4/1/2015

courtnic.nic.in/supremecourt/temp/pr5056505715p.txt

1
ITEMNO.33+59COURTNO.9SECTIONII
SUPREMECOURTOFINDIA
RECORDOFPROCEEDINGS
Petition(s)forSpecialLeavetoAppeal(Crl.)......CRLMPNo(s).
50565057/2015
(Arisingoutofimpugnedfinaljudgmentandorderdated16/12/2014
inRCNo.220/2013,16/12/2014inCRNo.3/2014,11/03/2015inRCNo.
220/2013,11/03/2015inCRNo.3/2014passedbythePatialaHouse
Court)
Dr.MANMOHANSINGHPetitioner(s)
VERSUS
CENTRALBUREAUOFINVESTIGATIONRespondent(s)
(withappln.(s)forpermissiontofileSLPandinterimrelief)
WITH
SLP(Crl.)...CRLMPNo.5079/2015
(Withappln.(s)forc/delayinfilingSLPandOfficeReport)
SLP(Crl.)...CRLMPNo.5154/2015
(Withappln.(s)forc/delayinfilingSLPandOfficeReport)
SLP(Crl.)...CRLMPNo.5155/2015
(Withappln.(s)forc/delayinfilingSLPandOfficeReport)
SLP(Crl)No.2504/2015
(Withappln.(s)forexemptionfromfilingc/coftheimpugned
judgmentandInterimReliefandOfficeReport)
SLP(Crl.)...CRLMPNo.5319/2015
(Withappln.(s)forc/delayinfilingSLPandOfficeReport)
SLP(Crl.)...CRLMPNo.5404/2015
(Withappln.(s)forpermissiontofileSLPandinterimreliefand
OfficeReport)
W.P.(C)No.161/2015
(Withappln.(s)forpermissiontofilelengthylistofdatesand
OfficeReport)
SignatureNotVerified
Digitallysignedby
VinodKumar
Date:2015.04.01
Date:01/04/2015Thesepetitionswerecalledonforhearingtoday.
16:04:04IST
Reason:

CORAM:HON'BLEMR.JUSTICEV.GOPALAGOWDA
HON'BLEMR.JUSTICEC.NAGAPPAN
http://courtnic.nic.in/supremecourt/temp/pr%205056505715p.txt

1/4

4/1/2015

courtnic.nic.in/supremecourt/temp/pr5056505715p.txt

ForPetitioner(s)Mr.KapilSibal,Sr.Adv.
Dr.A.M.Singhvi,Sr.Adv.
Mr.K.T.S.Tulsi,Sr.Adv.
Mr.AshwaniKumar,Sr.Adv.
Mr.VivekTankha,Sr.Adv.
Mr.HirenP.Rawal,Sr.Adv.
Ms.AnuradhaDutt,Adv.
Ms.FereshteD.Sethna,Adv.
Ms.B.VijayalakshmiMenon,Adv.
Mr.AnishKapur,Adv.
Mr.PawanSharma,Adv.
Ms.EktaKapil,Adv.
Mr.MunindraDvivedi,Adv.
Mr.RajatJoneja,Adv.
Mr.TusharJarwal,Adv.
Mr.GauravBhargava,Adv.
Mr.KuberBoddh,Adv.
Mr.H.N.Salve,Sr.Adv.
Mr.MohanParasaran,Sr.Adv.
Mr.AmitDesai,Sr.Adv.
Mr.AbhinavAgarwal,Adv.
Ms.NeenaNagpal,Adv.
Mr.A.Singhvi,Adv.
Mr.MaheshAgarwal,Adv.
Ms.RadhikaGautam,Adv.
Mr.E.C.Agrawala,Adv.
Mr.RavindraShrivastava,Sr.Adv.
Mr.VikasMehta,Adv.
Mr.NarhariSingh,Adv.
Mr.VarunSingh,Adv.
Mr.PuneetGowda,Adv.
Mr.PulkitTare,Adv.
Mr.AnshumanShrivastava,Adv.
Ms.RuchiSahay,Adv.
Mr.VivekK.Tankha,Sr.Adv.
Mr.D.Kumanan,Adv.
Mr.VaibhavSrivastav,Adv.
Dr.SanjayShukla,Adv.
Ms.VialayakshmiMenon,Adv.
InCrlMP515455/15Mr.AmitDesai,Sr.Adv.
Dr.AbhishekManuSinghvi,Sr.Adv.
Mr.AjayBhargava,Adv.
Ms.VanitaBhargava,Adv.
Mr.SusmitPushkar,Adv.
Mr.AbhijeetSwaroop,Adv.
Mr.AnkurKhandelwal,Adv.
Mr.AnchitOswal,Adv.
Ms.EshaSandhu,Adv.
3

ForM/s.Khaitan&Co.
Dr.ManishSinghvi,Adv.
Mr.RiteshKhatri,Adv.
Mr.VinayK.Sharma,Adv.
Mr.D.K.Devesh,Adv.
ForRespondent(s)
Mr.A.Sharan,Sr.Adv.
http://courtnic.nic.in/supremecourt/temp/pr%205056505715p.txt

2/4

4/1/2015

courtnic.nic.in/supremecourt/temp/pr5056505715p.txt

Mr.AmitanandTiwari,Adv.
Mr.SanchitGuru,Adv.
UPONhearingthecounseltheCourtmadethefollowing
ORDER
Heardlearnedseniorcounsel/counselforthepetitioners.
PermissiontofileSLPsinPetition(s)forSpecialLeave
toAppeal(Crl.)......CRLMPNo(s).50565057/2015is
granted.
Delaycondoned.
Instantpetitionsarefiledbydifferentindividuals
againsttheimpugnedjudgmentsandorderstakingcognizance
andissuingsummonstothepetitioners.
Sincecertainimportantsubstantialquestionsoflawas
wellastheconstitutionalvalidityofSection13(1)(d)(iii)
ofthePreventionofCorruptionAct,1988areraisedinthe
instantpetitions,weareoftheviewthatthesematters
requireexamination.
Leavegrantedinallthespecialleavepetitions.
IssuenoticeinWritPetitionNo.161of2015.
Sinceleaveisgrantedinthespecialleavepetitions,
4

thereshallbeadinterimstayoftheimpugnedordersdated
16.12.2014and11.03.2015passedbythelearnedSpecial
Judge,PatialaHouseCourts,DelhiinClosureReportNo.03
of2014arisingoutofR.C.No.220of2013EOO11andstayof
thefurtherproceedingsrelatingtoPetition(s)forSpecial
LeavetoAppeal(Crl.)......CRLMPNo(s).50565057/2015.

Mr.AmitanandTiwari,learnedcounselacceptsnoticeon
behalfoftheCentralBureauofInvestigationinallthese
petitions.

http://courtnic.nic.in/supremecourt/temp/pr%205056505715p.txt

3/4

4/1/2015

courtnic.nic.in/supremecourt/temp/pr5056505715p.txt

SLP(Crl.)...CRLMPNo.5404/2015
Detagthismatterandpostitseparatelyon06.04.2015.
(VINODKR.JHA)(TAPANKUMARCHAKRABORTY)
COURTMASTERCOURTMASTER

http://courtnic.nic.in/supremecourt/temp/pr%205056505715p.txt

4/4