Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
6 8, 2015,
Cairo, Egypt. http://www.iacconf.com/
I. INTRODUCTION
Currently Egypt and many other developing
countries are facing a major power and energy
problems. These problems are attributed to
many factors. These factors include insufficient
power generation, low network reliability and
insufficient maintenance, insufficient fossil
fuels, and bad economy [1]. Due to their
availability and competitive prices, renewable
energy can contribute in the national energy
security. The whole world is expanding in using
the renewable energy, especially German,
China and USA [2].
The nuclear power can be considered as a
feasible alternative to renewable energy. With
nuclear power, huge amounts of energy can be
generated using small amounts of nuclear. In
addition, the variability, intermittency, and
dispatchability of nuclear power sources are
significantly better in comparison with most
Germany
France
Spain
48 < f <
51
10 cycles
n/a
n/a
10 cycles
n/a
n/a
Over frequency
trip time (sec.)
Underfrequency trip
time(sec.)
No
trip
Zone
Over-frequency
limit
60 to < 60.6
Minimum time
N/A
(continuous)
< 59.4
> 60.6
3 min
< 58.4
> 61.6
30 sec
< 57.8
7.5 sec
< 57.3
45 cycle
< 57
> 61.7
Instantaneous
120
Normal operation
120
V 137.5 %
TABLE IV
Response to voltage deviations for PV systems connected to
the LV grid according to IEC61627
Voltage range
V < 50%
100
Normal operation
100
V > 135%
2.5
TABLE V
Voltage limits for high PV penetration countries
Germany
Spain
France
Fig. 4:
polygonal
curve
ABCD.
In
overvoltage
conditions the reactive current is defined by the
curve D-C which is the mirror of the polygonal
ABCD. Above voltage level of 1.3 p.u of nominal
voltage, the PV plant must be disconnected by
the means of protective relay [16] as shown in
Fig. 7.
TABLE VI
Current harmonic limits recommended by IEEE 929-1992 for
six-pulse converter
Odd harmonics
Distortion limit
3rd 9th
< 4.0%
th
th
< 2.0%
th
th
< 1.5%
11 - 15
17 - 21
rd
23 - 33
rd
< 0.6%
< 0.3%
TABLE VII
Voltage harmonic limits recommended by IEEE 519-1992
Individual
Total
voltage
voltage
Voltage at the PCC
distortion
distortion
(%)
(THD %)
69 KV and below
3.0
5.0
69.001 KV up to
1.5
2.5
161 KV
More than 161.001
1.0
1.5
KV
Table VIII
The term fault ride through (FRT) is related
FRT requirements for wind generator according to different
to how the plant has to act in the case of utility
grid codes
voltage drop because of faults to maintain grid
Fault
Fault duration
Min voltage
Voltage
Grid
code
stability, reliability and operational security. The
duration
based on 50Hz
level
restoration
(ms)
system (cycles)
(% of Vnom)
(s)
Germany
general form of FRT requirements is depicted in
150
7.5
0
1.5
Fig. 8 [12]; above the solid line the plant must(E.On)
Denmark
100
5
25
10
not be disconnected from the utility grid while
underneath the line there are no requirementsSpain
500
25
20
1
to stay connected. However, each code can add
more constraints on the connection and the
disconnection of the plant. Four main
parameters can define the FRT requirements
which are the minimum acceptable voltage
during the fault (Vmin), fault duration, voltage
restoration time and steady state voltage (Vss).
These FRT requirements are applicable for both
wind and PV plants.
For wind plant the FRT parameters according
to some different grid codes are shown in Table
VIII, more information and international
coverage of these values in can be found in
[12]. While in PV grid connected systems, Fig. 9
represent the FRT limits in the German E.ON
Netz grid code [4, 7, 11]. The plant must not be
Fig. 9: FRT limits according to German grid code
disconnected above borderline 1, which means
it must not disconnect when voltage drops to
According to SANDIA [3], in the US the FRT
0% of the utility nominal voltage with a duration
requirements for wind plants were first
not more than 150 ms (7.5 cycles based on
standardized in the Federal Energy Regulatory
50Hz system). The voltage restoration time
Commission (FERC) Order 661A [13]. This
must not exceed 1500 ms (75 cycles on 50Hz
requirement often applies to transmissionsystem) with minimum acceptable steady state
connected PV plants, even though the standard
voltage equals to 90% of the utility nominal
states that it applies only to wind plants. FERCs
voltage. Underneath border line 3 there are no
FRT requirement mandates that a generator
requirements to remain connected to the grid.
shall withstand zero voltage at the point of
In the area above borderline 2 and beneath
common coupling (PCC) -typically the primary
borderline 1, the following options are available
side of the station transformer- for up to 0.15
according to an agreement with the utility
seconds (7.5 cycles based on frequency of
operator: feed-in of a short circuit current, or
50Hz) and the ensuing voltage recovery period.
short-time disconnection up to 2 seconds, or
The FERC requirement is not specific about the
depending on the concept of grid connection
requirement to ride-through during the voltage
borderline 2 can be moved. Below borderline 2
recovery period.
a short-time disconnection can be carried out in
The North American Electric Reliability
any cases, also a longer disconnection time are
Corporation
(NERC)
proposed
PRC-024-1
possible.
standard [8] addresses voltage tolerance for all
generators. If approved, NERCs voltage ridethrough (VRT) standard will have to be
reconciled with FERC Order 661A and other
LVRT regional standards that may exist. Fig. 10
shows the FRT curve contained in the proposed
NERC PRC-024-1 requirement.