Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
MANAGING MULTINATIONALS
S.
No.
1
2
3
3a
4
5
Remarks
Chapter 16 SCM
Chapter 17 HRM
Kadsdatabank
Kadsdatabank
Ch-2, RM Joshi
International Trade Theory and Application - Handout given by Prof. Chawla
Mercantilism is a 16th Century doctrine stating that a nation should export more goods
that it imports.
Governments job is to create policy that promotes heavy exportation, collection of
revenue, and industrial development internally.
In practice, it serves to make the State the stockholder, financier, customer, marketer,
collector, and enforcer of contracts with other nations.
In 1776, Adam Smith proposed that market forces rather than government desires were
a better predictor of trade.
Laissez-Faire policy where government has no influence should promote trade better.
Nations will export to pay for goods they import.
Nations could specialize in producing and exporting goods where they have a natural
or acquired Absolute Advantage and import those goods they dont produce as well.
Comparative Advantage Theory
David Ricardo indicated in 1817 there may be a better explanation since few States
actually specialize like that.
Ricardo indicated that nations that are comparatively more efficient at production will
make those goods even though they may not have an absolute advantage.
Kadsdatabank
Heckscher-Ohlin Theorem
Countries export goods that make intensive use of the countrys abundant factor.
Countries import goods that make intensive use of the countrys scarce factor.
Differences in comparative advantage are attributed to differences in the structure of
the economy.
Assumptions:
Countries vary in the availability of various factors of production.
The Production Function is identical anywhere in the world.
The amount of output produced by using any given amount of capital and
labor.
Technology is constant in all trading countries.
Conditions of demand for production factors are the same in all countries.
Implications
Trade should be greatest between countries with the greatest differences in
economic structure.
Trade should cause countries to specialize more.
Trade policy should take the form of trade restrictions.
Countries should export goods that make use of the abundant factors.
Free trade should equalize factor prices between countries with similar relative
factor endowments.
Factor prices should be nearly equal between countries with more liberal mutual
trade.
International investment should be stimulated by difference in factor
endowments.
Factor endowment theory
A trade theory which holds that nations will produce and export products that use large
amounts of production factors that they have in abundance and will import products
requiring a large amount of production factors that they lack. This theory is also known
as the HeckscherOhlin theory (after the two economists who first developed it).
Kadsdatabank
Keesing indicated that trade direction and flow is predicted by gaps in human skills and
technology.
Nations with higher levels of humans skills and technology will produce and export
goods to nations with lower levels.
Human Skills and Technology-Based View
Human Skills are predicted by
Level of development in the scientific, technical, managerial, and skilled labor
sectors.
Technology level is predicted by:
capital-intensive technology development
imitation lag that exists as technology innovations diffuse to developing areas.
Product innovation and initial use occurs first in higher income countries
Diffuses to middle and lower income countries as technology and skills gaps overcome
and consumer preferences switch to the newer products.
Several trends emerge in PLC:
The export performance of the mature innovating country is better than others.
Technology is better in the mature countries as products diffuse production
tends to move from technology-intensive to labor-intensive.
Countries that were innovators can fall from that place.
Trade may increase in later stages of product maturity as costs and prices
decline and production economies rise.
Kadsdatabank
Theory Assessment
These theories provide insights in international trade.
No theorem can fully explain the range of motives for international trade.
Kadsdatabank
What is WTO?
Successor to GATT
International Organisation embodied in the results of the Uruguay Round
Established: 1 January 1995
Member driven (159 +1 Members)
Serviced by WTO Secretariat - 650+ staff
Based in Geneva
Classification of Members
Developing Countries
Least-Developed Countries (LDCs)
Developed
Transition Economies
Kadsdatabank
Full form
Year of creation
Purpose
Framework
Scope
Dispute resolution
GATT
General Agreement on Tariffs
and Trade
1948
To strengthen international
trade.
No permanent structure or
framework.
Trade in goods.
Has a permanent appellate
body to review findings and
settle disputes.
WTO
World Trade Organization
1995
To govern GATT and international trade
practices.
Has a permanent structure with a permanent
framework.
Trade in goods; trade in services and traderelated aspects of intellectual property rights.
Disputes are resolved faster as settlement
system has a select time frame.
Kadsdatabank
Provide the frame work for the implementation, administration and operation of the
multilateral Trade Agreements.
Provide the forum for negotiations among its members concerning their multilateral trade
relations in matters dealt with under the Agreement in the Annexes to this Agreement.
Administer the Understanding on Rules and Procedures Governing the Settlement of
Disputes.
Administer Trade Policy Review Mechanism.
Cooperate, as appropriate, with the international Monetary Fund (IMF) and with the
International Bank for Reconstruction and Development (IBRD) and its affiliated agencies.
Kadsdatabank
10
Trade remedies (fair trade) - The rules on non-discrimination MFN and national
treatment are designed to secure fair conditions of trade. So too are those on dumping
(exporting at below cost to gain market share) and subsidies. The issues are complex, and
the rules try to establish what is fair or unfair, and how governments can respond, in
particular by charging additional import duties calculated to compensate for damage
caused by unfair trade. Many of the other WTO agreements aim to support fair competition:
in agriculture, intellectual property, services, for example. The agreement on government
procurement (a plurilateral agreement because it is signed by only a few WTO members)
extends competition rules to purchases by thousands of government entities in many
countries.
Kadsdatabank
11
Date
913 December 1996
1820 May 1998
30 November 3 December 1999
914 November 2001
1014 September 2003
1318 December 2005
30 November 2 December 2009
1517 December 2011
36 December 2013
Host City
Singapore
Geneva, Switzerland
Seattle, United States
Doha, Qatar
Cancn, Mexico
Hong Kong
Geneva, Switzerland
Geneva, Switzerland
Bali, Indonesia
Kadsdatabank
12
and called for an end to agricultural subsidies within the EU and the US. The talks broke
down without progress.
Sixth ministerial conference: World Trade Organization Ministerial Conference of 2005
Held in Hong Kong from 13 December 18 December 2005. In this meeting, countries agreed
to phase out all their agricultural export subsidies by the end of 2013, and terminate any
cotton export subsidies by the end of 2006. Further concessions to developing countries
included an agreement to introduce duty-free, tariff-free access for goods from the Least
Developed Countries, following the Everything But Arms initiative of the European Union
but with up to 3% of tariff lines exempted.
Seventh ministerial conference: WTO Ministerial Conference of 2009
Was held 30 November 2 December 2009 in Geneva, Switzerland. The general theme for
discussion was "The WTO, the Multilateral Trading System and the Current Global Economic
Environment".
Eighth ministerial conference: World Trade Organization Ministerial Conference of 2011
Was held 1517 December 2011 in Geneva, Switzerland. Membership agreement where
made for Russia, Samoa, and Montenegro.
Ninth ministerial conference: World Trade Organization Ministerial Conference of 2013
Was held 36 December 2013 in Bali, Indonesia. 159 members of World Trade Organization
agreed to the Bali Package which eases barriers to international trade.
Kadsdatabank
13
Kadsdatabank
14
Kadsdatabank
15
to import goods in certain categories. This keeps the amount of goods imported under check
and thus protects domestic producers.
Import Quotas is another trick used by countries to place a barrier to the entry of foreign
goods in certain categories. This allows a government to set a limit on the amount of goods
imported in a particular category. As soon as this limit is crossed, no importer can import
further quantities of the goods.
Non tariff barriers are sometimes retaliatory in nature as when a country is antagonistic to a
particular country and does not wish to allow goods from that country to be imported. There
are instances where restrictions are placed on flimsy grounds such as when western countries
cite reasons of human rights or child labor on goods imported from third world countries. They
also place barriers to trade citing environmental reasons.
What is the difference between Tariff Barriers and non Tariff Barriers
The purpose of both tariff and non tariff barriers is same that is to impose restriction on
import but they differ in approach and manner.
Tariff barriers ensure revenue for a government but non tariff barriers do not bring any
revenue. Import Licenses and Import quotas are some of the non tariff barriers.
Non tariff barriers are country specific and often based upon flimsy grounds that can serve
to sour relations between countries whereas tariff barriers are more transparent in nature.
Regional economic integration is only beneficial if the amount of trade it creates exceeds
the amount it diverts
trade creation occurs when low cost producers within the free trade area replace high
cost domestic producers
trade diversion occurs when higher cost suppliers within the free trade area replace
lower cost external suppliers
Trade Creation
This involves a shift in domestic consumer spending from a higher cost domestic
source to a lower cost partner source within the EU, as a result of the abolition tariffs on
intra-union trade. So for example UK households may switch their spending on car and
home insurance away from a higher-priced UK supplier towards a French insurance
company operating in the UK market.
Trade creation should stimulate an increase in trade within the customs union and should,
in theory, lead to an improvement in the efficient allocation of scarce resources and gains
in consumer and producer welfare.
Kadsdatabank
16
Trade Diversion
Trade diversion is best described as a shift in domestic consumer spending from a lower
cost world source to a higher cost partner source (e.g. from another country within the EU27) as a result of the elimination of tariffs on imports from the partner. The common external
tariff on many goods and services coming into the EU makes imports more expensive.
This can lead to higher costs for producers and higher prices for consumers if previously
they had access to a lower cost / lower price supply from a non-EU country.
The overall effect of a customs union on the economic welfare of citizens in a country
depends on whether the customs union creates effects that are mainly trade creating or
trade diverting.
Kadsdatabank
17
Kadsdatabank
18
http://commerce.nic.in/india_rta_main.htm
Kadsdatabank
8.
9.
10.
11.
12.
13.
14.
15.
16.
17.
18.
19.
20.
21.
22.
23.
24.
25.
26.
27.
19
India-MERCOSUR PTA
A Framework Agreement was signed between India and MERCOSUR on 17th June
2003 at Asuncion, Paraguay. The aim of this Framework Agreement is to create conditions
and mechanisms for negotiations in the first stage, by granting reciprocal tariff preferences and
in the second stage, to negotiate a free trade area between the two parties in conformity with
the rules of the World Trade Organization.
2.
As a follow up to the Framework Agreement, a Preferential Trade Agreement (PTA)
was signed in New Delhi on January 25, 2004. The aim of this Preferential Trade Agreement
is to expand and strengthen the existing relations between MERCOSUR and India and
promote the expansion of trade by granting reciprocal fixed tariff preferences with the ultimate
objective of creating a free trade area between the parties.
3.
The India-MERCOSUR PTA provides for five Annexes. These five annexes have been
signed between the two sides on March 19, 2005, upon the conclusion of G-20 Meeting in New
Delhi. The five Annexes are: Offer List of MERCOSUR, Offer List of India, Rules of Origin,
Safeguard Measures and Dispute Settlement Procedure.
4.
Under this PTA India and MERCOSUR have agreed to give tariff concession to the
other side on 450 and 452 tariff lines respectively.
5.
The PTA would be operational after its ratification by the legislatures of the MERCOSUR
countries.
6.
Through IBSA Declaration made by the Heads of India, Brazil and South Africa on
th
13 September 2006, it was agreed that India-MERCOSUR PTA would be expanded by
__________________________________ Managing Multinationals - Executive MBA - Semester IV
Kadsdatabank
20
increasing the number of products covered and increasing the tariff concessions agreed by
each side. Accordingly, a preliminary discussion to work out the modalities of the future
negotiations was held in New Delhi on 15 and 16 November 2006 wherein India presented a
wish list of 626 additional products. In December 2006, MERCOSUR also presented its wish
list of 2099 products which is being considered in consultation with all concerned stakeholders.
Kadsdatabank
21
Self Reference Criterion (SRC) An unconscious reference to ones own cultural values,
experiences, and knowledge as a basis for decision-making. SRC significantly influences
ability of international managers to objectively evaluate environmental factors and make
business decision.
The Concept of Culture Culture is the way of life of people, including their attitudes,
values, beliefs, arts, sciences, modes of perception, and habits of thought and activity.
Cultural differences across the countries significantly influence business decisions.
Constituents of Culture A variety of learned traits that influence human behaviour can
contribute to the culture of a social group, the major constituents, include: value system
norms aesthetics customs and traditions language religion
Characteristics of culture
Learned
Shared
Trans-generational
Symbolic
Patterned
Adaptive
Value System Shared assumptions of a group about how things ought to be or abstract
ideas about what a group believes to be good, desirable, or right.
Value systems vary among managers across different countries : Eg. US managers : high
achievement orientation vs Japanese managers how have a growth and size orientation vs
Indian Managers who have moralistic orientation.
Norms Guidelines or social rules that prescribe appropriate behaviour in a given situation.
For eg. In Japan, aggressive selling is not perceived in the positive spirit. Eg. Indian use
hands or different types of spoons for eating. Chinese and Japanese use chopsticks.
Europeans and American use forks and knives to cut the food before eating. Lessons:
International managers need to know what is acceptable , unacceptable in foreign culture.
They also need to know cultural tolerance to business customs that may be grouped as :
Cultural Imperatives; Cultural Exclusives; Cultural Adiaphora
Kadsdatabank
22
Aesthetics Ideas and perceptions that a cultural group upholds in terms of beauty and
good taste. music, It includes areas related to dance, painting, drama, architecture, etc.
Eg. Colours have different aesthetic value in different cultures:
Africa : bright colours are favourites
Japan : pastel colours preferred as they express harmony.
China : red is lucky colour but associated with witchcraft in Africa.
America : blues and greys are perfect for official environments. But blue is evil in Africa
Death colours :
Black signifies death in America, Europe; In India, Japan & other Asian countries it is
white, For Latin Americans Purple means death; Dark red is the mourning colour in the
Ivory Coast.
Traditions and Customs Traditions: passed The down elements from of culture
generation to generation. Customs: An established pattern behaviour within a society.
International managers need to know the customs and traditions of the culture being dealt
with: Eg. Food Habits eg. Chocolate flavors preferred are different in different cultures : Eg.
Americans and Germans prefer blends, French- Dark, Dutch White. Coffee brews:
Nescafe manufactures200 different varieties of coffee to suit local tastes. The concept of
Indian vegetarianism is very complex for foreigners to understand. Vessels used for
cooking both should be different. KFC offers vegetarian dishes in its Indian outlets. Pizza
Hut offers Jain Pizza in India alone. Lessons: companies need to modify products/services
to suit the local customs and traditions.
Manners and Customs. Manners in gift giving: A lot of preparation and sensitivity required
while giving gifts. What and when is important. China : occasion : New Year Preferred Gifts:
Modest gifts such as coffee table, books, ties, pens. Japan: Oseibo( January 1) Preferred
Gifts : Brandy. Scotch, round fruits such as melons Manners and Customs in the Way
Products are used should also be considered Example Orange juice: Breakfast item in US,
Refreshment in France Moisturizers : After bath lotion in one, beauty 19 product in another.
Language A systematic means of communicating ideas or feelings by the use of
conventionalized signs, gestures, marks, or especially articulate vocal sounds. The Four
Roles of Language
Language aids in information gathering and evaluation.
Language provides access to local society.
Language capability is increasingly important in company communications.
Language provides more than the ability to communicate because it extends beyond
mechanics to the interpretation of contexts that may influence business operations
__________________________________ Managing Multinationals - Executive MBA - Semester IV
Kadsdatabank
23
Language some lessons for managers Even though English is considered linguafranca for non English speaking countries, it fails to provide non-verbal cues for example:
Coca Cola was named Ke-kou-ke-la in China which translates in Mandarin to Bite the
wax tadpole. Subsequently Coke found a close phonetic equivalent Ko-kou-ko-Le which
translates to Happiness in the mouth after researching 40,000 Chinese characters. The
Swedish vacuum cleaner Manufacturer Electrolux introduced the same print ad which was
successful in Britain in the US Market with the tag line Nothing sucks like an Electrolux.
Later they found this to be a disaster in the US because sucks in American means really
Bad. i.e. Electrolux is a really bad vacuum cleaner
Religion Religious beliefs significantly influence people behaviour and business decision
making. Religion encompasses three distinct elements:
Explanation: God seen as a first cause behind the creation of the universe
A standard organization: Consisting of places of worships and rituals
Moral rules of good behaviour : concerning principles of right and wrong in human
behaviour.
Religion : lessons for managers Considerable influences international business
decisions. For. Eg. Location of commerical buildings and office interiors need to be as per
Fen shui in China and Vastu Shastra in India, as it concerns free flow of cosmic energy and
keeps evil spirits away. Advertisements and corporate communications must keep religious
sentiments in mind. For eg. Islam does not permit shaving. So Shaving equipment makers
like Gillette need to be sensitive while advertising their product in Islamic countries.
Kadsdatabank
24
Collectivism: The tendency of people to belong to groups and to look after each other in
exchange for loyalty. In such cultures, interest of groups have precedence over individual
interest . For instance, Guatemala, Pakistan, Singapore, Malaysia etc. Lessons:
International Business strategy is greatly influenced by individualism vs. collectivism in
terms of decision making and market communication. For a product to be successful. In
collective societies, it should have group individualistic societies. acceptability unlike in
the
Masculinity vs. femininity In masculine societies, the dominant values emphasize on
work goals, such as earnings, advancement, success, and material belongings. e.g.
Japan, Switzerland, Great Britain, the US etc. In feminine societies the dominant values
are achievement of personal goals, such as quality of life, caring for others, friendly
atmosphere, getting along with boss and others. e.g. Sweden, Norway, Denmark,
Thailand etc. India falls in between. Summarily, in masculine societies, people live to
work, whereas in feminine societies people work to live.
Uncertainty avoidance The extent to which people feel threatened by ambiguous
situations. In high uncertainty avoidance societies there is lack of tolerance for ambiguity
and the need for formal rules. For instance, Greece, Portugal, Japan, France are the most
uncertainty avoidance countries. Low uncertainty avoidance countries Singapore,
Denmark, India, the US etc. include
Trompenaars Cultural Classification
Universalism vs. Particularism
Universalism: The belief that ideas and practices can be defined and applied everywhere
without modification e.g. the US, Australia, Germany, Sweden etc.
Particularism: The belief that unique circumstances and relationships, rather than abstract
rules are more important considerations that determine how ideas and practices should be
applied e.g. Venezuela, the US, Indonesia, China etc.
Kadsdatabank
25
Specific vs. Diffused The relative size of Public space and Private space and the degree to
which individuals feed comfortable sharing it with others differ considerably across societies .
Specific Cultures: Cultures in which individuals tend to have a large public space which is
readily shared, and a smaller private space. For instance, Australia, the UK, the USA and
Switzerland.
Diffused Cultures: Culture in which public and private space are more or less similar and
public space is guarded more carefully. For instance, Venezuela, China and Spain
Achievement vs. Ascription
Achievement Cultures: Culture in which status is accorded to high achievers and high
performers. For instance Austria, the USA, Switzerland, the UK, Sweden and Mexico etc.
Ascription Cultures: Culture in which status is accorded to those who naturally evoke
admiration from others such as elderly, seniors, highly qualified and skilled people. For
instance, Venezuela, Indonesia, China, the CIS, and Singapore etc.
Other Cross-Cultural Classifications
High Context vs. Low Context High Context Cultures: Culture in which high significance
is given to implicit communications, such as non-verbal and subtle situational cues. For
instance, countries. China, Korea, Japan and Arab Low Context Cultures: Cultures in
which communication is more explicit with heavy reliance on words to convey the
meanings. For instance, Germany, Switzerland, Scandinavia, North America and Britain.
Homophilous vs. Heterophilous
Homophilous Cultures: Cultures where people share beliefs, speak the same language,
and practice the same religion. For instance, Japan, Korea and Scandinavian countries.
Heterophilous Cultures: Countries that have a fair amount of differentiation in languages,
beliefs, and religions followed. For instance, India and China.
Relationship vs. Deal-focused
Relationship-focused Cultures: Cultures in which strong orientation towards building
relationships and developing mutual trust. For instance, India, Japan, China, Singapore,
Saudi Arabia, United Arab Emirates, Egypt, Brazil, Mexico, and Russia.
Deal-focused Cultures: Task-oriented cultures with openness to hold direct business talks
with strangers. For instance, Britain, USA, Germany, Denmark, Australia, Canada, Finland
etc.
Formal vs. informal cultures
Formal Cultures: Status differences are large and valued and formality is used to show
respect. For instance, India, UAE, Egypt, Brazil, Russia, Poland, Japan, China,, Singapore,
France, Belgium, Britain, Germany, Denmark, Finland etc
Informal Cultures: Status differences are not valued and Informal behaviour is not
considered disrespectful. For instance, the USA, Canada, and Australia etc.
Kadsdatabank
26
Polychronic Cultures: Cultures in which time schedules and deadlines are flexible and
relationships take precedence. For instance, India, Thailand, Philippines, UAE, Egypt,
Brazil, Russia etc.
Monochronic Cultures: Cultures with rigid time schedules and deadlines with high
emphasis on punctuality. For instance, Japan, China, Singapore, Britain, USA, Canada,
Australia, Germany, Denmark etc.
Expressive cultures: people are more expressive with direct eye contact. For instance,
Russia, Poland, Romania, USA, Australia, and Canada
Reserved cultures : people restrain their facial expression and gesturing. For instance,
India, Japan, China, Singapore, Britain, Germany, Denmark, Finland etc
Parochialism: Belief that views the rest of the world from ones own cultural perspective.
Simplification: Exhibiting same cultural orientation groups.
EPRG Approach
Ethnocentric orientation The belief which considers ones own culture as superior to
others. The belief that the business strategy which has worked in the home country would
also be suitable in alien cultures.
Polycentric orientation It is based on the belief that substantial differences exist among
various countries. Therefore, a single business strategy cannot be effective across the
world and customized business strategies need to be adapted in different countries.
Regiocentric orientation A firm treats the region as a uniform cultural segment and adopts
a similar business strategy within the region but not across the region. For example Mc
Donalds strategy is to not serve beef based products in India, but serves beef based
products in other countries. Also in the Middle East, it does not serve pork and all meat
based preparations are made out of halal process only .
Geocentric orientation The approach considers the whole world a single market and
attempts to formulate integrated business strategies. A geocentric firm attempts to identify
cultural similarities across countries and formulates a globally uniform business strategy.
Examples: the Harry Potter series of books and films, cartoon characters and their serials,
Jeans, T-shirts etc apparels like
Emic vs. Etic Dilemma
The Emic school holds that attitudes, interests, and behaviour are unique to a culture and
best understood in their own terms. It emphasizes studying the business research problem
in each countrys specific context and identifying and understanding its unique facets. The
Etic school emphasizes identifying and assessing universal attitudinal and behavioural
concepts and developing pan-cultural measures. Thus, etic is basically concerned with
measuring universal behavioural and attitudinal traits.
Kadsdatabank
27
Operationalisation of Emic and Etic Emphasis is often placed an identifying and developing
constructs that are feasible across countries and cultures, while conducting cross country
research.
Kadsdatabank
28
TRADITIONAL THEORY
Capital arbitrage theory - The theory states that direct investment flows from countries
where profitability is low to countries where profitability is high. It means therefore that
capital is mobile both nationally and internationally. But sometimes implication is that countries
with abundant capital should export and countries with less capital should import. If there was
a link between the long-term interest rate and return on capital, portfolio investment and FDI
should be moving in the same direction.
International trade theory-the country will specialise in production of, and export those
commodities which make intensive use of the countrys relatively abundant factor.
MODERN THEORY
__________________________________ Managing Multinationals - Executive MBA - Semester IV
Kadsdatabank
29
Product-cycle theory New products appear first in the most advanced economy in respond
to demand conditions. The maturing product stage is described by standardisation of the
product, increased economies of scale, high demand and low price. The standardised product
stage is reached when the commodity is sold entirely on price basis.
Internalisation Theories Of FDI
The theory explain that why the cross-border transactions of intermediate products are
organised by hierarchies rather than determined by market forces.
Theory Of Appropriability. The theory explains why there is a strong presence of hightechnology industries among MNCs.
Eclectic Theory of FDI
The theory tries to offer a general framework for determining the extent and pattern of both
foreign-owned production undertaken by a countrys own enterprises, and that of domestic
production owned or controlled by foreign firm. Dunning and Lundan(2008) assert that, the
eclectic theory of international production enlarges the theoretical framework by including both
home-country and host-country characteristics as international explanatory factors. It argues
that the extent, form, and patterns of international production are determined by the
configuration of three sets of advantages as perceived by the enterprises.
First Ownership (O) advantage
2nd Location (L) and
3rd Internalization (I) advantage in order for the firm to transfer its ownership advantages
across national boundary
Kadsdatabank
30
possessed the technological advantage and foreign direct investments were made during that
period.
Theory of Exchange Rates on Imperfect Capital Markets
This is another theory which tried to explain FDI. Initially the foreign exchange risk has been
analyzed from the perspective of international trade. Itagaki (1981) and Cushman (1985)
analyzed the influence of uncertainty as a factor of FDI. In the only empirical analysis made so
far, Cushman shows that real exchange rate increase stimulated FDI made by USD, while
a foreign currency appreciation has reduced American FDI. Currency risk rate theory
cannot explain simultaneous foreign direct investment between countries with different
currencies. The sustainers argue that such investments are made in different times, but there
are enough cases that contradict these claims.
Internalisation theory is considered very important also by Dunning, who uses it in the
eclectic theory, but also argues that this explains only part of FDI flows.
Hennart (1982) develops the idea of internalization by developing models between the two
types of integration: vertical and horizontal.
The concept of firm-specific advantages and demonstrates that FDI take place only if the
benefits of exploiting firm-specific advantages outweigh the relative costs of the operations
abroad. According to Hymer (1976) the MNE appears due to the market imperfections that
led to a divergence from perfect competition in the final product market. Hymer has
discussed the problem of information costs for foreign firms respected to local firms,
different treatment of governments, currency risk (Eden and Miller, 2004). The result meant
the same conclusion: transnational companies face some adjustment costs when the
investments are made abroad. Hymer recognized that FDI is a firm-level strategy decision
rather than a capital-market financial decision.
Kadsdatabank
31
specific advantages and using them abroad leads to higher marginal profitability or lower
marginal cost than other competitors.
There are three types of specific advantages:
a) Monopoly advantages in the form of privileged access to markets through ownership
of natural limited resources, patents, trademarks;
b) Technology, knowledge broadly defined so as to contain all forms of innovation
activities
c) Economies of large size such as economies of learning, economies of scale and
scope, greater access to financial capital;
L from Location: When the first condition is fulfilled, it must be more advantageous for
the company that owns them to use them itself rather than sell them or rent them to foreign
firms. Location advantages of different countries are de key factors to determining who will
become host countries for the activities of the transnational corporations. The specific
advantages of each country can be divided into three categories:
a) The economic benefits consist of quantitative and qualitative factors of
production, costs of transport, telecommunications, market size etc.
b) Political advantages: common and specific government policies that affect FDI
flows
c) Social advantages: includes distance between the home and home countries,
cultural diversity, attitude towards strangers etc.
I from Internalisation: Supposing the first two conditions are met, it must be profitable
for the company the use of these advantages, in collaboration with at least some factors
outside the country of origin . This third characteristic of the eclectic paradigm OLI offers a
framework for assessing different ways in which the company will exploit its powers from
the sale of goods and services to various agreements that might be signed between the
companies. As cross-border market Internalisation benefits is higher the more the firm will
want to engage in foreign production rather than offering this right under license, franchise.
Eclectic paradigm OLI shows that OLI parameters are different from company to company
and depend on context and reflect the economic, political, social characteristics of the host
country. Therefore the objectives and strategies of the firms, the magnitude and pattern of
production will depend on the challenges and opportunities offered by different types of
countries.
Kadsdatabank
32
Kadsdatabank
33
When a firm adopts polycentric approach to overseas markets, it attempts to organize its
international marketing activities on a country to country basis. Each country is treated as a
separate entity and individual strategies are worked out accordingly. Local assembly or
production facilities and marketing organisations are created for serving market needs in
each country. Polycentric orientation could be most suitable for firms seriously committed
to international marketing and have its resources for investing abroad for fuller and longterm penetration into chosen markets. Polycentric approach works better among countries
which have significant economic, political and cultural differences and performance of these
tasks are free from the problems created primarily by the environmental factors.
Kadsdatabank
34
assesses the overall spread of activities in terms of the number of countries in which the TNCs
have direct linkages (affiliates/subsidiaries). A company is therefore assessed as having a high
degree of internationalisation if it operates in many foreign countries. It is an attempt to
measure the overall geographical spread of TNCs subsidiaries according to the number of
countries/nations/states in which they are established.
Kadsdatabank
35
Ch-14, RM Joshi ; Focus on Sec 14.5 and 14.6 and Presentations shared in WiggioPath is Group Folders > MBA(E) FMS North Campus Folder > MANAGING
MULTINATIONALS > eBook-PPT
Read PPTs for Ch1, Ch8-16
Entry Mode is the institutional mechanism to make the companys products and services
available in international markets. Various types of entry mode are as follows :-
Low Investment Entry modes - such as exports are yield low returns but are less risky and
involve much lower exit costs. Small firms usually prefer exports as entry modes. Large
companies use these for testing new markets
Contractual Entry Modes - such as international licensing and franchising, offers rapid
entry market entry opportunity with low resource commitment .
Kadsdatabank
36
Rules ?
Anything allowed.
Almost everything is allowed (Open General License OGL)
One can export goods and services.
Restricted and prohibited items are on the DGFT website.
Kadsdatabank
37
Export restrictions
Export restrictions fall under two categories -:
General Trading Items : For these exports , one has to approach Export Facilitation
Committee (EFC) at DGFT HQs.
The Dual Use Items (SCOMET Special Chemicals , Organisms , Materials, Equipment
and Technologies) Special provisions for nuclear material under the WMD Act , 2005.
Most of the items are allowed to be freely imported (OGL)
However, there are some import controls on account of security, public health, public morals
and environmental grounds.
Prohibited items include beef, beef tallow, products of wild animals and ivory.
Restricted items include live animals, birds,
Restricted imports - Vegetable planting material , psychotropic substances, special
chemicals, unworked stones, arms and ammunition, aircrafts, security printing paper,
second hand consumer goods, certain categories of waste and scrap, satellite and
communication equipment of certain frequency
Canalised imports through State Trading Enterprises food grains , coconut oil, certain
petroleum products , fertilisers etc.
Import controls :
Less than 4% of Indias tariff lines (at 8 digit level) are under import controls,
Rest about 11,100 lines are free for import.
Presently :
Prohibited items 53 lines.
Restricted items 485 lines.
Canalised items (through STEs) 33 lines
Indias Export Basket
Merchandise exports 300 billion USD appx
Petroleum products 60 billion USD
Gems and Jewellery 40 billion USD
Engineering products auto components etc
Textiles Ready made garments etc
Pharmaceuticals
Handicrafts , Leather
Merchandise Imports 500 billion USD appx
Petroleum crude 170 billion USD
Gold 55 billion USD
Pearls , semi precious stones 23 billion USD
Coal , Coke 15 billion USD
Vegetable oils - 11 billion USD
India has an adverse Balance of Trade Merchandise Exports < Merchandise Imports
Service Exports 150 billion USD out of which software exports are about 50%.
Service Imports 80 billion USD
Thus India has a surplus in its Balance of Services as Service exports > Service
imports.
__________________________________ Managing Multinationals - Executive MBA - Semester IV
Kadsdatabank
38
Even though net remittances are positive , the overall balance in the current account
of Balance of Payments (BoP) is negative. This is balanced by a positive in the
capital account of BoP.
Markets Where To Export ?
Emergent (serendipitous) strategy Honda penetrated the USA market by chance
Honda cubs 50/100 cc motorcycles took on the might of Harley Davidson, the American
icon.
Deliberate (systematic ) strategy Honda penetrated the Indian market by choice by
forging a joint venture with Hero ; later aborted this joint venture and now is present in India
as Honda Motorcycle and Scooter Ltd; Hero Moto Corp is entering Latin America by setting
up an assembly plant in Columbia ; penetrating the African market through Kenya and
SAARC market through Bangladesh.
Naive rule use the same expansion mode for all foreign markets ignoring the
heterogeneity of different foreign markets.
Pragmatic rule enter a few markets initially with a low risk entry mode.
Strategy rule all alternative expansion modes need to be systematically compared.
Waterfall approach cascading effect first penetrate the platform economies like
Dubai / Singapore/ Hongkong and then focus on emerging economies like Vietanam ,
Myanmar, Laos and Cambodia OR growth economies like BRICS or mature economies
like South Korea/ Taiwan OR established economies like USA , EU and Japan.
Sprinkler approach penetrate all economies, all at the same time.
Sovereign and Political risk The first and foremost is peaceful and lawful conditions ;
political stability so that MNC businesses can flourish with a sense of security and
confidence . Today , Ukraine (in the midst of a civil war) ; Syria ; Iraq and some countries
in Africa Somalia ; earlier Rwanda and Sere Leone were theatres of war and thus out of
bounds for the MNCs.
Legal and contractual risk a good market / country should have rule of law ; strong legal
system where legal contracts and property rights can be enforced. Afghanistan fares very
poorly on this criterion.
Market size Population Honble PM of India attracts FDI and FPI into India by our 3
Ds Demand ; Demographic dividend and Democracy . We are the second largest
populated country in the world after China ; 65% of our population is below the age of 35
years and we are the worlds largest democracy thereby attracting the attention of the
worlds most powerful democracy USA. In National Income Accounting -:
Y=C+I+G+XM
Income GDP (nominal and PPP) and Per Capita Income.
Indias nominal GDP is about 2 Trillion USD but in terms of PPP terms it is ranked fourth in
the world after USA , China and Japan. Our USP is our affluent middle class about 300
million with robust purchasing power making every MNC FMCG / Consumer durables /
Luxury brands look at India seriously.
__________________________________ Managing Multinationals - Executive MBA - Semester IV
Kadsdatabank
39
Macro economic strength and stability Fiscal , Monetary, Trade & Commercial ,
Wage & Income policies should be transparent , consistent, stable and predictable. Voda
phone retrospective tax issue was a big dampener earlier.
World Economic Forum (WEF) ranks the countries in terms of Global Competitiveness
Index (GCI) . GCI refers to a set of institutions, policies and factors that determine the level
of productivity of a country which in return determines the rate of return obtained by
investing in that country. GCI sits on 12 pillars -:
(i) Institutions.
(ii) Infrastructure.
(iii) Market Size.
(iv) Macro economic stability.
(v) Health and Primary education.
(vi) Higher education and training.
(vii) Goods market efficiency.
(viii) Labour market efficiency.
(ix) Financial market sophistication.
(x) Business sophistication.
(xi) Technological readiness.
(xii) Innovation.
World Bank computes the Ease of doing business across the economies , based on
regulations affecting the ten stages of a businesss life -:
(i)
Starting a business.
(ii)
Dealing with licences.
(iii) Employing workers.
(iv) Registering property.
(v) Getting credit.
(vi) Protecting investors.
Ease of doing business:(vii) Paying taxes .
(viii) Trading across borders.
(ix) Enforcing contracts.
(x) Closing a business.
Kadsdatabank
40
Chapter 16 SCM
Chapter 17 HRM