Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
Wickham, Chris. The Inheritance of Rome: A History of Europe from 400 to 1000. New York: Viking, 2009. Page 380. Print.
Wickham, 376.
Blockmans, Willem Pieter, and P. C. M. Hoppenbrouwers. Introduction to Medieval Europe 300-1500. Second ed. Page 87. Print.
Emerson King
feared the Lombard rulers threats and their encroachment on his papal territories4.
Charlemagne ensured the Lombard threat was suppressed by forcing their King
Desiderius and his son Adalgis into exile out of Italy5. He then took over the rest of Italy
and made his son the King.
Of all the wars started by Charlemagne, the war with the Saxons shed the most blood
and was a continuous obstacle to his goal of consolidating a unified empire. The war
lasted for over thirty years (772-804). There were underlying causes that threatened daily
to disturb the peace, such as murder, theft, and arson. Charlemagne was infuriated by
these recurring incidents, and saw no other option but to declare war on the Saxons.
When the Saxons lost battles, they often pledged oaths to the Carolingians and vowed to
convert to Christianity. However, they often went back on their word and continued
fighting6. There were multiple capitularies targeting Saxon pagan culture, punishments
for committing perjury, and penalties for committing a robbery that prove the Saxons
were a massive problem for the Carolingianswar was the only option to suppress them7.
It would be foolish to undermine the smaller wars fought by Charlemagne. Had he
lost a battle by not putting forward the necessary military force, rebellions or invasions
may have sprung up throughout the peripheral states or external nations. He took
seriously the many shorter and decisive wars, such as against the Bretons in 786, whom
surrendered all hostages and promised to follow his orders8. Or against the Bavarians in
787, where a rebellious Duke Tassilo was urged by his wife to take revenge on the
Carolingians for exiling her father, King Desiderius, from Lombardy. She allegedly used
her husbands power to fulfill her own wishes. However, when Charlemagnes army
approached Bavaria, Tassilo quickly surrendered and pledged his loyalty. Or when
Charlemagne declared war on the Slavs immediately after the incident with Duke Tassilo
because the Slavs were attacking the Abrodrites, who were allies of the King. A decisive
battle made sure that the Slavs never thought to disobey his commands9.
With enemies in the north, south, and east, Charlemagne felt the need to always be on
the offensive. An exception was his conflicts with the Northmen. He built a fleet to
protect his empire from the constant raids of the Northmen. Fortifications and guards
were set up at all the ports and at the mouth of every river that touched the North Sea.
Charlemagne took the same precautions along the southern border of the empire where
Moors had recently taken to plundering. As a result of these fortifications, the Italians
never suffered harm from the Moors, nor did Gaul or Germany suffer from the
Northmen10.
4
Emerson King
Once conquered lands were secured, the maintenance of the vast empire loomed over
Charlemagne as a nearly impossible task. In 778, he realized that the empire could not
continue expanding its borders. Military activity largely became one of policing and
extracting tribute from still independent neighbors11. Apparently, Carolingian officials
did a poor job addressing the basic problems of the West while fighting wars. There was
decay in economic infrastructure, such as roads and bridges, and a loss of the
manufacturing and monetary subsidy that the West had enjoyed when it was under
Roman imperial control12.
Difficulties in converting conquered peoples to Christianity were recurring themes for
the Carolingians. This may be rooted in the fact that regardless of whether these people
converted to Christianity immediately or not, tithes were always required 13 . After
Charlemagne defeated the Saxons, they promised to convert to Christianity, as per his
demands. When a Saxon leader, Widukind, attempted to rebel again and failed,
Charlemagne spared his life on the condition that he be baptized (unbaptized saxons were
to eventually be sentenced to death)14. Charlemagne was Widukinds godfather at the
baptism, not out of kindness, but as a public gesture to make clear that Widukind was
entirely at the kings fatherly mercy15. Charlemagnes advisors were adamantly against
violent conversion to Christianity, purporting that Christianity must be born of an inner
conviction16. This standpoint became official Carolingian policy after the Avars, who
were not converted quickly either, were conquered in the 790s. Charlemagne had a
mission, not just to rule the Franks and their neighbors, but also to save their souls17.
With the understanding that the Saxons may have been hostile to Christianity, it makes
sense that there were extensive entries in the capitularies outlining punishments of death
for a myriad of religious crimes. These crimes included stealing from a church, eating
meat on lent, damaging church property, etc.18
Charlemagne regarded nothing as more important than the restoration of the ancient
glory of the city of Rome. Not only did he protect and defend the church of St. Peter, but
with his own money he even embellished and enriched it above all other churches19. As a
result, when residents of Rome inflicted injuries on Pope Leo III in 799, Charlemagne
intervened. He traveled to Rome to restore the state of the church, which was extremely
disjointed, and stayed there for months mending the situation. Charlemagne wasnt
simply an aggressive fighter; he was also an excellent politician. Tumultuous times like
these were resolved in part by Charlemagnes approachable but firm disposition. These
11
Wickham, 380.
Wickham, 378.
Loyn, H. R., 283.
14
Loyn, H. R., 282.
15
Blockmans and Hoppenbrouwers, 58.
16
Blockmans and Hoppenbrouwers, 59.
17
Wickham, 384.
18
Loyn, H. R., 282-283.
19
Einhard and Notker, 33.
12
13
Emerson King
political successes were used as defining factors for Einhard and Notker to glorify
Charlemagne as the ideal ruler20.
One method Charlemagne used that checked the power of his citizens, kept his
conquered peoples loyal, and organized his empire was the creation of elaborate
sociopolitical structures. Through gift-exchange, Charlemagne would reward valiant
warriors or individuals who pledged their loyalty to the Carolingian empire with land or
riches. The booty taken from the Avaric campaign in the early 790s was immense, and
funded lavish gift-giving for years. However, only war could keep in place the system of
gift-exchange. Such a structure could only remain intact through an almost permanent
state of warfare, which was essentially the case until the early 800s21.
Assembly politics and the strategic placement of the most trusted aristocratic families
throughout the empire also helped the Carolingians maintain control 22 . This was
strengthened by aristocratic family intermarriage. Regional kings also sent
representatives, or missi, to the provinces. The missi were the kings eyes and ears23.
Corruption of the aristocratic-run court system gave peasants the illusion that they could
stand up to their lords and the justice system could, at least sometimes, work as it was
supposed to. The peasants almost always lost the cases 24 . The network of public
assemblies remained crucial in the Carolingian period. These national assemblies were
matched in every county by local assemblies, or placita, meeting two or three times a
year under the counts presidency, in which local elites were brought into the same public
network; these heard reports of national deliberation25. Carolingians made considerable
use of vassals, who had particularly close ceremonial ties to the kings that were fortified
by personalized oath-swearing and homage. While the counts, dukes, and missi attempted
to maintain structure in their regions, their devout loyalty to the Empire was contingent
on receiving gifts. What was to happen when the wars stopped and the booty ran out?
Another part of this structure was the system of oaths. For example, every freeman
over the age of twelve had to swear formal oaths to the King and their names would be
recorded by the counts and missi. Oath-breakers were considered as perjurers, and risked
damnation, dispossession, mutilation, and sometimes death. While conquering territory in
757, King Pepin forced the rebellious duke Tassilo of Bavaria to swear to become a
vassal on many holy relics. Charlemagne eventually forced the duke into a monastery for
violating the oath26. The breaking of oaths particularly offended Charlemagne, since
creating an empire where inhabitants swore allegiance to him and were proud to do so
was his dream. One of Charlemagnes main goals was to create a unified empire. His
vision was undoubtedly a nationalist one. Charlemagne was the first leader to attempt
20
Emerson King
27
Goff, Jacques. The Birth of Europe: 400-1500. Malden, MA: Blackwell, 2007. Page 29. Print.
Le Goff, 32.
Le Goff, 33.
30
Wickham, 394-395.
31
Le Goff, 39.
32
Wickham, 396
28
29
Emerson King
family itself33. Louis the Pious sons felt entitled to land and power, and were willing to
obtain them at the expense of the unity of the empire.
33
Wickham, 404.