Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
com
ScienceDirect
Acta Materialia 78 (2014) 113
www.elsevier.com/locate/actamat
Received 31 March 2014; received in revised form 10 June 2014; accepted 11 June 2014
Available online 10 July 2014
Abstract
In situ neutron diraction of two binary Mg alloys, Mg0.5 wt.% Y and Mg2.2 wt.% Y have been carried out in compression. The
experimental data has been modelled using the elastoplastic self-consistent methodology in order to determine the critical resolved shear
stress for basal slip, second-order hc + ai pyramidal slip and f1 0
1 2g twinning. It was found that the addition of Y strengthens all three
of the deformation modes examined. However, increasing the Y concentration from 0.5% to 2.2% showed no additional hardening in the
basal slip and f1 0 1 2g twinning modes, indicating that solute strengthening of these deformation modes is already exhausted by a concentration of 0.5% Y. Second-order pyramidal slip showed additional solute hardening at the higher concentration.
Crown Copyright 2014 Published by Elsevier Ltd. on behalf of Acta Materialia Inc. All rights reserved.
1. Introduction
Magnesium and its alloys exhibit a strong anisotropy in
mechanical behaviour. This is evident both in the singlecrystal case [13] and in wrought products that have developed a strong crystallographic texture [4]. The essence of
the problem is the much higher critical resolved shear stress
(CRSS) of the non-basal slip systems compared to basal
slip and f1 0
1 2g twinning [1]. This eect is exacerbated
by the polarity of twinning, which can lead to severe yield
strength anisotropy in wrought products. A potential avenue for alleviating this problem is the addition of solute elements which can change the ratio of the CRSS for the
dierent slip and twin systems [2,3,57]. It has also been
found in single-crystal studies that certain alloying
Corresponding author.
http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.actamat.2014.06.023
1359-6454/Crown Copyright 2014 Published by Elsevier Ltd. on behalf of Acta Materialia Inc. All rights reserved.
Fig. 1. {0 0 0 2} Pole gures of the hot-rolled plates: (a) Mg0.5 wt.% Y; (b) Mg2.2 wt.% Y.
Fig. 3. (a) Engineering stressstrain curves for the IPC samples. The diracted intensity from selected grain orientations is shown in (b) and (c).
hkl
d hkl d hkl
o
;
d hkl
o
Fig. 4. Internal elastic lattice strain response for IPC tests for the 0.5 and 2.2 wt.% Y alloys. (a) Parent grains, where the {0 0 0 2} peak comes from the axial
detector and the f1 0
1 0g from the transverse bank. (b) Daughter (twinned) grains where the f1 0 1 0g peak comes from the axial detector and the {0 0 0 2}
from the transverse bank.
Fig. 5. (a) Engineering stressstrain curves for the TTC samples. The diracted intensity from selected grain orientations is shown in (b) and (c).
that these grains undergo early basal slip before the onset
of macroscopic yielding. This is consistent with previous
reports on other Mg alloys [2023]. For both alloys, the
behaviour of the f1 0
1 2g grains was very similar.
The behaviour of the twinned material is slightly more
complicated. The twinned material is oriented with the caxis in the axial (compressive) direction. This orientation
is known to be a hard orientation, not favourably oriented
for basal or prismatic slip. The internal strain measurements indicate that these orientations continue to increase
in compressive strain as the stress increases (see Fig. 4), and
this behaviour was exhibited by both of the alloys. The
grains oriented with f1 0
1 0g in the transverse direction,
which are a subset of those with {0 0 0 2} in the axial
direction, showed quite dierent behaviour between the
two alloys. The weaker alloy showed linear elastic behaviour up until a stress of 200 MPa, and after this point
the grains began to bear more strain per unit of applied
Fig. 6. Internal strain data for the TTC samples. The macroscopic yield point is indicated by the grey horizontal dashed line. Macroscopic elastic
behaviour is indicated by the black dashed line, and corresponds closely to the Youngs modulus. Blue lines are visual guides, and indicate microyielding.
(For interpretation of the references to colour in this gure legend, the reader is referred to the web version of this article.)
Fig. 7. (a) Engineering stressstrain curves for the 45IC samples. The diracted intensity from selected grain orientations is shown in (b) and (c).
Fig. 8. EBSD of 45IC samples: (a) Euler map where lenticular regions are twins; (b) misorientation histogram for map and rotation axis inverse pole gure
showing the f1 0
1 2g tensile twin is present.
grain set, and it will be shown below that the same was
observed in the other two test orientations.
3.2. Through-thickness compression (TTC)
The orientation of the TTC samples results in compression in the normal direction of the rolled sheet. In this orientation, many of the grains have c-axes in the compression
direction, but it should be remembered that there is a signicant dierence in the texture between the two alloys.
The stressstrain curves are shown in Fig. 5a, and it is
apparent that the higher concentration alloy has a signicantly higher yield strength and also exhibits higher ductility. The intensity data indicates that there was negligible
f1 0
1 2g twinning in either alloy (Fig. 5b and c).
Looking now to the internal strain measurements, we
note rstly that the data is signicantly dierent between
Fig. 9. Internal strain data for the 45IC samples. The macroscopic yield point is indicated by the dashed line. Macroscopic elastic behaviour is indicated
by the black dashed line, and corresponds closely to the Youngs modulus. Grey lines to guide the eye, and indicate microyielding.
is initiated in the soft grains, the grains in hard orientations carry more internal strain.
1 2g grains, well oriented for basal slip, show
The f1 0
the development of compressive strains in the transverse
direction, despite the fact that macroscopically the strains
in the transverse direction should be tensile (Fig. 6b and d).
Fig. 11. Summary of the microstrain data for both alloys and all three
compression directions for those grains oriented with {0 0 0 2} planes in the
axial direction.
Fig. 10. (a) Summary of the microstrain data for both alloys and all three compression directions for those grains oriented with f1 0 1 2g grains in the axial
direction, which are best oriented for basal slip. (b) Summary of the IPC and 45IC microstrain data for both alloys. Graph shows microstrain data for
grains with {0 0 0 2} in the axial direction, which are best oriented for pyramidal hc + ai slip.
10
(e.g. Fig. 10). Hence, the rst conclusion from the in situ
results is that basal slip (Fig. 10) and twinning (Fig. 3)
are remarkably similar in both alloys.
In order to extract from the data sets an accurate assessment of the CRSS for the basal slip mode, the data from
the axial microstrain has been collated for the three dierent compression orientations and for both alloys (Fig. 10).
It can be seen that there is good consistency across all of
the diraction data, and that the microyielding occurs at
an internal strain of 1450 le. This corresponds to an
applied stress of 65 MPa in the axial direction. As a result
of the similarity between data sets shown in Fig. 10a, the
CRSS for basal slip was assumed to be the same for both
alloys during the EPSC tting procedure.
Also shown in Fig. 10 is a similar plot for those grains
with the basal plane in the axial direction. These grains
have a hard orientation, being poorly aligned for the soft
modes of basal slip or twinning. These grains are likely
to deform by hc + ai slip. Upon straining, these grains ini-
Fig. 12. EPSC simulation results for the two alloys compressed in the orientations indicated. Individual data points represent experimentally measured
values, solid lines represent EPSC simulation.
from linear elastic behaviour is of the order of 800 le corresponding to an applied stress of 36 MPa in the axial
direction.
The remaining deformation mode to consider is the
f1 0
1 2g twinning mode. We can see from Fig. 3 that the
onset of twinning is similar for the two alloys, and the internal strain development of the set of grains best orientated
for twinning, those with f1 0
1 0g in the axial direction, is
also the same for both alloys (Fig. 4). Twinning commences
in both alloys at an applied stress of 150 MPa, and this
corresponds to an internal strain of 3300 le. As a result of
the similarity between the twinning onset in both alloys,
the CRSS for twinning was assumed to be the same for both
alloys during the EPSC tting procedure.
Finally, the last deformation mode to be considered is
the prismatic slip system. Unfortunately in this experiment
11
Fig. 13. EPSC simulation results for the two alloys deformed in the IPC orientation, which has the best alignment for twinning. Individual data points in
(a) and (b) are experimentally measured values, solid lines represent EPSC simulation.
12
Table 1
EPSC simulation parameters used in the present simulations (all shear
stress values are in MPa).
s0
s1
h0
h1
LH
Twin fraction
0.5% Y
Basal slip
Twinning
hc + ai slip
Prismatic slip
17
95
120
105
10
0
10
10
10
0
10
10
0
0
0
0
1
1
1
1
0.06
2% Y
Basal slip
Twinning
hc + ai slip
Prismatic slip
17
95
170
120
10
0
10
10
10
0
10
10
0
0
0
0
1
1
1
1
0.045
5. Discussion
5.1. The eect of Y on solute hardening
One of the most interesting ndings of this study was
that the basal slip system is not particularly aected by
increasing the Y concentration from 0.5% to 2.2%. This
is somewhat unusual because most other alloying elements
have been shown in single-crystal studies to harden the
basal slip system [2]. This suggests that hardening of the
basal slip system through alloying with Y is very quickly
Table 2
Summary of the CRSS values for the dierent deformation modes in Mg and AZ31. Values taken from literature data [6,8].
Alloy
Method
Reference
Basal
Prismatic
Twin
hc + ai
AZ31
Pure Mg
VPSC
Experimental only
[6]
[8]
7.2
8
64.5
38
Not measured
14
81.5
Not measured
13