Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
Functionality
Function
EBS
E1
Replaces
Demand
Planning
(1:1
migration)
Replaces Demand
Forecasting and
Demand Consensus
(Net-Net migration)
New
Replaces Advanced
Forecast Modeling
(Net-Net migration)
Option:Oracle Demantra
Real-time Sales and
Operations Planning
New
New
New
New
New
New
Demand Management
Siebel
New
New
New
CRM
Demand Planning
Supply Planning
Strategic Network Optimization
Inventory Optimization
Adv. Supply Chain Planning
Sales
and
Operations
Planning
Sales
Marketing
Finance
Financial Planning and Budgeting
SRM
Supplier Contracts
SCM
Oracle Demantra
Product
EBS
JDE Enterprise1
Siebel
Peoplesoft
Enterprise
Demand Management
R11i10, R12
R8.12, R8.11SP1,
R9.0
TBD
Advanced Forecasting
and Demand Modeling
TBD
R12 (Other
versions TBD)
TBD
TBD
R7.8 (Other
versions TBD)
Deduction and
Settlement Management
TBD
R7.8 (Other
versions TBD)
CRM
Trade Promotion
Optimization
Roadmap
Demand Management*
Sales and Operations Planning
Trade Promotion Management
Maintain momentum;
Deliver next generation
functionality based on combined IP
Lower TCO;
Simplify technology infrastructure
EBS
Consensus forecast,
Demand priorities,
ASCP
Demantra
Contracts
(Inventory,
Shipping, Order
Management, Pricing, etc.
Demand
variability
Inventory Optimization
Integrated Demand
Management
EBS 11i10 and JDE E1
8.12
Pre-configured DM
Model
Pre-configured
worksheets
Integrated user
experience and lower
TCO for all six
Demantra products
* Many business objects are not available in JDE- E1 and will be empty. Category codes for product and organizations (branches)
will be seeded that can be to mapped to the JDE-E1 during implementation as needed. See R 7.1.1 TOI presentations for details.
Product Functionality
Demand Management
Key functional advantages statistical forecasting
Demantra DM
EBS DP
E1-Numetrix DF/DC
Supported
Supported
Supported, versioning
and historical accuracy
report are not automated
Supported
No support
No support
Supported
* Requires customization for forecasting at lower than daily buckets. ** Requires to create series to display outliers.
*** Requires initial one-time setup of forecasting tree and configuration of engine parameters.
Demand Management
Key functional advantages statistical forecasting
Demantra DM
EBS DP
E1-Numetrix DF/DC
Only Crostons
Supported
Supported
Only uni-variate
regression models, no
support for ARMA
Causal forecasting
No support
Demand Management
Key functional advantages collaborative demand planning
Demantra DM
EBS DP
E1-Numetrix DF/DC
Limited support
Supported
Limited support
Supported
Supported
Supported
No support
UOM conversion
supported, but display in
only one UOM/currency
Supported
No audit trail
No audit trail
No support
No support
Demand Management
Key functional advantages multi-dimensional analysis
Demantra DM
Worksheets
EBS DP
E1-Numetrix DF/DC
No concept of named
worksheets. No support
for context sensitivity,
multi-view, embedding, or
edit-lock expression logic
Supported
Supported
Limited scalability
Limited scalability
Limited support
Supported
Supported
3 dimensions unlimited
hierarchies
* Requires to define/load prices for every combination; no precedence or prioritization logic available.
Demand Management
Key functional advantages Miscellaneous
Demantra DM
EBS DP
E1-Numetrix DF/DC
Supported
Supported
Supported
No support
Supported
Supported
Supported
Up-sell, Cross-sell,
substitution support
No support
Integrated to EBS
Integrated to E1
No support
No support
Demand Management
Key functional wish list
Demantra DM
EBS DP
E1-Numetrix DF/DC
No support
Dynamic drilldowns
across multiple levels
within a hierarchy inside a
worksheet
Supported
No support
Intelligent rounding
No support
No support
No support
Demand Management
Key functional wish list
Demantra DM
EBS DP
E1-Numetrix DF/DC
No pre-seeded reports.
Adhoc and exception
reports supported
Automated mapping of
manufacturing
weeks/periods to
months/quarters
No support
Allocation floor
No support
No support
Per-dimension allocations
No support
Limited support
No support
No support
No support
Collaborative
Planning
Demand Management
Demand Collaboration
Yes
Customer VMI
Yes
No support
Supply Collaboration
Yes
No support
Supplier VMI
Yes
No support
Fixed baseline
Allocation based on baseline/lift proportion
y Nodal tuning
Future
Past
3000
3000
2500
2500
2000
1500
Actual
Cases
Cases
2000
1000
500
500
Week 6
0
W eek 1
Week 11
Week
Net
lift
Gross
lift
Cannibalization
Forward buying
Pantry loading
1500
1000
0
Week 1
Future
Competitive switching
Category growth
Baseline
Baseline
Actual
W eek 6
W eek 11
W eek
AFDM
DM
DM
AFDM
Causal Forecasting
Forecasting models
9 forecasting models
within Bayesian
framework
No
Supported
Available in
DM
DM
DM
DM
DM
Holt (HOLT)
DM
DM
DM
Regression (REGR)
DM
AFDM
AFDM
AFDM
AFDM
Logistic (LOGISTIC)
AFDM
AFDM
y Fpos/Fsum functions to
Suitable for
Taking better replenishment decisions based on better understanding of
demand (not the mechanics of placing replenishment orders)
Direct retail replenishments of large number of SKU-locations for Media and
Entertainment and Consumer Goods companies
* Several pre-configured series and calculations and 3 worksheets based on demo data are provided for guidance. No out-of-box support
for execution of replenishment orders. Requires consulting effort to map to planning item attributes in EBS and to execute orders.
y Out-of-box worksheets
Automated re-synchronization
User approved conflict resolution
Any data can be extracted for offline review and update
y
y
y
y
y
y
y
y
Budgeted
Actual
Projected
PTP
DM
DM + AFDM
Yes
No
Yes
Yes
No
Yes
Yes
No
Yes
Yes
No
Yes
Yes
No
No
Account planning
Yes
No
No
Yes
No
No
No
No
PTP
DM
DM + AFDM
No
Yes
Yes
No
Yes
Yes
No
Yes
Yes
Multi-dimensional analysis
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
customers (usually retailers) who have run your promotions and now
need to reconcile payments
y Process payments
Q U E S T I O N S
A N S W E R S