Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
OF THE
Museui
II
the Whitney
Museum Independent
Front cover:
Installation views of the
Downtown
at
Art,
Back cover:
Scratch
made by
Scralcher,
1988
1989 Whitney
Museum
of American Art
New
York,
New York
10021
7 ^4
The Desire of the Museum
Introduction
CATSOU ROBERTS AND TIMOTHY LANDERS
1 he museum
and exhibition of
and
status as art
largely determines.
it
of art
Conceived
museum
is
devoted to the
objects
in the
whose value
It
developed
the eighteenth and early nineteenth centuries, along with parks and other
spaces for leisure, as part of the emergent public sphere. By providing access to
art objects for the cultural
assumed
But the
historically,
museum
it
does not
strictly
its
has
inception.
late
trialists,
museum
many
of the
whose values these museums often upheld and whose names they
museum
Finally,
museums
art
cum
M
Market
aD
ST*
"The Desire
intentions;
it
of the
and contradictory
This
is
own
its
it
museum. However,
museum?"
For
that
it
is
the plav
ol
ol
as a
ol
you
and the
These
art.
where
and
not entirely
"What do
where
museum-goer
also be asked,
that
as a site
desires.
is
it
and conscious
museum-goer must
the
stall all
desiring subject shifts the princ ipal focus of examination from the
to the
was
it
of this show,
title
special interests
interests,
the
desires, beliefs,
museum
culturally specific
and
curators, artists,
museum conceives
its
museum. But
essays
the
museum
mu.is
sented by
Marcel
artists.
Such
Duchamp and
a critical
his
museum
Duchamp
readymades.
an
Duchamp, focused
first
social,
is
located.
More
itself
(
l
.)7()s,
political
must he traced
meaning
and
recently, artists
museum, we hope
its
economic and
museum
is
in
to
museum
artists,
often influenced by
which
network
in
art
is
viewed, and
which the
museum
the
is
examination of the
to highlight
our role
in
also at-
Through
by Julia V),
docent instruction
atmosphere (with dramatic lighting and the proliferation of gallery sounds), and
spatial organization.
and
and
By
this intervention,
artistic
work
that has
in the
we mean
LAURIE SIMMONS,
Untitled
(Women Looking at
Art),
1984
&
4
MO
II
Y I.ANDl kS
museum
1 he
tion:
it
determines what
forms of knowledge,
"truth," "reality,"
depend on
is
is
normalizing
not;
it
institu-
allows particular
it
produces
its
collection,
tions
is
display,
is
ex-
and
fetishism. In the
museum,
in
museum depends on
itself
of
this exhibition
Aimee
ability to
its
vision, subject
at this site
of
in
It
is
can be located.
scrutinizes
even as
it
in
which
tfie
cannot be taken for granted (we must look into the box, squint our
this
work both
solicits
and
our gaze. The process thus plays upon the voyeurism of the viewer
1987),
and
is
now
states gives
from the
The
threatened.
viewer
The
scientific
museum.
is
two
box Fear
of these
is
does not prepare us for the lush, textured, curio-cabinet interior that offers a
museum
culture.
V (1989)
level,
art
the narrative
this case
an
spaces, to police
the
borders, to protect
its
at the
its
work,
museum to monitor
museum-goer and
this
installation of security
and displacing
some are
gallery;
museum and
mapping
Museum
is
of American Art,
Museum
Downtown
at
bench, nine display cases with silkscreened images, and catalogues in a wall
display. All these
seum
galleries.
This ordering
in
onto new, unfamiliar terrain by substituting the logic of museum display for the
logic of the installation, revealing both as
edge only once certain precepts have been given. The catalogue
installation
the
ing,
On
Kolbowskis
paper.
in
this tracing
and other
paper are
texts omitted
Kolbowskis own
text, subjective
and question-
American
history of
dominant
museum
to
girl
taken
desire of the
The
titled
in
museum
class.
cultural production
and the
method
museum
denies in
its
prestigious,
women and
and
non-white
(K
artists"
is
i m
statistics
which
list
is
in recent exhibitions
ill
a matter of course
is
men
sponsored by major
Like Kolbowski and the Guerrilla Girls, Andrea Fraser and Louise Lawler
documentary of
The
Life of Art:
a docent's tour
Museum (1988-89)
It
of a
PBS
begins like
and
free
and
form
subjectivities" of the
takes the
to the public
into the
"split
,"
its
tape-re-
smiley-face disks
AIMEE rankin, De
museum
in
Tourism: Parthenon
and Tourism:
Eiffel Tower,
famous
the
The way
general
in
me
history.
borders.
its
rely
on consumption
change your
Til
is
The maniacal
life).
acknowledges
placelike a
museum: on
commodity
to
text, points to a
"change your
as transcendental, able to
art as a material
toy.
Where does
economy
Untitled (Buy
and
in
of stock photos of
in front
museum
it
life";
clings to the
on the other,
in the
it
market-
museum's self-image as an
its
institution aloof
from the
actual behavior.
/according
to
ates in
all
He
forms of
civilized behavior,
it is
most
it
and argued
that,
socially
though
valued
it
oper-
satisfies
museum, inasmuch
contemplative mind
in
as
it
and
The
site
of
sublimation.
In modernist art, this desexualization of the viewer
is
primarily effected
is
art, a
"pure"
mode
contemplation. This
vision.
purpose
to serve the
Mondrian
Piet
to
vision
is
of vision:
it
is
the temple
institution
become
forced to
touch" and
this
on perception. Recent
desires
that vision
oi vision
it
is
to
desire
art
disembodied
oi
corporeal and
is
sexuality. In el led,
bound up with
oneself seeing.
of the
berized hair,
ers,
museum. Artschwager's
set in
museums
filled petti
visibility.
Lamer
of (he
desire to be a clean,
Museum
well-lit
place of neutral
pun on
the double
brilliant
meaning of "culture,"
fade during the course of the exhibition). These infusions reflect the desires of
the curators to address issues such as
nationalism, paternity
psychic ramifications of
machine
loss.
Another Larner
museums
walls.
practice,
and the
Moved
to a
new
is
it
produces more and more gashes, eventually leaving a scarred ring around the
gallery. Larner's clinically precise
controlled climate,
tion of dirt
and
decay, desire
its
Aimee Rankin's dioramic boxes not only stress the carnal aspect of
also
in the
museum. One
They contain
plugging
in
historical
disembodied
eyes, all
arranged
to
vision, but
walls,
interior tableaux.
tissues,
art
and
ALLAN McCOLLUM,
Plaster Surrogates,
1982-89
yj
flfl
movement connect
the body and the box in a way that denies any "pure" vision or
body and
unconscious desires;
its
it
monochrome
of almost identical
frame, the mat, and the "picture" painted on the plaster. They metaphorically
to a
viewer
nothing
single but
"see" no original
to
no unique work, nothing "pure" about the work or the visual form. The
caught
is
is
The
in
ol
looking for
distinctive features for contemplation, but the sheer proliferation of the surro-
gates
makes us
all
As
depend on museological,
and
in relation to
all art
the
objects, the
it.
meaning only
McCollum
suggest that
it
is
and
its
own
presuppositions,
its
own
museums
sublimated
museum. Considered
museum
way
to begin to
as a
under-
Any
sire
of the
critical
museum
of the
of Marcel
museum
Duchamp
as
to those of
Joseph Kosuth, Louise Lawler, Ashley Bickerton, Peter Nagy, Mark Dion, and
Jason Simon.
Two
objectives of the
museum
10
I
need
critiques: the
work
of
art
to
museum
effectively disappears as
it
an entity
in
its
own
right to
of art
enters a
become
part of
investigated by
first
Duchamp; indeed,
in a Valise)
is
paradigmatic. As a
(first
comprehensive mini-collection. In
museum. As
aesthetic.
art.
museum.
meaning of art
established by
is
as
a repository of documents,
role of curator,
its
as
provoked
nomic, and
artists
political
Duchamp, began
in the
museum.
commercial
interests
opened up
enmeshed. In
this way, a
status of
its
Haacke brings
wider
18881975
(1975),
Haacke provides
traces the
and economic
constitute the
it,
This, in
social, eco-
that the
United States
social
an
mocks the
it
Duchamp demonstrates
with text
as
institutional context.
occurs in
doubles
often influenced by
artists,
it
art usually
As
effect,
in a Valise
traveling salesman
artist is a
in
his
successive owners
facts
about the
to light
The
and catalogue
artist's
work of art
entries.
commercial
as a creation untainted by
Haacke
Kosuth
is
is
and
as
commodity.
interested in
how patronage
affects the
work of
11
art,
its
Joseph
meaning.
-S*
comment on
and
texts contain
matching
its
.tie
institutional settings.
that
The images
and suggest
a specific
to think
photograph of
areas)
is
museum
setting
(i.e,
an installation shot or
labels, a color
a view of storage
Midnight (1986), for instance, the word "midnight" refers to the viewing condition
of the photographed artwork
(1986), the
word
(a
room
in
at night),
while in Green
sculptures are being stored. In this way, Lawler focuses our attention on the
work's surroundings on
INTERESTING
its
itself.
With
at
every local cash machine, Lawler poses an analogy between cultural and financial
institutions.
S^vV
to the
punning
rT
tr
Jug
MARCEL DUCHAMP,
From
(The Box
1960
in a Valise), c.
or by
Marcel Duchamp or
12
Rro.se Selavy
associations be-
M[N
interest,
it
also alludes to a
broader
in turn,
of the art market. His wall constructions are assembled from industrially fabricated parts, with electronic
and painted
#5
signs,
markings such
topicality with
Confirming
financial value.
as
commodity
Peter
own updated
is
#5
its
directly links
value.
issue of the
museum
as a
white photocopy of
the collection
is
Electric,
IBM, General
this relationship,
museum and
Nagy
reveals an aspect of
fate of the
as a clinical technician
To accompany the
cut
up
to
deemed
work of
(1988),
art in a
retrieved
A Restoration Comedy
restorer
film,
from a restoration
studio.
produce smaller works when the expense of restoring the originals was
exorbitant.
Between the
film
and the
the
and
museum
immune
The
to
implication
hidden
These varied
notion of the
work of art
is
desires.
critical
approaches
museum as an
of the viewer.
is
altruistic institution
musem and
13
complicate
its
objectives.
En
Works
All
in
the Exhibition
in inches; height
dimensions are
Mixed-media
dimensions variable
Collet lion
RICHARD ARTSCHWAGER(b.
Blps,
1923)
the artist
<>l
MARCEL DL CHAMP
(1887-1968)
1989
From
or by
Marcel Duchamp
(The Box in a
Valise), c.
x60x
Rune
Selavy
opened
\7Vi
Collection of Timothy
or
I960
Baum and
Roland Augustine
(b.
1959)
ANDREA ERASER
(b.
1965)
Amuse(um), 1989
Installation with seven
MARK DION
SIMON
(b.
(b.
1961)
and
JASON
1961)
Artful History:
aluminum
disks
and
Videotape transfer
of color film,
sound.
ANDREA ERASER
LAWLER
1917)
28 minutes
and
LOUISE
(b.
MARK DION
Collection of Terry
McCo)
GUERRILLA GIRLS
J.G.
altered painting by an
artist, c.
1825,
1987
Offset poster, 22 x 17
and
text,
25 x 15
Cntitled.
1988
Offset poster.
History Bunk, 1984
17x22
unidentified
Untitled.
Offset poster,
1989
1 1
x 28
altered painting
and
Untitled.
24 X 18
1989
Offset poster,
17x22
14
HANS HA ACRE
(b.
1936)
"Melancholia,
hair,
Gallery,
Enlarged from
"The United
cases,
1953)
JEWEL,
tears, a
dishes
artist;
courtesy 303
York
1947)
(b.
1982
1989
on paper, 4x13
Metro Pictures,
x 17 each;
bench, 18 x 60 x 16; wall display, 10 x 30
Postmasters Gallery, New York
display: display cases,
New
LOUISE LAWLER
(b.
Mixed-media
in agar-filled petri
Collection of the
Gallery.
SILVIA KOLBOWSKI
States of America,"
Utopia" (three
1989
New York
the Catalogue,
Mama.
wish),
Mixed media
1888-1975, 1975
Fourteen panels with text. 30x20 each,
and one color photograph, 23% x 27 V\
John Weber
and a
50 x
17
New York
STORAGE,
Museum
JOSEPH KOSUTH
(b.
type on paper, 4 x 13
1945)
Metro Pictures,
New York
84'A>x 119'/>
Slater
Leo
New York
Castelli Gallery,
Connecticut, 1984
Color photograph and transfer type
on paper, 4x13
Metro Pictures, New York
84 'A- X
The
I19'/t>
Arranged
by
Metro
BARBARA KRL'GER
I
'nlitled
(Buy me
I'll
(b.
1945)
change your
life),
Pictures,
New York
INTERESTING, 1985
(reinstalled 1989)
1984
Metro
Black-and-white photograph. 72 x 48
Private collection
Pictures,
New
York
Green, 1986
LIZ
LARNER
(b.
on paper, 4 x 13
Metro Pictures,
I960)
New York
Midnight, 1986
18'/l>
of the
Museum
Cultures: Timothy
and
blood):
and
Benjamin
museum
Weil,
floor
and
walls):
Marek
Wieczorek,
15
...
fcfH
ALLAN McCOLLUM
(b.
1982-89
Enamel on hydrostone, 96
1944)
Plaster Surrogates,
units,
Collage,
12x20
Whitney
Museum
New
(sight)
of American Art,
76.46
dimensions variable
John Weber Gallery,
New York
Portend
/ the Artist us
Yhung
Mandala, 1955
Collage, 2()!/ix 13M> (sight)
Whitney
PETER NAGY
(b.
Intellectual tin/on,
1959)
New
composite photocopy,
A1MEE RANKIN
De
Pictura,
ill
from the
(b.
Whitney
New York
New
Museum
York;
(.ilt ol
[ULIA SCHER
1958)
series
Security by Julia V,
Renaissance, 1983
of American Art,
Rita Reinhardt
76.48
1954)
(I).
1989
12
installation,
New York
76.45
11x8'/..
|ay
of American Art,
1984
Art
Blac k-and-white
Museum
dimensions variable
Pittura,
NYCO
Electronics, Security
20 x
Electronics (U.S.A)
12
(
Police
198384
Mixed-media assemblage, I6x20x
Collection of Catherine Holland
LAURIE SIMMONS
Renaissance,
(b.
1949)
12
Collection of the
Collection of the
Fear,
Metro
Pictures,
artist;
New
courtesy
York
Possession,
Metro
Pictures,
Untitled
artist;
courtesy
New York
(Women Looking
at Art).
Black-and-white photograph,
Sex,
AD REIN HARD
Museum
New
LAURIE SIMMON S
LEVINE (b. 1947)
Project jor the cover of
(1913-1967)
and S
HERR
"New
Observations," 1984
Landscape, 1950
Museum
10
8x10
Whitney
1984
8x
two
of American Art,
artist
8x
10,
one 10x8
Collection of Laurie
66. 14
Photograph
16
of
Simmons
Duchamp
by Nathan Rabin
Downtown
at
33 Maiden Lane
New
York,
at
Nassau Street
New York
10038
(212) 943-5657
Monday-Friday, 11:00-6:00
Free admission
GALLERY TALKS
Monday, Wednesday, Friday, 12:30
Tours by appointment
Branch Director
Susan Wilharm
Manager
Charles A. Wright,
Jr.
Gallery Coordinator
ART,
JULY 12-SEPTEMBER
12,
1989