Dear Junaid

We are pleased to inform you that your paper 60, titled "Implementation of Industrial Wireless Closed-Loop
Control Network Using ZigBee " has
been provisionally accepted for oral presentation in IMTIC 2015 to be held on
February 11-13, 2015.
Kindly be advised that your paper requires major revisions and hence will not
be published by CCIS series. But it is very likely to be published as a Book
Chapter by a well-known International publisher if all the suggestions and
comments given by reviewers are incorporated at satisfactory level. We are
already in contact with IGI global in this respect.
This year, IMTIC15 received more than 400 submissions, which after author
withdrawals and deleting only abstracts led to a total of 294 papers that were
reviewed. A small subset of papers was classified as quick rejects based on
their quality and likelihood of acceptance. All the other papers underwent a
rigorous review process with each paper receiving at least 2 reviews. The
review process included several stages including TPC member reviews, an on-line
discussion among the reviewers, TPC lead summary recommendations, and
additional reviews (as needed). Based on the TPC recommendations, we were only
able to accept a total of 54 papers for the publication and presentation at
IMTIC15; this represents an acceptance rate of approximately 18.36%.
Additionally, some papers are provisionally selected as potential papers to be
considered after major revisions in other selected venues.
Please prepare your camera ready paper, strictly adhering to Springer LNCS
format available at http://www.springer.com/computer/lncs?SGWID=0-164-6-7933410. Ideally we require latex files of the final paper. The page limit for camera
ready version is strictly 12 pages max (Extra pages
are not permitted).
Please be advised that the camera ready paper *must* incorporate the
reviewers comments. If above instructions are not followed then it may lead to
rejection of your paper.
Shortly, you will receive instructions for uploading the camera ready version
to IMTIC15. The hard deadline for camera ready version is February 10, 2015.
Registration of at least one author is mandatory for presenting the paper and
to be included in the proceedings. Please complete your registration
(http://www.imtic.muet.edu.pk/registration) by February 01, 2015.
For a paper to be included in the conference proceedings, it must be presented
orally.
Thank for your contribution and we look forward to see you at IMTIC 2015 at
Jamshoro, Pakistan.

Regards
PC Chairs
IMTIC15

----------------------- REVIEW 1 ---------------------

PAPER: 60
TITLE: Implementation of Industrial Wireless Closed-Loop Control Network Using ZigBee
AUTHORS: Junaid Ahmed, Bhavesh Kumar, Farah Haroon and Asif Ahmed Memon
OVERALL EVALUATION: 1 (weak accept)
Reviewer's confidence: 4 (expert)
Originality: New or novel contribution, also consider contribution to applications: 3 (fair)
Technical/Scientific Contribution: Also consider papers that contribute to development of applications: 3 (fair)
Significance of Topic: Relating to the theme of the track/symposium: 3 (fair)
Presentation: Clarity and organization of content, quality of writing: 3 (fair)
Can the paper be accepted as short paper if not as regular paper: 1 (yes)
----------- REVIEW ----------The paper may well contain performance improvement of Zigbee for control and automation, but the
presentation lacks in terms of research element. It would rather seems final year project with less research
element. several figures are unnecessary and should be removed like Fig 2, 8, 11...I don't see their impact in
terms of research element or for an international conference.

----------------------- REVIEW 2 --------------------PAPER: 60

TITLE: Implementation of Industrial Wireless Closed-Loop Control Network Using ZigBee
AUTHORS: Junaid Ahmed, Bhavesh Kumar, Farah Haroon and Asif Ahmed Memon
OVERALL EVALUATION: 1 (weak accept)
Reviewer's confidence: 4 (expert)
Originality: New or novel contribution, also consider contribution to applications: 2 (poor)
Technical/Scientific Contribution: Also consider papers that contribute to development of applications: 3 (fair)
Significance of Topic: Relating to the theme of the track/symposium: 4 (good)
Presentation: Clarity and organization of content, quality of writing: 4 (good)
Can the paper be accepted as short paper if not as regular paper: 2 (no)
----------- REVIEW ----------The contribution/novelty of the work is not defined. The proposed work is standard and can be found in rich
literature. Literature review is very week and not up-to-date. The hardware implementation is interesting and
seems to be the main contribution of this paper.

----------------------- REVIEW 3 --------------------PAPER: 60

TITLE: Implementation of Industrial Wireless Closed-Loop Control Network Using ZigBee
AUTHORS: Junaid Ahmed, Bhavesh Kumar, Farah Haroon and Asif Ahmed Memon
OVERALL EVALUATION: 2 (accept)
Reviewer's confidence: 4 (expert)
Originality: New or novel contribution, also consider contribution to applications: 4 (good)
Technical/Scientific Contribution: Also consider papers that contribute to development of applications: 3 (fair)
Significance of Topic: Relating to the theme of the track/symposium: 5 (excellent)
Presentation: Clarity and organization of content, quality of writing: 4 (good)
Can the paper be accepted as short paper if not as regular paper: 1 (yes)
----------- REVIEW ----------The author emulated the network for achieving transient and steady state responses in order to ensuring the
effectiveness and real time implementation of wireless closed loop control network for industrial applications.

Typo.
Figure 2 is titled as Figure 1. Check that out.
Suggestion:
Figure 4 can be eliminated by mentioning the laptop and its base configuration. Thus, figure 3 can be expanded
and this would make it easily readable.
Overall, the paper is finely written, contains supporting concepts, and is successful in making its impact for
reader.