Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
Bank
Audit
How much is Enough?
CONTENTS
EDITORIAL BOARD
ISSN 1993-3649
Editorial
Presidents Desk
2
3
ARTICLES
Green Banking and Sustainable Development: 5
the Case of Bangladesh
- Atiur Rahman Ph.D
Md. Abdus Salam FCA
Gopal Chandra Ghosh FCA
Akhtar Sohel Kasem FCA
Masih Malik Chowdhury FCA
Nasir Uddin Ahmed FCA
Sabbir Ahmed FCA
Md. Sayeed Ahmed FCA
Mahmudul Hasan Khusru FCA
Md. Abu Bakar FCA
Md. Mahamud Hosain FCA
Mohammed Jashim Uddin FCA
Snehasish Barua FCA
Ajit Kumar Paul FCA
Md. Abid Hossain Khan FCA
Muhammmad Aminul Hoque ACA
Zareen Hosein ACA
Md. Shahidul Islam ACA
Dipok Kumar Roy ACA
Chairman DRC-ICAB
Chairman CRC-ICAB
15
22
- Ishter Mahal1
- Benazir Rahman2
49
71
79
DISCLAIMER
"The opinions expressed in this publication are those of the
respective authors themselves and do not necessarily reflect the
views of the Editorial Board of the Institute of Chartered Accountants of Bangladesh (ICAB) or the ICAB itself."
EDIT ORIAL
As the technological
improvements and competitive
environment changes, so is the
risk of financial markets and
economic fraud all around the
world. As an answer to these
new threats, the need to ensure
transparent accounting and
reporting standards cannot be
overstated for the overall
economic success of a country.
To cope up, auditors need to
adapt with the rapidly changing
banking industry and the
present concerns including:
continuous auditing, regulatory
changes, fraud, Enterprise Risk
Management, social media and
internet risks. Inview of this,
the issue would offer an
opportunity to gain insights into
the current hidden and
unknown facts and anomalies
centering Bank that is haunting
public perception with a sense
of insecurity. The issues are not
unknown to the world history.
The best recognized bank
offered best report even gave
rise to corporate fraud shaking
the country's financial sector.
For our country, the dimension
may vary compared to other
modern economy. We tend to
forget once it is over. The real
perpetrator sometimes remains
beyond touch.
On the recent financial
irregularities of some
PRESIDENTS DESK
Instilling more Trust
and Confidence
As I take over the presidency, I
consider it to be a sacred duty to
uphold the interests of the
Profession and contribute to the
Accounting and private sector
Auditing. We cannot stop till we
get the result, we expect. To
hold the continuity of our
progress and advancement, I will
not leave any dearth of my effort
to discharge my function as the
President of the Institute. I must
be able to do justice to the trust
and confidence bestowed upon
me by the members.
In this quarter, I raised different
pending issues with the
Minister/Secretary/Officials of
Regulatory Bodies and convey
different contentious issues to
them like utilization/
engagement of more Chartered
Accountants in different
Division/Bodies/Projects under
the Ministries, allocation of land
for ICAB Academic Campus,
approval of the ICAB submitted
Project proposal lying in the
Planning Commission, engaging
more Chartered Accountants in
the banking sector etc. We
pointed out contradiction
between IFRSs & IASs and Bank
Company Act, 1991 & some
BRPD circulars of Bangladesh
Bank which is required to be
amended for the sake of
exercising sound accounting
practices in Bangladesh.
According to the proposal of Mr.
The Bangladesh Accountant
BB FORMULATED
GREEN BANKING POLICY
GUIDELINE IMPLEMENTED
IN 3 PHASES FROM 2011 TO
2013. BY FOLLOWING THESE
GUIDELINES, BANKS WILL
BENEFIT IN TERMS OF
IMPROVED CAMELS
RATING. BESIDES, BB WILL
DECLARE THE NAMES OF
THE TOP 10 BANKS
REGARDING THEIR
OVERALL PERFORMANCE IN
GREEN BANKING
sustainable financial and economic
growth. Bangladesh Bank has also
issued a common format to all the
commercial banks to report green
banking activities including the extent
of carbon footprint in a structured
way. Banks and financial institutions
enthusiastically responded to this
'Green Banking' drive. Now they
regularly submit a quarterly report to
Bangladesh Bank on their
performance of green banking
activities.
BB formulated green banking policy
guideline implemented in 3 phases
from 2011 to 2013. By following
these guidelines, banks will benefit in
terms of improved CAMELS rating.
Besides, BB will declare the names of
the top 10 banks regarding their
overall performance in green banking
activities and will actively consider
green banking activities of banks
while according permission for
opening new branch. BB has decided
to accord permission for SME branch
subject to installation of solar panel in
06
07
08
Introduction
I would like to start this article with a very
famous quote that came to my attention
many years ago while reading an
interview of a Global Banks CEO. The
quote I am referring here is Banking is
such a unique industry where you do not
want your competitor to fail. Honestly
speaking it did not make much sense at
that time. However, after working as a
professional accountant for many years the
perspective of the comment is quite vivid.
Why it is so that a Bank would not like to
see his fellow competitor Bank to fail? The
simplest and shortest answer is Banking
business is based on Trust and failure of a
Bank severely dents that Trust and it
affects not only other Banks but the whole
economic systems bears the brunt.
It is an undeniable fact that Banks play a
central role in the economy. They hold
the savings of the public, provide a means
of payment for goods and services and
finance the development of business and
trade. To perform these functions securely
and efficiently, individual banks must
command the confidence of the public
and those with whom they do business.
The stability of the banking system, both
nationally and internationally, has
therefore come to be recognized as a
matter of general public interest. This
10
11
12
The development of
sophisticated real-time
computerized information
systems has greatly improved
the potential for control, but in
turn has brought with it
additional risks arising from the
possibility of computer failure
or fraud. The introduction of
electronic commerce has also
introduced significant new risks
and requires, in turn, additional
controls. From supervisory
point of view these are very
critical element.
Supervisors are concerned to
ensure that the quality of
management is adequate for
the nature and scope of the
business and try to understand
managements business plans
and strategies and how it
expects to achieve them.
Similarly, the supervisor seeks
to discover whether the bank is
properly equipped to carry out
its functions in terms of the
skills and competence of its
staff and the equipment and
facilities at its disposal.
13
14
Conclusion
The key theme of this issue of the
Bangladesh Accountant is very
topical, as hardly any single day
has been passed during the last few
months where not only business
and finance section, but even
headlines of local dailies were not
free from news about banking
sector in Bangladesh. Many of
those articles also touched upon
the performance of external
auditors in their audit of banks.
Therefore, an attempt has been
made through this article to reflect
respective roles and responsibilities
of auditors as well as other
stakeholders like board,
management and supervisors for
the conduct of a successful audit as
all are quite interrelated.
Introduction
Commercial Bank (Bank), either local or
international, is required to be
incorporated under the laws of the land
where they are incorporated as Banking
Companies. Every country has its specific
laws, rules and regulations on how to
incorporate Banking Company, how it will
be run, what are the requirements for
audit, who will conduct the audit, what
guidelines are to be followed and so on.
Generally the Auditors follow the local
and international standards and guide
lines while conducting an audit of a
commercial bank. There are different
types of audit of banks: internal, external,
statutory, special and compliance audit.
External audit may be from the Central
Bank, from the government auditors, from
the management on specific purposes,
from the parliamentary audit committee.
Bank audit is completely different and
unique in itself because banking
businesses are different from other
ordinary businesses. The importance of
banks audit has been increased
tremendously after the Global Financial
and Economic Crisis started from the giant
economy of the United States since 2007.
In Bangladesh, special audit consideration
has been provided by various authorities
including the stakeholders, the central
bank and the government, after the
15
16
IN MANY CASES OF
AUDIT: INTERNAL,
EXTERNAL, STATUTORY
AND OTHER TYPES, FAIL
TO DETECT AND CONTROL
FRAUD, ERRORS,
NEGLIGENCE,
MISAPPROPRIATION OF
FUND, LOAN SCAMS, ETC.
IN LARGE BANKS. IN
BANGLADESH, AUDIT
JOBS ARE CONDUCTED BY
VARIOUS AUDITORS AND
THERE ARE INTERNAL
CONTROL SYSTEMS IN
EXISTENCE BUT THE LOAN
SCAMS OF HALL MARK
AND DESTINY GROUPS
PROVE THAT BOTH
INTERNAL CONTROL AND
VARIOUS AUDITS FAIL TO
CONTROL AND PREVENT
THE EMBEZZLEMENT OF
HUGE FUND. FROM THE
VARIOUS ANALYSIS AND
INVESTIGATION IT IS
EVIDENCED THAT THERE
ARE MANY LAPSES AND
WEAKNESSES IN THE
INTERNAL CONTROL
SYSTEMS OF BANKS
WHICH ARE NOT
DETECTED WHILE
CONDUCTING AUDITS BY
THE AUDITORS.
Establishing degree of
Reliance on Internal control:
Managements responsibilities
include the maintenance of
adequate internal control, the
selection and application of
accounting policies, and the
safeguarding of the assets of the
entity.
The auditor is required to obtain a
sufficient understanding of the
internal control to plan the audit
and develop an effective audit
approach. After obtaining the
understanding, the auditor should
17
18
19
20
Conclusion:
It has become conspicuously
evident that the banks are in no
way obviated of corrupt and
fraudulent practices after all.
Abundant facts in the recent
studies attest to this claim. The
banking sector in particular has
become a terrain for various
appalling corrupt and fraudulent
practices. In addition, the recent
studies noted that the internal
mechanisms in the banks are not
sufficient to guarantee transparent
and accountable service in the
conduct of official business in the
sector. Mere conventional audit is
not enough to protect the banking
industries from entwine of
corruption and fraud. The audit
procedures, plans and programs of
21
Abstract
Profitability is the ultimate test of
managements operating effectiveness and
success of a financial institution.
However, profit is one of the quantitative
elements which reflect the bank
performance story. Baking industry of
Bangladesh has developed tremendously.
Among contributory financial
organizations both conventional and
Islamic banks of Bangladesh are making
significant contribution in economic
development of Bangladesh. But both
types of bank need to ensure sustainability
along with the profitability by maintaining
adequate liquidity. In the recent years
banks are developing at a high growth
rate. Both of these banks are concentrated
in their profitability trend for better
sustainability. Profitability depends on the
overall performance efficiency of the
bank. The study shows a comparative
study between conventional and Islamic
banking system of Bangladesh and reveals
the competitive scenario for both sectors.
Introduction
Banking is the backbone of national
economy. All sorts of economic and
financial activities revolve round the axis
of banks. In the global context, the role of
banks is far-reaching and more penetrating
22
Objective
Broad Objective
The main objective is to focus on the
profitability trend of both
Conventional and Islamic banking
system in Bangladesh taking 5 banks
from each category and comparing
them by applying appropriate tools.
Specific Objectives
The specific objectives of this paper
are the following:
Literature Review
AFTER ANALYZING
THE AVERAGE
PROFITABILITY RATIOS IT
IS FOUND THAT BOTH THE
SECTORS ARE DOING WELL
BUT THEIR CLASSIFIED
LOANS/INVESTMENTS
AMOUNT SHOULD BE
MAINTAINED AT A
TOLERABLE LEVEL. AFTER
THE COMPARATIVE STUDY
IT IS FOUND THAT
PROFITABILITY TREND OF
SELECTED ISLAMIC BANKS
ARE HIGHER BUT AVERAGE
PROFITABILITY RATIOS OF
CONVENTIONAL BANKS
SHOWS BETTER POSITION.
THOUGH ISLAMIC
BANKSGROWTH RATE IS
BETTER BUT
CONVENTIONAL BANKS
RATIOS ARE IN BETTER
POSITION. IT MAY
BECAUSE OF THESE
BANKS HAVE BETTER RISK
MANAGEMENT
TECHNIQUES AND ALSO
DIVERSIFIED RANGE OF
INVESTMENTS. IN SHORT,
IT CAN BE SAID THAT
BOTH SYSTEMS HAVE
DIFFERENT COMPETITIVE
ADVANTAGES IN THEIR
FIELD WHICH INFLUENCE
THEIR PROFITABILITY.
23
24
Conventional Banks
Islamic Banks
Variation in
Deposit
Other
Facilities
Business Efficiency:
Profitability of conventional banks depends
Profitability
on Loans and investments both.
These banks have to maintain more SLR that
Liquidity &
is 19% now.
Solvency
Conventional banks use deposits as a core
Sources of
source of banks in exchange of fixed deposit
Funds
interest.
These banks mainly invest in loans &
Uses of Funds
advances as a core function of the banks &
also invest in many sectors on term basis.
The growth profile of selected conventional
Business
banks indiates better positon.
development
The selected conventional banks shows
Efficiency
efficiency and productivity in the recent
&Productivity
years.
Commitment
to Economy
&Community
Islamic Banks
Deals with Shariah based principles o n the
basis of Islamic Shariah under the
supervision of BB.
Islamic banks mainly providing
concentration on improving profit margin as
well as increasing shareholders equity. But
now these banks also improving their
technology and concentrated in CSR
activities but these are left behind than
conventional ones.
Islamic banks receive deposits under two
principles:
Al-Wadeeah principle
Mudaraba prin ciple
25
1174.9340
48719.0000
41720.5640
Std.
Deviation
882.2125
16612.7650
15484.9360
Variables Entered/Removed
Model
Variables Variables
Entered Removed
1
LOANS,
.
DEPOSIT
Correlations
PROFIT
PROFIT
1.000
N
5
5
5
Pearson
Correlation
Sig. (1-tailed)
Method
Enter
DEPOSIT
LOANS
PROFIT
DEPOSIT
LOANS
PROFIT
DEPOSIT
LOANS
.928
.951
.
.012
.007
5
5
5
DEPOSIT
.928
LOANS
.951
1.000
.994
.012
.
.000
5
5
5
.994
1.000
.007
.000
.
5
5
5
Model Summary
R
Model
1
Adjusted R
Std. Error of
the Estimate
Change Statistics
2
.964
.929
.859
331.6207
R Change
.929
F Change
13.154
df1
2
df2
2
Sig. F Change
.071
Adjusted R2:
Coefficient of Determination(R2):
R2 shows the proportion of the
variability in the dependent
variable that can be explained by
the estimated multiple regression
equation.Here R2 is equal to 0.929
(92.9% expressed in percentage)
indicates 92.9% of the variability
in Profit after tax is explained by
the input variables.
26
ANOVA
Model
Sum of Squares
1
Regression 2893250.743
Residual
219944.545
Total
3113195.288
df Mean Square
F
Sig.
2 1446625.372 13.154 .071
2 109972.273
4
Here
t-Test:
t- Test is used to determine
whether each of the independent
variable is significant. We refer to
each of the separate T Test for each
of the independent variable as a
test for individual significance.
Ho: 1 = 2 = 0
Coefficient Correlations
Model
1
Correlations
Findings:
From the output above we can
bring out an equation that is like:
LOANS
DEPOSIT
Co variances
LOANS
DEPOSIT
a. Dependent Variable: PROFIT
LOANS
1.000
-.994
9.679E-03
-8.968E-03
DEPOSIT
-.994
1.000
-8.968E-03
8.409E-03
Collinearity Diagnostics
Eigen value Condition Variance
Index Proportion
s
Model Dimensio
(Constant) DEPOSIT LOANS
n
1
1
2.937
1.000
.01
.00
.00
2
6.280E-02 6.838
.63
.00
.00
3
5.426E-04 73.565
.36
1.00
1.00
Y= a+2X2+3X3
PAT =-755.208-7.799 Deposits
+0.137Loans & Advances
Here (-7.799) represent an
estimate of the changes
corresponding to single quantity
changes in deposit volume which
is in inverse relation that for 1
increasing or decreasing
arrangement with deposit volume
results 7.799 decrease or increase
the PAT.Similarly 1 increasing or
decreasing arrangement with loans
27
& advances results 0.137 likelihood to increase or decrease the PAT which is in positive relationship.
(-0.755.208) represent the value of 1 which is constant coefficient that shows the reduction of PAT when two
independent variables are zero (0).
If we calculate regression from different samples we can get the following standard errors of Y intercept 1, 2
and 3for deposits & loans are 609.691, 0.092 & 0.098.
Multiple Regression-2 (For Islamic banks) :
For the regression analysis we have selected following variables;
Net Profit After Tax- Dependent Variable (Y)
Deposits- Independent variable (X1)
Investments- Independent variable (X2)
Descriptive Statistics
Mean
PROFIT
DEPOSIT
1253.6780
74078.9240
LOANS
68401.7600
Std.
Deviation
769.4472
27057.356
3
28159.013
2
Variables Entered/Removed
Model
Variables
Variables
Entered
Removed
1
LOANS,
.
DEPOSIT
a. All requested variables entered.
b. Dependent Variable: PROFIT
N
5
5
Pearson
Correlation
5
Sig. (1tailed)
Method
Enter
Correlations
PROFIT
PROFIT
1.000
DEPOSIT
.978
LOANS
.981
DEPOSIT
LOANS
PROFIT
.978
.981
.
1.000
.998
.002
.998
1.000
.002
DEPOSIT
LOANS
PROFIT
DEPOSIT
LOANS
.002
.002
5
5
5
.
.000
5
5
5
.000
.
5
5
5
Model Summary
R
Model
1
.98
2
R2
.963
Adjusted R2
.927
Std. Error of
the Estimate
207.9287
Change Statistics
R2Change
.963
F Change
26.388
df1
2
df2
2
Sig. F Change
.037
28
F-Test:
The F Test is used to determine whether a significant relationship prevails between the dependent variable
and independent variables. It is considered as the test for overall significance. Here the hypothesis for the F
test shows significant relationship between dependent and independent variables. The alternative hypothesis
is vice versa.
Therefore the null hypothesis is:
H o: 2 = 3 = 0
Ha: one of the parameters is not equal to zero
If null hypothesis is rejected we can conclude that the overall relationship between Y (PAT) and independent
variables X1 (Deposits) & X2 (Investments) is significant.
Test Statistic, F= MSR/MSE
= 26.388
And the given table value is 9.00 with the level of significance,
= 0.10
As 26.388 is higher than table value so we certainly derive that the null hypothesis is rejected. So, the overall
relationship is significant.
29
Here
t-Test:
F-Test:
The F Test is used to determine whether a significant relationship
prevails between the dependent variable and independent variables. It is
considered as the test for overall significance. Here the hypothesis for
the F test is deemed as there is no significant relationship between
dependent and independent variables. The alternative hypothesis is vice
versa.
Therefore the null hypothesis is:
Ho: 1 = 2 = 0
LOANS
DEPOSIT
Covariances
LOANS
DEPOSIT
a. Dependent Variable: PROFIT
LOANS
1.000
-.998
3.340E-03
-3.469E-03
DEPOSIT
-.998
1.000
-3.469E-03
3.618E-03
Collinearity Diagnostics
Eigenvalue Condition Variance
Index Proportions
Model Dimension
(Constant) DEPOSIT LOANS
1
1
2.926
1.000
.00
.00
.00
2
7.417E-02 6.281
.23
.00
.00
3
2.165E-04 116.234
.76
1.00
1.00
a. Dependent Variable: PROFIT
30
the PAT which is in positive relationship. (-494.547) represent the value of 1 which is constant coefficient that
shows the reduction of PAT when two independent variables are zero (0).
If we calculate regression from different samples we can get the following standard errors of Y intercept 1, 2
and 3 for deposits & loans are 577.084, 0.060 & 0.058.
Comparative position of both regression analysis
Both the systems are in almost similar situation as per the analysis. Wehave used only the average of selected
banks &found that profit of both banking systems are influenced by deposits and Loans/Investments.
SWOT Analysis
For Conventional Banks
Strengths
Huge product line
Fixed rate of return
Have various management skills to be utilized
Weaknesses
Strict regulations provided by BB than Islamic
ones
Greater rate of loan default
Opportunities
Diversed loan facilities or options can be created
Easy access in money market/ interbank borrowing
Strong customer background
Can invest in those sectors which are prohibited by
Islamic Shariah
Threats
Huge credit risk
Demand of clients change frequently
May more restrictions imposed by BB
Weakness
Lack of Shariah manual or guidelines
Lack of linkages with training institutes and
Shariah supervisory bodies
Lack of managements commitment in strictly
following the Shariah guidelines
Opportunities
Huge investment opportunities
Strong religious influence
Threats
Insufficient legal protection
Market demand may change
Lack of unified Shariah rulings
Shortage of supportive and link institutions; and
Shortage of skilled and trained manpower in
Islamic Shariah banking.
Lack of linkages with other Islamic banks and
Islamic NGOs for extending micro credit.
31
PEST Analysis
This analysis mainly deals with macro environment that affect banks.
Factors
Political
Economic
Socio-cultural
Technological
Conventional Banks
As our economy greatly influenced by political
instability, our commercial banks are also
affected by this issue.
Commercial banks are highly affected by
monetary and fiscal policies. Tax rate for banks
are 42.50%. Any change in these policies will
affect banks significantly.
Many people avoid commercial banking
products due to presence of interest.
But conventional banks have strong reputation
in corporate world than Islamic banks as most
of them are old and experienced players.
Conventional banks are now providing
e-services frequently to capture the market
especially the corporate clients and the
youth. Now-a-days these banks also providing
debit card facilities which facilitate instant
cash needs such as in time of shopping.
Concluding Remarks
Statutory Liquidity Reserve(SLR) is
the reserve that every scheduled
bank in Bangladesh must maintain
with Bangladesh Bank (BB).
Conventional banks have to
maintain more reserve than Islamic
ones. So they face more difficuty to
balance between liquidity &
profitability.
For Conventional Banks
SLR-19.0% For Islamic Banks
SLR-10%
(Banglapedia: Bangladesh Bank,
accessed 2011)
Islamic banks have flexible
regulations than conventional ones
in case of SLR. So these banks can
invest more funds in market.
Islamic banks have to follow
Shariah principles according to
Islamic Shariah. So these banks
need to improve their efficiency by
maintaining such laws. As
Bangladesh is a Muslim country, so
many people like to get Islamic
32
Islamic banks
Islamic banks are not exceptions.
Same goes for Islamic banks.
Must concentrate on
promotional activities to
attract new customers.
DAMODAR N.
GUJARATI(2006) Essentials of
Econometrics, 3rd ed., USA:
Mc Graw-Hill Irwin.
33
34
35
755.208
7.799 E-02
137
(Constant)
DEPOSIT
LOANS
-1.012E-02
3.652E-02
DEPOSIT
71(076(91
.058
.060
577.084
Std. Error
.098
.092
609.691
2.411
-1.469
Beta
1.337
-.356
Beta
Standardized
Coefficients
Std. Error
Sig.
1.396
-.850
-1.239
1.632 .592
-.968 .882
-.857 .482
Standardized
Coefficients
-.212
-.269
-2977.565
.285
.249
.981
.978
.408
-.118
Partial
.951
.928
Zero-order
Correlations
.561
.317
1868.109
Upper
Bound
Correlations
Upper Zero-order
Bound
1988.471
-.286
-.473
-3378.526
95%
Confidence
Interval for B
Lower Bound
95%
Confidence
Interval for B
Lower Bound
.297
.485
.341
Sig.
-494.547
(Constant)
a.
Unstandardized
Coefficients
Model
Coefficients
Annexure - II
Unstandardized
Coefficients
Model
Coefficients
Annexure - I
.085
-.023
Part
.262
-.160
Part
.004
.004
Tolerance
Collinearity
Statistics
.012
.012
Tolerance
VIF
84.412
84.412
),9
245.031
245.031
Collinearity
Statistics
36
THE FINANCIAL
STATEMENTS OF PUBLIC
BUT NOT LISTED AND
PRIVATE LIMITED
COMPANIES ARE
PREPARED ON THE BASIS
OF THE GUIDELINE GIVEN
IN THE COMPANIES ACT.
IN ONE HAND, THIS
GUIDELINE IS NOT IN
LINE WITH THE
BANGLADESH FINANCIAL
REPORTING STANDARDS;
ON THE OTHER HAND,
THIS GUIDELINE IS NOT
COMPLETE AND
COMPREHENSIVE. DUE
TO HAVING NO
COMPLETE AND
COMPREHENSIVE
GUIDELINE, THE
FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
OF THOSE NON LISTED
AND PRIVATE LIMITED
COMPANIES ARE NOT
BEING PREPARED IN
UNIFORM AND
SYSTEMATIC
MANNER.
37
38
39
40
landscape
The BB mandate
41
42
THE COUNTRY'S
INFLATION, AS MEASURED
BY CONSUMERS' PRICE
INDEX (CPI), MOVED
SLIGHTLY IN DECEMBER
2012 ON POINT-TO-POINT
BASIS. THIS IS MAINLY
BECAUSE OF INCREASE IN
PRICES OF FOOD ITEMS.
THE INFLATION RATE
MOVED UP TO 7.69 PER
Growth Strategy
Interest Rate
The interest rate spread has marked
a declining trend in recent months.
The BB predicts that it would
continue in the near future through
their monitoring and supervision.
Reducing REPO
Falling inflation has created the
space for the repo rate reduction. It
should have an impact on lending
rates. It will also stimulate more
growth-enhancing investments. At
the same time, the BB is mindful of
inflation risks. This is why it has
calibrated the rate cut accordingly.
Balance of Payment
The BB projected that the country's
overall balance of payments (BoP)
would be in surplus to the tune of
$2.226 billion by the end of this
fiscal from $494 million in FY'12.
The current account balance is
likely to rise to $1.075 billion in
FY'13 from $151 million in FY'12.
Comments/
recommendations on few
specific points
(i) Last two MPS
The monetary growth targets set in
January 2012 were met by the end
of FY12 and key outcomes falling
inflation and easing of external
sector pressures were achieved.
The July 2012 MPS had as its core
objectives (i) limiting domestic
credit growth to levels consistent
with the FY13 single digit CPI
inflation target (ii) ensuring that
productive growth-conducive
activities are not hampered by
access to credit and (iii) preserving
external sector stability including
building reserves to more
comfortable levels. Average
inflation has been declining
steadily over the past nine months,
from a peak of 10.96% in February
to 8.74%in December and within
reach of the FY13 CPI inflation
target of 7.5%.
The above achievements are
appreciable. However, statistics of
import of capital machinery and
industrial raw material indicate
negative trend which will lead to
lower production and hamper
employment generation.
(ii) Growth
In 2013, global growth is expected
to be 3.6% with the average for
developing countries projected at
5.6% and high income countries at
1.5%.
The targeted GDP growth of 7.2%
in FY13 is unlikely to be achieved.
43
44
b.
45
d.
e.
46
Month-wise comparison
of reserves among the
three fiscal years
47
48
Concluding remarks
References:
Analytical Review of
Bangladeshs Macroeconomic
Performance in Fiscal Year
2013- Centre for Policy
Dialogue (CPD)
www.tradeeconomics.com
and Bangladesh Bank website.
6
4
2
9.6
11.6
1.9
9.5
1.9
50
BY CONSUMERS' PRICE
AVERAGE INFLATION
14
10
INFLATION, AS MEASURED
Financial Sector Growth Rate and Share of GDP, Source, Annual Report 2011-12, Bangladesh Bank
12
10
8
THE COUNTRY'S
2009-10
2.1
ACHIEVABLE, THOUGH
RISKS REMAIN.
2011
-12
18.4
cr_y
30.6
50.6
48.8
Sri Lanka
9.4
14.4
10.2
13.3
Ir
Pakistan
38.01
38
m2_y
50
Performance
Banking sector: Bangladesh
banking sector has shaped with the
size of total assets of BDT 5867.6
billion & loan and advances of
BDT 3792.5 billion against deposit
of BDT 4509.7 billion as on 31
December 2011, where loan
deposit ratio is 84%, as per Annual
Report 2011-12 of Bangladesh
Bank. Growth rates of total assets
and loan are 27% and 22%
India
77.8
68.7
Bangladesh
100
51
Countries
2009
2010
2011
SCB
6.9
9.0
8.9
11.7
2012
(June)
11.2
DFIs
-5.3
0.4
-7.3
-4.5
-4.3
PCBs
11.4
12.1
10.1
11.5
11.4
FCBs
24.0
28.1
15.6
21
21.5
Total
10.1
11.6
9.3
11.4
11.3
2010
2011
2012(Sept.)
Bangladesh
11.7
9.3
11.4
10.85
India
14.0
14.6
13.5
Sri Lanka
16.1
16.2
14.3
Pakistan
14.0
14.0
14.1
Banks
2008
2009
2010
2011
2012
(June)
NPL
224 8
224.8
227.1
226.4
290
23.8
Req. Prov.
136.1
134.8
149.2
148 2
178.4
3.8
Prov. Made
126 2
137.9
142.3
152.7
167.5
3.2
Excess/(shor all)
-9.9
3.1
-6.9
4.6
-10.9
7.2
Prov. Maint. ra o
92.7
102.3
95.4
103
93.9
2008
2009
2010
2011
2012
(June)
SCB
25.4
21.4
15.7
11.3
13.5
DFIs
25.5
25.9
24.2
24.6
PCBs
FCBs
Total
4.4
19
10.8
3.9
2.3
9.2
3.2
3.0
7.3
2.9
2.9
6.1
52
Income earned to expenses made i.e, income expense ratio could be the
measurement of management efficiency. The total expenditure to total income,
operating expenses to total expenses, earnings and operating expenses per
employee, and interest rate spread are generally used to expose management
soundness and efficiency. Technical competence & leadership of mid and senior
level management, compliance with banking laws and regulations and
compliance of all policies including sound internal policies with adequately and
appropriately, ability to plan and respond to changing circumstances etc. are also
taken into consideration to demonstrate the quality of management.
2011
0.76
-0.63
1.49
2 92
1 27
22.55
-6.95
16.4
17.8
15.6
19.7
-0.9
15.7
16.6
17.0
0 96
0 37
1 55
3.18
1 37
1.14
0 23
2.11
2 93
1 81
1.3
0.1
1.6
3.2
1.5
26.15
-171.68
20.95
22.38
21.72
Expenses-income Rao
2008 2009 2010 2011
SCB
DFIs
PCBs
FCBs
Total
89.6
103.7
88 8
72 9
90.4
7.9
1.9
48.5
12.6
70.90
12.11
1.92
56.71
10.71
81.46
75.6
112.1
72.6
59.0
72.6
80.7
87.8
67.6
64.7
70.8
62.7
88.6
71.7
47.3
68.6
18.43
-3.23
20.9
17.0
21.0
Banks
19.8
6.2
82.8
13.0
121.9
34.3
4.9
91.4
16.1
146.7
Banks
2008
2009
2010
2011
2008
2009
2010
2011
SCBs
DFIs
PCBs
FCBs
Total
32.93
13.73
20.77
31.36
24.83
25.13
9.68
18.28
31.85
20.66
27.22
21.33
21.54
32.18
23.09
34.7
12.3
23.9
30.5
26.5
14.9
4.9
4.7
13.3
8.4
17.6
7.1
5.3
21.8
9.00
8.2
2.3
4.6
13.2
6.0
15.7
2.5
7.0
11.8
9.3
53
1 or strong
2 or Sasfactory
2
3
5
2
28
32
32
33
CAMELS
2008
2009
2010
2011
No. of Banks
3 or Fair
4 or Marginal
10
8
7
9
5 or Unsasfactory
4
4
2
2
4
1
1
1
Total Banks
48
48
47
47
Total
NBFI
1 (strong)
Capital Adequacy
29
18
Asset Quality
29
13
2 (sasfactory)
3 (fair)
4 (Marginal)
5 (unsasfactory)
Management Eciency
29
15
11
29
16
Liquidity
29
16
54
Capital Market: Lets review of the market structure and its price volatility in 2013:
Indicators
No. of listed securi es
As on 28
March-13
516
Indicators
Highest Records
DGEN index
8918
Recent records
20/3/2013
3939
Equi es
243
DSEX Index
4305
3857
3681.66
Mutual Fund
41
36807
2310.27
2242.37
Treasury Bonds
221
32450
1.45
1.16
Corporate Bonds
Debenture
3
8
Annualized P/E
12.85
12.40
Tannery, 0.63
Ceramic, 1.16
Mutual Fund, 1.84
Tex le, 4.67
Cement, 4.56
Bank, 26.02
Recent records
27/03/2013
3794.29
19.25, 2 3%
62.81, 77%
Life
56
Non-life
59.74, 95%
State Owned-JBC
Private
17.27, 90%
100%
600,000
500,000
Total
Assets, 167,47
3
400,000
Investment, 12
4,102
300,000
200,000
Life Fund
147,600
Premium
, 58,159
100,000
-
Total
Assets, 202,94
6
80%
Total
Assets, 44580
60%
Investment, 15
3,318
Life Fund
177,381
Premium
, 62,814
40%
20%
Investment, 22
926
Premium, 165
44
0%
Premium, 192
49
2011
2011
Life Fund
Investment, 28
360
2010
2010
Premium
Total
Assets, 55444
Investment
Total Assets
Premium
Investment
Total Assets
57
Basic fact
No. of Central Cooperative Societies: 21
Amongst them some of famous national Co-operatives are: Bangladesh Milk Producers Cooperative Union Ltd.
(Milk Vita), Bangladesh Samabaya Bank Ltd., Bangladesh Jatiya Samabaya Shilpa Samity Ltd., Bangladesh Samabaya
Shilpa Sangstha Ltd., The Eastern Cooperative Jute Society Ltd. etc.
No. of Central Cooperative Societies : 1,107
No. of Member of C
ooperative Societies : 1,33,188
Working Capital of Cooperative Societies: : Tk. 1,026.80 crore
Name?
No. of Primary Cooperative Societies : 163,408
No. of Member of Primary Cooperative Societies : 8,505,738
Working Capital foCooperative Societies : Tk.1,909 38 crore
Name?
58
June, 2008
293
15,077
98,896
23.45
17.79
134,680.96
June, 2009
418
16,851
107,175
24.85
18.89
143,134.03
47,386.19
50.610.04
Portfolio Yield
BRAC
ASA
Bureau Bangladesh
TMSS
Jagorani Chakra Foundation
Society for Social Services
Shakti Foundation for Disadvantage
Women
United Development Initiatives for
Programmed Actions- UDDIPON
Pdakkheo Manabik Unyan Kendra
RDRS Bangladesh
Average of TOP 10 NGOs
Average of 576 NGOs
The Bangladesh Accountant
June, 2010
516
17,252
109,597
25.28
19.21
145,022.66
June, 2011
576
158,066
111,828
26.08
20.65
173,797.60
51,362.93
63,304.44
Micro
Enterprise
Loan, 41, 23%
Micro Credit
28.83
26.32
31.80
23.54
23.1
25.05
28.28
Interest
rate Spread
22.323
22.61
20.79
18.42
16.24
19.12
19.36
Return On
Assets
2.77
10.27
0.52
2.38
5.88
4.8
4.22
Operational
Self Sufficiency
111.09
159.26
95.93
105.58
135.87
118.25
118.07
24.67
18.96
1.8
103.12
21.84
23.72
25.72
20.33
15.42
19.36
19.26
16.26
1.12
3.53
3.73
1.18
92.67
99.07
113.89
102.88
59
Micro finance fund is comprised of generally fund from donors, Palli Karma Sahayak Foundation (PKSF), banks,
clients savings, surplus over expenses etc. The fund composition of micro fianc as per the said report is
below:
Fund Composition of micro credit (BDT, bn):
200
8.85
36.26
23.9
22.67
40.53
150
4.43
31.17
23.48
22.71
3 64
100
50
0
2008
Clients' Savings
2009
Loan from PKSF
Stability:
IMF conducted the Financial
System Stability Assessment of
Bangladesh Financial system in
2009 based on the Financial Sector
Assessment Program (FSAP) and
published the report in February
2010. The key findings of that
report are:
60
23.58
31.77
63.3
2010
2011
Donors' Fund
7.73
50.3
10.91
42.34
23.01
24.48
47.44
Nevertheless, significant
long-standing risks and
vulnerabilities remain. Loan
classification, provisioning,
and even capital remain
uneven in the banking sector,
creating potential
vulnerabilities. Non-prudential
government
interventionsuch as interest
rate ceilings, moral suasion,
directed credit and explicit
requirements to ease debt
service for some sectors of the
economyincreases risks,
reduces transparency, and
Cumultaive surplus
Other funds
10
20
30
40
50
60
61
Categories
Factors, Policies and Ins tu ons
1.
2.
3.
Pillars
Ins tu onal Environment
Business Environment
Financial Stability
2.
Financial Intermedia on
4.
5.
6.
FINANCIAL
INTERMEDIARIES
3.
Financial Access
7.
Financial Access
POLICY MAKERS
Each of above 7 pillars has equal weight of 14.29% (14.29x7=100%) and is sub categorized with weight
within each pillars weight of 14.29. However, the rank was finally awarded for a country based on the rank
and value of 7 pillars obtained from sub categories rank & value of seven pillars based on the value & rank of
121 indicators under sub categories (i.e, 121 Indicators ranking- 24 subcategories ranking-7 Pillars rankingCountry ranking). In 2012 amongst 62 countries, 20 countries of Asia were placed in the rank of worlds
leading financial systems and capital markets that may be presented below:
Total Score
5.31
4. Singapore
4.9
7. Japan
4.42
18. Malaysia
4.03
21. Kuwait
23. China
24. Israel
3.94
25. Bahrain
3.93
3.84
26. UAE
3.68
3.56
34. Thailand
3.55
3.29
40. India
3.13
47. Kazakhstan
3.12
2.95
50. Indonesia
2.92
52.Vietnam
57. Bangladesh
262
2.61
62
Score
out of 7
2.5
1.1
3.3
2.9
2.6
Remarks
Each of four categories of
Bangladesh is about last ranked
from 58 to 62 out of total 62. 22
indicators out of 26 vulnerable and
hence, significant reforms are
needed to develop the following
indicators under the pillar
Institutional Environing:
-capital account liberalization
-Commitments to WTO
Agreements on trade Services
-Extent of incentive based
compensation
-Efficiency of corporate boards
Reliance on professional
management
-Willingness to delegate
-Ethical behavior of firms
-Protection of minority
shareholders interest
-Regulation of securities exchange
-Property rights
-Intellectual property protection
-Diversion of public funds
-Public trust in politicians
-Corruptions perceptions index
-Central bank transparency
-Judicial independence
-Irregular payments in judicial
decisions
-Time to enforce a contract
-Number of procedures to enforce
a contract
- Cost of enforcing contracts
Out of 26 Indicators of
four categories, only
three indicators such as
burden of government
regulation (33),
Strength of legal right
index (24) and Strength
of investor protection
index (17) have good
and moderate rank. One
indicator Domestic
financial sector
liberalization was not
applicable.
63
2.Business
Environment
-Human
Capital
-Taxes
-Infrastructure
-Cost of doing
business
62
62
55
62
57
2.7
2.8
3.4
1.4
3.1
3.Financial
Stability
-Current
Stability
-Banking
system
Stability
-Risk of
Sovereign
debt crisis
37
9
23
52
4.4
5.6
4.6
2.8
64
Out of 22 indicators of
four categories only 5
indicators such as,
Distortive effective on
taxes (37), Time to pay
taxes (46), cost of
closing a business (17),
Time to start a business
(37) Time to close a
business (48) are in
moderate index where
reforms also required to
develop more.
4.Banking
Financial
Services
-Size index
-Efficiency
index
-Financial
information
disclosure
50
41
35
59
3.00
2.00
5.00
1.00
5.Nonbanking
financial
Services
-IPO activity
-M & A
activity
-Insurance
Securitization
60
35
61
59
58
1.2
1.3
1.0
1.4
1.0
Out of 14 indicators of
three categories, 2 have
very good ranked such
as, Central bank assets
to GDP (18) and
Aggregate profitability
indicator (2) and 9
indicators such as
deposit money bank
assets to GDP (43),
Financial systems
deposit to GDP (38). M2
To GDP (45), private
credit to GDP (45), Bank
deposit to GDP (39),
money market
instrument to GDP (33),
bank overhead costs
(37), bank operating
costs to assets (32) and
public credit registry
coverage (32) are seems
to be moderate where
development is also
needed.
Out of 14 indicators we
have 6 indicators good
and moderate rank on
Life Insurance Density
(15) IPO market share
(42), IPO access amount
(34), Share of world
IPOs (20), life insurance
penetration (43) and
non life insurance
density (33). Yet,
reforms are also needed
in these area to improve
the Non-banking
financial services pillar
One indicator is not
applicable for
Bangladesh.
65
6.Financial
Markets
7.Financial
Access
66
-Foreign
exchange
markets
-Derivatives
market
-Equity
market
development
-Bond
market
development
41
n/a
-Commercial
access
-Retail
excess
51
56
37
n/a
31
1.8
n/a
n/a
2.6
1.0
53
2.8
2.8
2.9
Out of 17 indicators we
have only good ranked
on stock market
turnover ratio (4) and
another 3 have
Out of 17 indicators, reforms
moderate rank such as
measures should be taken to
Private domestic bond
develop on the following4
market capitalization to
vulnerable indicators:
GDP (42), stock market
value traded to GDP
-Stock Market capitalization to
(40) and Public domestic
GDP
bond market
-No. of listed companies per
capitalization to GDP
10,000 peoples
(45). 9 Indicators are
-Private international bonds to
related to derivatives
GDP
foreign exchange swap
-Public international bonds to
that are not related to
GDP
Bangladesh.
Out of 12 indicators we
One category retail excess is
have very good ranked
ranked 37, seems to be moderate.
for 2 such as, Loan
Out of 12 indicators reforms
account to MFIs (5) and
measures should be taken to
Loan form a financial
develop the following 4 vulnerable institutions (3) and 6
indicators:
seem to be moderate
like ease of access to
-Financial market sophistication
credit (40), financing
-Venture capital availability
through local equity
-Foreign Direct investment to GDP market (34), ease of
-Debit card penetration
access to loans (48),
market penetration of
bank accounts (44),
commercial bank
branches (45) and total
number of ATMs (48)
where reforms are also
needed.
Out of four categories, bond
market development is ranked 53
and equity market development
seems to be moderate.
67
68
69
70
71
THERE ARE
PEOPLE, WE CAN NEVER
FORGET; THEY LIVE BY
THEIR WORDS; THEIR
DEEDS ARE THE
TREASURES OF THE
FUTURE GENERATION.
I AM REMEMBERING A
MAN HAVING GREAT
VIRTUES; ICAB WAS IN
HIS HEART-A
LEGENDARY
ACCOUNTING
Accountants of Pakistan and was
continuously elected to the Council
until 1971. He was elected its Vice
President three times as well. In
recognition of his merit the erstwhile
government of Pakistan awarded him
the honorific title T. Pk., which he
relinquished in 1971. Upon
independence of Bangladesh, Mr.
Chowdhury was instrumental in
piloting the Institute of Chartered
Accountants of Bangladesh. He was
elected to the office of President of
the Institute upon its establishment in
January 1973.
Late Mufazzal Hussain Chowdhury
had paved the way for us in the
profession and always focused on its
advancement. He endowed two
scholarships for CA students, but did
not name these after him. It is only
after his death that the Article
Students Committee, decided to
name the scholarships as M. H.
Chowdhury Scholarship.
I was touched by his courteousness
and magnanimity despite his seniority
and iconic stature in the profession
when he e-mailed me to wish on
Eid-ul-fitr in August 2011. He wished
72
PROFESSIONALS, FOR
WHOM WE CAN ALL BE
PROUD OF. HE IS
MUFAZZAL HUSSAIN
CHOWDHURY FCA.
KNOWN TO US AS M H
CHOWDHURY.
73
74
II.
75
76
Preparing Accountants
for Future Challenges
ICAB President Md Abdus Salam in an interview with
the Daily Star States that existing curricula match global standards
77
78
Dividend
distribution
tax
a) where declared dividend
does not exceed 50% of
Paid-up
capital...........................15%
b) Where declared dividend
exceeds 50% of the
Paid-up capital..........................
25%
Provided that the Provision of this
Section shall not apply in case of
dividend referred to in sub clause
(dd) and sub clause (e) of clause
(26) of Section 2 of the
Ordinance..
........................................................
...
New Para 21A with the following
provision may be inserted after
Para 21 of Part A of the Sixth
Schedule of the Ordinance.
Any income from dividend for
which dividend distribution tax
is payable by the company
02.
Special provision for computing profits and gains of foreign companies engaged in the business of civil construction, errection, testing or commissioning
in connection with turnkey project
Page 1 of 12
Section
Reference
Subject Matter
Existing provision/Situation
Proposal
Reasons/Justification
To increase Revenue
from foreign contractors
and justified imposition
of tax on contract under
turnkey project.
Section
Reference
Subject Matter
Existing provision/Situation
crore)
6. Where the payment
5%
exceeds
taka
3,00,00,000
(three
crore)
7. In case of oil supplied by oil
marketing companies(a) Where the payment does not
exceed taka 2,00,000 (two
lakh)..............................................
Nil
(b) where the payment exceeds
taka 2,00,000 (two
lakh).......................0.75%
Proposal
Reasons/Justification
3,00,00,000 (three
crore)
6. Where the payment
6%
exceeds
taka
3,00,00,000 (three
crore)
7. In case of oil supplied by oil
marketing companies(a) Where the payment does
not exceed taka 2,00,000 (two
lakh)..........................................
...Nil
(b) where the payment exceeds
taka 2,00,000 (two
lakh).................0.75%
04. To introduce higher rate of TDS if the person receiving payment does not have TIN certificate and VAT registration certificate.
52A &
52AA
05. Introduction of withholding tax @ 1% from gross payment to freight forwarders against any sea freight, Airfreight, other
charges and commission etc. and deletion of existing section 52M.
52M
Connection of tax U/S 52M Freight forwarding agency As worldwide freight forwarding
Enhancement of
from
freight commission is subject to deduction of business run on revenue sharing
revenue
forwarders
tax at source @ 15%
basis, rather than commission
Control of tax
basis hence to ensure revenue
evasion
collection and control on the
expenditure
claim,
it
is
recommended that :
TDS will be on gross
amount payable to freight
forwarder @ 1%.
Existing provision u/s-52M
may be deleted.
06. Introduction of collection of tax at source from subcontractors of RMG by the Industrial exporters @ 0.8% where the
payment is made without establishing any Back to Back letter of credit or local letter of credit and consider such income u/s
82 (C).
Technically subcontract is included Collection of tax at source from To ensure revenue from
under section 52 for deduction of tax subcontractors of RMG by the this sector.
at source.
Industrial exporters @ 0.8% is
recommended where the payment
Practically the above situation of is made without establishing any
subcontractors of RMG is not always Back to Back letter of credit or
considered
local letter of credit and such
income may be considered for
assessment u/s 82(C).
07. Increase of rate of TDS from agent of foreign buyer @10% instead of existing 7.5%
Page 3 of 12
Section
Reference
53EE
Subject Matter
Existing provision/Situation
Proposal
Where, in accordance with the terms The rate of seven and a half
of the letter of credit or under any percent may be increased to ten
other instruction, a bank, through percent
which an exporter receives payment
for export of goods, pays any amount
out of the export proceeds to the credit
of any person being an agent or a
representative of the foreign buyer, as
commission, charges or remuneration
by whatever name it may be called,
the bank shall deduct or collect tax in
advance at the rate of [seven and a half
percent] on the commission, charges
or remuneration so paid at the time of
such payment.
08. To introduce TDS from payment of signing money by the real estate developers.
The developer shall deduct tax
Collection of tax
@10% at the time of payment
from
signing
from the person receiving such
money
money.
Deduction of tax
from commission
or remuneration
paid to agent of
foreign buyer
Reasons/Justification
Stream of revenue will
be increased.
To ensure collection of
Govt. revenue.
13. Change of Rule 33B to impose higher tax on rent free accommodation.
Rule 33B Rent
free For rent free accommodation, the Proposed to change the Rule as To maintain relevance
accommodation
rental value of the accommodation or follows:
with Rule 33A.
25% of the basic salary whichever is
Page 4 of 12
Section
Reference
Subject Matter
Existing provision/Situation
Proposal
Reasons/Justification
This
will
remove
unnecessary
complication in the
process of assessment.
Page 5 of 12
II.
Section
Reference
Subject Matter
Existing provision/Situation
Proposal
Reasons/Justification
19. Modification of provisions for Charge of Mimimum tax for company to enjoy the previlge of reduced or special rate of taxes granted under
different provisions of the Ordinance unless the provisions of Section 16CCC are removed.
Section
1 Notwithstanding anything contained To facilitate the exemptions granted
As
the
companies,
Charge of
16CCC
in any other provisions of this under Part A of Sixth Schedule of ITO- enjoying tax holiday and
minimum tax
Ordinance, every company shall, 1984 and benefit of reduced rate of
the
tax
exempted
taxes and exemptions and concessions
irrespective of its profits or loss in an under different SROs or orders issued
companies have no tax
while there are several
assessment year for any reason by NBR, it is necessary to introduce a
whatsoever, including the sustaining provisio before the word Explanation implication payment of
minimum tax in field
of a loss, the setting off of a loss of of Section 16CCC
earlier year or years or the claiming of Provided that nothing contained in this level, an explanation is
allowances or deductions (including section shall apply to classes of income required on the issue
referred in section 82(C) of the
regarding payment of
depreciation) allowed under this ordinance, Part A of Sixth Schedule of
minimum tax.
Ordinance, be liable to pay minimum the ordinance and the reduced rate of
tax at the rate of zero point five zero taxes referred under different SROs or
For instances, some
(0.50%) per cent of the amount General Order for the time being in
companies are paying
representing such company's gross force
Page 6 of 12
Section
Reference
Subject Matter
Existing provision/Situation
Proposal
Reasons/Justification
20. Amendment to allow the subsequent refund of relevant loans as allowable deduction in the year of repayment if made
through Account Payee Cheque or bank transfer.
19(26)
Receiving loan Where an assessee, being a company, New proviso may be inserted
Fundamental principle of
by company
receives any amount as loan from any
Single point tax to be
other person otherwise than by a Provided that where the loan in established.
crossed cheque or by bank transfer, this sub section is paid back in
the amount so received shall be subsequent income year, the
deemed to be the income of such amount so paid through account
assessee for that income year in which payee cheque or bank transfer
such loan was taken and shall be shall be deducted in computing the
classifiable under the head "Income income in respect of that
from other sources"
subsequent year
21. Amendment to allow the subsequent refund of relevant loans as allowable deduction in the year of repayment if made
through Account Payee Cheque or bank transfer.
19(28)
Fundamental principle of
Single point tax to be
Provided that where the loan in established.
this sub section is paid back in
subsequent income year, the
amount so paid through account
payee cheque or bank transfer
shall be deducted in computing the
income in respect of that
subsequent year
22. NBFIs Interest income in relation to classified loan should be treated in consistent with commercial and specialized banks.
Section
Income
from Existing Section: 28 (3) reads as The word and after the words All the activities of Non
Bangladesh Krishi Bank may be Banking
28(3) of
business
or follows:
Financial
replaced with a coma and the Institutions (NBFIs) are
ITO 1984 profession.
Notwithstanding anything to the words and any Non Banking supervised and controlled
contrary contained in any other Financial institutions may be by Bangladesh Bank
provisions of this Ordinance, in the inserted after the words Rajshahi similar to commercial
banks. Like commercial
case of Bangladesh Shilpa Bank, Krishi Unnayan Bank.
banks, NBFIs are required
Bangladesh Shilpa Rin Sangstha,
to comply more or less
Investment Corporation of Bangladesh
with all the regulatory
and any commercial bank including
requirements particularly
the Bangladesh Krishi Bank and
in terms of lending, capital
Rajshahi Krishi Unnayan Bank, the
adequacy,
risk
income by way of interest in relation
management,
to such categories of bad or doubtful
provisioning, etc. As
debts as the Bangladesh Bank may
NBFIs are regulated by the
classify in the income year in which it
same
authority
and
is credited to its profit and loss
through similar regulations
account for that year or, as the case
like commercial banks, tax
may be, in which it is actually
treatment for same issue
received, whichever is earlier.
should be done in the
similar way.
23. Increase of allowable limit of perquisite to Tk. 3,50,000 from Tk. 2,50,000 (Per person per year)
30(e)
Deduction
not The maximum limit of allowable The amount may reasonably be Taka
250,000
as
admissible
in perquisite is Taka 250,000.
increased to Taka 350,000
allowable limit is quite
certain
inadequate considering
circumstances
the present economic
situation.
24. Enhancement of rate of investment tax credit to 15% instead of 10%
Section
Investment
tax Present rate of investment tax credit is Proposed to increase the rate to It was 15% up to the
44(2)(b)
credit
10%
15% to encourage investment
year 2007 now to be
reintroduced considering
general
growth
of
Page 7 of 12
Section
Reference
Subject Matter
Existing provision/Situation
Proposal
Reasons/Justification
investment trend.
25. Extension of exemption of tax of newly established industrial undertaking setup between the period July 2011 to June 2015
instead of July 2011 to June 2013.
Section - Exemption from Specified Industrial Undertaking setup Such exemption may be extended Considering
industry
46B
tax of Newly between the period of 1st day of July to the new industrial undertaking specific incentive
Established
2011 and 30th June 2013 are eligible setup by June 2015.
for exemption of tax for five years at
Industrial
different rates based on location and
Undertakings.
year as well.
26. Extension of exemption of tax of newly established physical infrastructure facility setup between the period July 2011 to June
2015 instead of July 2011 to June 2013.
Section - Exemption from tax Newly
established
physical Such exemption may be extended To encourage the sector
46C
of
Newly infrastructure facility set up between to the new physical infrastructure and
infrastructure
Established Physical the period of 1st day of July 2011 and facility setup by June 2015.
development
of the
30th June 2013 are eligible for
Infrastructure
country.
exemption of tax for five years at
Facility.
different rates.
27. Timing and audit of return U/S 75A.
75(A) 2(C) Return
of Return under Section 75A is to be Proposed that the return along To ensure reliability of
withholding tax filed by the fifteenth day of October, with certificate from a Chartered the return and to make
January, April and July of the Accountants is to be filed by the the submission more
financial year for which the tax is next thirty days from the end of easy.
deducted or collected;
the quarter.
28. To make exercise of section 82C optional and to delete sub section (6), (7) and (8) u/s 82 (C)
82(C)
Tax on income of The provision of sub-section (6) (7) a) To include the following
certain persons
and (8) of section 82C provide for
sections for final discharge of
imposition of additional tax over and
tax: 52A, 53BBBB, 53E, ;
above the tax deducted at source.
b) Sub sections (6), (7) and (8) of
section 82C may be deleted in
order to restore the original
idea of final settlement.;
c) The assesses eligible for final
discharge of tax liability under
section 82(C) may exercise the
option for final settlement or
not.
This
is
obviously
unreasonable and against
the basic principle of
Final Settlement. and
self-contradictory. This
self-contradiction may
be removed by deleting
those
sub-sections.
Moreover, basically at
present there are
no
difference
between
normal assessment and
assessment under section
82C. Hence assessment
under
section
82C
should be optional.
This is a tax-payer
friendly measure and its
progress would promote
tax-payers confidence as
well as improve revenue
collection.
Section
Subject Matter
Existing provision/Situation
Proposal
Reference
31. Revision of the allowable limit of Motor Vehicle for claiming normal depreciation.
3rd Schedule Maximum
At present the ceiling is Tk. 20 Lakh
Recommended to increase the
11(6) (a)
Allowable Cost
limit to Tk. 40 Lakh
of
a
Motor
Vehicle
for
Normal
Depreciation
Allowance
32. Allowance of amortization/depreciation on intangible assets.
To
Allow
Amortization/De
Amortization/Depreciation
on
preciation
on
Intangible Assets like License fee,
Intangible Assets
etc. as Deductible Expenses in
case of Information Technology
Related Companies including
Mobile Operator and other
Telecom Companies, a new
provision may be included in 3rd
Schedule
33. Extension of time for exemption to handicraft exporters
6th
Exemption
of Exempted up to 30.06.2013
May be extend to 30.06.2015
Schedule, Income
from
of
Part-A, Para Export
- 35,
Handicrafts.
34. Enhancement of limit of yearly turnover of SME and clear definition of SME may be introduced.
6th
Exclusion
of Presently, Maximum Yearly Turnover Recommended to increase the
Schedule, SME
income of Tk. 24 lakh is set as pre-condition limit of Maximum Yearly
Part-A, Para from the total for exclusion of Income of Small and Turnover to 50 Lakh as a pre- 39
income
Medium Enterprise (SME).
condition for exclusion of Income
of Small and Medium Enterprise
(SME). Further separate definition
of SME should be introduced.
35. Exemption to commercial producer of Biogas.
Production of
To include in the Sixth schedule
Biogas
to extend the exemption facility to
commercially
the producers of
Biogas
commercially
36. Time limit to deposit TDS to be specific
Rule 13
Time limit for
Income tax deducted at source is to be Proposed to change the Rule to
payment of tax
deposited within three weeks from the allow deposit of withholding tax
deducted at source date of deduction or collection
within the immediate next month
of deduction.
37. Enhancement of exemption limit of house rent allowance from Tk. 15,000 to Tk. 25,000 per month
Rule-33A House
rent The limit for exempted house rent This may reasonably be increased
allowance
allowance for an employee is Taka to Taka 25,000 per month.
receivable in cash 15,000 per month.
37. Increase of exemption limit in respect of conveyance allowance from Tk. 24,000 to Tk. 48,000 p.a.
Rule - 33C Maximum
Existing limit is Tk. 24,000 (Tk. 2,000 Proposed to increase the same to
Exemption Limit per month)
Tk. 48,000 (Tk. 4,000 per month)
of Conveyance
Allowance
receivable in cash
Reasons/Justification
Considering increased
price of motor vehicle
Considering
industry
specific incentive
This
amount
is
unchanged since 2008
and quite low.
Section
Reference
Subject Matter
Existing provision/Situation
Proposal
Reasons/Justification
Expenditure on & 0.50% respectively in the case of a Pharmaceutical Industry and to businesses
Distribution
of Pharmaceutical Industry and 1.5%, 2%, 0.75% & 0.375% in the case
0.75% & 0.375% respectively in the of Other Industries.
Free Samples
case of Other Industries.
40. Increase of the limit of total income for individuals from Tk. 2,00,000 to Tk. 2,50,000 for tax imposition.
Finance
Threshold
for The exempted income for individuals Tax exempted income for General price index has
Act, 2012 exempted income is Taka 200,000
individuals should be raised from gone up significantly
Taka 200,000 to at least 250,000. during the year. This
justifies the increase.
41. Enhancement of limit of net wealth imposing surcharge
Finance
Surcharge
in The minimum limit for imposition of This amount may be increased This amount is rather
low in view of the fact
Act, 2012 addition
to surcharge is Taka 2 crore of net reasonably
that value of property
wealth.
assessed tax
has gone up remarkably
in recent years
42. Corporate tax rate of banks and financial institutions may be reduced to 40% instead of 42.5%
Finance
Corporate tax rate Corporate tax rate is quite high Corporate tax rate may be reduced Our corporate tax rate is
Act, 2012
compared to other regional countries, to 40% particularly for the much higher compared
particularly the rate for banks and financial institution, banks.
to
other
regional
financial institutions 42.5% is
countries. This is a
unusually high
discouraging factor for
corporate growth and
FDI
43. Corporate Tax Rate for trading and manufacturing company should be different
Finance
Corporate tax rate There is no difference in Tax rate for There should be at least difference The
manufacturing
Act, 2012
trading and manufacturing companies of 2.5% in corporate Tax rate, companies add more
manufacturing companies being @ value and employment to
35% and trading company @ 35% the economy.
43. Corporate Tax Rate for mobile phone operating companies should be lesser than cigarette manufacturing companies
Finance
Corporate tax rate Tax Rate for mobile phone operating Tax rate for both mobile phone Health
and
Act, 2012
companies-45%
operating companies and cigarette environmental reasons.
manufacturing companies should
Tax Rate for cigarette manufacturing be 42.5%.
companies -42.5% for non-publicly
trading company.
44. Corporate Tax Rate should not be higher than individual Tax rate
Finance
Corporate tax rate Base Corporate tax rate -37.5%
Corporate Tax Rate should not be High corporate Tax rates
Act, 2012
Corporate tax rate for Publicly Traded higher than individual Tax rate.
discourage FDI and also
Company declaring dividend more
local investment.
than @20% - 24.75%; if dividend is
declared@10% to 20% - 27.5%; and if
dividend is declared less than @10% 37.5%
Highest individual Tax rate -25%.
45. Tax rebate for dividend shall be eligible for all companies
Finance
Corporate tax rate 10% Tax rebate available for publicly Tax rebate for dividend shall be To be Just and fair.
Act, 2012
traded companies for declaring eligible for all companies and
dividing more than @ 20% is not penalty for non-payment of
available for bank, insurance and dividend minimum @10% should
financial institutions. There is no also be applicable for mobile
conditionality of declaring dividend phone and cigarette manufacturing
for mobile phones and cigarette companies.
manufacturing companies for reduced
Tax rate of @35% from their base rate
of @45% and 42.5%.
46. Introduction of progressive tax rate for SMEs
Finance
Corporate tax rate None
A progressive tax rate for SMEs To encourage the SMEs
Act, 2012
either base on turnover or profit
and
employment
may
be
introduced
47. Interest payable by the assessee on deficiency in payment of advance tax
Section
Interest payable The period for which interest under The period for which interest Income Tax Ordinance
73(2)
by the assessee sub-section (1) shall be payable shall under sub-section (1) shall be prescribes
uniform
Page 10 of 12
Section
Reference
Subject Matter
Existing provision/Situation
Proposal
Reasons/Justification
Section
Subject Matter
Existing provision/Situation
Reference
50. To remove the Conflicting provisions
SRO
No. To remove the The SRO provides that the tax rate for
269/2010,
conflicting
a Company being a Sponsor
dated
provisions
Shareholder is 10% whereas the
01.07.2010
Section 53M provides that the 5%
and of the
TDS on such income is Final Tax
Section
liability U/S 82C.
53M
Page 12 of 12
Proposal
Reasons/Justification
2
2
2
2
3
3
3
3
4
5
5
6
7
8
8
9
10
11
12
12
12
13
13
14
14
14
15
15
15
Sl.
No.
Reference
Section/Rule/
SRO/Order
Existing
Provision/Situation
Proposal
Reasons / Justifications
cv - 2
Sl.
No.
Reference
Section/Rule/
SRO/Order
Existing
Provision/Situation
Proposal
Reasons / Justifications
miKvii -Gi
GmAviI bs180/AvBb/
2012/638g~mK| ZvwiL 7
Ryb, 2012
wLv
L) Abvb t
eemvqx KZK cY, Avg`vwb ev q ev ARb ev msMn I cY weqi mv_ m mevi Dci iqvZ Mnbi myweav_ DcKiYi msv cwieZb t
o eemvqxi cY msMn Ges
wewi Z_v eemv
cwiPvjbvi Rb wewfb mev Mnb
Riix (hgb wevcb, exgv,
dBU divqvwWs, wKqvwis I
aviv (2) Gi `dv (M) Gi DcdivqvwWs, cwienb wVKv`vi,
`dv (Av) Gi wbic cwZvcb
evsK KZK Fbc mev
Kivi cve Kiv njt
BZvw`)| eZgvb D mev
(Av) eemvq cwiPvjbvi ,
mg~ni Dci cwikvwaZ g~mKi
DcKiY
weq, wewbgq ev cKvivi n (Av) eemvq cwiPvjbvi ,
iqvZ Mnb meci nq bv| hvnv
aviv (2) Gi
1
vii Dk Avg`vbxKZ, weq, wewbgq ev cKvivi
(Input) Gi
`dv (M)
eemv cwiPvjbvi Cost
qKZ, AwRZ ev Ab Kvbfve nvii Dk Avg`vwbKZ,
msv
of Doing Business-K ew
msMnxZ cY;
qKZ, AwRZ ev AbKvbfve
KiQ Ges DcKiY Ki iqvZ
msMnxZ cY Ges cY, Avg`vwb
Mnbi g~mKi gwjK
ev q ev ARb ev msMn I cY
bxwZi mv_ mvsNwlKI eU|
weqi mv_ m mev|
ZvB eemv cwiPvjbv eq
nvmKiY Ges g~mKi gwjK
bxwZi evevqbi Rb AvBbi
cvweZ mskvabx AZxe Riix|
mev ivwbi ivwbi cwZ mywbw`KiY t
wewa 27 Gi Dc-wewa 10-G ev
bZzb Dc-wewa 11 mshvRbi
gvag mev ivwbi
wbwjwLZ welqjv Afy Kiv
hZ cvi t
(K) mev ivwbi Rb mev
mieivnKvix
Ges
mev
wewa-27-G cY ivwbi cwZ MnYKvixi
ga
^vwiZ
wevwiZfve eYbv Kiv AvQ AxKvic
(jUvi
Ae
2 wewa 27
ivwb cwZ
wKmev ivwbi cwZ we GbMRgU) _vKZ nBe;
vwiZfve Dj-L Kiv bB|
(L) mev ivwbi g~mK
Pvjvbc c`vb KwiZ nBe;
(M) mev ivwbi wecixZ
e`wkK
gy`v
evsjv`k
cZvevwmZ nBZ nBe; Ges
(N) e`wkK gy`v cvwi `wjj
`vwLjci mwnZ mshy KwiZ
nBe|
KUvi KZK mve-KUviK mev g~j ev Kwgkb cwikvai mgq g~mK Drm KZb bv Kiv cm t
GB avivi Abvb weavbvejx e`wkK mvnvhc~ kjv
mI, Kvb wbewZ ew KZK wejy Kivi Rb cve Kiv nj|
c`q g~j mshvRb Ki evW aygv e`wkK mvnvhcy cK
aviv (6) Gi
cwikvai mgq KZK, wewa viv wbavwiZ bq, eis Abvb cKI Gic
3 Aaxb Dc-aviv
I cwZ
cwZZ, mev MnYKvix ev, myweav cvIqvi AwaKvix nIqv
(4KK)
gZ, mevi g~j ev Kwgkb DwPZ| G aviv 6(4KK)
cwikvaKvix KZK mevi g~j ev Gi Abvb mKj kZ AcwiewZZ
Kwgkb cwikvaKvj Drm _vKv DwPZ|
cv - 3
Sl.
No.
Reference
Section/Rule/
SRO/Order
Existing
Provision/Situation
Av`vq ev KZbc~eK miKvix
URvixZ Rgv KwiZ nBet
Proposal
Reasons / Justifications
mev mieivnKvix ewK
wbqvM `b Ges mevg~j ev
Kwgkb c`vb Kib ZLb mgy`q
mevg~j _K g~j weqvRb
nq| G g~j mshvRb nq
bv|
Ze kZ _vK h, e`wkK
mvnvhc~ Kvb cKi AvIZvq
Kvb mev MnYKvix KZK c`q
g~j mshvRb Ki hw` mev
MnYKvix ev, gZ, mevi
o weqvRbi Dci g~j mshvRb
g~j ev Kwgkb cwikvaKvix
Ki Avivc Kiv g~mK bxwZi
ew mevi g~j ev Kwgkb
mv_ mvsNwlK| Z_v AwaK g~mK
cwikvaKvj evW KZK, wewa
Avivc/cwikva Kiv nQ hv
viv wbavwiZ cwZZ Drm
eemv cwiPvjbv eqK ew
Av`vq ev KZbc~eK miKvix
KiQ,
`ki
A_bwZK
URvixZ Rgv Kib Ges D
AeKvVvgv wbgvYi weic
mev mieivnKvix ew KZK
cwZwqv mw KiQ Ges Ki
D mgy`q mevi Askwekl
duvwKi cebZv ew KiQ|
mieivni Kvb mve-KUvi,
GRU ev Ab Kvb mev
o hnZz KUvii m~Y mevg~j
mieivnKvix ewK wbqvM
ev Kwgkbi Dci g~mK Drm
Kib, mB D mev
KZb Kiv nQ Ges miKvix
mieivnKvixi
mve-KUvi,
KvlvMvi Rgv c`vb KiQ,
GRU ev wbqvMKZ Ab Kvb
mnZz mve-KUvii Dci g~mK
mev mieivnKvix ewi wbKU
Avivc Kiv g~mK Gi gwjK
nBZ, D mevi Dci cv_wgK
bxwZi mv_ mvsNwlK|
chvq chvR g~j mshvRb Ki
Av`vq ev KZb Ges miKvix
URvixZ Rgv c`vbi `vwjwjK
cgvYvw` Dcvcb mvc
cybivq Drm g~j mshvRb Ki
Av`vq Kiv hvBe bv|
DcKiYi qg~j ev g~j mshvRbi cwieZbi cwigvY NvwlZ gybvdvi mv_ mg^qi myhvM _vKv mvc g~j NvlYv bv `Iqv Ges iqvZ KZb bv Kiv
cm t
o DcKiYi g~j ev g~j
aviv (9) Gi Aaxb Dc-aviv (1) aviv (9) Gi Aaxb Dc-aviv (1)
mshvRbi cwigvY ew cj
Gi
`dv
(QQ)
Z
ejv
nqQ
h
Gi `dv (QQ) t
hw` cYi weqg~j ew bv Kiv
DcKiYi bvg g~j wfwi ga
nq Zvnj ewcv AskUzKz
Afy _vKj mB DcKiYi
aviv 5 Gi
gybvdvi mv_ mg^q nq| ZvB
Dci iqvZ cv nBe Ges
Dc-aviv (2) G G g~j NvlYvq c`wkZ
weq g~j ew bv cj
Dwj-wLZ
cYi DcKiY g~ji nvm ew iqvZ
mskvwaZ g~j NvlYvi cqvRb
KihvM
g~j MnYi wfw nBe bv|
bvB| G g~mK KZc
aviv (9) Gi
wfwi ga Afy Abvw`K, wewa (3) Gi Aaxb
ewaZ DcKiY g~j Ges g~j
Aaxb Dc-aviv
bq Ggb DcKiYi Dc-wewa (2L) Abyhvqx g~j
04
Ki iqvZ
mshvRbi cwigvY NvwlZ
(1) Gi `dv
wecixZ
g~bvdvi mv_ mg^q nq wKbv Zv
mshvRbi
cwieZ
bi
nvi
cu
v
P
(QQ)
cwikvwaZ
g~j kZvski ekx nj mskvwaZ
`LZ cvi Ges mg^q bv nj
mshvRb Ki;
AwZwi DcKiY g~j ev g~j
g~j NvlYv `vwLj KwiZ nBe|
mshvRbi cwigvYi Dci
iqvZ evwZj KiZ cvi|
(Av) Dc-aviv (2) Gi wZxq Abw`K, aviv (9) Ges wewa
kZvsk Dwj-wLZ eemvqx KZK (19) G h_vg Ki iqvZ Ges
qKZ
DcKiYi
Dci DcKiY Ki iqvZ cwZi o DcKiY g~j ew cjI, weq
kZjv ewYZ AvQ| wK,
g~j ew bv cj Ges ewcv
cwikvwaZ DcKiY Ki;
NvwlZ DcKiYi q g~j ew
DcKiY g~j NvwlZ gybvdvi
cv - 4
Sl.
No.
Reference
wewa (3) Gi
Dc-wewa (2L)
Section/Rule/
SRO/Order
g~j mshvRb
Ki ev, gZ,
g~j mshvRb
Ki I m~iK
avhi Rb
g~j NvlYv
Existing
Provision/Situation
Proposal
Reasons / Justifications
Ze kZ _vK h, GB weavbi
KviY Dc-wewa (3) G ewYZ
Z`ev Rwic msvKvhgi
GLwZqvi zb nBe bv|
mev c`vbKvixi AbZg DcKiY weePbv Ki AeKvVvgvi wbgvY, fvov BZvw`i Dci c` g~mKi Dci iqvZ Mnbi myhvM c`vb cm t
aviv (9) Gi Aaxb Dc-aviv (1)
Gi `dv (O) Abymvi wb ewYZ
mg~ni DcKiY Ki
iqvZ Mnb Kiv hvq bv t
aviv (9) Gi
05 Aaxb Dc-aviv
(1) Gi `dv (O)
Ki iqvZ
KihvM cY Drcv`b ev
KihvM mev c`vbi mwnZ
mivmwi m nBjI Kvb
`vjvb-KvVv ev AeKvVvgv ev
vcbv
wbgvY,
mylgxKiY,
AvaywbKxKiY,
cwZvcb,
mcmviY, cybtmsviKiY I
givgZKiY,
mKj
cKvi
Avmevec, kbvix `evw`,
GqviKwkbvi, dvb, AvjvK
mivg, RbviUi BZvw` q ev
givgZKiY, vcZ cwiKbv I
bKkv, hvbevnb, BZvw` fvov ev
jxR MnY, BZvw`i mwnZ
mswk- cY Ges mevi Dci
cwikvwaZ g~j mshvRb Ki;
o AeKvVvgv
aviv (9) Gi Aaxb Dc-aviv (1)
Gi `dv (O) Gi ev AeKvVvgv
kwj wejy Kivi cve Kiv
nBjv|
AbK mev
c`vbKvix cwZvbi mev
c`vbi Rb iZc~Y DcKiY|
Kbbv AeKvVvgv wbgvY ev fvov
Ki AbK mev c`vbKvix mev
c`vb Ki _vK|
GKB ew/cwZvbi wewfb weq K`i ga cY mieivni Rb qg~j evswKs ev BjKUwbK gvag cwikvwaZ bv nj iqvZ KZb bv Kiv cm t
aviv (9) Gi
06 Aaxb Dc-aviv
(1) Gi `dv (X)
Ki iqvZ
cv - 5
ev
mevi
DcKiYi
Sl.
No.
Reference
Section/Rule/
SRO/Order
Existing
Provision/Situation
cY ev mevi DcKiYi
q g~j GK j UvKv ev
Z`~a nBj Ges Dnvi
mgy`q ev AvswkK q g~j
evswKs ev BjKUwbK
gvag ewZZ cwikvwaZ
nBj,
m
D
qg~ji Dci cwikvwaZ
DcKiY Ki|
Proposal
qg~j GK j UvKv ev Z`ya
nBj Ges Dnvi mgy`q ev
AvswkK qg~j evswKs ev
BjKUwbK
gvag
ewZZ
cwikvwaZ nBj, m D
qg~ji Dci cwikvwaZ
DcKiY Ki| Ze D weavb
GKB ewi/cwZvbi Aaxb
GKwU wbewZ vb nBZ Ab
GKwU wbewZ vb mieivni
chvR nBe bv|
Reasons / Justifications
nBZ weq KwiZ Pvb, Zvnj
cwZwU weq K`i Rb
Avjv`v Avjv`vfve wbewZ
nBZ nq Ges g~mK cwikva
KwiZ nq (K`xq wbeb
eZxZ)| hw`I Zvnv wnmve iY
bxwZ Abyhvqx weq bq eis
K/gRy` vbvi| Aciw`K
Kvvbxi
evsK
GKvDU
Kvvbxi bvg nq Ges
GjvKvwfwK nq bv Ges
AbjvBb evswKs Gi Rb `ki
wewfb cv_K GKwU evsK
GKvDUi gvag jb`b mb
KwiZ cvi| GgZvevq, wewfb
weq K` g~mK AvBb Abyhvqx
g~mK c`vb KwijI hnZz
Kvvbxi cavb weq K` /
KviLvbvi mv_ q g~j wnmve
Avw_K jb`b nq bv mnZz
GB weavbwU GKB ewi Aaxb
wewfb wbebi AKvhKi
Ges AhwK| DcwiD welq
AvjvPbv Kwij evweK A_
GB weavb GKB ewi
mieivn weePbv Kwiqv evevqb
Kiv me bn|
wnmveib
evaZvg~jKfve g~jmshvRb Ki
msv`wjjvw` I wnmvec RvZxq
ivR^ evW KZK wbavwiZ
mdUIqvii gvag msiYi Ges
chvR g~mK Kvhvjq
ciYi Av`k ejer AvQ| G
Dk hvMZv mb mdUIqvi
wbgvYKvix I mieivnKvix GK ev
GKvwaK cwZvbK miKvix wewaweavbi
AvjvK
ZvwjKvfz
(Enlistment)
KwiZ
Ges
cqvRb wb`kbv I evLvc Rvwi
KwiZ cvwie| wbevwPZ wbewZ
cwZvb Zvi g~j mshvRb Ki
msv`wjjvw`
I
wnmvec
ibveYi
Dk
Kej
ZvwjKvfz hKvb mdUIqvi
wbgvYKvix I mieivnKvix cwZvb
_K Zvi cwZvbi DchvMx
o hme
cwZvb
BwZc~e
Dj-LhvM wewbqvMi gvag
I
DbZgvbi
KvwiMix
mnvqZvq mdU&Iqvi Wfjc
Ki wnmve msiY KiQ
Zv`i G aibi
evaZvg~jK
mdU&Iqvi
eenvi nBZ AevnwZ `Iqv
cqvRb|
o `wjjvw`
cv - 6
o mdU&Iqvi
eenviKvix`i
mgmv mgvavb AmsLK
mieivnKvix AbK mgq bq
dj eenviKvix`i eemvq
mgmv nq|
I
wnmvec o mdU&Iqvi mieivn Kivi Rb
mdU&Iqvii
gvag
mieivnKvixiv cPzi mgq bq|
msiYi ii ZvwiL b~bZg
30k Ryb, 2014 chew
Kiv cqvRb|
GB cwZ wbavwiZ mgqmxgv Ges
mdU&Iqvi mieivnKvixi msLv ew
g~mK wbewZ evwiv Zv`i LyeB Riix|
wbRi
cQ`
Abyhvqx
mdU&Iqvi Wfjci o GQvovI hmKj g~mK wbewZ
Zv`i cQ`K cvavY w`Z
ewiv Zv`i wbR`i AvBwU
nBe Ges Zv`i Pvwn`v
`ji `Zv viv mdU&Iqvi
Abyhvqx Ab~b 6gvm mgq
Wfjc Kie, Gic NvlYv
c`vb Kiv AvekK|
c`vb Ki RvZxq ivR^ evWi
wbKU mgq cv_bv Ki Zv`i
eZgvb Abygvw`Z mdU&Iqvi
mgq Abygv`b Kij m
eZgvb
mdU&Iqvi
mieivnKvix`i mv_ bZzb
mieivnKvix`i Dci Pvc
mdU&Iqvi mieivnKvix`i
Kge|
Abygv`b `Iqv evbxq|
Sl.
No.
Reference
Section/Rule/
SRO/Order
Existing
Provision/Situation
Proposal
Reasons / Justifications
(Customized)
evW
KZK
ZvwjKvfz hKvb mdUIqvi
msMnc~eK eenvi KwiZ cvwie|
Avevi evW KZK wbevwPZ
mdUIqvi, m s w k - Kwgkbvi KZK
wbevwPZ wbewZ cwZvb mg~n KZK
1 RyjvB, 2012 ZvwiL nZ eenvi
Kiv evaZvg~jK nBe| cieZxZ
RvZxq ivR^ evWi mvaviY Av`k
bs-14/g~mK/2012, ZvwiL - 5
RyjvB, 2012 wLv Gi gvag
D mgqmxgv cybtwbaviY Kwiqv 1
Rvbyqvwi, 2013 Kiv nq|
Aciw`K, RvZxq ivR^ evW bw_
bs-08.01.0000.073.01.001.1274 ZvwiL - 1 Avei, 2012 Gi
gvag wb Dwj-wLZ 5 (cuvP)wU
mdUIqvi (Software) wbgvYKvix
I
mieivnKvix
cwZvbK
ZvwjKvfz KwiqvQbt
(K)
SYMPHONY Softech
Ltd., 1st Floor, 160 Lake
Circus,
Kalabagan,
Mirpur Road, Dhaka1205.
(L)
UNISOFT
Systems
Limited, A/2 Rupsha
Tower, 7 Kamal Ataturk
Avenue, Banani, Dhaka1213.
(M) UY Systems Ltd., House:
289, Road: 19/B, New
DOHS,
Mohakhali,
Dhaka-1206.
(N) Ennovia Technologies
Ltd., House # 279 (G.F),
Road # 19, New DOHS,
Mohakhali,
Dhaka1206.
Dhrupadi
Techno
(O)
Consortium
Limited,
House # 375/A (1st
Floor), Road# 28, New
DOHS,
Mohakhali,
Dhaka-1206.
Avwcji Av`k cvwi ZvwiL _K Avwcj Ave`bi mgq wbaviY Kiv t
08
aviv (42) Gi
Dc-aviv (1)
Avwcj
KgKZv ev h Kvb ew
Kvb g~j mshvRb Ki
KgKZvi GB AvBb ev
Kvb wewai Aaxb c`
Kvb wmvev Av`k viv
msz nBj wZwb D
wmvev Av`ki wei,
cYi mieivn ev c`
mevi aviv 56 Gi
Aaxb c` Kvb AvUK ev
weq Av`k A_ev cY
Avg`vwbi
cv - 7
Sl.
No.
Reference
Section/Rule/
SRO/Order
Existing
Provision/Situation
Customs Act Gi
section 82 ev section
98 Gi Aaxb Kvb Av`k
eZxZ, D wmvev
Av`k
c`vbi
ev,
gZ, Av`k Rvwii
beB w`bi ga|
Section
196K of the
Customs
Act, 1969
Notwithstanding
anything
contained in this Act, any
person, who is entitled or
required to attend before any
officer of customs, an
appellate
authority,
the
Board or the Government in
any proceedings under this
Act or any, rules made
attend in such proceedings
Appearance by by a person authorised by
the authorised him in writing in this behalf,
representative being a relative of or a
person regularly employed
be, the aggrieved person, or
an advocate who is entitled
to plead in any Court of
Law,
or
a
Customs
Consultant as defined and
licensed
under
rules
prescribed in this behalf, and
not being disqualified under
sub-section (2).
Proposal
Reasons / Justifications
bv|
GvKvDUU
Accountant)
g~j NvlYvi wecixZ Abygv`bi Av`k cvwi ZvwiL nBZ Avwcj Ave`bi mgq wbaviY Kiv t
(7) Dc-wewa (1) nBZ (6) G
hvnvB _vKzK bv Kb, Kwgkbvi
g~j mshvRb
wbewZ ewi Ave`bg ev
Ki ev, gZ, ^^Ztce nBqv ev wefvMxq g~j wbicYi ZvwiL nBZ wk
KgKZvi Abyivag cYi Kvh w`emi cwieZ g~j
g~j mshvRb
wewa (3) Gi
10
evRvig~j DVv-bvgvi KviY ev wbicYi Av`k cvwi wk Kvh
Ki I m~iK
Dc-wewa (7)
Zuvnvi weePbvq AbKvbv w`emi kjv cwZvcb Kiv
avhi
Rb g~j NvlYv wekl KviY Kvbv cY ev cY cqvRb|
kwYi Ki wbicYi Rb
g~jwfw wi KwiZ cvwieb:
Ze kZ _vK h, wefvMxq
cv - 8
o cvKwUwms
GvKvDUU`i D
wekevwc ^xKZ|
PvUvW
gZv
Sl.
No.
Existing
Proposal
Reasons / Justifications
Provision/Situation
KgKZv NvwlZ g~j Acv
g~j wbicYi Av`kwU g~mK
DPZi g~jwfw wbicY Kwij
wbewZ ew cvq bv|
m s w k - wbewZ ew D
DPZi g~j wbicYi ZvwiL
nBZ wk Kvhw`emi ga D
wbiwcZ g~jwfw cybweePbvi
wbwg Kwgkbvii wbKU Ave`b
`vwLj KwiZ cvwieb Ges
Ave`b cvwi ZvwiL nBZ
cbi Kvhw`emi ga Kwgkbvi
D Ave`bi Ici wmvc`vb
KwiZ e_ nBj wZwb Ave`bwU
gyi KwiqvQb ewjqv MY nBe:
wwfwK Drcv`bi DcKiY ^vwaKvixi wbewZ wVKvbvq bv Avwbqv mivmwi PzwwfwK Drcv`Ki wVKvbvq ciYi gZv c`vb Kiv Ges cwqvKZ
DcKiY mieivni eevi weavb Kiv t
wewa (16) Gi Dc-wewa (3M) Gi
o AbK hnZz qKZ
wbic cwZvcb Kivi cve
DcKiYi cwieZbi Rb Kvb
Kiv nBjv t
cwqv ^vwaKvixi wbewZ
KviLvbvq nq bv mnZz
Pzw wfwK Drcv`bi AvIZvq
^vwaKvixi wbewZ wVKvbvq bv
cYi ^vwaKvix Drcv`Ki
Avwbqv mivmwi PzwwfwK
wbKU DcKiY ev cwqvKZ
Drcv`K Gi wbKU mieivn
DcKiY mieivni mgq ev
Kwij wbv NVbvjv _K
DcKiY mieivni Rb dig
AevnwZ cvIqv hvBet
g~mK-11M G wgyLx Kveb eenvi
Kwiqv GKwU Pvjvbc c`vb
1. DcKiY
mivmwi
Kwieb Ges Pvjvbci wZxq
mieivnKvix
_K
AbywjwcwU Pvjvbc cyK mshy
PzwwfwK
Drcv`Ki
Aevq eemvqj Ab~b Pvi
wVKvbvq cvVvj mgq
ermi msiY Kwieb|
AcPq iva nBe;
2. AwZwi cwienb LiP
(3M) PzwwfwK Drcv`bi Ze kZ _vK h, cYi
Kwge;
Zvnvi
qKZ
AvIZvq cYi ^vwaKvix ^vwaKvix
3. cYi DVvbvgv msvwZ
Drcv`Ki
wbKU
DcKiY DcKiY Zvnvi g~mK wbewZ
_K iv nBe;
KihvM cYi
mieivni mgq dig g~mK- wVKvbvq bv Avwbqv mivmwi
4. `vgRvZ Kivi LiP nvm
wewa (16) Gi
mieivn I
11M-G wgyLx Kveb eenvi PzwwfwK Drcv`Ki wbKU
cvBe|
11
Dc-wewa (3M)
ivwbi
Kwiqv GKwU Pvjvbc c`vb mieivn KwiZ cvwieb|
Pvjvbc c`vb| Kwieb Ges Pvjvbci wZxq
o GKB mv_ aviv (9) Ges wewa
AbywjwcwU Pvjvbc cyK Aviv kZ _vK h, hB ZvwiL
(19) Gi iqvZ MnY msv
DcKiY
PzwwfwK
mshy Aevq eemvq j Ab~b D
weavbvewj ^vwaKvixi Rb
Drcv`Ki
g~mK
wbewZ
Pvi ermi msiY Kwieb|
cwieZb KwiZ nBe| Kbbv
KviLvbvq cek Kwie mB
aviv (9) Abyhvqx iqvZ MnYi
ZvwiLi
wfwZ
DcKiY
Rb cY ev mev ^vwaKvixi
ceki wZb Kvh w`emi ga
wbewZ wVKvbvq AvmZ nq|
^vwaKvixK g~mK-11M Pvjvb
Bmy KwiZ nBe Ges g~mK-11M
Gi wfwZ PzwwfwK Drcv`K o eq msKvPbbxwZi ev cqvRbi
ZvwM` aygv cvwKs/GKwU
wnmve msib Kwieb|
cwqv Pzwi gvag AbKvb
Drcv`K cwZvbi KvQ _K
aviv 9 Gi Dc-aviv (1) Gi
mb Kiv AbK
mwnZ wbic kZ mshvRb Kivi
AvekKxq
nq
hvq|
cve Kiv nBjv t
GgZvevq, cwqvKZ DcKiY
^vwaKvix _K PzwwfwK
Aviv kZ _vK h, aviv 5(2K)
Drcv`Ki wbKU g~mK-11M
Abyhvqx Kvbv wbewZ Drcv`K
Gi gvag mieivni eev
KZK Pzwi wfwZ Ab Kvb
_vwKZ nBe|
wbewZ Drcv`Ki evhy cY
Reference
Section/Rule/
SRO/Order
cv - 9
Sl.
No.
Reference
Section/Rule/
SRO/Order
Existing
Provision/Situation
Proposal
Reasons / Justifications
cv - 10
Sl.
No.
Reference
Section/Rule/
SRO/Order
Existing
Provision/Situation
Proposal
A_ev chvR , ^vwaKvix
KZK `vwLjKZ g~j NvlYvi
g~mK AvivchvM g~ji wfwZ
Pvjvbc c`vb Kwieb|
Reasons / Justifications
Rb cY ev mev ^vwaKvixi
wbewZ wVKvbvq AvwmZ nq|
cv - 11
Sl.
No.
Existing
Proposal
Reasons / Justifications
Provision/Situation
diZ c` nq wKsev cY
eZgvb cwZhvMxZvg~jK eemvq
mieivni ev mev c`vbi
wUK _vKv K`vqK nq|
cKwZ gwjKfve cwiewZZ nq
wKsev Pvjvbc cKZ c`q
Kii Zzjbvq AwaK Ki Dwj-wLZ
nq, mB wZwb evwZjKZ
Pvjvbc c`wkZ Ki wKsev
diZ c` cY ev mevi
wecixZ c` Ki wKsev
Pvjvbc AwaK c`wkZ Ki
PjwZ wnmve I chvR
cieZx `vwLjc mg^qi
Dk PvjvbcwU evwZj Kwiqv
cY ev mevi MnxZvi AbyKj
dig g~mK-12-G GKwU
wWU bvU Bmy Kwieb Ges
cieZx Kvhw`mi ga mswk-
mvKj ivR^ KgKZvi wbKU
Dnvi GKwU Abywjwc `vwLj
Kwieb:
Ze kZ _vK h,
(K) cY mieivn ev mev
c`vbi ci Zvnv m~Y ev
AvswkKfve diZ MnYi
cY ev mev KviLvbv ev
eemvqj nBZ AcmviYi
beB w`b ci diZ MnxZ
nBj;
(L) cYi YMZgvb Lvivc
nIqvi KviY mieivnKZ cY ev
mev cZvnvi Kiv nBj;
D wbewZ ewi GB
wewa chvR nBe bv|
Drm g~mK KZbi AvIZvaxb mev mieivnKvix KZK iqvZ Mnb Kij Ges 15% nvi g~mK c`vb Kij, Drm g~mK KZb bv Kiv cm t
35wU mev c`vbKvix KZK mev
RvZxq ivR^
o DcKiY Ki iqvZ bIqv
c`vbi wecixZ Drm g~mK
evWi mvaviY
nj m megvU cvwi
KZbi wb`kbv `Iqv AvQ|
Av`k bsDci 15% nvi g~mK _K
Abvw`K 35wU mev c`vbKvixi D 35wU mev c`vbKvixi ga
09/g~mK/2011
DcKiY Ki iqvZ mg^q
ZvwiL: 12
ga S007.00 wevcbx hw` Kvb mev c`vbKvix 15%
g~mK Drm
Ki Aewk Ask c`vb Kiv
Avei, 2011
msv mg~n h vbxq g~j nvi g~mK c`vb Ki Ges
Av`vq/KZb Ges
nq| wK hw` 15% Gi
mshvRb Ki Kvhvjqi ivR^ DcKiY Ki iqvZ Mnb Ki
14
cieZx KiYxq
mgy`q Ask Drm KZb Kiv
RvZxq ivR^
KgKZv/mnKvix ivR^ KgKZv _vK, Zv`i Drm g~mK
mK w`K
nq m mev c`vbKvix
evWi mvaviY
KZK cZvwqZ g~mK-11 KZb chvR nBe bv Ges
wb`kbv msv|
KZK c` g~mK diZ `vwe
Av`k bsPvjvbc ev g~mK-11 wnme wevcbx msvi Abyic weavb
KiZ ne| diZ cvIqv ev
01/g~mK/2012
weewPZ Kvb Pvjvbc c`vb Zv`i Af~ Kiv DwPZ|
weK A_ LyeB KKi Ges
ZvwiL: 28
Kie, m g~j mshvRb
hbv`vqK|
AbK
deqvwi,
Ki (g~mK) Drm KZbi
diZ cvIqvI hvq bv|
2012
AvekKZv bB|
^vwaKvix KZK PzwwfwK Drcv`Ki wbKU ciYKZ DcKiY diZ c`vbi weavb Af~KiY t
Pzw evwZj ev AbKvb Kvib ^vwaKvix KZK PzwwfwK
o eemvqxK
Kvib,
gvbDrcv`Ki wbKU cwiZ DcKiYi _K AeeZ DcKiY diZ
wbqb/eveZv
wbix
15 eZgvb GB msvKvbv weavb bvB `Iqvi cqvRb nBj g~mK-11M Gi Abyic Pvjvbci gvag
mieivnKZ DcKiY diZi
D DcKiY aygv ^vwaKvixi wbKU diZ c`vbi weavb Kiv
weavb _vKv AZvekK|
AvekK|
KwZcq mevi Dci c`q Kii m~b Ask iqvZ Mnb cm t
wewa (19) Gi
DcKiY Ki
(1K) Dc-wewa (1) G hvnv wKQyB hnZz wbv mev mg~n D mevmg~n ewMZ eenvii
16
Dc-wewa (1K)
iqvZ cwZ|
_vKzK bv Kb, KihvM cY Drcv`b ev eemvqi mv_ m~Y mv_ RwoZ bq eis Drcv`b ev
Reference
Section/Rule/
SRO/Order
cv - 12
Sl.
No.
Reference
Section/Rule/
SRO/Order
Gi `dv (K)
Ges (L)
Existing
Provision/Situation
Drcv`b evmieivn ev KihvM
mev c`vbi mwnZ mc
GBic vb, vcbv ev Ab
eeZ
(K) exgv, Mvm I we`yr
weZiYi Ici cwikvwaZ g~j
mshvRb Kii AvwkkZvsk; Ges
Proposal
Reasons / Justifications
eemv cwiPvjbvi mv_ mivmwi
m myZivs g~mKi gwjK bxwZ
Abyhvqx GmKj mev mg~ni Dci
c` mgy`q g~mK, DcKiY Ki
iqvZ wnmve mg^qhvM nIqv
DwPZ| Ab_vq eemv cwiPjbv eq
ew cve|
17
wewa (24)
Gi Dc-wewa
(1)
cZK
KihvM
cYi
cZKviK ev Drcv`K ev
eemvqx ev KihvM mev
c`vbKvixK cwZwU Ki gqv`i
Rb dig g~mK-19 G
`vwLjci `yBwU Abywjwc Ki
gqv` cieZx gvmi 15 (cbi)
ZvwiLi ga vbxq g~j
mshvRb Ki Kvhvjq Rgv w`Z
nBe
`vwLjc
ckKiY
Ze kZ _vK h, 15 (cbi)
ZvwiL miKvwi QywU _vwKj
AekB Zrc~eeZx Kvhw`em
h_vwbqg dig g~mK-19 G
`vwLjc Rgv c`vb KwiZ
nBe|
Ze kZ _vK h, 30 (wk)
ZvwiL miKvwi QywU _vwKj
AekB Zrc~eeZx Kvhw`em
h_vwbqg dig g~mK-19 G
`vwLjc Rgv c`vb KwiZ
nBe|
cv - 13
Sl.
No.
Reference
Section/Rule/
SRO/Order
Existing
Provision/Situation
mevmg~nK wbaviY Kwij|
Proposal
4.
5.
Reasons / Justifications
S045.00
AvBb
civgkK
S056.00 evswKs I bbevswKs mev c`vbKvix
Avg`vwbKZ Jlai Dci g~mK c`vb cwZ mywbw`KiY Ges cvBKvix I LyPiv chvq g~mK AevnwZ c`vb KiY t
`k
Drcvw`Z
Jlai
g~mKhvM g~j I c`q g~mK
`k Drcvw`Z Jlai wbavibi AbymZ RvZxq
cvBKvix I LyPiv chvq chvR ivR^ evWi bw_ bs-8(15)
RvZxq ivR^
g~mK AevwnZ `qv mvc g~mK (bx: I ev:)/95 ZvwiL : 4
`k Drcvw`Z
evWi bw_ bsDrcv`b chvq eemvq chvqi Ryb, 2001 Gi Abyic Av`k /
Jlai
8(15) g~mK
19
wb`kbvi gvag Avg`vwbKZ
g~mK c`vb Kivi weavb AvQ|
g~mKhvM g~j
(bx: I ev:)/95
Jla, wUKv BZvw`i
I c`q g~mK
ZvwiL : 4 Ryb,
wK Avg`vwbKZ Jla, wUKv Avg`vwbKviKi nvZB mgy`q
wbaviY cm|
2001
BZvw`i Abyic mywbw` g~mK Av`vqi weavb Ges
w`K wb`kbv bB|
cvBKvix I LyPiv chvq chvR
g~mK AevnwZ `Iqvi weavb
Kiv cqvRb|
c Lv`i cyw wcwgK g~j mshvRb Ki nZ Drcv`b chvq AevnwZ c`vb cm t
Afixb m`
wefvM, A_
gYvjq,
MYcRvZx
evsjv`k
miKvii
20
GmAviI bs180AvBb/2012/63
8-g~mK ZvwiL
07 Ryb, 2012
wLv
o
o
o `k G wki msLv `Z
evoQ|
Avg`vwb chvq,
Avg`vwb I
Drcv`b chvq,
Drcv`b chvq,
c` mev Ges
eemvqx chvq
g~mK AevnwZ|
chvqi
RvZxq ivR^
evWi GmAviI
bs-17521
AvBb/2011/59
8-g~mK ZvwiL 9
Ryb, 2011
KihvM mevi
cwiwa wbaviY
S037.00
hvMvb`vi-A_
KvUkb
ev
`ic
ev
Abweafve wewfb miKvix,
AvavmiKvix,
^vqZkvwmZ
cwZvb,
emiKvix
msv
(GbwRI), evsK, exgv ev
AbKvb
Avw_K
cwZvb,
wjwgUW
Kvvbx
ev
wkvcwZvbi wbKU cYi
wewbgq hKvb cY ev mev ev
DfqB mieivn Kib Ggb Kvb
ew, cwZvb ev msv|
cv - 14
Sl.
No.
Reference
Section/Rule/
SRO/Order
Existing
Provision/Situation
Proposal
Reasons / Justifications
we`gvb weavb aviv (3) Gi
mwnZ mvsNwlK|
RvZxq ivR^
evWi GmAviI
bs-175AvBb/2011/59
8-g~mK ZvwiL 9
Ryb, 2011 Ges
23
RvZxq ivR^
evWi GmAviI
bs-181AvBb/2012/63
9-g~mK ZvwiL
7Ryb, 2012
KihvM
mevi cwiwa
wbaviY
Infrastructure
development
(Combination
of
Hardware & Software)
mshvRb Kwiqv Z_-chyw
wbfi mevi cwiwa wbic
Kivi cve Kiv nBjv t
Digital
Content
Development
and
Management, Animation
(both 2D and 3D),
Geographic Information
Services
(GIS),
IT
Support and Software
Maintenance
Services,
Infrastructure
Development
(Combination
of
Hardware & Software),
Web
Site
Services,
Business
Process
Outsourcing, Data Entry,
Data Processing, Call
Centre, Graphics Design
(digital service), Search
Engine
Optimization,
Web Listing, E-commerce
and Online Shopping,
document
conversion,
imaging and archiving.
cv - 15
Sl.
No.
Reference
Section/Rule/
SRO/Order
wefvM, A_
gYvjq,
MYcRvZx
evsjv`k miKvii
GmAviI 72AvBb/95/113g~mK ZvwiL 8 g,
1995
RvZxq ivR^
evWi wekl
Av`k bs18/g~mK/2004
ZvwiL 10 Avei,
2004
Existing
Provision/Situation
nq|
Proposal
AevnwZ cqvRb|
o `~Zvevm, KUbxwZwe` I
KgPvixe`,
iv`~Zi
evmvb, RvwZmsNi wewfb
A cwZvb, wek Lv`
msv, wek evsK, wek ^v
msv, AvRvwZK kg
msv, Gkxq Dbqb evsK
BZvw` KZK KwZcq
mevi qi g~mK
AvswkK ev m~Y AevnwZ
`Iqv AvQ|
RvZxq ivR^
evWi wekl
Av`k bs04/g~mK/2005
ZvwiL 2 g, 2005
AwWU G
GKvDwUs dvgi
25 mev c`vbi
Dci Drm g~mK
KZb cm
mvavib Av`k bs
07/g~mK/2012
ZvwiL 28 R,
1419 ev/07
Ryb, 2012 wLv
wgK bs: 18
mevi KvW: Gm 034.00
mev c`vbKvix: AwWU G
GKvDwUs dvg
g~mK Drm KZbi nvi: 15%
wgK bs: 18
mevi KvW: Gm 034.00
mev c`vbKvix: AwWU G
GKvDwUs dvg
g~mK Drm KZbi nvi: 4.5%
cv - 16
106
Reasons / Justifications
107
108