Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
Subject of the course is a social history of music, with special focus on the 18th and 19th century. In
this period, the status of both music and musicians rose to unprecedented heights. The key to
understanding the sacralisation of music, which turns music into an alternative religion and brings
the musical man of genius into the position of its high priest, is closely related to the development
of the public sphere and bourgeois capitalism.
The course relies on a book written by the English historian Tim Blanning, an internationally
acclaimed expert in the field. It is titled:
The Triumph of Music: Composers, Musicians and Their Audiences, 1700 to the Present
(London, 2008)
American edition:
The Triumph of Music: The Rise of Composers, Musicians and Their Art
(Cambridge, Mass., 2008)
The book contains five chapters:
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
Chapter 1 (on Status) will be dealt in depth with. Special topics will be selected from the remaining
chapters.
Status
STATUS OF MUSIC
ANTIQUITY
Mythology
belief that music is of divine origin
Egypt:
Osiris as composer of the traditional chants
any alteration strictly forbidden
Ancient Greece:
Orpheus, legendary singer and musician:
divine ancestry: Apollo and the muse Calliope
alternative version: son of the Thracian king Oeagrus
divine power of his singing and playing
charming wild beasts, diverting the course of rivers,
Philosophy
music as a main preoccupation
Plato (428/427 BC -348-347 BC)
affinity between music and mathematics
Harmony of the Spheres (Pythagoras)
music as an essential part of education
theory of the ethos music affects the character (soul)
good versus bad music
blueprint of the ideal state (totalitarian utopia?)
music strictly regulated to avoid anarchy, disorder and moral degeneration
only Dorian and Phrygian modes permitted (courage, temperance)
MIDDLE AGES
Reformation:
16th century
attempts to reform the Roman Catholic Church
establishment of the Protestant Churches
Calvin (1509-1564):
uneasy about power of music
unaccompanied congregational singing of psalms
aversion of instrumental music
Ulrich Zwingli (1484-1531): total banning of music
Martin Luther (1483-1546):
music as magnificent gift of God
song of the congregation
hymn Eine feste Burg ist unser Gott (A Mighty Fortress is our God)
Conclusion
Blanning, p.11:
In short, with the exception of the grim Franco-Swiss reformers, Europeans have always
cherished music especially when performed collectively (whether by Athenians, Jews,
medieval monks, Protestant congregations or whomever).
ANTIQUITY
musicians often slaves
Aristotle, Politics:
music = essential part of education (moral improvement)
professional performers (payment) = vulgar
MIDDLE AGES
Boethius
ca 480 ca 524
De institutione musica
division into three types:
musica mundana
musica humana
musica instrumentalis
music as a science:
music = a science of numbers (part of the quadrivium)
true musician = philosopher (clerics!)
performers and composers (!) driven by instinct
Lay musicians
Jongleurs (jugglers):
perform tricks, tell stories, sing or play instruments
itinerant
precarious living
low status
Minstrels:
more specialized musicians (from 13th century on)
itinerant
often employed at court or city
varied backgrounds (former clerics, sons of merchants and craftsmen, knights
Troubadours / Trouvres:
poet-composers in medieval France (12th 13th century)
supported by the many castles and courts all over the country
Claudio Monteverdi
1567-1643
music director at the court of Mantua:
1607: Orfeo
1612: Vincenzo Francesco Gonzaga
abrupt dismissal
1613 maestro di capella in Venice, St Marks Basilica
1620
Mantuans try to recover him
Monteverdi refuses and makes his point in a famous letter:
income, regularly paid out
permanent appointment (security)
control over his musicians and singers
respect
Prussia
Frederick the Great (1740-1786)
Gertrude Elizabeth Mara (1749-1833):
1774: London offer
1780: illness
weight of slavery
O Libert!
Russia
society:
tsarist autocracy
magnates
serfdom
serf = unfree person, bound to the land
musicians:
serf troupes maintained by magnates
position often complicated and ambiguous:
o relatively well-paid
o emancipation
o corporal punishment
Sheremetev family:
> 8,000 km of land
compare Belgium: 30,528 km
200,000 registered serfs (approx. one million in real terms)
Saint Petersburg palace (Fountain House)
(> 300 servants)
splendid theatre buildings in the summer houses (French opera!):
o Kuskovo Palace (east of Moscow)
burns down in 1789
o Ostankino Palace (north of Moscow)
opens in 1795
room for 260 spectators
Conclusion
Blanning, p. 15:
the subservient status of even the greatest singers and composers was the rule in courts
large and small.
Further illustrations
10
Farewell Symphony
symphony no 45 in F sharp Minor (1772)
context:
Esterhza summer palace
Versailles of Hungary
opera house (500 spectators)
in the middle of nowhere
musicians living there without their families
closing adagio: musicians one by one snuffing their candle and leaving the room
return to Eisenstadt
Haydn revolutionary:
good-natured, easy-going (Papa Haydn)
grown up and socialized in the society of the Ancien Rgime
(masters and servants)
Haydns greatest frustration
= isolation / restrictions on his freedom of movement:
frustration grows as time goes on
examples of self-pity (1790):
Esterhaza = my wilderness
It really is sad to be a slave, but Providence wills it so.
11
12
elements:
expansion of towns / promotion of urban values
rise of consumerism / commercialisation of leisure
proliferation of voluntary associations (reading clubs, choral societies, masonic lodges,)
improvement of communications and postal services
result = a new kind of cultural space into which musical entrepreneurs eagerly moved
Blanning, p. 24
In short, by the time Haydn really did reach London on New Years Day, 1791, the musical
public was ready and waiting.
13
A NEW HANDEL?
Haydn Handel
London musical public willingness to embrace German-speaking musicians
musical entrepreneur
paying public
wealth + social status
14
15
HAYDN IN LONDON
17911792 / 1794-1795
warm welcome:
newspapers
invitations for dinner
financially rewarding:
6,000 guilder in 6 months
net profit: c. 15,000 guilder
compare annual salary at Esterhzy court: 1,000 to 1,200 guilder
Hanover Square Rooms:
1775
first purpose-built concert hall in London
private enterprise
Sir John Gallini (1728-1805)
Swiss-Italian dancing-master
mover and doer
Johann Christian Bach / Carl Friedrich Abel
subscription concerts
SACRALISATION
music:
functional valued for its own sake
religion art
sacralisation of music
concert hall church building:
audience seated as if it were a congregation
orchestra in a chancel-like space:
o platform fenced off by a rail
o organ taking the place of the altar
16
COMMERCIALISATION
commercialisation impact on the content of an art form
PUBLIC RECOGNITION
Oxford:
honorary doctorate, 7 July 1791
on the proposal of Charles Burney (1726-1814)
Sheldonian Theatre (Christopher Wren)
Symphony no. 92 in G (Oxford) (1789)
emblematic of his emergence as a celebrity
17
Blanning, p. 29:
At the beginning of his career, Haydn became famous because he was the Kapellmeister for
the Esterhzys; by the time he died, the Esterhzys were famous because their Kapellmeister
was Haydn.
18
Biography:
1756-1773: childhood / travelling as child prodigy
1773-1781: employment at the Salzburg court
1781-1791: freelance composer-performer in Vienna
SALZBURG PERIOD
Salzburg
Court of archbishop Hieronymous Count von Colloredo
relation patron-servant bad luck
Colloredo = narrow-minded and unappreciative
chain of humiliations
e.g. eating with the valets and cooks
Mozarts revolt
Mozart Haydn:
generation younger
extensive travelling as a child prodigy
encouraged in social aspirations by his ambitious father Leopold
lively temperament
June 1781 Count Arcos notorious kick on the arse
servant freelance composer and performer
revolutionary step:
socially:
personally:
19
VIENNA
4 sources of income:
commissions for new works
ticket sales from concerts as a pianist
royalties from publishers
music lessons
1787: appointment as imperial chamber composer (800 guilders annually)
Mozart, gifted and energetic, lives well in Vienna:
comfortable accommodations
horse and carriage
wardrobe of an aristocrat
Major flaw in his condition
dependency on the (high) nobility:
private concerts in their palaces
main presence at public concerts:
o Academies
o subscription concerts
noble connoisseurs:
exceptionally high level of musical education
receptive to innovative music of high quality
Countess Thun
Count Cobenzl
Prince Galitzin
Archduke Maximilian Franz (brother of Joseph II)
20
late 1780s
Mozart confronts financial problems:
moves 4 times in 18 months
loans from friends
explaining elements:
1786:
1788:
1787-1790:
Le Nozze di Figaro
illness Constanze
war with the Turks:
exodus of noble army officers
contraction of cultural life in Vienna
Europe-wide economic recession
from 1790 on
recovery
1791: La Clemenza di Tito / Die Zauberflte
international reputation
invitations from London to St. Petersburg
1791: Mozart dies of rheumatic fever
Caution!
Mozarts alleged poverty and falling into oblivion
to a large extent the product of romantic imagination
creation of a legend
financial problems = shortage of liquid assets (short term)
recovery had started
achievement recognised in public and private
memory venerated
21
STATUS
1809 Beethoven gets an attractive offer from Jerome, king of Westphalia (Kassel)
3 aristocrats coalesce to keep Beethoven in Vienna
lifelong annual income of 4,000 guilder
prince Lobkowitz
prince Kinsky
archduke Rudolph (brother Francis I)
Observations:
Beethoven clearly recognised as a man of genius
relation more akin to friendship than patronage
Beethoven only wants to be treated on equal terms
dedications as friend, not as supplicant
e.g. archduke Rudolph (piano concerto no 5, Archduke trio, Missa Solemnis)
Beethoven thinking of himself as being the son of Frederick II
22
Beethoven 1827
Beethoven 1827:
sense and awareness of an historical moment:
autopsy
locks of hair
drawing and death mask by Josef Danhauser (1805-1845)
last words: Pity, pity too late!
(Schade, schade, zu spt)
funeral: grand and formal event:
formal invitations
school holiday declared by the authorities
funeral procession:
o 36 torch bearers (Schubert)
o 10,000 30,000 onlookers
Whring cemetery:
o oration written by dramatist Franz Grillparzer
o only deity recognised = music per se
Beethoven as its high priest
sacralisation of music
23
developments
noble connoisseurs (Lichnowsky, Lobkowitz) subject to substantial financial pressures:
o wars 1787-1815
o dissolution of their musical establishments
growth of population
emerging public sphere (middle classes)
larger musical public
cultural participation as social pressure
keeping up appearances
public concerts
impresarios
profit
Blanning p. 44
These paying audiences were given what they wanted, and that was easy listening in the
form of plenty of variety, good tunes, regular rhythms and pieces that were not too long or
demanding.
pot-pourris
popular overtures, operatic arias, dance tunes
at best a single movement of a symphony or concerto
Haydn/Mozart/Beethoven Italians
complex music simple enjoyment
complaint of vulgarisation
Beethoven: It is said vox populi, vox dei- I never believed it
24
Stendhal (1783-1842)
Vie de Rossini (1824)
Light, lively, amusing, never wearisome, but seldom exalted Rossini would appear to have
brought into this world for the express purpose of conjuring up visions of ecstatic delight in
the commonplace soul of the Average Man
stupendous success
popular adulation
middle classes
in Italy even popular among layers of the working class
public sphere has come of age
musician enters spheres previously reserved for kings and generals
Stendhal:
Napoleon is dead; but a new conqueror has already shown himself to the world; and from
Moscow to Naples, from London to Vienna, from Paris to Calcutta, his name is constantly on
every tongue. The fame of this hero knows no bounds save those of civilisation itself; and he
is not yet thirty-two! The task which I have set myself is to trace the paths and circumstances
which have carried him at so early an age to such a throne of glory.
25
26