Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
1 Introduction to Shariah
1.1.1 Objective of Shariah
Shariah is the entire body of Islamic law, and the term literally means "the way to the water source." It
is a wide-ranging body of law and personal rules, regulating matters not limited to jurisprudence,
politics, business, banking, family, and society. The main objectives of the Shariah is to ensure that
human life is based on maruf (good) and to cleanse it of munkar (evils). The term maruf denotes all
the qualities that have always been accepted as good by the human conscience, and conversely, the
world munkar denotes all those qualities that have always been condemned by human nature as
evil.
1.1.2 The Concept of Ad Deen (Shariah)
Broken down to its bare elements, Islam comprises of Aqidah (a set of beliefs), Shariah (a set of
laws) and Akhlak (a code of moralitie).
Aqidah means a set of beliefs. From the Islamic point of view, Aqidah means strong belief in Allah
s.w.t, His Prophets and the hereafter, also belief in the angels, the holy books and predestination.
Shariah or Islamic law is also known as Fiqh . Fiqh is Islamic jurisprudence. Fiqh deals with the
observance of rituals, morals and social legislation in Islam. Branches of Fiqh includes Ibadat,
Muamalat, Munakahat and Jinayat.
Fiqh
Ibadat
The rules of ritual purification, prayer, pilgrimage, fasting, zakat, jihad and some other
forms of worship are dealt under this heading. Most of these rules deal with the rights
owed to Allah s.w.t by the individual alone or by the community as a whole.
Fiqh
Muamalat
This area deals with property, contracts, business organisation, security of debts and
Fiqh
Munakahat/Usrah
This area deals with marriage, divorce, inheritance, guardianship and related matters. This
is similar to conventional version known as personal law.
Fiqh
Jinayat
This area deals with major offences like illicit sexual (zina), theft (sariqah), robbery, pirate
and brigandage (hirabah), and other matters collectively known as hudud laws.
Akhlaq is a term referring to the practice of virtue, morality and manners in Islamic theology and
falsafah (philosophy). It refers to ones disposition, nature, temper, ethics, morals or character (of a
person). Akhlaq covers all aspects of Muslim behaviour, attitude and work ethics which influence his
acts.
1.1.3 Mandatory Law (Hukm Taklif)
Taklifi law is the law that describes the commands, prohibitions and the option to run or leave an
activity / job. According to Islamic terminology, the acts of a Muslim must be guided by these five
commandments (al-Ahkam al-Khamsah) classified as follows:
Wajib
(obligatory)
The term wajib means an act the performance of which is obligatory for the subject.
Example: performing solat and fasting in month of Ramadhan. In its technical sense, it is
an act whose commission is demanded by the Lawgiver (Allah s.w.t) in certain and binding
terms.
Mandub
(recommended)
Mandub is defined as a demand by the Lawgiver (Allah) for the commission of an act
without making it binding and without assigning any blame for its omission. The rule for
mandub is that for doing so there is reward (thawab) for the doer, while omitting it entails
no penalty such as giving charity to the others.
Haram
(prohibited/unlawful)
Haram is defined as one which omission is required by the Lawgiver (Allah) in binding and
certain terms. An example of prohibited act (Haram) is the misappropriation of anothers
wealth.
Makruh
(reprehensible
or
disapproved)
Makruh is defined as one which omission is demanded by the Lawgiver (Allah) in non-
binding terms. An example of reprehensible act (Makruh) such as debt which is not
documented (unrecorded).
Mubah
(permissible)
The Mubah or permissible act is one in which the Lawgiver (Allah) has granted a choice of
commission and omission, without blame or praise for omission or commission. According
to this principle, all contracts and transactions are permissible, unless there is evidence
indicating otherwise.
1.1.4 Primary and Secondary Sources of Shariah
Nos.
Primary Source
Description
i Quran
ii As-Sunnah
Nos.
Secondary Source
i. Ijma
Description
Ijma is Juristic consensus of opinion of the imams
mujtahid among Muslims in a particular time after the
death of the Prophet (s.a.w.) regarding the legal
position of a matter or problem.
In its application, Ijma is an agreement of Muslim jurist
in the event the ruling being sought is not found in
either of the main sources ie the Quran and the
Sunnah. All the mujtahidin must reach a consensus on
a juridical opinion at the time an issue arises.
ii Qiyas (Analogy)
iv Urf
v Istishab
Istishab means presumption of existence or nonexistence of facts. It can be used in the absence of
other proofs (dalil). Istishab relates to the sense that
the past accompanies the present without any
interruption or change.
vi Istihsan
Description/Remarks
Religion
Life
Lineage
Intellect
Custom
is
of
force
A fiqh legal maxim states that Custom is of force. In many Shariah commercial contracts
many things become permissible following customs.
1.2.2 Prohibition in Muamalat
All economic activities are legally permissible as long as these activities do not transgress any of the
tenets of Shariah. In line with this maxim, it is the unanimous opinion of all four major Islamic Shariah
School of thought (Shafii, Hanafi, Hanbali, and Maliki) that all forms of business transactions that
transgress any of the tenets of Shariah are considered invalid.
General Principles:
No contract should be made for selling or buying forbidden products such as alcohol or any
Prophet
Muhammad
s.a.w.
said,
Gold is to be paid for by gold, silver by silver, wheat by wheat, barley by barley, dates by
dates, and salt by salt - like for like, equal for equal, payment being made on the spot. If
the species differ, sell as you wish provided that payment is made on the spot'. [Reported
by
Muslim].
From the above hadith, gold and silver represent money while wheat, barley, dates and
salts represent fungible item or food stuff. These items are known as ribawi item.
It would appear that the prohibition regarding riba has two dimensions. The first one
prohibits increases arising from debts/loans (duyun), known as Riba Duyun, while in barter
trades (buyu), unequal exchange of ribawi item of same kind and same basis in is known
as
Riba
Buyu.
This
can
be
summarised
as
follows:
Riba Duyun (singular dayn) is formed through financial loan:
i. Riba Qard - where the increase (interest) on the principal sum of the loan is agreed
upon at the point of contract;
ii. Riba Jahilliyah - this refers to the increase levied on the borrower for late repayment
or failure to repay the financial loan.
Riba Buyu (singular Bai) is formed through exchange contract in barter trade; i.e Riba
Fadhl (happen in unequal exchange of its counterpart) and Riba Nasiah.(due to extension
of
time
of
delivery).
The following rules of exchange apply in deciding whether the said transactions fall under
Riba
Fadhl
or
Nasiah.
Rule
1:
exchange between ribawi materials of the same kind (and of the same basis) must be with
equal weight, measurement or number and payment delivery must be made at the same
time.
i. If payment and delivery are made at the same time but the weights, measurements
or numbers of the materials exchanged are not equal, then Riba Fadhl occurs.
ii. If payment and delivery are not made at the same time but the weights,
measurements or numbers of the materials exchanged are equal, then Riba
Nasiah occurs.
Rule
2:
payment and delivery between ribawi materials of different kinds and of the same basis
must be made at the same time, though they may be made at different prices. Equal
weights, measurements or numbers of the materials exchanged are not required to be
observed here.
iii. If payment and delivery are not made at the same time (on spot), then Riba Nasiah
occurs
Maisir (Gambling)
Any transaction or activity relating to games of chance or gambling. A contract that
involves element of maisir (gambling) is Batil (void). Maisir can be concluded as betting or
charging something that will be forfeited if one fails to obtain the greater gain that one
hopes for. It is also defined as zero-sum game i.e the sum of those who gain and those
who lose equal to zero. For a transaction to be equated to gambling, it must involve the
devouring and unlawful appropriation of the property of others.
Allah SWT says:
"They will ask thee about intoxicants and games of chance. Say: In both there is great evil
as well as some benefit for man; but the evil which they cause is greater than the benefit
which they bring." Quran (2: 219)
Gharar (Uncertainty)
Gharar or uncertainty makes a transaction or activity un-Islamic as it will result into an
unjust or unfair outcome for the parties involved. It is where the quantity and the quality
involve in the transaction is not predetermined and known. Ayub (2007) Gharar means
hazard, chance, stake or risk. Gharar occur when there is element of uncertainty in a
transaction whose existence or characteristics are not definite, due to the risky nature
which may makes the contract void or voidable.
The Messenger of Allah s.w.t also forbade us from Gharar, Al-Baji Al-Andalusi states:
The Prophet (s.a.w)s prohibition of the sale of al-gharar render such a sale defective. The
meaning of sale of al-gharar refers to sale in which gharar was the major component,
leading it to be justifiably described as sale of al-gharar. This is the type of sale which is
unanimously forbidden. On the other hand, minor gharar does not render a sale contract
defective, since no contract can be entirely free of gharar. Gharar can be divided into Minor
ii. Major
(Fahish)
Gharar
The Gharar that causes a contract to be invalid is major (excessive) Gharar. In
general terms, major Gharar is:
an uncertainty which is so great that it becomes unacceptable; or
It is so vague that there is no means of quantifying it.
1.2.3 The Concept of Contract in Muamalat
Barbati defined aqad or contract in his kitab Inayah ala Fath al-Qadri as follows:
Legal relationship created by the conjunction of two declarations, from which flow legal
consequences with regard to the subject matter.
The literal meaning of aqad is join or tie. The English word for aqad is contract. Contract can
also be defined as being an expression of the matching between a positive proposal made by one of
the contractors and the acceptance of the other contractor in way which has an impact on the subject
of the contract. A contract must consist of:
Elements of Aqad
Descriptions/Remarks
Sighah
Maaqud alaih
Underlying Contract
i. Kafalah
ii. Tabarru
Means gift or donation which is
given by one in favor of someone
without seeking any consideration.
iii. Wakalah
iv. Ujrah
A contract of hiring whereby one
person hires someone for definite
services, in which the hirer is under
the duty to provide a reward for the
v. Ju'alah
A contract of hiring for services, in
which one party undertakes to pay
a specified amount of money for
rendering a defined service in
accordance with the terms
negotiated between them.
vi. Mudharabah
The nature of Mudarabah (profit
sharing) practices is that, it is a
financial contract whereby one
party called Rabbu al-Mal provides
fund to the other party called
Mudharib who undertakes to
manage the fund through
investment or trade and generates
profits, in which both the Rabbu alMal and also the Mudharib shre in
the profit in a pre-agreed
proportion.
vii. Musharakah
The contract of Shirkah
(partnership). Musharakah is an
agreement between two or more
parties to operate a particular
business in which all parties
contribute to the capital in view of
profit. In al-Musharakah dealing,
the parties involved herein share
the liability, profit, and also loss
according to their agreement.
Is the subject matter affected by the loss the same as that insured under the certificate?
If everything is cleared, this particular claim may be considered by the Takaful operator for
reimbursement. In most cases, the Takaful operator will not reimburse the full amount as there are
items in the bill that are not covered under the certificate.
Assuming that, say only RM 5,000 out of the RM 5,500 hospital bill is considered eligible for
reimbursement. Taking into consideration the 10% co-Takaful, the reimbursement amount is
RM4,500. Fazlina will end up having to pay RM 1,000 out of her own pocket.
A13.8 Disputes
A small proportion of many claims settled each year by Takaful operator usually end
up in disputes. The disputes between claimants and the Takaful operator generally will
involve one of the following two issues:
The question of whether the Takaful operator is liable;
The quantum of loss, if the Takaful operator is liable.
When a dispute arises, it may be resolved through the following channels:
1. Negotiation
and
Compromise
Settlement
In the event of dispute, normally the first step taken by a Takaful operator is
meeting the claimant to settle the dispute through discussion. The Takaful
operator representative, normally the staff of claims department will explain the
reason
for
the
rejection
of
the
claim.
In the case of dispute on the quantum of loss, the representative may try to
negotiate for an amicable compromise, which is acceptable to both parties. This
kind of settlement will usually result in the Takaful operator paying something
more than its interpretation of the facts would warrant and the claimant
accepting payment for less than that claimed.
2. Litigation
A claimant may take the Takaful operator to court if he is unhappy with the
outcome of his discussion/negotiation with the claim department. However, the
Takaful operator normally considers litigation as a last resort. The Takaful
operator will use other platform such arbitration or Financial Mediation Bureau
unless it involves a huge claim or an important point of principle.
3. Arbitration
An arbitration clause which provides that all disputes or disputes relating to
quantum only will have to be referred for arbitration is normally included in
most
of
general
Takaful
certificate.
Arbitration is a well-established and widely used means to end disputes. It
provides parties to a controversy with a choice other than litigation. Unlike
litigation, arbitration takes place out of court: the two sides select an impartial
third party, known as an arbitrator; agree in advance to comply with the
arbitrator's award; and then participate in a hearing at which both sides can
present evidence and testimony. The arbitrator's decision is usually final, and
courts rarely reexamine it.
Mediation
The Financial Mediation Bureau (FMB) is an independent body set up to help settle
disputes between the customers and their financial services providers regulated by
The loss does not fall within the scope of an exclusion of the certificate.
2. Claims Documentation
Claim forms are designed to assist the Takaful operator to gather information relevant to
assessing claims. The layout of the claim form may vary depending on the insurance
company, but there is some information that must be provided no matter who the carrier is.
Participant's name
Participant's address
Phone number
Certificate number
The Takaful operator makes the position very clear by making a remark that the form is
issued without prejudice, which means that issuance of the claim form does not mean liability
is admitted under the certificate.
Is the subject matter affected by the loss the same as that insured under the certificate?
2. Claim Form
Once the claims department completed the preliminary check and found the claim is valid, a claim
form will be given to the claimant. A clear instruction on the procedures and required documents
will also be given to the claimant. However, if the preliminary check shows that the claim does not
exist, the claim department will inform the claimant and stop the process.
3. Claims Register
All claims must be registered into the claim register once it is notified to Takaful operator. Takaful
operator must maintain an up-to date register of all Takaful claims as it serves as an official record
of claims. Takaful operator cannot remove any of the record from the register as long as they are
still liable for the claims.
Name
Address
Date of birth
Information regarding if the certificate owner is covered under a group plan through his
employer
Expect to provide not only the dates of any medical treatments or doctors visits, but also the date of
the injury or illness as well as the exact nature. There may be several additional questions or possibly
an additional form if an injury is involved because the Takaful operator will need to determine if the
injury is due to another person's negligence.
The claimant also needs to provide the authorization permitting any medical provider, physician, or
employer to release records or information concerning the insureds medical history or employment
status. This is to enable the Takaful operator to obtain records for a thorough review of the claim.
Proof of identification,
The original bills of the hospitals in which the insured was admitted,
Failure to furnish such proof within the time provided shall not invalidate any claim if it can be shown
not to have been reasonably possible to furnish such proof and that such proof was furnished as
soon as it was reasonably possible.
form and submit it to Takaful operator together with all supporting documents such as medical report to
substantiate the claim. All these documents are to be provided at the claimants own expense. Should an
insurer require further investigations, such additional cost of investigation would be at the insurers
expense.
Expenses
Medical Expenses is to cover the treatment cost of a sickness and injury, subject to the limits and
conditions stipulated in the certificate. Medical expenses plan generally cover amounts above a
pre-agreed deductible.
2. Hospitalisation
and
Surgical
Hospitalisation and Surgical covers the expenses regarding hospitalization treatment cost. The
plan is intended primarily to cover expenses incurred by having surgery and hospital stays.
Coverage options and costs vary depending on the specific certificate plan. The plan, however,
often
is
not
as
comprehensive
as
major
medical
health
Takaful.
Generally benefits provided by a hospital and surgical Takaful plan include the following:
Anaesthetist's Fees
Surgeon's Fees
Post-Hospitalisation Treatment
Ambulance Fees
Organ Transplant
3. Major
Medical
Expenses
Major Medical Expenses is a form of medical and health plan that provides benefits for most
types of medical expenses that may be incurred. Major medical expenses cover a much broader
range of medical expenses - including those incurred both in and out of the hospital - with
generally
higher
individual
benefits
and
certificate
maximum
limits.
The coverage for medical care charges is wider with few internal limits and a high overall
maximum benefit and may take the following forms:
Supplemental
Major
Medical
Expenses
When a Supplemental Major Medical Expenses plan is used, it typically backs up and
enhances a basic plan that usually includes hospital, surgical and medical coverage
along with an additional plan covering the broader range of medical expenses. Generally,
the basic plan will cover expenses with no deductible, up to the certificate's limit. Above
that limit, the supplemental plan kicks in, operating in exactly the same manner as a
comprehensive plan that does not provide first ringgit coverage. In simpler terms, after
the basic plan's limits are reached, the participant must absorb a deductible, after which
the supplemental major medical coverage will accomodate. Since the deductible actually
occurs between the basic and supplemental certificate, it's often referred to as a corridor
deductible. Like the Comprehensive Major Medical Plan, a supplemental plan is likely to
include
a
stop-loss
limit
and
a
maximum
lifetime
benefit
limit.
Example:Puan Sakinah participated in both basic medical takaful plan and supplemental major
medical takaful plan. She was hospitalized and her medical bill has exceeded the basic
medical
takaful
certificate's
limit.
As she already exhausted the basic plan certificate's limit, the supplemental plan will kick
in. The plan will pay the medical bill as per the supplemental plan certificate's limit minus
a deductible. For example, the plan will pay 80% of the bill and the remaining 20% will be
borne by Pn. Sakinah.
Comprehensive
Major
Medical
Expenses
Comprehensive Major Medical Expenses Plan is a medical and health plan that provides
coverage for most types of medical expenses. It is similar to a basic Hospitalization and
Surgical Takaful Plan except for the imposition of a substantial deductible. Most major
medical plan begins paying benefits after the deductible is satisfied. The certificate's
deductible is considered satisfied as long as the participant individual can show evidence
of
having
incurred
and
paid
the
necessary
covered
expense.
Another important feature of major medical coverage is the concept of co-Takaful which is
the sharing between the Takaful operator and the participant of any covered expenses
that exceed the deductible amount. The Takaful operator always carries the bulk of these
expenses, usually paying 80% while the participant is responsible for the remaining 20%.
Other proportions (as stipulated in the particular certificate may also be used, such as
75/25.
Excess
Major
Medical
Expenses
Excess Major Medical Expenses is normally offered as a top-up of a major medical. Once
the claim exceeds the limits of primary major medical plan, the excess major medical
plan begins coverage.
Basis
of
Takaful
Coverage
Comprehensive Hospitalisation and Surgical Takaful is also called "As Charged" plan in Malaysia.
The certificate normally covers the actual amounts charged by the hospital, on top of the room
and board. However, Takaful operator may put a control mechanism by putting a limit of
compensation for each benefit. Some of the limits imposed by Takaful operator are Per Disability
Limits, Overall Annual Limits and Overall Lifetime Limit.
Group
Medical
and
Health
Takaful
Plan
Group Medical and Health Takaful plan is similar in cover to individual medical and health plan. It
is normally employer-sponsored coverage for business owners, employees and often for
dependents. The contribution for group medical and health plan is calculated based on the
characteristics of the group as a whole, such as average age and degree of occupational hazard,
unlike
individual
plan
where
each
person's
risk
potential
is
evaluated.
There are two types of Group Medical and Health Takaful Plan:
a. Contributory
Basis
Under this type of plan, employees contribute a portion of group Takaful contribution.
Normally this kind of plan requires participation of at least seventy-five per cent (75%) of
the eligible members of the group.
b. Non-contributory
basis
Under this type of plan, no contributions are required of the employees as all group
Takaful contributions are paid by employer. However, this plan requires full participation
of all eligible members of the group.
Hospitalization
Cash
Benefit
Takaful
Plan
This plan provides participants with daily cash benefit, should the participant be hospitalized due
to all causes, subject to the terms and conditions of the Rider. It can be offered as stand-alone
certificate or as riders to Family Takaful or Medical and Health Takaful plan.
Critical
Illnesses
Takaful
Plan
The plan provides protection against any of the specified critical illnesses. It is also known as
dread diseases Takaful. Upon being diagnosed with any of the specified critical illness, the plan
will
cover
the
participant
a
lump
benefit.
This plan is introduce as a stand-alone certificate or as a rider to a Family Takaful certificate.
Disability
Income
Takaful
Plan
Disability Income Takaful, is a plan that covers the beneficiary's earned income against the risk
that a disability will make working, (and therefore earning), impossible. It includes paid sick leave,
short-term disability benefits, and long-term disability benefits