Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
KEY WORDS
ABSTRACT
Calcanei and tali of 100 skeletons in the Hamann-Todd Collection at the Cleveland Museum of Natural History were measured. The
skeletons represented 50 males and 50 females distributed equally by race,
i.e., whites and blacks. Linear-regression equations, with standard errors
ranging from 4.09 to 6.11 cm, were derived from these measurements for the
purpose of estimating stature. Two independent control samples, including
one comprised of remains of American servicemen lost in World War I1 and
the Korea and Vietnam wars, were tested with relatively accurate results.
0 1995Wiley-Liss, Inc.
A variety of mathematical techniques for several reasons. First, Steele (1976) has
have been developed to estimate living stat- already demonstrated the value of the calcaure from skeletal remains. Probably the neus and talus in assessing sex, thus premost widely used technique in the United senting the potential to determine both sex
States is that devised by Trotter and Gleser and stature from the same elements. Secin a series of articles in the 1950s (1951, ond, the calcaneus and talus preserve rela1952, 1958; also Trotter, 1970). A similar tively well (e.g., Pickering, 1986). Finally,
technique developed by Genoves (1967) is the required measurements taken from the
not uncommonly applied to Native North calcaneus and talus are relatively easy to
obtain and replicate.
American archaeological samples.
As effective as these technique are, howMATERIALS AND METHODS
ever, they suffer from a limited applicability
A total of 119 calcaneuskalus pairs and
to fragmented remains since they require
intact long bones. Unfortunately, both ar- one unpaired calcaneus from the Hamannchaeological specimens as well as those of Todd Collection at the Cleveland Museum of
forensic interest commonly are recovered Natural History were measured. The elewithout intact or even reparable long bones. ments represented 60 males and 60 females
In response, several authors have presented distributed equally by race (American
techniques for use in cases where intact limb whites and blacks). The individuals reprebones are not available. Some (e.g., Holland, sented ranged in age a t death from 16 to 81
1992; Steele, 1970; Steele and McKern, years. No element with obvious or suspected
1969; Simmons et al., 1990) have focused on pathology that might have adversely affragmented long limb bones, while others fected the results was used.
The Hamann-Todd specimens were di(e.g., Byers et al.,1989; Meadows and Jantz,
1992; Musgrave and Harneja, 1978) have vided into two samples. Sample 1 consisted
opted for methods employing alternative el- of 100 calcaneudtalus pairs representing 50
ements such as metacarpals and metatar- males and 50 females distributed equally by
race. This sample was used to formulate the
sals.
The technique presented in this paper
was devised for use with the calcaneus
Received April 8,1994; accepted September 20,1994.
and/or talus. These elements were selected
0 1995 WILEY-LISS, INC.
316
T. D. HOLLAND
TABLE 1. Sample-1 statistics
Measurement
Race
Sex
Number
Mean
Standard
deviation
White
White
Black
Black
White
White
Black
Black
White
White
Black
Black
Male
Female
Male
Female
Male
Female
Male
Female
Male
Female
Male
Female
25
25
25
25
25
25
25
25
25
25
25
25
81.66
75.38
82.84
75.86
58.64
53.50
60.46
53.09
61.44
56.02
61.96
53.67
4.87
4.15
4.95
4.48
3.58
3.07
2.81
3.56
2.63
2.91
3.59
3.09
MCAL
PCAL
MTAL
regression equations used to estimate stature. The second sample (Sample 2) represented 20 individuals distributed equally by
race and sex and consisted of 19 calcaneusl
talus pairs and one unpaired calcaneus. The
purpose of Sample 2 was to serve as a control group to better gauge the accuracy of the
equations derived from Sample 1.
Statures for the individuals represented
by the Sample 1 and Sample 2 foot bones
were taken from the Hamann-Todd files
(see Todd and Lindala, 1928, for information
on how statures were recorded for this collection) and represent stature a t the time of
death. Previously, Dupertuis and Hadden
(1951) observed that the statures obtained
from the Hamann-Todd cadavers were
equivalent to living statures. Given the age
range of the specimens used, however, corrections for age-related stature changes
were made using the protocol outlined by
Giles (1991). Corrected statures range from
56.5-74.4 in. for Sample 1 and 59.2-73.2 in.
for Sample 2.
A second control sample (Sample 3) consists of 9 calcanei and 10 tali representing
10 American servicemen (mostly aircraft
crews) lost during World War I1 (n = 2), the
Vietnam War ( n = 6), and the Korean War
(n = 5) and subsequently identified at the
United States Army Central Identification
Laboratory, Hawaii (CILHI). Statures for
these individuals were taken from antemortem medical records on file at CILHI and
range from 66.0 to 73.5 in. (in cases where
two or more statures were recorded for the
same individual, either the mean or the
modal value was used). The ages at death for
317
Fig. 1. Measurements of the calcaneus and talus utilized in this study. For discussionsee text.
318
T. D. HOLLAND
TABLE 2. Eauations for estimatinp stature (in em) from the calcaneus and talus
Rniiation
Standard
error ( k 1
Sample-2l
Accuracy %
1SE
2SE
1.003(PCAL) + 112.42
0.674(MCAL) + 116.24
Sample-3'
Accuracy %
1SE
2SE
100
100
100
100
100
100
100
100
100
100
100
100
100
100
100
100
86
80
86
100
100
100
83
67
83
80
100
100
100
100
100
100
100
100
100
100
100
75
91
63
86
71
100
100
100
100
100
100
'Percentage of applicable Sample-2 individuals whose estimated stature falls within one standard error USE) and two standard errors (2SE).
Percentage of applicable Sample-3 individuals whose estimated stature falls within one standard error (1SE)and two standard errors (2SE).
319
320
T. D. HOLLAND