Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
REVIEW
Suvarna S K
(2008) Histopathology
National guidelines for adult autopsy cardiac dissection and diagnosis are they achievable?
A personal view
Adult autopsy cardiac pathology has been previously a
quiet backwater of ischaemic heart disease and the
occasional cardiomyopathy. This has changed to an
increasingly tense area, following recent genetic discoveries and some medicolegal cases. All autopsy
pathologists should consider their dissection protocols
Introduction
The impetus for review of autopsy methodology for
cardiac diagnosis have been gathering for some time.
Starting from aspects of Alder-Hey and Bristol, through
considerations of Coronial service review (now shelved
yet again) to the phased implementation of the Human
Tissue Act (2004), with its requirement for licensing of
autopsy-related activities from 1 September 2006,
autopsy practice has been under increasingly intense
scrutiny. Other drivers include the criticism of some
pathologists autopsy practice in various National
Address for correspondence: S K Suvarna, Department of
Histopathology, Northern General Hospital, Sheffield Teaching
Hospitals, Herries Road, Sheffield S5 7AU, UK.
e-mail: s.k.suvarna@shef.ac.uk
2008 The Author. Journal compilation 2008 Blackwell Publishing Limited.
S K Suvarna
be needed. Of particular importance is good information pertaining to sudden deaths, and this should be
derived from witness accounts if possible. Since many
cases are derived from the Coroner Procurator Fiscal,
their assistance may be vital in securing data on the
pathologists behalf.
Certainly, the consideration of consent and Coronial
medicolegal instructions is essential before the autopsy,
and critical if considering retaining tissues. Specialist
investigation preservatives and culture transport media, for the purposes of electron microscopy, microbiology and DNA extraction, should be considered prior to
the commencement of the dissection in order to
optimize sampling, and these should always be available in a mortuary.
Digital photography is a quick and cheap adjunct to
autopsy diagnosis, and camera facilities should be
available in any mortuary. A digital image of mid-low
ventricular transverse section s and other views of the
heart are very helpful as a record, and for referral.
Indeed, they may obviate the need for retention of the
whole organ. Tissue retention of the whole organ is
understood to be particularly problematic in some parts
of the UK, reflecting individual Coronial jurisdictions.
However, in sudden cardiac death organ retention and
referral should be regarded as the gold standard, with
many cardiac pathologists being prepared to examine,
block and turn around cases with a few days. Families
can be reassured that the bulk (usually more than 90%
of the cardiac tissues) can be reunited with the body in
such circumstances.
Digital photography is not mandatory for all cases.
However, in some cases the images may be a vital part
of autopsy record and comprise part of the text report
as illustrations. It is advisable to consider acquire
appropriate consent for consent autopsies and to
indicate to the Coroner that images have been taken
in medicolegal cases. There is GMC guidance on this
matter.19 The author has not had any problems with
regard to images being recorded and published (as in
this paper) provided that the case image is anonymous
and the reasons for image capture are made clear at the
time to interested parties.
Referral pathways
Some cases can be handled by all autopsy practitioners,
whereas others may benefit from wider discussion
and or referral. Most ischaemic and valvular heart
diseases can probably be dealt with by all qualified
autopsy pathologists. However, trainees without the
MRCPath (or equivalent) must have all cases checked,
no matter what their seniority.
2008 The Author. Journal compilation 2008 Blackwell Publishing Ltd, Histopathology
Table 1. (Continued)
Kawasakis disease
Myocardial bridging
2008 The Author. Journal compilation 2008 Blackwell Publishing Ltd, Histopathology
S K Suvarna
The autopsy
in situ ma cr o sc op ic r e vi e w
The heart should initially be examined in situ, having
exposed opened the pericardium by removal of the
anterior chest wall. At this point, one should sequentially examine the connections of the major arteries
and the gross external architecture of the heart and
the pericardium. This should be accomplished before
removal of the heart from adjoining structures. Any
grafts [e.g. left internal mammary artery (LIMA), vein
grafts] and electrical pacemaker connections should be
identified and preserved intact with the cardiac tissue.
Any effusions and or blood collections should be
recorded in terms of volume and character.
Open the pulmonary artery (PA) about 20 mm
above the valve and follow with fingertip palpation
within the proximal internal PA trunk (to avoid
disrupting and missing proximal pulmonary emboli).
Then transect the aorta (Ao) and PA. Transect the
superior vena cava (SVC) at least 10 mm above the
atrium and SVC interface, preserving the sinoatrial
node (SAN; Figure 1). One should now lift the apex
of the heart upwards in a cranial direction, allowing
transection of the four pulmonary veins and the
inferior vena cava (IVC), making sure that the posterior
atrial wall and septum are kept intact with the heart.
The heart should again be considered from anterior
and posterior aspect to assess whether the arrangement
of the atria and ventricles is normal. The right and left
atria have a triangular and rectangular appendage
architecture, respectively. The right ventricle should be
of palpably less thickness than the left, but both
ventricles should be more precisely and objectively
measured, as below. At this point it is possible to open
the back of the right atrium [RA; along the posterior
wall of the septum in a line from the IVC to the SVC;
and 10 mm parallel to the posterior wall septum
interface on the left atrium (LA) after opening across
the LA roof between the pulmonary veins] in order to
inspect the superior aspect of the tricuspid valve (TV)
and mitral valve (MV), but do not cut into across the
valve rings (Figure 2).
MV
TV
2008 The Author. Journal compilation 2008 Blackwell Publishing Ltd, Histopathology
PA
TV
2008 The Author. Journal compilation 2008 Blackwell Publishing Ltd, Histopathology
S K Suvarna
CXA
OMI
LAD
RCA
PIVD
The myocardium
2008 The Author. Journal compilation 2008 Blackwell Publishing Ltd, Histopathology
Figure 8. The three transverse slices are examined with the right
side myocardium on the left hand aspect, akin to computed
tomography style with right and left side indicated. The overall
architecture of the chambers is apparent.
Figure 10. The right ventricular outflow tract (RVOT) is opened and
should be measured in thickness. This case had a background
pulmonary disorder with some thickening of the RVOT due to
pulmonary hypertension. Attention should always be paid to the
presence of fibrosis or fatty tissue.
Figure 9. The opened right atrium (RA) and right ventricle (RV) are
seen with the auricle being easily inspected (*). There is no need to
further incise the RA appendage. The fossa ovalis is closed (arrow).
Figure 11. The free wall of the right ventricle (RV) may have a
variable thickness of fatty wall tissue (top image), often underappreciated until histology. The histology (bottom) shows the normal
fatty wall structure from the epicardium (E) to the chamber lumen (*).
2008 The Author. Journal compilation 2008 Blackwell Publishing Ltd, Histopathology
S K Suvarna
LA
RA
LMS
auricle
RV
LV
LAD
Figure 12. The left atrium (LA) and left ventricle (LV) can be seen
from the posterior aspect, along with part of the right side tissues.
It is not necessary to further incise the LA auricle, as the content
can be directly viewed.
MV
Figure 13. The mitral valve (MV) can be lifted gently using forceps to
inspect the aortic valve (AoV) inflow (arrow). The superior aspect can
be seen from the transected aorta (Ao). Given the significance of
pathology at this position, it is important to consider the state of the
valve before any further cut is made.
into the aortic root through the MV, as later consideration demonstration of pathology is more difficult.
Photography of the chambers and valves is ideal at this
point, and consideration of atrial and ventricular septal
defects should occur at this juncture.
Once the heart has been fully opened in this fashion
it is possible to weigh the tissues, with subsequent
cross-comparison against standard charts for body
mass and sex.14,17 It should be noted (with regard to
referred cases) that fixation may increase heart weight
by up to 5%. It is also possible to inspect closely the
valves and to record ring circumferences, if relevant.
If there is fibrosis, distortion, calcification or other
pathology then this should be defined.
When considering global ventricular architecture it
has been suggested that measurement of ventricular
CXA
Figure 14. The left ventricular outflow tract (LVOT) and aortic valve
(AoV) are best examined after opening the heart from the front. Note
the arteries run as indicated in the image (red lines), and the cut
(black lines) is best made with scissors running upwards and between
the left atrium (LA) appendage and behind the pulmonary artery
(PA). Note, care is required not to damage the mitral valve (MV) as
one begins to make the turn of the cut towards the aorta (Ao).
2008 The Author. Journal compilation 2008 Blackwell Publishing Ltd, Histopathology
Histopathology
t is s u e bl oc ks
Tissue blocks should be taken only from areas of
myocardial tissue of relevance, and it is essential to
record the site of sampling. The choices must reflect the
needs of the case and the underlying pathology, as well
as other factors such as tissue retention. The scenarios
are diverse, but can be considered in the following
schema, although it should be remembered that even
the most stringent blocking will sample only about
10% of the organ mass, leaving 90% for return to the
body if desired.
I have only occasionally used frozen section at
autopsy, mainly for unexpected cardiac pericardial
tumours or to consider a possible myocarditis, before
choosing how to sample a case. However, in practical
terms I do not recommend this as standard practice.
2008 The Author. Journal compilation 2008 Blackwell Publishing Ltd, Histopathology
10
S K Suvarna
Figure 15. Infarcted posterior right ventricle (RV), left ventricle (LV)
and septum with rupture of wall by previously correctly placed
pacemaker wire. In this scenario the disease of transmural infarction
is the cause of the wire penetration and cardiac tamponade, and
not poor placement of the pacemaker electrode.
2008 The Author. Journal compilation 2008 Blackwell Publishing Ltd, Histopathology
11
AVN
Figure 17. The right atrium (RA) and right ventricle (RV) view
here allows identification of the triangle of Koch (green lines) and
the likely position of the atrioventricular node (AVN). The HisB and
bundle branches (BB) lie immediately below and deep to the AVN.
To examine these fully one needs to resect a square of tissue (black
lines) to encompass all the conduction system elements. The slices
taken in the short (superiorinferior) axis should incorporate the fatty
atrial parenchyma, the membranous septum and the top of the
muscular septum (lower right inset).
2008 The Author. Journal compilation 2008 Blackwell Publishing Ltd, Histopathology
12
S K Suvarna
Cardiovascular devices
Temporary and permanent devices are increasingly
common in autopsy practice. Indeed, this is an evolving arena and what will be available in the next
510 years cannot be predicted. Ante-mortem data are
often paramount in appreciating issues before the
autopsy (e.g. defibrillator pacemakers, vi). However,
the examination should follow the above standard
protocols. Issues relating to medical and surgical
interventions with the complications successes provide feedback for clinicians, relatives and those with
medicolegal interest. Likewise, knowledge of the
cardiac intervention undertaken, for what primary
cardiac disease and whether any complications have
followed, is vital beforehand to maximize data retrieval
from autopsy examinations.
Pacemakers
Cardiac pacemakers are increasingly frequent
(Figure 20) and almost all appear to be reliable. In a
personal review of more than 500 units removed after
death, I have found only one with a end of life battery
and none with abnormal program parameters. However, the pacemaker box should ideally be returned
to the local ECG cardiac pacemaker department for
2008 The Author. Journal compilation 2008 Blackwell Publishing Ltd, Histopathology
13
Figure 21. Suggested scheme to dissect the left atrium (LA) and left
ventricle (LV) in cases of mitral valve (MV) prosthesis, allowing
superior and inferior views to be examined. Solid lines are cuts on the
posterior face and broken line is continuation onto anterior aspect.
RA
Prosthetic valves
Valve replacement surgery broadly follows two patterns: those with tissue replacements (allograft or
xenograft) or artificial devices (usually metal).36
Although primary valve replacement failure can occur
due to technical issues, the primary pathologies include
local haemorrhage, infection, poor alignment, local
leak and tissue overgrowth across the valve (pannus).
It is not possible to open a prosthetic valve in a manner
similar to native valve tissue. Consequently, cardiac
dissection requires exploration of the valve from above,
as well as from below, to assess carefully the valve and
any pathology. Thus, opening an atrium along the
posterior aspect alongside the septum, then turning
90 to run the incision along around the atrial base
immediately above the atrioventricular (AV) groove to
approximately 50% of the atrial chamber is recommended for AV valve prostheses. The ventricles are
explored by opening the ventricular chambers from the
apex of the heart, running a cut upwards adjacent to
the ventricular septum posteriorly and then turning
90 towards the lateral aspect of the ventricular
chamber, allowing the ventricular chamber to be
displayed (Figure 21). For a PV or AoV prosthesis the
dissection may largely follow standard parameters, but
must allow for below above review of the prosthesis.
Finally, one relatively rare procedure for AV valves is
previous surgical valvuloplasty or partial prosthetic
RV
valvuloplasty (Figure 22). Standard exclusion of infective endocarditis and review of cardiac chamber
anatomy are most important in such cases.
Other devices
Developments are ongoing, and these are increasingly
common in cardiac tissues. Examples include, first,
septal closure devices, which broadly comprise two
umbrella platforms that are placed across the septal
leak (Figure 23). These should be inspected carefully as
the chambers are opened, with photography and
2008 The Author. Journal compilation 2008 Blackwell Publishing Ltd, Histopathology
14
S K Suvarna
Figure 23. Atrial septal device placed 5 years previously with good
effect, now sealed in by normal fibrous tissue and endocardial surface
tissues. The cruciate architecture can be made out below the surface.
2008 The Author. Journal compilation 2008 Blackwell Publishing Ltd, Histopathology
Conclusions
This paper set out to review the guidelines that should
govern safe, appropriate and helpful autopsy practice in
the UK. In short, they are achievable whether one is
working in a general or teaching hospital. I suspect
they could be applied outside the UK, nevertheless. The
paper is not an absolute set of rules, but rather strives
to develop dataset concepts in this complex field.
Ultimately, prosectors must chose for themselves what
the case requires. One must choose carefully which of
the above situations is applicable and how detached
the final text report needs to be. This will reflect the
individual case history and findings.
There are several useful resources that are recommended. These include information from the Royal
College Pathologists website,13 and the Association of
European Cardiovascular Pathologists SADS guidelines.15 General and autopsy texts on cardiovascular
disease are recommended,37,38 and access to some
specialist publications is also helpful. Time spent
beforehand considering local contacts is valuable, and
less stressful than if one is unprepared when a hot
case is present in the mortuary.
In writing an autopsy report it is important not to
forget the family. Inasmuch as pathologists need
background data, the families of the deceased need
feedback. Some may occur via clinicians, but one
should be prepared to meet relatives and to discuss explain the findings. These out-patient style
interviews often take up to 1 h and are draining, but,
in the authors opinion, are part of the job.
It is expected that this document will need updates
and re-working along with developments of medicine,
pathology, law, microbiology and genetics. However,
the days of a substandard cardiac autopsy are over, and
it is to be recommended that those active in this area
decide how they will deliver the modern cardiac
pathology for the nation.
References
1. http://www.ncepod.org.uk
2. http://www.cemach.org.uk
3. Department of Health Coronary Heart Disease National Service Framework. Chapter 8. Arrhythmias and sudden cardiac
death. 2005. Available at: http://www.dh.gov.uk/en/PolicyAnd
Guidance/HealthAndSocialCareTopics/CoronaryHeartDisease/
DH_4117048
15
2008 The Author. Journal compilation 2008 Blackwell Publishing Ltd, Histopathology
16
S K Suvarna
29. Lewis W, Silver MD. Adverse effects of drugs on the cardiovascular system. In Silver MD, Gottlieb AI, Schoen FJ eds. Cardiovascular pathology, 3rd edn. New York: Churchill Livingstone,
2001; 541561.
30. Glassman AH, Bigger TJ. Anti-psychotic drugs: prolonged QTc,
torsade de pointes and sudden death. Am. J. Psychiatry 2001;
158; 11741182.
31. Frassat D, Tabib A, Lachaux B et al. Hidden cardiac lesions and
psychotropic drugs as a possible cause of sudden death in
psychiatric patients: a report of 14 cases and review of the
literature. Can. J. Psychiatry 2004; 49; 100105.
32. Davies M. Colour atlas of cardiovascular pathology, Appendix 1.
New York: Harvey Miller, Oxford University Press, 1985; 170
173.
33. Suvarna SK, Start RD, Tayler DI. A prospective audit of
pacemaker function, implant lifetime and patient cause of death.
J. Clin. Pathol. 1999; 52; 677680.
2008 The Author. Journal compilation 2008 Blackwell Publishing Ltd, Histopathology