Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
* Received March 30, 1955. I am grateful to Dr N. R. Hanson, Dr W. H. Thorpe, F.R.S., and Dr N. Tinbergen
for their comments on the manuscript.
1
Lorenz, op. cit.; Tinbergen, op. cit., W. H. Thorpe, Nature, 1954, 1174, 101; R. A. Hinde, in press in American Psych. Soc. study of the status and development of psychology; K. Lorenz, Sym. Soc. Exp. Biol., 1950,
4, 221.
Note: In recognition of his important early influence on John Bowlbys thinking about motivation, the ethologist Robert
Hinde was a 2003 recipient of the Bowlby-Ainsworth Award. This classic article reflects Prof. Hindes style of rigorous
conceptual analysis. The influence on Bowlbys analysis of psychoanalytic drive theory is apparent. EW
A. Arber, The Mind and the Eye, Cambridge, 1954, Pp. 40-44; K. J. W. Craik, The Nature of Explanation,
Cambridge, 1943, p. 51; S. E. Toulmin, The Philosophy of Science, London, 1953, PP. 31-39 and 165-167.
R. B. Braithwaite, Scientific Explanation, Cambridge, 1953; M. B. Hesse, This journal, 1953. 4, 213.
3
4
Thorpe, Nature, as cited ; Hinde, op. cit. ; M. Bastock, D. E. Morris and M. Moynihan, Behaviour, 1953, 6,
66 .
3
1
2
(c) Key-lock analogy. The I.R.M. is often compared to a lock which is unlocked by the appropriate
'key' stimuli. This implies a valve-like and essentially static view of the I.R.M. - on Tinbergen's view
all I.R.M.s were thought of as equally active all the
time. In practice this is not so : with increasing motivation the animal becomes more unselective in the
stimuli to which it will respond, even though the
intensity of the response, once elicited, does not
change. An instance of this was demonstrated by
Beach 7 in 1942, but the keylock analogy caused
ethologists to neglect it until Prechtl 8 came across
another case.
6 Conclusion
We have seen how the use of a particular type of
model has influenced ethological concepts; and how,
when the properties of the model were not clearly
differentiated from those of the original, this has
sometimes had a retarding influence on research.
Brain Mechanisms and Consciousness (Sym. of Council Int. Organisations of Medical Sciences), Oxford,
1954.