Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
!"#$!%'&(*),+-
#$.
1/ 032547698:2<;>= 2@?BADC7EGFHJI925KLKL2@MN2@H7OPCQ2@H76SRTUF03VWH7FX;FY%8[Z\ZLFPA
^rtsnuvbdbLwyxWrzv{i|zv]<bdf@^X}9bL_Uzv`~_U*a7@bd9cWePkbLDf<t5ghUa7iGbdjlcWknePm bLo%fUkh@"pqmbdeDbLzvwbdbDUlbdw~DcU
DDDB5D5Dt BtPUU$PBB@B$5P$@DDt#GqtBd5 DDBPtnB5
3'bdLuvdePdbd
$fUxWbdtwsqDbds
uv bd5fBzvbu\DrcUbduv~DettSrtfWwcWuvsdUr#uvb
bcWuvsq5Ub
'bXtrrtsnfUuvsqDbLfBz5cWrt
wyfruvu<D1fUx5bLs%zvwy$yre5}WWy5wbDb*-r
}Bf<@5ud#bdtw
uvx9WxDb'r$xWzvrbcUwywy~tuvrtWz%zvbdbduvz'W
bLr[sk w
uqcU5z\sqbLr$b*uv
bL<zv
}BWfWr$uvbu\UrbduvsqDb}5ruu\
rtrfW5sqsqbdfWcW~X
3zvrtx5txWuvyxUtwfWyrds%rxWuv'cUDrt}WfUUwsdb%_Qrto"ffUcUDxUz|fBzv5sqbde@
DDcWcUcUwyr$s%sluvzvwyytbduv'fWbLz\s1rtr$ruvwzvcUbLbzzvb
}
rrsq}9b*'D<c5fWu%D@f5uvWb$rb
L_ uv5cyrsnb kw
uq5zvB}Wbdsc5uvfWDufX:twyw*
r1fWxUtcUysqusqtuqf
z\r$U
sn|uqzvrzv}Wbc5uvfWDdfQzq_ zvbdLblu*PbdsnfXu\rxW}WrwzqsquvdcU:w[zr$z*uvDWuvbGUWb zvysnfUuxWuvc5
uuqbz\uvrW
ru
rcUfw*U#bzbz"dbL}9zqtu\rtcWff<LbLzv5LcWsnuv
s|sntu\frtfUuvdWbdbs rtuvfWWtbfBrtUw
~Dzvu' uvUtcWsq5b*'rt}@snuvbL|z*WbdwrtyrtfW}Wwb%Ux5sqzvd$e@ePybUz|bLuvs|WfUr u
rfWD5fB'5rt
snuvubLBz|_ ssqbwy~tWBfuv-wuvWr~tuWbLuvzWb<uvcUrxWfx9uvbLWzr}9u|DxUcWzvfW$e@yUtb*fr}@fW'DfB|5bd
wyrtu}U-wybtx5_ zv$e5y5b*}B
r}Wb1wyuUbLf@uv%uv[x5zv9e@rdyUbs#rf
fWtuvWf@5b
sq3uuB#trrzvfbzvf'bde@|bdbLw[r}W{PbLwb1uvrWzvrb*uGrs:c5uvzqWuvrWubLzlrzvdb|D
fWbdx5LzvbdDsq
svrzqsqb:tuvzs
uv}9UbGb"cWsqsqbdb*d"c5uvzvu'bdettrtwcWrruv
bGcW
f5fbLrDz7W5Wuvyt%fLuvzvLcWr
sqtsnu\cWrtffUdbdrts7w~tuvWtzvbuvuWl<|
_Uo"5c5zfW~rtfWrrtwy~tw5tsqzvysuvW*
rf s
lsqx5UzvtDBzvcWd{bdwy
sqdsrt}9fN:btz|rcWwysq
sqb*'}9uvb%fW@cU}95sqbdb*bsn<u#UbdrtrtxUs1\Wwyr*5bd3eP
z\b|rbd
rfBfWuvbLDsd#_fB5zv
{3utz"rtbdfWsnu\Xrtsv}UrwyuvsqUsn3y
fU~'uvUrXbdsqzlbdxUdc5cUzvzvx9uDsqzvbtbL_5e5o"bLcU z
W|9%v|
F|qHWZFtH7F$Z#Y"2UK83H8yZL83250[03V
Fd$F83T5FD6
25Kl2d2BZ Fl2@HUHWVM<54QKFHT83UHM<FHWZtDBYY"F
H7BYZ 2BZ8[Z25H-QF'2<BY"F40GK4TUF830[0:2@HQ$FZ50Q25HV55H7FXt2@72503F5 0[8:KvZLFH83H<ZL
Z F%$UM<M4H8:2@Z835H0[83H K 25HKWV5HqHWZLFLHF$Z 47KFdKCPY 8303F672BZL2M<8[H78[HZLFt H8:W4FtK
2@LFFt5M<83H<8[H7FD25K8[H7503VNQBY"F402@HQ6M<5LFXY%836F03V25t$FDKK8[70[FU
LFtKFLTW83H83TB25V69FtKXH5Z
5H03VJM<Ft25H FFt8[H7S83H9UMN2BZL8[UH5H9Q6FHWZ8:2@08[Z
2@0:K\<M<Ft25H7K%H5ZFtT5FD2@038[H<83H95LMN2BZL8[UHS25QU49ZY N8:K$UM<M4H8:2@Z83HNY%8[Z Y UMS
HUHWVM<54QKLFMN2@830[FtLK12503K250[03Ft6y$D250[03BYZ Ft8[#47KFdKZLKFH76
FtMN2@8303KY%8yZ 54Z
6983KL$03UK83H%Z F18:69FHWZL8yZvVX@9Z F|LFt8[78[FtHUZZ2%Z 8[d6
725\ZvVU FtVX2503K250[03BYZ FK\FtH769Ft
@ 2M<FDKKL2@UFZL<K\ZL2PV2@HUHWVM<54QK|ZL<Z F
LFt8[78[FtHUZD
F'5vFt*ZL8[TUF5lZ 8:KY"5 8:KZ 2PTUFW472@HWZL8yZd2BZ83T5FFDK\40[ZLK5H-Z F25H5HVM<8yZvV
25*ZL472@0303VLBTW8:69FD6VZvY"NM<8yK\5ZvY"25F83M70[FtMFtHWZL2BZL8[UH7K%83HY%8369F69F03BVM<FHWZtCZL
ZFtK\ZZ F25$Z4725025H5HVM<8yZvV7BT8:69Ft6ZZ FJ4QK\FtLKN5XZ FJLFMN258[03FKFLT83F5C|25H76
ZJ$UM<72@LFZ FNZvY"-698[FtFtHUZ6FtK8[UH7KGFFtTB2@03472BZLF<25H5HVM<8yZvV8[H2-K8[H7503F$nH969F
!#"
%$'&(
)*$'$'&
,+
%-
0+21
5/ .
8:9<;
3-
6 . &
=?>A@CBEDGF*H*IKJ
4 1
.'/(
%$'$3
71
M
T
PQ
VU
W
YX
Z
O
R3&
lm t
xr$zvysqtfN}9bLulbdbdfu#xUz\rtuvydrtw
UbLsqy~tfWs
7H72@0LFt8[83FHWZD FH4MF @M<FDKKL2@UFtK|KFHWZ8[HS2 -5HFX$V90[F@Z FM<8[7
83K24HQ*Z835H5GZ
F HW47MF @#MFDKKL2@UFtK"83HZ F
WU0
[
`_
\2Q]^"
a(bdcefgGhjilkmonqp
ros k r abtcPnvuwohGx(eyfzghjikm'ej{ghqp
r s k r kmnvu|ohx(e}p
o
,
.'/
^
6
O
\ A_
}_
A_ V[(_
0.9
0.8
0.7
P(n)
0.6
0.5
0.4
0.3
0.2
0.1
5'rtsnuvbLz|fuvUb %N
50
100
n
150
V
8:98
200
5IK<>AD7AI
zvxWxWbLe5wwbdbd
tcWbLbdsf@fBluuvb*tuvzv
{yfJbdWsnrtu\|srbd
r$wzvyxW~DrtcWs}WbdwbDf
uvrtxUr$xUuzvDuvWx5zvsyr
uvbXbLuv5Ubd@wyrd<s:cUz%fWwb*rt{P\bdw
uv"<}9bfNb uvWbdLbuvxePrbtuvt sqfUh5d%blh uvW_7bjQsqzvbdcUfbX5bLhBzvk s}9b
r}WUwbLbs|uvl"DUcWbLwyuv<bzvzv
b ByfUcWbGzvuvbUrb
sqUbLbdzvsqe@~tdfWb"b*Jx5zve@uvyUb|DsqfUcWw\'rfU:x9BzvD'wr
uvD-f7_@fW1bubL#~Przvz\{J5wbdyfsqsdU
rtslfuvUb1uv
Wbdbdsqsqbsvruv~Dy
b1xUbLsnzvu\trtuv
BLxWDsw9 rzvrb<s#fUtzvtu'~DcUfWsqrtb*ww7 _
1bLwyyr}Wwb%uv5cUsUBbdsfUtuxUzv$e@yUbrf@'zvbdsqsnu\rfWdb%uvuvUs|{@ftrLuvePbruqu\r{9_
1
~
!# vR$3
^
P]j ]jQQ
71
j
MX
Z
W
Q]
8:9
BB6HJDE
\LG! A5
O
}o*.
O(/.
v.
}
:
v]^] <
P ]o\] A" ] }'! ]
O
y N.'.3 <
QA P PV ]^]j
? .'(
O!
. 3
K
0
.'3
mlt
xr$zvysqtfN}9bLulbdbdfu#xUz\rtuvydrtw
UbLsqy~tfWs
ZSZ FNH4MQFtX@14QK\FtLKtqHZ 8:KX72@F
Y"F<Y%8[030 47KFZ FNHUH9H75LM<250[83?FD6 Q2PTU5@
Z F
M<F$ZL8:@
F'2@HUHVWM<8[ZvVLBT836Ft6WVS2<M<8y-25HSF5M<49ZLFt6S5Z F'83H75M<8[H7N5%U
Z F549ZL5U8[HM<FtKLK255FtKt5F
250[0QZ 8:K 5 B N2@HQ6
B B
5
B 5M<49ZLFZ FJKFH76F2@H75HVM8[ZvV5C#Y"F-Y"25HWZZL H7BY Z F
F$Ft*ZL8[TUFK8[?tF5 Z F2@HUHWVM<8[ZvVSKF$ZX@|KFH76FdK%52M<FtKLKL2@5F549ZL49ZVSZ FM<8[
FLF$UFUCY"FN$UM749ZF<Z F<FHWZL5VJ5|Z FNU72@78[038yZvVJ683K\ZL8[749Z835HZ 2@Z'Ft032@ZFDK
54Zd2@L5F$Z%U49ZU583HM<FDKKL2@UFY%8[Z 2@030Z F
QWKK8[70[F
83H49ZdK
$
B X$5M<4ZF1Z F"F$Ft$Z83T5FFD$8383FHWZl25H5HVM<8yZvV
KF$Z K\83?F"@Q25H
8[H75M<83HM<FtKLKL2@5F'Z 2@Z5FDKZ U4 Z FM8[CQY"F 2PT5F
ZL$UM<49ZFZ FFHWZLUWV
@Z F-L5725830[8[ZvV698:KvZL8349ZL8[UH Z 2BZNLF0:2BZFDKZ FJ WK\FtH 83H49ZY%8[Z 250[0UKLK\8303F
549ZL49ZLKt
@ZLF%Z 2BZ|83H<Z FDK\FZvY1't25KFtKtCBZ FM<F$ZL8:$UM749ZFDK Z F2@H75HVM8[ZvV52
8[H749ZU54Z49ZMFDKKL2@UF58[Z69FDKH5Z583T5F'2<UFHFtL250TB2@034F
52<M8[-69FtK8[UH
2@H768[Z|83K|69FFH76FHWZ1UHZ FZd2 72@Z\ZLFLH F2U69TB2@HWZL255F@Z 83K|UQFt\ZvV83KZ 2@Z
M8[9FtK
MN2PVJ5Ft'83H95LMN2BZ835H2@54Z
Z F X2@HUHWVM<8[ZvV-Z FtV25F<LBT836983HQ
F698:KL2569TB2@HWZd2@5FX8:KZ 2BZ8yZQFD$5M<FDKT5FtV698 $40[ZZL$UMQ2@LFXZ Ft5LF$Z8:250[03V698y
FLFHWZM<8y69FDK\835H7KtGFT5Ft\Z F03FtKLKtC8yZ83KQWKK8[70[FNZLJM<Ft2UK\4LFN5HLFt250|K\V9K\ZFtM<KU
K\83M40:2BZL8[UH7KdZ F%2@HUHVWM<8[ZvV
59Zd2@83HFt6520:2@L5F"H4MF#@M<FtKLK255FDK25H767BT8:69F
$5M<725L2@Z83T5FXKvZd2BZL83K\Z8:KtC25KY"F
69N8[HZ 83K%Q2@FD
MFD25K4LF 8[9M<2UKvZLF KlKFH769Ft 2@H76
LFt8[78[FtHUZ 2@H75HVM8[ZvV5CDY"F 2PTUF125038[FD6
Z F
5LM40:25KLBTW8:69FD6
V;>= 25?12@HQ6 LFH7FF0W83H ; n F%2@HUHVWM<8[ZvVX@ %Ft0[8:2@70[F 2UK
QFtFHM<Ft2UK\47FD64QK\83H
Z FUM4032UK LFtKFHWZFD68[H FH7698[ 5ZF%Z 2BZ|Y"F540:6
H@Z%2@70[VZ FM<F$Z 9647KFt6V XFDK65U25H
R QFD2547K\FY1F698:6H5Z"MN2 F25HWV
25KLK\4M<9ZL8[UH5HZ F6983K\ZL8349Z835H@Z FM<8[ K18[HQ$5M<83H'ZLL2 ' XFDK69UU25H25KLK\4M<FDK
8[H75M<83H 58:KK5HZd2 t$
]" ]^]
]^" M]]
P L
<
M P L
]]^]
<
]j]^]j
LG A
Q!#
6Q ]
#
.
M }R$3
:
j1
C9<;
4HH3DG3BECIK
)!#
v..'/
0&
q1
A'/
$'$K
/'$
3'
l G
:9<;
5DGACF*><F)jRH3IM>< 7H4H*JDE
}
M
Q
P"
<
mlt
xr$zvysqtfN}9bLulbdbdfu#xUz\rtuvydrtw
UbLsqy~tfWs
8[HWZFtTB250
M<8[H49ZLFtKN
U$QF2503K$5HQKvZL47$ZFD62 5H9Q6FH7F
8[HWZFtTB2505#Z 83K FDKvZL8[MN2@ZF55qHZ 8:K Y"2PVY1F"547H76
Y%8yZ 5H969FH7FFt5835H
5 FHY1FXF5LM<Ft625969HFtKLK\5Z"ZFDKvZ%ZL69F$ZLFLM<8[HF
8[#Y1F
25H
F\vFt*Z%Z F VQ5Z FDK\8:K
BZ F
H4MF%5%25L83TP2503K"F%ZL8[M<F
83HWZFLTB2@0 58:KKt
Y FLF STB2@L83FtKBTUF|Z F
$UH7K\ZL47*ZLFt65H9Q6FH7F83HUZLFLTB2@0 F5969HFDKK\n@Z|ZLFtK\Z
Y1F147K\FD6'8:KZ F"Y1Ft0[0[ HBY%H</ 8yqKLU4Q2@LF ZFDKvZ%6
U* K83H2K\835H78yQt2@H7F
0[FtT5F05 5CWZ F
HW470[0 V@Z FtK83KUF$ZLKLFvvFD*ZLFt6/ 8[nTP250[47F
U
qH Z F0[FZ72@ZN@ l8354LF JY"F-K BY Z F-H4MQFtN@MFDKKL2@UFtKFD$Ft8[TUFt6V
Z FXM<8yQFt 54D FXL8[ Z725\Z@ 83547F K BYK1Z FXFT5U0[4Z835HS@Z F'2@L83TB2@0:K
QFt62PV5FXt2@HS57KFLT5FZ 2@ZZ FXZLL2 NZ 2BZ2@L83T5FD62BZZ FXM8[S6483HZ F7dK\Z
MUHWZ 83KM47 Ft2PT8[Ft"Z 25H83HSZ F50303BY%8[HZ FtFM<UHUZ Kt 83K%K BYK1Z 2BZ%Z F
8[H749Z'Zd2 72@Z\ZFtHZ 2BZ'UF$ZLKZLJ2M<8yH969FN83K 8[ 03VJ4HLFt683$ZL2@70[F25H76Z 2@Z
Z F'2UKK4M<9Z835HS@#0:2@M62F83H<Z83M<F$n8[H76FFH769FtHWZ2@H7H@Z U036
83547F K BYKZ FLFtW4FtH7$V8[H U4dKN2@H76(83H 672PVK<5LFtF83T8[H2FZL2@83H
HW47MFX@2@L83TB2@0:KQFN25HKFFZ 2@Z
8[HMWKvZ
5Z F U4dKZ F<M8[LFtF83T5FtK0[FDKK
Z 25H M<FDKKL2@UFtKt
q3&
A'*.'.
$'&'
,5
3$$o
3$$ P..K&
_O3.'
(''.
7. .
7
.
:98
5DGACF*><F)j=?>A@CBEDGF*H*IKJ
F 2PTUFNK\83M40:2BZLFt62 8y9MN25K\ZFt
H969F25KXF903258[H7Ft68[HIFD*Z835H Q 8y9MN25K\ZFt
83K
250M<8[2@HQ679$FDKKFtK"M<FtKLKL2@5FDK"8[H72@ZL FDK FXLFt8[83FHWZ25H5HVM<8yZvVN5lFD25
MFDKKL2@UF83H-2583T5FHU4H7683K%Z F
KL2@M<F5R1U478[TB2@03FHWZL0[VUC2@030549ZL49ZLK@l2L54HQ6 2PTUF
Z F<K25M<FK\FtH769Ft25H5HVM<8yZvVSTB2@034F5qH-Z 83KXKFt$Z835HJY"FK BY Z FLFtK40yZdKU9ZL258[HFD6
8[H547K\83M40:2BZL8[UH
qH l8354LF
Y1FK BY Z F5LFt032@Z835HF$ZvY"FFtH<Z F%LFt8[78[FtHUZ|25H5HVM<8yZvV2@H76Z F
69F0:2PVN5%FtT5FtVNM<FtKLKL2@5FU 83547F K BYK1Z F'KL2@M<F5KFH76F2@H75HVM8[ZvV5
F7dKvZ5H70[4QK\835H Y"FJ$5M<F-ZLY FH U7KFLTW83HZ FJ7U4FDK<83KZ 2@ZZ FLF
83K<20[BY"FQU4H76ZZ F-2@H75HVM8[ZvV@ 8y9MN25K\ZFtt#nZN83KY"5Z H7@Z83HZ 2@ZtCK
2@DCY1FN69SH@Z HBY 2@HVZ Ft5LF$ZL83t2@02@HQ2@03VK8:K5"50 M<8y9FDK
2@03FZLFD698:*Z
Z F
2@HUHWVM<8[ZvV2<QU0M<8ySBT8:69FtKtC2@HQ67835ZL<Z 8:K2@HQ2@03VK8:K"Z FtF
Y"FLFXH<7547FDK
5HNZ F25H5HVM<8yZvVZ 2@Z 8[9MN25K\ZF1Y"2UK|2U*Z4Q2@030[V<LBT836983HQ@ 8yZ Z 83K"K8[M4032@Z835HC
Y1F2@HJ0[FD2@L0[VKFF'Z 2BZ 8[MN2UKvZLFU472@d2@HWZLFFtK2M<8[H78[M4M K\FtH769FX2@HQ6FD$838[FtHWZ
2@HUHWVM<8[ZvVN@l25QU49Z 8:KM<Ft2@HQK"Z 2@Z"Z F
K\FtH769FtXFD$8383FHWZd"52MFDKKL2@UFUF$ZLK
2M<83H83M4M2@HUHWVM<8[ZvV
FtW483TP250[FtHWZZLFFt$Z8[HQ6983K\Z83HU483K 258[038[ZvV2@M<5H7
K\FtH769FdK
LFt8[78[FtHUZdKL$
Ft2@HK\FtFZ 2@Z
Z FM<83H83M4M 2@HUHWVM<8[ZvVJ83K'BT8:69Ft6Y FtHZ F<Zd2 -2@
83TB2@0:KL83KG0[BY
KGZ F|Zd2 83H7FD25KFtKtC2@HUHVWM<8[ZvV83H7FD25KFtKtC5FZ\ZL8[HMN2B98[M4M TP250y
4FtK@725QU49Z '8 FU[CPFDU478[TB2@03FHWZZFFt$Z83H7698:KvZL8[H7548:K 2@830[8[ZvV
2@M<5H7 UA
W
K\FtH769FdK U|LFt$8383FHWZLKt5F2503K'5QK\FtTUF1Z 2BZ1Z F69F0:2PV9K@Z FM<FtKLKL2@5FDK 695H Z1ZL2 F
8[ TP250[47FtKtC94H03FtKLK"Z FXZLL2 N03U2U6UF$Z\ZL8[H7ZL<Z F
M<8[8:KT5FtV03BY
qH5d69F
ZLK\Z476VZ FF 2PT835'5%Z FM8[4H769Ft698[FLFHWZZLL2 N0[W256KtCY"F
2PT5F0[5Z\ZLFt6TP250[47FtK@69F0:2PV-2@H762@HUHVWM<8[ZvV59Zd2@83HFt68[HZ FNK8[M40:2BZ835H5Z F
)
3
}3.
3.'
1800
18000
1600
16000
1400
14000
1200
12000
Number of arrivals
Number of arrivals
1000
800
10000
8000
600
6000
400
4000
200
2000
500
1000
1500
2000
2500
3000
20
40
7 pfUdD
fW~uqz\rX%xruquvbzvfWs
hours
60
80
100
120
days
V
Binwidth = 500
Binwidth = 20
80
1800
70
1600
60
1400
1200
1000
800
50
40
30
600
20
400
10
200
0
200
400
600
800
1000
Number of arrivals
1200
2000
1400
8
Sender Anonimity per message
10
7
6
5
4
1
0
mlzqzvbdwyruvDfbdwyrd@ki1fWtfBU
u:z%5'rtsnuvbz
V
16000
14000
12000
10000
8000
Number of arrivals
W
10
6000
7 Uzvb BcWbLfWLrfrtw5sqs1fWxUcUuvs
V *
4000
x 10
9
8
x 10
140
mlt
xr$zvysqtfN}9bLulbdbdfu#xUz\rtuvydrtw
UbLsqy~tfWs
U4H76KY%8[Z FtY 25L8[TB2503KX03BY ZLL2 t*C78[HWZFtM<FD69832@ZF
H4MQFt%@ 2@L83TB2@0:KM<Ft69834M
Zd2 t$C2@H76SMN2@HV25L8[TB2503KX 8[ ZLL2 ND*
F 2PT5F'KF03Ft$ZFt6SZ F03BY
C7M<FD698[47MSC25H76 83 ZLL2 N
ZL2 83H83HWZ2U$U4HWZZ F
62BZd2K\ZL2@Z8:KvZL83tK@lZ F'25L83TP2509FtKLK
2@030QL547H76K1Y FLFZ FH4MQFt15G2@L83TB2@0:KY25K|QFZvY1FtFHNZ FQLK\Z"25H76
Z 83d6SW4725\ZL8[03F< 672BZL2 5* FtH7$F Fd$FtHWZ5GZ FXU4H76K%25FX69FH7@ZFD6
25KHUMN250Zd2 @
2@030QL547H76K1Y FLFZ FH4MQFt15G2@L83TB2@0:KY25K|5LFt2BZLF|Z 25HZ F
Z 83d6SW4725\ZL8[03FX49Z03BY1Ft"Z 25HZ F
54Z038[Ft%QU4H76 62@ZL2 P*
2@030U4H76KY%8[Z 549ZL0[83FTB2@034FtK5Z F83H75M<8[H7M<FtKLKL2@5FDK62BZd2
D$
qH l8354LF Y"FK BY Z F'M<8[H49ZLFtK569F0:2PV@ FtT5FLVM<FtKLKL2@5FNZ FWq2B98:K8[HQ698y
2BZLFtKZ FNFT5U0[4Z835H83HZ83MFP*F25HKFFZ 2BZXZ F6F0:2PV-5H03VZL2 FtK 83 TB2@034FtK
Y FHZ FZd2 83K03BY
F2U*ZZ 2@Z
K5M<FMFDKKL2@UFtK2@Ft252UK 2PTW83HS269Ft032PV
$03UKFXZ?tFLN8[HZ F03BYZLL2 X7547F
8:K6947F
ZNZ F'2U*ZZ 2BZY1F 2PT5F
M<5LF'K25M
0[FDKCUK\XZ FLF2@LF%M<FtKLK255FtKlZ 2BZ|25L83T5Flv47K\Z|QF5LFZ F 747K 8[H7'2@H76<2@LF5LY2@d69Ft6
8[M<M<Ft698:2BZLF03V5UqH l8[U4F XY"FK BYZ FFD$838[FtHWZ|2@HUHWVM<8[ZvV@FtT5FLVM<FDKKL2@UFXZ F
K\FtH769F2@HUHWVM<8[ZvVLFtKFHWZLK%TUFLVK8[M<830325 2@d25$ZFt8:KvZL83tKL$9F2@H-KFFXZ 2BZ2UKZ F
Zd2 "8[H7FD25KFtKtCZ F2@H75HVM8[ZvV
LBT8369FD6
Zd2 FDK 83 FtlTB250[4FDK@XM<2@Z\ZLF BY0[BY
Z FXZLL2 N03U2U68:KCZ F'25H5HVM<8yZvVNLBT836Ft6WV 8y9MN25K\ZFt%83K%250[Y2PV9K2@BT5F
H*J(DGE
=?Io><B
(
&.
H*J(DGE
>^H*JDE
j
0
&
Y
minutes of delay
Mixmaster: Delay values for rounds with low, medium and high traffic
500
500
500
450
450
450
400
400
400
350
350
350
300
300
300
250
250
250
200
200
200
150
150
150
100
100
100
50
50
50
bdwyrdetrtwcWbLs#:tz5'rtsnuvbLz
Low Traffic
Medium Traffic
High Traffic
V
:9
5DGACF*><F)j5IK<>AD7AI
FZ FUFZ8:2@05MFZ 96
7UQWK\FD683H
R WZ 2BZGU8[TUFtKG2U72@78[0383K\Z8:#LFt698:*ZL8[UH
5 HZ F25H5HVM<8yZvV-LBT836Ft6WV %F03832503F8:K
72UK\FD6UHZ F25KLK4M<9Z835H@ 58:KK5H
Zd2 @ KY"F 2PTUFKFFHGCZ 83K25KLK\4M<9ZL8[UH-83K69F7H8[ZF03VSH@ZX$5LLFt*Z%UFtM<258[0M<8y
Zd2 @
Y vR$3
d
10.5
10.5
10.5
10
10
10
9.5
9.5
9.5
8.5
8.5
8.5
7.5
7.5
7.5
7
0
7
0
7 i1fUDfB5
u
etrtwcWbds 3tz"U'rsnuvbLz
Low Traffic
Medium Traffic
High Traffic
V
F 2PT5F
K\83M47032@ZFt6-2 F0383250[FM8[-25K%F703258[HFD6S8[HIFD*ZL8[UH 7 %Ft0[8:2@70[F
ZLFD2BZdK
F T5FtVM<FtKLK255F8[HQ69FFH76FHWZ03VUY FtHN8yZ1FD$F83T5FDK2XM<FtKLK255F8[Z"69Ft032PV9K 8[Z512
LFt69F
ZFLM<8[H7Ft62@M<54HWZX@ZL8[M<F-KF03Ft$ZFD6JL5M 25HF$95HFtHWZ8:2@0 698:KvZL8349ZL8[UHQ2@H76JZ FtH
5LY"25L6K"8[ZtF
LFLFtKFHWZ%2K\ZL25tC 3C9FM<FtKLKL2@5FU
qH 83547F Y"F'LFtKFHWZ%Z FK\FtH769Ft2@HQ6LFt8[78[FtHUZ2@HUHWVM<8[ZvVLBT8369FD6SWV %F$
0[8:2@03FS5<Z F-FD2@0K\ZLFt25M @8[H749ZLKNY"F 2PTUFS5H7K836FLFt6 F-2@H KFFSZ 2BZNZ F
2@HUHWVM<8[ZvVZL2 FtKM<8[H78[M4M TB2@034FtK
0[WK\FZ?tFL7CY 8: M<Ft25H7KZ 2@Z'K\UMF<5|Z F
MFDKKL2@UFtK<25HFZL83TW8:2@0303VZd25Ft6V(2Q25KLK\83T5F2BZZL25 FD FM<2@98[M4M TB2@034FtK
@ %F03832503F K'2@HUHVWM<8[ZvV-5XZ 8:K'83H49Z25F<03BY1FtZ 25H 8y9MN25K\ZFt KXMN2B98[M4MNK
83547F K BYKZ F 8[ 0[V$5LLF0:2BZFD6-TB2@034FtK5"KFH769Ft
2@H76FD$8383FHWZX25H5HVM<8yZvV
5Q5Z %F03832503F2@HQ6 8[9M<2UKvZLFDQFN25H$03Ft2503V-K\FtF'Z 2BZX5 %F038:2@03FK5M<F@
Z F
M<FtKLKL2@5FDK|UF$Z%HFD2@L0[VNHN25H5HVM<8yZvVUCWY 8[03FZ F
UHFtK"@ 8[MN2UKvZLF%5FZ2@Z%0[FD25K\Z
K\FtH769F25H76FD$838[FtHWZ2@HUHWVM<8[ZvV
O1
1
:o
M
1
)
:9
=?>A@CBEDGF*H*IKJCF97YIo<>AD7AI
`?3
G1
mlt
xr$zvysqtfN}9bLulbdbdfu#xUz\rtuvydrtw
UbLsqy~tfWs
t
mlzqzvbdwyruvDfNbLw[rd@ki1fUDfB5
uX:z|1bdwyrt}Uwb
V
8
7
6
5
4
3
2
1
0
4
5
6
Sender Anonimity per message
7 mlzqzvbdwyruvDfh5bLfUbzqk|bddxUybLf@u i1fWtfBU
uX:z1|bdwyrt}Uwybrf<5'rtsnuvbz
V
10
)1
` !P
`
#" `
}
M1
'
z1
$C9<;
^FH)F3I'J%^I'J5>AH*IjJ>HP
)
./3
&
'
$C98
(
)><F*F3IKF
qH283TB25V2@038:2BZL8[UH$0383FHWZtC25H83HUZL48[Z83T5F47K\Ft8[HWZFt\2U$F83K"FtKLKFHWZ8:2@083H5d69Ft|ZL
FH7K4LF Z 2@ZZ F1K@ZvY2@LF 8:KG47KFt6$5HQK\8:KvZLFHWZ03V
2@H76$5LLFt*ZL0[V I25K n 5LFt2@ZFG0[FtT5F0
@K 830[02@H-KL2BFt0[VQF2UKK4M<Ft6SY FtHJ69FtK835H83HNL8[TB2U$VK@ZvY2@LFZ 2@Z83K8[HWZLFH769FD6
ZJF5Fd2BZLFt625K2-K\FtT8:$FUC BY"FT5Ftt UK\Z2@HUHWVM<8[ZvVKVK\ZFtMNKC8[H70[4Q698[H7JM<8y
j#rtfWfWW~XbLtzvuvbfUWzvh5tr$cUcWeDf9b#~Do%}9hbduvbdWWfXh@b
DfUcWwyrsnsqzvu\b'rtsdfW1Lh@bdmcWsfUo%~9hzvbdUf9'i1rt p wbL5zvysGpfWzv}U*rUsqb*ls Xb$o%DDfht-uvU<b|frtr*uvo%UePh 'bLwSrsn uvrt bLfWz5f_uv5U$zvdt@cWs 5~tbd}j ruvsqWb1fWb
trx9cWuvbLsqePb
z\bdrwuq k
mrtfW5~tf9cUwuv yxU wbfWePUbL*zvsqDs fU"stG:uvaQUzvf@tcUcW~D_ XuvU bcWsqb|tm 5~tf9 UzvbLb* h5 "bu\ h5@o"x9bdf h@
4
%.'3
,+
0+
-+
U
/.
%.
lm t
xr$zvysqtfN}9bLulbdbdfu#xUz\rtuvydrtw
UbLsqy~tfWs d
8[M<03FM<FHWZd2BZ835HQKCP6983M<03V'2K\835H78yQt2@HWZl6F5LFF|@7$UM<0[F98yZvVUPI83H7FZ F1UQFtL2@Z835H
@2470[8:"qHUZLFLHF$ZKFLT83F|83HWTU503T5FDKZ F%$5LLFt*Z#$UH97547L2@Z835H25H76MN258[HWZFtH72@HQ$F"@
Z F UK\Z1KFLT5FDCBZ 83K1HFD$FtKLKL2@LV$UM<0[F98yZvV83K125t$FZL2@70[F2UK035H25K Z FUQFtL2@ZU K
K 830[0 03FTUF0#83K
K4 $83FHWZD F<0[FtT5Ft0l5"K 8[030 FDW48[LFt6JZL5FL0[V-83H7K\ZL250[0C$UH97547FUC
2@H76(5Fd2BZLFJ2M<8y(H969FJK 540:6(H@ZF$FFD6Z 2@ZFDU478[LFt6Z7UQFt03V83H7KvZd2@030C
$5H754LF5C925H76S5Fd2BZFZ F'K\FtTUF"8yZdK\Ft0yv
FK@ZvY2@LFN725 2@UFtK
Y"FFtTP250[4Q2BZFD6698[FtFD6Y%8[Z LFW2@d6ZL-Z F8383HWZF25F
$5M<03F$98[ZvV83H2H4MQFt%@ 2@LFt25Kt
qHUFHFtL250C %Ft0[8:2@03F 2UKN2UFD2BZLF \Ft2UK\FS@X47KF 25$ZUY%8[Z LFtKQFD*Z<Z8[ZLK
8[HWZFt\2U$FU 8y9MN25K\ZFt2@49ZL5MN2BZLFtKlMN2@HV'83M<QU\Zd2@HWZ#ZL25K KC@K47 25K 2U62@9ZL8[TUF%694M<MV
5FH7Fd2BZ835HGC FtV<5ZL2BZL8[UH2@H76 FtVF98[d2BZL8[UH2@HH754H7FM<FHWZDCW25H7683HWZFUL2@ZFDKM<5LF
Ft25K830[V<Y%8[Z Z F UK\Z J F0383250[F K183H7KvZd2@03032@Z835H79$FDKK|83K1Ft2UK\83FDC5749Z"8[ZLK14830:6
9FtKLKLFtW483FDKZ F47KF@
Z 8[d6n72@ZvV $5M<M<Fd$8:2@02@70[8:2@Z835H7KS2@H7625KLK\4M<FDK
F$9QFt83FHQ$FY%8[Z 83H769BYK169FTUF035M<FHWZDCUK
MWKvZ147K\FtLK|Y%8[030783H7K\ZL250[02
LF$q$5M<8303Ft6
8[HQ2@LV5Q/15M<830:2BZ835HS@ 8[9M<2UKvZLF8:K%QFt\UM<FD6Z U4 2<K\83M<03F'K Ft0[0KL$L839Zt
Z'7dKvZU0325H7$FUC8[Z2@7QFD2@dKXZ 2@Z %Ft0[8:2@03FY%830[01QFFt2UK\83F
U UVW8:K\ZLK
ZLJ5
Fd2BZFZ 25H 8[9M<2UKvZLFD BY1FtT5FttC 8y9MN25K\ZFt K68 $470yZvV-69FtKH5ZL83KF25QBTUF
Z F
698 40yZvV-5|MN2@83HWZL2@83H83H2K\FD$4LFqHWZLFLHF$Zn5HHFD*ZLFt6JKFLT5FttC2@H76Z 47K 25K0[8[Z\ZL0[F
F$Ft*ZUHZ F
BT5FtL250[0KFt48[ZvV5l2M<8ySH969F'69F70[BVM<FHWZt
*
q1
,+
*-
11
'
'
$C9
2J3JDGBEB>A06AD4^D5jI
1
$C9
8 jJIM'CIC'BIKH3DH*><j
25$83038yZd2BZFK\U4d$F6FLFT8[FtY2@H76JT5FL8[Q2@Z835H@125H2@70[8:2@Z835H K5LFD*ZLHFtKLK
Y%8yZ LFU25L6ZL8[ZLK8[M<03FM<FtHUZd2BZL8[UH @2 L@Z950C|8[ZS8:KFH7F$Q83250UZ FLFJZL
%j#<Wrtbw}Uj7cWz\wrt{XfWsqx9uvWzqu1b1i1d@~DUbLb"f@u*3Utz1bD_ ~U_Wsq5bd'f5rtsn'uvbLrtz|w@t_ z|x9 Drsns uqU zvuquvbLf}B
`"w DwwbLz1rts Ws#Uzvsnu 'r tz
sqUtbd[~uzv bdr$b zvb U bdeDbd_UwD"xWb1
bLrtf@sulsqxUfWzvLnbbd~Pu|ryfUb*Uwyb"zvbddsqDx9
bLLxUu|wybrtuvs|yfUr~sqU{@yslwwb*cWf5LbLzq5zv~txUz\uvrttU~tcWz\rrxWuvbWdt
sqxW3uc5 uvrbLzvz#bsqd5bdbdePfUbddwb k
DcWx9fWbLUzQbLz":r
zWxWsqsbd tcWx9UbdDf%fB5sqD<c5Wzvdrtb#frflbx5zvdDrtxUfzvDbLfUu\wr$zqsqx9UbdbLdePcUbdw[wr$DuvxUbX
rbd}9fBDuQcUx5u1zv uvWbdbLuvwsdbd_$eP|bdwbdtwyGrt}WbL5wbx9 bLzvrsbdfWrtLc5buvWtzvbduv s
rtWc5bd}5uvWzvctz*r_zqBj# UDbLDzvDb"W_ rts}9bdbdffW{@fW*f'dD
cWfW*r$uvDfXuvuvUb"rcUuvUtz |bdwyrt}Wwb1sqyfUdb
NX
<
=<
<
./
$C9
`1
)<IolA>JDJ>AIoF
?>
'
\ '
A
@
/
' 1
$C9B$
CJ(:H3DjJD7><H*><jF
/ .
E
GF
}1
O .
C1
H
$C9KJ
0 .
&
LHJj:F3jJIoF
FW47250[8[ZvV5Z FFHWZL5V<K\U4d$F0:2PV9K|25HNF$ZLFM<F03V<8[M<5ZL25HUZ1U0[F83H@Z Z F
Q50M<8[2@H76I M<8[K FM<FtKtPqHWU0UM<8[K\V9K\ZFtM<KtCDZ F"M<8y983H8[HZ F"QU0WM47K\Z
QFN$LV9ZU5d2@ 83t2@030[VSL25H769UM 8[H5d69FZM<8yZ FZd2 8[H2H75H9q69F$ZLFLM<8[H8:K\Z8:
1sbLrtUwyyf'r}WyrfWwsnbUuvbdbLzvx9bLz wybLfbd_ s"@U_ bLDf@f<Wu#rtuvrtWsxUbrxWfw*bLrf@5uvuv'DzvrtfbdsnwuvyfbL5z uv s _b@zv*_ bdfBfu}WdzvfW@~DrUzqBbLu*}Urt3rttsqfWz"buvsqDsq
rtUf%DbcWuvtwyW'GrufWuvs|u3cW}9fUb"L5duv'tDfWrtfsqsnryuvUwbLbLzuzvB@bd9_5|_ rbd w
[rW}Wbzvwwbbb
bLpu%@uvbds%fWcUsqftUfbzvuvsnuvBuv@Wb%uvWr5u'rr*snuvbLs%zdf@UuvWbL}brtLsqzqbt5_ xUuvD~z\rtxUW
rtw~ttzvuvW
swwGr bdLu%uvUbsqbdLcUzvu
uvtDW~sqbdz\frt3xWubd UeDrr
zvwbcrtrxUuvuvxWfUr$wu ~*rzvuvuvbdWwDbbdfUs1sqsWcUrrx9zvzvDb*b
f5uvLcWWzqb5DxUuvsqbuvDrt~wr*z\~DrtxUzvs"WuvyUf%
wuvyWsd}5_bz\1rzv
$bdlxWsdbdw_ bdeP
bLz*bdUfBsqu\rfWuvdb%tfQ
9t*snr$u|zvbXruqu\rcUsn{@u"s }9Dbfu\Lrtzq{P5bLxUf k
%x9tzvzquz1:uvzuvuvUUb%bXbL"5hUxWi1z\1ruvg tfNrttfWuvW b"hUi h5igxwr$}Uuvbdz\fBr$zvu*yWbLeDsbLrzvsqsDlfWbdsww_`"sqb
5'#ruvsnWuvbdbLsqz b
eD_ 5bL_zv<sqD fWsbLzvb*1<sqcUxU@kk
'rtsnuvbLzs|wyrzv~DbLwrt}WrtfWUDfUb*7_
~
}U
lm t
xr$zvysqtfN}9bLulbdbdfu#xUz\rtuvydrtw
UbLsqy~tfWs
Y"2PVU F
ZL8[M<FtK\ZL25M<7KZ 2BZ69FZFtM<83HF BY 0[UH2NM<FtKLKL2@5F
K 547036F Ft036V25H
IW M<8[83M70[FtMFtHWZL2BZL8[UHNM47K\Z|2@0:K
QF%L5M2
KvZLUHXFHWZL5VK547LF5 Z FKL2@M<F
FD25K5H7Kt5qH25668yZL8[UHCWZ F 8[9M<2UKvZLF"M<FtKLK255FUMN2@ZKQFD$8[7FtK1Z FX47K\F@L25H7695M
62BZd2U%8yZdK%M<FtKLK255FX2@H76 FD2569Ft725668[HQ
I@ZvY2@LF8:Kl6FFH769FtHWZ#UH8[ZLKl4H76FL0[V83HUQFtL2@Z83HKV9KvZLFM Ul2596'K54d$F1@
FHWZL5V5/1V9ZL55d2@ 83XW47250[8[ZvVFtHWZL5V8:K2KL25LF
FDK\U4d$FX5H-M<UK\ZKV9KvZLFMNKCA
2@H76Z FLF$UF'Z FFHWZL5VSK\U4LFtKBT8:69Ft6VM<UK\ZM<969FLH-5Fd2BZL8[H7K\V9K\ZFtM<K
25*ZL472@0303VLBTW8:69F U49Z4ZY 83 S 2UKQFtFH-K\FtFt69FD6Y%8[Z ZL403VWd2@HQ695M 62@ZL2
8y9MN25K\ZFt4QK\FDK FHII9E KSL25H76 47H7*ZL8[UH7KALA F0383250[F47KFtKZ FK\ZL25H762@d6
8[H76BYKKV9KvZLFM 250[0C H76$C%Y FH59Zd2@83H8[H7 FHWZLUWVUC|Y%8[Z Z FF$$Ft9Z835H@
MFDKKL2@UF25H76 Ft2U69F%Q2566983H-Y 83 8:K%695HF
VNZ F'K45Z83H 8y9MN25K\ZFt 9
8[HQ2@LV9$ F H764HQ*Z835H 8:KH7@ZJ2 V9ZL55d2@ 83t2@030[V K\ZL5H(K\U4LF5FH9
ZL5V /15 %H76GKvZd2@ZLK'Y%8[Z 2KFFt6TB250[4FS2@H765FH7Fd2BZFDK
H4MFdK'Y 83 250[0
Y%8yZ 8[H2X0[83M<8yZLFt6Nd2@HUF5 FtT8[U47K#Y1U 25K|69FM<5HQKvZLL2@ZFt6Z 2BZK\V9K\ZFMNK#Z 2BZ"47KF2
H7BY%HKFFt6Z<26F$ZFtM<83H8:KvZL83 25FZL8[T8:2@030[VN2@Z\ZL2U 2@03F 9 8303F8[ZLK
47K\F@ %H76ZL6F$ZFtM<83HFZ FX0:2BZFtH7$VU2M<FtKLK255F83HBvFD*ZFD683HWZZ FM<8y83K1Z F
MWKvZ69FtTB25K\ZL2BZL8[H77C %Ft0[8:2@03F
47KFtK %HQ6"U%MN2@HV@Z F8[Z8:2504LQWK\FDK25KY"F030
1 ~
P
1
61
,1
71
1 ~
4 ~ z$
1
G1
$C9BQ
1
RIKHSjJ3H*><BE>A06DH*H*DG3CF
~
A_0
:
XW
./ (
Y
~
l1
j1
j1
'
Z
/.
01
4*.
3.G&
1
~
'1
'
O1
~
Y1
Y3CO<IK0^BEIoH*F
61
..'.\[.'
~
<
V1
GN
`~
~
` `
.'.o .'
1
'
.Gj ./
.G(. ./
v1
5[
'
6
6 ' <..K
. .'
./
7~
)1
_^
~ '
. '. $$
`~ .G*$o '
.
.K$G .'/
ba
M
M
%
..
v
][
'
['.
0j*$
#
c6
~
?6 .' 3$$
N1
lm t
xr$zvysqtfN}9bLulbdbdfu#xUz\rtuvydrtw
UbLsqy~tfWs
9 | q \
5LMN2@038[?tFZ F
F 2PT835@lZ F
M8[9FtKtC9Y1F
69F7HFU
'772@25HSH5834H7Z55UM<8[H78[H7M<M<FDKFDKLK2@KL2@UUFF03Ft252PTL838[HT83H2@<Z%2BZZ%83M<Z83FM<*F U
9Z F'25M<54HWZ%@Z83MF'2<M<FDKKL2@UF 2UKQFtFH-69Ft032PVUFt6
F H7BYZ 2BZZ FM8[9FtK69F0:2PVZ FM<FtKLKL2@5FDKF$95HFtHUZL83250[03V2@H76Y"F 2PTUF'K\FZZ F
MFD2@HZ U4t F$9G D*
6 #
52@030 S
F0:K\FtY FLF<
6 N N
U2@030
F0:K\FtY FLF
030G69F0:2PV<Z83M<FtK25FX83H769FtQFtH769FHWZD
/14783250|ZLH5ZFS8[H Z 8:K<K\FZ483KZ 2BZ<Z FKFtW4FHQ$F554Z5U8[H7JM<FtKLK255FtK83K
H@Z2 U83KLK\UHL9$FDKKt 8:K%Y"540:6S5H03VFXZL4F'8[#250[0G8[H749ZLKY1U403625L8[TUF2@ZZ F
K25MFZL8[M<F5C FH7F
QFt0[UHZ<Z F
M<8ySY FHSZ F'69F0:2PV8[HNK\ZL25\ZdK1U%8ylZ FK\FDW4FH7F
@25L8[TB2503K'25FS2 U83KLK\UHLFtKLK "49Z83H U4<25KF5CM<FtKLK255FtK2@L83T5F2BZ683K\Z83H7*Z
MUM<FHWZLK83HSZ83MFUCFt2U F83HNF5H7FHWZ8:2@030[V69F0:2PV5FD645HSZ F832@L83TB2@0Z83M<FtKt
8y9FDK 747K 2@Z9Ft6Z83M<F
MUM<FHWZLKY 8: 2@LFU7KFLT5Ft6VZ F'2BZ\Zd25 FD
tU49Z A %549Z O %U49Z
F'2@0:KU7K\FtTUFtK1Z F'2@L83TB2@0Z83M<FtKt
D8[H A %8[H O 83H
n2'M<FtKLKL2@5F0[FD2PT5FDK Z FM<8[2BZ"Z83MF *CY 2BZ%2@LFZ FHZ FL5725830[8[Z83FtK|5"Z F
2@L83TB2@0Z83M<FtK 'I4UKFZ F'6F725\ZL4FZ83M<F |8:K"9Ft69FXZ FH0[ 5Z F
U72@78[038yZvVJZ 2@Z'Z FNM<FDKKL2@UFZ 2BZ0[FZ2BZ'ZL8[M<F X8:KXZ FK25M<FM<FDKKL2@UF<2UKXZ F
5HFZ 2BZFHWZLFLFt6Z F
M<8[S2BZZL8[M<F U
N
* N 549Z P
F<25H FHQ$FFt d25KF'Z FL570[FtM 83HJZLFLMNK5Z F69Ft032PVY 8: TB2@034FtKU
Z F6F0:2PV ZL8[M<FtK2@LFZ FMWKvZU72@70[F /103Ft2@L03V5CHFtU2@Z83T5FJ69Ft032PV83K8[M<UKLK\8303F
K\5H70[V25L83TP250GZL8[M<FDK
L8[UZL X2@LFL5Q2@03F5 FDK\FN25L8[TB250ZL8[M<FDK5LM 2K\FZ
t83H 8[H 83H Y%8yZ 83H
FMN2BZd 8[H769Ft032PVZ83M<FtKX2@LF'Z FH v
8[H A CA qnO 8[H O C[t$C v83H ZL'Y 8: Y1FY%8[030QLF$FtZL25K A O
WU5ZFZ 2@Z
F
@
2
L
<
F
5
2
[
0
<
M
W
v
K
Z
@
2
'
Z
Z
F
\
K
U
[
0
9
4
L
Z
[
8
U
H
5
2
X
K
Z
F
9
6
F
Q
H
\
K
[
8
v
Z
V
47H7*ZL8[UH@
ved
o
`
}`
ih
gkj5l
gkm
Dn
/\l 0f
VHoqpsr
ut
5v
}woxpyr
ut
_z|{
*
S}~'
'
[z{
N*
5~K
Nq)Q
6Q
j5G lih vz
Q
**
D\~
:Q 5E~
*
C
EQ
DQ
@{0Q
V?oz
** \~
Vz.
>9 9
i|fbLUr
xWwbtrtf<bL5x9tfWbdfBuvyrtwxUzvt}r}Wwu<5bdfWsqu3cWfULuvDf
#j Wb%'ruv\WfU~bL5x9DfUbdfBuvyrtwdcWcWwyruvePbUbdfUsqu':cWfULuvDf
BY 2@H<Y"F%Z FH250340:2BZFZ F7U72@83038yZL8[FDK @Z F69F0:2PV'ZL8[M<FDK M<2 FZ 83K
$03Ft2@DC903F$Z47K%03 2@Z l8[U4F N25H76K4UKFXZ 2BZY"F
5H03V 2PTUFZ LFF
2@L83TB2@0ZL8[M<FtK
835Z PF 2PTUF|Z 47KZ LFF"QWKK830[F69Ft032PV9K
@EGF$Z 47KlHBY 2UKK4M<F
5K8[M<038:$8[ZvVLFt2UK\UH7KZ 2@Z A U4dKC O A 54O dK
2@HQ6
547t F
TP258:2@70[F69F0:2PV'8:K $UHUZL8[H4U47K 2@HQ6t2@HZ Ft5LF$Z8:250[03VXZL2 FFTUFLV
TB2@034F8[HZ F%8[HWZFtTB250
n BY"FTUFDCQY"F HBYZ 2@ZXY"F5H03V 747K 2@ZXZ LFF72@Z8:$470325ZL8[M<FtK
25H76Z 2@Z
FH7FUH0[VZ FtF'72@Z8:$47032569F0:2PV9Kt2@H-94t7F2@H-F90[U8yZZ 8:K H7BY%0[FD695F
83H
Z FXU0[03BY%8[H7Y2PV
N A N O
0[83 ZK4\2U$F<
A
N O N
MFD69834M K425F
O
N
N
62@ K425$F
qHZ 83K"Y2PVN5HFX25H0[FD2@L0[VNKFFZ 2@Z"Z F8[U5FDKvZ%K\47\2U$FX$5LLFtKQUH76K ZLZ FXM<UK\Z
U72@70[F69F0:2PV 83K#8:K K\Zd2@83 Z\UY2@d65 M<5LF1Z 25HZ FtF%69F0:2PV9K U$UM749ZL2@
Z835HY"FMN2 F47KF5Z FX$47M40:2BZL8[TUF698:KvZL8349ZL8[UHN4H7$Z835H69L1Y 83 83K15d2@ Ft6
>9;c 9
'
N$
\Q
.2/
'
z <.
lm t
xr$zvysqtfN}9bLulbdbdfu#xUz\rtuvydrtw
UbLsqy~tfWs
8[H l8354LF /147M40:2BZL8[TUFL5725830[8[Z83FtK2@LF'0[8:K\ZFt6J8[H-Zd2@03FtK2@HQ6 H7BY%H-8[HKvZd2BZ8:K\
Z8:2@0 K@ZvY2@LF5 5LFt25K5HQK%@1K83M70[8:$8[ZvV-Y1F49ZZ FM<Ft25HJ@Z FF$9QUHFHWZL83250GZL
QF U4'FD25KV72@d2@M<FZFL83?t2BZL8[UHQ*
N A N A N O
N O N O N A
N
N
qHU4038[Z\Z03F-F$25M70[FUCZ FM<FtKLK255F5LFDK\5HQ6K'M<UK\ZN0[8 Ft0[VY%8[Z Z FSUHFZ 2@Z
FHWZFtFD6Z FM<8y 54QF5LF 54 t2@H2@0:K$03Ft2503VKFFZ 8:K5H l8354LF
qHd25*ZL83t2@02@038:2BZL8[UH7K BY1FtT5FttC@MN25HWVUKLK\8303F69Ft032PV9KY%83030Q94K\
Z 2BZT83K47250
8[H7KFt*ZL8[UH7K%Y%830[0H7@ZF
F $83FHWZ2@HQ6t2@0:$40:2BZL8[UH7K 2PT5FZNMN2U69F
2@H76S$UMQ2@LFt6
S
6
\3.
^
O
Hv
v
Hv
v
Hv
m
m
Vz. '/'
,Q 4
Y$
M9A;
(><jJB
IoAD'CF
x9tsnu*<rd @_
1
O ^GP
PAA
A!
[
Y[
7
% G
X
X
GZ
2Z
Z
(Z
\KK\#q#3
uxyG?=
3
s.
= 3 U
<
r$zq _
P
t
r
@
f
c
"^rgG "WD~PwrxNf^%r bLdbsvdUw_D~DrtbLf7zvwQPLDrt
fxgr$~DuvfU}WbLwz*b"GzvrtbdfW~tcWwy1rz1tbLw[r5fxUJzvbdsqsqcUtsqfWUsd_{Pbdsd_h@uvtxUkrtfW5k~Dp "bdsd
zv$e@[5fW~x5zvD}Wrt}WwsnuvrtfWtfBU
u
fr*f_h@DxUx9zvbLffW~tsnbL5zqsnk uvbdbL<zvwy_rp~Uf Wa %m hN @ _
`1Dw _ twwybz*_@bLzvsqDfWrtwBdt
cUfW*ruvtfQ_zvyetruvbGbd'rywtuvaQbdfhUrsqsvrt'rfQ *i|cW~tcWsnu
Nm#hUt 'uv `"bz|w zvDuvwBwbLdz*Dw aQrtfWLbLbzvsqmlttf uquqzvbd_ wwbLuvbzrtw3z\rtUbLz*rtfaQbdfhUrsqsvrt'rt f7_'5'rtsnk
P DPGnP5DlqDd L9 $@$B B@ P
t
W
c
^D xUi|sqfbd@czv5b*DrtfBs"5
Uuud'rtfUrfNx5rtzvfWDx9t<svrtr$wzv:uz#^%uvbLDzvU
fBuvfWDtxWwx7D_1~tBi1_7fWpftfBU
uBUcUfWt}WsqbLzvetrt}Uywu<rtfW
1h5rtsvz 1a7bdfzvBh5drtbdsqsqsvsdrt_'h5rbLfQwybL_GLuvj#ePUbb%5xUbdzvfWDy
rtw9sqbsqbLzvxUe@zvdetb%rtLr$tBuqWu\_rtxp\f@rt{@e@~tsdbd_uvsbd`" sqbLu\@rtfW wbL{9Du WcUx9aQw tpqsnh5u*i DWDh5@bd_x5"uvp\bd 1}9$bLePz|bd}9b@z _
D _
h@%
i|fbuq@zvzvybd:h5bzz qrtrtfUfBDuv$fBeJ5
rtfWuB_"pbdftzv~t|bD~D%brzNfWb dfWsd~t_wybdjU*fW#bSrz\rtUfsXrtfJrcWfUw:h@zv'5ePrbuvzvsqDDfJfQ#uvWb*bLUtzvuvbLtuvzvsd
*_
@
h
U
x
v
z
W
f
t
~
L
b
q
z
k
b
v
z
[
w
r
U
~
W
a
m
h
1
i
5
x
v
z
y
w
t
Z
X ` Z
X
b?Eb\-%
\=xBki?GBK-cB=%G
E
W
S(
)U
??B#q= GG
]KBPE?=bq x%G D.
Z
P
ub?Bb\iE?=?xPE=%GBu\ ?GK?qcGK
] ix%G
Z
K<
U
ub?B] SS K=
E?=bq H%= 5.
3
'Z
*
K<
M
B=%G \
xcGB? 5.
o
Z
X
X
X
X
*%Z
Z
??BbP=%G
D.
5
D #c
; Z
G]KBPE?=bq S
Z
Z
Z
Z
b%
,+
Eb?Bb
D.
x
-\B=%G qS
? G3??B\ q,K E?=?xi\#
\#BE/c=\=BKiGS=%G K
c
@+_ q.
6
K<
??BbP=%G
D.