Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
Cor r o si on Re v i e w
Remember, corrosion is defined as the deterioration of a material or its
properties as it reacts with the environment. Remember also, that the rate at
which corrosion attacks a material is directly proportional to the corrosivity of
the environment, to which the material is exposed, and is inversely proportional
to the corrosion resistance of the material being exposed.
Of course, the ideal solution is to prevent corrosion but corrosion can also be
managed. You can manage corrosion if you understand causes and effects and
implement effective decision-making.
The content of Course 201-C is directed at both of these conditions and addresses
corrosion mitigation.
Cor r o si on Ce l l Re v i e w
A corrosion cell, which consists of: an
anode, a cathode, an ionic current path in an
electrolyte, and an electronic path in a
conductor between the anode and cathode must
be present for corrosion to occur. As shown
in the corrosion cell animation, removing any
one of these 4 elements stops corrosion.
201CCh.1:
Ch.1:Introduction
Introductionto
toCorrosion
CorrosionControl
Control
201C
Section2:
2:Managers
ManagersRoles
Roles
Section
Cor r o si on M an ag e r s
Corrosion managers are decision makers at every management level who have a stake
in and responsibility for preventing and controlling the onset of corrosion,
mitigating the destructive effects of corrosion, assessing the impact of
corrosion technology alternatives and associated trade-offs, and implementing
effective management tools and controls to achieve corrosion prevention and
control objectives.
Cor r o si on D e ci si on P oi n t s
Corrosion managers need to: Understand the nature and impact of corrosion and
insist on and perform adequate planning for corrosion prevention and control.
Oversee or perform legitimate corrosion affordability acquisition and support trade-offs
between cost, performance and availability before committing to initial designs or
design changes,
processes.
materials
utilized,
manufacturing
methods,
or
maintenance
Cor r o si on D e si g n : P o or P l a n n i n g
This montage shows the result of poor design for both up-front corrosion
prevention and downstream corrosion maintenance on:
military ground vehicles, munitions in storage and inventory, and equipment in
harsh marine environments, etc.
Cor r o si on D e si g n : S y st e ms E n g i n e e r i n g
The most cost-effective design approach is to design corrosion resistance into a
system, a piece of equipment, or a facility.
Cor r o si on D e si g n : E c on o mi c s
Use economic analysis early in the design phase to support risk prevention and
mitigation approach as shown in these two diagrams.
Cor r o si on D e si g n : E n t i r e S y s t e m
Taking a systems approach to design for corrosion prevention and mitigation means
analyzing the corrosion risks within the entire system and examining the
interfaces between system components.
It is important to define how each component affects the potential for corrosion
in other components and to determine how electrochemical corrosion cells can form
and assess the potential impact of corrosion on the reliability, availability and
overall performance of the entire system.
Cor r o si on D e si g n : D e si g n S y st e m s
Some corrosion design shortfalls and pitfalls that might be experienced during
the design phase are explained here by two DoD subject matter experts.
Theres a lot of geometric features as well that you would like to design against
from a corrosion standpoint. You dont want things that are going to, you dont
want geometry features that are going to trap water or allow water to not drain
properly, because then if you have some sort of coatings defects then the
corrosion will start taking place and most of the time it's gonna be at a place
that you dont want it to occur: places that are hard to see, difficult to
inspect. From a design point, we want to make sure that we take care with the
small detailed geometric features. Those are the features that can keep water
from draining properly or moisture from draining and collecting in places that
are very difficult to see from visual inspection, which is the bulk of the
inspection procedures, and in the aircraft industry, for sure. So if we can guard
against that, essentially, not letting corrosion take a foothold like keeping the
environment out of the critical areas, thats a big step right there reducing it
completely. If you pick up from that, that says really when youre gonna go ahead
and start the design youre designing for life. So, part of the life cycle
considerations are not only: can you select materials?
can you bolt them together? Its how you gonna manage them for the lifetime so
there are some things where you're gonna have hidden and inaccessible areas and
youre gonna have to have them in that condition so part of that design is to
understand that youre not only picking the materials and youre picking their
performances in the environment but that youre also gonna consider how you're
gonna inspect those things that are hard to get to. So its not just whats the
geometry? how do they fit together? how do they react to the loads?
Cor r o si on D e si g n : D e si g n S y st e m s
If youre gonna design a system for corrosion control, one of probably the most
important things for a design engineer to do is kind of step back and recognize
that every decision that hes gonna make involves a number of trades and so it
requires the expertise of a number of folks with different backgrounds so you
probably need someone that understands materials, materials properties. Probably
one of the most helpful things Ive ever heard that would probably kick off a
design engineer, moving forward when youre talking about corrosion prevention
and control is to understand that a material its a dance with what you come
with so it brings all of its properties and all of its susceptibilities to the
design and you have to treat it holistically.
Cor r o si on D e si g n : D e si g n S y st e m s
Say one of the shortfalls or a pitfall that is very easy to fall into is to take
commercial experience and assume that its sufficient to cover military
experience so aircraft systems that are designed to work on a commercial
environment which is nowhere near the length of time that we're operating
military aircraft and assume that the data and some of the material selection
that would support that kind of application sufficient would be short of what we
have to have for military performance.
As we go and do maintenance again with these systems engineering approach, the
coatings that we put on the airplane are really the first line of defense. We try
to pick corrosion resistant materials as much as we can but when it comes to
coatings thats going to keep it, keep corrosion from occurring over these very
long life cycles that we had. Whoever would have thought that wed fly a KC-135
for 80 years. No one ever thought that and thats whats gonna happen. So the
coatings that were putting on there both initially and during maintenance, we
have to make sure that we take care of those so that we dont have degradation of
the coatings again not to let corrosion start. So, there are just new challenges
for the designer, keeping in mind that we have this very long life cycle now and
we have to think of the solution over the entire life cycle but if you take in an
integrated systems engineering approach where you have the materials people, the
designers, the structures, the maintainers - all cooperating and seeing how the
design evolves - this is definitely a solvable problem. Its within our means to
do it.
Cor r o si on D e si g n : C or r o si o n M a n ag e m e n t
As
has
been
discussed,
effective
corrosion management consists of defining
and understanding the corrosion risks and
making informed decisions regarding how
to prevent or mitigate those risks.
You define the material requirements by: reviewing the system design and
performance specifications, determining mission requirements in terms of how and
where the mission will be accomplished, and developing corrosion design
performance specs that define all system operating environments and specific
system operation, including functions to be performed, and required and expected
system lifetime.
process
design
are
closely
constrain the
and to which
combinations
of
materials
and
the
Aluminum alloys in non-chloride atmospheric conditions, and copper alloys in nonoxidizing environments.
On the other hand, its imperative that you avoid incompatible combinations of
materials and the environment. For example, stainless steel exposed to hot
chloride solutions is highly susceptible to corrosion.
High strength aluminum alloys exposed to marine
generate significant intergranular corrosion.
environments
are
likely
to
evaluate
methods
of
M ai n t e n an ce Co n t r ol : S h i p s an d S u b m ar i n e s
Ships and submarines are exposed to harsh marine environments, in which they may
be immersed periodically or for the life of the craft.
Decision-makers must consider the following when planning for ship and submarine
corrosion control: Extended periods of immersion in a highly conductive chloride
solution require selection of materials that endure such an environment and
specific methods to reduce corrosion effects, such as, impressed current cathodic
protection and sacrificial anodes.
Extended exposure of topside surfaces, internal areas, voids, and equipment to
the corrosive atmosphere require:
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
Tanks, which contain solutions that are inherently corrosive or can stimulate
microbial activity require:
1. Specific, long-life coatings selected for the environmental conditions
M ai n t e n an ce M an ag e me n t
When decision-makers consider corrosion maintenance strategies and requirements,
the ability to determine material condition, predict corrosion growth rates, and
determine required maintenance or repair actions depends on capabilities and
methods to monitor and inspect materials and then to interpret the results.
monitoring
methods
can
be
adversely
affected
by
Cor r o si on I n s p e c t i o n
There are a number of corrosion inspection methods. One of the most useful
inspection techniques is visual inspection.
Other methods include enhanced visual inspection using
magnification for observation in restricted areas like:
fiber
optics
Systems,
and
Mobile
Cor r o si on I n h i b i t or s
One of the primary strategies is the use of corrosion inhibitors. Inhibitors are
chemicals that are applied to the surface of a material to form a protective
film, increasing the resistance to corrosion.
For example additives in coatings, primers, sealants, surface treatments and
corrosion preventive compounds (CPCs).
Inhibitors need to be dispersed though out the operating environment to interact
with its elements and reduce its corrosivity.
For example, additives in recirculating systems such as automotive radiators,
water used to wash vehicles and equipment and boiler water to adjust pH and
remove oxygen.
Cor r o si on I n h i b i t or s T y p e s
There are several types of inhibitors that use different mechanisms to reduce the
incidence and effects of corrosion. Some include:
I n h i b i t or C om p ou n d s
This table lists some inhibitor compounds, designed to neutralize components of
the corrosion cell.
In general, the mechanisms of inhibition accomplish one or more of the following:
Remove moisture and, therefore, the electrolyte; isolate the material from the
potentially corrosive environment; and stem reactions at the cathode and/or
anode.
with
Cathodic Pr otecti on
This segment describes methods for adjusting the electrical potential at the
corrosion cell electrodes to assist in corrosion control.
Cathodic Protection is a widely used electrochemical method for protecting a
structure or materials buried or immersed in soil, water, or concrete.
The objective is to reduce corrosion of the buried or
fresh water or seawater. The engineering principle
cathodic current to flow onto the metal surface to
impressed current from electrical power supplies, or
with sacrificial anodes.
A rectifier converts the AC power to direct current (DC), and can also control DC
current flow. The buried steel structure is a tank or pipeline vulnerable to
corrosion.
A group of five or six impressed current anodes are composed of high silicon cast
iron, graphite, iron oxides or other similar materials, and the current passes
through the electrolyte in the soil to the structure.
The impressed current forces the entire tank or pipeline to be a cathode, and
therefore completes the circuit back to the rectifier via an electric cable
welded to the buried structure. The absence of anodes in the buried structure
eliminates the corrosion cell.
The anode and cathode must have electrical contact to complete an electrochemical
cell circuit that provides the desired protection. An electrolyte, such as
seawater, is also needed in the corrosion cell. The galvanic action between the
metals will cause a current to flow from the active metal anode, through the
electrolyte in the corrosive environment, to the nobler metal cathode, and back
to the anode. The reaction at the cathode prevents it from corroding. Anodes are
consumed by the galvanic action, hence the term sacrificial anodes.
They must be replaced periodically to maintain the cathodic protection, and they
cannot be coated because they will no longer be a component of the corrosion cell
formed to provide cathodic protection.
low
costs
for
small
system
Conversely, impressed current cathodic protection systems are more complex. They
require more inspection and maintenance, but low capital investment for large
systems. They have longer useful system life, but can cause unintended corrosion.
Re i n f or c e d Co n c r e t e S t e e l C or r o si on
Corrosion of steel in reinforced concrete can cause severe degradation of bridge
decks, parking garages and support columns, as shown in these photographs.
Steel rods are imbedded in concrete to strengthen the concrete. The steel rods
are normally passive under the mild alkaline condition few corrosion problems
occur in that environment.
If chloride ions from salt or marine environments permeate the concrete and reach
the steel surface, the passive film breaks down and the steel corrodes. The steel
corrosion products expand, taking up more volume than the corroded steel and
causing concrete cracking and spalling. Cathodic protection is one of the few
ways to mitigate further damage.
A n o d i c P r o t e ct i on T e ch n i qu e
Anodic protection techniques are only useful in limited conditions - the metal
being protected must have an accessible passive zone in which to apply anodic
currents. The objective is to shift the electrical potential of the metal surface
to the passive zone as shown on the pH diagram.
The schematic shows an example of the configuration
for anodic protection. The structure to be protected
is a steel tank filled with sulfuric acid. The power
supply is a potentiostat, which provides an electric
current to the auxiliary electrode. A reference
electrode is also attached to the power supply to
enable the potentiostat to regulate the current
level.
control
the
corrosive
environment
using
Types of Coatin gs
Barrier coatings shield the reactive metal from
moisture and corrosive agents.
Metalli c Coatin gs
Metallic coatings enhance corrosion resistance by providing a barrier between a
metal and its environment, or a sacrificial coating for more active metals.
Metallic coatings can be applied by: forming and bonding layers of cladding,
electroplating, spraying, hot dipping, diffusion, chemical vapor deposition, or
ion vapor deposition.
A l u mi n u m
Aluminum, which can be applied by hot dipping to protect metal from atmospheric corrosion
and oxidation at high temperatures. Spraying to provide uniform, impermeable
protection.
Ca d mi u m
Cadmium, which can be applied by several methods to protect steel in moist and
marine environments; provide a smooth, conductive coating that resists fretting
and fatigue.
Ch r o mi u m
Chromium provides a hard chromium oxide coating on the surface.
Note that certain types of chromium are environmentally incompatible and may be
restricted in their usage.
Tin
Tin is a coating that provides metal substrates with corrosion resistance either
barrier or sacrificial protection of steel and copper.
Organic Coatings
Organic coatings protect metal surfaces by providing an impermeable barrier
between the metal substrate being protected and the corrosive environment, and
provide sacrificial cathodic protection.
Types of organic coatings and their characteristics are shown in the table:
Paint a pigmented liquid, which converts to a solid, tough, adherent film after
application;
Oil paint contains oil or varnish to cause film formation as well as alkyd,
epoxy or vinyl resins for drying and durability;
Water paint uses a water to disperse the liquid emulsion; Enamel paint with a
very smooth surface film;
Varnish a clear combination of drying oil and resin that dries by oil oxidation
to form a solid translucent film;
Lacquer a combination of polymeric esters or ethers and plasticizers in a
solvent that dries by solvent evaporation to form a solid film;
Baking finish paint or varnish baked above 150 degrees Fahrenheit to obtain
desired properties.
They also repair areas where the primary coating has been damaged, and separate
galvanic couples when dissimilar metals are present. Common CPCs are shown here.
L i ni ng s a n d Cl ad d i n g s
Linings and claddings, which are usually thicker
described, are also used for corrosion protection.
than
the
coatings
already
They include rubber linings, glass linings, porcelain enamel, clad metals, and
concrete and cementatious coatings and linings.
corrosion
as
an
impermeable barrier, a coating stops
the
penetration
of
moisture,
eliminating the electrolyte in the
corrosion cell; prevents chlorides
and other aggressive chemicals from
getting
to
the
metal
surface;
increases
electrical
resistance
which
reduces
the
mobility
of
chemical ions.
Shrink-Wrappi ng
Methods for modifying the environment to reduce corrosion. Shrink-wrapping is
used to protect this USMC CH-46E "Sea Knight helicopter from atmospheric
contaminants, moisture, and therefore corrosion.
Shrink-wrapping is used during storage and transport of systems and equipment to
provide temporary protection from moisture and other weather-related factors.
This protection depends on clean, dry initial conditions achieved by pretreatment
of vulnerable material, and cleaning and drying prior to packaging.
Covers are also used to protect a variety of assets from harsh environments.
A lot of the corrosion challenges that we face here in Wheeler and on deployment
are the majority are the moisture accumulation that happens in the recessed areas
of the aircraft.
Mostly back in the F pores of the aircraft where your tail boom fitting
attachments are. A lot of the major issues come with the dust accumulation when
were on deployments along with weather - ambient moisture is there - which
creates more of a problem. The severity of the types of corrosion that you find
here is more severe due to the high salt content as for other places.
Theres more dry places out in Kansas; Texas; Fort Bragg, North Carolina. The
intent to apply the sheltering of helicopters is tried to be used as far as armywide as we possibly can but given the facilities and the nature of the areas that
we operate in, sometimes, it becomes difficult to do. The nose covers and covers
in general have kind of been mixed and those covers work quite well in keeping
the aircraft dry and a lot of water accumulation out as far as the nose
compartment area it goes.