Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
DOI 10.1007/s00266-014-0431-2
I N N OV A T I V E T E C H N I QU E S
AESTHETIC
Abstract
Background Though minimally invasive procedures
often yield excellent esthetic results for axillary osmidrosis,
the high recurrence rates of malodor limit its further
application. Incomplete removal of the apocrine glands
would lead to recurrence of the axillary bromhidrosis,
while excessive resection of the apocrine glands firmly
attached to the dermis would easily result in local skin
necrosis. Therefore, accurate management of the apocrine
glands is extraordinarily important, particularly with a
limited access. Herein, we would like to introduce an
effective and minimally invasive procedure combining
subcutaneous curettage and trimming for the treatment of
axillary osmidrosis.
Methods A 5-mm incision was marked at the inferior
pole of the central axillary crease. Subcutaneous undermining was done clinging to the axillary superficial fascia.
The whole procedure was performed in the following
sequence of scrapingtrimmingscraping against the
undermined skin flap until the remaining hairs were easily
pulled out.
Results All the wounds healed primarily without significant complications. Out of 300 axillae, 294 (98 %) showed
good to excellent results for malodor elimination. Scars
were invisible in 280 axillae (93.3 %) and slightly visible
in 18 axillae (6 %). The dermatology life quality index
score decreased significantly after the operation.
Conclusion The procedure is an efficacious and minimally invasive method for the treatment of axillary
osmidrosis.
Level of Evidence IV This journal requires that authors
assign a level of evidence to each article. For a full
description of these Evidence-Based Medicine ratings,
please refer to the Table of Contents or the online
Instructions to Authors www.springer.com/00266.
Keywords Axillary osmidrosis Minimally invasive
procedures Subcutaneous trimming Curettage
Introduction
It has long been a severe psychological burden for patients
who possess axillary malodor, especially for Asian people.
It is generally accepted that osmidrosis is due to the
interaction between bacterial activity and hyper-secretion
of apocrine gland [1].
Current treatments for osmidrosis include antibacterial
products, deodorants, botulinum toxin injections, subcutaneous laser, percutaneous ethanol injections, and various
surgical methods [27]. However, to achieve permanent
resolution of axillary bromhidrosis, surgical eradication of
the apocrine sweat glands is necessary.
A histological study by Byron and associates showed
that the apocrine sweat glands of the axilla extended from
the lower dermis deeply into the subcutaneous fat [7]. As
the reticular dermis is composed of dense irregular connective tissue, technically, removal of the apocrine glands
firmly attached to the lower dermis is relatively more difficult compared with those located subcutaneously.
Incomplete removal of the apocrine glands would lead
to recurrence of the axillary bromhidrosis, while excessive
123
Surgical Technique
With the patient in a supine position, the axillae were
exposed with the upper arms abducted slightly above the
shoulder level. Bilateral axillary hair was shaved. Short
(24 mm) axillary hairs were left as indicators. The area
was marked 0.51 cm beyond the hair-bearing area for
dissection. A 5-mm incision was marked at the inferior
pole of the central axillary crease as the access (Fig. 1). For
patients who have longer axis of the hair-bearing area, an
additional incision could be marked in parallel with the
original incision. The operating field was routinely prepared with Povidone-iodine, and then the draping was
done. Local anesthesia was given using 0.5 % lidocaine
with 1:200,000 epinephrine. The incision was made
through the axillary skin down to the subcutaneous fat
tissue using a No. 11 blade along the marked incision.
Subcutaneous undermining was performed clinging to the
superficial fascia with a pair of ophthalmic scissors
(Fig. 2). A 4 9 7 mm fenestrated cup curette was used to
Fig. 1 A 5-mm incision was marked at the inferior pole of the central
axillary crease as the access. As for patients who have longer axis of
the hair-bearing area, an additional incision could be marked in
parallel with the original incision
Value
Number of patients
158
Female
106
Male
56
Family history
123
Combined hyperhidrosis
Follow-up time, (mean SD)
56
618, (11.2 4.1)
123
Fig. 3 Scrape back and forth against the undermined flap using a
4 9 7 mm fenestrated cup curette to remove the apocrine sweat
glands
Fig. 5 Blind trimming with the ophthalmic scissors. With the blunt
tips facing down, the flap was elevated by the scissors. The pulp of the
index finger was used to press the axillary flap against the scissors to
assist in efficient trimming
123
Results
Fig. 9 The right axillary fossa 14 days postoperatively
123
All the wounds (158 cases with 316 axillae) healed primarily without significant complications like skin necrosis,
wound dehiscence, or inflammation. The follow-up duration ranged from 6 to 18 months. Of all the 158 cases, 93
patients came back to our clinic for a follow-up visit, 57
received a telephone follow-up, and 8 patients were lost to
follow up 6 months postoperatively. Table 2 includes the
postoperative complications and patient subjective assessments obtained 6 months after the surgery. The most
common postoperative complication was skin ecchymosis
(19 axillae, 6.3 %), which spontaneously faded away
within 2 weeks. Three cases of hematoma (1.3 %) occurred, two of which were males. The two cases in males both
occurred on the right side, while the one case in a female
occurred bilaterally. After aspiration and proper pressure
dressing, the wound healed primarily. As for malodor
elimination, 294 axillae (98 %) showed excellent to good
results. The other three cases (2 %) who had poor to fair
results received a re-operation in the same manner, and all
of them showed excellent results afterwards. Hair growth
was reduced significantly in 214 axillae (71.3 %) and
moderately in 81 axillae (27 %). There was no hyperpigmentation, hypertrophy, or atrophy of scars. Scars were
invisible in 280 axillae (93.3 %) and slightly visible in 18
Table 3 Median DQLI scores before and 6 months after the surgery
N (%)
Preoperative
6 months
postoperatively
9 (416)
0 (03)a
0a
0a
1
2
0
0a
Question 5
0a
Question 6
0a
0a
Postoperative complications
Ecchymosis
19/300 (6.3)
Hematoma
4/300 (1.3)
Clinical symptoms
Skin necrosis
Question 1
Wound dehiscence
Self-conscious
Wound infection
Question 2
Daily activities
Malodor elimination
Excellent
264/300 (88)
Good
30/300 (10)
Fair
5/300 (1.7)
Poor
Reduced hair growth
214/300 (71.3)
Moderate
81/300 (27)
Mild
4/300 (1.4)
No significant
1/300 (0.3)
Work or study
Question 7
Personal relationship
Question 8
Sexual relationship
Scar formation
Invisible
280/300 (93.3)
Slightly visible
18/300 (6)
Very conspicuous
Leisure
1/300 (0.3)
Significant
Conspicuous
Question 3
Question 4
Question 9
Treatment
Question 10
3/300 (1)
0
Patient satisfaction
Very satisfied
128/150 (85.3)
Satisfied
18/150 (12)
Neutral
3/150 (2)
Dissatisfied
1/150 (0.7)
Very dissatisfied
Discussion
It is generally believed that the secretion of the apocrine
glands and the activity of bacteria create the characteristic
malodor of axillary osmidrosis. The apocrine glands of
osmidrosis patients are both hypertrophic and hyperplastic,
which has been confirmed by the published studies [10,
11]. To achieve permanent resolution of axillary
123
successfully performed operations have one thing in common; they manage to remove the residual apocrine sweat
glands firmly attached to the dermis.
Liu developed a minimally invasive surgical subsection
method for axillary osmidrosis. The glandular tissue was
removed by manual excision with scissors through a 1-cm
incision. The whole procedure was performed blindly.
The method showed a very high percentage of good results,
which was confirmed by the histological examinations. But
thorough trimming using scissors alone blindly may result
in tearing of the skin. Further, for long lesions, a single
incision may not be enough to reach all the sweat glands
[16]. Li described a procedure combining tumescent liposuction with subcutaneous pruning. Long-term follow-up
showed a high satisfaction rate as well. However, the
access incision was designed on the superior pole of the
center crease. Though the incidence rate of hematoma was
0 in their series, either for an esthetic or therapeutic view,
we believe that an incision designed on the inferior pole is
more advantageous [17]. Liu and associates excised the
central apocrine glands using scissors supplemented with
scraping against the marginal glands to treat osmidrosis.
Trimming performed under direct vision insured a more
radial removal of the apocrine glands while compromising
the appearance of scars [18].
Herein, we design a new method to combine subcutaneous curettage and trimming together to treat osmidrosis
through a limited incision. Subcutaneous curettage allows a
wide range of scraping toward the apocrine glands, while
mild to moderate curettage tends to result in incomplete
removal of the apocrine glands and aggressive curettage
may lead to scar formation. Thus, after a moderate curettage, we detach the residual glands using a pair of ophthalmic scissors. The pulp of the index finger of the nondominant hand is used to press the axillary flap against the
scissors to assist in efficient detachment. There is no need
to drag or evert the skin flap. Lastly, scratch gently to
remove the sweat glands that are not completely off. Sharp
pruning combined with blunt scraping ensures a more
radical elimination of the apocrine glands while avoiding
excess mechanical injury to the skin flap. The whole procedure is followed through a scrapingtrimmingscraping sequence. If the remaining hairs are not easily pulled
out after the secondary scraping, the trimmingscraping
procedure can be repeated.
The technique holds many distinct advantages: (a) It
allows permanent elimination of axillary malodor compared to those non-surgical methods. (b) The postoperative
scars are almost invisible and much more esthetically
pleasing than those of open surgeries. (c) It is applied with
the most basic surgical tools. The ophthalmic scissors and
fenestrated cup curette are the main tools we need.
(d) Compared to those curettage-only methods, it allows
123
References
1. Yoo WM, Pae NS, Lee SJ, Roh TS, Chung S, Tark KC (2006)
Endoscopy-assisted ultrasonic surgical aspiration of axillary
osmidrosis: a retrospective review of 896 consecutive patients
from 1998 to 2004. J Plast Reconstr Aesthet Surg 59(9):978982
2. Lee JB, Kim BS, Kim MB, Oh CK, Jang HS, Kwon KS (2004) A
case of foul genital odor treated with botulinum toxin A. Dermatol Surg 30(9):12331235
3. He J, Wang T, Dong J (2012) A close positive correlation
between malodor and sweating as a marker for the treatment of
axillary bromhidrosis with Botulinum toxin A. J Dermatol Treat
23(6):461464
4. Shin HS, Min SK, Lim JS, Han KT, Kim MC (2013) Minimal
subdermal shaving by means of sclerotherapy using absolute
ethanol: a new method for the treatment of axillary osmidrosis.
Arch Plast Surg 40(4):440444
5. Ichikawa K, Miyasaka M, Aikawa Y (2006) Subcutaneous laser
treatment of axillary osmidrosis: a new technique. Plast Reconstr
Surg 118(1):170174
6. Ou LF, Yan RS, Chen IC, Tang YW (1998) Treatment of axillary
bromhidrosis with superficial liposuction. Plast Reconstr Surg
102(5):14791485
123
123
14. Kim SW, Choi IK, Lee JH, Rhie JW, Ahn ST, Oh DY (2013)
Treatment of axillary osmidrosis with the use of Versajet. J Plast
Reconstr Aesthet Surg 66(5):e125e128
15. Lee JC, Kuo HW, Chen CH, Juan WH, Hong HS, Yang CH
(2005) Treatment for axillary osmidrosis with suction-assisted
cartilage shaver. Br J Plast Surg 58(2):223227
16. Liu Q, Zhou Q, Song Y, Yang S, Zheng J, Ding Z (2010) Surgical
subcision as a cost-effective and minimally invasive treatment for
axillary osmidrosis. J Cosmet Dermatol 9(1):4449
17. Li Y, Li W, Lv X, Li X (2012) A refined minimally invasive
procedure for radical treatment of axillary osmidrosis: combined
tumescent liposuction with subcutaneous pruning through a small
incision. J Plast Reconstr Aesthet Surg 65(11):e320e321
18. Liu X, Mao T, Lei Z, Fan D (2010) A simple and practical
method for axillary osmidrosis resection. J Plast Reconstr Aesthet
Surg 63(4):e420e421
19. Wu YC, Hsieh CL (2011) Pharmacological effects of Radix
Angelica Sinensis (Danggui) on cerebral infarction. Chin Med
25(6):32