 650*
600
Distance [km]
709
822
503
1246
519
22
30
10 / 13*
22 / 27*
10
ilina
Lovosice
Capacity of
TEU in the
wagon
Sggrmss
Sdgnss(semitrailers)
Number of
wagons in
the train
[wg]
Sggrmss
12
12
11 / 13*
9 / 13*
12
Sdgnss(semitrailers)
22
22
21 / 24*
16 / 24*
22
Number of
ITUs in the
train
[TEU/train]
Sggrmss
48
48
44 / 52*
36 / 52*
48
Sdgnss(semitrailers)
22
22
21 / 24*
16 / 24*
22
Transport
capacity of
the
train(net
weight of
goods) [t]
Sggrmss
970
970
890 / 1055*
730 / 1055*
970
Sdgnss(semitrailers)
550
550
525 / 600*
400 / 600*
550
* Normatives apply to the section ilina - Leopoldov, respectively Wien, in the travel time the time
for stay for processing of the train in Wien, respectively in Liverpool is counted
75
FEASIBILITY STUDY
76
FEASIBILITY STUDY
8.
77
FEASIBILITY STUDY
Semi-trailer 13,6 m
13620 mm
2480 mm
2700 mm
Loading weight
24000 kg
21
23835 kg
Habbillns
21200 mm
2840 mm
2800 mm (under the
roof beam)
61200 kg
(D category)
52
59020 kg
More than twice of IBC containers can be loaded into railway wagon compared to semi-trailer
assuming that the transportation to the customer will be transported down the railway tracks of
category D, where the highest load of the wagon is allowed.
78
FEASIBILITY STUDY
79
FEASIBILITY STUDY
return transportations of empty containers are relized exclusively by road transport (52
empty IBC containers stacking two layers in semi-trailer),
80
FEASIBILITY STUDY
8.1.2. Special transit prices D Cargo ZSSK Cargo for consignments of Ukraine Germany and vice versa
In the case of transportation of chemical substances (except of non-listed10) in IBC containers from
Ukraine to Germany under the same conditions as in the previous case we compare the cost ratio of
road and railway transport.
Tab. 14 Transport charges for individual transit routes from ierna nad Tisou11
Transit session
Distance
(km)
2-axles wagon
4- axles wagon
2- axles wagon
4- axles wagon
(weight of
goods min 10 t
/ 20 t)
(weight of
goods min 25 t
/ 40 t)
(weight of
goods min 10 t
/ 20 t)
(weight of
goods min 25 t
/ 40 t)
913
29,40 / 21,00
29,40 / 21,00
28,40 / 20,00
28,40 / 20,00
960
29,40 / 23,00
29,40 / 23,00
28,40 / 22,00
28,40 / 22,00
1022
29,40 / 23,00
29,40 / 23,00
28,40 / 22,00
28,40 / 22,00
On the route ierna nad Tisou Dn state border we apply for our case12 the rate of 21 EUR/tonne,
that is 0,023 EUR/tkm. In the case of road transport and of the price 1,2 EUR/km and in the case of
payload 24 tonnes the rate is 0,05 EUR/tkm and therefore we can say that the railway transport in
this case is preferable. For other rates per km of road transport the conversion to the tkm is as
follows.
10
Products: of all kinds, excluding military transportations, containers, cars, coal and iron ore, PLM and special
transportations without previous debate, goods of RID Class 1 and 7 and the same time NHM 2801, 2806, 2807, 2808, 2809,
2814, 291521. Trains (groups of wagons and individual consignments) will go through the route ierna nad Tisou s.b. <->
Lky pod Makytou s.b. / Horn Lide s.b. <-> Dn s.b., Lovosice (in the case of goods are transhipped from road transport
from/to DB), esk Kubice s.b., Cheb s.b. and back. Normative for the integrated train Gross: 2200 tonnes and 600 m.
11
CargoBusiness 2/2010 - www.zscargo.sk
12
Habbillns 4 axles load 59 tonnes
81
FEASIBILITY STUDY
Tab. 15 Comparison of prices per tkm for cargo in transit ierna nad Tisou Den s.b.
Transport
Railway
21,0
1,0
1,2
1,3
1,4
Road
Price
EUR/t
EUR/km
EUR/km
EUR/km
EUR/km
Tab. 16 Increase of the load of road transport by toll in the Czech Republic on transit
route from Ukraine to Germany across Slovakia and the Czech republic
Route
Vehicle
Articulated vehicle
40 tonnes
5-axles
EURO 3
Articulated vehicle
40 tonnes
5-axles
EURO 3
Toll to 31.12.2010
Toll to 1.1.2011
62,44 EUR
62,44 EUR
64 EUR
62,5 EUR
78,125 EUR
Sum
50 EUR
14
112,44 EUR
124,94 EUR
Toll to 1.1.2012
13
15
143,125 EUR
Railway transport
o
Road transport,
o
13
82
FEASIBILITY STUDY
9.
cleaning stations ,
New intermodal
connections
Cleaning stations16
16
Feasibility
Current processed project
documentation. Infrastructure
owned by state according to
legislation of EU
It depends on the completion of
new terminals and on cooperation
between operators in establishing
of continental intermodal lines
with the connection of Slovakia to
the European network. The
development in charging of road
infrastructure and traffic
restrictions, including emissions
from logistics will affect the
development of intermodal
connections.
New modern advanced cleaning
station - only technical issues requirements for operation are
clearly defined in existing
legislation.
Proposal of activities
Investments from EU funds
Within this part the feasibility study was processed: NETWORK OF CLEANING STATIONS FOR TANK
CONTAINERS, TANK WAGONS AND TANK VEHICLES IN SLOVAKIA, rail and road tankers in SR
83
FEASIBILITY STUDY
Solution
Feasibility
Proposal of activities
It is necessary to solve
technological questions issues.
Interested parties
Financial Plan
Timeline
Placement of terminals
MDVaRRMinisterstvo
dopravy, vstavby
a regionlneho
rozvoja (Ministry
of Transport,
Construction and
Regional
Development of
the Slovak
Republic)
171 mil. , 85 % EU
Cohesion Fund, 15 %
State Budget (more
details in Table. 18)
2014-2016
New intermodal
connections
intermodal
operators, road
carriers (hauliers),
railway transport
infrastructure
managers
not available
2012-2014
It depends on the
location, size and type
2012-2016
Cleaning stations17
17
operators and
customers,
Within this part the feasibility study was processed: NETWORK OF CLEANING STATIONS FOR TANK
CONTAINERS, TANK WAGONS AND TANK VEHICLES IN SLOVAKIA, rail and road tankers in SR
84
FEASIBILITY STUDY
Solutions
Interested parties
Financial Plan
Timeline
association of
cleaning stations,
terminal operator,
chemical company
of provided services
Trains-forming
Improvement of railway
infrastructure
MDVaRR, SR a.s.
2012-2014
Initial value
Target
value*
Source
km of reconstructed
railroads
Length of modernised
railway tracks in km
92
257
MTPT SR
- of which TEN-T
71
236
MTPT SR
Time saving in
passenger/freight
transport (min.)
35/295
MTPT SR
Number of railway
infrastructure projects
18
MTPT SR
28,7
30
MTPT SR
Name of indicator
INDICATORS OF OUTPUT
Core 19
INDICATORS OF RESULT
Time saving
Core 21
(railway transport)
INDICATORS OF CONTEXT
Core 13
Number of projects
85
FEASIBILITY STUDY
Code
Name of indicator
Initial value
Target
value*
Source
5,6
5,9
MTPT SR
NOTE: * - It is an estimated value of indicator. The real target value will be known upon the completion of the
implementation of OPT
Priority axes
Community
funding
National
counterparts
Indicative breakdown
of the national
counterpart
National
public
funding
National
private
funding
Total
funding
Cofinancing
rate
For
information
EIB Other
b=c+d
e=a+b
f=a/e
Priority axis 1
Railway
Infrastructure
920 878
680
0,85
Priority axis 3
Intermodal
transport
infrastructure
18 109 579
18 109 579
120 730
526
0,85
COHESION FUND
ChemLog PROJECT and FEASIBILITY STUDY present specific proposals for the development of railway
and intermodal transport in terms of Slovakia in relation to neighboring countries. The action plan
should follow up on these studies within a continuation of this project.
86
FEASIBILITY STUDY
Literature
AJDA, M.: Bezpene s nebezpenmi vecami 2009. CMS TREND, Bratislava, 2009. ISBN 978-80-969095-3-7
amaj, J.; Gapark, J.: Evaluation of railway stations as part of basic implementation time discrete train
formation. In: TRANSCOM 2009, 8-th European Conference of Young Research and Science
Workers, ilina June 22
Petrovsk, A.: Dopravn slovnk. Alfa, Bratislava, 1983. ISBN 63-137-83
Bujna, V. a kol.: Almanach dopravy Slovakia transport. Luxur, Bratislava, 2006. ISSN 1335-7433-24
Gapark, J.; Blaho, P.: Metodika prideovania kapacity elezninej infratruktry v nkladnej doprave. In:
Horizonty elezninej dopravy 2010, medzinrodn vedeck konferencia, ilinsk univerzita v iline 2010, s.6269, ISBN 978-80-554-0247-5
Mrton, P.: Vvoj potu vlakotvornch stanc v sieti SR v rokoch 2005 2010. In: eleznin doprava a
logistika, elektronick odborn asopis, Ro. 6, . 1 (2010), s. 9-12, ilinsk univerzita v iline 2010, ISSN 13367943
Nariadenie Vldy Slovenskej republiky . 344/2006 o minimlnych bezpenostnch poiadavkch na tunely v
cestnej sieti
Council Directive. 68/414/EEC as amended by amendment Council Directive 98/93/EC, which regulates the
production of oil and petroleum products
Dekra automobil: Tunelem nebo pes alpsk kopce? 4/2009, Praha
AMENDMENTS OF ADR 2009 ON CARRIER POSITION, number I, 2009, Bratislava
Vnos . 2/2010 radu pre regulciu elezninej dopravy z 18. augusta 2010
o regulanom rmci pre urovanie hrad za prstup k elezninej infratruktre, Available online on:
http://www.urzd.sk/legislativa/VynosURZD-2010-02.pdf
irok, J.: Opertoi a provozovatel terminl intermodaln pepravy v R. In: In: eleznin doprava a
logistika, elektronick odborn asopis, Ro. 6, . 3 (2010), s. 14-26, ilinsk univerzita v iline 2010, ISSN 13367943.
http://www.profivodic.sk/adr
http://www.telecom.gov.sk/files/doprava/cesta/scd/adr2009/adr2009_cast1.pdf
http://pernerscontacts.upce.cz/13_2009/halama.pdf
http://pernerscontacts.upce.cz/13_2009/halama.pdf
www.telecom.gov.sk/index/open_file.php?file=doprava/adr
http://www.ndsas.sk/tunely/12385s
http://www.telecom.gov.sk/files/doprava/cesta/scd/adr2009/adr2009_cast8.pdf
http://www.euroinfo.gov.sk/index/go.php?id=1071
http://portal.statistics.sk/showdoc.do?docid=16383
http://www.telecom.gov.sk/externe/idic/index.html
http://www.slovnaft.sk/sk/o_nas/pre_media/prezentacie_a_publikacie/
http://www.slovnaft.sk/sk/o_nas/pre_media/prezentacie_a_publikacie/
www.benzin.sk/obr/pistol.jpg
http://www.piestany.sk/index.php?id=15&L=0
http://www.tamex.sk/data/Video_Car_Recorder_W.pdf
http://www.ssc.sk/sk/Bezpecnost-cestnej-premavky-BECEP/Kriticke-nehodove-lokality/Kriticke-nehodovelokality-a-hustota.ssc
http://www.strukturalnefondy.sk/operacne-programy/doprava]
http://www.gefahrgut-wiki.de/StVO
http://www.telecom.gov.sk/files/doprava/cesta/scd/adr2009/adr2009_cast8.pdf
PETRUNK, P. ADR 2009 Peprava nebezpench vc po silnici. Praha: Sdruen automobilovch dopravc
ESMAD BOHEMIA, 2009. 216 s. ISBN 978-80-87304-02-0
87
FEASIBILITY STUDY
SSELBECK, G. Basiskurs ADR 2009. Wegberg: Verlag Gnter Hendrisch, 2009. 262 s. ISBN 978-3-938255-08-7
WINKLER, E. Tunelem nebo pes alpsk kopce? Nebezpen nklad. ISSN , 2009, . 4, s. 8 11.Dohoda
ADR.Available online on: <http://www.mdcr.cz/cs/Silnicni_doprava/Nakladni_doprava/adr/ADR+2009++ke+sta%C5%BEen%C3%AD/>.
Vyhlka
Ministerstva
dopravy
a
spoj
.
30/2001
Sb.
Available
online
on:
<http://www.autoskoly.cz/psp/Vyhlaska_30_2001_k_21_4_2009.pdf>.
Vyhlka
Ministerstva
vntra
SR
.
9/2009
Z.
z.
Available
online
on:
<http://www.zbierka.sk/zz/predpisy/default.aspx?PredpisID=208783&FileName=zz2009-000090208783&Rocnik=2009>.
Zkon . 361 / 2000 Sb. o provozu na pozemnch komunikacch. Available online on:
<http://www.mdcr.cz/NR/rdonlyres/C33E38FC-A12A-46B8-9E89-841136D385FE/0/MicrosoftWord361.pdf>.
Zkon Nrodnej rady Slovenskej republiky . 8/2009 Z. z. o cestnej premvke. Available online on:
<http://www.zbierka.sk/zz/predpisy/default.aspx?PredpisID=208782&FileName=zz2009-000080208782&Rocnik=2009>.
Zkon Nrodnej rady Slovenskej republiky . 168/1996 Z. z. o cestnej doprave. Available online on:
<http://www.zbierka.sk/zz/predpisy/default.aspx?PredpisID=13633&FileName=96-z168&Rocnik=1996>.
Objectives DIOMIS. UIC. [Online] 2010. [cit. 2010-06-06] <http://www.uic.org/diomis/>.
88
FEASIBILITY STUDY
List of abreviations
ADR
AT
Austria
CACS
CSC
CR
Czech Republic
ECD
EN
EP
European Parliament
ESTY
EU
European Union
FTE
hrtkm
HU
Hungary
IBC
ICA
Intercontainer Austria
IMDG
IT
Intermodal transport
ISO
IT
Intermodal terminal
MDVaRR
UTI
ILU
MEGC
OPT
OSD
PL
Poland
RID
RNE
ROLA
s.b.
State border
STN
TR1
UA
Ukraine
UN
United Nations
URD
vlkm
Train-kilometer
RTR/F
SR
89
FEASIBILITY STUDY
Prloha 2
East-Slovakian hubs
Prloha 3
Megaboxes
Prloha 4
90