Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
Chapter4
Determining Interest Rates
.1
4.1
HowtoBuildanInvestmentPortfolio(pages8894)
Discussthemostimportantfactorsinbuildinganinvestmentportfolio.
Thedeterminantsofportfoliochoiceincludewealth,theexpectedrateofreturncomparedtoother
investments,degreeofriskcomparedtoalternatives,liquiditycomparedtootherassets,andthecost
ofacquiringinformationabouttheinvestmentrelativetootherinvestments.
Tocompensatefortheinabilitytofindaperfectasset,investorstypicallyholdvarioustypesofassets,
suchassharesofstockissuedbydifferentcompanies.
4.2
MarketInterestRatesandtheDemandandSupplyforBonds(pages94102)
Useamodelofdemandandsupplytodeterminemarketinterestratesforbonds.
Thedemandandsupplyofbondsdeterminesbondpricesandthustheirinterestrates.
Changesinthefollowingfactorswillcausethedemandcurveforbondstoshift:wealth,expected
returnsonbonds,risk,liquidity,andcostsofinformation.
Changesinthefollowingfactorswillcausesupplycurveforbondstoshift:theexpectedprofitability
ofphysicalcapitalinvestment,businesstaxes,expectedinflation,andgovernmentborrowing.
4.3
TheBondMarketModelandChangesinInterestRates(pages102107)
Usethebondmarketmodeltoexplainchangesininterestrates.
Anyfactorthataffectsthedemandorsupplyofbondsaffectsbondpricesandthusinterestrates.
4.4
TheLoanableFundsModelandtheInternationalCapitalMarket(pages107115)
Usetheloanablefundsmodeltoanalyzetheinternationalcapitalmarket.
Virtuallyalleconomiesinteractwiththerestoftheworldandareopeneconomies.
Inasmallopeneconomy,thedomesticrealinterestrateisdeterminedbytheinternationalcapital
market,sincethedomesticsupplyanddemandforfundsistoosmalltoaffecttheworldrealinterest
rate.
Alargeopeneconomyisaneconomythatislargeenoughtoaffecttheworldrealinterestrate.
.2
ClosedeconomyAneconomyinwhich
households,firms,andgovernmentsdonot
borroworlendinternationally.
FishereffectTheassertionbyIrvingFisherthat
thenominalinterestrisesorfallspointforpoint
withchangesintheexpectedinflationrate.
DiversificationDividingwealthamongmany
Idiosyncratic(orunsystematic)riskRiskthat
2012PearsonEducation,Inc.PublishingasPrenticeHall
32Hubbard&OBrienMoney,Banking,andtheFinancialSystem,FirstEdition
differentassetstoreducerisk.
ExpectedreturnThereturnexpectedonan
assetduringafutureperiod;alsoknownas
expectedrateofreturn.
pertainstoaparticularassetratherthantothemarket
asawhole,aswhenthepriceofaparticularfirms
stockfluctuatesbecauseofthesuccessorfailure
ofanewproduct.
LargeopeneconomyAneconomyinwhich
shiftsindomesticsavingandinvestmentarelarge
enoughtoaffecttheworldrealinterestrate.
OpeneconomyAneconomyinwhichhouseholds,
firms,andgovernmentsborrowandlend
internationally.
Market(orsystematic)riskRiskthatis
commontoallassetsofacertaintype,suchasthe
increasesanddecreasesinstocksresultingfrom
thebusinesscycle.
RiskThedegreeofuncertaintyinthereturnon
anasset.
SmallopeneconomyAneconomyinwhichtotal
savingistoosmalltoaffecttheworldrealinterest
rate.
Chapter Outline
Ifinflationincreases,arebondsagoodinvestment?
Someinvestmentadvisorsinlate2009advisedclientstonottobuybondsbecauseofanticipatedinflationin
upcomingyears.
4.1
Teaching tips
2012PearsonEducation,Inc.PublishingasPrenticeHall
Chapter4DeterminingInterestRates33
InMakingtheConnection:FeartheBlackSwan!onpages9091,theauthorsintroducetheconceptofa
BlackSwaneventthatwasdevelopedbyNassimTaleb,professionalinvestorandprofessoratNewYork
University.Thebasicideaofablackswanisthat,occasionally,thereareuniqueeventsthattakeplace(more
oftenthanpeoplethink)thathaveasignificantlyadverseeffectonreturns.InanarticletitledPreparingfor
theNextBlackSwanintheWallStreetJournal(August21,2010),pointsoutthatdiversificationmaynotbe
sufficientinreducingriskwhenthereareBlackSwanevents.Forexample,duringthefinancialcrisisinlate2008,
virtuallyallassetclassesdeclinedinvalueatthesametime.Insteadofrelyingononlydiversification,
investorsmayinsteadwanttomakeuseofvariousformsofderivativestoprepareforBlackSwans.However,
thereisnofreelunch,sincetherearecostsinvolvedinpurchasingderivativeswhiletheymayonlybe
exercisedonrareoccasions.ThistopicwillbeexploredfurtherinChapter7.
4.2
Market Interest Rates and the Demand and Supply for Bonds (pages 94102)
LearningObjective:Useamodelofdemandandsupplytodeterminemarketinterestratesforbonds.
A. ADemandandSupplyGraphoftheBondMarket
2012PearsonEducation,Inc.PublishingasPrenticeHall
34Hubbard&OBrienMoney,Banking,andtheFinancialSystem,FirstEdition
Thedemandcurveforbondsrepresentstherelationshipbetweenthepriceofbondsandthequantity
ofbondsdemandedbyinvestors,holdingconstantallotherfactors.Asthepriceofbondsincreases,
theirinterestratesfallandtheybecomelessdesirabletoinvestors,sothequantitydemandedwill
decline,resultinginadownwardslopingdemandcurve.Thesupplycurverepresentstherelationship
betweenthesupplyofbondsandquantityofbondssuppliedbyinvestorswhoownexistingbondsand
byfirmsthatareconsideringissuingnewbonds.Asthepriceofbondsincreases,theirinterestrates
willfallandholdersofexistingbondswillbemoreinclinedtosellthem,resultinginanupwardsloping
supplycurve.Anexcesssupplyofbondsleadstoalowerbondpriceand,therefore,ahigherinterest
rate,whereasanexcessdemandforbondsleadstoahigherbondpriceandalowerinterestrate.
B. ExplainingChangesinEquilibriumInterestRates
Thedemandandsupplycurvesforbondsheldconstanteverythingthatcouldaffectthewillingness
ofinvestorstobuybonds,orfirmsandinvestorstosellbonds,exceptforthepriceofbonds.Ifany
otherrelevantvariablesuchaswealthortheexpectedrateofinflationchanges,thenthedemand
(orsupply)curveshiftsandwehaveachangeindemand(orsupply).
C. FactorsthatShifttheDemandCurveforBonds
Anincreaseinwealthincreasesthedemandforbonds.Iftheexpectedreturnonbondsrises,relative
toexpectedreturnsonotherassets,theninvestorswillincreasetheirdemandforbondsandthedemand
curveforbondswillshifttotheright.Ifexpectedinflationincreases,theexpectedrealinterestrate
willdecline,reducingthedemandforbonds.Anincreaseintheriskofbonds,relativetotheriskness
ofotherassets,decreasesthewillingnessofinvestorstobuybondsandcausesthedemandcurvefor
bondstoshifttotheleft.Iftheliquidityofbondsincreases,investorsdemandmorebondsatany
givenpriceandthedemandcurveforbondsshiftstotheright.Lowerinformationcostsforbonds
causesthedemandcurveforbondstoshifttotheright.
Teachings Tips
Inthespringof2010,therewasconsiderableconcernaboutapossiblesovereigndebtcrisisinEurope,with
particularattentionpaidtoGreece,Portugal,andSpain.Havestudentsdiscusstheresponseofglobalinvestors
tothiscrisis.BesuretoindicatehowglobalinvestorsfledtothesafetyofU.S.Treasurybonds,resultingina
declineininterestratesonU.S.governmentbonds.
D. FactorsThatShifttheSupplyCurveforBonds
Anincreaseinfirmsexpectationsoftheprofitabilityofinvestmentsinphysicalcapitalwill,holding
allotherfactorsconstant,shiftthesupplycurveforbondstotherightasfirmsseektofinancenew
investment.Whenbusinesstaxesareraised,theprofitsfirmsearnonnewinvestmentsinphysical
capitaldecline,andfirmsissuefewerbonds,causingthesupplyofbondstoshifttotheleft.An
increaseintheexpectedinflationrateresultsinadeclineintherealinterestrates,causingthesupply
curveofbondstoshifttotheright.Ifthegovernmentrunsalargerbudgetdeficit,itwillneedto
issuemorebonds,causingthesupplyofbondstoshifttotheright.Ifthegovernmentrunsadeficit,
householdsmaysavemoreinanticipationofhigherfuturetaxpayments,causingthedemandfor
bondstoshifttotheright.However,studiesindicatethathouseholdsdonotincreasetheirsavingby
thefullamountofthebudgetdeficit,thus,allelseequal,bondpricesarelikelytodeclineand
interestratesincrease.
Teachings Tips
Encouragestudentstospendsometimereviewingthefollowingtables:
Table4.2,FactorsthatShifttheDemandCurveforBonds,onpage99.
Table4.3,FactorsthatShifttheSupplyCurveforBonds,onpage103.
2012PearsonEducation,Inc.PublishingasPrenticeHall
Chapter4DeterminingInterestRates35
4.3
The Bond Market Model and Changes in Interest Rates (pages 102107)
LearningObjective:Usethebondmarketmodeltoexplainchangesininterestrates.
A. WhyDoInterestRatesFallDuringRecessions?
Duringrecessions,wealthdeclinesasdoestheexpectedprofitabilityofinvestments.Thedeclinein
wealthshiftsthedemandforbondstotheleft,puttingdownwardpressureonbondprices,whilethe
declineintheexpectedprofitabilityofinvestmentcausesthesupplyofbondstoshifttotheleft,
puttingupwardpressureonprices.EvidencefromU.S.datashowsthatinterestratesdeclineduring
recessions,indicatingthatsupplydeclinesmorethandemand,resultinginhigherbondprices.
B. HowDoChangesinExpectedInflationAffectInterestRates?TheFisherEffect
Higherexpectationsofinflationreducetheexpectedrealinterestrate,leadingtoanincreaseinthe
supplyofbondsandadecreaseinthedemandforbonds.Asaresult,thebondpricedeclinesandthe
interestrateincreases.ThissupportstheFisherEffect,whichstatesthatthenominalinterestrate
increasesoneforonewithchangesinexpectedinflation.Economistshavefoundthatvariousreal
worldfrictionsresultinnominalinterestratesnotalwaysincreasingordecreasingbyexactlythe
amountofachangeinexpectedinflation.
4.4
The Loanable Funds Model and the International Capital Market (pages 107115)
LearningObjective:Usetheloanablefundsmodeltoanalyzetheinternationalcapitalmarket.
A. TheDemandandSupplyforLoanableFunds
Thedemandcurveforloanablefunds,whichshowstherelationshipbetweenthequantitydemanded
forloanablefundsandtheinterestrate,isequaltothesupplyofbonds.Thesupplycurvefor
loanablefunds,whichrelatesthequantityofloanablefundssuppliedtotheinterestrate,isequalto
thedemandforbonds.
B. EquilibriumintheBondMarketfromtheLoanableFundsPerspective
Anyofthefactorsthatthatcausethedemandcurveforbondstoshiftwillcausethesupplycurvefor
loanablefundstoshift.Similarly,anyofthefactorsthatcausethesupplycurveforbondstoshift
willcausethedemandcurveforloanablefundstoshift.Interestrateswilladjusttoensurethatthe
quantitydemandedforloanablefundsequalsthequantitysuppliedofloanablefunds.
C. TheInternationalCapitalMarketandtheInterestRate
Nearlyalleconomiesareopeneconomies,wherefinancialcapital,orloanablefunds,ismobile
internationally.Borrowingandlendingtakesplaceintheinternationalcapitalmarket,whichisthe
capitalmarketinwhichhouseholds,firms,andgovernmentsborrowandlendacrossnationalborders.
Theworldrealinterestrateistheinterestratethatisdeterminedintheinternationalcapitalmarket.
Aclosedeconomyisaneconomythathasnointeractionintermsoftradeorfinancewithother
countries,whichisextremelyrareintodaysworld.
D. SmallOpenEconomy
Inthecaseofasmallopeneconomy,thequantityofloanablefundssuppliedordemandedistoo
smalltoaffecttheworldrealinterestrate.So,asmallopeneconomysdomesticrealinterestrate
equalstheworldrealinterestrateasdeterminedintheinternationalcapitalmarket.Ifthequantityof
loanablefundssupplieddomesticallyexceedsthequantityoffundsdemandeddomesticallyatthat
interestrate,thecountryinvestssomeofitsloanablefundsabroad.Ifthequantityofloanablefunds
demandeddomesticallyexceedsthequantityoffundssupplieddomesticallyatthatinterestrate,the
countryfinancessomeofitsdomesticborrowingneedswithfundsfromabroad.
2012PearsonEducation,Inc.PublishingasPrenticeHall
36Hubbard&OBrienMoney,Banking,andtheFinancialSystem,FirstEdition
E. LargeOpenEconomy
Alargeopeneconomyisaneconomythatislargeenoughtoaffecttheworldrealinterestrate.The
interestratewilladjustuntiltheexcesssupply(demand)ofloanablefundsfromthelargeopeneconomy
equalstheexcessdemand(supply)forloanablefundsintherestoftheworld,resultinginthedomestic
realinterestrateequalingtheworldrealinterestrate.Factorsthatcausethedemandandsupplyof
fundstoshiftinalargeopeneconomywillaffectnotjusttheinterestrateinthateconomy,butthe
worldrealinterestrateaswell.
Teaching Tips
Foryears,theUnitedStateshasexperiencedhugenetcapitalinflows.Somepeopleareconcernedabout
borrowingfromabroad.HavestudentsdiscusswhatwouldhappentorealinterestratesintheUnitedStatesif
werestrictedborrowingfromoverseas(i.e.,iftheUnitedStatesbecameamoreclosedeconomy).
2012PearsonEducation,Inc.PublishingasPrenticeHall
Chapter4DeterminingInterestRates37
.1
TheFishereffectstatesthatthenominalinterestraterisespointforpointwiththeexpectedrateof
inflation.TheFishereffectimpliesthatchangesinexpectedinflationcanleadtochangesinnominal
interestratesbeforeachangeininflationhasoccurred.BillGrossfromtheinvestmentfirmPimcocited
inflationaryexpectations,aswellasanincreaseinthesupplyofTreasurybonds,asreasonsforinterest
rateincreases:
Besidestheinflationfearssetoffbythestrengtheningeconomy,Mr.Grosssaidhewasalso
waryofTreasurybondsbecausehefearedtheburgeoningsupplyofnewdebtissuedtofinance
thegovernmentshugebudgetdeficitswouldoverwhelmdemand,drivinginterestrates
higher....
2.
TheU.S.inflationrateinthelate1970sreacheddoubledigitlevels,whichmadeinflationthenations
numberoneeconomicproblem.AfterPaulVolckerwasnamedchairmanoftheFederalReserveBoardin
August1979,theFedbegantoreducethegrowthofthemoneysupply.Thecombinationofhigh
inflationaryexpectationsandtightmonetarypolicydroveinterestratestoveryhighlevels.Asaresult,
theUnitedStatessufferedfromarecessionthatbeganinAugust1981andendedinNovember1982.As
theeconomycontracted,inflationaryexpectationsandinterestratesdeclined.
Aportfolioisacollectionofinvestmentsheldbyaninstitutionorprivateindividual.
1.2
Therearefivedeterminants:1)Theamountofwealthasaverhas,2)theexpectedrateofreturn
comparedtoalternativeinvestments,3)thecomparativedegreeofrisk,4)thecomparativedegreeof
liquidity,and5)thecomparativedegreeofthecostofacquiringinformationabouttheinvestment.
1.3
Expectedreturnisthereturnexpectedonanassetduringafutureperiod.Riskisthedegreeof
uncertaintyinthereturnonanasset.
1.4
Riskaversereferstoinvestorswhohaveanaversiontorisk,meaningthatwhenchoosingbetween
twoassetswiththesameexpectedreturnsriskaverseinvestorswouldchoosetheassetwiththe
lowerrisk.Mostinvestorsareriskaverse.
1.5
Thehighertheriskthatanassethas,thelowerthedemandfortheasset,whichraisestheyieldor
return.Lowriskassetshaveahighdemand,whichlowerstheiryieldorreturn.
1.6
Marketriskistheriskthatiscommontoallassetsofacertaintypebecauseofsharedeconomic
conditions.Idiosyncraticriskistheriskthatpertainstoaparticularasset,suchasanindividual
stock,ratherthantothemarketasawhole.
1.7
Diversificationistheprocessbywhichindividualsorfirmsallocatesavingsamongmanydifferent
assets.Diversificationreducesriskbecauseindividualsandfirmshaveavarietyofdifferentasset
classes,soifoneclass(saybonds)performspoorlytherestoftheportfoliomayperformwell.
2012PearsonEducation,Inc.PublishingasPrenticeHall
38Hubbard&OBrienMoney,Banking,andtheFinancialSystem,FirstEdition
GooglefoundersPageandBrinwerereducingtheamountofidiosyncraticriskintheirportfoliosby
reducingtheirholdingsofGooglestockandpurchasingotherassetstoincreasediversificationand
liquidity.
1.9
Ablackswaneventisaneventthathappensveryrarelythathasalargeimpactonsociety.Black
swaneventsarehardtopredictbecausethelikelihoodofthemhappeningisstatisticallyverylow.
Someconsiderthefinancialcrisisof20072009ablackswanevent.
1.10
Theprimarytradeoffisbetweenriskandreward.Generallythemoreriskanassethas,thehigher
thereturnitprovides.Forinstance,ahighyieldingcorporatebondprobablyhasahighyield
becauseoftheriskofdefault.However,ifthecompanystayssolventthentherewardisveryhigh.
Agovernmentbondhasaverylowriskofdefault,butalsohasarelativelyloweryield.
1.11
Youngpeopleshouldallocatethemajorityoftheirportfoliotoequitiesbecauseofthegreaterrateof
returnoverthelongrun.Asinvestorsgetolder,theirportfolioshouldswitchtolessriskyassetssuch
astreasurybonds.
4.2 Market Interest Rates and the Demand and Supply for Bonds
Learningobjective:Useamodelofdemandandsupplytodeterminemarketinterestratesforbonds.
Review Questions
2.1
a. Thedemandcurveforbondswouldshifttotheleftbecause:
1. wealthdecreases,
2. expectedreturnsonbondsrelativetootherassetsdecreases,
3. expectedinflationincreases,
4. riskonbondsrelativetootherassetsincreases,
5. liquiditydecreases,or
6. costsofinformationincreases.
b. Thesupplycurveforbondswouldshifttotherightbecause:
1. expectedprofitabilityincreases,
2. corporatetaxratesdecrease,
3. subsidiestobusinessincrease,
4. expectedinflationrises,or
5. governmentborrowingincreases.
2.2
Thebonddemandcurveslopesdownbecauseasthepriceofbondsdecreases,theinterestrateson
thebondswillrise,andthebondswillbecomemoredesirabletoinvestors,sothequantitydemanded
willrise.Thebondsupplycurveslopesupbecauseasthepriceofbondsdecreases,theirinterest
rateswillrise,andholdersofexistingbondswillbelesswillingtosellthem.Also,firmswillfindit
moreexpensivetoborrowatthehigherinterestrateandwillissuefewerbonds.Forbothofthese
reasons,thequantityofbondssuppliedwilldecrease.
2.3
Theexcesssupplyofbondscausesthepriceofbondstofall,increasingquantitydemandedand
reducingquantitysupplied.Thereisnoshiftinthesupplyordemandcurve.
2.4
a. False:thequantitydemandedofbondsfalls.
b. True:Thelowertheprice,thehighertheyield,whichincreasesthecostofborrowing.
2012PearsonEducation,Inc.PublishingasPrenticeHall
Chapter4DeterminingInterestRates39
c. True:Ashifttotherightinthedemandcurvewillpushbondpricesupandyieldsdown.
d. False:ThiswouldcauseashifttotheleftofthedemandforU.S.governmentbonds,pushingprice
downandyieldup.
2012PearsonEducation,Inc.PublishingasPrenticeHall
40Hubbard&OBrienMoney,Banking,andtheFinancialSystem,FirstEdition
a.
b.
c.
d.
e.
Demandcurveshiftsleft,supplyofbondsshiftsright.
Supplycurveshiftsright.
Supplycurveshiftsleft.
Demandcurveshiftsleft.
Demandcurveshiftsleft,supplycurveshiftsleft.
2.6
a. Theactualrealrateofinterestcanbecomenegativeiftheactualinflationratesufficientlyexceeds
theexpectedinflationrate.
b. Duringthe1970s,theinflationrateunexpectedlyrosetodoubledigits,leadingtonegativeactual
realinterestrates.
2.7
a. Supplycurveshiftsright,reducingthepriceofbondsandincreasingtheequilibriumquantityofbonds.
b. Thedemandcurveshiftstotheright,increasingthepriceofbondsandincreasingtheequilibrium
quantityofbonds.
2012PearsonEducation,Inc.PublishingasPrenticeHall
Chapter4DeterminingInterestRates41
c. Thesupplyofbondsshiftstotherightandthedemandforbondsshiftstotheright.Thisincreases
theequilibriumquantityofbonds,butthechangeinthepriceofbondsisindeterminant.
2.8
Thesupplycurvewouldshifttotheleft,raisingbondpricesandloweringbondyields.
2.9
Theprofitablebusinessopportunitieswouldincreasethesupplyforbondsandtheincreaseinstock
priceswouldlowerthecomparativereturnonbonds,decreasingthedemandforbonds.Asshownin
thegraphbelow,thepriceofbondswouldfall,buttheequilibriumquantitywouldbeindeterminate.
2012PearsonEducation,Inc.PublishingasPrenticeHall
42Hubbard&OBrienMoney,Banking,andtheFinancialSystem,FirstEdition
Interestratesfallduringrecessions.Asthegraphbelowshows,thedemandforbondsdecreasessince
householdsexperiencedecliningwealth,andthesupplyofbondsdecreasessincebusinesseshave
fewerprofitableopportunitiesduringarecession.Forinterestratestofall,thepriceofbondsmust
rise,sothedecreaseinthesupplyforbondsmustexceedinmagnitudethedecreaseinthedemand
forbonds.
3.2
AccordingtotheFishereffect,thenominalinterestraterisesorfallspointforpointwithchangesin
theexpectedinflationrate.Asthegraphbelowshows,anincreaseinexpectedinflationdecreasesbond
demandandincreasesbondsupply,decreasingbondpricesandincreasingbondyields(interestrates).
2012PearsonEducation,Inc.PublishingasPrenticeHall
Chapter4DeterminingInterestRates43
a. Demandwillshiftrightandsupplywillshiftleft.Thepriceincreases,andbutitisunclearwhat
happenstotheequilibriumquantityofbonds.
b. Thedemandforbondsshiftsrightwiththeincreaseinwealthfromtheexpansionandthesupplyfor
bondsshiftsrightwiththeincreaseinprofitableopportunities.Duringeconomicexpansionsinterest
ratestypicallyrise,sothepriceofbondsmustfall,implyingthattheincreaseinthesupplyforbonds
exceedstheincreaseinthedemandforbonds.Theequilibriumquantityofbondsincreases.
c. Supplyofbondsshiftstorightandthedemandforbondsshiftsleft.Thepriceofbondsfalls,butitis
unclearwhathappenstotheequilibriumquantityofbonds.
d. Thesupplyofbondsincreasesshiftingthesupplycurvetotheright,forcingpricesdownandthe
quantityup.
3.4
a. ItwasunclearwhethertheGreekgovernmentwasgoingtobeabletocontinuetofinanceitslarge
budgetdeficits.
b. ThedemandforbondswasfallingdrasticallybecauseoftheriskofGreecedefaultingonitsdebt.
c. ThelargeGreecebudgetdeficitsincreasedbondsupplyandtheincreasingriskofdefaultdecreased
bonddemand,decreasingbondpricesandincreasingyields.
3.5
a. Deflationisafallintheaggregatepricelevel.
b. Whencalculatingtherealinterestrate,deflationincreasestheyieldonbonds.
3.6
3.7
Anincreaseinexpectedinflationwouldshiftthedemandforbondstotheleftandthesupplyfor
bondstotheright,pushingpricesdownandyieldsup.Longertermbondswouldbemoreatrisk
becauseinflationisexpectedtoincreaseoverextendedperiodsoftimebecauseofFederalReserve
policyduringthefinancialcrisis,foragivenchangeininterestrateslongtermbondpricesaremore
affectedthanshorttermbondprices.
a. Bondpriceswillfallandinterestrateswillrise.
b. Investorswhoboughtlongtermtreasurybondswillbenefitbecausethepricewillnotfallas
anticipated,meaningownersofthesebondswillmakeahigheryield.
2012PearsonEducation,Inc.PublishingasPrenticeHall
44Hubbard&OBrienMoney,Banking,andtheFinancialSystem,FirstEdition
4.4 The Loanable Funds Approach and the International Capital Market
Learningobjective:Usetheloanablefundsmodeltoanalyzetheinternationalcapitalmarket.
Review Questions
4.1
a. BondMarket:Thegoodisthebond.LoanableFunds:Thegoodistheuseoffunds.
b. BondMarket:Thebuyeristhebondholder(thesaver/investor).LoanableFunds:Thebuyeristhe
borrower.
c. BondMarket:Theselleristheborrower(agovernmentoracorporation).LoanableFunds:
Theseller(supplycurve)isthesaver.
d. BondMarket:Thepriceisthepriceofthebond.LoanableFunds:Thepriceistheinterestrate.
4.2
Thedemandcurveisdownwardslopingbecausethehighertheinterestrate,thelessdemandfor
borrowingbecausethecostishigher.Thesupplycurveisupwardslopingbecausethehigherthe
interestratethemorewillingsuppliersofloanablefundswillbetolendmoney.
4.3
Thebondmarketapproachismostusefulwhenconsideringhowthefactorsaffectingthedemand
andsupplyforbondsaffecttheinterestrate.Theloanablefundapproachismostusefulwhen
lookingattheflowoffundsbetweentheU.S.andforeignfinancialmarkets.
4.4
a. Aclosedeconomyisaneconomywherehouseholds,firms,andgovernmentsdonotborroworlend
internationally.
b. Smallopeneconomy:Aneconomywherethequantityofloanablefundssuppliedordemandedistoo
smalltoaffecttheworldrealinterestrate.Itisalsoassumedthatfinancialcapitalmovesinternationally.
c. Alargeopeneconomyisaneconomythatislargeenoughtoaffecttheworldinterestrateand
assumesthatcapitalmovesinternationally.
d. Theworldrealinterestrateistheinteretratethatisdeterminedintheinternationalcapitalmarketthat
equatestheworldquantitydemandedofloanablefundstotheworldquantitysuppliedofloanablefunds.
a. Asshowninthegraphbelow,thedemandcurveforloanablefundsshiftsright,raisingtheworldreal
interestrate.
b. Thesupplycurveforloanablefundswouldalsoshiftright.Theinterestratewouldfallfromits
previouspointinpartatoanundeterminedpoint,dependingonhowmuchhouseholdsincreased
theirsaving.Seethegraphbelow.
2012PearsonEducation,Inc.PublishingasPrenticeHall
Chapter4DeterminingInterestRates45
4.6
Asshowninthegraphbelow,thedemandcurveforloanablefundsintheUnitedStatesshiftstothe
left,whichlowerssomewhattheworldrealinterestrate.Thiswouldcauseanexcesssupplyof
loanablefundsintheU.S.,whichwouldmaketheU.S.anetinternationallender.
4.7
a. Nochangeinworldinterestrate.Sinceasmallopeneconomyhasthesameinterestrateastheworld
interestrate,therewouldbenochangeinthedomesticinterestrate.
b. Nochangeintheinterestrate.
c. Thesupplyofloanablefundsworldwideshiftstotheright,reducinginterestrates.
d. Nochangeinworldinterestrate.
4.8
a. Demandforloanablefundsincreases,increasinginterestrates.
b. Demandforloanablefundsdecreases,decreasinginterestrates.
2012PearsonEducation,Inc.PublishingasPrenticeHall
46Hubbard&OBrienMoney,Banking,andtheFinancialSystem,FirstEdition
c. Supplyofloanablefundsincreases,decreasinginterestrates.
d. Supplyofloanablefundsdecreases,increasinginterestrates.
4.9
a. Netexpectedprofitabilityfalls,sothedemandforloanablefundsfalls.
b. Expectedprofitabilityrises,sothedemandforloanablefundsrises.
c. Theincreaseintheexpectedaftertaxinterestratereducesthedemandforloanablefunds.
4.10 a. ThetreasurymarketisthemarketforU.S.Treasurybonds.
b. Iftherewerepanic,peoplewouldsellTreasurybondspushingpricesdown,andtheyieldup.The
authornotesthatyieldshavenotrisen,whichmeanstherehasnotbeenaselloffofTreasurybonds.
2012PearsonEducation,Inc.PublishingasPrenticeHall
Chapter4DeterminingInterestRates47
4.11 a. Inthegraphbelow,beginwiththeworldrealinterestrateequalto3%andtherestoftheworldasa
netinternationallenderandtheU.S.asanetinternationalborrower.Anincreaseinsavingintherest
oftheworldshiftsthesupplyofloanablefundsintherestoftheworldtotheright,loweringtheworld
realinterestrateto1%.Withtheincreasedsaving,therestoftheworldbecomesmoreofaninternational
lender,andwiththelowerworldrealinterestratetheU.S.becomesmoreofaninternationalborrower.
b. ThereisadebateoverwhethertheFederalReservewasresponsibleforlowinterestratesorwhether
theglobalsavingsglutwasresponsible.Iftheglobalsavingsglutwasresponsible,wecouldargue
thattheFederalReserveshouldtakelessblamefortheartificiallylowinterestratesthathelped
facilitatethehousingbubble.
Data Exercises
D4.1
Thepeakyieldoverthe5yearperiodwas5.11inMayandJuneof2006.Thelowestyieldwasat
2.42inDecemberof2008.Bondyieldsfellfrompeaktotroughbecauseofinvestorsflighttosafety.
InatimeofpanicU.S.Treasurybondsarethesafestassetintheworld.Thedemandcurveshiftsto
theright,pushingpricesupandyieldsdown.
2012PearsonEducation,Inc.PublishingasPrenticeHall
48Hubbard&OBrienMoney,Banking,andtheFinancialSystem,FirstEdition
D4.2
Assumingtheinvestorholdstomaturity,1981wouldhavebeenthebestyeartobuyabond.
2012PearsonEducation,Inc.PublishingasPrenticeHall