Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
ARCHAEOLOGY
Bridging method and theory
Thomas
L.
Edited
Evans and Patrick Da/y
o 1 n s up
DR CARMEN I
wife, love, best frie
would nev,
Routledge
Routledge
least ;
2005
930.1'028-dc22
2004028972
ISBN 0-415-31048-2 (hbk)
ISBN 0-415-31050-4 (pbk)
TOEZR
the push down the road to
CONTENTS
lll
RI
Where we've and where we are going
historical context
10
W. ZUBROW
R
Data collection
2
Archaeological survey in
33
digital world
35
BRADLEY
3
50
PAUL BACKHOUSE
RI
Quantification made easy
4
You,
59
CONTENTS
61
eastern France
THOMAS L. EVANS
PART VII
PARTIV
95
Conclusion
97
Afterword
PATRICK DALY AND THOMAS
128
JvlICHAEL FRACHEI
and hierarchy
MARCOS LLOBERA
169
Virtual worlds
8 'Digital gardening': an approach to simulating elements of
palaeovegetation and some implications for the
interpretation of prehistoric sites and landscapes
BENJAMIN R. GEAREY AND HENRY
171
CHAPMAN
191
GRAEME . EARL
PARTVI
211
213
JULIAN D. RICHARDS
KENNI
226
the screen
GARY LOCK
Vlll
Index
CONTENTS
i1
Age of north-
61
236
classifying ( past
ANDREW BAINl':S AND KENNETH BROPHY
PARTVII
eology
95
Conclusion
251
97
Afterword
253
128
257
Index
148
169
ulating elements of
5
foc the
ndscapes
171
'
;raphical
191
211
213
226
IX
PASTORAL LANDSCAPES
Central Asia
Michael Frachetti
128
n
y
()
II
n
e
e
y
:I
:I
)
e
s
t
i
1
:!
)
M. FRACHETTI
130
IEI
recr
te
ts
themselves contrihute to we
'}1ti.
is (\. gnal of developillg
1scape.s {har accounts foc {he vi
dt sources with wh ich "" i
M. FRACHETTI
I,
data and allow them to reflect changes across each other's spatial and tem
poral boundaries. Using computer simulations, trends in mobility patterns
need not simply be linked to seasonal ecology, for example, but can also
reflect localized activities that are recovered from settlements, burials, ritual
contexts, as well as the changes in the natural environment over the longue
duree. Each of these contexts impacts the formation of a nomadic popula
tion's landscape at a different scale - a topic that I will now explore in
detail.
I:
Large-scale
Mobile pastoralists do not wander aimlessly. For many nomadic societies,
the concept of 'territory' takes on a unique definition, in that their move
ments are almost always confined to an 'orbit' that is regular and repetitive
from year to year. This orbit exists as a conceptual space, which may define
a large-scale territory, but is experienced incrementally over time as groups
pass over it. Therefore, I propose that herding pathways represent a data
source at the largest spatial and temporal scale in terms of socially and
economically constructed landscapes.
Herding orbits and pathways represent a large-scale data source in that
they provide a general spatial extent, over which activities (e.g. migration,
camping, rituals) occur on a long-term schedule. An ethnographic example
is the Kazakh horse game called k6kpar, which entails racing and wrestling
for a beheaded goat carcass. This game may take place at any time of the
year, but tends to be played during the summer when a number of pastoral
groups converge on upland summer pastures. Although the game itself
is spatially localized (Le. a medium-scale event), over the long term, the
location and timing of the festival are conditioned by the construction of
and adherence to overlapping herding pathways of numerous mobile
groups. The repetition of their migration pattern to specific upland pastures
annually brings groups together, and over time this pattern creates the insti
tutionalized activity of the game. Therefore, from a temporal perspective,
the repetitive use of a particular herding pattern contributes to social
interaction on a long-term temporal scale.
At their widest extent, these pathways serve as the arteries through which
a network of ecological and social places are connected. The spatial extent,
or territory encompassed by pastoral orbits at their widest scale, reflects the
boundaries of a broad anthropogenic landscape that serves as the backdrop
for the creation of social locations of smaller scales.
133
~--..J
__ _ _ _ _ _ _ _
~
~~"'
".,,0''''''~
M. FRACHETTI
Medium-scale
Medium-scale aspects of pastoral social landscapes include settlements,
cemeteries, and other group contexts (e.g. playing fields, etc.). These con
texts bring together groups of individuals, and demarcate a definable space
or territory. For example, Bronze Age burials across Eurasia are often
marked with standing stele, or with stone fences that provide a separation
between the burials and outside space. In this case, the space of the cemetery
rarely extends beyond a radius of 500 meters. For settlements, the activity
space around the actual structure is slightly wider, perhaps 1.5 to 2 kilo
meters (discussed below). In this medium-scale space, social and economic
activities that are related to the settlement itself frequently occur. Especially
in the case of mobile societies, settlement contexts do not reflect long-term
occupation, but rather tend to be occupied seasonally. Although these
places may be returned to year after year, the success of a settlement space
depends on the availability of localized ecological resources (e.g. water
sources) that change from year to year, so that the experience of these places
is temporally discrete. Ultimately, medium-scale contexts are created by,
and condition social activities. As data sources, they are useful as focal
points of constructed space and practices within the wider landscape.
Small-scale
Spatially and temporally small-scale components of the landscape are dif
ficult to recover and model archaeologically. These factors are represented
by the kinds of events that archaeologists wish they could demonstrate with
material, but more often tend to propose as assumed behavior. However,
with the landscapes of Eurasian pastoralists, there is physical archaeological
evidence that reflects small-scale events, and that illustrates a social focus on
discrete locations, disarticulated from group activity. An example of this
type of data is rock-art.
Rock-art is a major element in the assemblage of data available to
archaeologists of Eurasia (Mar'yashev 1994). Rock-art is categorized as a
small-scale phenomenon not because it is rare or disassociated with other
contexts, but because it reflects a personal knowledge and attention to the
natural and social landscape. Individuals create drawings, and the places
they select to carve are at once extremely specific and also set within a
broader concept of the landscape (Frachetti and Chippindale 2002). Rock
art reflects the personal investment in the historicity of the landscape,
through a reflection of an instantaneous and unrecoverable action. There
fore, the spatial and temporal context of rock-art production reflects an
aspect of. agentive behavior, where individuals can make their irrevocable
mark on their landscape.
134
Scalar continuity
These scalar phenomena are not separated, but like gears of a clock turn
one another over geography and time (Giddens 1984). In real life the
experience of large-scale and small-scale phenomena is simultaneous, yet
the effects of discrete events may have long-lasting impacts. If we are to
understand this complex process in prehistory, our tools for analyzing
archaeological data of multiple scales should account for the correlation
between these various ecological and social factors.
The remainder of this chapter is devoted to illustrating a digital approach
to modeling Bronze Age pastoralism of Eurasia that contextualizes a variety
of archaeological data in light of its scalar qualities and role in the creation
of pastoral landscapes.
I
L
I'
I I
Dzhungar Mountains
!'
135
......
M. FRACHETTI
I
"
:1
)f
d
;e
:r
n
d
)f
n
1.
lt
.s
s
n
:s
it
d
:t
:s
!t
y
l-
It
d
g
If
tl
:l
-,
11
e
I.
L1
:l
e
~
137
~'
M. FRACHETTI
Study zone
The Koksu River Valley is located in the southern range of the Dzhungar
Mountains, forms an east-west grassland corridor between sub-alpine pas
tures and lowland, arid semi-deserts. The detailed study zone is approxi
mately 2,500 sq. km, and extends from the point where the Koksu River
emerges from steep-walled upland canyons to the territory where it flows
out of the Dzhungar Mountains (Figure 6.2). The study zone includes
highland zones with elevations over 3,000 meters above sea level, as well
as lowland depressions of less than 600 meters above sea leveL The region
is rich in archaeology primarily attributed to the Bronze Age (second mil
lennium BC), Iron Age (first millennium BC), and Medieval periods, and
ethnographically is host to semi-nomadic Kazakh herders.
Modeling pastures and land-cover
U
'!'
:1,
For the purpose of landscape modeling here, we will assume that the vegeta
tion and climate of the study region during the mid-second millennium was
broadly comparable with contemporary conditions. 3 When more detailed
reconstructions are processed, the land-cover theme can be adjusted to reflect
more comprehensive conditions of the second millennium. For pastoralists,
138
'"
),
; Kazakh herders.
md londcover
, we will assume hI the vgt
detailed
conditions.) When
V"
"' ...fVV'..". ",
....... ...
t..","," . .{ 1/
'.{;;
/
_
<X:
,'
.
.
::
1:
...
..
.
.
<.,'"
.:.(" "
'\l
"rJ I t:.J' :-"7:;- ....?..;z
, .
....
'"-. ..
'"'S\.-. r \ .I.i.r-.... .f-'
....,....., . <'...
:""
IIY;
'''' ''
.... _ ....
. (
._
"
'"I
lti d pastUl"es (> 1,400 m.a.5.1.) are more th:: rhree [imes <lS producliv e .a s
: lrs below 800 m <I.s.l. (Bykov 1974). The.efore,
'.
.
",
'01>
,",, "'"
<
'
,
---... l..,\
" ."
'
'
''
'
.
,'
....
\'l
f',..
_
.
. ".
.-'"/"
."
"
.
'._
..
,
-...
-'
k
I::..
__
..
.,./" '/;"'J o':) "-/ "
'"
",
'"_' '...._,... "'-. '(/i'<,
. ....'..J_ J
.. _-
!.1.\;'\:
:..;/l;.,
-,",. _\1;.:,.,
--"":
.. V'-':.
.
"
l,t,i'"-,.
' . ,,J-;.t'
,_
\ ,r
..... ,'.'..JJ.
,
.
,
l
o
l'
_. .
..
".....-'J
'(':'1?,/., :
'"'
. _
'"
..
,
"\...
':v)
.
,!,
..... :.,..'
....
...
'
--.f\...- ..[J'J
... \
(V\..... ....
-,-,'
- ,
,
,,_
.
.
........
L ,-,
''-"1/- .
'-J'-,
okw River
_.1
(-, "1)'\ ,
..., --.- .
.....,
N--U""""""' ;.
i:> ':';'r'\.
.....'
deling large
.. .:v
;.,',"";"'/' C'r ' 'I.'1
r
1 "
t1
Ino
....
....
JU.
----
':'1..
'_
1"",,,,
Flgurt 6.3
.jIIIII""
M. FRACHETTI
acts as one of the large-scale factors that determine spatial and temporal
cycles of pastoral movement.
II
at dti spatial d l
potentia/ pathways
ture resourees we then begin to
. assumption is tlblt
heir animals over pathways wllere
() Jonger { pastllre 10cations,
\\'il] le to
sertlemt to ,
, tl1at
, v
or, Jeast costlgreatest benef1t patllways were calculated bet veen these
(approx. 1.5 km). h, llsing the pasture resources again the restrictiye
route to pasture
S5
Rituallandscapes
turing mvllts, and otl1er patl1ways rhar clef1ne tl1e social splleres of
141
. FR.ACHI::TI
SLR STRUCTURE
'.
,...
!hh"
t'/SI11e
1.'" ..
._
h
6.S Nerwork
pasrtlres.
,,
ltil thW$
berween 5ett.lements
:d rhe richest
Figr 6.6
,,
flow U1ul;,ltin fo
ilinl lhWiI)'S ovec lwl
groups, II,t r!"s betweell pastures and settlements ;' co mpartd witl\
roures btrw
ss 3 burials (Fig\:
Since !": m()vtment bc::twC!":en various lls in (he lan dsc apc: dQC!":S I
alw"ys entai! fttding htrds , other delimiting fIS 10 tra vtling over
il1lO routc sclcction, 5uch
ll scales as well as
additional pat11ways
"
m ring
parhways [
pathways assessed .
Wllen m (ed wirh r.he pathways { hcrd\ng (based !\ rich ilst loca1\0115), the pafllways (( r oures betwccn sttls and rock-act, and
berweel1 settleln encs and rock-arr, illus trr pattern of parhways, whic11
142
Jn'
SUJ
populato
i ll would uplalld duri
HEI
".
,
"
.
destinatiol1s.
It th\vs tO kt (sed
! socially construcred contexts, (
areas , landscape.
we re tu rn ( p:tth....'a ys modeled berweert sttl ms and pastures
(Figllre 6.5), few conspicuous sires that 11v rhw)'s to
theln. These settlements are located [ lw!d , where summer pas
[ resources are [! . Ev n when [l tolerance is set
extremely high. productive hrdig parhways do not rh these fe3tures
143
SCAlAR SRUC1'URE
= suggt'
in k!)t
T
lI of imls d their Ilff
19731.
Di:
In cases rested , some b
beell made: 1 [hat desire go()d
,
!.>
1"",,,,
1'W cn
views, d
abiliry ro
" .
figu,
6.7
Discussion
In the cases tested above, some basic assumptions about pastoralists have
been made: 1 that they desire good pasture for their animals; and 2 they will
choose easier travel routes when not feeding their herds. These assumptions
are admittedly circumstantial, but seem to produce an output that is con
sistent with data from other scales (e.g. locations of burials). To produce a
comprehensive model, there are many data that may change the current
picture. For example, population dynamics could be modeled to show the
degree of stress on the landscape, or herd size could be assigned to different
regions to revalue the way resources would likely be valued. All of these
potential adjustments, however, bring us back to the goal of this chapter
to theoretically and analytically relate various scales of data to simul
taneously impact the outcome of archaeological reconstructions and
interpretations.
Combining data such as land-cover with settlements and mobility pat
terns to rock-art locations shows how an array of factors can produce
rather different landscape views, depending on how scale was qualitatively
assigned to the data. Settlements were selected to have a wider landscape
impact than rock-art (reflected in the distance buffers around them). This
scalar assignment has an effect on the 'communication' between data
sources in the digital environment. Digital archaeological modeling thrives
on the ability to test countless iterations of data of different scales to more
accurately reconstruct some of the potential ways humans experience their
landscape. In the case study here, combining large-scale, medium-scale and
small-scale data to preference various patterns of mobility, illustrated that a
variety of pathways may accurately define the pastoral landscape. These
patterns are not random, but in fact represent the compression of a number
of ecological and social factors that are weighted in a particular way. To
produce different results, one need simply reclassify the scale and impact of
their data. The most 'real' model is only distinguished according to the
kinds of questions that are being tested. This kind of simulation is not anti
145
-=-- ..
M. FRACHETTI
Acknowledgements
The archaeological research underpinning these reconstructions was funded
by the National Science Foundation and George F. Dales Foundation.
The archaeology and paleo-climatic studies were conducted in collaboration
with Dr. Alexei Mar'yashev (Institute of Archaeology) and Dr. Bulat Aube
kerov (Institute of Geology), Almaty, Kazakhstan. In addition, conversa
tions with Dr. Dana Tomlin (University of Pennsylvania) were instrumental
to the GIS modeling.
Notes
1 Also known in Russian as 'Semirech'ye.'
2 The Dzhungar Mountains Archaeology Project (1999-2003) which I co-direct
with Dr. Alexei Maryashev (Inst. of Archaeology, KZ).
3 For summary of the stability of steppe vegetation during the late Holocene, see
Khotinskiy (1984: 196-7), also more generally (Kremenetski 2002). For complete
discussion of paleoclimate and paleovegetation of the case study region, see Ph.D.
thesis by author (2004).
4 During the summer growing season (June-August).
5 Normalized Difference Vegetation Index.
References
Anshuetz, K. F., Williams, R. H. and Scheick, C. L. (2001) 'An archaeology of land
scapes: Perspectives and directions'. Journal of Archaeological Research 9:
157-211.
Barfield, T. (1989) The Perilous Frontier: Nomadic Empires and China. Cambridge,
MA: Basil Blackwell.
Barth, F. (1964) Nomads of South Persia. New York: Humanities Press.
Bykov, V. A. (1974) Bilogicheskaya Produktivnost' Rastitel'nosti Kazakhstana
(Biological Productivity of the Vegetation of Kazakhstan). Alma-Ata: Nauka.
Chang, C. and Grigoriev, F. P. (1999) 'A preliminary report of the 1994-1996
146
"
field seasons at Tuzusai, an Iron Age site (c. 400 Be-lOa AD) in Southeastern
Kazakhstan'. Eurasia Antiqua 5: 1-20.
Chekeres, A. I. (197 3) Pagoda, klimat, I otgonno-pastbishchnoe zhivotnovodstvo
(Weather, Climate and Distant Pasture Stock Breeding). Leningrad:
Gidrometeoizdat.
Chernykh, E. N. (1992) Ancient Metallurgy in the USSR: The Early Metal Age.
Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Cribb, R. (1991) Nomads in Archaeology. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Frachetti, M. and Chippindale, C. (2002) 'Alpine imagery, alpine space, alpine
time; and prehistoric human experience', in Nash) G. and Chippindale, C. (eds)
European Landscapes of Rock-Art, pp. 116-43. London: Routledge.
Giddens, A. (1984) The Constitution of Society: Outline of a Theory of Structura
tion. Cambridge: Polity Press.
Goloskokov, V. P. (1984) Flora Dzhungarskogo Alatau (Flora of the Dzhungar
Mountains). Almaty: Nauka Kazakhskoi SSR.
Ingold, T. (1993) 'The temporality ofthe landscape'. World Archaeology 25 : 152-74.
Kuz'mina, E. E. (1986) Drevneishie skotovody ot Urala do Tian'-Shania. Frunze:
Ilim.
Kuz'mina, E. E. (1994) Otkuda prishli indoarii? material'naia kul'tura plemen
andronovskoi obshchnosti j proiskhozhdenie indoirantsev. Moskva: MGP
'Kalina'.
Larin, 1. V. (1962) Pasture Rotation; System for the Care and Utilization of Pastures.
Jerusalem: Israel Program for Scientific Translations.
Mar'yashev, A. N. (1994) Petroglyphs of South Kazakhstan and Semirechye.
Almaty: Akademiia Nauk.
Margulan, A. X., Akishev, K. A., Kadirbaev, M. K. and Orazbaev, A. M. (1966)
Drevnaya KuZ'tura Tsentral'nogo Kazakhstana (Ancient Cultures of Central
Kazakhstan). Almaty: Nauka Kazakhskoi SSR.
McGlade, J. (1995) 'Archaeology and the ecodynamics of human modified land
scapes'. Antiquity 69: 113-32.
Potemkina, T. M., Stefanov, V. 1. and Korochkova, O. N. (1995) Lesnoe Tobolo
lrtysh e v kontse epokhi bronzy. Moskva: Institut Arkheologii.
Salzman, P. C. (1972) 'Multi-resource nomadism in Iranian Baluchistan', in Irons,
W. and Dyson-Hudson, N. (eds) Perspectives on Nomadism, pp. 60-8. Leiden:
E. ]. Brill.
Shilov, V. P. (1975) 'Modeli skotovodcheskikh khoziaistv stpenikh oblatei Evrazii v
epokhu eneolita i rannego bronzogo veka (Models of pastoral economies in the
steppe regions of Eurasia in the Eneolithic and early Bronze Ages)'. Sovetskaya
Arkeologiya 5-16.
Sobolev, L. N. (1960) Kormovye Resursy Kazakhstana (Fodder Resources of
Kazakhtan). Moscow: Nauka.
Sorokin, V. S. (1966) Andronovskaya Kultura. Moscow: N auka.
Spooner, B. (1973) The Cultural Ecology of Pastoral Nomads. Addison-Wesley
Module in Anthropology No. 45. Reading, MA: Addison-Wesley.
147