Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
Microsoft Project
by TheP6Pro
Often folks are asking about the differences between Microsoft Project and
Oracle Primavera P6. While coming up with a definitive list is more than
challenging, below highlights some of the detailed feature differences
between Primavera P6 over Microsoft Project.
Its All About The Enterprise
Its clear that Primavera P6 was designed for the enterprise from the start,
while Microsoft Project migrated from a desktop application and added
enterprise capabilities with Project Server. Now that Oracle owns
Primavera P6, this gap is accentuated with the introduction of other heavy
weight Oracle applications that support Primavera P6. Examples of these
include Primavera P6 Analytics, Business Intelligence Publisher, Workflow
and Primavera Gateway. These tools allow for integration with other
enterprise applications marrying project information with other corporate
data, applications and dashboards. Microsoft has not stood still either,
with additional offerings such as SharePoint and Dynamics.
With all these true enterprise capabilities in mind, below are some of the
more detailed features differences listed by real users. This list is not
meant to be exhaustive. It is also important to note that were not
recommending one product over the other.
Multiple User Access
Microsoft Project doesnt allow multiple users to work on a single project
at the same time, Primavera P6 does. In Primavera P6 you can specify
what features of Primavera a particular user is permitted to use. Microsoft
Project Server supports many projects at the same time, but a user locks a
project when its in use.
Baselines
In Microsoft Project, 11 baselines can be created for a project. In
Primavera P6, unlimited baselines can be created and as many as four of
these baselines can be assigned at any one time to a schedule.
Progress and Status
Primavera P6 offers a feature called Progress Spotlight. This Progress
Spotlight highlights activity table rows in yellow if they are due any
status in the next period (day, week, month, quarter or year). Microsoft
Project requires the development of filters to allow for the selection of
activities requiring status.
MS Project and Primavera are both reputed software for project planning, reporting and
updating, tracking. Both the software are used worldwide and they have their own bene
There are several differences between MS Project and Primavera P6.
The following are the differences between Primavera P6 and MS Project:
Baselines
In Primavera you can even specify what features of Primavera a particular user can use
and which he can not.
Issues & Risks
MS Project lacks the feature of tracking project issues or risks.
In Primavera, we can record issues and risks.
Web Support
Primavera plan, documents and other information can be converted to HTML directly fr
MS Project doesn't have such option.
Steps
Steps in Primavera allows you to create sub-activities (steps) of an activity.
Each step can have its own start and finish date, and a completed step can be marked
This useful feature is missing in MS Project.
Expenses
Besides Costs, in Primavera project expenses e.g training, travel, etc can also be added
in MS Project we can not.
Custom Fields
Both MS Project and Primavera allows us to create custom fields. But MS Project even a
complex formulas or use fields and add additional values to it, to use in the custom fiel
In Primavera we can create a blank custom field, but can not set formulas to it,
so users have to manually enter values in each in the field, for each column.
Columns
Primavera P6 has many useful columns.
It comes installed with over 200 columns, each giving you different information.
Some column category to name include EVM, Budgeting, Costs, etc.
On the other hand in MS Project, there are only around 40 columns.
Multiple Activity Relationships
In Primavera P6, more than one type of relationship can be established between activit
we can have FF and SS between the same two activities.
In MS Project only one relationship can be made between two activities.
Project Website
This can be done in MS Project too but since MS Project is not intended for multiple proj
it doesn't allow us to do things like we can do in
Primavera like multiple project tracking,
Multiple project or WBS
comparisons, cost
and
units
There are many more minor differences between Primavera P6 and and MS Project but
above list is of major and prominent differences between the two software.
WBS
In Primavera P6 WBS is created separated from activities.
Once WBS has been created, then we can add activities with each WBS element.
Whereas in MS Project, activities are indented to make them look like WBS.
Which one You Should Learn?
If you are heavily involved in a project or multiple projects, and you are requiring to com
every detail of your project you should go for Primavera P6.
Or if you are working on a single project that doesnt require you record details other th
activity schedule, resource list, and assignment details, use MS Project as it is simpler
See
more
at:
http://www.scientificera.com/business/52-projectmanagement/312-primaverap6-vs-msproject.html#sthash.NSw1mRgZ.dpuf