% ‘New York University RE: Katy Percy's Claim to Own a Copyight in Left Shas Deus Me, Pini: Leepresent Fernand Sosa. Mr. Sosa isthe Odando, FL artist who seulpted Left Shack and then potted, on 3D printing site Shapeways and elemere, electronic files that peanit anyone with a 3D pantec to egeat tec very own Left Shark seulptuee. [waite in response to the lemec you teat to Shapeways demanding that Me. Son's seulpeuce of Left Shack be cemoved fom ite site. Mz. Sosa it not especially eager to be fighting over copyright, but the legal madi of your claim seem very Weak. (We abo wonder what Katy Per could possly stand to gun fom dectasing war on an Internet meme, but that’s her business) Mic Sosa has afew questions {hat he wants answered befoie le wil remove Left Shark from the othe: online stores ia ‘hich its atl avalahle Fist, can you tell me why you believe the costume ofa shack that you clam Katy Peary corns is coppightable? As yoa ely know, federal concts and the United States Copyaght (Office have made clear that cosmaes ate generally not copyuightable. Please tell me why you think the Left Shack cortume shonld be tented different Second, what isthe bass for your cam that Kety Peny, and not some other pesson, owns the copysight? Did Kary Petry design the Left Shack costume? Lf so, whea? I not, who cid? Did that peson tanser any copyright intecest he or she might have (x ceairy, very kelp one) to Katy Pec? Ifo, when? ‘Weask aboat ownechip not least because Katy Pesy heeelé hes suggested tht she ddatt Inve coatrol ores the content of he halftime show, bu ater the NFL did Se, for example, he secet interview with Ele mapuzineFebruary 9.2015 Page 2 of 2 “La my show, Lam boos dadcy. Iam boss mommy. They cll ase Bore, ‘Ecerything goes thcongh ary eyes; call all the shots, 100 percent of it With lhe NFL, Ihave to be accoactable to several levels of red tape. Thee are ‘many committe: Thave © go thongh for ary costumes, the badgers of my show, every intereiew— everything, [have to seport to somebody. So Tam ‘90 longer the boos have to celingnih that contzol” ‘At the reey last, Katy Peary’s own accouat sises questions aboat what, anything, she ‘cons. Ifthe wasa't the bors ofher halftime shor, she's also ualiely tobe the coprsight ‘Tend any lertec with a very simple coquest Jus top this thing. My cent wants to get back ‘to his business, and be (and Ta wager prety aruch everyone else) world be gatefl fyou'd [it baci off Going ahead with these very cubsovs copyaght cine wall aot benest Katy ‘Feury. Bot if you're detesmined to press oa, please do tespond to my legal questions, and we ‘can ty to wodk it ont from these. All best spac, Go_ (Chie Sprigman