Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
Table II-200-1
Other Acceptable ASTM Editions
Book Section
Specification
III
IV
VIII 1
VIII 2
Non
Nuc.
Code
Case
Latest
Adopted
VIII 3
XII
Nuc.
Code
Case
07
88c through 07
Other Acceptable
Editions
SA 6/SA 6M
Identical
SA 20/SA 20M
General Requirements,
Plates
10
88 through 10
05
88 through 05
Identical
SA 29/SA 29M
Identical
SA 31
X
05
88 through 05
SA 47/SA 47M
99(R09)
Identical except for the deletion of welded repair references in 11.2 and 11.3 and mandatory certification in 14.1
84 through 99(R09)
SA 53/SA 53M
X
X
X
X
Identical except for the insertion of test practices in 11.1, and editorial corrections to Table X4.1
01
88a through 01
SA 105/SA 105M
Identical
05
87a through 05
SA 106/SA 106M
Identical
08
88a through 08
96(R12)
SA 134
85 through 96(R12)
SA 135
Identical
01
88 through 01
SA 178/SA 178M
Identical
95
89 through 95
SA 179/SA 179M
Identical
90a(R12)
SA 181/SA 181M
Identical
06
SA 182/SA 182M
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
11a
87a through 11a
Identical except for the inclusion of F316Ti in para. 7.3.1
(a) S32202 (F66) heat treatment range shall be 1870F to 1975F (1020F to 1080C) for ASTM editions prior to 09a
(b) S32202 (F60) min YS in Table 3 shall be 70 (485) in all ASTM editions
(c) S30815 (F45) and S32228 (F56) direct or indirect in process heat treatment is prohibited for ASTM editions prior to 07
(d) K90901 (F91) and K91061 (F911), other acceptable editions are limited to 05 or later
SA 192/SA 192M
Identical
91
88 through 91
SA 193/SA 193M
Identical
07
05 through 07
SA 194/SA 194M
07a
87 through 07a
Identical. For Grades 2H, 2, 4, 7, and 16, other acceptable ASTM Editions are limited to 03 and later. For Grades 2HM and 7M, other acceptable ASTM
Editions are limited to 04 and later.
SA 202/SA 202M
Identical
93
82 through 93
SA 203/SA 203M
Identical
12
82 through 12
1758
Table II-200-1
Other Acceptable ASTM Editions (Cont'd)
Book Section
Non
Nuc.
Code
Case
Latest
Adopted
Specification
III
IV
VIII 1
VIII 2
VIII 3
XII
Nuc.
Code
Case
SA 204/SA 204M
Identical
12
SA 209/SA 209M
Identical
03(R12)
95
SA 210/SA 210M
X
X
X
Identical except for editorial differences in Table 2
Other Acceptable
Editions
88 through 12
88 through 03(R12)
88 through 95
SA 213/SA 213M
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
08
01a through 08
Identical except for the additional H Grade heat treatment requirements in 6.2 and Grades T23, T24, T91, T911, T92, and T122 are limited to 06a and
later.
90a
88 through 90a
SA 216/SA 216M
X
X
X
X
X
Identical except for addition of 2.3 and editorial differences in 2.1 and 10.1
07
84b through 07
SA 214/SA 214M
Identical
SA 217/SA 217M
Identical
07
93 through 07
SA 225/SA 225M
Identical
12
86 through 12
96
91
07
82a through 07
SA 231/SA 231M
SA 234/SA 234M
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
Identical except for Grades WP91 and WP911, other acceptable ASTM editions are limited to 05 and later.
SA 240/SA 240M
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
11
88c through 11
Identical except for UNS S31050, other acceptable ASTM editions are limited to 04 and later. For UNS S32906, other acceptable ASTM editions are
limited to 07e1 and later.
SA 249/SA 249M
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
04a
88b through 04a
Identical except for the deletion of S5, which addresses unstraightened tubes, and S9 is mandatory when 100% joint efficiency is required.
SA 250/SA 250M
X
X
05(R09)
Identical except that Supplementary Requirement S1 is mandatory when 100% weld joint efficiency is required.
SA 263
12
88 through 12
Identical. In cases where cladding is used in the design strength calculations and welding is used to join multiple alloy cladding plates, ASTM editions
prior to 12 are not acceptable unless welding was performed by an ASME Certificate Holder.
SA 264
12
88 through 12
Identical. In cases where cladding is used in the design strength calculations and welding is used to join multiple alloy cladding plates, ASTM editions
prior to 12 are not acceptable unless welding was performed by an ASME Certificate Holder.
SA 265
12
88 through 12
Identical. In cases where cladding is used in the design strength calculations and welding is used to join multiple alloy cladding plates, ASTM editions
prior to 12 are not acceptable unless welding was performed by an ASME Certificate Holder.
SA 266/SA 266M
Identical
03a(R08)
SA 268/SA 268M
Identical
05a
SA 276
Identical
97
SA 278/SA 278M
X
Identical except for an editorial change to 5.1.1 and a change to 16.1 making certification mandatory.
1759
01(R11)
87 through 03a(R08)
85 through 01(R11)
Table II-200-1
Other Acceptable ASTM Editions (Cont'd)
Book Section
Non
Nuc.
Code
Case
Latest
Adopted
Specification
III
IV
VIII 1
VIII 2
VIII 3
XII
Nuc.
Code
Case
SA 283/SA 283M
Identical
03(R07)
88 through 03(R07)
SA 285/SA 285M
Identical
12
82(R87) through 12
SA 299/SA 299M
Identical
04
82(R87) through 04
Other Acceptable
Editions
SA 302/SA 302M
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
12
82 through 12
Identical except for the addition of Note 1 to Table 1. ASTM editions prior to 12 are acceptable provided that any accelerated cooling of plates as
permitted in 5.3 is followed by tempering.
SA 307
X
X
X
X
Identical except for the deletion of the term private label distributor from para. 13.1.1.
07b
00 through 07b
SA 311/SA 311M
X
04(R10) 90b through 04(R10)
Identical except for the deletion of 5.1.11, revision of Table 1 footnote A, and editorial change to 5.1.9, and 11.1 revised to make certification mandatory.
SA 312/SA 312M
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
01a
88a through 01a
Identical except for the deletion of 5.2, revision to 6.2 to add H Grade heat treatment requirements, and editorial differences in 7.1 and Table 1 and an
editorial correction to the Cr and Ni percent chemical composition for UNS S31002 in Table 1
SA 320/SA 320M
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
07
01 through 07
Identical except for editorial clarification of exemption of carbide solution treated austenitic material from impact test requirements in 6.2.1.1.
SA 325
X
X
X
X
Identical except for the deletion of the term private label distributor in 15.1 and 15.5
07a
SA 333/SA 333M
X
Identical except for the deletion of 12.3 that conflicts with 15
94 through 04a
SA 334/SA 334M
Identical
04a
04a(R10)
SA 335/SA 335M
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
06
88a through 06
Identical except for the addition of hardness requirements for P23 and P911 in 9.3 and 14.2.1, and the correction of UNS numbers for P9 and P91. For
Grade P23, other acceptable ASTM editions are limited to 05a and later; for Grades P91, P92, P122 and P911, other acceptable ASTM editions are
limited to 06.
SA 336/SA 336M
Identical
07
06a through 07
SA 350/SA 350M1
X
X
X
02b
Identical except for the deletion of 6.1.2 and 14.1, revision to 14.2.5, and test reports have been made mandatory
87 through 02b
SA 351/SA 351M
Identical
00
SA 352/SA 352M
Identical
06(R12)
SA 353/SA 353M
Identical
09
87 through 09
07a
86 through 07a
SA 354
X
X
X
X
Identical except for the deletion of the term private label distributor in 15.1 and 15.3.5
86 through 00
88 through 06(R12)
SA 358/SA 358M
X
X
X
01
88 through 01
Identical except for clarified heat treatment requirements in 6.3.1, the deletion of 6.3.2.2 for HT O pipe and 6.3.2.3 for HT SO pipe, an editorial difference
in 1.2, and the following additional requirements apply as shown in the specification.
SA 369/SA 369M
Identical
SA 370
Identical
06
88 through 06
05
77 through 05
1760
Table II-200-1
Other Acceptable ASTM Editions (Cont'd)
Book Section
Specification
III
IV
VIII 1
VIII 2
VIII 3
XII
Nuc.
Code
Case
SA 372/SA 372M
Identical
Non
Nuc.
Code
Case
Latest
Adopted
03(R08)
Other Acceptable
Editions
02 through 03(R08)
SA 376/SA 376M
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
06
88 through 06
Identical except for the deletion of HT O option from 6.2 and 14.1 and clarification of heat treatment requirements in 6.2
SA 387/SA 387M
X
X
X
X
X
Identical. For Grade 91, acceptable ASTM editions are limited to 11 and later.
SA 395/SA 395M
Identical
11
99(R09)
88 through 11
80 through 99(R09)
SA 403/SA 403M
X
X
X
X
X
07
86 through 07
Identical except for the correction of Table 2 Ni minimum for Grade WP S38815, clarified heat treatment requirements in 6.1 and 6.4, the deletion of
304/304L/304N in 14.5, and the deletion of 5.14 and 5.15. For H Grades, other acceptable ASTM editions are limited to 02 and later.
SA 409/SA 409M
X
95a1
88 through 95a1
Identical except for clarified heat treatment requirements for H grade stainless steels and S30815 editorial corrections in 5.3.1 and Tables 1, 2, and 3,
deletion of 5.3.2.2 and 5.3.2.3 for the non heat treated pipe provisions, and the inclusion of a grain size requirement in 5.1.1 for H grade stainless
steels. A requirement for ASME Stamping has been added and editorial requirements apply as shown in the subtitle of the specification
SA 414/SA 414M
Identical
07
88 through 07
SA 420/SA 420M
Identical
04
85a through 04
SA 423/SA 423M
Identical
95(R04)
07
SA 426/SA 426M
Identical except for a correction to the molybdenum content for Grade CP91 in Table 1.
SA 435/SA 435M
Identical
SA 437/SA 437M
Identical
90(R12)
06
89 through 95(R04)
80 through 07
82(R87) through 90(R12)
84b through 06
SA 449
X
X
07b
87 through 07b
Identical except for requiring all mating fastener components to be coated by the same zinc coating process in 5.1.4 and the deletion of private label
distributor in 16.1 and 16.3.2, and removal of reference to bolts in para. 6.4.
SA 450/SA 450M
Identical
SA 451/SA 451M
96
06(R10)
88a through 96
80(R85) through 06(R10)
SA 453/SA 453M
X
X
X
04
00 through 04
Identical except for the requirement contained in para. 5.1 that material and fasteners conform to the chemical requirements in Table 3.
X
03(R07)
SA 476
Identical except for editorial changes in 4.1.6 and 13.1 to make certification mandatory
00(R09)
82 through 00(R09)
SA 479/SA 479M
X
X
X
X
X
X
Identical except for minor editorial changes to Tables 1 and 2 in earlier editions.
11
87b through 11
SA 455/SA 455M
Identical
SA 480/SA 480M
Identical
11a
88 through 11a
SA 484/SA 484M
Identical
11
87 through 11
1761
Table II-200-1
Other Acceptable ASTM Editions (Cont'd)
Book Section
Non
Nuc.
Code
Case
Latest
Adopted
Specification
III
IV
VIII 1
VIII 2
VIII 3
XII
Nuc.
Code
Case
SA 487/SA 487M
Identical
93(R12)
SA 494/SA 494M
Other Acceptable
Editions
88 through 93(R12)
SA 508/SA 508M
X
X
X
X
X
X
05b(R10) 87 through 05b(R10)
Identical except for revision prior to 05b. For these A 966/A 966M added to 2.1, 3.1, and 7.2.1 revised to allow A 966 in revisions prior to 051
reference to Notes 2 and 3 in 6.1.2.2 should be 3 and 4 respectively.
SA 513
00
Identical except that Supplementary Requirements S6 and either S7 or S8 at the manufacturers option are mandatory
SA 515/SA 515M
Identical
03(R07)
82 through 03(R07)
SA 516/SA 516M
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
Identical. The reference to Footnote B in Table 1 shall apply to the 04, 05, and 05e editions.
06
86 through 06
SA 517/SA 517M
X
X
Identical except for Grades A, B, E, F, J, P, and deletion of fusion in 1.1
06
87a 1 through 06
SA 522/SA 522M
Identical
07
87 through 07
SA 524
Identical
93
88 through 93
99
88a through 99
SA 530/SA 530M
Identical
SA 533/SA 533M
Identical
09E1
SA 537/SA 537M
Identical
08
86 through 08
SA 540/SA 540M
Identical
06
84a through 06
SA 541/SA 541M
Identical
05(R10)
SA 542/SA 542M
Identical
09
88 through 09
SA 543/SA 543M
Identical
09
87 through 09
SA 553/SA 553M
Identical
06
87b through 06
SA 556/SA 556M
Identical
SA 557/SA 557M
Identical
90a
88 through 90a
SA 562/SA 562M
Identical
06
82(R87) through 06
87 through 09E1
SA 563
X
X
07a
84 through 07a
Identical except for deletion of the term private label distributor in paras. 14.7 and 14.9 and editorially corrected title.
SA 564/SA 564M
Identical
SA 568/SA 568M
Identical
04(R09)
07a
1762
Table II-200-1
Other Acceptable ASTM Editions (Cont'd)
Book Section
Specification
III
IV
VIII 1
VIII 2
VIII 3
XII
Nuc.
Code
Case
SA 572/SA 572M
Identical
Non
Nuc.
Code
Case
Latest
Adopted
06
Other Acceptable
Editions
01 through 06
SA 574
X
X
04 1
97a through 04 1
Identical except that Table 1 on chemical requirements has been deleted and Supplementary Requirement S1 is now mandatory. Paragraphs 6.1 and 6.2
have been revised to refer to Table S1.1 and 6.3 has been deleted.
SA 577/SA 577M
Identical
90(R12)
86 through 90(R12)
SA 578/SA 578M
Identical
07(R12)
85 through 07(R12)
SA 587
93
04(R09)
85 through 04(R09)
91(R07)
83 through 91(R07)
12
SA 638/SA 638M
00(R04)
87 through 00(R04)
SA 612/SA 612M
Identical
88 through 93
87 through 12
SA 645/SA 645M
Identical
05
87(R91) through 05
SA 649/SA 649M
Identical
04
91a through 04
SA 656/SA 656M
Identical
00a
SA 660
Identical
96(R10)
SA 662/SA 662M
Identical
12
86 through 12
SA 666
Identical
03
90 through 03
SA 667/SA 667M
Identical
87(R12)
94
85 through 94
SA 672
94
Identical except for the deletion of pipe Grade K. The additional requirements apply as shown in the Specification.
81 through 94
SA 671
88 through 96(R10)
SA 675/SA 675M
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
03(R09)
Identical except that Supplementary S7 is mandatory and Grades 65 [450] and 70 [485] have been added to S7. Certification is mandatory.
SA 688/SA 688M
X
X
04
88a through 04
Identical except that in the case of the 96 and 98 ASTM revisions, solution treatment of Grade UNS N08367 is mandatory
SA 691
Identical except that the additional requirements apply as shown in the Specification
98(R07)
SA 693
021
88 through 021
Identical except for aligning the elongation requirements for Gr. XM 16 and correction of the max. hardness for Gr. XM 12 and 630 in Table 5. Also a
revision to Note B of Table 1.
1763
Table II-200-1
Other Acceptable ASTM Editions (Cont'd)
Book Section
Specification
SA 696
Identical
SA 703/SA 703M
Identical
SA 705/SA 705M
Identical
Non
Nuc.
Code
Case
Latest
Adopted
III
IV
VIII 1
VIII 2
VIII 3
XII
Nuc.
Code
Case
90a(R12)
07
95(R09)
02
88 through 09
SA 723/SA 723M
X
Identical except that for Class 2a the minimum elongation shall be 13.5%.
SA 724/SA 724M
Identical
09
SA 727/SA 727M
Identical
02(R07)
91
SA 731/SA 731M
Other Acceptable
Editions
85 through 90a(R12)
87b through 07
87a through 95(R09)
88 through 91
SA 736/SA 736M
Identical
03(R07)
SA 737/SA 737M
Identical
09
87(R91) thru 09
SA 738/SA 738M
Identical
07
87a through 07
SA 739
Identical
90a(R12)
94(R09)
SA 745/SA 745M
Ultrasonic of Stainless Steel Forgings
Identical except for deletion of 1.5
88 through 03(R07)
SA 747/SA 747M
04
86 through 04
Identical except for the revision of the mandatory ordering requirements of 4.1.6 and the mandatory use of Supplementary Requirement S15 of
SA 781/SA 781M
87(R12)
97(R02)
SA 751
Chemical Analysis Test Methods for Steel
01(R06)
SA 748/SA 748M
Identical
SA 749/SA 749M
Identical
01
SA 770/SA 770M
Tension Testing of Steel Plates
Identical except for editorial correction to Table 2
03(R12)
SA 781/SA 781M
Identical
06
87a through 06
SA 788
Identical
06
05c through 06
SA 765/SA 765M
Identical
1764
94 through 01
86(R90)1 through 03(R12)
Table II-200-1
Other Acceptable ASTM Editions (Cont'd)
Book Section
Specification
III
IV
SA 789/SA 789M
Identical
(a) S31260 restricted to revisions 87 and later
(b) S32003 restricted to revisions 04 and later
(c) S32950 restricted to Editions 89 and later
(d) S32760 restricted to Editions 08b and later
(e) S32202 restricted to Editions 09 and later
(f) S32808 min. S in Table 1 shall be 0.10
VIII 1
VIII 2
VIII 3
XII
Nuc.
Code
Case
Non
Nuc.
Code
Case
Latest
Adopted
10a
Other Acceptable
Editions
88a through 10a
SA 790/SA 790M
X
11
88 through 11
Identical.
(a) S32003 minimum tensile strength in Table 3 shall be 95 (655) for editions prior to 09a
(b) S32202 heat treating temperature in Table 1 shall be 1870 1976 (1020 1080) for editions prior to 09
(c) S32760 heat treating temperature in Table 1 shall be 1960 2085 (1070 1140) and maximum hardness in Table 2 shall be 300 for editions prior to
08a
(d) S32808 maximum S in Table 2 shall be 0.010 for editions prior to 10
SA 803/SA 803M
Identical
03
96 through 03
SA 813/SA 813M
X
X
05
88a through 05
SA 815/SA 815M
10a
86 through 10a
Identical except for the deletion of para. 5.9, 5.14 (Class CR fittings), and 5.15.4.
(a) Paragraphs 5.14 and 5.15 deleted for all editions prior to 10a
(b) S32202, para. 7.2.3 filler metal with nominal 23.5% Cr, 12.00% Ni is not permitted, minimum HT temperature in Table 2 to be 1870 1975F
(1020 1080C)
(c) S32808, maximum S in Table 2 shall be 0.010 in all editions
SA 832/SA 832M
Identical
SA 834
Identical
06
84(R89) through 06
95(R11)
84 through 95(R11)
SA 836/SA 836M
Identical
02(R07)
SA 841/SA 841M
Identical
03a(R07)
88 through 03a(R07)
SA 874/SA 874M
Identical
98(R04)
98(R04)
SA 905
Identical
93
91 through 93
SA 941
Identical
06a
SA 960/SA 960M
Identical
07
99b through 07
07
99 through 07
07
99 through 07
SA 961/SA 961M
Identical except for the deletion of the time requirement for purchaser rejection of material in para. 18.1
SA 962/SA 962M
Identical
1765
Table II-200-1
Other Acceptable ASTM Editions (Cont'd)
Book Section
Non
Nuc.
Code
Case
Latest
Adopted
Specification
III
IV
VIII 1
VIII 2
VIII 3
XII
Nuc.
Code
Case
SA 965/SA 965M
Identical
06a
04a
03 through 04a
98(R07)
04a(R09)
01 through 04a(R09)
SA 985/SA 985M
Identical
SA 995
Identical
SA 999/SA 999M
General Requirements, Pipes
Identical except for the editions prior to 04a, para. 6.2.1 on grade substitution of the 04a edition applies.
SA 1008/SA 1008M
Identical except for the addition of 8.1.1.1 on mechanical properties for pressure vessel design
01a
SA 1010/SA 1010M
SA 1011/SA 1011M
Identical
SA 1016/SA 1016M
Identical
01(R09)
06b
04a
01 through 04a
11
01 through 11
98
93a through 98
00 through 01a
SA 1017/SA 1017M
X
Identical. For Grade 122, acceptable editions 07 and later. For Grade 23, acceptable editions 11 and later.
SF 568M
Identical
Other Acceptable
Editions
NOTE:
(1) SA 350/SA 350M Grade LF2 forgings, made to revisions earlier than the 2001 ASME Boiler and Pressure Vessel Code, or to ASTM Speci
fication A350/A350M with year dates from 1987 through 1997 are acceptable for either Class 1 or Class 2 applications, unless Supplemen
tary Requirement S4 was used to test forgings at a higher test temperature.
Table II-200-2
Other Acceptable Non-ASTM Specifications
Book Section
Specifications
III
IV
XII
Nuc.
Code
Case
Non
Nuc.
Code
Case
Latest Adopted
SA/AS 1548
X
2008
2008
Identical except for thickness reduction ratio, marking, and chemical composition as shown in the specification.
SA/CSA G40.21
2004
Identical except for marking, chemical composition and resurfacing by welding as shown in the specification
2004
SA/EN 10028 2
X
X
2009
2003 through 2009
Identical except for marking, chemical composition, tension test and quality as shown in the specification. For Grade 13CrMo4 5, other acceptable
editions is limited to 2009.
SA/EN 10028 3
X
Identical except for marking, chemical composition, and quality as shown in the specification.
1766
2009
Table II-200-2
Other Acceptable Non-ASTM Specifications (Cont'd)
Book Section
Specifications
III
IV
XII
Nuc.
Code
Case
Non
Nuc.
Code
Case
Latest Adopted
SA/EN 10028 4
2009
2003 through 2009
Identical except for marking, chemical composition, tension and impact tests, and repair welding as shown in the specification
SA/EN 10028 7
2007
SA/EN 10088 2
2005
Identical except for marking, resurfacing by welding and extent of testing as shown in the specification
2005
SA/EN 10216 2
X
X
X
Identical except for marking as shown in the specification.
2002+A2:2007
2002+A2:2007
SA/EN 10217 1
2002
Identical except for material, dimensions, marking and resurfacing by welding as shown in the specification
2002
SA/GB 713
2008
2008
Identical except for chemical composition, marking, controlled rolling and normalizing requirements as shown in the specification.
SA/IS 2062
2006
2006
SA/JIS G3118
X
2005
2000 through 2005
Identical except for marking, plates produced by TMCP, trace elements, mechanical properties and welding repairs as shown in the specification. Annex,
supplementary quality requirements, does not apply.
SA/JIS G4303
X
Identical except for marking and mechanical testing as shown in the specification.
1998
1998
SA/JIS G5504
X
2005
2005
SA/NF A 36 215
1997
1997
Identical, except for marking, normalizing rolling, quality, and chemical composition as shown in the specification.
GENERAL NOTE: The date of publication of the European standards considered in this table is the year of approval of the standard by CEN.
This date appears in the body of the standard on the page starting with EN; dates appearing on the front page of an XX EN standard (e.g., XX = BS
or NF or DIN) correspond only to the date of adoption by each member country.
1767