Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
BY
Introduction
This paper is looking at a triangulation and application of three knowledge
areas in the process of materials development for teaching and learning
speaking skills in a second language acquisition context.
The knowledge areas include, Inter Language Analysis (ILA), Speaking skills,
and Language materials design. The concepts of Needs Analysis (NA) and
content development will be subsumed under these broad areas as the
implications of triangulation become manifest.
We will focus on our contexts, summary of our research work, brief discussion
of basic concepts from literature, the implications for materials development
and our concluding thoughts on the work done.
Our Contexts
Expanding Circle
Outer circle
Inner circle
UK, USA
Canada
India, Nigeria
Singapore
South Korea, China
Russia
Our contexts
5/16/2012
Vernacular style
(more pidgin-like)
Unattended
speech data
Style 2
Attended
speech
data
Careful style
(more TL/NL like)
Literature Review.
Selinker (1972 cited in Davies,1989) Inter
Language (Henceforth IL) is a learners
language characterized by permeability,
dynamism, and systematicity. Thus, IL is
continually evolving with more input to the
learner and revision by the learner
(Lightbown &Spada, 2006)
IL describes the structured system constructed
by the learner at every stage of his
development. (Ellis, 1985)
5/16/2012
Literature Review.
Needs Analysis
It is a learner-centered process
5/16/2012
Literature Review.
5/16/2012
Literature Review.
Materials Design
5/16/2012
Literature Review.
We find this framework most useful because it is systematic, coherent purposeful and
flexible. This review has given a mulch-dimensional insights to this paper.
5/16/2012
10
Research Analysis
5/16/2012
11
Research Analysis
Aims
Data Collection
We used unstructured
interviews recorded
using Skype over three
interview sessions.
5/16/2012
12
Data Analysis
Recorded interviews
were converted into
transcripts using voice
walker.
Phonology
Grammar
Vocabulary
pragmatics
5/16/2012
13
Findings
Phonology
Nkiru's pronunciation was
good with an intermediate
level of fluency.
However, she commits local
errors attributable to
transfers from L1 e.g.
Omission of sounds like /t/ in
'least'.
Lee also has good
pronunciation but, he
displays a mixed grill of
abilities.
5/16/2012
14
Findings
Grammar
Vocabulary
5/16/2012
15
Findings
Pragmatics
5/16/2012
16
Implications
We believe that ILA has implications for
material development in the following
areas:
Needs analysis
Usability
Contextual focus
Needs Analysis.
ILA employs approaches that are
systematic and empirically established
by a careful accumulation and analysis
of data e.g. Canale's framework. These
approaches are universally acceptable,
they account for variations across IL
sub-systems (phonology, grammar,
vocabulary & pragmatics), and they are
internally consistent, parsimonious and
elegant, (Tarone, 1989).
NA tries to get information about the
learners' perceptions of their needs
and how others perceive them
5/16/2012
17
Implications
Needs Analysis
In view of the scientific and pragmatic nature of IL, we believe that it may be used to
strengthen the process of identification and elaboration of needs in materials
development. Errors or language variations identified will now become the learners'
needs. For example, our studies observed that the subjects need more pragmatic
knowledge of English language to function and communicate effectively, thus,
content design will include politeness, turn taking in conversation, or even elements
of interaction in English language discourse.
5/16/2012
18
STEP 1.....
STEP 2.....
STEP 3.......
STEP 4.......
STEP 5......
STEP 6......
Administration (Interviews)
Analysis
Fig 3
5/16/2012
19
5/16/2012
20
Implications
Types of materials
Usability
21
Implications
This evaluation will simply ascertain
whether or not the speaking material is
easy to learn, efficient to use, easy to
remember, allows the learner to
commit only a few errors, and is
pleasant to use.(Nielson, 1993).
5/16/2012
Contextual focus
Finally, we believe that the role of ILA in
the future development of English
language as an international language
will become more pronounced. This
belief is based upon the striking
similarities that occurred in the results
of our independent researches of
learners that represent the outer circle
and expanding circle.
Secondly, Graddol's (2010) futuristic
axioms about India, which we find in
view of the results above to be
increasingly relevant to our research
contexts
22
Implications
These are summarized thus;
5/16/2012
23
Conclusion
This paper has looked at the influence of ILA on
materials development based on studies carried
out in two contexts. We must quickly add that, we
interviewed only one subject each and in three
events and to these extents can the results be
generalized. However, we think that more of
these studies are needed in other contexts with
other specifications to build a body of knowledge
in preparation for a future which is very near.
5/16/2012
24
References/Bibliography
BENESCH, S (2001) Critical English for Academic purposes:
Theory, politics, and practice. Mawah: Lawrence Erlbaum
Associates, Publishers.
CRYSTAL, D (2010). The Cambridge Encyclopedia of English
Language. Second Edition. Cambridge: Cambridge University
Press p 107.
ELLIS (1994) Differences between L1 and L2 acquisition (based
on Bley-Vroman 1988)
ELLIS , R (1997) SLA Research and Language Teaching. London:
Oxford University Press. Chps 5&6.
ELLIS , R (2009) The study of second language acquisition.
Second Edition. London: Oxford University Press. Chps 5&6.
ELLIS, R (1987) Contextual variability in Second Language
Acquisition and the relevancy of language teaching In R,
Ellis (Ed) Second Language Acquisition in context. London:
Prentice Hall International. Pp 179-195.
GRADDOL, D (2010) English Next India: The future of English in
India. India: British Council. Pp14-15
GRAVES, K (1996) A framework of course development
processes In K. Graves (Ed). Teachers as course
Developers. Cambridge: Cambridge University press.
5/16/2012
25
References/Bibliography
http://www.linguistics.ucsb.edu/projects/transcriptio
n/tools.html